Added: 5 years ago
From: bravenewworld711
Views: 437,123
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (862)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • still one of the greatest musicals ever written. and one of the greatest musicals to play in.

  • He looks like a male version of megan fox

  • Thumbs up if u listen to that more than fourty five years later !

  • Dr. Jacoby and Ben Horne from Twin Peaks!

  • hoping this comes up in the GCSE mock ahahhaha if not.... i'm dead.

  • Music GCSE students already revising unite :D

  • I must say, I liked WSS, but I find pretty much every singing voice to be painful to hear. Not good, pitchy, just hard to listen to. The songs are good, just... the voices... Agh... Maybe it's the way singing was done back then but it's excruciating.

  • Blah, this version of this song is bad and Darren Criss' is even worse, I don't even know why you guys are fighting over.

  • @phylosaccount

    because people have different opinions to yours and therefore feel the need to express it. This is the internet where people come to argue over stupid things but to just outright belittle ones opinion like you did is arrogant and foolish. I happen to enjoy darrens version and this version cause they both come at the song a different way. Lighten up man.

  • Fuck Glee. This is West Side Story.

  • Thumbs up if it was not glee, but GCSE music that brought you here!

  • what interval does the chorus land in??x

  • The euphemism song!!

  • Am planning on playing Tony next year in my school production 0_o the prospect is kinda daunting...

  • GCSE music...

  • best song ever.......:D

  • I love Glee, BUT. The covers of West Side Story that glee has done...

    I just like, Tonight (Jenna's Version), I Feel Pretty(on the mash-up with Unpretty), A Boy Like That/I Have A Love(only the parts where Naya sings), Cool and America.

    I really hate the glee version for this song, for Somewhere, Tonight (Darren and Lea's version) and One Hand, One Heart.

    I think that Lea and Darren weren't good as Maria and Toni. I hate only the songs when these 2 sing.

    OH, AND I LOVE THIS VERSION!! <3

  • he is so talented.

  • Am I the only one who thinks he sounds a bit like Elvis at 2:26 on?

    I love both versions (have both on my ipod :P) ; actually prefer Darren's belting "tonight" at the end rather than Richard's high "tonight."

    And I liked this WAY before Glee ever touched it.

  • Comment removed

  • its so annoying how everyone keeps comparing this to retarted glee!!! glee isnt even comparable to West Side Story

  • thumbs up if you were here before glee and you love both

  • Saw the Broadway revisited version yesterday on stage at Michigan State University. Saw the movie when I was in 6th grade... the stage version left me speechless with its singing, dancing and stage sets. Definitely worth seeing live. It's a bit more 'R' rated than the movie, that's for sure. Probably the way it was in the original stage version on Broadway. Warning posters up that the play contained 'adult' content. If the stage version comes to your town, see it.

  • The GLeee version it'ssoooooo much less GAY than this jujuju

  • @JustMeFreakOut Glee fans have no taste. GET OUT.

  • Why does everyone freak out about better this better than that shit, Chill out. And this is of course better. 

  • @SarahLeeAnn lol you said it!

  • Dont get it? Compare the part from 1:34 to Blaine's version. ^_^

  • Before Glee, this is okay, but now he appears to be so sympathetic compared to Blaine. ^__^

  • thumbs up if you were here before glee :D

  • @Rafavampire96 i'm here for gcse music mate

  • @Rafavampire96 I am so proud of Darren, especially with his brilliant cover of this song. but I have always been a fan of West Side Story, favorite musical.

  • Tony is almost as handsome as Bernardo.

  • @amberfwn No, Bernardo's still much more handsome ;)

  • I wish they had the scene when the Lt. comes into Doc's store and starts to tell both gangs off. He really tells the Jets off, gets real personal.

  • I dont understand all of the fighting... This is an amazing version, Glee had an amazing version, the actor in the performance of West Side Story I saw in September had an amazing version, the one that Albert Brooks sings just before he dies in Defending Your Life is an amazing amazing version... JUST CHILL PEOPLE!!!

