I have seen this for the first time about 5 years ago on (believe it or not!) MTV and it was the first time I was confronted by the music of Zappa. First I thought he did just some funny music but then I also discovered his other work and... I would be fucked today without it. Thanks Frank and thank you Mr. Cebix for the upload!
People! Buy the "Does Humor Belong In Music DVD" . Bobby brown, Keep it greasy, dancin' fool, and a cool rendition of Whipping Post... and others. This live dvd is awesome.
@tehdank19 You're right and that is also not what I said. I said that FZ 'almost automically' connects homosexuality with 'perverse sex'. Why not make a song with 'He's so straight' and than only sum up perversions in connection with straight people? Those people also exist, why not make a song about them (and don't tell me he already did that with 'Brown shoes' or 'Dirty Love' or 'Dinah Moe Hum'...
Another example: Bobby Brown, homosexuality and of course a golden shower... ;-) cliché
@brabon1 No, I don't get your interpretation of FZs work: FZ was always against 'overindulging'? What is wrong with a little hedonism according to FZ?
FZ is at his best when he shows the hypocrisy of men. But nowadays in civilized countries homosexuality is accepted. Not because FZ treated it as some sort of sex that is into 'perversions' like s&m, golden showers, anal sex and so on.
FZ helped in matters of free speech, but didn't help the gay community by summing up these 'perversions'.
@brabon1 He's so gay is NOT about hiding who you are; and so isn't Bobby Brown. The latter is maybe about not knowing who you are, but that is something else.
I think FZ is hilarious when he sings about sexual perversions, whether it is connected with straight or gay men or women. I guess it was very important to show conservative people that things like that existed. But you will have to admit that his view is outdated. Gay is not something that you become...
@brabon1 okay, if that is true, bobby brown again is about homosexuality in connection with perversions (just like always in FZs narrow view on homosexuality)
and what about He's so Gay?
"spanking, golden rain, into rubber every night, eat a little chain..."
"You could be just like him tomorrow?"
That is a republicans view on homosexuality!
Xenophobia? Homosexuality is contagious?
Towards homosexuality FZ was also very conservative!
@brabon1 So another connection of homosexuality and perversion? He PRETENDS not to be gay, so he goes out 'date raping'. So that is what gay people do when they pretend not to be gay?
And when they are gay, they like 'rubber, golden showers, spanking'. And what is worse! It is contagious!
Because you can be GAY just like HIM tomorrow. LOL
For FZ homosexuality is not about love between 2 people of the same sex, but about acting out perversions
this song was really controversial to gay people simply because he was making fun of gays. why can't they simply learn to take a joke? i think this song's hilarious.
@mnipgailid I don't have to read up on FZ, since I know his work quite well. And the fact that I enjoy it, doesn't make me uncritical about this aspect of his work. I like the way he attacks the mainstream, but the way he sings about homosexuality... well, it is just summing up all prejudices. And yes: perversions are funny! But it is also cliche to connect them automatically with the gay community.
Homosexuality brings up the Republican in Zappa! :-) LOL
"Writing in the Guardian Adam Sweeting declared that in his lifetime Zappa 'railed against America's corporate complacency and political lurch to the right and deplored racism and homophobia'"
I'm not the only one. You need to look a bit deeper.
@mnipgailid. But that doesn't contradict my view (although I don't think Sweeting is very accurate on this point). In his songs FZ connects homosexuality almost automatically with 'perversions' like anal sex, s&m, golden showers and so on (and not only in this song!). That is cliche and a prejudice. I'm not at all convinced that helped the emancipation of the gay community. But funny it is
Of course FZ is all about free speech and so on, but his view on homosexuality is typical of the eighties.
If you're serious then go shove something up your arse! Frank is one of the best musicians of all time and you imply that he did all of the music, and that is wrong too
He's so gay He's so gay He's very very gay He's so gay He's so gay And he likes to be that way With his keys all on the right He's into rubber every night He's so gay He's so gay He's ALMOST EVERYONE TODAY
i just started getting into zappa, cause of my dad haha. bobby martin is too good in this song. If you want more bobby martin check out zappa does zappa don't eat the yellow snow
Is that Mr. Vinnie C on drums? This song is hilarious, especially when Frank Points at da bass player saying that he's gay and the bass player just shakes his head frantically.
