The Bribe Mentality: Neglecting and Derailing Intrinsic Motivation

[1point7g]

Excellent video! 

[beauxq]

This video touches on this a little bit, but here is another resource on this topic.

watch?v=u6XAPnuFjJc

I was also looking for another one that talks about the box of tacks and candle. But I can't find it. Does anyone know where that video is?

[michal90ns]

@saydaysago2008 I've reuploaded that movie, now i just have to wait couple days for Machine Transcriptions, so i have time codes, then i'll translate it to polish and i got captions. I'm just letting you know, hope you don't mind. In the end it's all about sharing knowledge, right?

[saydaysago2008]

@michal90ns yes, definitely! if you get a decent captions file created, would you mind sending it to me so that I can add it to this upload as well? PM me when / if this is possible. :D

[jusrag]

I love this 8:25 - 9:12

[iParadoxVII]

awolnation -- sail

xD

[Syburi]

Thank you so much for this video and summarising the research. Very much appreciated.

[RifetOkic]

Joyfull participation/Joyfull effort

[live2skate4]

Yeah Aaron! I heard you speak alongside Matt Berkowitz and others for TZM's radio show two weeks ago. Great speech then and this video is awesome as well! Keep it up! I'm going to show this video to my dad who keeps saying that in a resource based economy, there will be no motivation. But it's okay, he's pretty damn close to being a ZM advocate. This video is the perfect response..

[TheDarkFenix]

Awesome, i've learned something on how to educate my children, when (if) i ever have them.

[KaleRay93]

Ahhh! I fucking love AWOLNATION. :)

The Infinite Yes, you often have amazing content.

[InvertedFox]

You have bettered yourself dude. Fantastic video.

[MrIzzyDizzy]

figured it out is it aaron moritz of the tzm global radio sometimes?

at least on this episode last week? watch?v=dFhYX_jyrvM

[saydaysago2008]

@MrIzzyDizzy yep that's me. :)

[MrIzzyDizzy]

@saydaysago2008 you do a great job :)

[terasus4]

Beautiful!!!!!!! thank you

[Joker9588]

Congratulations for your job with the video, excellent educational material presented in a very appealing fashion.

Loved the music right at the beginning, what's its name?

[saydaysago2008]

@Joker9588 thanks!

the song is called 'the ghost inside' by broken bells. all the songs are listed in the info box.

[abcdjames]

Great Video!

[NewDayDawning2012]

Liked it. Thank you for sharing. Namaste.

[UniversalAngel13]

Random acts of Kindness & senseless beauty .... a daily quest which brings inner JOY

[efortune357]

Bravo!  I love Alfie Kohn

[MrIzzyDizzy]

really like this video thanks - it seems like i have heard your voice before - have you narrated or been on other videos other than this name?

[saydaysago2008]

@MrIzzyDizzy there are a bunch of similarly produced videos to this one on my channel. if any you might know capitalism: epic fail or, believe nothing but understand as much as you can. also i have a vlog channel yt username theinfinityes

[MrIzzyDizzy]

@saydaysago2008 yes i have seem those mirrored though - some by strawprophet - you also sound a little like a historian in another doc

[AnimusSolis]

@saydaysago2008 Amazing video, but for the sake of constructive criticism, can you maybe speak with a little more enthusiasm? It would make the video that much better.

[ivanlezhnjovjr]

Good one. Thanks!

[teewilson333]

Perfect video! 10/10

[icebergbart216]

Seems like adopting children would be the pinnacle of this idea.

Too bad most Americans don't even consider it. 

[saydaysago2008]

@icebergbart216 heh.. you lost me my friend. i mean, i think adopting children is a wonderful thing, but what does it have to do with a society not using extrinsic rewards like money and excessive praise?

[icebergbart216]

@saydaysago2008

6:30 Doing things to enhance people's lives. Nothing is more fullfilling that contributing to people's well being.