  • GLEE DID A LOUSY JOB. stop saying otherwise. haha

  • This is very awesome compared to the present version. Thumbs up!

  • i love this song it is so energetic and happy and positive love this!

  • Correct me if I'm wrong but doesn't Richard Beymer not even sing in this? I'm pretty sure it's someone else singing...so isn't it a little hypocritical to hate on the Glee version for a little autotune when the actor in this isn't even singing it?

  • @softball36smile it says at the very end that jimmy bryant was singing iit instead so you are correct

  • I don't see why there's hatred! I admit - I haven't looked into West Side Story before Glee took it on, but surely that doesn't matter if I liked it enough to come find and experience the original? Who cares if you knew it before, and who cares if you prefer one version over another? Can't we just enjoy them both?

  • GCSE music is fun...

  • My favourite songs of this musical, :) The lyrics just make me happyy. And to the annoying Darren/Glee fans: Prejudice is just ignorance. Don't bash other atrists just cos you prefer them, keep it civil man. And, I say this as a Darren/Glee/Starkid maniac. That is all.

  • I love the instrumentals and melody to this song.

  • God, some of these Darren fangirl comments are why being a Glee fan is embarrassing. How about trying to appreciate the beauty of this version instead of being a dumbass and going "OMGZ DARREN WAS LYKE SO MUCH BETTR!!", ignorance is never cute.

  • GCSE MUSIC! :)

  • Its not even him singing it

  • Look, I'm a Glee fan myself, and I'm disgusted at what some of you people are saying about this. Darren did *not* sing it 'better', though I do love his version. This is the ORIGINAL here, and it's really comparing apples to oranges. So please, stop complaining, if you can't appreciate this version, then go listen to something else.

  • only you say that it's becouse the glee version it's better and YOU know it..

  • WHY is this page being contaminated by Glee people? Don't get me wrong. I LOVE Glee and Darren Criss could have me anytime. BUT cmon everyone! This is the glorious original, pure voice, not autotuned, and without it Darren would have never even gotten to sing his jipped version on Glee. I like to come to this page often, btw, because I have a low voice and can actually sing this song...in the same octave as this brilliant guy here... :P

  • All the Glee fans arguing about how much better Darren was. To be honest he used very little dynamics and sang it completely wrong. Yes he has an awesome voice but Stephen Sondheim would be so angry at that version. He got pissy when the cast sang it slightly out so when Darren just sung it without keyed techniques... This is far better than the glee one thumbs up if you agree

  • i. hate. this. song. but that's GCSE music for you, not glee or whatever.

  • Blah blah blah West Side story vs. Glee... who cares? Just enjoy the music. Both casts are talented. You know who deserves the intense props? The composers of this musical.

  • @ stargatelover007: Uh-oh, they might have to have a big rumble. lol

  • Im srry guys, original , or not, Darren criss sang it better. U cant argue w/ the quality of the voice

  • I like glee and I like west side story. I don't get all the hate for each other. I like both versions...

  • atleast this one dont KILL my ear drums ! ... damn Peripetie -_-

  • LOVE THIS SONG

  • GCSE Music brought me here

  • @yoursdiana1 Up yoursdiana.

  • Glee monetizes on someone else's creativity and incredibly sub-par actors and writers.

  • GCSE MUSIC last year yay

  • I'm glad Glee did the cover, because it reminded me of what an amazing musical WSS is and prompted me to watch it again...I think both sides should chill.

  • @bobbyrayfans both sides should be 'cool' ;D ... 

  • @bobbyrayfans SAME HERE

  • I don't know why people are complaining about people coming here because of glee! D: Seriously if glee wasnt made, I wouldn't know about things like this or artists like Barbra! People are just saying what they think, there entitled too theres no need to get in a fuss over it, just love the music thats amazing by both artists! :D

  • i think glee's version is better. /shrugs

  • I didn't care for the Glee version of this song so I came here to see how it's supposed to sound and I gotta say, now I'm sure I don't really care for this song at all... I think this is one musical that's just not for me.

