This video was totally one sided.If you were serious about having a genuine interest in these people & their lives you would have employed the services of an interpreter.They never understood a thing of what you spoke & the only reason you were invited in was in hope of the cash you might give them.How would you like it if an Inuit man speaking ONLY his language was filming you & your family asking a lot of unintelligible inept questions & had the temerity to touch your child like you did his?
@kanakaken -- thanks for your note. I would not judge you because I don't know you. I can respond to your comment and say that these people speak Hamer. They don't speak Amharic. Even local Ethiopians don't speak Hamer. They welcomed me into their village and home. They don't use money so no money was involved. You have NO idea where I was, what I was doing, why I was there or anything, really. So, I'll let you continue to use your imagination.
@whereisdanman These people are Hamer-Banna and they are predominately Sunni hence using the word Salem/Salaam.My imagination now runs wild. I only judge what I saw.You spoke to the people in your form of English,they understood nothing. Being Sunni, they recite the Koran in Arabic yet you didn't bother to learn basic Arabic greetings or Hamer-Banna. please tell us you NEVER touched any women or girls as you did the boy, a blatant mistake against all Muslims.Where was interpreter?
@kanakaken -- I'm going to do you a favor and teach you something that you didn't know, or rather correct you on something that you thought you knew. First, the Hamer tribe is different from the Bana tribe. Although they both speak Hamer-Banna. Second, NONE of the tribes in the Omo Valley are "Muslim," they don't speak Arabic, and they don't know what a Koran is. Your imagination is humorous! Anyway, I'll leave you with some info so you can go learn: They believe in Animism. Look it up, buddy.
@kanakaken there not muslim, or sunni dumb ass, selam is a universal way of saying peace in ethiopia. cristians,muslims, jews,and pagaans say selam in ethiopia!
@robutta100 Thanks dumb ass, I appreciate the information. Oh by the way dumb ass, it's not 'there not muslim', It's, 'They're not Muslim'. Dumber Ass! A person who has never been taught a particular subject cannot be blamed for not having that knowledge but I do blame myself because I could have looked it up. You on the other hand attended school In the US yet have failed to comprehend English grammar. But what you say is true, I say 'Salaam Halaikum' often but I'm not Muslim.
man why the hell they let this cracker in there like that... filming the girl and shit,, f'n pervert ass nigga... they cant tell this fool is a wierdo
At least 80% of the video and questioning was focused on the pre-pubescent female and the zoom feature was used to its maximum. The father invites the man into his house and this is how his hospitality is treated. He videos his child and post it on YouTube for subtle unflattering titillation. The Devil will always be the devil. Shun him when he knocks on your door.
@TheIbiscus - your ignorance and hatred is very obvious to others. Please try to keep it in your own world. This is the best way to be enlightened and free from the negative emotions you have.
@GiggleHz wtf...so wtf does that make you...you whites love your world wars...lol..have a few more and your def going to make your population even smaller..and for you to say that def shows your ignorance because Im 100% sure that if I where right in front of you, you wouldnt have the balls to call me that shit to my face because I would fuck you up..its funny how white people talk shit behind a computer screen then say nothing in public..even down here in georgia..lol..shit b funny as hell..lol
@dbaile2@GiggleHz - man, GiggleHz is full of hatred and negative emotions. The only one "talking shit behind a computer screen" is....well... GiggleHz! I suggest that you watch again while imagining you are in the remote Omo Valley between Ethiopia, Kenya and Sudan - alone and vulnerable in the remote desert with beautiful people and an amazingly precious ancient culture. This is what I experienced and have shared with you. I hope you get to go there some day. Maybe you won't be so angry.
@whereisdanman If I ever make a trip to africa it will be to stay...the United States has nothing to offer our people but hatred...Alot of blacks are starting to go back to west africa and start new lives there..hopfully in the future I will have the funds to leave this racist country and return to africa.
@whereisdanman Before you come back at me saying I'm angry or untravelled, I have NO anger towards you & I have lived in a Papua New Guinea village with the people & I learnt their language, I also learnt the language of the Ni-Vanuatu. I lived in Peru and Cuba with the locals & I speak Spanish.
How many words of the Hamer people did you learn? Don't include 'Salaam', that's Arabic & I'm assuming they are Muslim people here,but I could be wrong. Did they greet you with 'Halaikum Salaam'?
