@kaitamasaki That's true. I like both Tokunaga and Jacky very much. They are both great. Tokunaga is stronger in writing songs and Jacky is stronger in singing.
That is true.....2 different sad stories for 2 different songs....but one song melody...2 different men told their stories.....2 different styles....no compare
I really love this song. Hideaki Tokunaga , he is the best singer with his love song , it makes me feel that i have to be strong, to forget all the bad thing , and easily to live with lonliness with his song. In my life there is only my love for the music. and his song has big place in my heart. Thank you for your love music, to singing for all ...
Oh this MTV was shown in a music programme named 翡翠音樂幹線 on TVB Jade (a Hong Kong TV station). They always have Chinese subtitles for Japanese songs. I just wonder if anyone could upload a better quality version of the MTV on YouTube. I like the song as much as the colour shown in the MTV.
i like this song both japanese or mandarin/cantonese version. but japanese version was the original one. it's tokunaga hideaki, who was the first singer make this song so popular. and then jacky cheung sang it in mandarin & cantonese version. but both of them was so great. two thumbs up
both versions are good. i like jacky's version better and i agree with "loveoverated".
k0pyme 1 year ago
佢後生時很英俊....................
mercigl 1 year ago
@mercigl 有冇相- -?
arenadvd 1 year ago
UPありがとうございます♪
kirakira1950 1 year ago
tokunaga hideaki is a original singer and composer of this song.
springstar17 1 year ago
いい曲は何回きいても心の奥深くに波紋のように広がって癖になる。徳永さんの楽曲は そんな思いをさせる 何かがある 魔法にかかる 本当です
toku1115 1 year ago 2
He is so beautiful in this video!!!
lalaparfait 1 year ago 2
好年輕..好英俊
ngsungling 2 years ago 2
ah shit, youtube took away dbsk's version. gahh
staiinedbyu 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
咩叫la li bu -.-
aesop82245 2 years ago
日本人比較難分R & L....新一代歌手較有改進..不過唱la也不會怎樣..反而蠻耐聽的
徳永唱的好聽就好!
wwebrockf5 2 years ago 3
i like his voice
hulia27 2 years ago 4
why compare?
both are marvellous!
dominicshe 2 years ago 2
i agree, they both are absolutely amazing at singing
jeffwan 2 years ago
i think jacky's voice has much more texture and 層次感.
loveoverated 2 years ago
there is no point to compare.
tokunaga has a different, more tenor voice. this version is also a key higher than jacky's.
kaitamasaki 2 years ago 17
@kaitamasaki ...agree..different singers express differently ...just need to open our hearts and enjoy both of them ^^
offshorescorpion 1 year ago
@kaitamasaki That's true. I like both Tokunaga and Jacky very much. They are both great. Tokunaga is stronger in writing songs and Jacky is stronger in singing.
yzhang2008 1 year ago
良い曲ですね
心に沁みてきます。本当に
ytkm5380 2 years ago 6
there's no way jacky is better than tokunaga....tokunaga is a superb talent compared to jacky
engkokhean 2 years ago 3
That is true.....2 different sad stories for 2 different songs....but one song melody...2 different men told their stories.....2 different styles....no compare
johnyick 2 years ago 3
I like both of them. They're both superb talented. No need to compare.
yzhang2008 2 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
the chinese version sang by Jacky Cheung is way better.
Deekkkzz 2 years ago
今 聞いてもヤッパリいいですネ! 最初に聞いたときはテープが擦り切れるくらい聞いた覚えがあります。古い話でごめんなさい。
jaguar0539 2 years ago 3
very talented
greenb1a 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
chinese song is always funny :) lol
umjs78 2 years ago
It's japanese brother.
starex5555 2 years ago 2
like your mom?
key05qui 2 years ago
今日初めて聴きました。もう最高で何回でも聴きたい名曲入りです!!心にしみるってこのことですね。
AYAKOEMMA 2 years ago 6
素敵です。
48488337 2 years ago 4
I can't help coming back to YOUTUBE to listen to this song again and again in the last 2 days. There is magic power in this song!
zhanginca 2 years ago 5
I agree with you.
This song has a magic power!!
epiker00 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
The guy has gay voice.
