Malalai Joya: All foreign troops should get out of Afghanistan now

[6906362]

i'm proud of this girl

[PashtunDefenceLine]

FOREIGN FORCES MUST NOT GO IN HURRY...OTHERWISE THEIR WILL BE A REPEATITION, OF WHAT BEEN HAPPENED AFTER RUSSIA WENT.....1ST STABILIZE AFGHAN GOVT, ARMY AND POLICE, THEN THEY CAN GRAGUALLY GO....

[AFGHANVIEW]

i had some respect for this lady but now she turns to be a mouth piece.

she went aroudn the world and still doesnt know 9/11 was an inside job.

[ARIGAK]

marg ba sebghatula n modadidi kharkos- marg ba syaf kasiff khar sag besharaf

[Qataghanbacha]

haahha... bechara hech waqt nakhowahat kamiyaab shodii, wa ba hadafe khood hechgah namerasi wa nakhowahad rasidi.. i think you are a FBI agent

[Mo79reed]

@Qataghanbacha i atleast sada'e khod ra mekashad ! :)

[Qataghanbacha]

Fuck Her, she trying to sell afghanistan in name of freedom and democracy, she is a FBI Agent.. its polotics babyyy.. think about it, she not just a women, its evil in face of an human!!

[Mo79reed]

she is just a women?what are you trying to say?i do know it's politics but she is not choosing any side... nd she is telling the truth.. someone should, don you think?

[Qataghanbacha]

I do not have to think of something logical, and it is very clearly to seen wat ze does en wants to do!

she calls every mujahid a bad person, she said there was no jihad needed in afghanistan, those mujahidin saved her family and her self from russians, from those who raped our afghan sisters and mothers, she must thank god dat she is born in afghanistan in a brave land brave poeple, she can`t insult those poeple who saved our nation from kafirs and munafiqiin!! or am i crazzy?

[Mo79reed]

4 agument sake lets say she is an infidel... but be realistic about other things... i hate russia i hate usa i always believed dat afghanistan is an idependent counrty we shloud bring peace in our country without any 'kofar's' help ... but most mojahid they did kills,rape, corrupt.. im all for peace whom ever is in the power!

[Qataghanbacha]

@Mo79reed, you right brother, but don`t think, what does happen if all of those kofar`s away from our country? don`t you think a little about that she calls Taliban just demonstrators!! who were Taliban? did they do anything good to our country? why should someone listen to them? she wants that Taliban come back in power and our dear homeland will destroy again by those animals. they aren't even Afghans, real Afghans were those mujahidin who fought and still wants peace for their homeland!!

[Mo79reed]

i'm a sister, mujahidin wants peace? come on they use the name of jihad!!! yes it's true wat u say abt taliban but atleast when an infidel kills ur borther,father,rape ur sister mother it will hurt less, but when ur own hamwatan so called mohjahid comes nd do all this 2 u nd ur family? u can't live with that... (im 4 peace)

[Qataghanbacha]

how do you mean, my own hamwatan? have been in afghanistan? ever in your life? I talk about the life I really experiencing now, you think very realistic, it is really very much. things you hear is very different than you going through them! Iam also for peace only to my country and my fellow brothers and sisters all Afghans, countries now in Afghanistan have come, I know them all kufars, but we should actually use them instead of fighting them,

[Qataghanbacha]

we have a very very good luck that right now world willing to help us. and there will be peace if we just use them, use their power, money and experience to our country get back on its feet, that our neighbors do not bother and not interfere in our country, especially Pakistan and Arabs

[Mo79reed]

to be honest now u hve lost me! if u believe in jahad u shudn be using kufar's help! correct? and yes i hve beein in afghanistan, my family still lives there im aware of the stituation! like i told u b4 im 4 peace.. but onfortunatly our whole goverment is corrouped..May Allah help us (ameen)

[Qataghanbacha]

which peace you talking about? do you mean that Afghans can bring peace themselves in Afghanistan?everyone hope that kind of peace to be in Afghanistan, but i tell you we Afghans can`t coz we are nationalist people and we hate each other and that is reality, if all western countries leave Afg who control those bastards? it will be the worst time in history the darkness time ever in Afghanistan , so tell me which peace you want to bring while you dont even live in your own country? tell me please

[Mo79reed]

well my dear hamwatan, coz of so called mojahid we had to leave the country! but i never said we don need help... did i?yes indeed we need westerns help! but doesn mean we should close our eyes!

