Added: 5 months ago
From: RestingLegend55
Views: 21,028
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (168)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • the stalker girl is such a freak....lol

  • I haven't watched this shit before but certainly looks good, I'ma watch this shit in both japanese n' english!

  • i feel english dubs only work well for comedy shows. so this sort of fits.

    also i wonder if anyone hear actually can speak japanese and understand it. i feel most of the guys here are weeaboos. seriously.

  • I think they cast the right people, they just gave them the wrong roles.

  • Fuck this shit. I can go to my bed room and watch episodes 1-6 of season 1 when ever I want, because I have volume 1 of season 1!

  • ...regardless, this is pretty good for today's standards. I've seen amazing recent dubs (Gurren Lagann, Mushishi, Spice & Wolf, Strike Witches...hell even Hetalia, because of the use of accents), and this doesn't quite live up to them, but it's sure as hell better than those sorry excuses for dubs of amazing series, i.e. Clannad, among others.

  • American voice actors for overdubs seem to have a hard time portraying specific characters' personalities through the tone of their voice without sounding too monotone or over-the-top. Voice actors are a big deal in Japan, not to mention their scripts are the originals and are easily synced with the animation, so it'd make sense why they'd usually be better.

  • Maybe i should post a video of more of this dub to show people its real xP

  • shes sound better in japaneze

    

  • must... buy... DVDs!!!

  • @Megarexx1 or bluray :P

  • There's an English dub of this? Hm, I didn't know that... But I ink (hehe) I'll stick to the Japanese one for now while I watch the rest of the second season. Still, not half bad though. I've seen far worse, like the morning animes currently on CTNW. God, those are awful.

  • @fuzzydude64 there isnt an actualy english dub for this :3 it's just a "fan dub" search some fan dubs :) this is one of the best

  • @patar41 Thats wrong. I have the dvd and it has this dub in it... Its official

  • @patar41 Actually, this is the official English dub. I own the DVDs.

  • @Vidszhite where did you buy? i swear to got if you say singapore or hong kong im gonna rage ><

  • @Funkopotomis No... I just went to Amazon.com lol.

  • @Vidszhite purchased and i get on wednesday

    thanks yo

  • what the Gell is this think

  • Lol wow.

    So many weeaboos QQing here, it's fucking hilarious. I haven't seen this many wannabe-Japanese people since forever.

    Get the fuck out, this dub is fine.

    Inb4 the weeaboos QQ harder and thumb me down

  • "This is for the gulls!"

    With every new pun I find her voice more and more perfect.

  • @romanmonaghan Huh? The problems are not limited to the problem of language and puns.

    It is dramatists that create the pun and it is not the voice actors.

    The nub of the matter is quality of voice, and acting skills.

  • squiddy needs to be more over-the-top!!!

  • You like Alex, don't you, Squid Girl?

  • wow, the dub actually sounds pretty good.

  • ok, i that the girl who said she was jaelous is lesbian and she imagineded that ika was her pet

  • Ika Musume's english voice actor is voicing madoka in the Madoka dub!

  • I feel difference in ability of voice actors in Japan and the U.S.

    Many voice actor applicants are in Japan. A competition rate is high. There are a lot of voice actor training schools in japan.

    Therefore the Japanese voice actors have high ability in spite of the new face.

    tone, accent, emotional expression. etc.

  • @SuperTekuteku yeah now let me tell you

    do i give a fuck about you just said=no

    well i think about what you just said=no

    let me tell you what i will do i will go and watch the shows in japanese ith eng subs

    while lauging at idiots like you

    sorry baby but america is not the only country in this world and english is not the only language so shut the fuck emo bitch

  • Stop talking about the n80's and 90's, this is the flipping 2000's! The voice acting is good and I happen to like it.

  • Why ika chan no say "geso" at the end

  • Sounds good to me, no where near the 80s or early 90s voices. No wonder the companies bash these idiots for complaining. Majority don't even buy the products...

  • @ExcelGenerations thank you

  • When will we be able see the whole thing in english?

    I think they got the English voice acterss to get the right tone in Squidgirl. They match so perfectly

  • Anyone need a phosphorus grenade to escape from this horrible voice acting? Paid actors or not, this shit is horrible everytime.

