Caucasian or not, science shouldn't be fettered. Europeans, africans, polynesians, phoenicians, etc may have been coming here for millenia. This was found on federal land, so that is that, let the tribe sue the government. Truth shouldn't be silienced.
The "Native Americans" need to get over the fact that there were other people besides them that inhabited the Americans before they got here. They have not been here since the beginning of time, so they need to get over it.
@John95959 Of course, but I bet the "native" americans treated these people way more peaceful than the european settlers treated the native americans.
People from southern france called Solutreans had an ice bridge between france and america and there have been found several artifacts from these people and when the ice age melted a land bridge between the east and alaska was formed letting native americans in america. There have been a documentary about it and it have been uploaded to youtube. just search for it.
if the body is not native american ,,,,white-ish,,,is more like it ..then the tribe should have no say in what happens to it i would like to know were it realy came from ...
they have pretty much concluded already that this was a cauciside skull like Kenswick...This makes me angry...I am of Native descent and I don't know one Native who doesn't want these bones studied and who is to spiritual to want to learn about thier own anscestory and wants them burried...bunch of idiots taking them and burying them before anyone can study them...what's up with that...think maby someone has an agenda!
@raptor1madmetal I don't agree I am metis and so obviously I have a few native friends and I can't think of one of us who don't want these bones studied when they pull them up...I am sure God is not going to think we are bad ass because we studied the bones of our great, great , great ,great ,great ,great ,great,great,great,great....anscestors,lol!
IMO it looks Nunamiut if you look at the reconstruction, the inland version of Iñupiat or eskimos. They say the America's were inhabited from people coming over the land bridge of Alaska.
@bonsai108 I don't believe it...there is to much evidence to the contrary...for one why are there only two languages in them parts if the people migrated out and 400 in the rest of North America and 700 in South and Central America...there were caucasion genes mongoloid genes in the populations as well...that tells me that all native americans arrived in different parts of the world and were actually different people groups...
Incorrect. Certain Altaic groups do show a frequency for haplogroup X. The suggestion is that Altaic X may be an intermediary between European and American Indian X groups. Since the ancestral population initially came from the Middle East and branched, it would make sense that this haplogroup would split in two ways. No "white" or "Caucasian" people living in the Americas occurred to explain the presence of X among Natives.
@NopeJPeg I am not sure what you mean by that last sentence no white or caucasion people living in Americas occured to explain the presence of x among natives?
The Paiutes express concern over desecration of the dead for research. Funny they and other paleolithic Americans never gave desecration of the living a second thought.
Perhaps they just can't take the idea they are not the "first Americans" after all. Whatever they think, they are like the tail wagging the dog here.
Besides, this guy's spirit has had a nice long rest, he can get up for a minute while they study, him, then, its back to the old freezerino...:--)
"F***ing theives!! Let the sceintists study. What are you f***ckers afraid of?"
I am not afraid of the truth, if that's what you're asking. For your information, genetic testing has already been conducted on several Paleoamericans, including Kennewick Man. So far, they've all had American Indian haplogroups. "To date, mtDNA has been successfully extracted from about a dozen Paleoamericans from N. America. All belong to haplogroup B, C, or D." (Dr. James C. Chatters).
The haplogroup X that is on the wikipedia page may not be right. Last I had heard before seeing that was that no DNA had been usable on Kennewick Man. I figured I had missed the news. After I posted, I went and dug around and cannot find any link that shows they have come out with a sure result on his DNA. If you have a link, pease post it for me. I want to know the truth too.
They tested Kennewick man's DNA back in 2005, however, the results were inconclusive. Kennewick Man has simply been exposed for too long to the elements.
Also, haplogroup X is not found in S. East Asia or among the Ainu people. Haplogroup X has been found, however, among the Altai people in Central Asia, whom are Mongoloid peoples. Researchers have found that the haplogroup X in the Altai is most similar to the X in Amerindians. Suggesting that Indians brought X into America.
@akichita87 I guess someone ought to go fix wikipedia, as it says that the tests came back as haplogroup X and attributed it to the Ainu. Goes to show that we can't trust wiki. I knew something didn't sound right so that's why I started looking for all of the news stories on him and couldn't find any proof of any DNA results. Did you see the Tarim Basin mummies in China they found that are older than any Chinese remains? As far as Kennewick, maybe we'll find out one day for sure.Thanks!
We can never be sure about Wiki, but if you have any questions as to their authenticity, usually they have a bibliography on the bottom of the page. I have heard about those mummies. They are older than the Mongoloid (modern Chinese) peoples. We shouldn't be too quick to jump to conclusions though, because the Mongoloid morphology is a relatively late physical trait. Mongoloid peoples didn't fall from the sky, they are probably the modern descendants of these people.
For furthur clarification, I include a quote from Dr. Chris Stringer, the head of the human origins at the Natural History Museum in London. " I don't find the Solutrean Connection claims to be convincing, for a start, most humans in the world at that time were long headed." Also, the quote I mentioned earlier by Dr. James C. Chatters states that the only haplogroups found in Paleoamericans thus far have been B, C and D, which are Native American.
@akichita87 Well, most all of them have their own opinion, but all of the lectures from scientists and archaeologists that I've heard makes the Solutrean claims very convincing. We are being lied to about a lot of things. You should read Michael Cremo's 'Forbidden Archaeology' and you will see many things you have never heard before or have been lied to about. Check out the Starchild Skull too. Those DNA results are very interesting.
No offense, but the scientists and archeologists that support the Solutrean claims are few. They sound convincing because they have a tendency to leave out any contradictory claims that will refute their arguements. The DNA evidence just doesn't support such claims. Google the following "Mitochondrial DNA haplogroups of Paleoamericans in North America". The vast majority of geneticists support a single founding population of Native Americans.
