@drconfuse Are you for real? Surely got to be a wind-up! This has got to be one of the worst cover versions I've ever heard. No soul, no feeling and bereft of meaning. The only piece of genuis are the supreme lyrics of this classic Del Amitri song written by the hugely talented Justin Currie
i didnt know del amitri got so much respect from thier peers in enhland too bad this sucks they have done great with springsteen songs but this blows.....
I'm a lifelong MMEB fan, seen them many times, bought their albums. But I also love Del Amitri. The sheer cowardice of cutting the crucial last lines - "They'll burn down the synagogues at six o'clock and we'll all go along like before" is pathetic. Shame on you, Mike Lubowitz.
@simon10708 poor old steve waller; he was a bugger of a boy, and a great guitarist. saw him live a few times in london playing in a pub called the father redcap (think it was in camberwell)
Noel McCalla - Mike Rutherford (Genesis, Mike & the Mechanics fame) did his first solo album in 1980 - so much for it being a "Mike Rutherford" solo album, as Mr McCalla was handling the vocals!!!
Resorting to foul language in a comment reflects the writer`s lack of intellect and poor education associated with a bad upbringing. I used to be a social worker.
May I inquire as to why one so erudite as your good self is no longer a social worker? Perhaps the stereotypical presumptions you resort to and lack of familiarity with informal discourse were indicative of one fundamentally unable to be objective in such an environment?
Very good!
trudeluren 3 weeks ago
Really not a fan. Del Amitri made a version that really didn't need to be touched!
17JIMPY07 7 months ago
cool
albanlanfant 8 months ago in playlist manfred mann`s earth band
So amazing
Old manfred succeeds once again.
Taking a totally unskilled musicians song and tranformes it to epic divine tunes.
We all heard it before with Springsteen and Dylan songs.
These so call original artists don't even have the skill to tune their instruments correctly.
Takes a genious to make these magicians acts.
Hats off to Manfred
drconfuse 1 year ago 3
@drconfuse Are you for real? Surely got to be a wind-up! This has got to be one of the worst cover versions I've ever heard. No soul, no feeling and bereft of meaning. The only piece of genuis are the supreme lyrics of this classic Del Amitri song written by the hugely talented Justin Currie
STUKAY 1 year ago
@STUKAY : Agree
MsBainy 1 year ago
How someone can take a perfect Del Amitri song and then make that this sort of a drivel version of it is utterly puzzling.
tlil5774 1 year ago 2
i didnt know del amitri got so much respect from thier peers in enhland too bad this sucks they have done great with springsteen songs but this blows.....
unstabledavid 1 year ago
Wow! This is fantastic! Manfred Mann's Earth Band takes this song to a higher level!
Yameta67 1 year ago
@Yameta67 Bollocks! Sorry but your wrong!
swollower 1 year ago
Way to kill a great song.
And cutting the last, most powerful verse? Shame on you and may your career burn in flames as a result.
jamesstafforduk 1 year ago
Totally killed the sentiment and meaning of the song.
Fuckin cover artists should be hunted down and set on fire.
Fuck sake Mike it's not like you havn't penned some crackers in you're time????
gorgierebel 2 years ago
I'm a lifelong MMEB fan, seen them many times, bought their albums. But I also love Del Amitri. The sheer cowardice of cutting the crucial last lines - "They'll burn down the synagogues at six o'clock and we'll all go along like before" is pathetic. Shame on you, Mike Lubowitz.
simon10708 2 years ago
Comment removed
scotchlvr 2 years ago
@simon10708 poor old steve waller; he was a bugger of a boy, and a great guitarist. saw him live a few times in london playing in a pub called the father redcap (think it was in camberwell)
applemac555 1 year ago
Funny..... I so much more like this version....
bewemo 2 years ago
Awful cover. Urgggh!
getyoursfree 2 years ago
Manfred Mann forever! with Chris Thompson
mattmurd0ck 2 years ago
This is fucking horrible! I thought it was a joke. The singer is good but the cheesy music is dreadful, just dreadful.
casperld 2 years ago
@ casperld
So you think a guy who is singing and playing guitar like Bob Dylan in the 60s isn´t cheesy? MM liftd the song up to a higher point.
anonymusum 2 years ago
holy shit, is this the original. Its fuckin aweful. Prefer del amitris version.
bood22ataol 3 years ago
Fear not.....this is a cover version of a Del Amitri origional
celtickool 2 years ago
Nice vocab BBBS, you fucking fagget get alife no one cares about your big words.....im a social worker
Gatorade117 3 years ago
I liked Thompson and Waller as vocalists...
joh2 4 years ago
Thompson rocks! He was the best lead vocalist. Manfred Mann's Earth Band rocks! The best band in history!
Godofwrath68 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is an atrocity on a similar scale to the Holocaust.
harryedwards 4 years ago
at least it`s better than the version by that Scottish band who died a death
bigrexlowlife 4 years ago
If the Third Reich was a karaoke act, then maybe...
BBBS 4 years ago
Noel McCalla is the MAN!
Eschatosaurus 4 years ago 2
Noel McCalla - Mike Rutherford (Genesis, Mike & the Mechanics fame) did his first solo album in 1980 - so much for it being a "Mike Rutherford" solo album, as Mr McCalla was handling the vocals!!!
joh2 4 years ago 2
would this be the same guy who sang with moon in the 80s
stevesarah 4 years ago
FUCKING horrific cover version of a good song. this guy should make 80s coke adverts for a living... je's that gauche
BBBS 5 years ago
Resorting to foul language in a comment reflects the writer`s lack of intellect and poor education associated with a bad upbringing. I used to be a social worker.
bigrexlowlife 4 years ago
May I inquire as to why one so erudite as your good self is no longer a social worker? Perhaps the stereotypical presumptions you resort to and lack of familiarity with informal discourse were indicative of one fundamentally unable to be objective in such an environment?
BBBS 4 years ago 5
Now, isnt that much better . You have to understand that not everyone who is on youtube is over 18 .
bigrexlowlife 4 years ago
The only feasible explanation here is that you're some sort of profound troll.
Adieu, sir. And Godspeed.
BBBS 4 years ago
When on earth did this come out? The royalties off of this song must be how Justin Currie earns his living...heh heh
circusguy 5 years ago