The Autumn Offering "Silence and Goodbye"

[thomaschavers]

I like both old and new autumn offering. I loved Dennis's vocal, but I also like Matt's balance of clean vocals and screaming. I heard a song from Matt's old band, hell within. It was pretty good stuff.

[xxcannibalxchristian]

Go check out their FB page. If they get enough 'yes'es then they said theyd get back together and make another new album

[Rsbuddyscriptcracks]

I can't finish this video because I keep having to change my pants after the guitar solo :\...

[jeffpfeifer1988]

this band breaking up makes me wanna cry lol!!

[TheAtreyucof]

@ghosthuntermike12 50 cent got shot 9 times, and he still bitches about it on stage.

[IronmAidenthatsy]

@TheAtreyucof hey buddy i love you... jk

[disasterpiece92]

solo = best 10 seconds of life.

[g0sub]

I dont like the video.

[ghosthuntermikel12]

well the video dont like u lol

[heelfan88]

Good song!

[chocolatecityrocker]

great song,okay vid.

how does he scream like that?

[sexxxnuke80]

SpeedStrid is such a pathetic fag that he has to use the singer of Soilworkss name (the TAO singer is 1000 times better btw). don't you have your own identity? what a fucking loser you are and clueless about music. I'm a chick and I could probably kick your ass.

[SpeedStrid]

Cause Sexxxnuke80 is completely hardcore and matches your originality.

you are so unique and have your own identidy...

Fucking moron. Its obvious you're a chick because you ooze stupidity

Suck a dick and headbang to the unseen dumbass bitch.

[metalfan182]

why does every music video have a war in the comments about what the gener of music is?

Its pathetic.

If you like it listen to it, and if you don't then don't listen to it. Don't try and lable it. And don't insult others musical taste cause its all relative.

Seriosuly there are SO many more important issues. Love the song

5 stars.

[SpeedStrid]

I argue over this garbage because of its emo stature and horrible replacement to the old vocalist. this bullshit oozes mainstream ideals and ridiculous fucking money grubbing tactics.

[metalfan182]

Its called Capitalism bro.

Mainstream makes money.

Its sad but true.

Music industry is in fact an industry.

Don't argue about it. Just listen or don't listen. Its not like here, on youtube, what you write in a comment really even matters.

Nothing you say will stop someone from listening to the song if they like it.

[SpeedStrid]

I know... thats why we have artists like 50 cent who are millionaires and truly talented musicians like the band "Green Carnation" who disband due to insificiant funds.

But its completely cool if you like 50 cent.. the no talent ass clown who destroys the meaning of music for fame and fortune

Get you're head out of your ass kid... the music industry is destroying the foundation that music was built on. Its fucktards like you who help that corrupt system of thinking be considered ethical.

[metalfan182]

Talent is a COMPLEATLY relative term.

Now Musicians who conform themselves to what makes money or are just naturally in the style that makes money may destroy the fabric that the music you like, which isn't financially successful because not as many people want to hear it obviously because otherwise it WOULD be the mainstream. Now tell me if it was "Green Carnation" That made the millions and 50 cent quit the industry would you still be complaining? The industry serves what the public wants.

[ghosthuntermikel12]

You gota respect 50 cent man he got shot 9 times..and lived,..

[666loveisdead]

who gives a fuck speedstrid? i agree with metalfan, who cares what genre they are, just shut the fuck up and listen. rock on Autumn Offering!

[SpeedStrid]

you must suck alot of dick.

[666loveisdead]

no, not at all actually. now, i'd advise you keep your mouth shut before i come through the damn computer and punch you right in the face!

[Sha1Nick2R3Random]

I love this song...its amazing....Theo ld singer was good to, but this one is good czu he has more emotion in his voice...

[joannateenspirit]

love this song

its on repeat on my ipod!

[sexxxnuke80]

This band is so much better than before. Have you heard this whole record? For someone with the name SpeedStrid its way heavier than Soilwork. Fucking homo

[SpeedStrid]

...

?

are you mentally challenged? or like 12 years old...

[Sha1Nick2R3Random]

no and hey? whats wrong with being 12, gold damnit....you are a self rightous ass whole....

[SpeedStrid]

And you're an ignorant jackass..

Suck the dick of mainstream shitcore you pompous asshole

No one needs your mindless gibberish here... when you age a bit... come back with something legitimate to say douchbag.

[Sha1Nick2R3Random]

No, Im just not as pathetic as you...

You need to get a life....maybe some friends to...I htink you spent to much time hiding in that little corner of yours...

And you really need to shut up....I am agd enough to state some legitimate things...ass whole!

[SpeedStrid]

Another assuming statement from a complete tard.

Eat shit and die.

[Stalde]

I Like you!