  • Darn that GLEE, they're always making abominations out of everything! - Commander Up

  • Wooo GCSE Music -_-

  • Its not bad, but honestly the glee version is much more better, and cleaner :)

  • Darren Criss fangirls seriously need to go somewhere else. Nobody cares!

  • Richard Beymer wishes that he was as sexy, and talented, as Darren Criss (and this is coming from someone, who is been a huge fan of this movie for years, and has watched it dozens of times)! I predict, that Darren's Version will become the new standard!

  • I love both versions because they have both different ways of awesomeness I also like the old floss song they did on suite life of Zach and Cody to this song lol they do covers to show other arrangements

  • whose darren?

  • Excited for more west side story on glee :D

  • Hey, I think it's great that Glee brought a bunch of people here to introduce them to West Side Story, which they hadn't seen before, and other musicals, as well.

    I had the great advantage of going to a performing arts high school (waaay back in the 80's!) that inspired my love of musicals; not everyone gets that kind of exposure. Yay for Glee for inspiring a love of theater. If you hate the messenger (i.e. Glee), that's alright, but don't hate the message - the music and the magic.

  • Oh God, seriously, this isn't your personal Darren fansite, actual WSS fans don't want to see a Sondheim/Bernstein musical song being spammed with OMG DARREN CRISS IS THE LOVE <3. Take all your fangirl comments back to gleeonfox.

  • press like if u knew this song befor it was on glee

  • @Santoslovesglee well it was actually made before glee and is one of the popular songs for artist to sing. I think its awesome that because of glee, kids who may have never been interested in musicals now know about them. i think it is a good thing. my daughter watched west side story for the first time after darren sang somethings coming. and never heard of funny girl until glee. so horray for glee.

  • @brnigrlfl624 Thank you for saying this!! I loved this musical and this song before Glee but there are many great musicals I never heard of until Glee (like Funny Girl, which I'm in LOVE with now) and there's nothing wrong with that! When I see those comments, it makes me want to say... If Glee brings in more people to love musicals, and older musicals like Funny Girl, West Side Story, Singing in th Rain and Rocky, then let them love musicals. They just heard of the them a different way than you

  • Darren's will never be better because THIS IS THE ORIGINAL. BUT he did EXTREMELY FANTASTIC! (this coming from a gleek and never been this, but wants to)

  • Okay. I love the movie and all but as I rewatch this, I realize that Darren Criss made this song even more amazing. Even if you don't like glee, please just search him singing this song. It may be autotuned while this isnt but it is still pretty amazing.

  • Comment removed

  • I love how the top comments are about Darren's version of the song lol

  • I'm gratefull to Glee, really, because of it now I know so many wonderful songs...Thanks Ryan Murphy

  • Ok I love glee but come on guys glee would be nothing with out the originals please stop comparing to glee

  • @bvlucero1 you are right this is the original and no one should be comparing a cover to it. but you can prefer one singer over the other.. i love this song. but i do prefer darren criss singing this song more. nothing being taken away from the original . the song has been sung by many artist. its all about taste. he sings it great. just like darren's version.

  • Respond to this video... i know it use to irritate me when someone would compare the warbler covers to originals/ its an accapella group. duh. it would be different.lol. and glees versions are usually different too,, because its a glee club! lol. i think we should just enjoy different versions of the songs.

  • The comments on this video make me sad. You are going to come onto the original and talk about Glee and how much "better" it was? This is an amazing movie and the fact that you only pretend to appreciate it because you saw Glee is just silly. And back then they couldn't just auto-tune the cast to make them sound good, they had to have skill, which the cast of this movie did. I enjoy Glee, but I will always love the original works and artists they get their songs from more :)

  • @Kristniscte You know the parts of Maria and Tony were sung by someone else? Just throwing it out there.