@akichita87 Well there are enough of them in my opinion. Chatters is just one guy himself and his book was written quite awhile ago if I am remembering right. The Windover Florida Bog mummies are not American Indian and are of European DNA. The Tarim Basin mummies are of European DNA. Blonde mummies found in Peru. There was a book written in the 1800's by an American Indian woman who told of the tall red-haired people that were already here and they were killed off. Giant skeletons found as well
Since you are persistent on the topic, I'll give you a small list of archealogists that disagree with the Solutrean theory: James Chatters, Gentry Steele, Joseph Powell, Walter Neves, Ales Hrdlicka, Alan Goodman, Chris Stringer, Grover Krants, to name a few. The geneticists that disagree with the theory are even more numerous: David Glenn Smith, Frederika Keastle, Ripan Malhi, Jason Eshleman, Brian Kemp, Kivisild, Tamm E., Reidla, to name a few. I can give you journals to read
@akichita87 Most Archaeologists are part of the "system" and hide evidence or outright lie about it. They only put out the info they are allowed to by the establishment to serve certain political or financial interests. Look at Egypt. They've been lying about all of what really goes on there and squashing the truth. Look up the "Bagdad Battery". There are as many archaeologists now that agree with the Solutrean theory as you have shown disagree with it, so it comes down to who we each believe.
I am definitely interested in what you have to say, however, I doubt that all of the individuals I listed below would lie. Also, some of the anthropologists and geneticists metioned below are from South America, such as Walter Neves. I doubt that they all got together and decided to hoax the whole thing in favor of Native Americans. Also, many of them, if they wanted to lie, they would have a greater motive to lie in favor of the Solutrean theory, to bypass NAGPRA.
I suggest the following readings: "Mitochondrial DNA Haplogroups of Paleoamericans in North America"(2005), "Mitochondrial Population Genomics Support a Single Pre-Clovis Origin with a Coastal Route for the peopling of the Americas" (2007), "Beringian Standstill and spread of Native American founders" (2007). These reading stipulate that haplogroup X2b found in Native Americans is related to the Mongoloid peoples of the Altai in Central Asia.
@akichita87 Thank you for the list. I do agree that Amercan Indians and Mongoloid peoples in Central Asia are genetically linked. That doesn't mean Kennewick was American Indian, nor Mongoloid when we don't have DNA. He could be, but orbital shape looked Caucasoid. Maybe we'll never know for sure. The Windover Bog mummies are European. I hope you try and get that 'Forbidden Archaeology' book by Cremo. It will take you a long time to get through as it is quite something and thick as a brick.
In the journals I provided, the explaination for why Kennewick, and others like him, look different from modern Amerindians is due to natural phenomenon like genetic drift. And although they see craniomorphological differences between Paleoamericans and Indians, mtDNA remains unchanged. I don't trust the analysis of the Windover Bog due to the fact that it is an isolated incident, Dr. Joseph Lorenze himself mentioned a likely hood of accidental contamination by field workers.
I also wanted to say that I am sorry for being overly persistent myself. I don't want there to be any hurt feelings. This is obviously a subject we both feel strongly about.
@akichita87 this might be true however the haplogroup x factor is caucasion and it is not found in the central asia populations and it is prevelant in many North American Indian groups....the clovis origin is insignifigant in comparison to this...
@lucy9359 Haplogroup X is NOT a caucasian gene nor is it unique to caucasians.
You should know as well that mtDNA is only found in 4% of Europeans....and also 4% in Native Americans.
So claiming that X is a caucasian factor is wrong. Also Native Americans and Europeans share common ancestry in Central Asia and way back, in the Middle East where X originates. The common ancestor that gave out X cannot be uniquely Native American nor Caucasian.
As for the Starchild Skull. That is very interesting, but I am a skeptic at heart.
Believe me, I would be fascinated if the child was a alien/human hybrid, because there are stories in Native American lore about a human woman marrying a star being, and begetting a child, who grows up to be a savior. However, evidence points that the child was human. The child had both X and Y chromosomes, which only come from human mother and father. The child likely had hydrocephaly.
@akichita87 They just came out earlier in 2010 and the DNA has unidentifiable "alien" DNA. This was just a few months ago. Lloyd Pye had been trying to get DNA testing for awhile. It is here on YT where you can check it out. There were many differences between its skull and a humans as well, which was also different from hydrocephaly. That is interesting about the American Indian lore. There are definately star beings. Check out about ancient Sumerian tablets. Even had solar system engraved.
It's really an alien... I've seen da mummy at a secret facility in Oregon.... The government is coverin up da mummy portraying it as a human when it's really an alien the Indians worshipped at that time...
White Folks inhabited North America for thousands of years before the first non-white invader set foot here.
I know for a fact that when a certain event happened, which was 10,800 years ago, not a singe non-white had ever been to our White Homeland in North America.
I am a Native North American, those invading Asian savages are not!
@CelticSouthland LOL your argument had many problems with it....I can help you formlate another one to try to gain believers. But it won't make your argument any more closer to the truth
According to the Bureau of Land Management, Spirit Cave Man is not CULTURALLY related to any known tribe. However, Spirit Cave Man IS Native American, according to BLM.
@akichita87 Get off your ignorant primitive high horse, this is the remains of a people that Amerindians displaced. More closely related to the Ainu, similar to Kennnewick man. YOUR people exterminated his race and took his lands. The whiteman only took your lands and was more merciful to your sorry asses. Perhaps the white mans conquest of Native Amercians is the Great Spririts way of saying "Hey Pal - what goes around comes around !"
@richrajo Woah buddy. Take it easy. I was simply correcting the news anchor who incorrectly quoted the BLM (Bureau of Land Management). And another thing... you're a jack ass.
@akichita87 sorry pal, I clicked on the wrong "Reply" button and the wrong post, comments weren't directed at you. Regardless ... when dealing with antiquity this deep it appears that the Modern Native Amerindians are not neccesarily related to many of the ancient remains coming to light in recent years.... Have a nice day !
@richrajo All is forgiven. I, too, agree that there is a lot that we have to learn yet about these ancient people. I just got a little frustrated because I see that a lot of people have been using this evidence to justify injustices that occur in this modern era. For me, I believe that this evidence only proves that all races of people are really no different from one another.
i am a paiute shoshone indian and i am a member of the "fallon paiute shoshone tribe" in fallon,nevada which alvin moyle is the chairman of u am related to him also. i have nothing good to say about him and he shouldn't even be chairman because he has a criminal record.
Amy Dansie needst o go back to college, she is basing her finds of cacoziod strickly on cranium messurments which are unfounded. It is proven that cranium messurements change due to enviromental conditions. Therefore, to say that the remains are "white" based on its features is one sided to say the least!
White people really got around... I think the Indians oppose to DNA testing,because with each discovery of Caucasians being the first people here it weakens their special status...