  • @Bronzecop

    now now, we haven't heard the rest of the cast yet. And the VA's aren't that terrible, hell i wouldn't go as far as say they are bad. Like I said, it's gonna take some getting used to.

  • @ssupermario92 If you gotta get used to them then it is that bad XD LMAO ROTF!!! At least I have people like you to cheer me up.

  • ok Chizuro sounds exactly what I expected, same w/ Sanae.

    Ika and Eiko however....gonna take some getting used to (especially Eiko...)

  • Yea it's usually hard to get into a dub after watching the sub, and vice versa, but I think this one is done pretty well.

  • @xXUnoriginalNameXx33 Really? I don't have any problems with it. I used to watch Fullmetal Alchemist in English first then I watched it in Japanese and it didn't effect me. I guess I'm just those where it doesn't matter. Not like the Law of Ueki one. I mean, sure, they were new but it just didn't work at all.

    This one, they sound good to me so when I can, I'm getting this!

  • Is this even going to be a real show? If so, please tell me!

  • @SuperPichu62 Are you asking if the show itself is real? If so, it already is, albeit in Japanese with English subtitles.

  • @TheRamosOnline Nope, they didn't replace the curse words; except for no "~de geso" and a Japanese pun or two changed for English audience it's pretty simular to the original.

  • @simontheslakoth719 I expect to hear Bitch a few times :3

    I know its a small nack, but I HATE it when they water down anime just because it looks or has a childish story.

  • @TheRamosOnline Ah, well I don't remember hearing that particular word. And although I'm not a fan of bad language, I understand your position on this.

  • @TheRamosOnline They don't swear in the Japanese version to begin with, so how is it watered down? Ika Musume is pretty much the definition of an innocent for-all-ages SoL Comedy. Ika does drop "super-pissed" once or twice, but I don't believe she'd ever have a reason to say "bitch".

    If you read between the lines of what she's saying, Ika actually swears quite a lot in the English dub, she just replaces the actual words with fish puns that sound innocent.

  • Better than Pokemon's Eng Dub at least.

  • @pokepo11 Which one? 4Kids was like heaven, but the new dub is like hell

  • @naviproductions Yeah... Say that again after watching Sonic X... Enjoy puking blood.

  • @DarkSolnea Oh, I've seen Sonic X. Loved it :3 It made me cry though!! That part with Cosmo and Tails had me go into my bathroom to hide from my family so they wouldn't know I was crying. You didn't like that dub?

  • @naviproductions if we're talking english dub, no. I can't stand it. If it's the jap one then yes. How about elaborating the Tails and Cosmos part a bit more because the one I know is Tails not wanting to shoot because he loved Cosmos.

    Actually, search for Sonic X comparison vids. It'll explain things better than I can. When you find out that Live and Learn was in the jap dub and the several things they cut out in the english, you will hate 4kids.

  • @naviproductions I mean, after seeing those comparisons and realising how much 4kids butchered the Cosmos and Tails scene... I despise 4kids. I don't like most of the Sonic X VAs before the change. Sonic' VA annoys me, Rouge didn't sound like her age at all and Knuckles sounds dumb. I know Knuckles is meant to be a Knucklehead but when you compare that Knuckles with the ones back during Adventure 2 and Heroes, well, all of them, then you realise there's a problem.

  • Interesting! i might have really enjoyed watching this dubbed if i hadnt already seen it subbed (but now im used to the original voices). However, i think squid girl should have been just a bit more animated . . degeso. . .

  • Sanae reminds me of Daisy from Mario XD

    And Chizuru actually looks a bit like my aunt...I like her voice though. Eikos sounds a bit "out there"...

  • SANAAAAAAAEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE­EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

  • I swear, if I hadn't wiki'd it already I'd've thought it was Cristina Valenzuela doing Squidy's voice. This "Christine Cabanos" is almost a dead ringer, haha.

  • Certainly not the worst dub I've heard, but it just sounds flat.

  • After a LOT of dubs I have heard, I have to say while this is far from the quality of late 90s animes (Cowboy Bebop and Azumanga Daioh come to mind), it is quite bearable. Ika sounds a bit off, Eiko sounds pretty good, Chizuru's not too bad either. But from what I saw of Sanae, I am not too sure about her...

