Added: 5 years ago
From: marilliononline
Views: 704,010
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (743)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • not from these earth

  • i said it before and i will say it again AMAZING GENIUS

  • @daz2736 thats right ;)

  • I'm crying. it's amazing.

  • Pete's bass is awesome in the first verse.

  • Real music for real music lovers. Tremendous. Marillion fans check out Nathan Holme on You Tube - he'd be a great support act and a star of the future

  • <3

  • Even though I am just 16 I can say that this song is my soul. Someone so sensitive, romantic and and yet so alone. It's so hard. To be a person who likes that music, because really most of the people could never understand the true beauty of it. You are my favourite band, please keep going for people like me! We need your music...

  • @nadeto9696 I'm with you, bro! I feel the same way. It's a shame that more teenagers don't listen to this because it could help them feel better about all of the BS going on in their lives. This song truly makes me feel better whenever I feel sad or alone. Bad things may happen, but at the end of the day, this song is always there.

  • Had this been a Pink Floyd track would have met the rock classic acclaim this is good as any thing Pink Floyd done if not better a total masterpiece

  • ‎...Some people think I'm somethin'

    Well you gave me that, I know

    But I always feel like nothing

    When I'm in the dark alone......Beautifull song and words...And I hope I will land someday in Neverland;)

  • por DIos...no puedo dejar de escuchar a este grupo tanto con Fish., como con Mr. H. ...me provoca adicción!

  • One of the most moving performances ever.I love this band

  • with out a doubt there finest moment so far

  • Desde que salio a la venta Marbles no he podido dejar de escuchar esta maravillosa canción...una vez más queda desmostrado que los años pueden pasar...y que una excelnte canción permanecerà en el tiempo, canción delicada, sobresaliente, emotiva, todos los instrumentos con sus notas precisas, la voz expectacular..Mr.H canta con pasión y con el corazón, el ambiente perfecto...marillion realmente brillante. AL escuchar marillion mi vida es màs espiritual y ha despertado màs mis sentidos. :)

  • @carlitos210920091 tienes toda la razon!! y sabes? es raro escuchar comentarios de este tipo de musica en español que acaso esta prohibido que los latinos nos expresemos de este tipo de musica o musica que no sea en español!!??

  • @carlitos210920091 Ayer hiba en el camión, mientras miraba por la ventana escuchaba una serie de canciones (tux on entre ellas), que dije para mis adentros "esa banda toca muy bien", pero al llegar a esta rola sabia que antes de bajar tendría que preguntarle al chofer el nombre del grupo y pues... aqui me tienes. Te digo lo mismo que le dije antes de bajar: -Tendras malos ratos, pero no malos gustos-

    Saludos.

  • The world's longest power ballad right here

    

  • Wow, great bass playing in this song. I don't usually pick up the bass lines on most Marillion -- the guitar and keyboards tend to dominate, except on Fugazi,, which was my favorite album, and LOVED Ian Mosley on the drums.

  • soo beautiful thank you marillion for so many good songs

  • I want to run my fingers through his hair :)

  • Rothery ouzes Class

  • Comment removed

  • What a great great song

  • Fish's voice was more like Peter Gabriel's so Marillion was first compared to Genesis as a copy... (they were very similar, which is why I liked Marillion). I saw both performances... and while I did prefer the Fish concert.. Horvath has matured and come into his own - as well as the band. Not a Genesis clone any longer. Actually Genesis sold out to pop and I haven't liked them since Duke/Abacab. Marillion has improved with age.

  • es increible el comentario de fish, fue el vocalista fundador por lo que siempre sera marillion con fish para los que vivimos esa epoca, es como que guns &roses no tocara mas con axel no seria igual, no por eso despreciamos a hogan pero la banda inicial fue fish y fue su voz la que gusto en aquel momento.

  • Sorry guys... Hogarth, not Hogan...

  • Yeah! Steve Hogan, or Mr. H... Much much better than Fish...

  • to the enigma in my life i give all i have to give and this song says all the words i cant say x x

  • I totally agree with that, The era with Fish was great and since Steve joined the band they really have made fantastic music. 28 november i'm going to see them in Amsterdam for the .. time !!

  • @broes1966 that´s right, i think the same, was a great era for marillion and for fish the master of the art & excelent singer.

  • i love this gays

  • hermosa cancion se le dedico a mi mas grande amor

  • One of my favorite songs of all the time :P

  • so.. beautiful.. :')

  • How can 29 people NOT like this jewel ? I just don't get it... What is wrong with them ?

  • @Helene44400 is just because they love Lady Gaga. b-sides don't worry, not everybody can feel this kind of timeless sense.

