Purtroppo questi sono incidenti che possono succedere. E sono successi anche ai più illustri pianisti. Ricordo negli anni '70 durante un recital a Torino un drammatico "blocco" di Arrau all'inizio della Polacca op.53 di Chopin.Il pubblico restò raggelato,poi scoppiò in un fragoroso applauso di solidarietà per il grande pianista.Ma quando ciò accade durante le prove in un concorso internazionale significa la fine..
Come on, she obviously knew the piece very well and played the bits she played well marvelously. The mind does weird things in recitals. I mean when I performed Moonlight Sonata, I screwed up mvt 2, the "easy" movement.
Shut up loosers, there was another 57 minutes of music on this round played very well, besides overall 4 hours of music on that competition. Keep practicing and searching your problems :)
She was probabily stressed! But she plays with such easy, and she is very expressive, she never forgets to make music and not only notes. This is how the Etude should be played.
Hey - we're all mere humans. Overall, it was very good. And you WON, right? nuff said . . .
I bet half the people complaining couldn't play this difficult piece THIS well. Besides, keeping your fingers on the black keys without them slipping off in itself is worth the gold.
Gorgeous sound and musical.this is one of the eassier etudes so it was nerves and that tells judges you ain't ready to concertize full time.she looks really young but what a nice round pedaled sound she always makes.I'dlike to hear her in a long sonata see how mature her thinking is and what the sound is under different degrees of pedal.I likw wht newtonewmusic says i will try that. it helps when yiu know wht kew u inand where u are going when u practice too.
She has lots of potential. Great feel for the piece and her balance is very good. But pianists, who normally perform as soloists without music, need to learn the music differently. I practice by starting in different places all the time. I will play just one hand -- from memory! You'll have fewer memory slips because your mind will have more points of reference to rely on.
I'm not interested in her mistakes, which were probably nerves or memory slip. What I found interesting was how well she recovered. A good recovery is sometimes a crucial and necessary skill of a professional. Bravo!
Haydenbrooks83, EASY? Don't your hands slide off the black keys? And don't you miss them? Lol Sometimes I even miss some of the keys. I think this is so hard, and mainly because of the speed of course.
I support this woman. The parts she played well were superb; so she lost her way 3 times, the overall impression was to me (and I know this piece very well) superb. Just a case of jangled nerves which can happen to anybody. To those gloating here and having a bit of infantile fun; grow up, be human and get your own butt up there and play it yourself.
this is fucking legendary recovery. Fuck, this slip should be STUDIED, this is truly superb. Dis chick has da moz insane tech I have ever heard - not one extra movement!
I can understand her winnings! She is an excellent technitron at the piano. Any listener that doesn't know the piece would probably have given her thumbs up. Those of us that do could, still easilly give her thumbs up, she still made a fantastic performance of a peice she obviously had a 'blank out moment' in. Who of us could pull that off as smoothly as she??
Brava! She handles the slip very professionally. Some people said that they can't see that something went wrong. It's quite possible that the jury respected her ability to forge through. I made the same mistake in the LH pattern (at the end when it repeats) when playing this piece as a second encore following a difficult recital program in Buenos Aires 3 weeks ago (Rach/Horowitz Sonata 2, and an all Liszt second half). I was tired. I think whoever posted this should be ashamed of themselves.
thats not professional not to know the other harmony even the second time she dont know it.everybody could hear it,thats not proffesional.that could never happen to a real musician.i am sure she dont know the theorie behind this piece.
Did anyone notice the black key octave glissando at the end? It is really the only way of playing the triplet semi-quavers at the same speed as the rest of the piece.
That picture, of Chopin i guess, was like "looking" over the pianist, didn't you see. In the Fastish Part with the octaves the Picture is on top and Chopin, or whoever it is, is looking. WEIRD
I wish I could play this with only a few errors. My hands keep sliding off the black keys. She is obvious an OUTSTANDING pianist. But we're ALL human. And she may have been simply nervous in front of the audience. She still is FABULOUS!