The age of this mummy is the age of Kennewick Man. Any and all relationships should be studied. I am Native American, and believe some scientific study will further our people through education. Make sence...?
@WelderRDT this man was not native american he was cauciside...I am also of native anscestory and many native americans were actually carrying halogroup x genes which are cauciside genes....more than one earliest explorer said that there were white as well as bronze colour first nations tribes in the 1500's...the problem with these so called spirtual natives is they are stopping the scientists from going over these remains...as if the majority of us care...I am not spiritual in that respect...
...so there were people living here with caucasian traits -- so what -- Eskimos are more related to the people of coastal Russia and Greenland than Algonquin Indians -- the first Spanish explorers reported seeing light eyed and light skinned Indians in California -- Yes the Vikings reached north America and fought and lived with the Natives...but are these a white person's bones? Who cares - their on Indian land now -- And if they don't want you digging in their yard - stay out --
...I LOVE how NOBODY can even MENTION that the PIAUTES OWN HISTORYS....STATE...THEY..."KILLED OFF A RACE OF TALL RED HAIRED WHITE PEOPLE" In Ancient Times.
Somehow that odd little FACT NEVER even gets a MENTION
In FACT MOST MAJOR "Indian" Civilizations of the New World...OPENLY STATE...that "their" Civilization/Technology were FOUNDED/CREATED by "Tall White Skinned Bearded "Gods"
GENETIC RESEARCH has shown that the OLDEST "Indian" DNA LINE is actually the CAUCASIAN "X" Line
this guy is one of the biggest racists on youtube. look at his other posts he always yaps on about nonsense and loves to caps lock pointless BS. i get the feeling hes gonna shoot up something soon. all his posts are the exact same its amazing.
...Yet Another High IQ Post of Personal attacks and SCREAMS of "racism" by Lazrul.
I guess when YOUR faced with FACTS and SCIENTIFIC REALITY..and your totally unable to debate them...all thats left for YOU is silly 4th grade level personal attacks
The Only thing Im "shooting up" is YOUR BOGUS posting
WHY DO you TYPE like THIS? do you KNOW how ANNOYING it IS to READ! your the LAST person that should talk abou IQ. your a brain FRIED yokel. your just an INSECURE person who needs to be HEARD. you should JUST CAPS LOCK EVERYTHING if you NEED ATTENTION so BADLY.
why are you ALWAYS calling people a 3RD or 4TH GRADER? do YOU know thats EXACTLY what CHILDREN DO!!!
look if thy proved there was native American Indian in England we couldn't kick therm out of England so quit worrying even if there were prehistoric white man hear thy lived native so there is no way white man can claim this land even if thy were the first race on this land that dissent mater Ive always knew natives here weren't full Asians but stop with the race crap an realize you are only what you live,i think all body's an artifacts shud be studied recorded an prayed 4 by drum an reburied
This is another pathetic attempt from a "cauca-zoid" to try and prove that American Indians were not the first -people of this land. They want a connection to the Native American soil so bad, they will devour their own lies.They are not content with the fact that they started the first immigration problem ever to grace the "New-Worlds" soil.Their worth is displayed by their actions and they are found greatly WANTING. White-Man you are nothing.
You weak ass whiteboy, you didnt conquer anything so dont try and act like you have someting to be proud of you little bitch. It took your weak ass race of liars 400+ yrs to even fuck with us, in the end your race had to act like little bitches and infect everyone with diseases, kill millions of buffalo, and attack villages of people with trained soldiers. Yeah your tough! Killing innocent CHILDREN, WOMEN, and ELDERLY just waking up you pityfull piece of shit. Be proud you inhumane weakling.
Look Jack..The TRUTH is that..ALL..of the OLDEST Bones found in North American are...NON-"Indian"
Spirit Cave man
Kennewick Man
Penon Woman
....ALL..CLEARLY..."NON-"Indian".
Scientists in Mexico who researched Penon Woman reported her to be a "CAUCASIAN".
....and if you could get off the Bottle long enough to READ the PAIUTES OWN TRADITIONS..THEY STATE..THEY KILLED OFF..A RACE OF "TALL RED HAIRED WHITE MEN"
I read a poorly written "study" by the Bureau of Land Management that said the mummy was either ancient Ainu or Ancient Norse - ONLY problem with that statement is that there is NO evidence of ancient Norse or Ainu cultures that have been documented in their native lands, so how can they be of that origin and tim? I think too many amatuer scientists are drawing conclusions instead of conducting real scientific study.
A white mummy in the dessert, you couldn't even make it in the east coast, full of food and naturally resources, with out native people. so now u think u could've suvived in the dessert,mutha fuckers are trippin.and they found a million year old native american mummy in the Sierra Nevadas but u havent heard about that.they found native bones in AZ that were carbondated around 75000 years old. So you white people need to tell the truth. Gettin tired of hearin bull shit.
@str8Savvy You need to quit being a fucking racist. Remember that shit can come back at you if you keep it up. Did not go so well last time "your people" got it either did it?? So get off your racist tirade fuck head. Say your damn point and leave the racist insults out. Its always the conquered people that are fucking racist. REMEMBER THAT.....CONQUERED
No one knows for sure who was first... but we do know the oldest known skeletal remains were white... Jews are light skinned mongoloids.
There are tons of reasons why the white population could have gone extinct in NA. The most logical is breeding. The mongoloids have always been able to breed more than a white man. So it would make sense that the mongoloids would have continued to breed and than a cultural war would have taken place... Winner takes all.
ocpunkelite86 - that was some funny writing there. BTW, that fat lady who called Barack an "Arab". Did she mean to say that she mistook him for a lightskinned Mongloid Jew? LOL
In American History, our government passed the 1924 Immigration Act. "Not all Caucasions are White", was a slogan. This stopped people from Eastern and Southern Europe from immigrating to the United States.
...just like Europe, there are Germans, Italians, Bulgarians and even though they are European, they have different looks and genetic make-up. They are still Europeans, but different. The same with Native people. In old first-hand accoutns European settlers stated that Paiutes were different looking then the neighboring California Indians. Also they wrote that Paiutes did not have Asiatic features, and Kennwick Man was found on the border of Paiute country."
He's white! and as a brother I say go ahead and test him. He's MY relative not yours. Whites were killed off and assimilated by Indians when they arrived thousands of years later. Europeans and asians were the first people in this country.