4 part harmony in perfect unison while having fun on stage, another Zappa trademark. Kinda like 'lil Stevie Vai playing the hardest music ever written....while dancing. LLOL.
this song is too good
glasgowdmon 1 year ago
Legend
AmberLily7 1 year ago
(^з^)-☆Chu!!
FLADgE666 1 year ago
I cry with laughter whenever I hear this song! But he's got a great point, "He's so gay and he likes to be that way".
Django5198 1 year ago
He was so great! :-)
theexkgb 1 year ago
I think his other theme song is "Keep it Greasy" ... another FZ song.
videocanone 1 year ago
It's the Barney Frank theme song !
videocanone 1 year ago
@videocanone did barney franks call service have to be privatized too?
'cuz his business was going down?
vintagevic1 1 year ago
jajajajaj que grande el del saxo que grita xD me mueroooo
negosiandogasolina 1 year ago
i was at this show in it was great to see him outdoors in nyc a great show hate alan zavod
jackdelawack 1 year ago
The late great equal opportunity insulter. Great show! LOL
louiseduvee 1 year ago
Zappa is thje man!!!!
octoface4 1 year ago
I'm gonna send this song to so many people and tell them it made me think of them. :)
ThePinkBinks 1 year ago
He is so gay he is cowboy for a day, cool !
Is this song about bobby brown ?
MarioHerofull 1 year ago
immenso zappa.....
champalou 1 year ago 2
Cool song but is a joke jajajaja
MarioHerofull 1 year ago 2
the song is about bobby brown
younghippo 1 year ago
Seen many concerts with Frankie. Noone can ever compete with his intelligence, humor or concern for humanity. R I P
shirleyz29 1 year ago
lol
ioxDful 1 year ago
even before andy dick knew it, frank zappa knew andy dick was gay :)
junoprojekt 1 year ago
All wearing shorts or sweat pants.
"Let's skate awaaaaaay"
foutupourfoutu 1 year ago
izvrsno, i to već tad, ranih sedamdesetih...amerika...
striker11114 1 year ago
Scott Thunes was a phenomenal bass player - an unparalleled ability to screw around on stage but somehow never miss a note.
pfalconer 1 year ago 5
Hilarious
TCELL24 1 year ago
@LuneyTune72
bassist: scott thunes
keys: alan zavod
keys/vocals/sax: bobby martin
aapje1988 1 year ago
This is Frank's best back up band. What's the name of the bassist and keyboard player?
LuneyTune72 1 year ago
That keyboardist is some seriously epic win, gotta miss Frank Zappa.
Tapeworm121 1 year ago 3
@Tapeworm121 dont dare call bobby martin that keyboardist :)
BigKahuna93 1 year ago
0:14 xd
bramthart 1 year ago
I love this song so much.
Chakan 1 year ago
"He's just a cowboy for a day..." Hahahahaha...
Nacho66 2 years ago 2
lol
bramthart 2 years ago
Hes so gay
boredman1992 2 years ago
Fuckin Frank Zappa dude.. Righteous
craiclord 2 years ago 2
lol i played this song at a funeral
BigHashTouraj 2 years ago 46
@BigHashTouraj at a funeral...thats fucking hilarious
bradg203 1 year ago
Great song....
0ut3rhe4ven 2 years ago
I have seen this for the first time about 5 years ago on (believe it or not!) MTV and it was the first time I was confronted by the music of Zappa. First I thought he did just some funny music but then I also discovered his other work and... I would be fucked today without it. Thanks Frank and thank you Mr. Cebix for the upload!
namelessguy93 2 years ago
It's Bobby Martin there playing the keys and the gay, right? ;) Wasn't he the sax player before? Gotta google that up...^^
KenranThePanda 2 years ago
ROFL man!
Ouroboros010110 2 years ago
That was the good old time. Today the fucking political correctess doen't allow us to carck some jokes about faggots.
Good job FZ.
FB1801 2 years ago 4
hahahahahah!! Fucking Hell, Bobby Martin is awesome!
gerardbass1989 2 years ago 5
Are you aware of the irony in your post?
russythejack 2 years ago
@gerardbass1989 He's not awesome in this video. He's *fabulous*.
slacknhash 2 years ago
Hahahaha Rofl
Ouroboros010110 2 years ago
Now thats a song.
fretzombie 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Bad imitation of village people. Mala imitacion de village people..
xboxbattle 2 years ago
this is fucking wonderful
meepshizzleyams 2 years ago
BRILLIANT!!!
vincentpricesnephew 2 years ago 2
extra.franck is the best.
christominator 2 years ago
hahaha the keyboard guy
PrinceLonghair 2 years ago
BRILLIANT!
