John-this is a cabaret song. It would also work in a revue or maybe even a Broadway show. It doesn't necessarily come across as well in a 3-minute radio format which frequently has to grab your attention quickly. It has been recorded by more than 30 people. Great title. And Margaret was the best.
@Cleftonefan Yes, and cabaret songs are something else when done right and well like Margaret did here. Best among the versions out there, in my opinion, by a long shot! Thanks for the comp on the video.
Songs like this bother me - the lyrics are great - but the entire song sounds like the intro or prelude, and I keep waiting for the melody or interlude, and it never comes along; but one of my all-time favorite, straight-ahead singers is Margaret Whiting, so I listen anyway.
@ljliljohn I'm pretty sure most people would agree that the melody suits the lyric and the sentiment. If the melody and harmony were any more noticeable, you'd probably not pay enough attention to the bittersweet nature of what's going on. Also, what you could be reacting to is the second half of the bridge--it is a little short. I'm not sure how Blumenthal could have extended it, though. I think she likely captured the song as it was existing out there for someone to commit to paper.
I love this video, this song, and this wonderful reminder of handsome men through the decades. I recognize most of them, but oh how I would love a list of their names. Well done! I thank you!
@rampart331 I'm glad you like the song and video. Thanks for the compliment. I do have a list of the names posted, in order of appearance, via my blog post about this. I seem to have trouble posting the link in a comment, though. But if you look in the description and expand the box by clicking on the double downward arrow at the right of the description, the link is there. Thank you.
Ooops! Thanks for that correction. I appreciate it very much. It came out on an album in 1992, called Then and Now, though I'm not sure when it was recorded. I thought it might have been remastered but it doesn't seem to have a version before 1992. Thanks for the comp. with the correction. :-)
This is lovely. I had never heard it before. This isn't from the 1940s, though (the song may be, but the rendition is not). I would guess this was recorded in the 1970s or later. Beautiful job.
I can't believe noone mentioned how you put a picture of Ray Charles when she said the line about being blind.... lol
ceesayssorry 3 months ago
@ceesayssorry Thanks Cee. I try to be sublime. More than one decision of who went with what lines were chosen on little things like that. :-)
crowdsourceguy 2 months ago
the world's most handsome man Alain Delon
SaGoKeSH 5 months ago
The pianist was Tex Arnold. Sublime.
pattiloach 5 months ago
@pattiloach Thanks for the info. Sublime indeed!
crowdsourceguy 2 months ago
Beautiful song, Beautiful Singer and Beautiful men. What more could you ask for?!?
msjostockton 1 year ago
@msjostockton Well, I wouldn't mind a song and video for I Believe in the Lies of Pretty Girls, or Beautiful Women, or Classy Broads. :-)
crowdsourceguy 11 months ago
R.I.P. Margaret Whiting. The most perfect voice of her generation.
wothb 1 year ago
@wothb That is true. Thanks for sharing.
crowdsourceguy 11 months ago
John-this is a cabaret song. It would also work in a revue or maybe even a Broadway show. It doesn't necessarily come across as well in a 3-minute radio format which frequently has to grab your attention quickly. It has been recorded by more than 30 people. Great title. And Margaret was the best.
I like the video, too.
Cleftonefan 1 year ago
@Cleftonefan Yes, and cabaret songs are something else when done right and well like Margaret did here. Best among the versions out there, in my opinion, by a long shot! Thanks for the comp on the video.
crowdsourceguy 11 months ago
She is one of my favorites - I have a collection of her 78's. What a wonderful legacy she leaves!
NS4270 1 year ago
@NS4270 Yes, she does. I have the collection digitally and know what you mean. Thanks for sharing.
crowdsourceguy 11 months ago
What a lovely tribute, especially with Jack at the end. She was such a lady and such a great broad too.
sharonmcn 1 year ago
@sharonmcn Yes, she was. She definitely was! Thanks for the comp.
crowdsourceguy 11 months ago
R.I.P. Maggy , I for one among many will miss you so !
Joeinps 1 year ago
@Joeinps I, too.
crowdsourceguy 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Russian wives waiting gettop5.info
ewsaanikmaw 1 year ago
Comment removed
jazzyfunjazz 1 year ago
How wonderful....the song and your video! Thanks...
jazzyfunjazz 1 year ago
Songs like this bother me - the lyrics are great - but the entire song sounds like the intro or prelude, and I keep waiting for the melody or interlude, and it never comes along; but one of my all-time favorite, straight-ahead singers is Margaret Whiting, so I listen anyway.
ljliljohn 1 year ago
@ljliljohn I'm pretty sure most people would agree that the melody suits the lyric and the sentiment. If the melody and harmony were any more noticeable, you'd probably not pay enough attention to the bittersweet nature of what's going on. Also, what you could be reacting to is the second half of the bridge--it is a little short. I'm not sure how Blumenthal could have extended it, though. I think she likely captured the song as it was existing out there for someone to commit to paper.
ChristophePhilippe 1 year ago
@ljliljohn It keeps you in anticipation the whole time. That's not a bad thing, is it? :-)
Thanks for your comments.
crowdsourceguy 11 months ago
Beautiful, truly beautiful. ;(
Gramophones 1 year ago
@Gramophones Thank you. The song is beautiful and Margaret did an even more beautiful job on it.
crowdsourceguy 1 year ago
Bravo! Beautifully done! I have enjoyed it ever so much.....
rewardless 1 year ago
@rewardless Thank you. Glad to hear you did and thanks for taking the time to share.
crowdsourceguy 1 year ago
I love this video, this song, and this wonderful reminder of handsome men through the decades. I recognize most of them, but oh how I would love a list of their names. Well done! I thank you!
rampart331 1 year ago
@rampart331 I'm glad you like the song and video. Thanks for the compliment. I do have a list of the names posted, in order of appearance, via my blog post about this. I seem to have trouble posting the link in a comment, though. But if you look in the description and expand the box by clicking on the double downward arrow at the right of the description, the link is there. Thank you.
crowdsourceguy 1 year ago
Love it - thank you for posting! :-)
freemantom 2 years ago
@freemantom Thanks!
crowdsourceguy 1 year ago
О MY GOD!!! This song about me!!!)
Nice video, Marlon Brando - forever)
interzoneboy 2 years ago
@interzoneboy I figured it had to be about somebody, or that many people could relate to it. :-)
crowdsourceguy 1 year ago
Ooops! Thanks for that correction. I appreciate it very much. It came out on an album in 1992, called Then and Now, though I'm not sure when it was recorded. I thought it might have been remastered but it doesn't seem to have a version before 1992. Thanks for the comp. with the correction. :-)
crowdsourceguy 2 years ago
This is lovely. I had never heard it before. This isn't from the 1940s, though (the song may be, but the rendition is not). I would guess this was recorded in the 1970s or later. Beautiful job.
beyondtheforest 2 years ago