White, right. Whatever. Whites are becoming quite desperate and really it is quite pathetic with the stupid arguments they're coming out now to further justify their actions against Native peoples.
Asians were not the first...and don't buy into the ice age land bridge as being the first path for humans to enter into the continent of what is now called North America.
It shouldn't matter if the skeleton isn't "Indian" enough. It doesn't rule out a relationship. 9,000 yrs is a long time. Even without clear DNA connection, they're respecting the man's right to rest in peace and NOT be some artifact on display. When mothers are killing their own kids, it's clear that DNA ties are inane when compared to true human bonds. DNA is crucial only in the eyes of science. Real family wouldn't care about something as trivial as whose sperm met whose egg.
What if they did study the DNA? Maybe they COULD figure out what sort of life this man lived. That would be pretty interesting to know, I'll admit. But it's not a call that scientists should be making. They're strangers invading a gravesite. Do they care about the mummy as anything other than a gem of info? Do they see him as a man? Here there are people that DO care, that DO think this man is more than a bundle of bones for poking and prodding, yet they're being dismissed. Why?
Chuck, our traditional religious belief system is that it is taboo to alter a burial site. It is said it disturbs the spirits journey across the dusty trail called the Milky Way. Caucasoid ancestry questions will be determined in the Court system and challenged by Sovereign Nations as per religious belief. We believe what we believe and you have your belief concept, thus the court case. We will see.
Hey my people believe in the Milky Way as a trail we travel on after we die too cool, Im a Mohawk of the Hudenosonih or Iroquois... And my people say if you disturb the dead things will start happening to you and your family sickness and things like that....
...just like Europe, there are Germans, Italians, Bulgarians and even though they are European, they have different looks and genetic make-up. They are still Europeans, but different. The same with Native people. In old first-hand accoutns European settlers stated that Paiutes were different looking then the neighboring California Indians. Also they wrote that Paiutes did not have Asiatic features, and Kennwick Man was found on the border of Paiute country.
Chuck, most people believe that all Native people are the same. There were over 500 nations just in the North America. We had different cultures, languages and customs. We were still all Natives, but not all Natives look alike or are from the same genetic stock.
...but even though we have different features, language, and customs from different Nations. We are tied by our Native pride...the same as most Europeans do, even though they were different.
Sadly, i have seen a man argue saying after 10 generations we cannot be related he actualy said, i wish they were here so they could tell us were not related. they dug them up and wouldnt let us rebury them. the artifacts went a museum in england...
Man, this is bureaucracy. I'm sure we wont go to Europe and dig up their ancestors, an apeman and tell them, "nope, this isn't you people, when realistically it is their people and displace them!
Caucasian or not, science shouldn't be fettered. Europeans, africans, polynesians, phoenicians, etc may have been coming here for millenia. This was found on federal land, so that is that, let the tribe sue the government. Truth shouldn't be silienced.
sauroid1 1 month ago
The "Native Americans" need to get over the fact that there were other people besides them that inhabited the Americans before they got here. They have not been here since the beginning of time, so they need to get over it.
John95959 2 months ago
Comment removed
finstark 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@John95959 Of course, but I bet the "native" americans treated these people way more peaceful than the european settlers treated the native americans.
tontsa911 2 months ago
a discovery that may confirm stories in mormon tradition ~ the "book of ether" ! .)
aynradd 2 months ago
Wow so close to me I should go check that site out one day.
WTFMusicPerson 4 months ago
People from southern france called Solutreans had an ice bridge between france and america and there have been found several artifacts from these people and when the ice age melted a land bridge between the east and alaska was formed letting native americans in america. There have been a documentary about it and it have been uploaded to youtube. just search for it.
forsalololo95 5 months ago
That's a Caucasian? Bullshit!
WarriorOfTheOldWays1 7 months ago
if the body is not native american ,,,,white-ish,,,is more like it ..then the tribe should have no say in what happens to it i would like to know were it realy came from ...
raptor1madmetal 8 months ago
they have pretty much concluded already that this was a cauciside skull like Kenswick...This makes me angry...I am of Native descent and I don't know one Native who doesn't want these bones studied and who is to spiritual to want to learn about thier own anscestory and wants them burried...bunch of idiots taking them and burying them before anyone can study them...what's up with that...think maby someone has an agenda!
lucy9359 8 months ago
i have read the reports the body is ..not from there tribe this is there way of saying hey we were here first ...
raptor1madmetal 9 months ago
@raptor1madmetal I don't agree I am metis and so obviously I have a few native friends and I can't think of one of us who don't want these bones studied when they pull them up...I am sure God is not going to think we are bad ass because we studied the bones of our great, great , great ,great ,great ,great ,great,great,great,great....anscestors,lol!
lucy9359 8 months ago
IMO it looks Nunamiut if you look at the reconstruction, the inland version of Iñupiat or eskimos. They say the America's were inhabited from people coming over the land bridge of Alaska.
bonsai108 11 months ago
@bonsai108 I don't believe it...there is to much evidence to the contrary...for one why are there only two languages in them parts if the people migrated out and 400 in the rest of North America and 700 in South and Central America...there were caucasion genes mongoloid genes in the populations as well...that tells me that all native americans arrived in different parts of the world and were actually different people groups...
lucy9359 8 months ago
@lucy9359
Incorrect. Certain Altaic groups do show a frequency for haplogroup X. The suggestion is that Altaic X may be an intermediary between European and American Indian X groups. Since the ancestral population initially came from the Middle East and branched, it would make sense that this haplogroup would split in two ways. No "white" or "Caucasian" people living in the Americas occurred to explain the presence of X among Natives.
NopeJPeg 7 months ago
@NopeJPeg I am not sure what you mean by that last sentence no white or caucasion people living in Americas occured to explain the presence of x among natives?
lucy9359 7 months ago
@NopeJPeg
There were no caucasians predating American Indians in the Americas to explain the presence of haplogroup X in some Indian populations.
NopeJPeg 7 months ago
The Paiutes express concern over desecration of the dead for research. Funny they and other paleolithic Americans never gave desecration of the living a second thought.
Perhaps they just can't take the idea they are not the "first Americans" after all. Whatever they think, they are like the tail wagging the dog here.