Idiots she can out play allof u in these etudes. this was a competition -all kinds of pressures plus playing with ensembles and newly comisined or unknown beforehabd works. shut up sissies! If she was playing thewhole op10 first book her musicality presents itself. she is young.Italian. i know she didnt win though.
now i'm no expert of how long you should be at what age. she's pretty young. but mistakes like that should be a thing of the past at about age ... 7. i want to estimate from 3-5 you got the basics. 6 you're polishing off a nice little repretoir. 7 you're doing more difficult pieces. in the teens you're tackling that modern crap that i can't stand or even understand... who wants to listen to disonant 13th aolian in F flat minor. [shivers]
poor girl??? it doesent matter if a musician makes mistakes, we are not robots... is the musicallity, the expression that counts and defines good pianists (sorry for my english)
Your English is fine; there are worse native English speakers on YouTube.
Either way, what you're saying is true: Either way, musicians all have their bad days and their good days, and as Mahler (I think Mahler) said, the performance is merely the final set of mistakes, or something along those lines.
Finger or memory mistakes don't actually add to musicality though, do they. Though if your performance was robotic in the first place, it might become more interesting on account of a few slips...
some of the greatest pianists had memory slips. Competitions need pianists like the other way round too. luckily I no longer strive to be up there. I play for fun and find the more relxed my mind the beter the playing.
lol. i find it funny cause where she made the first mistake, i also very often have to stop. also without being nervous, and i play at 50% of her speed. i guess it's cause this part starts with right hand similar to a part before, but it's not the same.
This kind of thing happens to even the very best and although it seems pretty bad to those of us who know the etude, she did a masterful job at covering and anyone not familiar with the piece would never even know what was wrong!
lol are you ok, you hysterical thing? I just said there's one mistake and nothing more. even the greatest pianists make mistakes, so WAKE UP! and if your hands keep sliding off the balck keys, you should practice more.:-/didn'te get your point..
operaeater, but why point them out to those who don't know this piece well? Just let them enjoy. What they don't know won't hurt them in this case. lol
She's obvious an excellent player, but just got a little nervous because she's human like the rest of us. It's still pretty good.
@brehum like at 0:21 and 1:07 she repeats what shes already played and lost her place in the music... and please dont tell me you didnt hear 0:28 =/... but seriously we need to stop searching for mistakes... ye sure we hear them... but everyones human and if we werent we would all sound stale =/....
ChopinLipatti, no, but I see the comments now and how it refers to "her." Yes, thank you. She sped up and slowed down. I'm so surprised because obviously she's really good. It's nerves. Maybe her first competition.
It is very unfair to post only the video of this Etude. She played extraordinarily the whole Opus 10 ! I think people should enjoy the emotions of a concert, not the mistakes!
that was sloppy playing, unsteady and a harsh sound. plus the two gigantic slips, one where she stopped. how could she have won. are you sure of this?
You got through it, and you won, so be happy, I guess. You have the technique likebarnold81 said, but it was just the brian cramps. Wow. I feel for you, but you still won. I don't think I would have posted this though, sorry.
She probably just practiced it a little too much in segments and not enough play throughs before performance. It happens. Technically very well played. Bravo! I would only laugh if it got stuck in an endless loop that went on for several minutes. That would be funny, but I can't ever see that happening. Get over the mistake dude.
I agree with everything you said, except for dude because she's not a dude, she's a dudette. lol
I think she was very nervous at a competition and just had brain farts. That's happened to me many times whereby you just forget because you're trying too hard. My heart aches for her, but she WON! So she should be glad about that. I wonder what the others sounded like...
Questo è profondamente ingiusto: è stato un momento di cedimento all'interno dell'esecuzione integrale degli studi op.10; a parte gli incidenti in questo studio, la sua prova è stata SUPERBA... E' una cattiveria postare un video simile togliendolo dalla serie completa.
