Added: 5 years ago
From: lorelei80
Views: 101,832
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (421)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • LIZZY FROM SHAUN OF THE DEAD, WHAT ARE YOU DOING HERE.

    I swear to God, BBC has all the actors and actresses on stat. Either way, this was a bit confusing, but worth the watch.

  • reverse of secret smile?

  • well written and beautiful! And David Tennant, as always, amazing

  • @gich18nx

    The twist was that we were led to believe that if wanted to leave her but what he actually wanted to end was the uncertainty.

    The whole point was that he loved her deeply all along.

    Watch it again and you'll see. . .

    Don't worry- You're not daft, I'm an English graduate so I'm probably better than most people at spotting these thing.

    x x

  • @ticketyboooo Funny that you think being an English graduate makes you right about this. :D

    As far as I know short films are an artistic medium and therefore can have more than one interpretation. all of those interpretations are not wrong and not one single one is the only right one. (But I have no Art/Film/English degree or anything to back that up.)

    For me the ending means that she wanted to break up, too. I'm not going to explain why this is my interpretation though. ;)

  • 3:30 Hwat?! Doctor who anyone?

  • Clever twist.

    Stringing us along to think that he'd intended to break up only to reveal at the end he'd only wanted to end the uncertainties and not their relationship. He loved her after all.

    Very sweet.

  • @ticketyboooo no, I guess he really want to break up, but then there's a party, his father coming, Julia's mother saying that her father was sick, and everything.. then he just realize that he can't leave her.. but still a clever twist tho.. :)

  • So this is basically the exact opposite of Secret Smile, now Kate Ashfield is the one misunderstanding David Tennant haha

  • omg he sed kaput thts wat he sed wen wilfred was stook in that machine tht killed david tennant :( :<

  • lol

  • 16 Daleks made accounts! XD

    

  • That's absolutely brilliant. . . . I love the look on his face at the end. Definitely didn't see that coming.

  • A shelf that needed putting up for months... it's like it foreshadows Secret Smile :p

  • LOL, Minty.

  • i like his scottish accent. its much sexier then his british one haha

  • And that's why you shouldn't trust a woman...

  • poor guy. never really thought id see david tennant as a pushover

  • Haha GREAT video!!!

  • Haha! Didn't see that ending coming! Hilarious!

  • 6:40 I cried laughing)))

  • "Can we not just have five minutes without you rushing off to save the world?"

    LOL... To have David Tennant saying that to somebody else... XD

    Lovely video, thank you so much for uploading!

  • I love when he hits the spoon and it flies up in the air!!! XD

  • @anonymousartist89 hahahahaha too funny x°°°°D

  • I love it, especially the kork at 1:28 =)

  • Love him, hate his hair like that.

  • honesty i am so confused!! 

  • Will he cook dinner for me? (puppy face)

  • Genius bit of writing.

  • this makes me happy. like, honestly, joyous :)

  • i don't like his hair on this video

  • omg i love his hair,. hes sooo cute

  • should I be angry, annoyed, or happy?

  • WOW. THAT ENDING WAS AWESOME.

  • Oh, poor bloke, what a mess he landed himself in! And he's so young! I have to say, though, I like the longer hair and sideburns better :P

  • Anyone else have a little sniffle when DT said kaput? He said it during TEOT2 :(

    Loved this, hilarious! Kept laughing the whole way through...

  • Oh my god it's Liz, from Shaun of the Dead :)

    Not to mention how brilliant DT is in every freaking thing he does.

  • I thought for a moment it said John Masters played "nigger"...

  • Its over for them coz he wants me :D

    KAPUT! I love it when he says that!

    Wow he is hot when he gets angry <3

    The angry man from the window is from eastenders :D

    ~Tasha ♥

  • Its over for them coz he wants me :D

    KAPUT! I love it when he says that!

    Wow he is hot when he gets angry <3

    ~Tasha ♥

  • Its over for them coz he wants me :D

    KAPUT! I love it when he says that!

    ~Tasha ♥

  • Its over for them coz he wants me :D

    ~Tasha ♥

  • haha 7:13 i think its minty out of eastenders , he looks thinner haha , like this short movie altho i think i like his hair longer xx

  • That was BRILLIANT!!

  • the way he says Kaput is awsome x2

  • LOL he just got played

  • The first time my husband proposed, he made such a mess of it, I thought he was breaking up with me. The first time I saw this, ROFL was not just an abbreviation.

  • I'm guessing it was all an elaborate farce to get him to look stupid infront of all of his friends by dumping him first.

  • We're closed, shut, kaput..... sorry. lol.

  • This would have made a great sitcom on T.V.

  • Oh, his name is Peter Lawrence. If it were Carlisle, this would explain his first break-up.

  • Hahah! Oh, amazing! Wow, you never think about this kind of thing, but it could definitely happen, huh? XD

  • This "kaputt" makes me lol.. :P

  • where are his sideburns!!!!! i miss them :(

  • Ahaaa I laughed so much when Minty off Eastenders came on :P

  • hahahahahahahahahahaha, 'i never actually accepted x'D "

  • Fork!