  • @Satiaraha LOL

  • I've been listening to this song ALOT, but , but when I had the opportunity to read the lyrics...WHOA! I love it even more.

  • I loved Marillion with Fish, but this is an amazing performance by Steve H. Steve Rothery is still a God

  • @IchBinAbschaum22 I KNOW, wimpkins! ;o)

  • Hogarth is a GOD!

  • ▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬ஜ۩۞۩ஜ▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬

    SHUT UP AND ENJOY THE MUSIC!

  • grandiosi

  • Does it get more Beautiful than this marillion gem, NO? ;o)

  • No other human can produce so much passion in their words.

  • Rewelacyjny wokal...

  • to jest zajebiste !!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • "Brilliant"

  • AWESOME!! CHILLS!! BRILLIANT!!! & PLEASE COME TO THE U.S.A!!!!! ASAP!

  • pure magic music with heart and soul

  • Dios mio, que banda tan extraordinaria.

  • Steve Rothery es el alma de Marillion

  • 27 dislikes,why;;;;;;;;;;

  • very good, in barcelona samye.es

  • i love this song.thanks for all your beautiful songs.love from portugal

  • never never never land land neverland neverland... greeeeeeat

  • great video!!! check this Mr. Green's Garden - Neverland (live)

    watch?v=5TslajereFw&feature=re­lated

  • Hey, people! We are The Elastic Ones & The Normal Ones.

    We are making a musical experiment inspired by the free way of playing music that searched some bands in the 60's.

    We try not to limit ourselves with "normal music standards" like tempos, tonalities, styles and other "prejudices".

    We only try to express yourself with an instrument.

    If you want to hear it and share your impressions with us, you are welcome to do it here:

    s o u n d c l o u d . c o m / e l a s t i c o n e s

  • Кажется можно бесконечно наслаждаться каждым аккордом этой песни, каждым звуком этого восхитительного голоса.

  • .... I can stand anything when you're with me ......

    such a touching song - love it

  • Wow! Best song in the universe ... amazing

  • I am strictly a' fish' era fan, but i saw this the other night live on tv and thought it was utterly superb! Steve Rothery is probably one of the most underated guitarists of all time ever. He is absolutely superb! Sitting here with goosebumps all over. Amazing!

  • Still getting goosebumps listening to their tunes.

    I grew up to their music in germany living now for a long time in the US and nobody ever heard about Marillion here

  • Amazing! Who else can do solos on vocals?

  • @gerardch David Gilmour.

  • almost cried watching this video. fucking awsome

  • This is such a great song - H rules

  • this sure aint nothing like cinderalla search, tux on, he knows you know.

    NOT MUCH LEFT, SORRY !

  • @TheMproductions no THIS is a fuckin' 1000 times better, baby.

  • SOMEBODY WHO TELL ME TO WHO IS DEDICATED THIS SONG PLEASE??? IS THAT WENDY THE DEVIL I AM GOING IN CRAZY PLEASE HELP ME CAUSE I BELIVE IN GOD BUT I AM SO SCARED I DO NOT KNOW THE REAL LYRICS OF THIS SONGS...!

  • @rocketbelt1 - It's about the Wendy in Peter Pan

  • Comment removed

  • @rocketbelt1 Just search for "Steve Hogarth talks about Neverland" here on Youtube :)

  • One of the most beautiful and poignant songs ever written.

  • H brought Marillion to a whole new level. Fish was good but H is great.

  • Such a soul touching song...absolutely awesome, out of this world...

  • Who do people ALWAYS have to compare Fish and h???????? The one used to sing in the band, the other does sing now. Both are great. Let it be.

    For heaven's sake.

  • Comment removed

  • @vardebo

    could not have said it better myself. they are both amazing!

    

  • @vardebo

    Very true and if they split after Fish left, a lot of great music may never have been written/recorded.

  • @vardebo yap great voice he has. but fishs the jester-branded in his voice. thats what iam missing.

  • Breathtaking song from an excellent album

  • Hogarth is such a better vocalist that fish. granted marillions style is different now. they were more like genesis back in fish's day. but hogarths vocals are so much clearer and suit this style better.

  • Ten utwór jest boski nuce go całymi dniami to solo az mam dreszcze

  • Love Marillion been lissten to them for 30 years this new singer is amazing he sings with is Soul.

    Never give up,keep doing what you do :) 

  • Never heard these guys before. here in Australia it's virtually impossible to ever hear prog-rock or prog-anything. Radio doesn't play it. A real tragedy. This was excellent. So much like Genesis, Camel, Floyd.

  • Mr. H - there's nobody like you. Keep doing what you're doing - you're AmAzInG

  • @companyof8 ... agreed.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • 27 twot's :D

  • Visit our channel: rock-prog band Gran Torino: our album is coming in 2011: grantorinoProg.

