@yellowcluster I think you misundertood because I misexplained either... I didn't say I don't like the music because I do and It's one of my favourites of them. BUT It could be stronger as an interlude and not an epilogue and IT'S MY OPINION as a fan. For you is the best closer and it's YOUR OPINION so let's just repect eachother opinions, ok?
The most wonderful thing just happened to me. I was out on my balcony smoking a joint after getting home form work, when the wind picked up and blew all the seeds from the fireweed (think little wisps of cotton) and blew them upwards in a perfect spiral before sending them all drifting melancholic-ly past me. Sometimes I forget why I'm alive, and sometimes I remember :)
Holy crap this song stirred emotions in me I thought not possible...yet again PT has influenced my soul with the savory beauty I have come to expect from them....thanks for the post.
It's ok, bit dull though. I prefer their more energetic songs, this is a bit too monotonous for me. Plus I've had my fill of depressing music after spending most of my life listening to it.
i came home from work and my wife was upset and told me my 25 yr old cousin just died. i sat down and heard this song playing and it made sence. he's singing about letting someone go.
@Bverygood1 more than the half of this world are stuck up, they think they are better than us because they listen to rap and pop. They think listening to music about guns and murder, about being whores and sluts is better than PP, tool, Opeth, ect. and the other half are justin beiber/miley cirus fans. we are that 1% that no one cares about. we are the ones who truely appreciate music.
@Opethfullcovers Don't say that the people who listen this type of music are the only people that appreciate music. That is simply an ignorant statement. There is actually a large amount of hip-hop and rap that means so much more than just guns,murder, and sluts that you could never be able to appreciate because of your close mindedness. Don't dis a genre of music because the mainstream version of it sucks. That's like comparing PT to the Jonas Brothers.
@quigequige it's funny because i've been saying the same thing to you people for a long time. Before you speak to me again learn proper english. Hip-hop is not the same thing as Rap, I hate rap, but I like hip-hop, listen to "black moon - Gotch'a Open." that is REAL hip-hop. By the way, I wasn't refering to Rap as sluts, I was refering to pop when I said that. I will give you an example, Kesha - Teenage dream. I think that's the auther anyways. I have more of an open mind than you can imagine.
@Opethfullcovers They're essentially the same thing if you're categorizing. Don't think just because you like one song that it's suddenly more "real" than what any other artist can conceptualize; you're being extremely pretentious and elitist in that fashion. Just listen to the music and acknowledge that your mere opinion on it does not classify it as internationally good or bad. Concluding, your grammar and language are next to basic, so stop using that as a base for your argument.
I can barely write this comment, this song is so serene, beautiful in its simplicity. everything is perfect. Now I'm off to sleep, I can't really help it...
@onelastkissx5 This band should be known throughout the world
I feel that if the world knew of them, they would blow away any mainstream cookie cutter band and probably why they are blackballed by the industry. Steven Wilson will let NO record company produce or engineer his music. He does this all himself and is one main reason his music does not get airplay
@howdyfeller oh yeah for sure. But, damn. I didn't know all that. Not letting any record company produce his music just made me like him/them even more.
@onelastkissx5 Steven has his own production studio where he oversees all editing and mixing. Even the DVD's PT has put out are all engineered by Steven and those very close to him. Look up some of his interviews, he is very vocal about his view of mainstream. You should see the band live, they will blow your mind
This song = pain when it hits as close to home as it does. Beautiful song and I love it, but I look forward to the day when I can sit and listen to the whole thing with a dry eye. Anyone who has ever been through what this song describes knows what I mean.
@musli4brekkies It's actually in 6/8. It's just that it's a 5 bar pattern instead of the conventional 4 bar pattern.
PS: 3/10 doesn't exist. There are no 10th notes. There's quarter notes 8th notes, 16 notes, 32nd notes and so on but there's no note that equals a tenth of a bar.
My grandfather died last christmas, I loved him like the father I never had. It was really hard for me to accept that he was gone forever.
I can't avoid crying everytime I listen to this song, because it brings me back beautiful childhood memories and reminds me how much I used to love my dear grandpa.
I have always loved that if you listen close enough during the fading end, you can hear Steven's foot (probably bare) releasing the piano's sustain pedal. How is that for raw emotion?