  • ugh. the short hair is horrible! Maybe if it wasn't for the spiky bits on top, but short all over it might be okay. I never thought i'd see Tennant looking un-sexy.

  • @gothgate Haven't you seen the pics of him with grey hair...?

    Never thought I say this but that was... *shudder*

  • @killerpussy84 No I haven't. Where can I find them? I need to torture myself some more today. :)

  • @gothgate Come on, it's adorable.  I don't know what it is, I guess it's because I'm in the military, I think that pretty much all men look best clean-shaven and with short hair (he can pull off longer hair, though).

  • BRILLIANT ending! Wow!

  • what a twist!

  • When I look at videos that David is in, I find out he's been in a hell of a lot of stuff!!

  • Hehe, thats so ironic

    "Can't you just wait five minutes without you rushing off to save the world?"

    Well, mr Tennant! what the heck do you do?!

    Hey! I have a time machine so at least i can do it in one second. so ha.

    0_0

  • OMG I loved this vid. And I hate to be one of those people but david looks good with short hair.not gay at all.. actually I think he has never looked sexier .

  • whoa...

  • 2:57 "Can we not just have 5 minutes without you running off to save the world?" - That question could so easily be directed at the Doctor

  • wow poor guy i can't imagine the pressure if that was real

    love davids accent too, i turn speechless when i hear it lol

  • poor David <3 Love him to death <3

  • Yep. That is Miranda Cotton in Secret Smile. Have you all noticed that HE dumped her in this but SHE dumped him in secret smile? Lol so cool :P

  • I just love David Tennant. I will miss him as The Doctor ..

  • lmao!! xDDD Poor guy.

  • I love how he puts up shelves for Kate Ashfield when he is trying to dump her, and also right before he gets dumped by her (check out Secret Smile, it's true)!

  • @paigehobo

    RIGHT!! I thought this was almost the complete opposite of what happened in Secret Smile... Wow. But I do like seeing the two of them acting. Dunno why.

  • BACKFIRE! LOL

  • This is great! So cute, I loved it!

    But now that I think about it, this was made before Secret Smile, which had both of them together but it a WAY different story!

  • @Seonu24 Thst's true! When he said "Till death do us part, I was thinking, well he's going to kill her then isn't he!

  • David is sooooooooo cute, and really young in this thing

  • Poor basta'd. This is like a nightmare I had haha!

  • Can somebody tell me what did she (Julia) say at the end?

  • "I know.. I never actually accepted."

  • We Need to Talk.......About the Dishwasher ! :L :L Lol

  • omg hes soo manly ;)

    haahaa we need to talk...about the dishwasher :L

    his voice is sooo sexy!! so used to him with an English accent in doctor who :(

    love him and will miss him in doctor who ):

    Haaa minty off eastenders :P

    Haa keeps talking to himself in the kitchen

    :P miss you davey xx

  • his hair looks weird so short! so used to it being long!

  • ironic - since these two worked together in Secret Smile, and it was her who broke up with him.

  • LOL at the ending! Brilliant film. *u*

  • You mean, he isn't *just* The Doctor.

    Molto bene!

  • hillarious film!

    BTW there's a flying fork in 1:30 LOL

  • this video is the most hilarious backfire ever with guilt trips galore that ended up perfectly!

    also

    oh hello minty!

  • hey that's minty!

  • another good short

  • Isn't that the woman who played Miranda in Secret Smile?

  • yes it is

  • @RachyKinzx yes

  • @RachyKinzx no, it's David Tennant :))))) hahahaha :)))

  • wow, this was better than i thought it would be. He had intended to break up with her and he ended up proposing because she tricked him into a corner so he make an actual decision. I noticed how the only time he wasn't stumbling over his words was when he was alone in the kitchen.

    A really brilliant short film that made me giggle!

  • Oh man, I loved how at the very end, it showed she was having the exact same problem he was ^_^ Man, that's going to make one messed up marriage. Would make an awesome full length comedy film.

  • wtf is this o_o

  • what an odd little film...does that mean he is now trapped in a marriage with a woman he doesn't truly love...hmmm, odd! LOVE DAVID THOUGH <3

  • Apparently dishwashers mean you're gonna get married. O_o

    That was a great look on his face at the end. XD

  • The End was the best^^...at the beginning it was weird and then it turned into a nightmare. But the End was surprising ( why did he change his mind..fear?)and funny,

  • It's really strange, but I like it. Ending is great!

  • what a great short!

  • wtf. that was wierd

    i love david when when he uses his normal voice <3 its sexy

  • OMG I freaking LOVE David, hes so talented making his characters come to life. He's amazing!

  • omg!! That was ... er... different. I love how DT plays his characters... he's such a natural comedic actor. It's a rather clever short actually.

  • That was a great little film. Not really the ending I was expecting!

  • Poor guy, if only he had a time machine, or like a big box that would make it all go away.

  • looooool poor david

  • that was rather odd but i enjoyed it...

  • so were they or weren't they getting married? i guess so

  • wow, what a change from secret smile where she is the wacko and not him.

  • he looks so cute and young in this they both do. Was she not in Secret Smile with him thou?

  • yup

  • that was brilliant!