Besides, this guy's spirit has had a nice long rest, he can get up for a minute while they study, him, then, its back to the old freezerino...:--)
1000buffalos 1 year ago
Fucking theives!! Let the scientists study what are you fuckers afraid of.
ViolentVikingStrom 1 year ago
@ViolentVikingStrom
"F***ing theives!! Let the sceintists study. What are you f***ckers afraid of?"
I am not afraid of the truth, if that's what you're asking. For your information, genetic testing has already been conducted on several Paleoamericans, including Kennewick Man. So far, they've all had American Indian haplogroups. "To date, mtDNA has been successfully extracted from about a dozen Paleoamericans from N. America. All belong to haplogroup B, C, or D." (Dr. James C. Chatters).
akichita87 1 year ago
Comment removed
TheWaterlily2012 1 year ago
The haplogroup X that is on the wikipedia page may not be right. Last I had heard before seeing that was that no DNA had been usable on Kennewick Man. I figured I had missed the news. After I posted, I went and dug around and cannot find any link that shows they have come out with a sure result on his DNA. If you have a link, pease post it for me. I want to know the truth too.
TheWaterlily2012 1 year ago
@TheWaterlily2012
They tested Kennewick man's DNA back in 2005, however, the results were inconclusive. Kennewick Man has simply been exposed for too long to the elements.
Also, haplogroup X is not found in S. East Asia or among the Ainu people. Haplogroup X has been found, however, among the Altai people in Central Asia, whom are Mongoloid peoples. Researchers have found that the haplogroup X in the Altai is most similar to the X in Amerindians. Suggesting that Indians brought X into America.
akichita87 1 year ago
@akichita87 I guess someone ought to go fix wikipedia, as it says that the tests came back as haplogroup X and attributed it to the Ainu. Goes to show that we can't trust wiki. I knew something didn't sound right so that's why I started looking for all of the news stories on him and couldn't find any proof of any DNA results. Did you see the Tarim Basin mummies in China they found that are older than any Chinese remains? As far as Kennewick, maybe we'll find out one day for sure.Thanks!
TheWaterlily2012 1 year ago
@TheWaterlily2012
We can never be sure about Wiki, but if you have any questions as to their authenticity, usually they have a bibliography on the bottom of the page. I have heard about those mummies. They are older than the Mongoloid (modern Chinese) peoples. We shouldn't be too quick to jump to conclusions though, because the Mongoloid morphology is a relatively late physical trait. Mongoloid peoples didn't fall from the sky, they are probably the modern descendants of these people.
akichita87 1 year ago
@TheWaterlily2012
For furthur clarification, I include a quote from Dr. Chris Stringer, the head of the human origins at the Natural History Museum in London. " I don't find the Solutrean Connection claims to be convincing, for a start, most humans in the world at that time were long headed." Also, the quote I mentioned earlier by Dr. James C. Chatters states that the only haplogroups found in Paleoamericans thus far have been B, C and D, which are Native American.
akichita87 1 year ago
@akichita87 Well, most all of them have their own opinion, but all of the lectures from scientists and archaeologists that I've heard makes the Solutrean claims very convincing. We are being lied to about a lot of things. You should read Michael Cremo's 'Forbidden Archaeology' and you will see many things you have never heard before or have been lied to about. Check out the Starchild Skull too. Those DNA results are very interesting.
TheWaterlily2012 1 year ago
@TheWaterlily2012
No offense, but the scientists and archeologists that support the Solutrean claims are few. They sound convincing because they have a tendency to leave out any contradictory claims that will refute their arguements. The DNA evidence just doesn't support such claims. Google the following "Mitochondrial DNA haplogroups of Paleoamericans in North America". The vast majority of geneticists support a single founding population of Native Americans.
akichita87 1 year ago
@akichita87 Well there are enough of them in my opinion. Chatters is just one guy himself and his book was written quite awhile ago if I am remembering right. The Windover Florida Bog mummies are not American Indian and are of European DNA. The Tarim Basin mummies are of European DNA. Blonde mummies found in Peru. There was a book written in the 1800's by an American Indian woman who told of the tall red-haired people that were already here and they were killed off. Giant skeletons found as well
TheWaterlily2012 1 year ago
@TheWaterlily2012
Since you are persistent on the topic, I'll give you a small list of archealogists that disagree with the Solutrean theory: James Chatters, Gentry Steele, Joseph Powell, Walter Neves, Ales Hrdlicka, Alan Goodman, Chris Stringer, Grover Krants, to name a few. The geneticists that disagree with the theory are even more numerous: David Glenn Smith, Frederika Keastle, Ripan Malhi, Jason Eshleman, Brian Kemp, Kivisild, Tamm E., Reidla, to name a few. I can give you journals to read
akichita87 1 year ago
@akichita87 Most Archaeologists are part of the "system" and hide evidence or outright lie about it. They only put out the info they are allowed to by the establishment to serve certain political or financial interests. Look at Egypt. They've been lying about all of what really goes on there and squashing the truth. Look up the "Bagdad Battery". There are as many archaeologists now that agree with the Solutrean theory as you have shown disagree with it, so it comes down to who we each believe.
TheWaterlily2012 1 year ago
@TheWaterlily2012
I am definitely interested in what you have to say, however, I doubt that all of the individuals I listed below would lie. Also, some of the anthropologists and geneticists metioned below are from South America, such as Walter Neves. I doubt that they all got together and decided to hoax the whole thing in favor of Native Americans. Also, many of them, if they wanted to lie, they would have a greater motive to lie in favor of the Solutrean theory, to bypass NAGPRA.
akichita87 1 year ago
@TheWaterlily2012
I suggest the following readings: "Mitochondrial DNA Haplogroups of Paleoamericans in North America"(2005), "Mitochondrial Population Genomics Support a Single Pre-Clovis Origin with a Coastal Route for the peopling of the Americas" (2007), "Beringian Standstill and spread of Native American founders" (2007). These reading stipulate that haplogroup X2b found in Native Americans is related to the Mongoloid peoples of the Altai in Central Asia.
akichita87 1 year ago
@akichita87 Thank you for the list. I do agree that Amercan Indians and Mongoloid peoples in Central Asia are genetically linked. That doesn't mean Kennewick was American Indian, nor Mongoloid when we don't have DNA. He could be, but orbital shape looked Caucasoid. Maybe we'll never know for sure. The Windover Bog mummies are European. I hope you try and get that 'Forbidden Archaeology' book by Cremo. It will take you a long time to get through as it is quite something and thick as a brick.