Is it strange this song doesn't seem sad to me? It seems like hope. It's like the break down of everything at present to make room for better things. Either way it's an amazing song :) gotta love PT for making amazing songs all the time!
@sw15god so sorry for that.. he will live forever in your heart.. music is such a great help in times like that. Rest in Peace from germany, live like your brother would do it man.
@MyEggIsBoiled if no word can describe it, then why did you say that the song is bliss? i don't mean to be a jerk, just noticing a discrepancy in your comment. i agree completely with the first sentence.
my mates only just put me on to this band. I have to say they are cool as fuck.
mattlou1987 5 days ago
LOL I just spent ages trying to find this song by searching "pineapple tree".
Jinmane 1 week ago 5
@Jinmane And Porcupine Thief?
MrLosfuegos 4 days ago
I hope I hear this song when I die. Then I would go peacefully.
BelligerentPapayas 3 weeks ago
My sister love porcupine tree.. This is what I feel " I won't feel better in the cold light of day, But I wouldn't stop you if you wanted to stay"
Albalandia 1 month ago
Exquisite, simply beautiful
DemonsToSome1987 1 month ago
Chills up and down my entire back and neck. Every. Single. Time.
anyal1987 2 months ago
its very warming this song is
daxrunzyou 2 months ago
Steven Wilson is a master poet. When he belts it the last 90 seconds, he rips out both of our hearts. This is such a hauntingly, beautiful piece.
SequinedTears 2 months ago in playlist Favorite videos
Words cannot describe the magnificence of this song.
nicolasmarulanda 3 months ago 3
Is it any wonder In Absentia is their best-selling album?
uchihaitachi888 3 months ago
@uchihaitachi888 It's "one of the wonders of the world" :)
Gekko12482 1 month ago
amazing
Posthuman2003 3 months ago
ok put this song on and try putting your mind to something that you cant normally do. it motivates you like no other! xD
mindlessled 4 months ago
the only song that i have not said a word after for about 2 hours.
UltimateBadAssesUBA 4 months ago 2
This song is one of the most beautiful, there are incredible things in my head when I listen to it.
OLKA04 4 months ago 2
Best PT song
vikas400 4 months ago
i love porcupine tree
YOYO1991ism 5 months ago
I used to cry whenever I heard this song which is very odd for me. Im not a big crier.
trekkie1fan 5 months ago in playlist In My Life...
@trekkie1fan wah
gumbyonacid 4 months ago
i have never listened to an album that finishes as well as in absentia... strip the soul followed by this... brilliant
joverboss 5 months ago
it makes me wanna cry..it's to..oh i have no words..♥
XxKaramellMonsterxX 5 months ago
@yellowcluster I think you misundertood because I misexplained either... I didn't say I don't like the music because I do and It's one of my favourites of them. BUT It could be stronger as an interlude and not an epilogue and IT'S MY OPINION as a fan. For you is the best closer and it's YOUR OPINION so let's just repect eachother opinions, ok?
barcigian 5 months ago
Great! There are no other words to discribe this song.
TheDrumLuke 5 months ago
Amazing ! need i say more!
TwistedWillows 5 months ago
The most wonderful thing just happened to me. I was out on my balcony smoking a joint after getting home form work, when the wind picked up and blew all the seeds from the fireweed (think little wisps of cotton) and blew them upwards in a perfect spiral before sending them all drifting melancholic-ly past me. Sometimes I forget why I'm alive, and sometimes I remember :)
SomeoneLovesMango 6 months ago 4
best song ever
MetalOmgz 6 months ago
Look up "while the city sleeps-back when we knew", similar soundscapes and big crescendos.
KoiChannel 6 months ago
I feel like Peter Griffin listening to My Morning Jacket
TalkingBurrito 6 months ago
It's a breathtaking song for sure... But not to close an album!
barcigian 6 months ago
Holy shit. I got the chills.
jadeeverestmusic 7 months ago 2
This is such a deep dark album. It's almost depressing
JohnnyMastro 7 months ago
sorry about my english first of all,can some1 explain in simple words what thins songs means?i couldn't find the translation in my language,thank you
biancabrancato 7 months ago
<3
MrColonela 7 months ago
Gorgeous song
whatsername7GD 7 months ago
any other kinda songs like this out there?
revolutioN1005 7 months ago 2
a little simpler but, The Eels - Fresh Feeling. Or Sufjan Stevens - Chicago.
ktmurphy16 6 months ago 2
3 people need their skulls collapsed into earth.
jamesannucci 7 months ago
@jamesannucci lmfaooo
JohnPetrucci251 7 months ago
There can be nothing better than such a relaxing song..