  • @Kristniscte actually, if it weren't for Glee we would never know that such wonderful music is out there, for some who watch Glee it would be the first time hearing those songs, so of course they are gonna think that that version is better. We all love the originals :)

  • @xXDaN1213Xx or you these people that would never know that this stuff is out there could get some culture for a second and watch/listen to a show like WSS, just saying.

  • @Kristniscte Most of the actors in West Side Story didn't even sing their own songs. Honestly, I don't want to have some stupid debate about how 'terrible' glee is, but have you heard the cast of glee sing live? WIth out the auto tune? Most all of them are amazing singers. And who are you to say these people are "Pretending" to appreciate this music? People can actually like the original song and the glee covers.

  • @Kristniscte Lol I love this movie, but you should probably know that neither Natalie Wood nor Richard Beymer did the singing, their voices are dubbed.

  • @Kristniscte I was pleased when I saw the Glee one, it made me happy to see that such a classic and great film was involved in something modern. I have no issues with the singers in Glee singing this, but honestly, in comparison to this, the film back when it was on VHS (Video for those of you who don't know what it is), it just completely and utterly outshines the Glee one. I agree with you that people should not appreciate it (or rather pretend to) purely because they saw Glee. If anything....

  • <3 <3

  • love this film, obviously, who wouldn't? but darren criss is just such a brilliantly talented musician and actor, far better than this bloke. no disrespect, the film is still one of my favourites but my god darren is good.

  • i wish i wouldve seen the comments about this before the glee episode. <3

  • it's good that people were brought here by Glee but seriously people?! i just turned 19 (and though forced the first time in music class) have seen this film countless times! oh, && darren was pretty good (love him.!) but tony just has that VOICE.! yum

  • As much as I disliked this movie, this version of the song is still better than the Glee version. The version by Yes is the best, in my opinion.

  • like this if you watched this because darren criss sang this song on glee ;)

  • i love this song! i really wanna see this movie now because of glee and everything, is that sad or what? ;)

  • @leaveit2stever Definitely watch it! The whole thing is on YT. I bawl my eyes out every time...that darn ending scene... =(

  • that awkward moment when you like the glee version just a little bit better.

  • I like Darren Criss. But his interpretation/performance of this... has nothing on this version of the song. This is perfection.

  • I love Glee, and I'm a big fan of Darren Chris.. but I also love West Side Story, and for me this is definitely the BEST version.. sorry Darren!

  • WAIT WAIT WAIT

    So there are ACTUALLY people have seen Darren [<3] perform this, but have not seen WSS?!?!

    AHH. NO GO WATCH THIS PLAY GUYS NAOOO.

    Although, yeah, Darren killed it.

  • It's just so funny to see all those gleeks and starkids comments! Love you guys!

  • I'm here for Darren xD

  • how could people say they never watched WSS and that they come here cause of glee

    So sorry for them... Even Ryan Murphy know how much this movie is THE CLASSIC

  • Comment removed

  • I think he sings beautifully... I don't know y ppl say he sings bad...I mean as long as its not me singing, everybody should b happy. :)

  • I knew of West Side Story and I never liked this singer's version, then when Darren did it I gotta admit he did a lot better than this singer. But, there are way better singers than Darren who have truly done this song justice.

  • ....he can not sing. Just awful

  • Darren as Tony and Rachel as Maria it is!! so excited!! :D and to glee haters, if they did not do this cover, i wouldve have known this!! im not from the west so its really great to watch this!! so dont hate on glee, i personally love both~

  • i still like this version the BEST!

  • DARREN CHRISS IS GOOD, WEST SIDE STORY ITS PERFECT

  • Am i the only one slightly annoyed that the top two comments are about glee and not how great this song is?

  • tony is such a moron.

  • I love this movie, I have literally, watched it dozens of times. I have also, seen several different versions of the play, but I have to say, that Darren Criss's Version, is by far the best version, that I have ever seen, or heard. His Vocals, his Acting, and his Stage Presence, are all Superior to any version that I have come across. Not to mention the fact, that unlike Richard Beymer, he did not need a voice double! Darren Should play Tony on Broadway, he would be AMAZING in the role !!!

