Kiss Goodbye - 蕭敬騰 / 王力宏

[a60104a]

王力宏....贏了



[shrgrls]

而且蕭敬騰的是現場版....雖然聽不太出來.....

[shrgrls]

蕭敬騰唱得比較有強烈個人風格

[wooceo]

Im not a musician, but If I just listen to the melody and the lyrics of this song, I would say it needs a tender approach, and 蕭敬騰's voice is too strong, I know that's singing-style, but I really think that Leehom caught the essence of this song~~~(its his song, duh XD)

[smartrockboy]

兩個都是台灣最好

[MrQHTWinWin]

王力宏帅多了

[TOMYIPTSZ627]

LeeHom is best~

[Hope4freedom76]

hm....还是王力宏唱的更有感情..

不过两位歌手都很喜欢

[eddie8chi]

in terms of singing ability, jam prob has broader range,, but this songs feelings and emotions more suitable for leehom

[accolor95]

兩個都是我喜愛的歌手~~都好聽~^^

[wintersleep007]

我覺得不能說誰唱的比較好

只能說比較喜歡誰唱的

畢竟現場唱跟錄音室唱是不一樣的

真要說的話我只能說原唱唱的比較好但我比較喜歡敬騰的聲音

[CR7RONALDO9]

兩種唔同既風格放埋一齊,變左一首比原本更正既歌

[tswhchan]

还是力宏的好听^^

[MagnusMas]

王力宏唱得有感情多了,唱出歌詞的意思,絕對好聽多了!!!

[pooh512968]

還是喜歡王力宏的原唱版本

[luvjam2012]

great song~

luv jam's voice

leehom is a great singer too~

:)

thanks for sharing~

[vicious321]

They belong to sing different style of music.

[peachykeyn]

@vicious321 I agree. They both have their own styles. I guess that makes that both good 'cus if they were the same, they wouldn't be this good. =0)

[wing20xd]

Leehom is definately better and more suitable for this song.

[jeffreyhadi]

can't deny that leehom's voice is much sexier and more soothing to ears. i think jam's rock style didn't really suit this song well.

[pal6210]

jam is definitely a great singer in covering many singers' songs, but when it comes to singing leehom's songs, nobody can beat leehom's dreamy vocal!!

[Wuhan]

Both great singers. However, Leehom sings this song much much better

[sylviecute]

两个都是我爱的。对于现在刚刚起步的敬腾，爱护更需要加倍。

[doris88chang]

敬騰的高低音比較溫潤有厚度

[TWFEDERER]

蕭敬騰的特色就是易被吸引 也易被聽膩 要知道 音樂的深層力量不是如火山爆發的洶湧 而是如一股清泉 在心坎間緩緩流動 不斷地 永遠地 直到力宏來了

[diy650530]

這首歌是王力宏的吧

和原唱放在一起沒被比下去已經超強的囉

都很好聽^^

[myacnt8999]

i think both are excellent singers. but for me, jam lack of groove compared to leehom. leehom's voice and singing style is more soothing to me, although i admit jam is very powerful, but singing is not about to show off how powerful you are, but how to please audience's ear.

[remirap]

which they both succeed at

[StarZIvy]

2個都唱得好好聽,好難分誰比較好啦..

[bakerli9900]

力宏加油

[aeries0511]

力宏较有男人味。。。而且他的声音也比较搭。。

萧敬腾比较可爱。。

[hkhauy]

很奇怪!

樓主目的是給大家欣賞,

並不是投票誰唱得好或差!

大家可否靜靜欣賞!

兩個都唱得好好!

[ariesxx432]

yea i agreed, leehom's voice is more pure and its so dreamy <3

[joeleongkw]

Definately LeeHOM!!!

[zhengyih87]

i'm leehom fans. actually both leehom and jam are very good singers. but for kiss goodbye, i feel tat leehom would be better because this is the song he create which will suit him better. more feeling and nicer. jam sound's more deep while leehom sound more pure. love both them(:

[daimawong]

兩人音色截然不同，都唱得很好。較喜歡蕭的多一點(沒有比較之意­，純屬個人主觀)。

[JJJJJJJJ6666]

我觉得萧敬腾唱得很差！ 根本唱不出这首歌的内涵。而且声音显得很弱。这首歌是王力宏10­0%创作的，记载着浪漫凄美的爱情故事！。这首歌从此也成为王力­宏的经典歌曲.因为全世界都被他感动了！

[TommyLinXDXDXD]

是不至於多差吧...

畢竟蕭敬騰只是"表演"歌曲

而王立宏是認真放情感去"錄製"音樂

所以聽起來當然有差異

[JJJJJJJJ6666]

其实，我本身认为真的是差很远。你说得没错他只是表演歌曲而王力­宏是100%付出的。不过即使萧敬腾100%唱出也不可能超越王­力宏的。

[TommyLinXDXDXD]

你很喜歡王立宏喔

ㄏㄏㄏ~繼續保持你對他的熱愛吧

他們唱的我是都喜歡聽

我不予置評^^

[JJJJJJJJ6666]

谢谢你。可是，一些萧敬腾粉丝可不是这样想得喔

[TommyLinXDXDXD]

各有喜好啦

只要永遠支持自己喜歡偶像就好^^

[anagu0801]

我喜歡敬騰唱這首歌的唱腔

放一點比較好...

[dance99]

i love both singers! i can't choose between them! they are both my number favorite and respected singers on my list!

[JJJJJJJJ6666]

Choose leehom!

[dance99]

dude. no. they both did a good job. it's leehom's song. he'll obviously will do very well with it. i'm not choosey. i know a good singer when i hear one. and both are good.

[JJJJJJJJ6666]

You like jam? The fact is jam didnt do a good job singing kiss goodbye...this time. In fact i was rather disgusted cos he sounds constipated. He needs a stronger voice man if he wants to sing as good as leehom!

[myacnt8999]

actually jam did a very good job and his voice is unique. his singing is more powerful than leehom, i think, but doesn't sound as nice and soothing as leehom.

[JJJJJJJJ6666]

Well i don disagree..and you might not have gotten a taste of leehom's very powerful vocals yet!

[myacnt8999]

yes, i know leehom's vocal is powerful, i'm a big fan of leehom too, but jam is powerful as well. it cracks me up when you said jam needs to be more powerful. LOL

[cassie3178]

I perfer Leehom's voice more though Jam is also good

[x3crissie]

I adore Jam's voice but aaah I think Leehom sounds better here.

[happysmile8888]

此曲在今年新年時唱的,請search

"蕭敬騰&梁靜茹@PowerSunday初一特別節目3/4(­蕭敬騰組曲部分"

[bapebear]

wow.... when jam sang this song?

[crevettemunch]

I'm a fan of both, but for this song i think Lee Hom sounds better. hee. Thanks for the upload! =)

[ambafly]

Good job ! ^^

[cheryl719]

Thanks.. It's so nice~~

[mydogvisa]

thanks anniejc!

[purewater888]

謝謝分享!

剪輯的很棒!!

[myacnt8999]

i find that jam's sliding notes is sometimes annoying.

[gelbpaprika]

jam´s song is living and lihong´s is CD

[myacnt8999]

both jam and leehom sound better at live rather than CD.

[berries01jam]

Thanks for the great job !!

Both are excellent singers !!

[hkhauy]

Great job!

高人!

相都好覩!