Per la precisione il suo nome è Dinara Nadzhafova, ha 17 anni e non ha vinto il primo premio, bensì il secondo ex-aequo con Sofia Gulyak
this can hapen is not a musical problem, normally musicians with soul and feelings get nervous, they are not a machine, and in competitions, the jury wants machines...
se questa partecipava l'anno scorso col piffero che arrivava seconda....io gli avrei dato un terzo sia a lei e pure alla Gulyak....che guerra dei poveri quest'anno!
Senz'altro il livello di quest'anno è stato bassino. Cio' non toglie che questa ragazzina di 18 anni abbia sostenuto un insieme di prove di tutto rispetto.
Sei di una cattiveria infinita. Ha sporcato un po', ma non credo che sia quello il problema. Affari tuoi che giudichi un pianista dal numero di note che sbaglia.
ahahah....glissan ma te ne intendi un minimo di concorsi o per te il busoni è come il concorsino di paese?il busoni è il concorso dei migliori...ci sono stati anni che non hanno assegnato il 1°premio a pianisti della madonna non si sa perchè...e poi quest'anno mandano in finale 1che non fa una riga giusta!ma per favore...
How about uploading some of the best performances now? As far as "fuck ups" go, this really is nothing compared to the bad joke that is your own performance of op. 10 no. 1. You should be ashamed of yourself for having the nerve to judge this.
datruzepp: You tell him. We're ALL only human and make mistakes. So WHAT? You're very young. Just try again, and again, and again until you finally get it right. I loved the way you played this difficult piece. I wish I could play it half as fast and as good. And so does User Name cziffra1980. He's just JEALOUS!
the same people that talk trash about a yundi li perfect recording or kissin performance diss you for uploading this saying it's not right to do that, I don't really get it
everybody can make mistakes.. Nadzhafova is a very talanted young pianist from Russia.. This is not common for her!! You should opload some of the very good peformances of her! Everybody can hear that she is a great pianist..
ahahaha she wuz actually quite LEGENDARY at da hamamatzu n wuz one of da SDC favz fo dat competition. da SDC view diz az her CG tribute to da LAPZE WINNAH of da hamamatzu. n da jury, az evidenzd by deir decizion, clearly undahztood diz piece of CG 8)
anything can happen on the stage. As for her memory slips, she does not stop. No problem, and no need to discuss the worst performances of legendary performances. Lets discuss the best.
I think you're being quite rude, it's far too easy to criticize the others. Everyone can make mistakes. She is very epressive. Besides she didn't actually win the competition. She was awarded the second prize ex aequo with Sofya Gulyak.
Dinara Nadzhafova is capable of a sincere and high-quality playing and this clip is only showing that she is a human. Even with the accidents she has here it's clearly a well-learned etude.
When a pianist is making mistakes like this, there is something completely wrong with his/her musical intelligence. And she really won the competition? Unbelievable.
Stop patronizing us the actual piano players who watched this didn't give her a hard time!
chrissyluvspeace 4 months ago
I love your descriptions... so out of place... lol
chineseporcupine 5 months ago
Purtroppo questi sono incidenti che possono succedere. E sono successi anche ai più illustri pianisti. Ricordo negli anni '70 durante un recital a Torino un drammatico "blocco" di Arrau all'inizio della Polacca op.53 di Chopin.Il pubblico restò raggelato,poi scoppiò in un fragoroso applauso di solidarietà per il grande pianista.Ma quando ciò accade durante le prove in un concorso internazionale significa la fine..
schonklang 7 months ago
@schonklang
Infatti lei ha vinto...
liszt80 3 months ago
Come on, she obviously knew the piece very well and played the bits she played well marvelously. The mind does weird things in recitals. I mean when I performed Moonlight Sonata, I screwed up mvt 2, the "easy" movement.
atee12321 8 months ago
Shut up loosers, there was another 57 minutes of music on this round played very well, besides overall 4 hours of music on that competition. Keep practicing and searching your problems :)
vzaimno 1 year ago
how the hell did she win??????????
anonymousQ45 1 year ago
She was probabily stressed! But she plays with such easy, and she is very expressive, she never forgets to make music and not only notes. This is how the Etude should be played.
liszt80 1 year ago 2
It's hard to mess up the black key etude. :|
demosj 1 year ago
Hey - we're all mere humans. Overall, it was very good. And you WON, right? nuff said . . .