@Deptstate799 You seem to have this backwards idea that "culture" implies exotic things. Culture is that complex whole which includes knowledge, belief, arts, morals, laws, customs, and any other capabilities and habits acquired by man as a member of a society. Here are exampled of white people's cultures:
@Deptstate799 Why? Maybe because they want to explore? Want to know the place and the culture? What could they possibly learn? Well all about the people that live there as well as the geography. Then you say "White's are not appreciative of people who have culture" which is a very dumb statement again, as if whites themselves don't have cultures or aren't interested in learning about other people. You're just ignorant and prejudiced.
That's it, I'm done. Africa is screwed. It is a dark barbaric continent that will never amount to anything.
Are Africans nice people- yes. Will an African country ever go to Mar's? No
Over 6,000yrs to build a decent civilization and yet Africa has failed epically. These people have never moved beyond the stone age and the consequences are massive poverty, ignorance and cruelty through civil strife.
@akaroyalljelly Africa is not a country but a continent so that statement is bs, next up the trans atlantic slave trade was predominately focused on west african slaves not in Ethiopia which is on the horn of Africa in the east.
Next up even 2000yrs ago Europe was still more advanced with the Roman Empire than these primitive savages.
Your continent is a dark and primitive place because of Africans, Europe played a part but the biggest culprit is African stupidity.
@ImaginedWriter Africa was decimated of her populace. When you look at the world's population from 1500-1800 (transatlantic slave trade) there was less than 2billion yet 100million was violently uprooted to foreign shore. (do the math) The scar left on africa still festers. (imagine what europe would be today if she went thru the same) and her peoples still suffer no matter where they are in the world cont...
cont...As an atypical europid who suffers from a 'god complex' you figure that any culture that can't resist your guns must be inferior ; this is why you can turn a 'juandiced eye' to the australian aborigines, the native people of the americas, and the tasmanians, people who you have either destroyed or colonized.
@ImaginedWriter What's your definition of a decent civilisation? One that lives in peace and in total equilibrium with its surroundings or one that goes around murering innocent people, raping innocent women and destroying entire ways of life? Clearly a barbarians idea of a decent civilisation is far from my own.
@ImaginedWriter lol my friend you should never open your mouth to soon without doing any reseach on your racist views, Africa had many great civilzations and the greatest of all was Egypt(Kemet).. also other like: Dogons, They have great knowledge of the stars even NASA didnt know about Benin Timbuktu Kush Nubian Zulu Songhay kingdom Kiziba kingdoms there are more pyramids in Sudan then Egypt this list is only a few...viewpoint of history is imposed from a Eurocentric point of view
No doubt. I can imagine it was an awesome experience, you were just focusing on your own mind and world at the time. I would have focused on my own also, but it wouldn't have focused on just the baby. My focus would have been gaining great knowledge from the elder. He holds all the answers : ) Next time you have the honorable privilege, focus on the enlightenment...
@Spiritree41 All the answers to many questions I must add. The sacred Elder gentlemen in this video....Thanks for sharing your adventures. I would have preferred to say enlightenment, but not in this case..
@mutnojme -- i do not believe that they practice a "western" form of birth control. Their culture is quite different and is directly connected to nature: weather, temperature, moon, sun, wind and time. they use this in what westerners call a "spiritual" way to practice birth control. However, there are NGOs that have offered methods of western birth control - which is also a way to prevent sexually transmitted diseases. I am not an expert, so please don't use my word as factual. Good luck!
Why did you put soooo much interest in that adolescent child. Whats your fascination with her. This is exploitaion of a minor child. There is noooooo way you would have had that camara on my child! Other than that this would have been great footage...
@Spiritree41 -- My fascination? Wouldn't you find visiting this family in the Omo Valley of south west Ethiopia 'fascinating'? Can you imagine walking around this village and being warmly welcomed by the local people? If you watch the video, you'll see that her father invited me into his house and introduced me to his family. Thanks for watching. i hope you enjoyed it.
@whereisdanman I find people who make comments such as @Spiritree41 have never been out of the country and sadly have no understanding of the world. I spend a lot of time in the Omo and found nothing wrong with your video and in no way did it show you were fascinated with the young girl, nor were you exploiting a child!! You were sharing an amazing experience!