33peteb 2 years ago 2
this is amazing and the keyboard player is hilarious
piledriver89 2 years ago 2
bobby rules
aakkoin 2 years ago
People! Buy the "Does Humor Belong In Music DVD" . Bobby brown, Keep it greasy, dancin' fool, and a cool rendition of Whipping Post... and others. This live dvd is awesome.
harplaya 2 years ago 3
Yeah I have seen the dvd, Cool work! Fits the title! =)
mito0101 2 years ago
i think its safe to say LMFAO!!!!!!
ImSpiFF 2 years ago 2
The bass could be a little louder.
Apjooz 2 years ago
2:10 ahahahahahahahah
gianlutoro 2 years ago
Comment removed
gianlutoro 2 years ago
What in the world is the keyboardists name?
TSHNOFX 2 years ago
I think it's Ian Underwood.
cowartm 2 years ago
The one singing high? That's Bobby Martin. The other keyboardist is Alan Zvod.
intuantu 2 years ago 2
Bobby Martin
harplaya 2 years ago
haha i remember 2008 new year me and my friends were pissing ourselfs laughing at this video
HCadrenaline 2 years ago
I love Bobby the keyboard guy... not like that.
aakkoin 2 years ago 25
hahahahahhhaha
donskateboardsyo 2 years ago 3
LMAO!!
zitozentinel 2 years ago 2
great show and music! Italian Zappa's proud!!
FedeContrabbassista 2 years ago
The keyboard player is funny as balls!!!!!
theslutbitch 2 years ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
I wonder how many people younger than 50 even know who this douchebag is.
fnchrstphr 2 years ago
"Let's mine the harbour"
Reinisen 2 years ago 6
@tehdank19 You're right and that is also not what I said. I said that FZ 'almost automically' connects homosexuality with 'perverse sex'. Why not make a song with 'He's so straight' and than only sum up perversions in connection with straight people? Those people also exist, why not make a song about them (and don't tell me he already did that with 'Brown shoes' or 'Dirty Love' or 'Dinah Moe Hum'...
Another example: Bobby Brown, homosexuality and of course a golden shower... ;-) cliché
annedegro 2 years ago
or maybe he is just making fun of those that rejoice in the cliche's
bobby brown is about the facade of the supposed great heterosexual
frank was a god
brabon1 2 years ago
@brabon1 Well, normally the humour of FZ is quite straightforward.
And only after Bobby Brown 'turns' gay (another prejudice) he gets his golden shower (of course after the s&,)...
FZ a god? Yes, that is the problem: people that consider persons as being a god, tend to be uncritical about what they say.
annedegro 2 years ago
you really dont get frank...do you?
its not about being gay or straight...its hiding who you are and then overindulging
or going out of your way to show who you are...by overindulging
frank was always against overindulging
and why dont you take a look at the behaviour of men who pretend they are straight and then cruise public bathrooms looking for sex
that is what frank is commenting on
brabon1 2 years ago
@brabon1 No, I don't get your interpretation of FZs work: FZ was always against 'overindulging'? What is wrong with a little hedonism according to FZ?
FZ is at his best when he shows the hypocrisy of men. But nowadays in civilized countries homosexuality is accepted. Not because FZ treated it as some sort of sex that is into 'perversions' like s&m, golden showers, anal sex and so on.
FZ helped in matters of free speech, but didn't help the gay community by summing up these 'perversions'.
annedegro 2 years ago
@brabon1 He's so gay is NOT about hiding who you are; and so isn't Bobby Brown. The latter is maybe about not knowing who you are, but that is something else.
I think FZ is hilarious when he sings about sexual perversions, whether it is connected with straight or gay men or women. I guess it was very important to show conservative people that things like that existed. But you will have to admit that his view is outdated. Gay is not something that you become...
annedegro 2 years ago
bobby brown is not about a guy who becomes gay...he always was gay...but hid it with the facade of machismo and date rape
hes so gay is about those who feel the need to wear their sexuality on their sleeves...no need for anyone, straight or gay to do that
for all his liberalism, frank was very conservative when it came to relationships
brabon1 2 years ago 2
@brabon1 okay, if that is true, bobby brown again is about homosexuality in connection with perversions (just like always in FZs narrow view on homosexuality)
and what about He's so Gay?