I bet half the people complaining couldn't play this difficult piece THIS well. Besides, keeping your fingers on the black keys without them slipping off in itself is worth the gold.
Nice video worth posting.
TheLovelyPiano 1 year ago
.....the fuck is she doing? You can't play like this in an International competition. And you say she went on to win? BLASPHEMY, I SAY.
LetTheMusicFlow1 1 year ago
Pls never juge pianists for their mistakes. One more pls write in English.
bartoszthiede 1 year ago
the second time of the maintheme went wrong :(
dsyglym 1 year ago
Who is she?
e57uard0 1 year ago
@e57uard0 Dinara Nadzhafova
robshelrobshel 1 year ago
After reading the description I expected she'd shit herself or something.
katzenrubbl0r 1 year ago
What was the mistake?
Tsobanian 2 years ago
Gorgeous sound and musical.this is one of the eassier etudes so it was nerves and that tells judges you ain't ready to concertize full time.she looks really young but what a nice round pedaled sound she always makes.I'dlike to hear her in a long sonata see how mature her thinking is and what the sound is under different degrees of pedal.I likw wht newtonewmusic says i will try that. it helps when yiu know wht kew u inand where u are going when u practice too.
lovesGenet 2 years ago
without missing a beat... that's an amazing recovery....
chineseporcupine 2 years ago
Is this realy winer?
predoje 2 years ago
hahahah the unforgiving cold-stare of da Bus
jefftam1234 2 years ago 2
I don't care about the f*up. wonderful piano sound.
marvelous musicality.
gainweighttoday 2 years ago 3
She's hot. Serious.
juice797 2 years ago
She has lots of potential. Great feel for the piece and her balance is very good. But pianists, who normally perform as soloists without music, need to learn the music differently. I practice by starting in different places all the time. I will play just one hand -- from memory! You'll have fewer memory slips because your mind will have more points of reference to rely on.
newtonewmusic 2 years ago
All that weight in her shoulders helps her in this piece secure her wrist action, no doubt. Compared to a thin weak man.
username1p 2 years ago 3
It can happent...
She, Dinara has been performed all 24 etudes on this competition and got 1 prize.
I think she was just stresst or tired.
gercog88 3 years ago 2
I'm not interested in her mistakes, which were probably nerves or memory slip. What I found interesting was how well she recovered. A good recovery is sometimes a crucial and necessary skill of a professional. Bravo!
Chopinesque 2 years ago 3
She made a mistake but how she fixed it was very good!
thepianist213 3 years ago
What is her problem? Misstakes all the time-_-
addeex1 3 years ago
yes i agree these are triflingly easy pieces for me
afertyus1000 3 years ago
sarcasm?
ytfarmer90 3 years ago
yup,just a little,i was responding to the daft comment by addex1 [maybe that was also sarcasm?]
afertyus1000 3 years ago
this etude is quite easy. I am working on op 25 no 6 at the moment - that one is difficult.
Haydenbrooks83 2 years ago
Haydenbrooks83, EASY? Don't your hands slide off the black keys? And don't you miss them? Lol Sometimes I even miss some of the keys. I think this is so hard, and mainly because of the speed of course.
You must be more advanced than I.
I think she did very well on this piece.
Tlllllllllllllll 2 years ago
you have to keep your fingers a bit rigid if that makes sense. If you do a lot of arpeggios it should be easy.
Haydenbrooks83 2 years ago
It's sort of funny how you bluff
ciliaspippi 2 years ago
I support this woman. The parts she played well were superb; so she lost her way 3 times, the overall impression was to me (and I know this piece very well) superb. Just a case of jangled nerves which can happen to anybody. To those gloating here and having a bit of infantile fun; grow up, be human and get your own butt up there and play it yourself.
nearenough3 3 years ago 7
Totally agreed.
josimarneto 3 years ago
what second is the slip?
callenishss 3 years ago
this is fucking legendary recovery. Fuck, this slip should be STUDIED, this is truly superb. Dis chick has da moz insane tech I have ever heard - not one extra movement!
