She seems so nice and down to earth and in the film she is so beautiful but I'm serious all you hatred get a life the film was legendary it made me cry thrice and I'm not the one to cry when it comes to films but yes just happy that it had a happy turnout!!! ;D
Have you seen the new video of the abuse of the elephants in this movie....it is worse than what I ever thought and for anyone who defended this , shame on you.
@whateverpall physical bro , physical , and that was before the movie came about , this elephant was trained a long time ago and suffered from abuse but on this set there was nothing but love for it
Definately not watching that film, absolutely digusting, horrible and very sad to know what actually happened to that poor elephant, and how it was made to act - very sad indeed.
I want to read the book in next time, I don't know how old marlene is when she died. it is mentioned in the book? I don't know in which age the elephant died, but after the elephant died, she died too, exactly? he told it so fast in the movie. I'm confused!
@MORGANwoohoo im pretty sure she's 21. because she joined when she was 17. and then in the hotel scene on the book when she starts explaining her life the book says "she mentions how hard the past four years have been" sooo im assuming its the 4 years she's been on the show and married to august, making her 21. i might be wrong though. i always thought her older and in the movie she seems older
I'm a Nicolas Sparks reader and fan so once I finished buying and reading all of his book for my (Kindle) I was like so OMG what am I going to do with myself now!!! So i started looking at NY Best Sellers on Amazon and there it was Water for Elephants at first I thought well its a weird title but I will give t a try!!!! WOW I'm so glad I did!!! I fell in love with the story... I just wish they would have got Patrick Swayzies brother to play the ring master!!!
Love this book so much, I really really hope they don't screw it up.
They do make at least one HUGE change: no Uncle Al. August is going to be the ringmaster in the movie. I *think* it's a smart move...? Not sure yet, we'll see how it goes.
this was the book that got me into reading first of all. they better include walter the midget and show the grittyness of it. looks like its them in suits and whatnot. thats not really even close to how the book was besides august which i percieved as looking more like caption hook hah.
Reese Witherspoon would make an amazing Marlena and Cristoph Waltz would make an amazing August, I'm not sure how well Robert Pattinson is suited for the lead.
@NadiaBKat167 She doesn't die in the end as part of the main story. We know she is dead when he is old in a nursing home. It doesn't say how she dies.
@Haleyperforms Oh haha it's not a spoiler. The book is weird. chapter one he's 93 and then chapter 2 he's 23. it goes back and forth. He mentions it in the first chapter. :)
wow.who hear has read this book???? it's a really great book and am going to be mad as hell if they screw this up.but that's usually how it goes in Hollywood.
I have and it's a beautiful story. You can actually see everything that Jacob describes about his experience with the circus and how he falls in love with Marlena. Once I started reading it,I couldn't put it down. It's one of those books that just makes you sit down and read it until the end. Now I can't wait to see the filim,as I know it will be as good as the novel.
@thewall283 dude i hear what your saying but that's how it happens sometimes.hollywood comes along and goes hhhmmm what a great book let's make that into a movie.then you speand 6-8.00 on a movie that has taken things out,added things in or twists the plot around a little bit.i really like the book and i hate when movies are based off of a book and they mess every thing up.i don't want to be dissapointed so i'll just have a friend see it and tell me what they think.
My only concern is that they will tone it down to a PG-13 rating,just so Robert's younger fans can see it. Sara Gruen was quite graphic in her use of language and adult situations in the novel and it would be a shame to see that sacrificed,so most of the mainstream audience can see it. I hope they've stayed true to the novel and kept it as the beautiful and adult story that it is.
@thewall283 i know that's something i've thought about as well.this book in some ways might even be R-rated but with robert in it it might be a little lame because he's only famous because of twlight .the character in this book does everything he can to get the women of his dreams.but that's how it goes in the book and some people might not be okay with that.so will they change things are around for them??i don't know but that will only prove that hollywood can't do things the right way.
@leoaddict lol i'm sorry to hear that,cause truth is you might have to check out the movie before you read the book.and the book really is good i just hope that Hollywood will do right and keep it close as possible to the book.
@FightsRightsAlways I totally agree. But I saw the movie yesterday, and I have to say they really stayed true to the book. It's beautiful! I'm not a great fan of Reese Witherspoon, but she did a great job! And of course, *sigh* Robert was just Robert.
@FightsRightsAlways You bet ya :) Of course, the book is allways better, but I really loved the movie. Aaaww; the scenes where August hits Rosie with his stick, almost made me cry. I felt so sorry for her. The look in her eyes broke my heart ;(
This movie is going to suck.... I love Reese Witherspoon but they changed way too much crap, the actors are no where near the characters in almost every aspect and I cant stand Rob pattinson.....
reese is gonna be the perfect Marlena! and all you people saying shes too old . um did u even read the book! she is supposed to be older! thats the whole point. and they have to cut down the book and characters to make it fit the time limit! god
what kind of stupid question is that "are you worried of being hurt"? is obvious they take care a lot about her and would not let her to get hurt, is it so difficult to ask smart questions and avoid the dumb ones?
@SavageGenius135 I didn't see Reese playing Marlena either! I thought Marlena and Jacob were closer in age. I pictured a more 'classically beautiful' girl. And what character did they cut? I can't stand it when they can't keep the book the same as the movie...
@SavageGenius135 Thats the first thing I thought too, I thought she Marlena was the same age as Jacob, but shes 34. And they took out Uncle Al and made August the owner of the circus.
i wana see htiss soo baddd!! and in the book rob and reese's characters have sex, does this there'll b a sex scene, cuz i neeed to see this movie but i just wonder if it'll b pg-13
Robert Pattinson may look pretty, but he IS NOT a Jacob Jankowksi...All he had to do in Twilight was sparkle and not smile...what's it going to be like when he actually has to act? Bitter about this cast, that's for sure.
@redrider4show I take it you havnt seen him in "Remember Me"? Hes actually a really talented actor, and i know for fact he will do an outstanding job with the character Jacob Jankowksi. Apparently, word from the set of the film, is that Robert could be oscar nominated for this role. So i dont think you should judge.....
Meh. haven't seen "Remember Me". Didn't have the inclination. If he does well in this role I will be pleasantly surprised, I guess. I don't have to be a fan of him, and I can make any judgement I want. It's Hollywood. It's not like I'm attacking everyone who's a Robert Pattinson fan...
@redrider4show Im suprised you havent seen it, it got excellent reviews. Well, if you end up enjoying his performance in "Water For Elephants", i recommend "Remember Me".. big time :)
I really like Reese, she is a great actress! I look forward to seeing the film! Robert is a very talented actor, so it will be so great seeing him starring with Reese!
@grace123p the book is really good though. it actually talk about some of the cruel and unnessary things they did to the elephant :] its quite a good story
i can't wait to see this movie because of Rebecca Ostroff!!! the Women the hired to do a lot of the trapeze, she does a trick called the iron jaw that is only currently done by four people in the world!!! We were pirates in a show in NY... and she's awesome!!!
1st...Rob and Reese have worked together before...2nd...i do agree with your guys point but let's not rush to conclusions...give him a chance...he's still trying to make his way in the business...and everyone just precieves him as edward...give him a chance.
Lovin' Reese, but Rob? Really? As Jacob? I was thinking about a bit more of an awkward boy...
I believe Marlena was older, because she was married to August, and he was a bunch older than jacob...im still very very sad they are making this into a movie. The imagery in the book was absolutely stunning and Sarah Gruel just...was incredible, Im very very sad they feel the need to transform this piece of literature into a movie, it was and is beautiful all on its own.
"Are you going to do circus stuff??" bahaha it's a circus dumbass of course!
I'm sorry byt Robert just sucks. He sucks at doing his hair, sucks at acting, and his looks just suck. oh well all they want to do is wash out the story with a big name cast and try to draw some attention from those twilight fans. I'll just stick to reading the book
i. am. so. pissed. i live in santa barbara and they were shooting this movie in ventura which is minutes from my house and i didnt found out i was just minutes away from ROBERT PATTINSON until today. ughhhhh. i cud hav met himmm >X(
Reese Witherspoon as Marlena and Rob Pattinson as the red-headed Polish-American Jacob Jankowski? What awful casting. That producers probably never read the book and are just working off the script writer's summaries.
I'm exited for the movie, but I think Reese is a little too old for the role. I mean I wish Marlena would have been a little younger, but who knows it might turn out really good
They shouldn't promote the cruelty of circus animals in a movie. Elephants are endangered, and the elephant they are using in this movie, called "Tai", is a real, abused elephant forced to live in deplorable conditions. Quite sad...
Reese is playing Rob Pattinson's character Jacob's love interest Marlena....she is the circus acrobat who works with the horses and Rosie the elephant.
@ecarmosino yeah totally, i think the same. I think somebody with a fresher face would have been good. I just can't see her as Marlena and rob and her being in a love scene together. But still cannot wait for the movie though
Robert is going to butcher this movie. For Jacob i completely invisioned Tobey Maguire or Ewan McGregor. Those two would have been more suitable for Jacob's lost and naive sense of his dilemas. As for Reese I wasn't too excited. Nicole Kidman would have made a better choice. I must say that i was very disappointed and mad when i read that the twilight-guy was being casted for Jacob. But i am happy that the book is being made into a movie!
@dktuealdqw those are the most idiotic casting ideas yet. a dude whose 20 years older than the character. and a wimp, which goes completely against his description.
Christoph and Reese working together sounds interesting. I like Reese. From what I've seen, she's a talented actress and I'm looking forward to seeing her in this adaptation.
I cannot wait for this film! To see Rob, Reese and Christoph all on the same screen will be amazing. Reese may be older than the character is meant to be but so is Christoph, it'll work out. The book is brilliant and I can picture all 3 in their parts.
COME ON. She's a brilliant actress, and she will be wonderful with Rob and Christoph in this movie. Christoph himself is a little old for the part - good, liberties like that can be taken - but no one complains. She looks GORGEOUS, face and everything is perfect. Casting is perfect.
Reese did an amazing performance and rosie i love her i cried when she got beaten but reese looked older in the movie
olenarochelle143 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Check Out My Channel To watch All The Latest Films For Free
dominiquegai821 8 months ago 2
LOVE -HONERED haha that we have the same birthday!!! woo to March 22 babies haha
clarabelle1able 8 months ago
She seems so nice and down to earth and in the film she is so beautiful but I'm serious all you hatred get a life the film was legendary it made me cry thrice and I'm not the one to cry when it comes to films but yes just happy that it had a happy turnout!!! ;D
thespazzhand 9 months ago
@thespazzhand,
According to many people, she's very sweet and down to earth.
thelupoistheman1 6 months ago
God he ask's some dumb ass questions.. shhzzz sucking up to Reese interview
thesingingdj 9 months ago
Have you seen the new video of the abuse of the elephants in this movie....it is worse than what I ever thought and for anyone who defended this , shame on you.
sohcsarewicked 9 months ago
All circus ´train´ annimals with fysical abuse!!!
The elephants that are used in this film are also trained with fysical abuse!
whateverpall 9 months ago
@whateverpall physical bro , physical , and that was before the movie came about , this elephant was trained a long time ago and suffered from abuse but on this set there was nothing but love for it
paparazziFollower 9 months ago
@whateverpall please spell PHYSICAL right
clarabelle1able 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The Elephant who plays Rosie in the film has been electric-shocked. I invite to see on my channel the video which give more informations.
Veganpourlesanimaux 9 months ago
Definately not watching that film, absolutely digusting, horrible and very sad to know what actually happened to that poor elephant, and how it was made to act - very sad indeed.
redkatana99 9 months ago
I wonder if she took part torturing the elephants?
athens141 9 months ago
@AngryActivist45 you're obviously just jealous.
sophie77819 10 months ago
Horrible cast, with the exception of Waltz.
Excuseify 10 months ago
Check out our channel for a review on this movie!
ThePopMyCorn 10 months ago
I want to read the book in next time, I don't know how old marlene is when she died. it is mentioned in the book? I don't know in which age the elephant died, but after the elephant died, she died too, exactly? he told it so fast in the movie. I'm confused!
sweethimbeere 10 months ago
I love her!!! =]
Lauriesuelovesyou 10 months ago
@TheBayard77 do you know how old Marlena is? i never caught it in the book, but I must have missed it. It's been driving me crazy!
MORGANwoohoo 10 months ago
@MORGANwoohoo im pretty sure she's 21. because she joined when she was 17. and then in the hotel scene on the book when she starts explaining her life the book says "she mentions how hard the past four years have been" sooo im assuming its the 4 years she's been on the show and married to august, making her 21. i might be wrong though. i always thought her older and in the movie she seems older
xxkmd 10 months ago
@xxkmd
i am sorry bu...t who is 21 years old>?
BButterfllly 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
the movie was awesome, it really was:)
claritakrist 10 months ago
/watch?v=AJo9pUxnKFw check out reese witherspoons chin
TheOxycodone 10 months ago
TRUST IN JESUS AND BE SAVED! CALL UPON JESUS AND BELIEVE ON HIM!
JesusPaid4You 11 months ago
Reese is way too old to play Marlena and she wasn't a blonde. I hope they don't ruin the book on the screen.
TheBayard77 11 months ago
See what happens when you are out of good ideas? You work with a blood sucker bottom feeder and your movies suck. Poor Reese.
onenesstribe 11 months ago
BOOK = AWESOME. MOVIE = OSCARS?!
TheElizabethMusic 11 months ago
I'm a Nicolas Sparks reader and fan so once I finished buying and reading all of his book for my (Kindle) I was like so OMG what am I going to do with myself now!!! So i started looking at NY Best Sellers on Amazon and there it was Water for Elephants at first I thought well its a weird title but I will give t a try!!!! WOW I'm so glad I did!!! I fell in love with the story... I just wish they would have got Patrick Swayzies brother to play the ring master!!!
According2Ashley 11 months ago 2
Reese is so beautiful & lucky to be in a movie with Robert Pattinson...He is gorgeous in every way & we need more Roberts in this world :-D
salvear92 11 months ago
i looove her :)
AvrilCullen13 1 year ago
I'm reading the book right now, love it. :)
Ballerina324 1 year ago 5
Canadian author representin' wha wha
9raider 1 year ago 2
watch?v=jaIaGMl40Rs
second song from WFE trailer
MsPineapple112 1 year ago
Love this book so much, I really really hope they don't screw it up.
They do make at least one HUGE change: no Uncle Al. August is going to be the ringmaster in the movie. I *think* it's a smart move...? Not sure yet, we'll see how it goes.
phantommangagirl 1 year ago
@phantommangagirl Oh, hahaha i read too fast :)
meowmeowjazmine 1 year ago
@meowmeowjazmine It's in the first chapter, it's easy to miss :).
phantommangagirl 1 year ago
@leoaddict it actually is. I bought it like a month ago in athens:/ but you can also buy it online:)
anniewestwick 1 year ago
this was the book that got me into reading first of all. they better include walter the midget and show the grittyness of it. looks like its them in suits and whatnot. thats not really even close to how the book was besides august which i percieved as looking more like caption hook hah.
TheBeltones 1 year ago
@TheBeltones They have Kinko/Walter, but they don't have Uncle Al. August takes on the ringmaster role.
phantommangagirl 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Cover your mouth with you hand
2. Make a wish
3. Close your hand (fist)
4. Hold your hand at your heart for 5 seconds
5. Send this to 3 more videos
6. Tomorrow will be the best day ever
it actually works
901wakefiej 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Cover your mouth with you hand
2. Make a wish
3. Close your hand (fist)
4. Hold your hand at your heart for 5 seconds
5. Send this to 3 more videos
6. Tomorrow will be the best day ever
it actually works
901wakefiej 1 year ago
In vanity fair Reese was Roberts mother...so weird lol
sandra123marar 1 year ago 2
@sandra123marar ROFL IKR? that is really weird!
yvonnechalet1 1 year ago
haha 0:53
Wow I thought that was funn what Reese said because all i can picture her in is Legally Blonde.
"a tomboy" haha
XoPinkIz4FreaksXo 1 year ago
Phiew.. just released my first Robert-fanforum :) It took a while, but I can't wait to post about WFTE! Really :) It will be so great!
UnravelHope 1 year ago
Reese Witherspoon would make an amazing Marlena and Cristoph Waltz would make an amazing August, I'm not sure how well Robert Pattinson is suited for the lead.
yourmotherwashere1 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Respect four Robert Pattinson you are a great actor i cant wait to see this movie .
elieliosca 1 year ago
Well if it follows the book correctly, she does die in the end
MrDripdrop 1 year ago
@MrDripdrop Thanks for ruining the movie for me and many other people
NadiaBKat167 1 year ago
@NadiaBKat167 Not a problem, anytime i can help
MrDripdrop 1 year ago
@NadiaBKat167 She doesn't die in the end as part of the main story. We know she is dead when he is old in a nursing home. It doesn't say how she dies.
meowmeowjazmine 1 year ago
@meowmeowjazmine spoiler much? im hald way through. awesome. lol jk XD
Haleyperforms 1 year ago
@Haleyperforms Oh haha it's not a spoiler. The book is weird. chapter one he's 93 and then chapter 2 he's 23. it goes back and forth. He mentions it in the first chapter. :)
meowmeowjazmine 1 year ago
@meowmeowjazmine In the book, she died of really fast-acting cancer about 10 years before Jacob went to the nursing home.
phantommangagirl 1 year ago
@MrDripdrop .....
AlexanderRight 1 year ago
Love the book! Can't wait to see this =)
emy1975 1 year ago
She's such a BABE
wirezts 1 year ago
wow.who hear has read this book???? it's a really great book and am going to be mad as hell if they screw this up.but that's usually how it goes in Hollywood.
FightsRightsAlways 1 year ago 107
@FightsRightsAlways
I have and it's a beautiful story. You can actually see everything that Jacob describes about his experience with the circus and how he falls in love with Marlena. Once I started reading it,I couldn't put it down. It's one of those books that just makes you sit down and read it until the end. Now I can't wait to see the filim,as I know it will be as good as the novel.
thewall283 1 year ago
@thewall283 dude i hear what your saying but that's how it happens sometimes.hollywood comes along and goes hhhmmm what a great book let's make that into a movie.then you speand 6-8.00 on a movie that has taken things out,added things in or twists the plot around a little bit.i really like the book and i hate when movies are based off of a book and they mess every thing up.i don't want to be dissapointed so i'll just have a friend see it and tell me what they think.
FightsRightsAlways 1 year ago
@FightsRightsAlways
My only concern is that they will tone it down to a PG-13 rating,just so Robert's younger fans can see it. Sara Gruen was quite graphic in her use of language and adult situations in the novel and it would be a shame to see that sacrificed,so most of the mainstream audience can see it. I hope they've stayed true to the novel and kept it as the beautiful and adult story that it is.
thewall283 1 year ago
@thewall283 i know that's something i've thought about as well.this book in some ways might even be R-rated but with robert in it it might be a little lame because he's only famous because of twlight .the character in this book does everything he can to get the women of his dreams.but that's how it goes in the book and some people might not be okay with that.so will they change things are around for them??i don't know but that will only prove that hollywood can't do things the right way.
FightsRightsAlways 1 year ago
@FightsRightsAlways i'm dieing to read it, but it's not out in greece :(
leoaddict 1 year ago
@leoaddict lol i'm sorry to hear that,cause truth is you might have to check out the movie before you read the book.and the book really is good i just hope that Hollywood will do right and keep it close as possible to the book.
FightsRightsAlways 1 year ago
@FightsRightsAlways I love the book!
MrsCullenJankowski 1 year ago
@FightsRightsAlways I totally agree. But I saw the movie yesterday, and I have to say they really stayed true to the book. It's beautiful! I'm not a great fan of Reese Witherspoon, but she did a great job! And of course, *sigh* Robert was just Robert.
TwilightObsessedPage 10 months ago
@TwilightObsessedPage sigh okay i'll just have to take your word for it.
FightsRightsAlways 9 months ago
@FightsRightsAlways You bet ya :) Of course, the book is allways better, but I really loved the movie. Aaaww; the scenes where August hits Rosie with his stick, almost made me cry. I felt so sorry for her. The look in her eyes broke my heart ;(
TwilightObsessedPage 9 months ago
@TwilightObsessedPage okay well i'll give it a try.thanks for the feed back.
FightsRightsAlways 9 months ago
@FightsRightsAlways You're welcome :) Let me know what you think of it! ;p
TwilightObsessedPage 9 months ago
@TwilightObsessedPage okay i will.
FightsRightsAlways 9 months ago
Well if it fallows the book correctly, she does die in the end
MrDripdrop 1 year ago
@MrDripdrop hahahaha
CuntDangIt 1 year ago
This book is a MUST read! I can't WAIT to see the movie!!!
cindiarg 1 year ago 3
She's so adorable. i've always loved herrr
Thistoxiclove 1 year ago
They filmed some of this about 20-30 miles where I live.
jennel802009 1 year ago
@jennel802009 thats really cool!!!!!!!!!!
ERnews3967 10 months ago
the trailer will be released next week...so excited
gracequeen789 1 year ago
THEY NEED TO RELEASE THE TRAILER. LIKE NOW.
TheRealMaryAlice 1 year ago
I'm reading this book in English 12 right now :) It's awesome so far!
jordanclark1993 1 year ago
This movie is going to suck.... I love Reese Witherspoon but they changed way too much crap, the actors are no where near the characters in almost every aspect and I cant stand Rob pattinson.....
xoxMusicalHorsexox 1 year ago
what a terrible interviewer
ilovebrandontaylor 1 year ago
reese is gonna be the perfect Marlena! and all you people saying shes too old . um did u even read the book! she is supposed to be older! thats the whole point. and they have to cut down the book and characters to make it fit the time limit! god
CatiCullen 1 year ago 2
I loved this book :D
SwEeTTiFfYPoO 1 year ago 70
the movie is gonna suck compared to the book.
skad4 1 year ago
She is one of the most over rated actresses ive ever seen
starrygaze56 1 year ago
what kind of stupid question is that "are you worried of being hurt"? is obvious they take care a lot about her and would not let her to get hurt, is it so difficult to ask smart questions and avoid the dumb ones?
thatg98y6 1 year ago
I just loved this book ... so beautiful and brutal and wonderful evocative.
Contratrombone64 1 year ago
I'm sorry, Reese Witherspoon is not how I pictured Marlena to look at all... She seems a little old for the role, or is that just me?
Not to mention that they're apparently cutting out an entire character.
SavageGenius135 1 year ago
@SavageGenius135 I didn't see Reese playing Marlena either! I thought Marlena and Jacob were closer in age. I pictured a more 'classically beautiful' girl. And what character did they cut? I can't stand it when they can't keep the book the same as the movie...
Versailles1770 1 year ago
@SavageGenius135 Thats the first thing I thought too, I thought she Marlena was the same age as Jacob, but shes 34. And they took out Uncle Al and made August the owner of the circus.
oxSam11 1 year ago
ugh fuckin LOVE THAT BOOK!!!!!!!!!!!!!
SPDcru 1 year ago 2
I can't wait to see this...does it come out in april 2011? And does anyone know if they hvae a date for the premiere? Thanks (:
misssnazzypop 1 year ago
She should be doing the bend and snap in this movie too ;)
dairymoostache 1 year ago
does christoph waltz play August?
jbjboceanfront 1 year ago
@jbjboceanfront yes! hes gonna b so bad ass
DarthRoy1292 1 year ago
@DarthRoy1292 haha cool cant waitto see this movie
jbjboceanfront 1 year ago 2
@jbjboceanfront yup!!
xBadGirlBeautyx 1 year ago
I'm excited for this movie!
EmmaLoveJen 1 year ago
i wana see htiss soo baddd!! and in the book rob and reese's characters have sex, does this there'll b a sex scene, cuz i neeed to see this movie but i just wonder if it'll b pg-13
blingblinggirl12 1 year ago
they are shooting where i live :DDDD
I'M SO EXCITED!!!!!!!
CourtneyMurr 1 year ago 2
its so funny i adore rob
but in twilight he plays edward and he has an enemy who is jacob and in water for elephants his characters name that he is playing is jacob!!
hahhahhhaahahaha
love rob..
ILUVROBERTPATZ1 1 year ago
Robert Pattinson may look pretty, but he IS NOT a Jacob Jankowksi...All he had to do in Twilight was sparkle and not smile...what's it going to be like when he actually has to act? Bitter about this cast, that's for sure.
redrider4show 1 year ago
@redrider4show I take it you havnt seen him in "Remember Me"? Hes actually a really talented actor, and i know for fact he will do an outstanding job with the character Jacob Jankowksi. Apparently, word from the set of the film, is that Robert could be oscar nominated for this role. So i dont think you should judge.....
dangerouseef 1 year ago
@dangerouseef
Meh. haven't seen "Remember Me". Didn't have the inclination. If he does well in this role I will be pleasantly surprised, I guess. I don't have to be a fan of him, and I can make any judgement I want. It's Hollywood. It's not like I'm attacking everyone who's a Robert Pattinson fan...
redrider4show 1 year ago
@redrider4show Im suprised you havent seen it, it got excellent reviews. Well, if you end up enjoying his performance in "Water For Elephants", i recommend "Remember Me".. big time :)
dangerouseef 1 year ago
@dangerouseef
I will have to keep it in mind. I'd hate to miss a good movie for not giving it a chance.
redrider4show 1 year ago
Reese is not good to play Marlena. Nothing in common with the character. I wish Emma Watson or Nina Dobrev could play Marlena... way better.
sassie13 1 year ago
im in this movie im not lieing you will see my face in the movie cant wait for the movie! it will be good
lauese1 1 year ago
The "Marlena" character is wonderful at the book, i hope she can make it well
chinosita 1 year ago
you do know that theyve been in a movie together previously?
he was in the outtakes of vanity fair (the movie) as her son....lol which i find rath amusing myself ^_^
xLadyPattinson0o1x 1 year ago
I really like Reese, she is a great actress! I look forward to seeing the film! Robert is a very talented actor, so it will be so great seeing him starring with Reese!
VictoriaGil23 1 year ago
@kipandabear95 haha u kno wat they say great minds think alike :p lolz
grace123p 1 year ago
ugh i hate d circus... D: ANIMAL CRUELITY! but othr than dat i CNT WAIT 2 C ROBBERRRRT PATTTERRRSONNNN~!
grace123p 1 year ago
@grace123p the book is really good though. it actually talk about some of the cruel and unnessary things they did to the elephant :] its quite a good story
ManEatingSlug7 1 year ago
@ManEatingSlug7 then ill chek it out :D
grace123p 1 year ago
i can't wait to see this movie because of Rebecca Ostroff!!! the Women the hired to do a lot of the trapeze, she does a trick called the iron jaw that is only currently done by four people in the world!!! We were pirates in a show in NY... and she's awesome!!!
bmxmanzmh 1 year ago
1st...Rob and Reese have worked together before...2nd...i do agree with your guys point but let's not rush to conclusions...give him a chance...he's still trying to make his way in the business...and everyone just precieves him as edward...give him a chance.
LulusuzaForever27 1 year ago
Lovin' Reese, but Rob? Really? As Jacob? I was thinking about a bit more of an awkward boy...
I believe Marlena was older, because she was married to August, and he was a bunch older than jacob...im still very very sad they are making this into a movie. The imagery in the book was absolutely stunning and Sarah Gruel just...was incredible, Im very very sad they feel the need to transform this piece of literature into a movie, it was and is beautiful all on its own.
KellieCullen1901 1 year ago
@KellieCullen1901 what! I know her sarah why?
prettysufer 1 year ago
"Are you going to do circus stuff??" bahaha it's a circus dumbass of course!
I'm sorry byt Robert just sucks. He sucks at doing his hair, sucks at acting, and his looks just suck. oh well all they want to do is wash out the story with a big name cast and try to draw some attention from those twilight fans. I'll just stick to reading the book
PinkIce102 1 year ago
omg i read this book!! it was really good :D
cassie7373 1 year ago
This book was pretty awesome i just hope they do it justice nothing worse than taking a good bookand making into a fucking shitty movie
burnthebot 1 year ago 2
i. am. so. pissed. i live in santa barbara and they were shooting this movie in ventura which is minutes from my house and i didnt found out i was just minutes away from ROBERT PATTINSON until today. ughhhhh. i cud hav met himmm >X(
drink2theliars 1 year ago
Reese Witherspoon as Marlena and Rob Pattinson as the red-headed Polish-American Jacob Jankowski? What awful casting. That producers probably never read the book and are just working off the script writer's summaries.
10delaware 1 year ago
I hope they can make the movie as good as the book.. We'll see
xklynnx 1 year ago
Reese and Rob were awesome together in Vanity Fair, so I'm so excited for this! It's going to be great! :)
LuvRupertEvans 1 year ago 2
This movie is going to be an abomination. They couldn't have picked a more horrible cast, in my opinion.
Thunderkleez1 1 year ago
aaa omfg!!!!!!!
Ferxholaxwey 1 year ago
I'm exited for the movie, but I think Reese is a little too old for the role. I mean I wish Marlena would have been a little younger, but who knows it might turn out really good
estrellap101 1 year ago
They shouldn't promote the cruelty of circus animals in a movie. Elephants are endangered, and the elephant they are using in this movie, called "Tai", is a real, abused elephant forced to live in deplorable conditions. Quite sad...
FreedomForOrcas 1 year ago
Comment removed
lindsaytheatre99 1 year ago
I love this trio: Rob, Christoph and Reece! wow
TheArtesLiberales 1 year ago
god i love this book! im so excited to see christoph! its gonna be another slam dunk oscar if they do the movie rite!
CatiCullen 1 year ago
Reese is playing Rob Pattinson's character Jacob's love interest Marlena....she is the circus acrobat who works with the horses and Rosie the elephant.
edickins2 1 year ago
This book was so good! I'm so excited to hear that they're making a movie with it
nipntucklr 1 year ago
She's sooo friggin adorable
WilDnUnConTROlleD 1 year ago
Isn't Reese too old for the role? The character she plays is in her early twenties I believe. No offence against Reese though.
teddinax 1 year ago
@teddinax News said that she played Robert Pattinson's mom.
uoxouyukie 1 year ago
@teddinax yah, I kinda think Reese witherspoon was miscast, I like her, but from what Ive seen, I don't think shes perfect for the role.
ecarmosino 1 year ago
@ecarmosino yeah totally, i think the same. I think somebody with a fresher face would have been good. I just can't see her as Marlena and rob and her being in a love scene together. But still cannot wait for the movie though
BoRoKoLo 1 year ago
the book is amazing. I'm really excited, hopefully film will be good too.
VintageTypewriter 1 year ago
oh i have a sick weakness for Christoph Waltz! i want to marry him ahaha
CatiCullen 1 year ago
I can't wait to see this - because of CWaltz. Absolutely.
However, why is this guy kissing her ass so much?
merjones013 1 year ago
Robert is going to butcher this movie. For Jacob i completely invisioned Tobey Maguire or Ewan McGregor. Those two would have been more suitable for Jacob's lost and naive sense of his dilemas. As for Reese I wasn't too excited. Nicole Kidman would have made a better choice. I must say that i was very disappointed and mad when i read that the twilight-guy was being casted for Jacob. But i am happy that the book is being made into a movie!
dktuealdqw 1 year ago
@dktuealdqw Come on. Deep down, you're happy about Christoph Waltz. XD
merjones013 1 year ago
@dktuealdqw sorry what does Butcher mean?? lol sorry i feel stupid
LuvsToLaughGirl 1 year ago
@dktuealdqw He is actually a good actor but Twilight doesn't really give him justice and I think Reese is perfect for the role.
sunshinebeem 1 year ago
@dktuealdqw those are the most idiotic casting ideas yet. a dude whose 20 years older than the character. and a wimp, which goes completely against his description.
prouck 1 year ago
it's a great book, but the movie's probably going to suck
Lolzoidifed 1 year ago
@TheJoeCoolShow
I'm sure you are
InsanePuppy11010 1 year ago
I'm mad that Robert Pattinson is going to be in this.
BUT I'm going to give him a chance, JUST because it's Water for Elephants!
OMG SO HAPPY THIS IS GOING TO BE A MOVIE
InsanePuppy11010 1 year ago
ohh i can't wait to see this! Mainly because of Christoph Waltz!!! And what other 17 yr old says that?! ;) jk jk
8182570 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I can't wait to see this film. I loved the book and so far I'm loving the cast.
Christoph<3 I re-read it recently and picked up on a few hans landa esque 'death glare' moments :P
Witherspoon will make a really lovely Marlena.
EWHopkins 1 year ago
I can't wait to see this film. I love the book and so far I'm loving the cast!
Christoph <3
I re-read it recently and picked up on a few hans landa esque death glare moments :P
Reese will make a really lovely Marlena.
EWHopkins 1 year ago
Christoph and Reese working together sounds interesting. I like Reese. From what I've seen, she's a talented actress and I'm looking forward to seeing her in this adaptation.
coralin378 1 year ago
I cannot wait to see Reese and Rob work together....
reenata36 2 years ago 86
@reenata36 You forget Waltz : )
gege3017 1 year ago
Reece played Rob's mum in Vanity Fair! wow! theyve got catching up to do!
Loopyloualways 2 years ago 10
I cannot wait for this film! To see Rob, Reese and Christoph all on the same screen will be amazing. Reese may be older than the character is meant to be but so is Christoph, it'll work out. The book is brilliant and I can picture all 3 in their parts.
roadtoglory 2 years ago 42
DEFINETLY!
2write2sing2dance 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she is so wrong for the part
BondGirlx 2 years ago
COME ON. She's a brilliant actress, and she will be wonderful with Rob and Christoph in this movie. Christoph himself is a little old for the part - good, liberties like that can be taken - but no one complains. She looks GORGEOUS, face and everything is perfect. Casting is perfect.
2write2sing2dance 2 years ago 2
Loved this book and the casting is perfect
Marlena128 2 years ago 4