  • Comment removed

  • Fuckin glee, man...

  • why does he look so sweaty

  • @Ralphoegirl Cause he's working

  • @Ralphoegirl buy the movie 

  • Are you all REALLY here because of Glee? I thought West Side Story was well known...anyway, the original is so much better. Darren kind of...yelled it.

  • @CatsandBananas Yes WSS is popular, I've hear about it a lot but I've never seen the movie or the musical. I just watch Glee and really liked the song that Darren's charater sang and wanted to hear the original. #yeahiknowit'smylife

  • Got this movie on DVD. It came as a double set with Guys and Dolls. It's the only reason I bought it. Still haven't watched it yet.

  • I, like many of the people here, am commenting because of Glee. I've never seen West Side Story, but thanks to Darren's amazing rendition of the song, I am very much inclined to see the show now!! I love that Glee introduces our young generation to music we might not have listened to in the past.

  • I gotta say, when I saw this on glee last night all I thought was that I really preferred darren singing it.

    A bit biased b/c I've always disliked Tony. It's all about Bernardo<3

  • I want a Tony in my life :)

  • Oh come on people.

    You know you wanted to be that something thats coming to darren ;)

  • was anyone else singing at the top of their lungs when darren sang this ?

  • GCSE... Glee... This song is following me everywhere...

  • darren whipped

  • darren was sooooo good performing this song!!!!

  • @trishsilverio23 Come on, youtube, make a multiple thumbs up button so I can share my feelings of this comment

  • Glee wasn't that good for this song D: 

  • Darren killed it <3<3<3

  • Darren did a great job with this song, but there is something about the original Tony's voice. It just makes the song full of life to me. Also the last note Darren held kinda killed the song for me. I love the original Tony's soft "tonight" as the song fades away. Not every song needs to finish with a huge belting note. Sometimes soft does the trick.

  • @nurahsplaylists i like how you're so calm about darren's cover. I mean that's the way its supposed to be. Some people get so freaking uptight about glee. I love glee and I love both covers. Both are amazing

  • Darren did a great job with this song, but there is something about the original Tony's voice. It just makes the song full of life to me.

  • darren did kill this song, but this original version will be loved forever <3

  • @AlyssarulezD00d4 kill as in ROCKED IT! lol

  • I love Darren, but this version will always be my favorite <3

  • @klaineforever Or they could have people in their lives who watch these things? I'm a Glee fan, but seriously, Glee isn't the be all and end all of what "younger" people watch.

  • Before I watched this video, I had to scroll down' to see if there were any comments related to Glee. I guessed correct.

  • I've been obsessed with this movie, and song, for exactly 21/2 months. And just the fact that now Darren Criss has sung this song, it adds to the obsession :)

    p.s. i was a fan of Darren's before he was on Glee :)

  • @Muletail11 Lemme guess, you're a starkid too?

  • @abbyangel9 Oh yeah :) have been for 3 years

  • Stop comparing to 2 different versions :) i love both! <3333

  • i prefer darren criss' version!

  • Without Glee the younger generation wouldn't have seen this great music.

  • @klaineforever IKR Well I saw this movie when I was like 6 and I am 12 :D

  • Also, is it just me, or does he look like James Mardsen? (I'll stop trolling now. . . x3)

  • Isn't the guy named Richard Beymer, not Darren Criss?

  • @stefanieluvschocolat The Actor's name is Richard Beymer, but his singing was dubbed by Jimmy Bryant. : )

  • @trassaya I know, I meant to sarcastic in that comment : P

  • Comment removed

  • Thumbs up if you here not because of Glee but because you love West Side Story :)

  • @livyscrib Im here again because of Glee but I love this movie one of my favourite I first saw it when I was 6 yrs old :D

  • Hey haters, it could be worse. They could have had Finn sing it. Now THAT would have been horrible.

    I think Darren does just great. (:

  • @EternallyConfuzled You're wrong. CORY, not Finn would've been better than Darren

  • @ChiquisLc13 unpopular opinion.