Fuck, dis vid. Daim,
respect da zepp
mkaykov 3 years ago
hahahah da DIARRHEA
ProfessorSuckMah 3 years ago
I can understand her winnings! She is an excellent technitron at the piano. Any listener that doesn't know the piece would probably have given her thumbs up. Those of us that do could, still easilly give her thumbs up, she still made a fantastic performance of a peice she obviously had a 'blank out moment' in. Who of us could pull that off as smoothly as she??
okera123 3 years ago 2
Smooth cover up!
danceofthegoblins 3 years ago
lol I was expecting something completely different as I watched this. "da DIARRHEA, in her final recital round performance"
highart2003 3 years ago 2
Well, bit hurried, ain't?
zuknula 3 years ago
banned 8)
John11inch 3 years ago
poor girl... :(
Must have been having a bad day.
beryllium2 3 years ago 3
Well, it happens! She just won the competition, she must have been tired!
glantz91 3 years ago
Brava! She handles the slip very professionally. Some people said that they can't see that something went wrong. It's quite possible that the jury respected her ability to forge through. I made the same mistake in the LH pattern (at the end when it repeats) when playing this piece as a second encore following a difficult recital program in Buenos Aires 3 weeks ago (Rach/Horowitz Sonata 2, and an all Liszt second half). I was tired. I think whoever posted this should be ashamed of themselves.
PianistDG 3 years ago
thats not professional not to know the other harmony even the second time she dont know it.everybody could hear it,thats not proffesional.that could never happen to a real musician.i am sure she dont know the theorie behind this piece.
Achtelnote 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I think she did it intentionally
chopinandliszt 3 years ago
Busoni disgusted!
framaulo 3 years ago 2
haha
piedijon 3 years ago
I belive you play it a lot better! Loser! And she didn't mess it up after the mistake. But I belive you do it a lot better.
Pianisteny2k 3 years ago
You guess right, if you mean to play "Chopin etude op.10 n.5". But if you mean the stuff the girl plays, I'm not sure.
framaulo 3 years ago
Have you asked her, the pianist who plays, before you putted this video on you tube.. did you tell her that you will put the video on the site?
hoknokmik 3 years ago 3
Did anyone notice the black key octave glissando at the end? It is really the only way of playing the triplet semi-quavers at the same speed as the rest of the piece.
GypsyPianist 3 years ago
She really handled this beautifully. The true sign of a professional.
trschaefer 3 years ago 4
That picture, of Chopin i guess, was like "looking" over the pianist, didn't you see. In the Fastish Part with the octaves the Picture is on top and Chopin, or whoever it is, is looking. WEIRD
AZazaxe 3 years ago
Actually that picture is of Busoni...
chlrldud74 3 years ago 2
She had stage fright, other than that, she truly is an amazing pianist!
AZazaxe 3 years ago 2
I wish I could play this with only a few errors. My hands keep sliding off the black keys. She is obvious an OUTSTANDING pianist. But we're ALL human. And she may have been simply nervous in front of the audience. She still is FABULOUS!
YGYGYGYGYGYGYGYGYGYG 3 years ago
Idiots she can out play allof u in these etudes. this was a competition -all kinds of pressures plus playing with ensembles and newly comisined or unknown beforehabd works. shut up sissies! If she was playing thewhole op10 first book her musicality presents itself. she is young.Italian. i know she didnt win though.
lovesGenet 3 years ago
now i'm no expert of how long you should be at what age. she's pretty young. but mistakes like that should be a thing of the past at about age ... 7. i want to estimate from 3-5 you got the basics. 6 you're polishing off a nice little repretoir. 7 you're doing more difficult pieces. in the teens you're tackling that modern crap that i can't stand or even understand... who wants to listen to disonant 13th aolian in F flat minor. [shivers]
shakaama 3 years ago
amazing i think! she didnt stop! luv her,, she can be inspiration
wildejagdlover 3 years ago
wow she made several mistakes. after paying attention i was like HOLYMOLY. poor girl.
shakaama 3 years ago
poor girl??? it doesent matter if a musician makes mistakes, we are not robots... is the musicallity, the expression that counts and defines good pianists (sorry for my english)
visionfugitiva 3 years ago 2
Your English is fine; there are worse native English speakers on YouTube.
