I agree with all the comments commending your genius. I love the fact that you preserve Judy & Liza's integrity while managing to make it tearfully funny. Keep 'em coming!
@littleurchin28 So true. Funny, but clearly coming from a place of much love and admiration. Humanity, failings, talent and all, make both Judy and Liza the beloved legends they are.
Ok I think I've watched this about 50 times now and every time it is funnier. This is possibly my all time favourite youtube video of any genre.. I think people are getting tired of me walking around saying "mama who that is?" for no reason :p I'm going to see Liza in a few weeks and I think I might ask her to sing this for me. Liza who that is?
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I'm not sure I get the joke, or I'm reading things into it, and only the PunchyPlayers would know for sure, but is the tres gay framed picture of Vincente Minnelli the visual punchline... the irony of him being a daddy... as if gay men don't reproduce? I liked the video very much, but again, I'm not sure of the intent.
@defundthewar There is really no hidden message here. It is a parody of the pop song called "My Baby Daddy". We just thought it would be humorous to hear Judy & Liza sing it. It is not intended as a comment on Mr. Minnelli.
@defundthewar HUH? a subtext about the reproductive habits of gay men in the 1940s??? now just relax on this couch and tell me...do you see that hidden meaning in a lot of things? it's just silly camp fun. ...if you focus on anything more than the totally brilliant vocal talent and the fantastic graphics...you are missing the point.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
@tyjeffries Are you aware how often one can see on the blogosphere very simple crap posing as hip expressions like take your meds, did you switch to generic, tell your shrink, switch to decaf, etc.? You are bland, a follower... and likely often get riled when exposed to diverse viewpoints. Take a chill pill. Oh... I forgot... that's something you would parrot. That said... the fey picture of Minnelli with kitch frame, suddenly appearing at the end gave me vibes. Big deal. You'll live.
@marycarnival Well, of all the songs in the world that would be funny for this duo to perform... and of all the photographs available of Vincente Minnelli... and all
the picture frames that could be utilized... can one blame me? No, don't answer that. I am a horrible, horrible person for thinking that. For thinking, period.
@drujon Don't expect your cute expression to catch on in a big way, like "tell it to the hand" or "two fries short of a happy meal." You are bland. And didn't I already apologize for doing something horrible... thinking?
@drujon Phony wars and oil prices make me mad. A site about Judy, Liza & Cream of Wheat cannot. But if you are sufficiently bland, well, of course I will seem like an axe murderer to you. I've said this before-- as hip and on the ball as Judy was, her fans generally are not exactly a barrel of laughs.
@drujon Took you a week to come up with that? Unless you are under 12 years old, there is absolutely no excuse for your mindset and the things you write, cute itty-bitty punctuation drawings and all.
These gems have truly made me smile and smile and smile. Thank you so much for sharing with us. I love the creativity, the humor and the attention to vocal details. I pretty much have to watch at least once a day!
@wandawisdom Well, we have several things already recorded, and when they are animated, they will be posted. Some of the cast will return, naturally, along with some new faces.
@normadesmond Thanks. It's Mr. I"m Jeff, the one who does the voices, while Chris handles the visual end. We both cannot thank you enough for your enthusiasm. More to come, rest assured.
BRAVO! (Brava?) Once again, I BEG you to consider doing this professionally. The first step would be sending DVDs or YouTube links to ad agencies. It's definitely worth a shot!
Brilliant again! Judy's last line just had me rolling on the floor! More please! (I now eat cream of wheat every morning thanks to "Judy's Cream Of Wheat". She sold me on the stuff! )
As my aunt Carole says "you are too smart for the room". I think that means you have an innate sense of "camp" and the talent to display it. These videos have such a "knowing" quality. Does that even make sense? You are smart and clever enough to recognize the identifiable/iconic qualities of those you parody while not seeking to literally imitate them; that is your genious. I guess, maybe, that is also the definition of "camp". In any case, I am so happy that I have found your videos.
As the voice guy for PunchyPlayers, i am overwhelmed by the kind thoughts and comments. As I have said in the past, these little "sillies" were originally recorded just to amuse ourselves....to leave an essence of these stars, rather than an exact duplication....and. If they give others pleasure, I am honored.
if you guys want me to, i can do a DEAD ON judy speaking and singing voice for your vids. yours is good... but i am telling you i can sound exactly like her.
OMG! you guys are epic!
ajluvsny 2 days ago
SWEET!...Love all of them.
freshair3451 2 days ago
UNBELIEVABLE!!!!