[justaoldslave]

Thank you Malalai Joya, I will apologize for my corrupt governments behavior ( U.S. ). The problem in the U.S. is the ignorance. Three hundred million people in the U.S.. As of 12-24-09 3,797. views. The U.S. press is as much to blame as any body. The greed, evil and corruption that is destroying your country is destroying the entire plantant. Its not freedom and democracy. Its pure evil.

[Igentenos]

better believe they are occupying to line their pockets not bring about a better life for anyone but the powerful elite.

[TheGreatWoody89]

Lmao @ "TheRealNews" deleting so many peoples posts. More i see of this channel the more BS i see :(

[ConsuescoCoaegresco]

I saw Ms. Joya speak yesterday. Couldn't understand a word of what she said. Good thing I found this because I missed something special.

[huskerbird1]

Brave woman, more brave than anyone in america, this speech could certainly cost her her life. She should be presidnet instead of that corrupt Bush oil field trash thats now illegally installed

[MajNorberg]

SAme Here

[Imperiused]

There is no "Afghan" nation. Just an artificial buffer state made up of anyone who just happened to be living in the region. The "Afghan" people don't exist. There are Cities and Villages. There are Pashtuns, Uzbeks, Tajiks, etc. You can't create this "Afghan" people out of nothing, and say they oppose the warlords/taliban/etc, because they are very much part of that system. Forging an Afghan nation would require a destruction of the current system. Which would come at much cost.

[Imperiused]

To reduce loss of life, working within the system is needed. And that means appealing to established powers. And that means working with warlords/criminals/Taliban/loc­al strongmen. Which means swallowing any moral high ground.

[ezze902]

They already working with the Taliban... the Taliban is being paid to protect supply lines...

We are there to make money; not democratize that country.

[Imperiused]

Totally true. I suppose I was being more hypothetical in that instance. Sorta like "If we were actually there to solve Afghanistan's problems".

[amet1980]

some of them have devine status amongst his co-nationals as dostum with uzbek..

what ever possibility of an oppotition to this monster is with regionalizing the politics..

now dostum not only has been proclamed as ata-uzbek but he is olso representitive of the uzbeks in their negotiation with central goverment that forcibly unify uzbeks behind him..(although has a limited oppotition)

[amet1980]

very true..

as in iraq forging artificial national consepts, even if they have temporary pacifing effect, its a recipe for future disasters..

history makes cycles and then repeat it self..

creating avery loose confederation of national states is more humanatarian as a result in the end..

[humaner]

This woman is a fearless warrior bravo

[doobtribe]

Thank you TRN!

[RCinPAWA]

"Maybe people will take gun or not but it is clear they will not remain silent."

Sounds like America.

Too bad the men in this intelligent, brave woman's government didn't stand up for her when they had the chance.

[jona95822]

We need the Opium!!!

[BigBuckBunny420]

"Same donkey, new saddle" says it all...

[blackiron60]

You can say what you want about the Soviet-backed Afghan government in the 70s and 80s but under that government the average Afghan went to school, they got enough to eat, their kids got enough to eat, there was access to healthcare, women could walk the streets without a male escort, women could go to school and wear blue jeans etc. And practically none of that exists today. The U.S. empowered the warlords and the fundamentalists and sent Afghanistan back into the dark ages.

[historyscoper]

How about getting all fundamentalists out of the West and the U.S.? Click my profile to learn the 1400-year horrible history of Islam that's causing all the trouble in Afghanistan and elsewhere.

[hopaloop]

watch " who killed John O'Neil" and find out how Zabrinzki and the cia created islamic fundamentalism as a weapon to drag Russia into their oen Vietnam War in an efford to econamically cripple Russia( A plan that has back fired. Not unlike South America and the contras) Often it is more reasonable to look at ones own country and their behaviour that has led history to the point we're now at. This isn't a football game ...49'ers v dolphins. Times running out, start growing up or die.

