Added: 9 months ago
From: AmericanIdol2011TV
Views: 372,685
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,043)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I swear "internet trolls" will look for any opportunity to call someone fat....sad.

  • I like the way she changed the last refrain to make it a bit more dramatic. I wish The Band Perry actually did that.

  • You guys need to stop hating on lauren. She's not fat (AT ALL), she's not ugly (you need your eyes checked), she's not a bad singer (might wanna schedule an appointment for your ears too), and she's amazing. Super talented and deserves to be where she is. Unlike some lame pop stars who don't. So back off, kay?

  • She's definitely not fat in her music video Georgia Peaches

  • She has such a beautiful voice

    

  • Everyone hates too much. Just because she has the mic close to her mouth, or she isn't used to preforming, does not just automatically make her a bad singer. I think she had a beautiful voice.

  • Her mouth is a bit too close to the mic. She looks like she's about to eat it.

  • @PixiesintheBrugh you obviously don't perform. that's what have you do. lol

  • she sing it beter than the original.

  • LAUREN GOT SO TINY>  Jealous

  • american idol is not wat it used to be it stopped being good after david cook won this next upcoming season needs to be better or else XFACTOR will beat it

  • She is a normal looking, cute, just right beautiful young and talented singer and anyone that dares say that she is fat should be shot!

  • absolutely love her dress :)

  • It's great when you have someone knock the orginal artests socks off!

  • haley shouldve taken her out :)

  • I love The Band Perry but i think Laurens version is amazing!!

  • Wonderful!

  • @MagggieArt 1:32 - she recovered well though

  • @TheMs143codysimpson 1) learn correct grammar. *you're *for *you *freaking *you're *maybe 2) that's not me, its my brother. there is a video of me singing, look a little harder.

  • I stand by Lauren. From what I've seen, Haley's voice is very trendy and now, but isn't as versatile as Lauren's. And what is everybody's problem with country music? I like both girls as singers. And this girl isn't fat... people have issues. She's a genuinely good singer... along with Haley, so please stop hating on her. She was only 15 when she was on the show.

  • @TheMs143codysimpson right, nobody's perfect. oh sweetie, before you insult my singing, where are videos of you singing? exactly. and how old are you, like 12? maybe before you say something bad about someone else's singing, you should probably have your own videos.

  • i love this song ♥

  • @avirah1 In these shows it's not all about the singing. At the end personality matters the most since the public votes people they like the most, not just people who sing the best.

  • @exgf22 I'm sure your just perfect though right? No? Well shut the hell up and get a life.

  • She is really good!

  • good recovery =)

  • i remember this day as clear as it was yesterday we were sitting there watching american idol and she sang this song and when it ended my mom said "was it good? I dont know the song" and all i could say was "better then original"

  • @Kowalski88 I am convinced that after any of Lauren's performance you could ask her "What was that song you just sang about?"  and she would have no idea.

  • Better than even the original singer!!!!!!

  • @TheEquestrianQueen

    So agreeing with you!

    If she is fat, I want to be like her. Cause I know what fat is..

  • i love lauren!

  • I met her 10.13.11 NYC

  • I love her she is amazing!!! too bad she did not win! :(

  • @MrSodaman4 Um hip hop is still real music; people have a right to like whatever music they like, so stop trying to force them to listen to what YOUR opinion of good music is.

  • i love her and i love this performance

  • damn, she's good!!!

  • @Captainredneckdiesel She's 16 and after the auditions she lost 20+ lbs that she didn't need to lose. Sure she has more of a husky build, but she's not fat.

  • @Captainredneckdiesel Yep, You're an idiot.

  • @Captainredneckdiesel yep, ur an asshole

  • @Captainredneckdiesel thats a good friend of mine your talkin bout, so shutup

  • @exgf22 well who are you to be judge mental shes probley more talented then u and a whole lot prettier

  • @Captainredneckdiesel yep, ur a fuckin dumbass and what? 

  • I thought she would win (so sad that she did not)

  • amazing :D

  • if u dont like it dont watch it 

  • I AM HER # 1 FAN ILOVE YOU LAREN

  • I don't see the problem she sounds great!