I do think the peacecorps are helpful intentionally,I also think if various tribes live near the sea(seafoods.)they can thrive,but perhaps with a little more difficulty in interiorlands unless they have a huge herd of cows,et.cetera?
If living close to sea,various tribes could thrive,but may have more difficulty living far from the sea(unless they own larger herds of cows,sheeps,et.cetera.)
Sounds like Whereisdanman has a translator friend who is there with him,otherwise,Whereisdanman would be asking them himself in their African language,or he's asking the questions in English so we,the English-speaking YouTube learners can understand what's being said.
The road building must stop,but thousands of petitioners worldwide would be necessary to stop the road building. Africa is a huge country,why do they want to build roads near the tribes?It would be indignant of the builders,it would cause culture shock to the tribes.
Do tribe leaders lead the way with home ownership(where they live,place,et.cetera)I hope they will be safe from urbanizations for many years into the future!
These tribes are nomadic. They move around the land according to the weather. Within each tribe, there is a clan, or "community" with a chief. Each clan protects one another from intruders. Each clans understands whose home is whose. Misbehavior within a clan is dealt with by the chief and the counsel.
Unfortunately, there is a road being built from Arba Minch through the Omo Valley. This will bring tourism and undoubtedly urbanize the region. I hope they stop building the road.
i think this is really cool. i wanna travel to africa one day. if you ever go there again, you should visit the royal palace of benin city, ethiopia. i wanna be a game designer and thats where i got alot of my inspiration (all of my knowledge is from books and internet though :/
What else can you expect from some Euro-Western people were raised to force their own culture on everyone else and think if some doesn't speek English they are somehow incapable.
you mean the people who send billions in dollars of aid to them, the "euro-western" people are what give them their food, without them they would die. America sends the Peace Corps and the brave men and women who go there possibly risking their lives because of religous persecution of jews and christians (Catholics namely) or because of racism towards white people, so yeah, call us culture forcing euro westerners.
@laxfan41 these ppl survive by themselves. If you look @ africa it is only the areas that are colonized and westernized that are poorer. "uncontacted" tribes are self-sufficient.
Hi there. They understand the word "Salaam" because it is a universal word for "hello" in the muslim parts of Africa. 50% of Ethiopians have muslim roots. Single words are often understood like, "hello", "thank you" and "photo". Similarly, if you say "hello" in many parts of China or Peru or Liby, they will understand too!
This video was totally one sided.If you were serious about having a genuine interest in these people & their lives you would have employed the services of an interpreter.They never understood a thing of what you spoke & the only reason you were invited in was in hope of the cash you might give them.How would you like it if an Inuit man speaking ONLY his language was filming you & your family asking a lot of unintelligible inept questions & had the temerity to touch your child like you did his?
kanakaken 4 months ago
@kanakaken -- thanks for your note. I would not judge you because I don't know you. I can respond to your comment and say that these people speak Hamer. They don't speak Amharic. Even local Ethiopians don't speak Hamer. They welcomed me into their village and home. They don't use money so no money was involved. You have NO idea where I was, what I was doing, why I was there or anything, really. So, I'll let you continue to use your imagination.
whereisdanman 4 months ago
@whereisdanman These people are Hamer-Banna and they are predominately Sunni hence using the word Salem/Salaam.My imagination now runs wild. I only judge what I saw.You spoke to the people in your form of English,they understood nothing. Being Sunni, they recite the Koran in Arabic yet you didn't bother to learn basic Arabic greetings or Hamer-Banna. please tell us you NEVER touched any women or girls as you did the boy, a blatant mistake against all Muslims.Where was interpreter?
kanakaken 4 months ago
@kanakaken -- I'm going to do you a favor and teach you something that you didn't know, or rather correct you on something that you thought you knew. First, the Hamer tribe is different from the Bana tribe. Although they both speak Hamer-Banna. Second, NONE of the tribes in the Omo Valley are "Muslim," they don't speak Arabic, and they don't know what a Koran is. Your imagination is humorous! Anyway, I'll leave you with some info so you can go learn: They believe in Animism. Look it up, buddy.
whereisdanman 4 months ago
@kanakaken there not muslim, or sunni dumb ass, selam is a universal way of saying peace in ethiopia. cristians,muslims, jews,and pagaans say selam in ethiopia!