LOVESHOTLOVESHOT 1 week ago
F'ing love it.
Glenn1441 2 weeks ago
I love the "it's papa" part :P
poorlittlerichiegirl 1 month ago
Why not?
txquis 1 month ago
why?
MrSieish 2 months ago
OMG...LMBO!!!!!!!!!!!!
DaSourcespr06 2 months ago
LMFAO.
bpnc9092 3 months ago
what's a pimp master...? :D
heyheymister 4 months ago
OMIGOD OMIGOD OMIGOD funny
linorf 6 months ago
Amazinggg!! The Judy & Liza ones are def. my fav, you did such a good job (:
yutubecmnt 7 months ago
I agree with all the comments commending your genius. I love the fact that you preserve Judy & Liza's integrity while managing to make it tearfully funny. Keep 'em coming!
littleurchin28 9 months ago 8
@littleurchin28 So true. Funny, but clearly coming from a place of much love and admiration. Humanity, failings, talent and all, make both Judy and Liza the beloved legends they are.
Glenn1441 1 week ago
....what did i just watch?
akidiscool84 9 months ago
You guys are amazingly funny! Mama, who dat is? GENIUS!
nightmarecrazy08 9 months ago
are one of the voices I hear in your wonderful videos the same one as I hear as "Salmonetti" in the Varla Jean Merman commercial/video parady?
tampachicken 9 months ago
OK! You guys owe me a new MacBook! ;-P Because I pretty much fell over & died on it watching this! Hahahaha!
GENIUS!
LOVE it!
pookieSR71adams 9 months ago
I love this, please keep them coming!!!
semejanteael 9 months ago
TOO freaking funny! LOVE IT!
drewb52 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Love it love it love it! 'Liza, who that IS?!'----'It's Poppa!' *snort* You guys are the shizzle!
BionicBrat9 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Love it love it love it! 'Liza, who that IS?!'----'That's Poppa!' *snort* You guys are the shizzle!
BionicBrat9 11 months ago
Comment removed
BionicBrat9 11 months ago
lmao so funny ... I keep say that's just my baby daddy!!! lol hahaha lmao great keep making more
judygarlandxoxo 11 months ago
This is my absolute favorite......LOLOLOLOL brilliant.
dotbishop 11 months ago
Oh my gosh! I have been walking around saying "Mama, who dat is" since yesterday when I saw this! And then I giggle! I love this! More please!
imagiami 1 year ago
This video and all the others never get old. WOW. Great stuff. PLEASE keep them coming.
777tillery 1 year ago
this is kooky but awesome!
CATFISHratcoon 1 year ago
f'n funny
nocount1 1 year ago
O.O THE VOICES ARE DONE BY A MAN?!?!?! Whoa!!
RaWrZzZz 1 year ago
more please!!! you guys are amazing!!!
GinaMarie1982 1 year ago
OMG...i CAN NOT get enough of this. you guys are brilliant. MORE PLEASE!
Jasperburg 1 year ago
I hope rosie o'donnell has seen this.
wattever333 1 year ago 2
Love your stuff! Thank you...And to defundthewar...Vincente Minnelli was Liza's Dad. *rolls eyes*. Some people don't have a sense of humor!
bignorthsky 1 year ago
That was fantastic! Especially the last bit. Again, very very funny!
Caradog93 1 year ago
hahaha! this is great!
OldHollywoodLove 1 year ago
Dat is da bomb.
HermesAlchemist 1 year ago
The kids'll LOVIT
myhairiswaving 1 year ago
"Liza, who dat iz?" What singing, what dancing. The kidslloveit indeed!
BadQuarto 1 year ago 4
Ok I think I've watched this about 50 times now and every time it is funnier. This is possibly my all time favourite youtube video of any genre.. I think people are getting tired of me walking around saying "mama who that is?" for no reason :p I'm going to see Liza in a few weeks and I think I might ask her to sing this for me. Liza who that is?
tingaling124 1 year ago 24
@urouttaurLementdonni We miss you too, sweets!
txquis 1 year ago
I love it!!!! Not sure which my favourite is, this or cream of wheat but I think I laughed louder at this one :)
tingaling124 1 year ago
This delights me and my friends to no end. Perfection. We worship you, Punchy Players!
jmarchand 1 year ago 4
You guys are awesome. Keep up the great work!
quathenmathers 1 year ago
Best part is hearing a decent imitation of Judy Garland saying "Pimp Master."
jaredofmo 1 year ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I'm not sure I get the joke, or I'm reading things into it, and only the PunchyPlayers would know for sure, but is the tres gay framed picture of Vincente Minnelli the visual punchline... the irony of him being a daddy... as if gay men don't reproduce? I liked the video very much, but again, I'm not sure of the intent.
defundthewar 1 year ago
@defundthewar There is really no hidden message here. It is a parody of the pop song called "My Baby Daddy". We just thought it would be humorous to hear Judy & Liza sing it. It is not intended as a comment on Mr. Minnelli.