  • Kayyy so, some of yall need to shut up. She isnt just trying to please yall she needs the judges approvals too. And for those of you who call her fat...do you think that makes you mature? Cause it really doesnt. Just shows how immature some of you guys are. And its immature to come to her videos just to judge her. Yes you have you own opinions but is it really nessisary to be a jerk about it? If yall like Haley, its only a few clicks away to listen to her. Grow up. Thank you!

  • she sings this 10x better than orignal!!!!!!!!

  • i love lauren singing this than the original

  • FOR THOSE OF YOU INSULTING LAUREN OR SAYING SHE WASNT UR FAVORITE, all of the contestants were awesome. Thats how they got there. So just please leave Lauren alone. Shes an amazing singer and beautiful.who says Haley isn't amazing too? Who says James isn't awesome? They all are really talented and it doesn't make much of a difference which place they came in, unless of course it was 1st. Pia is successful,she came in 9th. So please just leave every1 alone because it never helps to put any1 down.

  • I will be the first person to buy Lauren's CD.---- I saw her in Chicago--- her voice was the strongest of the bunch

  • coool

    

  • I actually think that Haley, James, Lauren, Casey, and Pia should've been the Top 5. America really screwed over some talented people.

    I would've loved to see Haley vs Lauren/James/Pia for the finale.

    I think Lauren is talented and I will support her after Idol, I just think the uniqueness and talent Haley has, and difficult song choices Haley made surpassed any person on that Idol stage by a mile and a half.

  • All the top comments show that they prefer others -.- What kind of YubTub viewers are you, thumbing up retarded comments!?!?!?

  • she sings great but sam tsui is way better ,thumbs up if u agree !

  • Let’s see, Lauren Alaina has a Top 40 country hit, her new CD is being released next month, and she is currently in Nashville rehearsing with her band. Her fans are supporting her. Haley is currently doing what right now? And what are Haley’s fans doing? They are showing their character. For months on end, they continually make negative comments about a young 16 year old girl’s talent and appearance.

  • she naileddddddddddd this song!

  • This is already one of my favorite songs....with Lauren singing it, I'm BLOWN A W A Y!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! She is SO pretty and has a GREAT voice. Scotty won because of all the girls out there voting for him. well, actually, i take that back. he's OMG awesome and SUCH A GREAT SINGER!!!! I think they both had an equal chance of winning...

  • Say what you want about Lauren but her tone is definitely 100 times more beautiful than the lead singer of The Band Perry

  • i love all american idol contestants except Scotty!

  • @FarewellBlackSwan Erm your Mental As I Typed Before MOST SINGERS Can't Sing That well Live Period! PERIOD! she did Good for what it was, Most Not all but Most Have Sound people!

  • some haliens on these lauren videos are giving haliens a bad name..

  • @allisonraee I love Haley, but I like Lauren too. We can watch the person if we like them and aren't "hating". I think Lauren is amazing as well.

  • Lauren is amazing and so beautiful. Thumbs up if you agree :)

  • Lauren sounds amazing!!! I like this version better than the actual one by far!

  • I love Lauren AND Haley <3

  • Haliens, let's disperse. Let Lauren fans have their time on Lauren's videos, we wouldn't want anyone to be taking attention away from Haley's greatness on Haley's videos either. Let's not give Haley or Haliens a bad name...

    -Fellow Diehard Halien

  • HALEY SUCKS............Nuff said

  • Nothing againist Haley but vote their comments down because the comments should be about Lauren since this is her video.

  • awesome song and voice...

  • @mayclojoe they almost always are on lauren's video. it pisses me off. you would think lauren's fans would maybe be a little more loyal.

  • i lovee this version WAAYY better then the band perry's

  • @mayclojoe Yes and not only the top comments are about Haley!!

  • she is pure country! :)

  • Lauren is a beautiful and talented young woman! She rocked it in Providence, Rhode Island!!!

  • Comment removed

  • @ansonpang20 she sang it beautifully

  • @MCrockitoutxoxo I was gonna send the same response!! She sounds amazing

  • @TumbleSaultXO i know!! and shes 16!

  • @MCrockitoutxoxo i know! its crazyy!

  • @ansonpang20 shut up. she deserved to go this far. get real

  • @ansonpang20 huh, let's see you sing in front of 3,000,000 people. Oh yeah you can only critique.