[andybob600]

it doesnt matter what u guys think its about the band they play what they like not what u like ok people

[TallWhiteGuy5000]

Ha, try to keep a steady beat going from 2:07 - 2:11

It kinda goes in and out of time.

Anyone else catch that?

[331stang89lx]

its orite. but the best album was embrace the gutter. the old singer had balls of singing deep and goar. the new singer kinda sounds like a boyband. but its orite.

[SHMO412]

I saw them live . . it wasnt that great . . But thats just because i was waiting all fucking day to hear Mushroomhead play. But now that i go back and listen to them theyre alright . . i guess.

[compelledcontrol]

When i saw em' live they kicked-ass. I hung out with Mushroomhead on the back of their bus, and Tommy Church was back there as well. All really chill people.

[dixon0023]

This is so much better than revelation or embrace the gutter!

[SpeedStrid]

because you're a fag..

simple mathematics really..

[dixon0023]

I'm a fag huh? LOL anyone who has fuck school on their profile is clearly the fag!

[SpeedStrid]

lol...

Keep listening to this new gay shit from this band...

if callin other people fags makes you feel better.. keep doing it.

[dixon0023]

mmmmm love the new stuff!!!!!!!!

[SpeedStrid]

You would!!! Yarghahghaghahga

[wtfdrummer2]

dude there old stuff sucked the only good thing about there old stuff was there guitiar there vocals suckkkkkkkkk and now there good so stfu you retard

[SpeedStrid]

You're the retard... for liking this emo shit!

Cut your wrists som'more you fucking moron!!

[Connorpei]

wow, I see you need a litle class in musicology. This EMO?!?!?! you make me laugh. Emo's can't shred like that

[MilkMan2828]

They sure as hell sing like that though.

[SpeedStrid]

I think you need a break from fallout boy... open your ears young one...

[Sha1Nick2R3Random]

Emos are good tho....

[Sha1Nick2R3Random]

wow.....Okay....this is good music...this isnt emo......and not all emos cut....shawg....

[clockworxzorange]

they seem like they have trouble keeping people in the band. not one of the current members was in the band when it originally formed.

[metalguitar123]

wawa really? i know the drummer and singer have been changed but damn

[maicodavid]

i loved this song

[metalfan182]

I love this song

Its my favorite one by the band

But i prefer there first album as a whole to there new stuff.

[azteca555]

ha everyone loves mushroomhead! just look at the guitarist shirt!

[wtfdrummer2]

i really like them but if they did like half screming and halh singing they would be way better

[uponit17]

yeah man same band before the new singer lol it changes the band complety eh

[coops409]

Wtf? What happened? Was just listening to "Embrace the Gutter" and then I hear this. Is it even the same band? What the hell?

[anchovy93]

i live next to tommy church dude he's showing me how to play when he gets back

=D

[robertz87]

i love these guys i had the privilege to see them and hang out with them the other night.

[compelledcontrol]

Hell yeah me too man. I saw em' in Chicago and smoked with Tommy Church and Mushroomhead in the back of Mushroomheads bus.

[corrosivetrip]

yea it was a good tour dude, the bands, especially TOA, always hang out with the fans before and after the show. i went and hung out with the sinnger and guitarist almost the whole night

[chivas4lifeputo]

They should scream more often.

There really good at it.

[ZxyklonX]

agreed, i think dennis was ment 4 the band. but i dont mind matt at all. this new stuff aint that bad. jsut tput more screaming.

[smartpartsSUCKS]

Wow love this song had no idea that there was a video!

[MereFilth216]

anyone catch the MRH t-shirt? badass

[usmcbratusa]

Yupp

[1lik3rs]

i agree with u

[usmcbratusa]

Tommy is amazing, I hung out with the whole band on sunday, and I got a signed poster from the whole band, I also hung out with Mushroomhead.

[compelledcontrol]

Did you hang out with them or just meet them?

[mattador2792]

they sound much better live

[Pensi1234]

you're nuts they sound gay live

[mattador2792]

they sound even gayer the album.

[Pensi1234]

no way they sound waaay better it's just the clean vocals the rest was pretty good live

[compelledcontrol]

How do they sound gay? They sound happy???

[thraxnayel]

can you please explain what you mean by that statement, cuz the only thing ive heard from trivium that may sound similar to another bands song is the begining of dying in ur arms, and thats just the intro, and the song it sounds like is this song, which came out after that song, btw i like both bands im just stating what i hear between the 2 songs and trying to figure out wth this guy means

[Camaro4726]

he's talking about how matt sings like metallica in the crusade which everyone thinks they sold out and they didn't because they are just changing it up. These guys are good the newer singer isn't as good tho in my opinion

[camellights88]

i know the new drummer for this band hes good friends with my sister. sick drumming

[SpeedStrid]

Bring back dennis... what the hell is this shit?