TheWaterlily2012 1 year ago
@TheWaterlily2012
In the journals I provided, the explaination for why Kennewick, and others like him, look different from modern Amerindians is due to natural phenomenon like genetic drift. And although they see craniomorphological differences between Paleoamericans and Indians, mtDNA remains unchanged. I don't trust the analysis of the Windover Bog due to the fact that it is an isolated incident, Dr. Joseph Lorenze himself mentioned a likely hood of accidental contamination by field workers.
akichita87 1 year ago
@TheWaterlily2012
I also wanted to say that I am sorry for being overly persistent myself. I don't want there to be any hurt feelings. This is obviously a subject we both feel strongly about.
akichita87 1 year ago
@akichita87 this might be true however the haplogroup x factor is caucasion and it is not found in the central asia populations and it is prevelant in many North American Indian groups....the clovis origin is insignifigant in comparison to this...
lucy9359 8 months ago
@lucy9359 Haplogroup X is NOT a caucasian gene nor is it unique to caucasians.
You should know as well that mtDNA is only found in 4% of Europeans....and also 4% in Native Americans.
So claiming that X is a caucasian factor is wrong. Also Native Americans and Europeans share common ancestry in Central Asia and way back, in the Middle East where X originates. The common ancestor that gave out X cannot be uniquely Native American nor Caucasian.
guiltytangent 5 months ago
@TheWaterlily2012
As for the Starchild Skull. That is very interesting, but I am a skeptic at heart.
Believe me, I would be fascinated if the child was a alien/human hybrid, because there are stories in Native American lore about a human woman marrying a star being, and begetting a child, who grows up to be a savior. However, evidence points that the child was human. The child had both X and Y chromosomes, which only come from human mother and father. The child likely had hydrocephaly.
akichita87 1 year ago
@akichita87 They just came out earlier in 2010 and the DNA has unidentifiable "alien" DNA. This was just a few months ago. Lloyd Pye had been trying to get DNA testing for awhile. It is here on YT where you can check it out. There were many differences between its skull and a humans as well, which was also different from hydrocephaly. That is interesting about the American Indian lore. There are definately star beings. Check out about ancient Sumerian tablets. Even had solar system engraved.
TheWaterlily2012 1 year ago
It's really an alien... I've seen da mummy at a secret facility in Oregon.... The government is coverin up da mummy portraying it as a human when it's really an alien the Indians worshipped at that time...
tinonlia 1 year ago
what a bunch of crap. lemme guess... it is of a European decent right? LOL get real...that is so pathetic.
smokeofthesun 1 year ago
People don't realize that the earth is ROUND. why is this so mind blowing?
makeittill2013 1 year ago
@makeittill2013
frankvanqueens 1 year ago
That mummy is probably a White Man.
White Folks inhabited North America for thousands of years before the first non-white invader set foot here.
I know for a fact that when a certain event happened, which was 10,800 years ago, not a singe non-white had ever been to our White Homeland in North America.
I am a Native North American, those invading Asian savages are not!
CelticSouthland 1 year ago
@CelticSouthland Interesting
makeittill2013 1 year ago
@CelticSouthland LOL your argument had many problems with it....I can help you formlate another one to try to gain believers. But it won't make your argument any more closer to the truth
mylabonte 1 year ago
VERY AMAZING!
brianbirdtv 1 year ago
According to the Bureau of Land Management, Spirit Cave Man is not CULTURALLY related to any known tribe. However, Spirit Cave Man IS Native American, according to BLM.
akichita87 1 year ago
@akichita87 Get off your ignorant primitive high horse, this is the remains of a people that Amerindians displaced. More closely related to the Ainu, similar to Kennnewick man. YOUR people exterminated his race and took his lands. The whiteman only took your lands and was more merciful to your sorry asses. Perhaps the white mans conquest of Native Amercians is the Great Spririts way of saying "Hey Pal - what goes around comes around !"
richrajo 1 year ago
@richrajo Woah buddy. Take it easy. I was simply correcting the news anchor who incorrectly quoted the BLM (Bureau of Land Management). And another thing... you're a jack ass.
akichita87 1 year ago
@akichita87 sorry pal, I clicked on the wrong "Reply" button and the wrong post, comments weren't directed at you. Regardless ... when dealing with antiquity this deep it appears that the Modern Native Amerindians are not neccesarily related to many of the ancient remains coming to light in recent years.... Have a nice day !
richrajo 1 year ago
@richrajo All is forgiven. I, too, agree that there is a lot that we have to learn yet about these ancient people. I just got a little frustrated because I see that a lot of people have been using this evidence to justify injustices that occur in this modern era. For me, I believe that this evidence only proves that all races of people are really no different from one another.
akichita87 1 year ago
Alvin Moyle is a Asshole don't believe him!
boncos95sjtj 2 years ago
@boncos95sjtj How you know.
malcjow 2 years ago
im a member of that tribe and im related to his stupid ass!
boncos95sjtj 2 years ago
The Moyles come from Mono Lake, lol
Ahwahneechee 2 years ago
Your not making any sense to me - please explain.
1bridlington 2 years ago
i am a paiute shoshone indian and i am a member of the "fallon paiute shoshone tribe" in fallon,nevada which alvin moyle is the chairman of u am related to him also. i have nothing good to say about him and he shouldn't even be chairman because he has a criminal record.
boncos95sjtj 2 years ago
@boncos95sjtj YO! same here!!! haha
Myal37 1 year ago
Amy Dansie needst o go back to college, she is basing her finds of cacoziod strickly on cranium messurments which are unfounded. It is proven that cranium messurements change due to enviromental conditions. Therefore, to say that the remains are "white" based on its features is one sided to say the least!
Irishroyality36 2 years ago
Hey irish,
How come forensic scientists can determine 'race' based on skull shape & skeletal structure?
Also the "cranium measurements change according to environmental conditions" do Forensic scientists know this?
Who is the originator of this "Theory"?
Thanks Irish
666Winstonsmith 2 years ago
Just another conspiracy by the CIA to show that they (caucasians) are the real natives of America, so as to justify their imperialism!