robutta100 4 months ago
@robutta100 Thanks dumb ass, I appreciate the information. Oh by the way dumb ass, it's not 'there not muslim', It's, 'They're not Muslim'. Dumber Ass! A person who has never been taught a particular subject cannot be blamed for not having that knowledge but I do blame myself because I could have looked it up. You on the other hand attended school In the US yet have failed to comprehend English grammar. But what you say is true, I say 'Salaam Halaikum' often but I'm not Muslim.
kanakaken 4 months ago
@kanakaken thanx for the grammer class, u fuckin nerd
robutta100 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
man why the hell they let this cracker in there like that... filming the girl and shit,, f'n pervert ass nigga... they cant tell this fool is a wierdo
mixumup1 7 months ago
Comment removed
mixumup1 7 months ago
At least 80% of the video and questioning was focused on the pre-pubescent female and the zoom feature was used to its maximum. The father invites the man into his house and this is how his hospitality is treated. He videos his child and post it on YouTube for subtle unflattering titillation. The Devil will always be the devil. Shun him when he knocks on your door.
TheIbiscus 7 months ago
@TheIbiscus - your ignorance and hatred is very obvious to others. Please try to keep it in your own world. This is the best way to be enlightened and free from the negative emotions you have.
whereisdanman 7 months ago
@TheIbiscus;I concur. Why the hell are white people so fascinated with us fo anyway???? They really don't like us and hate us.
tHE1iAm38 7 months ago
white people have always been in our country..then they call us niggers and talk down upon us like we are nothing. I really dont understand why.
dbaile2 8 months ago
@dbaile2 cause your animals and we regard u as such
GiggleHz 8 months ago
@GiggleHz wtf...so wtf does that make you...you whites love your world wars...lol..have a few more and your def going to make your population even smaller..and for you to say that def shows your ignorance because Im 100% sure that if I where right in front of you, you wouldnt have the balls to call me that shit to my face because I would fuck you up..its funny how white people talk shit behind a computer screen then say nothing in public..even down here in georgia..lol..shit b funny as hell..lol
dbaile2 8 months ago
@dbaile2 @GiggleHz - man, GiggleHz is full of hatred and negative emotions. The only one "talking shit behind a computer screen" is....well... GiggleHz! I suggest that you watch again while imagining you are in the remote Omo Valley between Ethiopia, Kenya and Sudan - alone and vulnerable in the remote desert with beautiful people and an amazingly precious ancient culture. This is what I experienced and have shared with you. I hope you get to go there some day. Maybe you won't be so angry.
whereisdanman 7 months ago
@whereisdanman If I ever make a trip to africa it will be to stay...the United States has nothing to offer our people but hatred...Alot of blacks are starting to go back to west africa and start new lives there..hopfully in the future I will have the funds to leave this racist country and return to africa.
dbaile2 7 months ago
@whereisdanman Before you come back at me saying I'm angry or untravelled, I have NO anger towards you & I have lived in a Papua New Guinea village with the people & I learnt their language, I also learnt the language of the Ni-Vanuatu. I lived in Peru and Cuba with the locals & I speak Spanish.
How many words of the Hamer people did you learn? Don't include 'Salaam', that's Arabic & I'm assuming they are Muslim people here,but I could be wrong. Did they greet you with 'Halaikum Salaam'?
kanakaken 4 months ago
cool
CrazyNative4 9 months ago
@Deptstate799 u are a jerkoff, go die
kobie8819591 10 months ago
the little girl is pretty and very friendly...
passionateOne32 11 months ago 2
omg that girl is so beautiful!!!
Rachulie 1 year ago 2
@Deptstate799 You seem to have this backwards idea that "culture" implies exotic things. Culture is that complex whole which includes knowledge, belief, arts, morals, laws, customs, and any other capabilities and habits acquired by man as a member of a society. Here are exampled of white people's cultures:
watch?v=ZfghPINpAgQ
watch?v=a6Oy8FaBirQ
watch?v=FpThjLrs24U
watch?v=8yhwXyjVsVM
watch?v=P3zZszdvOGY
watch?v=_JpcR3kblv0
xm377Moyocoyatzin 1 year ago
@xm377Moyocoyatzin Hey, the footage of the Swedish keyed violin is amazing.
osiruskat 9 months ago
@Deptstate799 Why? Maybe because they want to explore? Want to know the place and the culture? What could they possibly learn? Well all about the people that live there as well as the geography. Then you say "White's are not appreciative of people who have culture" which is a very dumb statement again, as if whites themselves don't have cultures or aren't interested in learning about other people. You're just ignorant and prejudiced.
xm377Moyocoyatzin 1 year ago
@Deptstate799 That was a dumb statement (o_0)
xm377Moyocoyatzin 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I really hate this video because this isn't Africa.