  • hey superb video...love d guy,,,he is soo cute!!!

  • "Is It me or was DT a Fan of Converse Trainers before he styled the Doctor with them? -just watch when he kicks the Dishwasher 04:40, A Great short film confusing yet sweet and DT and his Accent well...*thud*"

  • I'd read somewhere that he asked to use the converse's with the long coat. they were his suggestions.

    I'm getting converses' just cuz of him. loool

  • LOL, I watched DT's conversation with Parkinson, they talked about The Doctor's Costume, DT said that He and possibly RTD and Steve Moffet got the attire idea from Jamie Oliver who had appeared on Parkinson previously,I would Love a pair of Converse But they look a WHOLE Lot better on DT :):)

  • lol - me too!

  • @emmdm101dm Why not? They're cool in their own right as the original gym shoe.

  • Comment removed

  • HAHA! Minty from Eastenders (X

  • His hair is so bad.

    Good video though. Well written.

  • Oh my god, that man is adorable.

    I love it when her mum is talking to him and you can see he's thinking 'could this get any worse?', so well done. And the ending is genius.

  • at the end the girl wanted to get pay back for him ending it with her so she staged the whole thing

  • i'm so confused at the end..........

  • The guy can't make his mind up about anything, he was so certain that it's over, but at the same time he never came out that they were broken up, because of his horrible communication skills. Throughout the whole party, I guess he changed his mind, or did he. It's a film of uncertainty, and the confusion you're left with at the end is what made the film so good!

    That is at least how I interpreted it, but that's the magic of film.

    One of the best shorts I've seen on Youtube that's for sure!

  • haha, thanks!! it's a good one, but i'm still confused, i just don't get him face expression, like why he did that :D

  • Thank you so much for sharing :D xx

  • I LOVE him and i LOVE this film so funny!!!!!

  • Nice XD

  • He's adorable. But I like his hair when it's longer!

  • totally agree with you :)

  • Woah... Wait a Second.

    Is that Kate Ashfield???

    Dude... O.O

    I just watched them in Secret Smile...

    That strange... He was with Kate in two films and he was with that chick from Recovery in two films... hm...

  • I love this short film! It's brilliant! But can someone tell me what they're saying at 0:42-0:50 between 'It's needed a putting up for months.' and 'I'm just knackered!'. I just can't seem to get it.

  • @Neyah444 "I didn't mean to upset you." "No. I had a near-fatal epileptic fit this morning, two coronaries, and a stroke. I'm just knackered." The dialogue is very witty because they never tell you that she is a nurse/doctor (hahadoctor) but clearly she must be because she would not be at home if she had had a fit, coronary, or stroke.

  • he does like the word "kaputt", does he? ^^

  • omg,is there more than that??is it a film??

  • yes, it's a film. a short film ;)

  • lol. that's evil!

  • So sweet! Love David Tennant!

  • ha! brilliant!

  • His face when she says 'I never actually never accepted', trying to figure out what she means right at the end, is priceless!!

  • That was marvelous! I genuinely never knew where it was going, which almost never happens. Great moment at the end

  • He said Kaput in this as well just saw an episode of Doctor Who where I noticed it... is that a word you usually use in english????

  • yeah, I love using that word

  • No, not really, it's probably something that David likes to say.

  • I personally don't use it all that often...can't remember the last time. But, yeah, we use lots of borrowed words in English.

  • That was a random little clip... enjoyable but random XP

    David and Kate actually look real cute together. They can really work well along side each other too =D

  • Bahahahah, David Tennant's one of my favorite actors. I love all the little indie films he does. This one's super cute.

  • lol. great

  • i found it really quite confusing

    but tennant is an amazing actor (Y)

  • Wow. I thought for sure he didn't like her. Great ending.

  • Hahah his face when the mum is like, "He's rather ill... With cancer." is bloody priceless! "Oh, God."

  • Great twist at the end! And Tennant was as wonderful as ever...

  • its minty out of eastenders! :L

  • This always makes me laugh out loud! It's great... I love his face when she tells them on the phone that he's proposed!!! It's brilliant! :-)

  • it was funny at the end haha it was good. but if you want to see a realy good short film search this: 10 minutes by Ahmed Imamovic

  • i loved these two in the radio play THE ISLAND also BRILLIANT

  • great video

    i lv David Tennant ..LOL

  • David Tennant and Kate Ashfield have also starred in Secret Smile together, where they have a very different relationship...

    Thanks for uploading!

  • Wow... awesome punchline at the end!

  • is that realy him???!!!!!

  • good ending

  • i could listen to him talk forever.

  • HELL YEH!!

    love the Scottish-ness! xoxoxoxoxox

  • ha ha fail.

  • ooh, look - minty from eastenders!

  • 'Can we just have five minutes together without you rushing off to save the world'. How ironic, it sounds like something someone would say to the doctor...

  • I know! It's like an inside joke now... ^_^

  • I knew it!

    The moment you got the dishwasher!

  • arggggg... that was really painful to watch! i cant stand thinking people are in misunderstood situations!! arg! especially david tennant!

  • That was so adorable!

  • Lmfao!

    Ahaha loved the ending XD