  • @ansonpang20 then why r u watching her! if u have nothing nice to say then dont say anything at all! LAUREN IS AN AMAZING PERSON AND SINGER LEAVE HER ALONE!

  • @ansonpang20 Are you stupid? She isn't off key. She sounds amazing. Just because she sings a few octaves up or down doesn't mean she's off key. I LOVE YOU LAUREN! <3

  • @ansonpang20 Hmm, if memory serves me right Carrie Underwood--remember her? She had a few off-key moments, and she not only won but has been the most successful idol thus far. So don't feed me with this " Lauren was off-key what kind of runner-up is that" bullshit. If you don't like her, don't watch her videos. Plain and fucking simple. You Lauren haters are a bunch of fucking idiots. You don't HAVE to like her, but shit if you don't....then don't watch her! Christ!

  • @mizzkitty20 lighten up, man. Lauren is awesome, we both know that. But so was Haley, James, Pia, etc....CHILL

  • @ansonpang20 you most likely don't know the first thing about music, but what she does there is a key change which doesn't happen in the original song. it's very difficult so give the girl some credit

  • @ansonpang20 back off.

    

  • @ansonpang20 im sure there have been more than one contestant on ai that has been off key. so what? ppl have their good days and ppl have their bad days. leave her alone. she has a beautiful voice. she made it this far cuz shes clearly got raw talent. so if you dont have anything nice to say, plz dont.

  • @ansonpang20 Why is Rhiannon "more hard" to sing and apart from missing that key change and immediately catching herself where is Lauren off key?

  • @SurrenderValerie thank you for pointing that out im so sick of people complainin bout it

  • she did a good job on this song but i think scotty should have been voted off way before the finals but he won and i dont think he deserved to win sorry scotty lovers hes a good singer, better than me:) but there were better ppl on that show like PIA who should have won

  • I was sad to see Lauren loose but happy to see Scotty win:) But really in my mind they both won<33333

  • @SurrenderValerie haley has very very flat voice when she sings low notes. Lauren will b most famous, take my word

  • vote up if you think lauren and scotty would make a good couple

  • I Like Lauren Voice She's A Very Good Singer But I Honestly Think Haley Shoud've Beenin' In The Top 2 Beside Lauren .

  • I saw Lauren in Chicago. She stole the show--people were crying. She is the next big star.

  • love this song and how she sang it

  • i love this song and this girl! i liked scotty, but really, i think lauren should of won...

  • Comment removed

  • 177 people died young

  • i love her she is amzing singer

  • she would have won if scotty wasnt a boss

  • yeah seriousley i agree with the valerie girl...get over it i like all of the 3 but i like lauren better and scotty isn't an ugly guy... oh and to all of you youtubers out there you should all see haley reinhart singing rollin in the deep by adele:)

  • HQ my ass

  • I love lauren alaina shes so amazing i was so happy to see my fav two scotty an lauren in the top two

  • Aww guys okay i am a HUGE Lauren fan. have been since she first auditioned. But everyone on there was amazing. Yall dont have to be mean to Scotty or Haley. They were all amazing! :) and i hope they all go far

  • haley all the way!

    FucX scotty

  • @Aisoyoyo correction...haley can sing adele but she can do much more than that i mean she has sung country rock and jazzy bluesy songs on american idol she is definitely no simple one genre girl she is unique and original

  • I think the ones that are in the top are the right ones!! Scotty and Lauren are very strong singers. Can you say ADORABLE!!! Seriously!!!

  • One of her best performances <3

  • honestly i dont get why people have to hate on haley. her and lauren both have diffrent styles that works for them. they are both amazing and still have a chance to do what they want

  • not as good as the band perry

  • 174 people are gonna die young...

  • actually, not to be nit-picky @gnarlyincubus but in "after" (i'm a goner) she's just the teensiest bit sharp...but barely. anyways, yeah, she has fabulous pitch.

  • @aeneaisamarshan what the hell are you talking about?

  • @countryboyjbink01 does my comment not make sense to you? do you not understand what "sharp" means? l0l0l

  • @aeneaisamarshan I know, but almost no singer can hit every note perfectly. She did well until she forgot to change keys. That was pretty bad.