  • It could have been worse. A LOT worse. Green Green worse.

    For the most, I like it, and I don't regret buying it either.

  • The voice of Ika Musume doesn't really fit, she sounds too old, imo...

  • I normally like english dub better then reading the japenese subs but the japenese sub is looking more and more better after watching this.

  • what the gill is this thing?

  • I happen to like the dub.

  • I miss de~geso

  • I dont like that fact the call her Squid Girl instead of Ika, and the stupid squid puns instead of de-geso

  • @TheAdeptRogue360: well it happens to be so the ika musume is squid girl in english, and de geso is a japanese word you cant used japanese word in a eng dub.

  • @AbridgedGalaxy I know, but to just call her "squid girl" and not an actual name is so stupid! I have a sort-of example, in Death Note, the Japanese name for "Killer" is "Kira" because the Japanese have a hard time pronouncing English "l" but when it was dubbed, we just left it as "Kira", so why cant they leave her name as at LEAST Ika? I could do without the De-geso though, but the bad squid puns gotta go XD

  • @TheAdeptRogue360: is basically the same (ika musume - squid girl)(squid girl - ika musme)

    is more like Anbe Masahiro did not think a name for her just squid girl an alias any name would be fine i dont know something like kaoru ika msume or mari ika msume etc.

  • This dub doesn't have same level of enthusiasm of chizuru and high pitched voice of Ika Musume.

    Makes the anime dull.

  • @MidShipCivic: high pitched voice makes the characters sound like same others i can tell a japanese voice actor who is it by her high pitch voice and that make's it sound old and dull.

  • @MidShipCivic: yes sometimes the moe thing get's annoying

  • @TheAnimedudeXD your previous comments have been rated bad by others to the point that they are hidden you have no taste in anime or know what good voice acting is please sit in your corner and STFU.

  • @MidShipCivic: i have a very good taste in fact those morons think they know but they dont i thing about voice acting (english,jap,spanish,german,it­alian,etc) i have even go voice acting school. if you thing you know how this work give a shot i dare to make a voice of any character you want and see is not easy.

  • I am so sick of BZ using cheapo fandub actors to get away with not having to pay for anything. The lack of talent really shows.

  • @catokeeffe I...I have to agree.

  • FUCK I KNEW THEY'D CALL HER SQUIDDY

    Media Blasters... why u do dis?

  • @UTAU53Yui: because ika musume translated is squid girl.

  • @TheAnimedudeXD No fucking shit, but it sounds absolutely ridiculous.

  • @UTAU53Yui: it would been more if they say it in japanese,people would be like WTH?

    that sounds really odd you cant mix jap words with eng words.

  • @TheAnimedudeXD Meh, it's not too hard to make it work. Plus, it's an anime. It doesn't have to be too realistic. She could have just said something like "I am the squid girl, Ika Musume!" or "I am Squid Girl! Call me Ika." Plenty of dubbers have done stuff like that before, successfully avoiding ridiculous direct translations.

  • @UTAU53Yui: and there lies the problem many complain about that, so they translated the full name to english example: Tenshi no shippo (Angel Tales) - Nana Inu no (Nana the Dog).

  • Squid Girl's voice was the only one I didn't like...

  • @RyuShoji: because she's a new actress give her a chance geez.

  • @mogechichioppai No that's not it. I've rewatched the two dub clips over and over again; the others are fitting well...this one? Not so much.

  • @RyuShoji: and i have watch to episode 6 and her other roles

    and i can tell she doing well. voice actors take time to get there potencial to a good level, like vic mignogna nobody know who was he but now every one likes him.

  • @mogechichioppai "Taking time to get their potential to a good level" doesn't make sense, as someone either has potential or they don't. If you mean warm up, they should do the warm ups before the final recording. As for Vic Migogna; it was the huge success of Fullmetal Alchemist that made people notice him - but once you've seen him in one role, you've seen him in all of them.

  • @RyuShoji: "doesn't make sence"? dude am saying keep warming up, keep doing more roles,etc

    as for vic he started with small show up's like in rozen maiden he does this kid voice only for 3 sec know one knew who was vic there, then came fma,fmp,ohshc,etc.