Either way, what you're saying is true: Either way, musicians all have their bad days and their good days, and as Mahler (I think Mahler) said, the performance is merely the final set of mistakes, or something along those lines.
bendmac52591 3 years ago
Finger or memory mistakes don't actually add to musicality though, do they. Though if your performance was robotic in the first place, it might become more interesting on account of a few slips...
stringph 3 years ago
some of the greatest pianists had memory slips. Competitions need pianists like the other way round too. luckily I no longer strive to be up there. I play for fun and find the more relxed my mind the beter the playing.
chad410 3 years ago
You gave up because you sucked.
WENCHINGTON 3 years ago
that too.
chad410 3 years ago
good player but bad performance
ouch
rankfrankrank 3 years ago
How can she be the winner??
jero13595 3 years ago
lol. i find it funny cause where she made the first mistake, i also very often have to stop. also without being nervous, and i play at 50% of her speed. i guess it's cause this part starts with right hand similar to a part before, but it's not the same.
suriya883 3 years ago
hahaha my best friend fucked up opposite way during a competition in Italy: he went directly to the finale: the etude lasted 20 secs!
voolare 3 years ago 2
lmao i could totally see how that could happen with this etude
chunlee02 3 years ago
Wonderful!!! I just think the real culprit here is the unreliable b***ard MUSCLE MEMORY!!!
SecretPianist38 3 years ago
good play...but fingers speedy than a brain..:(
Svarniovci 4 years ago
This kind of thing happens to even the very best and although it seems pretty bad to those of us who know the etude, she did a masterful job at covering and anyone not familiar with the piece would never even know what was wrong!
Grigor99 4 years ago
you're right, I kept waiting for the mistake and never heard it. The whole thing sounded great to me.
brehum 3 years ago
I don't mean to be rude but there was obviously a mistake : 0:27 - 0:28
operaeater 3 years ago
operaeater, no kidding? Read her info, Eintein! Was that your way of letting us know that you're familiar with the piece? Duh...?
She's obviously a phenomenal piantist, but she's also human.
YGYGYGYGYGYGYGYGYGYG 3 years ago
lol are you ok, you hysterical thing? I just said there's one mistake and nothing more. even the greatest pianists make mistakes, so WAKE UP! and if your hands keep sliding off the balck keys, you should practice more.:-/didn'te get your point..
operaeater 3 years ago
operaeater, my point was that she knows she made mistakes and didn't need anyone to point it out to her. The video is entitled:
nu #1 BEZ FUCK UP
So she knows she made mistakes, tyvm.
Bye! and peace!
; )
YGYGYGYGYGYGYGYGYGYG 3 years ago
well I was not pointing the mistakes out for HER, but for the viewers who don't know this piece well.
operaeater 3 years ago
operaeater, no problem.
YGYGYGYGYGYGYGYGYGYG 3 years ago
operaeater, but why point them out to those who don't know this piece well? Just let them enjoy. What they don't know won't hurt them in this case. lol
She's obvious an excellent player, but just got a little nervous because she's human like the rest of us. It's still pretty good.