[historyscoper]

Sorry, Islamic fundamentalism was created 1400 years ago by Muhammad, whose Quran teaches to all who want to read it. Yes, the CIA backed some IFs against the Soviets, how stupid of them, but they didn't created it. Click my profile for the url and study the real history of Islam from the Historyscoper and let knowledge enter your skull.

[hopaloop]

Thanks i will.... do you think it's more dangerous than Imperialisim. A death count of the last 90 years would surgest not.

[bealcd3]

PULL THE TROOPS OUT NOW!!!

[javsmom]

this needs to go viral.

rate and share.

this woman is powerful inspirational truth!!!!

[t4ac3y1]

Great interview!

[LvDaMuzic]

They don't come to Europe as refugees if elites keep their eyes and hands off from the energy resources in these countries. Money maniacs in wall street and power hungry in white house wants their hand in anything everywhere. That creates more and more problem. Once the US created Osama and talaban and now behaving as if they have nothing to do. A drug dealers' brother is president of Afganistan - what does it tell you?

[t4ac3y1]

Wow... Why bother talking when no one can understand a thing you just said; seriously! And, by the way, you made that incredibly hateful remark to my simple comment of "great interview"? When I'm simply remarking on the context of the reporting that was done? You're a freakin nut job!

[hadiki1234]

I understand her.

[jellybean2626]

nice interview a good questions asked

[DealerDirekt]

We could all take something from Malalai Joya. So many Americans just don't seem to get the mssg. She is a hero in my eyes.

[KamikazeKoscki]

13 Evil families run the world and are control by the Devil, USA only wants control of the pipe line, it's all about resources & oil it their goal. People around the world need to strike, stop helping these corrupt families.

[GetMeThere1]

Always great to hear an authentic voice of the people!

[JixMa]

Wow! What a woman! So brave to have said that at the mike in front of those backward thugs! She risked life and limb to have said what she said!

[cadenza46]

Malalai Joya is an astounding brave and intelligent woman. She should find ways to get support from people. Women should llok up to her as an example that it can be done. They can speak up. Incredible act of courage.

[smokydave]

She seems overly optimistic about truth being stronger than the AK-47

[JixMa]

@smokydave"AK-47 stronger than Truth"

The AK-47 may be stronger in the short-term, but what does it really get U? Death, despair & countries in ruin! So how good is brute strength & raw power in making a better world? If you're the elite in power, yeah U get a pretty cushy lifestyle, everyone else lives in slavery & poverty. The better way is 2 share the wealth & make everybody eat at the table rather than settle for the crumbs that fall on the floor. If ppl R happy there's no reason 2 fight.

[MankindCartoons]

She reminded me that we need to prosecute Georgie, Cheney, Rove, Rumsfeld, et all.

Let's get on that, people!

[TRUTHvsDECEPTION]

More then Million Afghan die by the hands of these Warlord during 1987 through 2000.

[darksideofthenation]

Can the maker of this video removed the comment from TheGreatWoody89.

It should not be allowed at all.

[WhirlingWolves]

wait why is someone not supposed to be "allowed"?

[WhirlingWolves]

fuck that darksideofthenation it ALL should be allowed for we are not a weak people.

We can handle ANY idea. We don't live in fear of ideas.

[JasonMelancon]

I'm so happy that TRN was able to get this amazing person! BTW, Mr. Jay, many nations were able to overcome oppression without guns. South Africa comes easily to mind.

[fatpius]

powerful woman

[Plum369]

Stop urging her to take up guns! Gandhi didn't need guns. Martin Luther King Jr. did not need guns. Just the Truth!

[82abhilash]

Ghandi was struggling against the British. Martin Luther King Jr. against the Americans. When Ghandi tried non-violence against radical Islamists, he flopped. Hindus got massacred because he urged them to do nothing. And finally one of them got frustrated and killed him. Know your enemy, choose your weapon.

[Plum369]

he knew that he might have to die. He said so...that if they killed him they would have his dead body but not his spirit. I am not against using guns, people have a right to use whatever means they feel necessary to defend themselves. I am saying that the minute they pick up guns, they become "terrorist" targets of the US army. period.

[82abhilash]

Like I said, know your enemy, choose your weapon.

[WhirlingWolves]

maybe they did'nt need guns but guns sure don't hurt.