  • Haley was a bitch, Scotty is good but Lauren deserved to win .

  • I hate the "Uh oh, Uh oh" part. Not Lauren's fault, but it makes me think the song is like a Tellatubby song. lol

    I wish she would actually try and connect with the lyrics though. She sings "As she buries her baby" and smiles? Try and feel what you are singing about would be my only critique to Lauren.

    And no, @Vulcan422 you obviously don't know much about music, key, and tone. Haley and Lauren are both amazing. Get over it.

  • hi, my name is david.

    i know not many people are going to read this comment,

    but it's worth a try.

    i live for music.

    i've been playing viola since i was tiny, i've been goign to juilliard for 6 years, and i was a contestant on american idol last season, so music is pretty much everything for me.

    i make covers and i would really appreciate it if you check out my covers, commented and subscribed.

    if you would please thumbs up this comment so that more people see it, i would appreciate it :)

  • Wtf... this isnt HQ! lol

  • i like Lauren, but i LOVE HALEY!!!

  • @yingdala DUDE HALEY WAS SOOOOOO MUCH BETTER I LUVED HER TOO!!!!!!!!

  • @wakawaka5491 hate burst your bubble Haley is very overrated!!..Lauren blows Haley out of the water everytime!!!!

  • i love her she is soooooooooo cuite

  • @lyndsiloo12 you are being JEALOUS of Lauren,aren't you?her success and her love humors with Scotty make you MADDDDDDDDD.omg, POOR GIRL!!!!!!!!!!

  • ALAINERs notice: search on Youtube "American Idol Lauren Alaina reaction!!!!! " those are really cool guys

  • She TOTALLY Ruined this song. I hate her. Scotty Is my Favorite Forever

  • I LOVE this song!

  • I think she may sing it better then Perry

  • @LookingAtYouFool and @22kk22kk2 thank you! i will not forget my daughter. it is just so hard to talk about her.

  • i LUV her dress!!

  • [als23100]

    I can't imagine what you're feeling. I hope you have a lot rainbows in your future.

  • i cant beleive they wouldnt let lauren alaina and scotty win this title of america's idol! because they both deserved it both equally

  • i like after 1:30 lol wen the oter ppl sing and then her it sounds really gooood :) if i die bury me in satin lay me down by a bed of roses

  • I just love Lauren's voice! It sounds like she has little bells in it! No matter the show's over and Scotty won, I still like to listen to her, and especially this song! Go Lauren!

  • this is laurens video not haleys

  • my daughter died last month, she was 5 years old. i listen to this song absout ten times day i miss her sooo much!</3 I LOVE YOU SOPHIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @als23100 im so sorry for ur loss:(

  • @mountainblue1000 She took almost no risks, no chances - she was a safe gamer. In comparison to Haley's immensely difficult song choices, as well as the other contestants in the show this year, she falls a little behind. Not saying she's a bad singer, Lauren's amazing. Just pointing out a flaw in your comment

  • sounds GREAT!

  • if haley is SOOO much better than lauren, then why has lauren sold 7,000 more coppies of her EP than Lauren? Why does lauren have 65,000 more followers on twitter than haley? In, my oppinion, haley over stayed her welcome, and lauren deserved runner up waaaaaayyyyyyy moere than haley.

  • @brianok01 Let's learn to make actual sentences... "Then why has lauren sold 7,000 more coppies of her EP than Lauren." Lauren sold more than herself? Lol, your statement right there emphasizes the difference between Lauren's audience/fan-base and Haley's. I'm not even counting the spelling mistakes. My work is cut out for me, I don't even need to argue.

  • @brianok01 im not trying to be rude.. but did you look at the # of views on haley's videos? i like lauren.. but i LOVE haley.. #justsaying

  • @TheBaseballfrek Honestly, youtube doesn't mean much. Lady Gaga's 'Bad Romance' video has like more than 407,000,000 views. Carrie Underwood's 'Before He Cheats' video has almost 25,000,000. but when it comes to album sales, Carrie wins.

  • i'd rather Lauren won. not saying Scotty ain't good but i like her better.

  • hm, a LITTLE off pitch , but still amazing ! (: