Jennifer hudson vs Siobhan magnus

[phuctran107]

SIOBHAN IS SO MUCH BETTER

[sigarantang]

jennifer much better i think.. and jennifer hits C6 in this song..

[errezitow]

siobhan best of the last idol show,,,

[limak24]

Siobhan.. best Idol ever

[FreakingWillow]

meh

[micciloi]

siobhan!!

[gyeislove]

siobhan is way mor better

[LiveToRide137]

Siobhan was way better!!

[oo0o0opss]

jennifer hits several c6's in this song

siobhan sustains a bb5

[oskmenh]

@oo0o0opss you have no idea what your saying, she was far below an c6, she is more powerfull and controlled though.

[oo0o0opss]

@oskmenh actually i do have an idea of what im saying...if u havent watched any live range videos of jen hudson that´s not my problem but that note at 2:17 was a c6 and she did a couple of those more in that performance.

[bjchabzroxy]

i like siobhan's version... she made it her own... however, jennifer's performance was cool too... they're both awesome! :) i just love siobhan though hehe :)

[mommasguy]

wow... awesome!!!!!! i like bought this girl we have fantastic voice... siobhan magnus use a very high scream at the end and jeniffer hudson use a very high note... please don't compare HUDSON to MAGNUS...

[alabamabregan]

You can't really compare them, but Siobhan has a great walk on the stage, that's for sure. I haven't watched idol since Siobhan was voted off. I'll watch the final to see her.

[daredaniel24]

siobhan for me :"D

[yupperoonie]

trying reaaally hard not to sound racist here, but really; it's a little 19 year old white girl versus the 28 year old diva that jennifer is. i prefer siobhan, but jennifer is a lot more experienced, and thus better than her. but just you wait, maybe siobhan will be a superstar like jHud some day. :]

[rocvil]

Jennifer is older than Siobhan, with more experience and she is black! No offense! please. On the contrary, when we flattered an incredible voice, we say it has a voice of blak girl. I love Siobhan!

[mellynumerounoo]

That one note Siobhan did alone put her version heads and tails above Jennifer's...

[IAmUnique678]

uhmm sihobain or however you spell her name, doesn't even come close to jennifer smfh. get real lol

[Devin1488]

@IAmUnique678 ahah wow. sad. siobhan hit notes in that performance that jennifer hudson couldn't hit with a chick munk up her ass running auto tunes. get real loser.

[IAmUnique678]

@Devin1488 lol you're an idiot. sihoniabann could NEVER ever do what jennifer does. Let's see how far she gets..

[Devin1488]

@IAmUnique678 You're right, Siobhan could never eat 3 dozen donuts, get really fat, and start crying in the middle of her performances because she has emotional issues.  She's too busy hitting all the right notes.

[MAL2BASIC]

@Devin1488 When did Jenn cry in the middle of a performance?

[IAmUnique678]

@Devin1488 oh and EVERYONE knows who jennifer is, no one cares about sihobianin

[Sepia1989]

@IAmUnique678 Dude, her name is Siobhan. You're a either a hypocrite or racist for not knowing it. And I think haters like you sure make your Idol Jenifer Hudson proud.

[eduzinhoxvre]

@IAmUnique678 SIOBHAN´S VERSION IS SO MUCH AMAZING, SO MUCH BETTER,,,

black girl SUCK

[ThePianoguy89]

@eduzinhoxvre Her name is not "black girl," her name is Jennifer Hudson and she doesn't suck. She is a great vocalist.

[yeahu96704]

And your point? Two different performances in two completely different settings. Post idol performance of Jennifer Hudson compared to idol performance of Siobhan. The limited format of Idol exposed only a tiny fraction of what Siobhan can do. Anyone who's seen Siobhan do Janis Joplin live knows that she can take improvisation to whole different level.

[EvaneSam]

@yeahu96704 where could I find her Janis Joplin live performance?? I really wanna'see it.