[Plum369]

This woman is bravely speaking out. I have news for you, it is not just the Afghan government that is a mafia! wake up and look around you at the US, Britain, the UN....wake up.

[RapahelakaMac]

An amazing women!

[cat22203]

someone please send this video to the White House!

[yo1dude1man]

My thoughts and prayers go out to Malalai Joya and her people.

[drgoodvibesxxx]

Her message "leave us the fuck alone"

[BrutusAlbion]

Damn this situation sounds alot like what alot of countries need.

Power to the people.

[mynameisbobtoo]

why not just Nuke you then? If you're sick of hearing about things and you have so many problems why don't we just burn you to death instead of an entire population?

[samin62]

i missed her seminar in Toronto yesterday. Sucks....

[Fukkutah]

In Afghanistan it is more like this: the devil you don't know must be related to, or in bed with the devil you already know. It is a corrupt place and lots of guns. Malalai is lucky to have escaped alive.

[megatron0357]

that is the same all over the world.. it just more over in afghanistan..other places..more subtle...

[Fukkutah]

The concept of corruption is the same; agreed, but in Afghanistan it is much, much more complex. Poor country to start with, major production of drugs, instable central government; creation of new social classes and a struggle for national identity in a tribal culture; in addition to foreign occupation and the insurgency. All of that fuels violence and greed; I don't think you will quite find an equal picture anywhere else.

[megatron0357]

somalia maybe?

[bertly71]

Women in this country will get the same treatment and worse if we continue to underestimate these terrorists. They are here already, just waiting for another opportunity, just like Ft Hood.

[mynameisbobtoo]

you do know more Americans are killed by Mexican drug cartel members then "terrorists" right? So what you should be asking is why aren't we against war with Mexico? Ready for the answer? Mexico has no oil....so stop being a sheep and think a little.

everything i said you can verify for yourself.

[drgoodvibesxxx]

congratulations you are an idiot

[WhirlingWolves]

Orrrrrr say you won't do it?

[WhirlingWolves]

so you will do it?

DON"T BE A COWARD.

You will cut her head off?

[VGMMASSACHUSETTS]

i'm amazed she's still alive

[jamil316]

she would live as long as God wants her to live if God wants America or anyone Dead its Done she is a very Brave Women Speaking i wish i had Money to send her so she can have Security Guards

[jamil316]

Ps America Power Days Are Numbered Like most Powerful Countrys who Lost Power in years

[megatron0357]

nations come and go.. history proves this. you can reform them..but power swings like a pendulum. that's the way of the world

[BrutusAlbion]

Isn't it up to god wether she needs security guards? or is it money?

You have a vague understanding of what god does and doesn't...everything good must be god apperantly and everything bad must be done by man or the devil ey?

[mynameisbobtoo]

which god? There are thousands to choose from...

[KhanZazai]

pre-installed memory.i hear this woman saying same thing over and over. by the way we oppose warlords but also dirty RAWA org.

[WhirlingWolves]

Or or or or are you scared of speaking your mind?

[WhirlingWolves]

I hsve all the braver she just showed. I am the Audie Murphy of the 21st century. We are the druids. To hell and back.

[TheGreatWoody89]

Since i cannot find where you responded to me I'll respond to this one. He/She cannot comprehend sarcasm. If you're going to speak to Americans at least speak good enough English that you don't have to listen to her speech 3x's over to understand what she's saying. He/she apparently loves using the phrase "he/she" because he/she is incapable of creating an intelligent sentence! hahahaha

[WhirlingWolves]

Since you can't be bothered to look then unfortuneatly we are at an impasse for I don't even remember responding to any of your comments.

However I have been known to write inane comments from time to time. I admit it. Alcohol is a hell of drug!

[langs13]

You r laughing but we are laughing at your ignorance.

HAHAHAHA

[xandras1111]

Women in Afghanistan are so much smarter than their men.... I think thats the problem, women should be in charge there.

[xandras1111]

Sucks to be a woman in Afghanistan

[dcruze]

Interesting interview, but can you subtitle the following segments? I really had to concentrate to understand what Joya was saying.

[GeeKayKayGee]

Man shes one brave and admirable person. I can only wish I had half the bravery that she has demonstrated.

[antiwarcampaigner]

This is real bravery.  Where are the Malalai's in OUR governments in the west?