Porcupine Tree is immortal.
zork14010 7 months ago
If you don't get goosebumps when you hear this song,you don't have a pulse.
runnermjr1296 8 months ago
Absolutamente preciosa...
CensuredLovesGuitar 8 months ago
3 people dont like this song, WTF???
rbferty 8 months ago
Joint favourite PT song alongside Half-Light
mookie427 8 months ago in playlist Various musics
I'm so baked right now and this song is amazing.
Alb20century 9 months ago 29
amazing song :O
zeppelin88ab 9 months ago
this is amazing.. just fucking amazing
PhilM284 9 months ago
I love piano music and this one is a good song.
juneshopper 1 year ago
i love how porcupine tree is so chill and can jump to the opposite end of the spectrum and be completely hardcore at the same time.
hailey1177 1 year ago
@hailey1177 word... like in Arriving Somewhere But Not Here, there's a hard part and then absolute and quiet bliss.. (:
blastedburrito110 8 months ago
Holy crap this song stirred emotions in me I thought not possible...yet again PT has influenced my soul with the savory beauty I have come to expect from them....thanks for the post.
Splatasmagore 1 year ago
It's ok, bit dull though. I prefer their more energetic songs, this is a bit too monotonous for me. Plus I've had my fill of depressing music after spending most of my life listening to it.
Restayvien 1 year ago
i came home from work and my wife was upset and told me my 25 yr old cousin just died. i sat down and heard this song playing and it made sence. he's singing about letting someone go.
TheBobv 1 year ago
4:59 beautiful
cermisan 1 year ago
My fave song by them =]
ILikeTheRain123 1 year ago
An orgasm in musical form
Nauticus89 1 year ago 23
@Nauticus89 we call it an eargasm
bilibiliboulou 3 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
from 2:59 my unconventional but very beautiful wedding march song! :)
BlazeContara 1 year ago
Comment removed
BlazeContara 1 year ago
Some people don,t like this ,can you beliefe that.
Bverygood1 1 year ago
@Bverygood1 NO. I cannot believe that. like WTF.
DarthBane93 1 year ago
@Bverygood1 more than the half of this world are stuck up, they think they are better than us because they listen to rap and pop. They think listening to music about guns and murder, about being whores and sluts is better than PP, tool, Opeth, ect. and the other half are justin beiber/miley cirus fans. we are that 1% that no one cares about. we are the ones who truely appreciate music.
Opethfullcovers 1 year ago
@Opethfullcovers To bad i,am the only 1 in my family that like this kind of music.
I try to give my kids a good musical backround but i can,t force them to listen to real music .
I,m glad to have 2 brothers with almost the same taste in music so we go to concerts together.
Let,s try to tell people about this kind of music.
1% is not enough let,s make it 2
Bverygood1 1 year ago
@Opethfullcovers Don't say that the people who listen this type of music are the only people that appreciate music. That is simply an ignorant statement. There is actually a large amount of hip-hop and rap that means so much more than just guns,murder, and sluts that you could never be able to appreciate because of your close mindedness. Don't dis a genre of music because the mainstream version of it sucks. That's like comparing PT to the Jonas Brothers.
quigequige 1 year ago
@quigequige it's funny because i've been saying the same thing to you people for a long time. Before you speak to me again learn proper english. Hip-hop is not the same thing as Rap, I hate rap, but I like hip-hop, listen to "black moon - Gotch'a Open." that is REAL hip-hop. By the way, I wasn't refering to Rap as sluts, I was refering to pop when I said that. I will give you an example, Kesha - Teenage dream. I think that's the auther anyways. I have more of an open mind than you can imagine.
