Added: 2 years ago
From: wrjnjcc
Views: 17,503
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (68)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • good voice- bad dress

  • This is My all Time favorite song off her Recent album, haters who say she can't sing Like she use to??? WELL thats Bullshit and not true, This song I think she did SO EXTRODINARY and She Uses her voice so amazing and extrodinary in here that Its Mariah Carey Writing a song about Life and WOW!!!! CRT FOREVER

  • my sister is the girl in the cube! latrina bolger :)

    the guys name is terry.

  • who says this is not live it is in every possible way

  • I Love you 4ever and always.. This is my favorite song off the album.. She really took alot of her to do this song you can tell.. She is so fantastic... PERIOD!! Their will never be a woman like her that can make me say You are my hero 4ever and always..CRT forever

  • DIVA Forever

    Number One

  • The best singer on The Planet, Always and Forever CRT, I love you From The Bottom of my heart, Thank you so much for giving me hope everyday of my life.

  • I love you From The Bottom of my heart, Always and Forever CRT, Nothing in this whole world can change that... Thanks for being the Best of all time, and My hero, Love Always CRT

  • bridge part of the song is live until 2:54. love MIMI

  • I'm 90% sure she lips the ending... It's very possible that she pre-records a 'live' vocal that she can mime to so that it sounds different from the studio version. I've compared similar (but different venues) performances of this, and the end chorus is always flawlessly identical, right down to every little vibration and nuance. It's not like that vocal came from nowhere tho, she can DEFINITELY sing. The fact that it may be pre-recorded doesn't mean it's not real talent!

  • @SonicEther it is...the only parts of this song that were sung live in the who tour was the adlibs during the first 2 chourses

  • i love MC sooooooooooooooo much, but i think that its a small dress for her. 

  • awesome performance! I saw her at the Hard Rock in Hollywood, FL and she sang this just as well there, live!

  • beautiful woman,song...voice! =)

  • She is singing live. i just saw her here in houston on feb 17. she sang that song and she was amazing! her voice is amazing!!!

  • i love mariah.... she fat now...is she pregnant?

  • its never live when we acually watch it though..i mean on youtube

  • love the song...love d mariah.. :)

  • I'm tired of the haters... Mariah Carey sung the hell out of this song and she did it LIVE!!!!! She still has it and all the haters are just afraid to admit the girl still has the goods!!!!! I LOVE this song, performance, and her flawless voice!!!!! AWESOME!!!

  • omg ofcourse its live it has to be!! when people pay singers to sing for them they HAVE TOO SING! and when they are on tv or summit that can mime of sing its upto the singer... but as this is an concert MAriah carey had to sing live..... and by any means she is AMAZIN!

  • she qainedd weiqht in a qudd wayy. beautiful voice

  • beautiful performance..i love her

  • love it

  • for people who is saying this isnt live go buy the album and c for yourself

    MARIAH IS #1 NO MATTER WAT ANY1 SAYS!!!!!!!!!!!!

    L4L!!!!!!!!!!

  • @mariahfan3277 Thank you so much I Toatally 100000000% agree with you... I love this woman forever

  • I sat front row for one of MARIAHS VEGAS SHOWS..THE VERY FIRST ONE on SEPT 11th.. That was the first time she sang this song...WOW!! and with the dancers.. I had tears.. I WAS LIKE WOW!! THAT IS DEF. A GREAT SONG!

    MARIAH CAN SING VERY VERY WELL LIVE...BUT.. SHE USES SO MUCH OF HER VOICE IN ALL RANGES..CHEST HEAD FALSETTO, SUPERHEAD..ALL THE TIME.. IT IS REALLY HARD TO SING THE SONGS SHE WRITES>> LIVE SHE HAS ALOT OF POWER...! AND SHE DOES SING LIVE..

  • omg love the dress!!

  • Great job. Love you Mariah!

  • have u ever wonder y she doesn't do many concerts?!