  • @mogechichioppai You do warming up by practicing at home and during classes, not with professional works.

    Vic only became huge because of shows like FMA, FMP and Ouran. I'll be perfectly honest, outside of "Over the top" characters like Ed and Tamaki, I find his voice pretty annoying xD

  • @RyuShoji: until he was discover he only did mini show ups in anime with a random character.

    you find it annoying other see him as a great voice actor.

  • @mogechichioppai His voice fits certain roles well (I wouldn't have anyone else voicing Ed Elric for example). However, to say he's a good actor when he has a limited vocal range and ends up getting cast as very similar characters...not a good 'actor'.

  • @RyuShoji: every body does that even japanese actors

  • @mogechichioppai I never said they were better either xD

  • @mogechichioppai if she is new she should have had more practice bein a background character then bein one of the main ones

  • I don't understand why some of you people get so worked up because an anime gets dubbed. it's not like the Japanese version disappears. It just allows the people who prefers it to watch it in English. Personally I prefer to watch it in Japanese, but if a English dubbing comes out I will watch that as well, and if it's a bad dub I will stop watching it. Besides, it's not like this is a 4Kids dub where 99% of the content is removed or edited out so little kids can watch it

  • I don't know about Cabanos, I just don't know. I'm mostly liking her as Azusa in K-On!, though. She's gonna be Madoka in the upcoming English dub for that, too.

  • @bluefives Seriously? Gross. Madoka should be Stephanie Sheh.

  • Where are the DEGESO !!!!!

  • @AtarashiiBlog: that's a japanase word you cant use a japanese word in a english dub.

  • @TheAnimedudeXD Yeah, I know :P

  • >english dubbing moe anime

    >ISHYGDDT

  • Where's the emotion D:

  • Yeah... sounds like crap.

  • You know the first time I heard this I hated it.

    BUT!

    That's because the squidspeak is SOOOOO lame in English when I can actually understand it.

    I'll get used to it, and as for the haters, well...admit it, you couldn't be satisfied even if you were.

  • Comment removed

  • I guess it coulda been worse

  • You guys seriously get mad over anything.

  • >ike sounding like a fat white woman

    3DPD strikes again!!

  • ...What the gill is this shit?

  • you know what a Funimation dub would have been way better, heck better yet a Bang Zoom dub now that would have blown everyones minds

  • @TheKiddtic Fun fact: this was a Bang Zoom dub, albeit with mostly fresh, new voice actors and not the union cast (Wendee Lee, Crispin Freeman, etc.). For new VAs as cast, their efforts are passable in some places, pretty brilliant in some other places. Of course, that's just me.

  • @JohtoKen Well, Tony Oliver is in the dub. And(if you can count her) Cristina Vee is in it as well.

  • wow i cant believe how many people hate anime dubs while i love them maybe because i prefer to understand what the characters are saying without them sounding like gibberish and having to read those stupid subtitles

  • funimation does better dubbing. You can tell pretty easily that these people are reading from a script, there is rarely any real life to these guys. Spice and Wolf is one of the better dubs i've ever seen.

  • Ika's sound like a homily

  • Imokwhitthis.jpg

  • I like this dub, I find none of the voices annoying and having the puns in ika's diolouge was a great idea!

  • I would like this if the Squid girl sounded younger.

  • @FreddyMercurysAIDS There are moments when she sounds like an old lady, specifically around 0:12, but I've managed to tolerate most of it anyway, far from the worst dub I've heard... seriously.

  • @FreddyMercurysAIDS Are you upset because not every english dub in the world makes the girls sound like six year olds? Not everything has to sound like Lucky Star you know.

  • @O2Eater Well, young girls typically sound like younger girls. All the other voices in this are pretty solid, but hers is total shit.

  • OH SHIT THERE'S MORE

    Well at least Chizuru sounds alright in this one.

  • I LIKE IT.jpg

  • Ika's voice is nice, but it doesn't sound cute or naive enough.

    Everyone else is either boring or doesn't fit compared to the original, Eiko sound like she's yawning every time and Chizuru lacks that trollish tone when she speaks. The low volume of the soundtrack and/or removal of the soundtrack doesn't help this dub though.

    Liking how they replaced the verbal tics with puns though.

  • fucking love this shit.

  • The only good voice actor here is that squid girl. Everybody sounded bored...

  • Dub "Haters Gonna Hate."

    Whatever.

  • What the gill is this

  • Bang Zoom! made a interesting choice with Chizuru's voice actor. I would love to see how her vocals contrast when she takes on Chizuru's during her darker scenes. I think for me that moment is going to be the difference between whether I find that her performance is either very good, or just average, over all.

  • It's not the best dub. I 'v e heard better and I'v eheard worse.

    But right now I'm shit faced and I 'm happy that i don't have to read antyhing.

    Fuck it, if this means more Ika Musume, I don't care.

  • So bad...

  • Hmm, interesting. I showed this to my niece and she laughed a lot at Squid Girl getting a collar - then asked me if she was being cruel!

    Looks like a success there, localisation team. Keep up the good work!

  • this dubber needs to learn how to change her voice a bit, I'm tired of hearing her in a lot of dubs, I think she is kind of bad too. I like the voices of all the other characters better.

  • Things are getting really fishy around here

  • CHIZUUUUUURUUUUUUUUURRRURUURRU­U WHAT THE FUCK IS WITH YOUR VOICE

  • honestly why do people watch dub? worst shit ever

  • @NightDen Someone hasn't seen Cowboy Bebop.

  • Download where?

  • I still think this should have been done by FUNimation.

    Luci Christian would be best Ika.

  • @SageTheWriter I dunno... I think Cherami Leigh would've voiced her better.

  • @AMUletVocaloid4278 Hm...You know, she would have done a great job too! My three top voices for Ika are now her, Luci, and Monica Rial.

  • @SageTheWriter Luci Christian may possibly be the greatest voice actress. =D

  • @NeroZero2009 She's really great, isn't she? She has that super adorable voice, but she's also able to sound much more mature. She's so talented!

  • @SageTheWriter Yeah, she's amazing in Princess Tutu, Azumanga Daioh and Negima!, I want to meet her so bad, I want an autograph. Not too many people show appreciation for the VA, but if I had to choose, Luci ftw.

  • @NeroZero2009 She was also adorable in Ouran! But yes, she'd do a great job on this show. I also think Monica Rial could be good.

  • @SageTheWriter I'm surprised she wasn't in here, she'd probably be great for Ika and maybe Cindy, but oh well *watches Season 2*

  • @SageTheWriter But then we would have had Todd Haberkorn cast as everyone.

  • @RyuShoji Todd Haberkorn happens to be my favorite voice actor. And I don't think there's anything wrong with the amount of roles he gets, considering he deserves them. He's just a good voice actor. And now I want to hear him say "de geso." Pfffft.

  • @SageTheWriter Todd's voice does fit certain roles...except he has practically no range other than his normal speaking voice. Sure, I liked Todd playing Ling Yao in Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood, but when I hear the exact same voice in other shows (Which is an increasing number these last couple of years), it just makes FUNimation dubs feel somewhat bland.

  • @RyuShoji But his normal voice is different, and I've heard him use a couple different voices. His normal voice doesn't tend to go as high as it does when he's acting. I heard him speak in real life, and I definitely noticed a difference.

  • @SageTheWriter "A couple of different voices" Oh yeah, that makes an actor good 9.9. Problem with a lot of "actors" these days, both in Hollywood live-action and anime dubs, is there's very little variation in their performances in one piece to another.

    Everything I've heard him in, and interviews I've listened to, have all been in relatively the same voice.

  • @RyuShoji Well, I see nothing wrong with it. He's got a good voice.

  • @SageTheWriter The problem is when a certain actor with a limited range is often cast in main or predominant roles. If they're a side character or something, then it's not as much of a problem.

  • @RyuShoji Well, I don't really have much to say to that other than I think he does great in all of his roles, and I have no problem with it.

  • BEST. DUB. EVER.

  • Immediately preceding the beginning of the clip, ika/Squid Girl actually says "Ya gotta be squidding me!",by the way.

  • Yeah, Eiko is a lot better in this one. You can still totally tell that she's new to this, but she's getting there.

    Nice to have a clip that shows off more of the cast, by the way.

  • Okay that was a hell of a lot better than the first clip

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list