Opethfullcovers 1 year ago
@Opethfullcovers Oh, the irony.
jek21 1 year ago
@Opethfullcovers They're essentially the same thing if you're categorizing. Don't think just because you like one song that it's suddenly more "real" than what any other artist can conceptualize; you're being extremely pretentious and elitist in that fashion. Just listen to the music and acknowledge that your mere opinion on it does not classify it as internationally good or bad. Concluding, your grammar and language are next to basic, so stop using that as a base for your argument.
BriansFeyLoka 1 year ago
@BriansFeyLoka can you give it up, I an honestly over it.
Opethfullcovers 1 year ago
@BriansFeyLoka One more thing, calling my grammar basic is quite funny. Just remember, Google doesn't make you smarter than me. Good day troll.
Opethfullcovers 1 year ago
Love it
jessicarene551 1 year ago
This one and The Rest Will Flow are my two favorites. Amazing.
pocketfiend36 1 year ago
...
noconfig 1 year ago
wow
IgibDAane 1 year ago
Music doesnt get better than this. If you dont like this song ... I feel very sorry for you,
WeirdRedFreak 1 year ago 3
great music !
kangurome 1 year ago
To imagine, as something as simple as a joke, could stem into such an influential band.
Makes you think a lot is possible on this small inconspicuous rock of ours.
kagestar616 1 year ago
This song is one of the few that brings a tear to my eye.
xolahx 1 year ago 4
I can barely write this comment, this song is so serene, beautiful in its simplicity. everything is perfect. Now I'm off to sleep, I can't really help it...
Arachnidius 1 year ago
Fuck, how I love this song :3
scrEamoOxXa99cOrE 1 year ago
In absentia is a fucking masterpiece, one of the most beautiful songs that ive ever heard.
007Pogo 1 year ago
wot a text ....
looneYeah 1 year ago
I just found this band through explosions in the sky and they are absolutely breath-taking. When the song is said and done, it leaves me speechless.
Im glad I found this band.
onelastkissx5 1 year ago 4
@onelastkissx5 This band should be known throughout the world
I feel that if the world knew of them, they would blow away any mainstream cookie cutter band and probably why they are blackballed by the industry. Steven Wilson will let NO record company produce or engineer his music. He does this all himself and is one main reason his music does not get airplay
howdyfeller 1 year ago 2
@howdyfeller oh yeah for sure. But, damn. I didn't know all that. Not letting any record company produce his music just made me like him/them even more.
onelastkissx5 1 year ago
@onelastkissx5 Steven has his own production studio where he oversees all editing and mixing. Even the DVD's PT has put out are all engineered by Steven and those very close to him. Look up some of his interviews, he is very vocal about his view of mainstream. You should see the band live, they will blow your mind
howdyfeller 1 year ago
@howdyfeller yeah, that's impressive. i hope ill get to someday too....
onelastkissx5 1 year ago
@onelastkissx5 funny you mention EitS, Your Hand in Mine and this are the only song to bring me down to tears
IlaiAshdot 7 months ago
This is a very nice song
mitchyyob777 1 year ago
This song = pain when it hits as close to home as it does. Beautiful song and I love it, but I look forward to the day when I can sit and listen to the whole thing with a dry eye. Anyone who has ever been through what this song describes knows what I mean.
tehnagabakti 1 year ago 4
I can't believe that up until a couple of months ago i had never heard of this band!
They are like a beautiful hidden treasure.....
topliff12345 1 year ago
I wish I could hold everyones hands and just listen to this song.
MrAwesomesauce4 1 year ago 6
Porcupine Tree....thank you for your existence....!
coldlife192606 1 year ago 5
I can't imagine how awesome it must have been to write this song.
Kisstal1988 1 year ago 6
This never fails to raise the hairs on the back of my neck,
and give me goosbumps.
Pure emotion, I love it
MCBarada 1 year ago 18
@ myegglsboiled....
Except your words....they speak the truth. I get chills when I listen to this song. Deeply touching. I LOVE PORCUPINE TREE
themuffinmansays 1 year ago
This song is in 3/10, right?
musli4brekkies 1 year ago
@musli4brekkies It's actually in 6/8. It's just that it's a 5 bar pattern instead of the conventional 4 bar pattern.
PS: 3/10 doesn't exist. There are no 10th notes. There's quarter notes 8th notes, 16 notes, 32nd notes and so on but there's no note that equals a tenth of a bar.