PunchyPlayers 1 year ago 26
@PunchyPlayers I got it...just for fun! More please?
MGMstar 1 year ago 4
@defundthewar HUH? a subtext about the reproductive habits of gay men in the 1940s??? now just relax on this couch and tell me...do you see that hidden meaning in a lot of things? it's just silly camp fun. ...if you focus on anything more than the totally brilliant vocal talent and the fantastic graphics...you are missing the point.
tyjeffries 1 year ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@tyjeffries Are you aware how often one can see on the blogosphere very simple crap posing as hip expressions like take your meds, did you switch to generic, tell your shrink, switch to decaf, etc.? You are bland, a follower... and likely often get riled when exposed to diverse viewpoints. Take a chill pill. Oh... I forgot... that's something you would parrot. That said... the fey picture of Minnelli with kitch frame, suddenly appearing at the end gave me vibes. Big deal. You'll live.
defundthewar 1 year ago
@defundthewar Yeah, you might be reading a bit more into it than necessary. Interesting point, though!
marycarnival 1 year ago
@marycarnival Well, of all the songs in the world that would be funny for this duo to perform... and of all the photographs available of Vincente Minnelli... and all
the picture frames that could be utilized... can one blame me? No, don't answer that. I am a horrible, horrible person for thinking that. For thinking, period.
defundthewar 1 year ago
@defundthewar Somebody needs to lay of the literal juice!
drujon 1 year ago
@drujon Don't expect your cute expression to catch on in a big way, like "tell it to the hand" or "two fries short of a happy meal." You are bland. And didn't I already apologize for doing something horrible... thinking?
defundthewar 1 year ago
@defundthewar It's funny because you get mad.
drujon 1 year ago
@drujon Phony wars and oil prices make me mad. A site about Judy, Liza & Cream of Wheat cannot. But if you are sufficiently bland, well, of course I will seem like an axe murderer to you. I've said this before-- as hip and on the ball as Judy was, her fans generally are not exactly a barrel of laughs.
defundthewar 1 year ago
@defundthewar I bet you smell funny. That's why you don't get enough hugs. I'm sorry :-(
drujon 11 months ago
@drujon Took you a week to come up with that? Unless you are under 12 years old, there is absolutely no excuse for your mindset and the things you write, cute itty-bitty punctuation drawings and all.
defundthewar 11 months ago
*Tom slides out of his computer chair in laughter*
thefabulousthomasj 1 year ago 2
Thanks. Thanks. Thanks.
The Punchy Players Forever!
bullbubb 1 year ago
has to thank Alex for this little beauty!
CParkerLPN 1 year ago
I've been wathing this every day for over a week--I'm addicted!
blueskyfox99 1 year ago 3
I used to think it would be a hoot to be a fly on the wall during Thanksgiving with the Sadaris family, but you've edged them out!
bearhedded 1 year ago 2
I just had the worst day at work. I knew the cure would be watching Judy and Liza again. You guys could be my baby daddy anytime!
hnc52 1 year ago 2
As Liza would say, "That was just TERRIFIC"!
TruthSerum101 1 year ago
you've done it again..!!! such detail..!! i am humbled and amazed.
leofilm 1 year ago
That picture of Vincente Minnelli gets me every time!
fossefan 1 year ago
Can't. Stop. Watching. Over and over!!!!! LOL
leestickler 1 year ago
So marvellous.
RealPete 1 year ago
These gems have truly made me smile and smile and smile. Thank you so much for sharing with us. I love the creativity, the humor and the attention to vocal details. I pretty much have to watch at least once a day!
Janimal1000 1 year ago 4
This made my day! More Judy&Liza vids!
hearthur 1 year ago
0:38...
gets me EVERY TIME! I love this!!
telephelion 1 year ago
Oh please don't ever stop making these Judy & Liza videos...ever!!! I just love them - thanks!!!
copacabana1971 1 year ago 2
Punchy Players, you are awesome!! Please post lots more videos!!
LitesofBway 1 year ago
Love It !! And everytime I view it & 'Judy' asks " What's a pimp-master ?",
I just Explode with Laughter !!!!! Great Job !!