Lame lame lame.

[Cyrus919]

Fuck metallica in it's ass ! fuckin sell out whining bitches !!!

[punishersadvocate]

CALM THE FUCK DOWN

[compelledcontrol]

Very true Megadeth kicks the shit outta Metallica.

[JaymzbYrD]

this song is bad i dont care wat other ppl think! i fuckin love it

[XxangelofemoxX]

what cd is this off of?

[smartpartsSUCKS]

Fear will cast no shadow I believe.

[ThEuSeDoNe82589]

this singer is so much more talented than dennis. that guy just screams like 100,000 other bands. deep and growling. this new shit blows my mind. the vocals are amazing. matt can change the octaves in his voice very well. singing and screaming sounds better than just screaming because you can't even tell what that dennis fucker is saying. just blah blah blah embrace the gutter. thats all i got out of it. lyrics can totally make a song.

[samsaman00535]

I am deffinatley hating the vocals

[slowburn34]

You are a dumb fuck

[truepothead420]

still a kickass band, fuckin hardcore, this guitarist can play some sick ass riffs

[briannamarie88]

the singer sucks the drummer rocks!!the guitarist rocks!

[slowburn34]

you are also a dumb fuck

[slowburn34]

those were for samsaman00535/brainnamarie88/a­nd mrd4v3......... MrD4V3 you're mom is emo.

[corrosivetrip]

let it the fuck go, this band is 20x better now with matt and everyone knows it. I'm sick of hearing all these bitches whine about them making better music.

[serrerra]

Matt so wins. Whatever. These guys are so much better now!

[supasole72]

love the beginning

[samknight666]

yeah but the 2 songs they have released of the new album or the softest songs on there. You should check out the rest man. search thier title track 'fear will cast no shadow'. I uploaded it. Its fucking amazin

[am0nrahx]

Matt fails. Whoever Dennis does vocals for next will have win.

[SparksRacing450]

i fuckin love the vocals.

[AbflugSupra]

i love this song. has so much meaning in the lyrics, nice vocals to back them up, and love the instrumentals. and that slow break down after the solo. looove this song :D

[yagermiester112]

Yeah, they do. First thing I thought when i first herd this song.

[deadscythe77]

i think that it shouldnt matter who sings..cuzz in revealation dennis sung and it wasnt bad

[thrash062291]

One thing I never understood was that some people only like the one simple skill of screaming, but now that The Autumn Offering has a multi talented vocalist people dog on them. Come on they are the same band minus Dennis. Oh and all bands sounds will change over a period of time look at metallica. Now they suck.

[deadscythe77]

heyy does metallica have any demos for their new album? i hope they dont shit bomb again i mean what its like their last album?

[SparksRacing450]

they have an Unforgiven III, they have some on thier myspace page.

[onehundredfortythre]

I got the new album today...

It's amazing... Beats the hell out of the last 20 years...

Suck metallica 88-08

Good Metallica 08-

[ridethelightningof84]

no suck metallica 94-now

good METALLica 81-93

[onehundredfortythre]

Suck Metallica has died... =]

[ule1010]

there new stuff is pretty cool but embrace the gutter was the best album so far, they sound more pussy in this song but its pretty cool.

[Axle45]

wat do u mean

[beforemyeyes]

The guitar riffs in the intro remind me of Trivium. That's all.

[slashfolife]

i saw these guys on the havoc and now i cant get enough!!!! lol :)...

[cutegurl0606]

hehe. my name is autumn.

[AlboytTaco]

i met the guitarist tommy at mayhem when they played they own!

[Sixxstringz]

I love this song!

I agree the new singer is better but old was still awesome.

[metalhulk]

i respect ur opinion but now they sound so fucking pussy they should bring back the other vocal seriously

[fuckitirule]

wow they used to be like

fucken heavy

[leonroque]

dude you suck

[ajjack88]

im addicted to the bridge

[greenbay67]

omg, that drum bass is sooo awesome

[smallboy21]

this sucks, the vocals are terrible, and don't match this song at all.

[thomaschavers]

i like the new album and singer. but i like the first 2 albums better. i prefer dennis miller on vocals, but both singers are good in my opniion.

[rickaffix]

i agree, both singers kick ass. the sounds aren't too different. which makes me happy.

[killswitchtilldead]

the old autumn offering were awesome...but this new singer is way better!

[HandOfBlood8894]

the singers awesome the hell are you talking about

[Hickthu06]

great song

[porcu12345]

the singer sucks 0.o

[TearsAesthetic]

wow, i liked the first song i heard, but holly fucking hell

this is the worst shit ive heard

vocalist is a douche

[garrethwippel]

my band played with this band a couple days ago. it was pretty fun.