"spanking, golden rain, into rubber every night, eat a little chain..."
"You could be just like him tomorrow?"
That is a republicans view on homosexuality!
Xenophobia? Homosexuality is contagious?
Towards homosexuality FZ was also very conservative!
annedegro 2 years ago
funny, when bobby brown pretends to be straight, he is out date raping....but you dont see that as a perversion
brabon1 2 years ago
@brabon1 Why wouldn't I see that as a perversion?
annedegro 2 years ago
@brabon1 So another connection of homosexuality and perversion? He PRETENDS not to be gay, so he goes out 'date raping'. So that is what gay people do when they pretend not to be gay?
And when they are gay, they like 'rubber, golden showers, spanking'. And what is worse! It is contagious!
Because you can be GAY just like HIM tomorrow. LOL
For FZ homosexuality is not about love between 2 people of the same sex, but about acting out perversions
That is a republicans view on homosexuality.
annedegro 2 years ago 3
ok....frank thought that all gays are filthy perverts...feel better now?
brabon1 2 years ago
@brabon1 No, I don't think that was what he thought, but it was what he expressed in his songs.
But if you can find a song/lyric that proofs I'm wrong, I'd be happy to hear it! ;-)
annedegro 2 years ago
this song was really controversial to gay people simply because he was making fun of gays. why can't they simply learn to take a joke? i think this song's hilarious.
MoniqueM11 2 years ago
homophobia; a cliche video with all prejudices against homosexual men
annedegro 2 years ago
Read up on Frank and you'll realize just how ignorant that statement is. He was a champion of free speech and civil liberties.
mnipgailid 2 years ago
@mnipgailid I don't have to read up on FZ, since I know his work quite well. And the fact that I enjoy it, doesn't make me uncritical about this aspect of his work. I like the way he attacks the mainstream, but the way he sings about homosexuality... well, it is just summing up all prejudices. And yes: perversions are funny! But it is also cliche to connect them automatically with the gay community.
Homosexuality brings up the Republican in Zappa! :-) LOL
annedegro 2 years ago
"Writing in the Guardian Adam Sweeting declared that in his lifetime Zappa 'railed against America's corporate complacency and political lurch to the right and deplored racism and homophobia'"
I'm not the only one. You need to look a bit deeper.
mnipgailid 2 years ago
@mnipgailid. But that doesn't contradict my view (although I don't think Sweeting is very accurate on this point). In his songs FZ connects homosexuality almost automatically with 'perversions' like anal sex, s&m, golden showers and so on (and not only in this song!). That is cliche and a prejudice. I'm not at all convinced that helped the emancipation of the gay community. But funny it is
Of course FZ is all about free speech and so on, but his view on homosexuality is typical of the eighties.
annedegro 2 years ago
This is so Great!!!
pigletized 2 years ago
What a genius... Damn god...
mariano141189 2 years ago
Zappa is Rafi for "adults".
logosfails 2 years ago
hes evening's not complete
without some meat
in the seat
aakkoin 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Clay Aiken, Adam Lambert, the Jonas Brothers. All them niggas is gay. Brokeback Mountain gay.
rbermea 2 years ago
herrMaria: :D Great Shit!
Ouroboros010110 2 years ago 2
Suck on this!:D
Ouroboros010110 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this is so awesome. :DDD
herrMaria 2 years ago 4
I'm assuming the keyboardist is gay
3dpaper 2 years ago
Man, your gaydar is messed up.
He's married.
To a non-male.
RossMedia2007 2 years ago 2
no one will ever take you serious after this.
ridingtheplastic 2 years ago
I think the guy who gave you a thumbs down didn't know this was a Zappa quote... Oh well. I got it.
PsychoticCat723 2 years ago
in this business you either gotta play the blues, or sing with a high voice
ridingtheplastic 2 years ago 6
You're right, I never should have joined the mothers... why I could be a star now!
PsychoticCat723 2 years ago 3
estoy de acuerdo que es cómico cuando zappa apunta a scott thunes y le dice que es gay, y lo niega, aparte de lo del calzon que esta de poca
danyelpollo100892 2 years ago
classic. makes me want to dig out the dvd!
zzbin 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I now remembered how much I despise this clown and his 'humorous' records. Zappa is the most over-rated musician of all time.
faliklunj 2 years ago
nobody is forcing you to listen to it m8
iouakick 2 years ago
Comment removed
kaosk90 2 years ago
Maybe I will turn out to be a 'genius' then, you putrid, festering bile sore.
faliklunj 2 years ago
If you're serious then go shove something up your arse! Frank is one of the best musicians of all time and you imply that he did all of the music, and that is wrong too
Argug1 2 years ago
... but so funny!