[saydaysago2008]

@icebergbart216 ah. :)

there i was so focused on what this video is against, I didn't think to put your comment in the context of what it supports. thanks for the head-shake. :)

[EagleSmeagol]

Great video :) I just hope it also gets seen by the people who aren't already in the movement, that'd be gr8

[tymoe16]

Very cool video man

[72wh27]

I luv the way they used the instrumental from AWOLNATION's song, "Sail" in the background...

[TheLoetter]

Thanks so much for your video and hence for your contribution

[xRA1D32x]

awesome job, Broken Bells is the shit! The shins are probably my favorite band!

[73quantum]

Fantastic, well done!!! :)

[jesusoro707]

0:20 What is the thing Called?

[saydaysago2008]

@jesusoro707 sorry, are you referring to the little money printer thing? it's just a video i found of someone making a fake bill.

[kaurinaj]

yeah! that's exactly what i was thinking too! what would the world be like if everyone did their heart;s passion?

[TronixGuy93]

What is it with keepvid and this particular video? It just WONT display links.

[saydaysago2008]

@TronixGuy93 hmm. not sure what the problem is. let me know if you work it out. if not i'll put the mp4 on megaupload for you.

[TronixGuy93]

@saydaysago2008 I'd greatly appreciate it. I couldn't even get keepvid to work on another pc & browser for that video, you?

[saydaysago2008]

@TronixGuy93 nope.. strange..

anyway.. megaupload ({dot)) com /?d=4UT01UKY

should work for ya

[TronixGuy93]

@saydaysago2008 "The file you are trying to access is temporarily unavailable. Please try again later." :(

[saydaysago2008]

@TronixGuy93 try again.. it works for me. 

[TronixGuy93]

@saydaysago2008 Worked today, YAY :) Thank You :)

[TronixGuy93]

@TronixGuy93 I guess keepvid just has a problem with this one video. I haven't ran across this before with keep vid. Anyone else having the same problem with keep vid.

[EagleSmeagol]

@TronixGuy93 not sure about keepvid, but I use opera plugin "download-youtube-videos-as-mp­4", it's ridiculusly easy to use, never failed me, and works on this video as well :)

[TronixGuy93]

@EagleSmeagol Not sure why either, however I just tried it again today and it seems to be working. I know it wasn't working 2 days ago because I've been trying to archive it as mp4 through keepvid since then just to submit a bug report to keepvid so they can fix the issue. It's great that it has started working, but were still trying to figure out why it wasn't.

[paronsoda]

Great video saydaysago2008. You put it together very nicely.

[deniceinspain]

1:30 peter grifin + adam west :)

[Farf420]

zietgeist and the venus project are giant loads of shit.

[ah1rooivalk]

Fuck Bra! I love your Video... Your Research is done so Well :) Love From Zeitgeist Movement South Africa

[Keessince1988]

Superb job!!

[Nosferatu9981]

Subscribed.

[ShaktiLila]

Magician

[TheAwakenedHeretic]

Aaron Moritz is one excellent god damn creator of online media.

[DeistReality]

Great video that will do much good towards a RBE;)

[Jumvlbunny]

No sound?

[blakerobbins1111]

very well done.. awesome

[TinyBlueCage]

Knowledge..... Like a BOSS

[stefankengen]

Well done! Shared!

[futurethoughts2015]

so important!

[SanPedro0000]

Good intentions just based on bla-bla-bla (i.e. BS)

Please READ!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Cameron, Banko & Pierce (2001). Pervasive Negative Effects of Rewards on Intrinsic Motivation:

The Myth Continues. The Behavior Analyst. 24, 1-44.

[trombilly]

@SanPedro0000 specifically in education though, the reward system is most effective in training a child in the ways of society-with it's whole direction, so once a child has accepted this reality and their place in the heirarchical stat's(dependent on suceptability to the training) of their enviroment you have a self perpetuating workforce. something we certainly dont need to sustain any more. weve enough to be getting along with without compromising any integrity we might be pretending to have

[SanPedro0000]

@trombilly What are you talking about???????????? Where is the evidence of that? The Zeitgeist Movement is based on science rather than talk, rumors and gossip. That is the cornerstone of change and this video is not.

[trombilly]

@SanPedro0000 I think we may be at crossed purposes. when you say where is the evidence of that? what bit are you refering to? I didn't mention the zeitgeist movement (tho I am an activist) I was simply (after a couple of pints) stateing how it seems to be, not how I think it should be, reading it back I think I had a little sarcasm creeping in there, have you watched the RSA 'changing education paradigms' film? recommended, please, I'd like to answer your question but you must be specific :-)

[dpclayburn]

I'm glad you don't get paid your vids:) Excellent work.

[GodEquals3]

The possibility we can´t refuse.

[TheFifthGreatApe]

Bad ass.

[CrazyAl1991]

love this video

[EducatorHQ]

where did you get that Marshall section from?!

[saydaysago2008]

@EducatorHQ

watch?v=L8fbxPAXBPE

[EducatorHQ]

@saydaysago2008 seemed to have missed this! Thanks man. Looking forward to the next video =) keep goin

[BooDamphir3]

brilliant insight!

[KillerWhaleSFl]

where is the double like button?

[meesterJos]

Damn, Aaron, you did it again!! Well done!

[GBDelektro]

61 People are retarded utopians



[CingerNebojsa]

@GBDelektro 1 person doesn't get it.

[GodEquals3]

@GBDelektro I like to see people that can only point one negative aspect "it´s to good to be/become true"

It´s as possible as we can imagine.

[trombilly]

@GodEquals3 if you can imagine it ...... then it is posible. if you live eminating it, its posibility becomes reality

[hypernation2007]

This was so awesome.

[TajuntoCapoeira]

awesome :) thank you

[CingerNebojsa]

Great video! I'll wait for youtube to update the share thumbnail and will share it!

[StevieGfromNL]

Great vid bud! We need more ppl like you, as soon as the ppl of Occupy realize its the whole system thats flaw everyone can come together and think of a new way of living thats sustainable for everyone!

[d0Nmademedoit]

Thumbs up for using Broken Bells audio and Vampire Weekend video, and also supporting TZM of course :)

[CitizenPlague]

Good video but how do you figure donations will diminish your -intrinsic- motivation?

[MrEmpathicus]

Worth the wait. Thank you!

[TLdAnon]

Another amazing video, man. Thank you.

[SterlingForreal]

In order to more easily manage supply & demand fundamentals of resources from around the world I'm assuming there would be a unit of account. If a resource like gold was used as a unit of account would it not be a resource based economy??

Thanks for sharing.

[saydaysago2008]

@SterlingForreal supply and demand would be measured directly and production adjusted accordingly. no need for any third party 'unit of account'. everything would be taken into account directly, from technological capabilities to energy requirements, to consumer demand, etc, etc, in order to optimize each. :)

[GBDelektro]

@saydaysago2008 If gold was used as a unit of account then it's not just a monetary system... it's a bad monetary system like the one ealy civilizations were using. In a real RBE gold would be used as a resourse(it's a great metal that is good for many things)

[TronixGuy93]

@SterlingForreal no.

[h3rEtiKos]

Bribe?In Greece?!NOOOOOOO?!?!?!!!!

[mannecri]

Great video! =)

[Inverted87]

Wow this is awesome, I knew that this had something to do with Alfie Kohn which I suggest if you ever have a chance to see him speak you do it he speaks with so much passion the room energizes.

[saydaysago2008]

@TheSnoop105 have you subscribed to mine as well? :P

[toughlightyear]

if videos like this go viral like cat videos, it wudnt take much time to convert this world into paradise

[serenade251]

This video is just what I needed to watch at this moment.

[SaM52461]

@serenade251

sorry but there's no way this is better than "cat flushing a toilet"

but I see the point you're trying to make

[Deviliumrei]

@serenade251 I totally feel the same way,

[LiberationSauce]

first comment!