  • i do

  • she never lips at concertS!

  • Beautiful!!!!!!!!!!:))))))))))­))

  • wow!!

    very good Mariah !!!

    ILOVEU so much!!

    i love this song.!

    this is the reason why i love u so much!! ^_^

    your not using throat voice anymore, your using your chest voice again! ^__^ i love your voice so much! :))

    love u all lambs!! this is warara22! my account is disabled because i post a video of Mariah that have a copyright. haha!

  • Ims so happy you guys think this is lip cause that mean she is singing unbelieveble and 100% live !!IM so happyy!!She just amazing if it goes around voice GO MIMI

  • I really hope her Label UNIVERSAL RECORDS release her 2003 CHARMBRACELET Live Tour DVD and this new 2009 MARIAH LIVE in VEGAS at the Pearl on DVD... Plus her DEC 31 New Year's Eve MARIAH LIVE on MADISON SQUARE GARDEN NYC Special Concert on DVD release for 2010!!!

    Can't wait... Everyone, Yall better go out and buy MARIAH CAREY New #1 Album MOAIA - In Stores Now!!!

    Also Check out and Dont forget to Buy her "MOAIA - THE REMIX ALBUM" COMING SOON !!!!

    and her Movie TENNESSEE on DVD in JAN 2010!!!

  • sshe going on tour in 2010!! yesss

  • this is 100% Live Performance from MARIAH, as much as possible she SANG Live.. not unless shes doing tons of promotional tours here n there, thats when she sings 50-50 Live and/or Lip syncing or with Back up.. Otherwise MARIAH can still SANG and she SOARS high whenever she does it... MARIAH always Delivers and Outsang 'em other Wanabe DIVAS out there trying to copy her Vocal styling n techniques!?!

    Go Out and BUY Mariah Carey newest 17th Album #1 Hit - MEMOIRS OF AN IMPERFECT ANGEL... Buy it!!!

  • you are very good lamb

  • It's a playback but she's still singing along with it. So it's not 100% live.

  • the ending is definetly 100% live and i think the rest is

  • i have the album, its definetly not live, at least the belting at the end

  • THIS IS LIVE....she even had different version from the original recorded compared to this one...

  • beautiful dress

  • I've listened lots of times to this version and the album version, and I can say that it's live at least for the most part

  • A M A Z I N G.......lost her voice..but i dont think she'll stop singing..to damn talented...thats why shes the best.........cant believe she still in the game..luv u mariah...u rock.......

  • ifs hes "too talented" how can you say she lost her voice? she never lost her voice, its always been there..but she does not get enough full rest

  • I am a fan of Mariah but I don't belong to those who deny the fact that she can't sing live. We c

  • ROTFL, the funniest thing I've ever read.

  • Why is it so hard to believe that Mariah can't sing her own songs live. She has sung live time and time again with those bonified live peformances being identical/better than the recorded versions. Cut her some slack! After years of singing her ass off she has vocal nodules/damage. If she has to lip sometimes then so be it. She could have the surgery but that would risk her losing that amazing voice forever. Not worth it IMO!

  • Of course its live lol.

  • Esa barriga no es normal!!! she is pregnant!!!

  • too amazing for words!!!

  • dont understand why ppl so jealous by the fact that mariah can sing well live!!

    it's clearly live !!

  • prove shes lipping

  • Anyone who has the album can tell instantly sh's miming - it is note for note exactly the same as the CD. I'm usually the first to defend Mariah but I can't be oblivious to the fact that she is blatantly miming this.

  • i beg to differ, although i respect what your saying, but the ending is completely different from the studio version

  • Def not note for not, but most of this is lipped.

  • No! Anyone who has the album can tell that that for the most of this song she is singing LIVE!

  • Muito bom *__*

  • Love this Song e this performance GARALEOOOOOOOO

  • Pregnant ?

  • seriously! i think so

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more