Sirvanta 2 years ago
So gay...
kaosk90 2 years ago
1:02 ... no comments...LMAO
zaggy1234567899 2 years ago
rotfl
pedrowup 2 years ago
I love how Frank just points to the bass player and declares him gay and he frantically tries to deny it.
youvebeenthunderstru 2 years ago
Comment removed
Tapeworm121 2 years ago
FreakOutG4 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i bet they had sex with each other after the concert.. hilarious song though..
chingchongbobloblaw 2 years ago
Oh God, I adore this concert performance.
RockoMyler 2 years ago 2
perfect.
christominator 2 years ago 2
Gotta love Bobby Martin.
Ncjpr1993 2 years ago
Jesse's song
Jomoufy 2 years ago 2
HE'S SO GAY!
lol'd
sent to my friends XD
dashcsn 2 years ago 2
was this taken off youtube before? i remember looking it up earlier before the date on the vid, and no results. Meh w/e its here now all that matters
PurplePlayer99 2 years ago 6
i just started getting into zappa, cause of my dad haha. bobby martin is too good in this song. If you want more bobby martin check out zappa does zappa don't eat the yellow snow
ZigZaggn 2 years ago
Zappa Plays Zappa, band of his son, Dweezil.
nhonho23 2 years ago
man, Bobby Martin is too good at that shit HAHA
johnnymagic10 2 years ago
thanks bro
DeathRiderHDG 2 years ago
¿porqué?
madridimo 2 years ago
who's the guy saying "He's so gay" in the girly voice?
DeathRiderHDG 2 years ago
It's the Keyboardist.
LordMorbid5 2 years ago
i know that but the name of the guy
DeathRiderHDG 2 years ago
Bobby Martin
madridimo 2 years ago
thank you very much, i've been waiting months for that answer. thanks again
DeathRiderHDG 2 years ago
If you like Bobby Martin here, make sure to check out his insanely good singing on Zappa's cover of "Whipping Post": watch?v=qM4xAYDumuk
badger500 2 years ago
Comment removed
DeathRiderHDG 2 years ago
just saw the whipping post video. fucking amazing
DeathRiderHDG 2 years ago
thats so wrong O_O
guyver93 2 years ago
I love this song :D
Do you have The Dangerous Kitchen from the same show, too? If so, could you upload it, please?
muzgol 2 years ago
Sorry, it's the only song.
cebix 2 years ago
thanks for putting this back up
DeathRiderHDG 2 years ago 2
you'll never get bored watching this live... LOL that was so funny
jonvistal 2 years ago 4
Is that Mr. Vinnie C on drums? This song is hilarious, especially when Frank Points at da bass player saying that he's gay and the bass player just shakes his head frantically.
ImSpiFF 2 years ago
Please don't look the other way
Shinmeiryu 2 years ago
4 part harmony in perfect unison while having fun on stage, another Zappa trademark. Kinda like 'lil Stevie Vai playing the hardest music ever written....while dancing. LLOL.
4JayeP 2 years ago
Stevie Vai, what an attention craving look at me play my guitar hack, f*** him
bauhausera 2 years ago 2
if i could play guitar like this id be an attention craving guitar hack too.
tehf00n 2 years ago
jealousy becomes you ;) lol
pfalky2k 2 years ago
I like the live version of this song better than the recorded version. My favorite part is the end of the song.
cyorgan 2 years ago
Fantastic <3
freak7koRn 2 years ago
this guy mastered so many different geners it's stupid....rock...jazz...doo wop...classical etc etc GENIUS !!
renduke 2 years ago 2
classic this and catholic girls are just classic
poodle720 2 years ago
+100000000
Decimator7 2 years ago
YES YES FINNALY I love this song lol
spleegulence 2 years ago
goin to see dream theater and zappa plays zappa in august cant wait.
RoSeMaN13 2 years ago
Isn't "Frank Zappa"?
Anyway, I like this song! xD
chicolink666 2 years ago
Holy shit, never saw that mistake. Fixed now, thanks.
cebix 2 years ago
Pure Genious :')..
kroepoekislekker 2 years ago
love this zappa song thanks for posting
zenhenswain 2 years ago