Beyond Reality - American Idol Results - Top 12 Revealed

[ZeldainPark]

lmao time to put asses in stools...strippa take ur pants off and sit in a stool

[sarahbearak20]

Aw, you said Luke was cute! lol

[kristinajeantwin1]

I freaken loved Danny!!

[fattymcthin222]

you too are weird

[dogstyleslut69]

the old lady is so annoying...

[BubblewrappedHeart]

Dark Haired William Sledd...

I THOUGHT THAT!

[littleasian894]

Ramiele Malubay is FUCKING FILIPINO! So stop saying that she is fucking chinese or japanese! GEEZ! I'm filipino so that is racist 2 mi if u think she is chinese or japanese! She has hot vocals!

[davidarchuletafan7]

How Old Is Maddie? lol

[cvaguy]

Rosie offers Danny a free cruise trip.

I thought it was interesting. Danny's fame will certainly extend beyoud idol.

watch?v=0ZeMpQkfCME

[Maserati777]

I love Kristy Lee Cook, I love female country singers like Carrie Underwood and Martina McBride. I liked Asia'h but she had 3 bad performances there

My original Top 6

Michael Johns

Brooke White

David Cook

Asia'h Epperson

David Archuleta

Kristy Lee Cook

I was hoping Robbie and Colton would make it, I'm glad Danny didn't. Don't like Ramiele. Thought Syesha and David H would go home, glad Kady and Luke went home. I predicted 10/12. I thought Danny & Asia'h over Syesha and David H.

[kristinajeantwin1]

thats rude

[9francis]

awesome job you two.. thnx for recapping...

nyway i think these are most likely the ones who are gonna stay longer...

Carly smithson- for sure... highest range on girls..

david archuleta- for sure agen... likable , great performer

Ramiele Malubay.. my favorite... cute, likable, mad vocals

Michael Johns- great vocals and charisma

Syesha Mercado- high range of vocals, though having problems at low notes

[Mizery06]

I completely agree w/ you about Amanda...I'm so over her. hahha..."This is not DeGrassi"...gotta love that show. Anyway, I love your recaps...I watch the show...but I still love to watch you guys recap it and hear your thoughts. :D I can't wait to see the Top 12 on the big stage this week!!! yay!

[ComfyChic92]

My God, I know! Who the heck is voting for "Cruella"?? She sucks! Asia'h should've stayed over her.

[cvaguy]

I'd rather send Amenda home than send Asia'h home. Asia'h is so much fun. Same goes for Danny. He is so fun to be around !!!

[marc0angel0]

I work weeknights now so I don't get to watch American Idol anymore when its on. All I go by now are the clips from youtube and your recaps. I like the top 12 but I was there during 2nd San Diego auditions and I got to root for the ones who auditioned there--chikezie, carly, michael, david f--and definitely david a.

[chiandp11]

hahah you guys are funny but assholes

[xxCherryLove]

i agreed with everything you guys said.

i also wouldve picked asiah and more importantly danny :(

except i like david a. more than carly

but carly is my favorite for the girls.

[purplemus6]

LOL. Danny is like a dark haired william sledd.

I LOVED DANNY!

[clr4444]

I adore you both and check out your videocasts each week on my fave reality shows. You both are ferosh.

[velocity246]

Danny would have brought so much personality to the Top 12. TMTH!!!

[obsessong]

Thanks again, nice ladies. I always look forward to your recaps.

[RowanPrincess]

What do you mean, Paula's track?  Dance like There's No Tomorrow?

[RowanPrincess]

I found your recaps/reviews last year & thought you were sorta funny, but this year I am cracking up every few seconds! Maddie, you are not annoying like people say. Janet, I love your laugh, & I love the things you say...the "Simon must have had his period" and "It was diarrhea"... I agree with most of your taste in the contestants. I haven't watched your reviews of anything else because I don't watch those shows. But you girls are making me laugh. Good on you both! Keep it coming!

[filmcritique08]

Danny should have stayed!!

[galaxygoose]

America Voted

and sent the right people packing

These are definatly the people I want to see on the Idol tour!!

[cheesepeasandcarrots]

you are not funny.

[stevenash1386]

i agree with the results

[evans54]

sorry- the right people got the boot

[AAG0541419]

I WANTED ASIA AND DANNY TO STAY!!! I am soooo pissed.

[dadmonson]

Girl on the right of the screen needs some braces BRONTO!!! HOW OLD ARE YOU? YOU SHOULD OF BEEN HAD YOUR JACKED UP TEETH FIXED!!!!

[AAG0541419]

ur an asshole!!!!!!!!!!!

[liina000]

what..the hell are you talking about?!Is it related to American Idol? don't think so.

[plasmatelevision]

dadmonson. You are an ignorant moron who should fade away. You need glasses and a brain. Go get a life . . no refunds on your pathetic, useless one.  Stop breathing please.

[frumpytuin]

you should shut up about her teeth. its none of your buisness.

[scareykatt]

William Sledd!

It did crossed my mind that Danny Noriega looked like William Sledd.

the same hair!

i wanted Danny to stay too.

[TomCollinsgirl]

You guys know I love ya. But Amanda is better than Brooke White who is annoying and like everyone else...which means Brooke is gonna go far

And as for Chickesie. I was shocked he got through. Happy but shocked

[kylerayner70]

Overall I was very happy with the top 12. I knew Luke would be going and the 2nd guy would be between Danny and Chikeze. Sorry guys, but I'm so happy Danny is gone. I truly thought he was going to be this year's Sanjaya and just not go away. But yeah!!! he's gone. As for the girls, I agree with you both, that Asia should have stayed over Kristy. And skunk girl (Amanda) should have gone as well. Wow, maybe she's this season's Sanjaya and won't go away. Yikes!!

[bspeezzzyy]

Oh, it's not really beatboxing. It's vocal scratching, two different things.

[bspeezzzyy]

He just beatboxed the "I'm through" part. Don't know what you guys are on about.

[eFlyFowler]

I didn't like that Malubay chose song ''against all odds' well it's ok if you choose a song by Phil C. but this song was covered by Mariah Carey so why didn't she choose another song ?? mr Collins has many interesting ones.

She is like keeping on same tradition as all Asian girls trying to become Mariah Carey or thinking they can make it better.

It's the same as other people try to sing a Whitney Houston song. Well for this she is not going to win it.

[eFlyFowler]

John had his only good ending of the song this time imo. I actually think Amanda is better at rocking than him. Everyone likes John because he is the only one looking like a young daddy and well with a clean background.

(meaning not former striper)

[Kryer98]

Thank you both for recapping this show three times a week, which I'm sure takes a ton of time. Glad you'll be getting a break from here on out.

[liina000]

Danny Noriega was so my favorite of them ALL. I just cried like a dork when he was eliminated. ughh. he wasn't the best singer and probably wasn't going to win but I LOVED HIM AS A PERSON. He's was so sincere for me and just such a sweetheart. I wish him the best of luck. *weeping*

[paspossible16]

i couldnt agree more. Danny added so much perosnality to the show. and he was definately my second favorite male. he was awesome, and had great talent too. the show won be the same without him, but hopefully he wont be goin anywhere. i expect to see him doin big things in the future.

[Mekias]

I agree. He was the most entertaining and funny person on the show and I'm really sad to see him go.

How the hell can a no-talent gimp like Sanjaya make it far in American Idol but Danny, who's voice is 1000 times better doesn't make top 12?

[interkid]

poor luke, kady, aishia, and danny