PianoCriticsKiller 3 years ago 5
well the title of the video says it all, people are looking for the "fuckup" and I help them to find it;)
operaeater 3 years ago
ahahah rezpec, ur hearin iz az gud az moz of da jury membahz'
datruzepp 3 years ago
@brehum she kept repeating parts she had already played =/ ... commmon mistake
maddorox 1 year ago
@brehum like at 0:21 and 1:07 she repeats what shes already played and lost her place in the music... and please dont tell me you didnt hear 0:28 =/... but seriously we need to stop searching for mistakes... ye sure we hear them... but everyones human and if we werent we would all sound stale =/....
maddorox 1 year ago
ChopinLipatti, no, but I see the comments now and how it refers to "her." Yes, thank you. She sped up and slowed down. I'm so surprised because obviously she's really good. It's nerves. Maybe her first competition.
Thanks.
Dudette0007 4 years ago
to Metroid9824 ,christian6657 and organboi :
upload your video like : "Me practicing with...". I'd like to laugh a bit too
vzaimno 4 years ago
I think Diarrhea did good.
Metroid9824 4 years ago
It is very unfair to post only the video of this Etude. She played extraordinarily the whole Opus 10 ! I think people should enjoy the emotions of a concert, not the mistakes!
liberacecarebil 4 years ago 5
agree
christian6657 4 years ago
that was sloppy playing, unsteady and a harsh sound. plus the two gigantic slips, one where she stopped. how could she have won. are you sure of this?
organboi 4 years ago 5
would someone explain tome why this is a mess up or anything?.
ChrisWatch 4 years ago
You got through it, and you won, so be happy, I guess. You have the technique likebarnold81 said, but it was just the brian cramps. Wow. I feel for you, but you still won. I don't think I would have posted this though, sorry.
Dudette0007 4 years ago
She probably just practiced it a little too much in segments and not enough play throughs before performance. It happens. Technically very well played. Bravo! I would only laugh if it got stuck in an endless loop that went on for several minutes. That would be funny, but I can't ever see that happening. Get over the mistake dude.
barnold81 4 years ago
I agree with everything you said, except for dude because she's not a dude, she's a dudette. lol
I think she was very nervous at a competition and just had brain farts. That's happened to me many times whereby you just forget because you're trying too hard. My heart aches for her, but she WON! So she should be glad about that. I wonder what the others sounded like...
Dudette0007 4 years ago
I was talking about the poster, not the pianist. I don't get why people are so amused and post these.
barnold81 4 years ago
barnold81, I agree. Post the best, not the worse.
Dudette0007 4 years ago
Questo è profondamente ingiusto: è stato un momento di cedimento all'interno dell'esecuzione integrale degli studi op.10; a parte gli incidenti in questo studio, la sua prova è stata SUPERBA... E' una cattiveria postare un video simile togliendolo dalla serie completa.
Per la precisione il suo nome è Dinara Nadzhafova, ha 17 anni e non ha vinto il primo premio, bensì il secondo ex-aequo con Sofia Gulyak
metiu182 4 years ago 3
datruzepp. Why are you such a cock up?
SolarJakee 4 years ago
She's very talented. She's only 16 or 17.
Tonedeaf101 4 years ago
how did she win? she is good i guess
koifuyt123 4 years ago
in fact, she plays BEAUTIFULLY.. she ought to win.. she has true musicality
fichan25052505 4 years ago 2
this can hapen is not a musical problem, normally musicians with soul and feelings get nervous, they are not a machine, and in competitions, the jury wants machines...
efraingonzalez 4 years ago
se questa partecipava l'anno scorso col piffero che arrivava seconda....io gli avrei dato un terzo sia a lei e pure alla Gulyak....che guerra dei poveri quest'anno!
fatinaLushina 4 years ago
Senz'altro il livello di quest'anno è stato bassino. Cio' non toglie che questa ragazzina di 18 anni abbia sostenuto un insieme di prove di tutto rispetto.
Glissan 4 years ago
e poi dicono che ai concorsi non ci sono i raccomandati...
Scusate ma la fà una riga di spartito giusta?
.........................
nino1712 4 years ago
Sei di una cattiveria infinita. Ha sporcato un po', ma non credo che sia quello il problema. Affari tuoi che giudichi un pianista dal numero di note che sbaglia.