Dramactica 1 year ago
wow!! I actually have some of their genes in my dna profile.
akaroyalljelly 1 year ago
@wakanu7 I mean not your intention, and yes I know she's not 2 yrs. old but damn. Back off, its a baby.
wakanu7 1 year ago
That's it, I'm done. Africa is screwed. It is a dark barbaric continent that will never amount to anything.
Are Africans nice people- yes. Will an African country ever go to Mar's? No
Over 6,000yrs to build a decent civilization and yet Africa has failed epically. These people have never moved beyond the stone age and the consequences are massive poverty, ignorance and cruelty through civil strife.
ImaginedWriter 1 year ago
@ImaginedWriter take a 100,000.0000 people out of any european country and watch the results.
akaroyalljelly 1 year ago
@akaroyalljelly Africa is not a country but a continent so that statement is bs, next up the trans atlantic slave trade was predominately focused on west african slaves not in Ethiopia which is on the horn of Africa in the east.
Next up even 2000yrs ago Europe was still more advanced with the Roman Empire than these primitive savages.
Your continent is a dark and primitive place because of Africans, Europe played a part but the biggest culprit is African stupidity.
ImaginedWriter 1 year ago
@ImaginedWriter Africa was decimated of her populace. When you look at the world's population from 1500-1800 (transatlantic slave trade) there was less than 2billion yet 100million was violently uprooted to foreign shore. (do the math) The scar left on africa still festers. (imagine what europe would be today if she went thru the same) and her peoples still suffer no matter where they are in the world cont...
akaroyalljelly 1 year ago
cont...As an atypical europid who suffers from a 'god complex' you figure that any culture that can't resist your guns must be inferior ; this is why you can turn a 'juandiced eye' to the australian aborigines, the native people of the americas, and the tasmanians, people who you have either destroyed or colonized.
akaroyalljelly 1 year ago
@ImaginedWriter What's your definition of a decent civilisation? One that lives in peace and in total equilibrium with its surroundings or one that goes around murering innocent people, raping innocent women and destroying entire ways of life? Clearly a barbarians idea of a decent civilisation is far from my own.
mymarkis666 1 year ago 2
@ImaginedWriter
we have kingdoms.
Dramactica 1 year ago
imallwayzright 10 months ago
No doubt. I can imagine it was an awesome experience, you were just focusing on your own mind and world at the time. I would have focused on my own also, but it wouldn't have focused on just the baby. My focus would have been gaining great knowledge from the elder. He holds all the answers : ) Next time you have the honorable privilege, focus on the enlightenment...
Spiritree41 1 year ago
@Spiritree41 All the answers to many questions I must add. The sacred Elder gentlemen in this video....Thanks for sharing your adventures. I would have preferred to say enlightenment, but not in this case..
Spiritree41 1 year ago
@whereisdanman do they practice birth control in these tribes what do they use as birth control get back at me with a response please
mutnojme 1 year ago
@mutnojme -- i do not believe that they practice a "western" form of birth control. Their culture is quite different and is directly connected to nature: weather, temperature, moon, sun, wind and time. they use this in what westerners call a "spiritual" way to practice birth control. However, there are NGOs that have offered methods of western birth control - which is also a way to prevent sexually transmitted diseases. I am not an expert, so please don't use my word as factual. Good luck!
whereisdanman 1 year ago
Why did you put soooo much interest in that adolescent child. Whats your fascination with her. This is exploitaion of a minor child. There is noooooo way you would have had that camara on my child! Other than that this would have been great footage...