CManArt1 1 year ago 5
another laugh riot, darlings! next, how about lucy and judy doing a 'telephone' parody?
wandawisdom 1 year ago
@wandawisdom Well, we have several things already recorded, and when they are animated, they will be posted. Some of the cast will return, naturally, along with some new faces.
txquis 1 year ago
So goofy, so great! Keep it up.
laughhaha326 1 year ago
You are too much! Thanks for this masterpiece!
turandot82 1 year ago
@normadesmond Thanks. It's Mr. I"m Jeff, the one who does the voices, while Chris handles the visual end. We both cannot thank you enough for your enthusiasm. More to come, rest assured.
txquis 1 year ago
MORE! MORE!
lenahorneclub 1 year ago 3
BRAVO! (Brava?) Once again, I BEG you to consider doing this professionally. The first step would be sending DVDs or YouTube links to ad agencies. It's definitely worth a shot!
makamson1 1 year ago
Brilliant again! Judy's last line just had me rolling on the floor! More please! (I now eat cream of wheat every morning thanks to "Judy's Cream Of Wheat". She sold me on the stuff! )
MGMstar 1 year ago
Excellent followup....the characterizations are AWESOME
berliozophile 1 year ago
Who are you guys?? These videos make me so happy!!! A quick follow up PLEASE!!
secreteyeable 1 year ago
Another classic! Who that IS? Just like it ...... oh it IS! It's cream of WHEAT!
ronnykmarshall 1 year ago
You are the BEST!!! Do more! MORE!!!
lcm29 1 year ago
More fabulousness...You are so clever. WHAT A HOOT!!! Brilliant x
tyjeffries 1 year ago
As my aunt Carole says "you are too smart for the room". I think that means you have an innate sense of "camp" and the talent to display it. These videos have such a "knowing" quality. Does that even make sense? You are smart and clever enough to recognize the identifiable/iconic qualities of those you parody while not seeking to literally imitate them; that is your genious. I guess, maybe, that is also the definition of "camp". In any case, I am so happy that I have found your videos.
amcoca 1 year ago 26
I can't stop watching!
Ludsy2001 1 year ago 3
Brilliant work once again - ROFL....
JAF528 1 year ago
I am peeing myself!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Robbo1159 1 year ago
oh my god!! this is SO FUNNY!!
SOPHI3333333333333 1 year ago
pimp master.
mmb1998 1 year ago 4
Love it! You guys are great.
lizafan01 1 year ago
I love you.
kyleyng 1 year ago
As the voice guy for PunchyPlayers, i am overwhelmed by the kind thoughts and comments. As I have said in the past, these little "sillies" were originally recorded just to amuse ourselves....to leave an essence of these stars, rather than an exact duplication....and. If they give others pleasure, I am honored.
txquis 1 year ago 24
if you guys want me to, i can do a DEAD ON judy speaking and singing voice for your vids. yours is good... but i am telling you i can sound exactly like her.
yellow85 1 year ago
I was hoping for a fantastic followup to the Cream Of Wheat and you've done it. I just wish it was longer. XD
teapotwashere 1 year ago
Get down with your bad selves!
BenPanced 1 year ago
oh my goooooooooodddd
superhetoric 1 year ago
Love it! Thanks, Buzz Stephens just turned me on to you, so thanks to all.
DrAuntSissy 1 year ago
I just died. Yet again. Two BIG thumbs up for our favorite Players - best part by far at the end. XD
Great job!!
romantic2543 1 year ago 14
Thanks so much! : ) We're really glad that you enjoyed it.
Much thanks to everyone for all your comments.
PunchyPlayers 1 year ago 5
@PunchyPlayers Very clever and sooo funny! Please do more!
jimblackwood 1 year ago
Been waiting for this next installment !! As Judy would say.... "b-b-brilliant" !!!!!
FLBoy46 1 year ago
Excellent work. Bravo! Hurrah for another video!
teabeaux 1 year ago
Why are you so great
Mernerwastaken 1 year ago
Inspired insanity.
BuzzStephens1 1 year ago
GOLD!
MrTimothyBehr 1 year ago
Haha, is that liza's and Judy's real voice??!!
MsJeffersonAirplane 1 year ago
OMG... This is soooooooooooooooooooooooooooo good. You guys are the best.
nandesneto 1 year ago
Just what I need in my life
princessjoots 1 year ago
Great guys. And it's so likely too.
kevshrop 1 year ago
LOL
kjone22 1 year ago