Glissan 4 years ago
Se si dimentica mezzo brano come posso giudicare sull'insieme?
nino1712 4 years ago
ahahah....glissan ma te ne intendi un minimo di concorsi o per te il busoni è come il concorsino di paese?il busoni è il concorso dei migliori...ci sono stati anni che non hanno assegnato il 1°premio a pianisti della madonna non si sa perchè...e poi quest'anno mandano in finale 1che non fa una riga giusta!ma per favore...
fatinaLushina 4 years ago
che miserie che arrivano in finale al busoni..
nino1712 4 years ago
How about uploading some of the best performances now? As far as "fuck ups" go, this really is nothing compared to the bad joke that is your own performance of op. 10 no. 1. You should be ashamed of yourself for having the nerve to judge this.
cziffra1980 4 years ago 2
ahahaha tru da beztfuckup zeriez vil be poztponed until u zend me all of yo home vidz.
rezpec yozelf n keep praxin!
datruzepp 4 years ago
datruzepp: You tell him. We're ALL only human and make mistakes. So WHAT? You're very young. Just try again, and again, and again until you finally get it right. I loved the way you played this difficult piece. I wish I could play it half as fast and as good. And so does User Name cziffra1980. He's just JEALOUS!
Marvelous, Darling, Marvelous!
: >))
ScrewTheUSA 4 years ago 3
It's the only piece she played bad. She played like a god the rest of the program. Shut up, little envious...
mcvanby 4 years ago
the same people that talk trash about a yundi li perfect recording or kissin performance diss you for uploading this saying it's not right to do that, I don't really get it
PianoPlaya123 4 years ago
HAAHAHAH da playah cummah!!!
rezpec 8)
datruzepp 4 years ago
everybody can make mistakes.. Nadzhafova is a very talanted young pianist from Russia.. This is not common for her!! You should opload some of the very good peformances of her! Everybody can hear that she is a great pianist..
Mucicboux 4 years ago 2
ahahaha she wuz actually quite LEGENDARY at da hamamatzu n wuz one of da SDC favz fo dat competition. da SDC view diz az her CG tribute to da LAPZE WINNAH of da hamamatzu. n da jury, az evidenzd by deir decizion, clearly undahztood diz piece of CG 8)
datruzepp 4 years ago
english please
djCRH 4 years ago
anything can happen on the stage. As for her memory slips, she does not stop. No problem, and no need to discuss the worst performances of legendary performances. Lets discuss the best.
mkaykov 4 years ago
I think you're being quite rude, it's far too easy to criticize the others. Everyone can make mistakes. She is very epressive. Besides she didn't actually win the competition. She was awarded the second prize ex aequo with Sofya Gulyak.
Isadoralotus 4 years ago
ahahaha do you also happen to have Alexej GORLATCH's chopin sonata2 from hamamatsu? That is another TRUE first prize winning performance, rezpec 8)
datruzepp 4 years ago
I have Gorlatch playing Chopin sonata2 in Chopin Competition 2005, and his whole performances from Hamamatsu =)
w3sp 4 years ago
HAHAHAHA upload the movement 2 from his hamamatsu performance 8)
datruzepp 4 years ago
Dinara Nadzhafova is capable of a sincere and high-quality playing and this clip is only showing that she is a human. Even with the accidents she has here it's clearly a well-learned etude.
daredash2005 4 years ago
Jeez, since this competition isn't so strict, it shouldn't be difficult getting first place...
NeoComposer 4 years ago
When a pianist is making mistakes like this, there is something completely wrong with his/her musical intelligence. And she really won the competition? Unbelievable.
FlorestanEusebius 4 years ago
ahahaha harsh, but it iz tru
datruzepp 4 years ago
What does this have to with diarrhea?
lonesaku 4 years ago 2
ahahah tiz her sdc name
datruzepp 4 years ago
Haha, you actually searched for "diarrhea", didn't you? :D
Skryabinist 4 years ago
Maybe Dr. Dahlman's video to conquer diarrhea, besides, a lot of diarrhea is posted on this site...
pianopera 4 years ago