  • un groupe phénoménale depuis 30 ans que je le suis et que je l' aime....

  • It's incredibly moving and musically inventive. No wonder they're not rich! And (here's the real point) they keep doing it anyway. Perhaps in 200 years, musicologists who are asked to name the best rock bands ever will automatically answer "Marillion, Pink Floyd and Rush". History will judge......

  • is there a non live version on youtube

  • F A N T A S T I C ! SO SOULFUL!

  • I was introduced to prog music from a man I met through yahoo. It was a whirling relationship; one that I wish hadn't had to end. Because of him, I stumbled across Marillion and was WOW'd to say the least. When our relationship ended, I stopped listening. Then, the other day, I found the song that attracted me to them on my cell.... "No One Can." And, now, here I am .... absolutely WOW'd again!!!

  • Ripping it right out of their chests for all to see! A show of grace, subtlety and undeniable Power that only music can give to us all! Yes, fine sweet magnificent Marillion - we hear you!

  • Best Marillion ever

  • Comment removed

  • Why is this band not accorded the recognition it deserves? Sometimes I think they're a beautiful secret I was somehow fortunate enough to be privy to.

  • Steve Rothery ......cudo gitara,a tak lubiłem Marillion z Fish-em.....teraz tylko Steve został:(

  • @polonista36 Steve właśnie najlepiej to robi nowy wokalista jest super bez zastrzeżeń

  • Thats Hogarth not Fish dude

  • wow marillion rule they just get better and better fish you can tell just put his sole into this steve rothery's guitar just blows me away.....

  • Steve Rothery, you are my favourite guitarist, theres Jimi Hendrix, Kirt hammett and Zayke Wylde, to name a few, but you kick em all, your awsome!

  • Thank you.

  • I like the song, and I love the bass and the guitar. And that guitarist Steve knows what Strats are all about--once you go Strat, you never go back.

  • very very nice..!

  • Magnifique, οι παλιες αγαπες κρατανε υποσχεσεις

  • marillion are by far the greatest band ever , including the fish era , so hard to choose so i dont both excellent , but this track just hits every emotion , cant stop playing it , not just the H vocal but the guitar work is just reminiscent of the early 80,s , THANK YOU

  • Quite happily have this played at my funeral .. Seen these guys live over 20 times , Played this track hundreds of times. Never fails to send a chill up the spine , never fails to leave me tear stained and red eyed . Pure emotional magic

  • All I can say: Thanks so very much Marillion - for making such beautiful music !!!

  • it feels so wierd seein my very distant relative playin keyboard for like a huggeeee croud!!! really random comment i just wanted to say it!

  • need find what cd this on ,anyone help?

  • @24367852 It's off Marbles. The one or the two disc will hace this great song.

  • @24367852 marillion - marbles live ! neverland - one of the best songs from "new" marillion !

  • ned find what cd this on ,anyone help?

  • oh man..i love his voice

  • The Marillion really thought that way after the Fish. Soon after his departure the band got a little lost, but over time has produced beautiful songs. Hogarth has an amazing voice. Great band!

  • Comment removed

  • Totally stunning track. Brilliant album and great band!!!

  • gran tema grande steve hogar ojala ven gan chile nuevamente los esperamos marillion lo mas grande

  • @gzloneoprog trato de no tener prejuicios pero con hogarth perdio mucho del toque sinfonico progresivo, solamente una buena pieza

  • @marillionfan65 HERMANO RESPONDEME ALGO ESTA CANCION A QUIEN ESTA DEDICADA? AL WENDY SERA WENDY EL DIABLO ESTOY ASUSTADOO PORQUE ME GUSTA MUCHOO ESTA CANCION Y YO CREO EN DIOS SERA QUE ME EXPLICAS DE QUE SE TRATA QUIEN ES WENDY? PANA ME ESTOY VOLVIENDO LOCO GRACIAS BROTHER

  • Great Band, great Song, great Riffs. MaxwellBurdick what you have to perform?

  • I wish they renamed themselves after Fish left.

  • i Go on their concert tomorrow!!! in memmingen germany.

  • thank you.yesterday i saw them as support from deep purple.great.

  • saw them on Marbles, Happiness and Somewhere tour and this is still one of the best live songs they do. fukin ace

  • 4 my wendy love you always xx

  • This is beautiful, there's no words for it... I mean, damn! Look at H while he sings! For Fuck Sake... "When you're with me, I can stand it".

  • this is a seriously great performance.