[ajjack88]

fuckin new singer sucks. he never freaking screams and when he does it sounds like a freaking fag

[jonathonhggns]

lol

by the way

gotta love those dimebuckers on that v

[jonathonhggns]

i have to say

the new singer has way more screaming range

and i think he does a pretty good job with his clean vocals

is it true that one of the guitarists is dimebag's cousin?

[SparksRacing450]

oo diff singer. big fucking deal. TAO still sound just as kickass as they're first and second albums.

[rskredbull1]

who gives a flying fuck what this guy has accomplished, the old singer was better.

[zakitron]

good band and i like the music. but why does the guitarists play another artist's signature series? i find it odd. good song, good band, nice guitar all the same.

[zakitron]

if thats micheal shenkner that thatd be why >.> forgot to add that bit

[VodkaAce]

maybe because it's a good series? fuck

[zakitron]

hey i didnt say it was bad. just said it seemed odd. dean makes some good guitars. for a while there they had the m s flying v for $160, i shouldve bought it

[StevenBuchan]

amazing band and song:D

[mattsdick]

face wet

[CONMANCAN88]

idk i heard embrace the gutter on xm and this guy is gay that blond singer way better this song makes me wana join backstreet boys

[rickmanpromote]

dude if you knew the shit this guy has accomplished you would shut your trap and stop fucking judging someone who has succeeded far more than you

[gangstastats]

same!!!

[ChuckZombie]

This is the best song on the album. Love it.

[MetalxFanatic]

I like the old Autumn Offering better. =\

This isnt that bad though.

[itsJRay]

i agree their old stuff was awesome

[godsmack4232]

chevy*

[TearsWillNeverFall]

Bass player has an A7x shirt :O

[godsmack4232]

thats lynyrd skynyrd

and why does the guitarist have a toyota sticker?

[ChuckZombie]

That would Lynyrd Skynyrd.

[TearsWillNeverFall]

Yeah, saw that now. my bad

[beefboy7]

i love this song!!!

[patricksanus]

But I give it 5 Stars.

[Paulscuntflaps]

Patrick, nobody cares

[patricksanus]

dick wet

[patricksanus]

I hate how the Bassist in The Autumn Offering is wearing a fucking Skynard shirt..

[666JIMJAM666]

AMAZING SONG

[slipknot605]

this drummer is probably better then the guy from all that remains, the the lead singer is amazing

[cardkoda]

booo the old vocalist was better

[mynameownsyou]

The clean vocals don't sound like other metalcore bands do. It sounds like it goes back to classic rock influences. Awesome band though.

[Dramagurl1548]

Wow this band is effin amazing!!

The lead singer has such a unique voice!!

[Boyan89]

i still like The Autumn Offering still such a kick ass band and to the guy that said his screaming was better no its not, this guy has a truly unique voice and he makes a great vocalist so its understandable why they got him

[fuelthefire1986]

excellent song from an excellent band, everyone band wouldnt be complete without the critics moaning :-P

[BPBundy]

lead singer is a good screamer, terrible singer.

[spikesethen]

Dude... other way around... when he screams he sounds like ninety percent of the females that I hear scream when they sing metal... when he sings he actually sounds like a man.... You obviously know nothing about vocals

[DCTACULAR]

i have to say, embrace the gutter is one of their better songs in my opinion,(although the video is sorta dumb) but this is pretty good too.

[SHADOWZEROKYO]

i hate this new singer

[NyrisPC]

this new singer is fakin' terrible

[fabibass]

Autumn Offering is a fantastic metal band - one of the best. Period

[xalphakillx]

this is hands down THE MOST underrated song of all time

[serrerra]

I went and saw these guys a while back and never knew who they were... ABSOLUTELY AWESOME live!!! I actually got a chance to hang and party with them after the show and they are really down to earth and alot of fun! I love this particular song... it's my favorite song right now... I have been telling everyone about them ever since I saw them! I'm getting everyone hooked! Love it!

[Brutus556]

i actually love how these metal bands are doing not necessarily slower songs but songs with actual singing. i mean, i love metal/death metal but all im saying is it shows their diversity. awesome song, in my opinion.

[folken161]

I completely agree, well put

I love the metal sound, but many of them arn't about vocals, so I like how bands like this can have the best of both worlds.

[ivany3]

the new singer is WAAAAYYY better. the other one looks dumb.. :(

lol. the music videos improved too.

i just saw embrace the gutter, and, man it ruined the whole song. the video is.. childish. only a tween would think its cool .

anywho. much love TAO

[emmforever]

yea this is a little like dyng in your arms nyway is really good

[schizophrenic2494]

yea i agree on that the begining riff gives me the same feeling when i listen to it as when i listen to dying in your arms

[damnedsilence]

ooo good song.

not as good as their heavy songs though, i reckon