No one can say from the skeleton alone what race the person must have belonged to.
himalayanspirit 2 years ago
White people really got around... I think the Indians oppose to DNA testing,because with each discovery of Caucasians being the first people here it weakens their special status...
ClarksonsinUSA 2 years ago
@ClarksonsinUSA No shit
prooc 2 years ago
The age of this mummy is the age of Kennewick Man. Any and all relationships should be studied. I am Native American, and believe some scientific study will further our people through education. Make sence...?
WelderRDT 2 years ago 11
@WelderRDT this man was not native american he was cauciside...I am also of native anscestory and many native americans were actually carrying halogroup x genes which are cauciside genes....more than one earliest explorer said that there were white as well as bronze colour first nations tribes in the 1500's...the problem with these so called spirtual natives is they are stopping the scientists from going over these remains...as if the majority of us care...I am not spiritual in that respect...
lucy9359 8 months ago
@lucy9359 The post said same age, NOT what you are addressing...
WelderRDT 7 months ago
...so there were people living here with caucasian traits -- so what -- Eskimos are more related to the people of coastal Russia and Greenland than Algonquin Indians -- the first Spanish explorers reported seeing light eyed and light skinned Indians in California -- Yes the Vikings reached north America and fought and lived with the Natives...but are these a white person's bones? Who cares - their on Indian land now -- And if they don't want you digging in their yard - stay out --
darkbranches 2 years ago
...I LOVE how NOBODY can even MENTION that the PIAUTES OWN HISTORYS....STATE...THEY..."KILLED OFF A RACE OF TALL RED HAIRED WHITE PEOPLE" In Ancient Times.
Somehow that odd little FACT NEVER even gets a MENTION
In FACT MOST MAJOR "Indian" Civilizations of the New World...OPENLY STATE...that "their" Civilization/Technology were FOUNDED/CREATED by "Tall White Skinned Bearded "Gods"
GENETIC RESEARCH has shown that the OLDEST "Indian" DNA LINE is actually the CAUCASIAN "X" Line
Go figure
Ooloosoon 2 years ago
Proof that we really ARE as ONE-race! Like "Baskin Robbins"-many flavors-still just ice cream, basically!
(Mmmm-ice cream...) Cool! (:
oobxer 2 years ago 2
this guy is one of the biggest racists on youtube. look at his other posts he always yaps on about nonsense and loves to caps lock pointless BS. i get the feeling hes gonna shoot up something soon. all his posts are the exact same its amazing.
lazrul 2 years ago
...Yet Another High IQ Post of Personal attacks and SCREAMS of "racism" by Lazrul.
I guess when YOUR faced with FACTS and SCIENTIFIC REALITY..and your totally unable to debate them...all thats left for YOU is silly 4th grade level personal attacks
The Only thing Im "shooting up" is YOUR BOGUS posting
I post FACTS and SCIENTIFIC REALITY
Sorry YOU cant deal with REALITY
Ooloosoon 2 years ago
he types like a bitch
oakfox1981 2 years ago 4
That doesn't change facts though
dud3man6969 2 years ago
WHY DO you TYPE like THIS? do you KNOW how ANNOYING it IS to READ! your the LAST person that should talk abou IQ. your a brain FRIED yokel. your just an INSECURE person who needs to be HEARD. you should JUST CAPS LOCK EVERYTHING if you NEED ATTENTION so BADLY.
why are you ALWAYS calling people a 3RD or 4TH GRADER? do YOU know thats EXACTLY what CHILDREN DO!!!
lazrul 2 years ago
leave the dead alone respect them !!!!!!!
jimiwhat 3 years ago
talking shit but too scared to do a DNA test. bunch of pussies.
aphyd2 3 years ago
look if thy proved there was native American Indian in England we couldn't kick therm out of England so quit worrying even if there were prehistoric white man hear thy lived native so there is no way white man can claim this land even if thy were the first race on this land that dissent mater Ive always knew natives here weren't full Asians but stop with the race crap an realize you are only what you live,i think all body's an artifacts shud be studied recorded an prayed 4 by drum an reburied
crazycoyotie 3 years ago
This is another pathetic attempt from a "cauca-zoid" to try and prove that American Indians were not the first -people of this land. They want a connection to the Native American soil so bad, they will devour their own lies.They are not content with the fact that they started the first immigration problem ever to grace the "New-Worlds" soil.Their worth is displayed by their actions and they are found greatly WANTING. White-Man you are nothing.
joeythom 3 years ago 4
Nothing huh? I guess NOTHING conquered your ass though.
niggaturd 2 years ago
You weak ass whiteboy, you didnt conquer anything so dont try and act like you have someting to be proud of you little bitch. It took your weak ass race of liars 400+ yrs to even fuck with us, in the end your race had to act like little bitches and infect everyone with diseases, kill millions of buffalo, and attack villages of people with trained soldiers. Yeah your tough! Killing innocent CHILDREN, WOMEN, and ELDERLY just waking up you pityfull piece of shit. Be proud you inhumane weakling.
piandagirl1 2 years ago 2
@piandagirl1 Your people did that too.. welcome to war.
budda10000 1 year ago
haha I think you are the one strecthing to call this yours! I will believe science before your opinion! Quit being a bith a man up
USAallDAY911 2 years ago
Nothing to FEAR from a little DNA Test then?
Look Jack..The TRUTH is that..ALL..of the OLDEST Bones found in North American are...NON-"Indian"
Spirit Cave man
Kennewick Man
Penon Woman
....ALL..CLEARLY..."NON-"Indian".
Scientists in Mexico who researched Penon Woman reported her to be a "CAUCASIAN".
....and if you could get off the Bottle long enough to READ the PAIUTES OWN TRADITIONS..THEY STATE..THEY KILLED OFF..A RACE OF "TALL RED HAIRED WHITE MEN"
Thats what THEY STATE
Ooloosoon 2 years ago
I read a poorly written "study" by the Bureau of Land Management that said the mummy was either ancient Ainu or Ancient Norse - ONLY problem with that statement is that there is NO evidence of ancient Norse or Ainu cultures that have been documented in their native lands, so how can they be of that origin and tim? I think too many amatuer scientists are drawing conclusions instead of conducting real scientific study.