LMA0NAISE 1 year ago
@LMA0NAISE
I was tired last night. I meant 3/8. Seems that was wrong anyway. Durr.
musli4brekkies 1 year ago
@musli4brekkies 6/8
skateandmusic 1 year ago
One of the most beautiful songs ever written.
filmfetale8 1 year ago
My grandfather died last christmas, I loved him like the father I never had. It was really hard for me to accept that he was gone forever.
I can't avoid crying everytime I listen to this song, because it brings me back beautiful childhood memories and reminds me how much I used to love my dear grandpa.
Thank you so much Steven Wilson.
WickedCrawl 1 year ago 7
I have always loved that if you listen close enough during the fading end, you can hear Steven's foot (probably bare) releasing the piano's sustain pedal. How is that for raw emotion?
willveda 1 year ago 2
@willveda the pedal's sound is part of the f***ing damn awesomeness of this beautiful masterpiece
whocaresofusername 1 year ago
When i hear the first note of this song a part of me dies and gets reborn.
LToastProductions 1 year ago 2
Imagine this live in an enormous venue. The crowd would be stunned into silence and it would be magical.
I would probably jizz everywhere...
DrAltais 1 year ago
T_T
LPmusicLP 1 year ago
more people need to hear this
ebola359 1 year ago
Is it strange this song doesn't seem sad to me? It seems like hope. It's like the break down of everything at present to make room for better things. Either way it's an amazing song :) gotta love PT for making amazing songs all the time!
rabbitalmighty 1 year ago 13
I just lost my brother due to a brain tumour. This song is so fitting to remember him with. Thank you so much Steven Wilson
sw15god 1 year ago 4
@sw15god Sorry to hear that man. Music is such a strong relief at times. Take it easy bud.
chronicreptile 1 year ago
@sw15god so sorry for that.. he will live forever in your heart.. music is such a great help in times like that. Rest in Peace from germany, live like your brother would do it man.
agolunda 1 year ago
This is probably the deepest and most touching song I've ever heard. Although I'm atheist it inspires me some kind of religious feelings. Thanks PT
vsftin 1 year ago 3
amazing.
Overactivedreamer 1 year ago
this song touches me so much right now...
Speedqueen7 1 year ago
Sends shivers up my spine, beautiful track.
ChiyoIshida 1 year ago
this song brings us beyond enlightenment...beyond bliss......beyond eternal happiness...........i brings us into the center of gods heart.
JaskaJunior 1 year ago
@JaskaJunior calm down.
fizzkick 1 year ago
Gorgeous sad song! PT are absolutely FANTASTIC!!!!!!!!!!
monkeyeagle 1 year ago
amazing song..
8iseeyou 1 year ago
Agree with MyEgglsBoiled
cvelascop 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is so boring
arenasification 1 year ago
@arenasification You obviously dont understand music, then.
JackJamesArcher 1 year ago
@JackJamesArcher Obviously :)
arenasification 1 year ago
this song is why i got into music. to move people. one of the finest songs ive ever heard
txeire 1 year ago 4
There's not much you can say about this song except.....WOW AMAZING
rabbitalmighty 1 year ago 2
I cried the first time I heard this song. Now I hear it, I cry again. AndI know I'll cry till the day I die. I can't help it.
algiasphere 1 year ago 2
No word(s) can describe the feeling this song induces. All comments are useless. This song=Bliss.
MyEggIsBoiled 1 year ago 97
@MyEggIsBoiled if no word can describe it, then why did you say that the song is bliss? i don't mean to be a jerk, just noticing a discrepancy in your comment. i agree completely with the first sentence.
TheYtml 1 year ago
@TheYtml You're absolutely correct.. what the hell was I thinking? I don't feel I deserve all those thumbs up with such a flaw in my logic haha.
MyEggIsBoiled 1 year ago
@MyEggIsBoiled oh i don't care really, i just wanted to point it out
TheYtml 1 year ago
@MyEggIsBoiled I stand by my comment. I was drunk then and I am now, and it never fails. Life will change, but this song never will.
MyEggIsBoiled 1 month ago
Fucking beautiful
ayad18 1 year ago 52
Pistoia blues 2010
fausto4cap 1 year ago
Fantastic song.
stars1861 1 year ago 4
...
tupi2p 1 year ago