Civsuccess2 2 years ago
Wonderful !!!!! Classical song ~~~~ I love this oringinal version although there is another 1997 version re-arranged~~~
pianowxy 3 years ago
i think i love the version of Jacky Cheung more
Newcastlefans 2 years ago
I think the guy who sing AND wrote this song deserve a lot more credit. So this version win just for being original.
youngien 2 years ago 7
94年第一次听学友唱的这歌,太好听了。95年买的一盘磁带,有德永的原唱,还有安全地带的月半弯原唱,好多好多,太怀念了
quakercn 3 years ago 7
very nice
sugizo86 3 years ago 3
I really love this song. Hideaki Tokunaga , he is the best singer with his love song , it makes me feel that i have to be strong, to forget all the bad thing , and easily to live with lonliness with his song. In my life there is only my love for the music. and his song has big place in my heart. Thank you for your love music, to singing for all ...
coffee1983vn 3 years ago 4
德永年輕的時候好帥喔!
crazytrf 3 years ago 4
he is a real good japaneses singer-son writer. he is still composing good songs in japan.
alexisyu 3 years ago
perfect single and sexy! men check my page
genociding 3 years ago
thats my favorite song... the very first song ive learned when i went to japan
yuriyabut 3 years ago
it's sound so good....
Kyuu17 3 years ago 4
私も、徳永さんの曲が一番彼に合ってて大好きです。
カバー曲には正直な所興味なしです。彼の何処か履かない歌声は彼の詩と一番相性がいいと思います。
オリジナルでどうか頑張って欲しいですね。
hajihaji2 3 years ago 4
This is awesome. This song is getting to my heart, and I cannot help but cry.
Again, he is touching the heart of me.
明明就超好聴的~~
何回聴いても泣いてしまいます。あの頃に戻れるものなら戻りたい。
RandomAssociation 3 years ago 3
love this song and tokunaga`s voice
rainjogeva 3 years ago
作曲にとても独特の才能を感じます。見た目がよすぎるのでしょうか、あえて無理して歌う姿を演じなくても、自作曲を歌っていたほうが、Onne&Onlyな魅力が光るのではないでしょうか?レイドバックや歌唱米語をマスターすれば、ジャズやロックのフィールで通用する歌曲がかけると思います。幾らハンサムでももう中年男、そろそろ大人が聴く音楽を歌って欲しい。がんばれ!!
GRETCHFUN 3 years ago 2
He sing like telling a sad story very romatic and touching
jollychippy 3 years ago 4
Who did this Chinese caption translation? Fantastic!
This is the original and the best ever. Jacky Cheung's version is no comparison.
tituschiu 3 years ago
Oh this MTV was shown in a music programme named 翡翠音樂幹線 on TVB Jade (a Hong Kong TV station). They always have Chinese subtitles for Japanese songs. I just wonder if anyone could upload a better quality version of the MTV on YouTube. I like the song as much as the colour shown in the MTV.
zzzlionzzz 3 years ago
that's bs jacky's the best male asian singer
you don't have to like his version more but do't say it's no comparison
imlmf 3 years ago
I think that we need not compare the two. I like both, actually.
seriusA 3 years ago 3
i like this song both japanese or mandarin/cantonese version. but japanese version was the original one. it's tokunaga hideaki, who was the first singer make this song so popular. and then jacky cheung sang it in mandarin & cantonese version. but both of them was so great. two thumbs up
daeokmyung 3 years ago 2
such a heartful song..! Wonderful, indeed!
g0ya9217 3 years ago 3
私は、rainy blue 1999 の方がオリジナルよりも好きです。thanks!
minmin3967 4 years ago 4
Jacky Cheung's 藍雨 is originated from this song.
scotguan 4 years ago 17
great song~
he got very good looking
153sinker 4 years ago 8
good!
mikann123kiss 4 years ago
This is not the original PV for this song, but it's still a great video clip. I love this song!
Takaji87 4 years ago
beatiful.
xuhenryca 5 years ago 2
i love this song
jols1967 5 years ago 2
He's one of my favourite Japanese artists in late 80's/90's. Anyway, I still love his songs now.
bebewakaba 5 years ago 2
Rainy Blue, is very great song !!
jackybong 5 years ago 2
very nice...
funnyfrog212 5 years ago
I love this oldie, but the voice seems sharper in video
siewyao 5 years ago