  • I was there when the great man that is ' H ' was singing this LIVE and believe me they are just brilliant and i have liked them since i was 11 and they only seem to get better long live MARILLION

  • this is marillion at their very best............classic song classic performance

  • Steve Rothery has become a fat bastard, since the Fish era. But he is playing absolutely brilliant in this number. I am not into the Hogarth era, but must admit that this number is very beautiful. So maybe I will buy the CD and give Hogarth a chance.

  • @JesperPip Well.... Fish is also a fat bastard.... an adorable one, of course

  • Long Fuckin' Live Marillion!!!

  • Io ADORO Hogart.... la sua passione è palpabile e mi mette i brividi ogni volta!!! Non vedo l'ora di vederlo a Milano al Blue Note a Dicembre!!

  • tu ne cesses de me hanter ... Vivie... depuis ce maudit 15 fevrier 2009!

  • à consommer sans modération, frissons des pieds à la tête garanties.....

  • This Band IS COOKING here ! Yes. I just joined the "virtual crowd" to this online show* We are really pumped up for this art and soul. This band is one tight MF'R

  • Fantastic performance, you feel it comes from the heart!!!

  • great classe

  • I'm tired of this stale debate, Fish vs. H. It's like Roger Waters vs. David Gilmore. Each and every one of them had a fantastic contribution to the Music and we should be grateful for that. Why do we go so low every time and, instead of enjoying the magnificent music, we impose/express opinions who's better? Fish was the lead singer 20 freakin' years ago.

  • But it's over for every day for the last 20 years. He had a immense contribution to what Marillion WAS. If you like him so much, go listen his post-Marillion songs and stop posting lame comments. Don't like H? So what are you doing here then? Just polluting with useless noise? Let's give H. ALL the credit he deserves for what he has done until now and be grateful to Thy for the chance to have Music. And hats off for the rest of the band. All this debacle reminds me of 'Beautiful' lyrics.

  • was a fishman but this does me nice F in awesome

  • Rothery's guitar work here is fucking amazing!!! Brilliant track - thanks for the great post!

  • cliquer sur mon nom et laisser vos comm.c'est un morceaux pop rock

  • Glad to be a 'Wendy'

  • Steve Rothery rox! Awesome as always

  • Steve Rothery rox! Awesome as always!

  • superbe chanson super album marillion est grandiose fish est grandiose vive le prog

  • @MultiReboot no man, YOU suck. Fish was amazing, but the best thing in Marillion is play of Steve Rothery, who is genious. Best feeling ever. Not Gilmour, not anybody else, not fastest metal guitarist, feeling of Rothery destroys everything. No matter who he plays with - it doesn't matter if it is Fish or Steve Hogarth.

  • I saw Marillion at the High Voltage festival a few weeks ago - it was a great performance and as the evening light faded in the sky and we were left with just the stage and spine tingling music.

  • Longue vie a marillion ... excellent !!!

  • @timouth144 oui.. longue vie , trés longue vie!!!!!!!!!

  • It's crazy, I keep listening to this song over and over again...very addictive !

    I like the love song lyrics in the first part...moving ! It seems that h went through a very emotional period prior to the Marbles album (listen to Fantastic place, You're gone, etc.)

  • I rediscovered Marillion again in the last year after a loooong period out in the wilderness. It has been such a joy to explore the post Fish era. Perfect, thanks for your music.

  • @TheFuturetraders funny you should say that, been listening to marillion since the mid 80's and they kinda fell off my radar towards the mid 90's as my moods shifted to simpler more stripped down music. Lately I was thinking I was in the mood for a Bold, Full, Emotional musical experience and the first band that popped in my head was these guys

  • just found marillion

    and wow

  • Been a fan of Marillion ever since Misplaced Childhood,I don't think I can find a track I haven't liked or hasn't grown on me very quickly.I had the pleasure of seeing this track performed live a few weeks ago at Leamington...Was knocked over by it completely live! LOng live Marillion!

  • One of the most beautiful song I heard! 

  • if that dont blow you away nuffin will superb from buttsy in rayleigh essex

  • mejor banda de todas , lejos

  • Este que esta cantando colega é o talentoso steve hogarth que assumiu u lugar do outro talentoso fish.

  • I have been a marillion fan for 18 years now, and still give them plenty of ear play. I now think both eras of the group are good ,in their own right. It took a fish to get me hooked.

  • absolutely love this track,

    and what a performance too, fantastic stuff

    long live Marillion

  • la cago,es una cancion que la dedico con todo mi amor a la mujer que me hizo muy feliz mientras estuve a su lado,cote,aun te sigo amando,jamas te olvidare,perdona todo el daño que te cause,jamas fue mi intencion de hacerte sufrir,te amo y recuerdo mucho.

    carlos s.

  • Comment removed