Malocosa 3 years ago
A white mummy in the dessert, you couldn't even make it in the east coast, full of food and naturally resources, with out native people. so now u think u could've suvived in the dessert,mutha fuckers are trippin.and they found a million year old native american mummy in the Sierra Nevadas but u havent heard about that.they found native bones in AZ that were carbondated around 75000 years old. So you white people need to tell the truth. Gettin tired of hearin bull shit.
str8Savvy 3 years ago 4
@str8Savvy You need to quit being a fucking racist. Remember that shit can come back at you if you keep it up. Did not go so well last time "your people" got it either did it?? So get off your racist tirade fuck head. Say your damn point and leave the racist insults out. Its always the conquered people that are fucking racist. REMEMBER THAT.....CONQUERED
severintsunami 1 year ago
No one knows for sure who was first... but we do know the oldest known skeletal remains were white... Jews are light skinned mongoloids.
There are tons of reasons why the white population could have gone extinct in NA. The most logical is breeding. The mongoloids have always been able to breed more than a white man. So it would make sense that the mongoloids would have continued to breed and than a cultural war would have taken place... Winner takes all.
ocpunkelite86 3 years ago
ocpunkelite86 - that was some funny writing there. BTW, that fat lady who called Barack an "Arab". Did she mean to say that she mistook him for a lightskinned Mongloid Jew? LOL
Malocosa 3 years ago
whats the definition of whites? are jews white? dont tell me you think jesus was white too?
alchemist7414 3 years ago
I would love to know what happened in this case. Does anyone know?
Cherri59 3 years ago
In American History, our government passed the 1924 Immigration Act. "Not all Caucasions are White", was a slogan. This stopped people from Eastern and Southern Europe from immigrating to the United States.
ihateimall 4 years ago
Please check if u can get more about this, I'm very interested in such subject. Thnx for the vid.
mafiotzi 4 years ago
i'd let them cut a small piece of tissue from my relative to learn who and how man first lived in North America
kbfresh1 4 years ago
This is very interesting. When was this story broadcasted? what has been the outcome thus far?
ChampionIndian 4 years ago
Years ago. I don't know what happened. I should check.
Ahwahneechee 4 years ago
Well said:
"Ahwahneechee
...just like Europe, there are Germans, Italians, Bulgarians and even though they are European, they have different looks and genetic make-up. They are still Europeans, but different. The same with Native people. In old first-hand accoutns European settlers stated that Paiutes were different looking then the neighboring California Indians. Also they wrote that Paiutes did not have Asiatic features, and Kennwick Man was found on the border of Paiute country."
Booboo85 4 years ago 2
He's white! and as a brother I say go ahead and test him. He's MY relative not yours. Whites were killed off and assimilated by Indians when they arrived thousands of years later. Europeans and asians were the first people in this country.
Jfirearrow 4 years ago
White, right. Whatever. Whites are becoming quite desperate and really it is quite pathetic with the stupid arguments they're coming out now to further justify their actions against Native peoples.
Enseni 4 years ago
the only thing i agree with you on is asians were the first to arrive, not whites thoe!..lol
alchemist7414 3 years ago
Asians were not the first...and don't buy into the ice age land bridge as being the first path for humans to enter into the continent of what is now called North America.
aupsychobilly 3 years ago
well if whites were really the First like you claim, why diden't they last long in North America!
alchemist7414 3 years ago
It shouldn't matter if the skeleton isn't "Indian" enough. It doesn't rule out a relationship. 9,000 yrs is a long time. Even without clear DNA connection, they're respecting the man's right to rest in peace and NOT be some artifact on display. When mothers are killing their own kids, it's clear that DNA ties are inane when compared to true human bonds. DNA is crucial only in the eyes of science. Real family wouldn't care about something as trivial as whose sperm met whose egg.
Onomon 4 years ago
What if they did study the DNA? Maybe they COULD figure out what sort of life this man lived. That would be pretty interesting to know, I'll admit. But it's not a call that scientists should be making. They're strangers invading a gravesite. Do they care about the mummy as anything other than a gem of info? Do they see him as a man? Here there are people that DO care, that DO think this man is more than a bundle of bones for poking and prodding, yet they're being dismissed. Why?
Onomon 4 years ago
Chuck, our traditional religious belief system is that it is taboo to alter a burial site. It is said it disturbs the spirits journey across the dusty trail called the Milky Way. Caucasoid ancestry questions will be determined in the Court system and challenged by Sovereign Nations as per religious belief. We believe what we believe and you have your belief concept, thus the court case. We will see.
Ahwahneechee 4 years ago
Hey my people believe in the Milky Way as a trail we travel on after we die too cool, Im a Mohawk of the Hudenosonih or Iroquois... And my people say if you disturb the dead things will start happening to you and your family sickness and things like that....
CheckLike 4 years ago
...just like Europe, there are Germans, Italians, Bulgarians and even though they are European, they have different looks and genetic make-up. They are still Europeans, but different. The same with Native people. In old first-hand accoutns European settlers stated that Paiutes were different looking then the neighboring California Indians. Also they wrote that Paiutes did not have Asiatic features, and Kennwick Man was found on the border of Paiute country.
Ahwahneechee 4 years ago
Chuck, most people believe that all Native people are the same. There were over 500 nations just in the North America. We had different cultures, languages and customs. We were still all Natives, but not all Natives look alike or are from the same genetic stock.
Ahwahneechee 4 years ago
Chuck, which bodies are those?
Ahwahneechee 4 years ago
...but even though we have different features, language, and customs from different Nations. We are tied by our Native pride...the same as most Europeans do, even though they were different.
Ahwahneechee 4 years ago
they want to cut up someones grandparent... gees Maybe one of my ancestors... I'd say leave them alone too.
bannockeater 4 years ago 2
Sadly, i have seen a man argue saying after 10 generations we cannot be related he actualy said, i wish they were here so they could tell us were not related. they dug them up and wouldnt let us rebury them. the artifacts went a museum in england...
zyx645 4 years ago
Everytime they find an Indian mummy or bones they claim they are "Caucausoid" so they can cut, poke and prod our ancestors.
Ahwahneechee 5 years ago
Comment removed
boncos95sjtj 2 years ago
Man, this is bureaucracy. I'm sure we wont go to Europe and dig up their ancestors, an apeman and tell them, "nope, this isn't you people, when realistically it is their people and displace them!
nylonshredder 5 years ago
More Bureaucracy or is it just more polictal agenda as the government shall call it...
greyxwolfx 5 years ago