Spiritree41 2 years ago
she's very beautiful?
starwars34 1 year ago
@Spiritree41 -- My fascination? Wouldn't you find visiting this family in the Omo Valley of south west Ethiopia 'fascinating'? Can you imagine walking around this village and being warmly welcomed by the local people? If you watch the video, you'll see that her father invited me into his house and introduced me to his family. Thanks for watching. i hope you enjoyed it.
whereisdanman 1 year ago
@whereisdanman I find people who make comments such as @Spiritree41 have never been out of the country and sadly have no understanding of the world. I spend a lot of time in the Omo and found nothing wrong with your video and in no way did it show you were fascinated with the young girl, nor were you exploiting a child!! You were sharing an amazing experience!
wildculture39 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Spiritree41 What an idiot you are.
GeekBoy03 1 year ago
@Spiritree41 what an idiot comment lmao
xDepthChargex 1 year ago
@Spiritree41 its good to see some whites are not racist...
dbaile2 8 months ago
why don't you just let these people alone?
constableman 2 years ago
What a beautiful people... thank you for the video..
angelkubin 2 years ago 2
I do think the peacecorps are helpful intentionally,I also think if various tribes live near the sea(seafoods.)they can thrive,but perhaps with a little more difficulty in interiorlands unless they have a huge herd of cows,et.cetera?
CulturePeaceForever 2 years ago
If living close to sea,various tribes could thrive,but may have more difficulty living far from the sea(unless they own larger herds of cows,sheeps,et.cetera.)
CulturePeaceForever 2 years ago
Sounds like Whereisdanman has a translator friend who is there with him,otherwise,Whereisdanman would be asking them himself in their African language,or he's asking the questions in English so we,the English-speaking YouTube learners can understand what's being said.
CulturePeaceForever 2 years ago
ja wer bist denn Du ????!!!!!! :)
Riola123 2 years ago
The road building must stop,but thousands of petitioners worldwide would be necessary to stop the road building. Africa is a huge country,why do they want to build roads near the tribes?It would be indignant of the builders,it would cause culture shock to the tribes.
CulturePeaceForever 2 years ago
you meant continent
caramelathome 2 years ago
They want to build roads so that they can become civilized like the western hemisphere and parts of the eastern.
laxfan41 2 years ago
Do tribe leaders lead the way with home ownership(where they live,place,et.cetera)I hope they will be safe from urbanizations for many years into the future!
CulturePeaceForever 2 years ago
These tribes are nomadic. They move around the land according to the weather. Within each tribe, there is a clan, or "community" with a chief. Each clan protects one another from intruders. Each clans understands whose home is whose. Misbehavior within a clan is dealt with by the chief and the counsel.
Unfortunately, there is a road being built from Arba Minch through the Omo Valley. This will bring tourism and undoubtedly urbanize the region. I hope they stop building the road.
whereisdanman 2 years ago
maybe the world would not be on the verge of global warming if everyone lived this way...
L2thePz 3 years ago
i think this is really cool. i wanna travel to africa one day. if you ever go there again, you should visit the royal palace of benin city, ethiopia. i wanna be a game designer and thats where i got alot of my inspiration (all of my knowledge is from books and internet though :/
kanoro16 3 years ago
I think they should learn about their own ways of life
funkyumesh 3 years ago
What else can you expect from some Euro-Western people were raised to force their own culture on everyone else and think if some doesn't speek English they are somehow incapable.
BigWaaz 3 years ago
you mean the people who send billions in dollars of aid to them, the "euro-western" people are what give them their food, without them they would die. America sends the Peace Corps and the brave men and women who go there possibly risking their lives because of religous persecution of jews and christians (Catholics namely) or because of racism towards white people, so yeah, call us culture forcing euro westerners.
laxfan41 2 years ago
@laxfan41 these ppl survive by themselves. If you look @ africa it is only the areas that are colonized and westernized that are poorer. "uncontacted" tribes are self-sufficient.
ebeledi 1 year ago
why they say salaam If ethiopians are christians not muslims or jews?
Sumayresta89 3 years ago
Hi there. They understand the word "Salaam" because it is a universal word for "hello" in the muslim parts of Africa. 50% of Ethiopians have muslim roots. Single words are often understood like, "hello", "thank you" and "photo". Similarly, if you say "hello" in many parts of China or Peru or Liby, they will understand too!
whereisdanman 3 years ago
because that is their language!
uneedz 3 years ago
actually ethopia has many religions including the ones you just named.
kanoro16 3 years ago
awesome...post more of your videos if you can...
websoull 3 years ago