i don't play GH but in other vids i've seen when you hit the notes they actually sound like you made that sound but in this vid i don't know its like you're just pushing buttons and there's a song playing...
carefull i don't say how not-realistic this is i'm saying that its not well coordinated...
Am the only one who thinks that sometimes, just sometimes, the other instruments get charted instead because they're funner to play? I'd rather play the crazy solo of another instrument than the same riff on guitar during said solo.
AhahaahAHAHahah, you play the saxophone solo on a guitar!!!
man, I just hate these games. People should get a life and learn to rock for real. That's why times are changing, everything is virtual, and nobody knows how to create good stuff. They just copy and paste...
I understand playing sax along with it. Easy mistake to put in extra instruments. But he's playing bass when there is guitar playing. This is guitar hero.
actually those who complain about the bass intro might be wrong, in my Making of the Dark Side of the Moon dvd says a guitar part is played over the bass
I don't see why people are freaking out about it being unrealistic. First off, it's a game. Secondly, in Rockband you can play Clint Eastwoord by the Gorrilaz and all you do is play the harmonica if your on guitar.
I don't mind playing the bass in some customs, but in Clint Eastwood, you play harmonica, piano, and a couple of DJ scratch effects, because there IS no guitar. If they charted bass on that song for guitar, it'd be boring.
There is. In fact the original demo is played by Roger Waters alone on an acoustic guitar. If you ever watch them live, the guitar plays the opening riff with the bass.
uhh... Its not supposed to be so realistic that he only plays the guitar its a fuckin custom idiot. He trying to make a fun chart to a great song who cares if he put bass and a sax part, it makes the song fun. Plus the chart is excellent in musicallity.
is this the bass chart?
1896danr 3 months ago
This is really how guitar hero would chart this song, saxophone and everything. I would totally play this song.
BassExpert666 3 months ago
Hahah it's funny how there's a chat for the Sax solo. This ain't Sax Hero!.... Hmmm there's an idea
tylerlovesthebeatles 8 months ago
i don't play GH but in other vids i've seen when you hit the notes they actually sound like you made that sound but in this vid i don't know its like you're just pushing buttons and there's a song playing...
carefull i don't say how not-realistic this is i'm saying that its not well coordinated...
Me4nM4ch1ne 9 months ago
@Me4nM4ch1ne I agree. I haven't tried making my own charts, but with some of these you can tell the creator didn't put much effort into them.
MattyBoy714 9 months ago
@MattyBoy714 i am uploading My chart already its a Little harder than this 1 its Still: Money from Pinkfloyd
bovb902 8 months ago
hahahahaha cool vid!! claps are incredibly off beat during star power im not trying to bitch though!!! so cool its on the game!
zeppelinrising 1 year ago
Am the only one who thinks that sometimes, just sometimes, the other instruments get charted instead because they're funner to play? I'd rather play the crazy solo of another instrument than the same riff on guitar during said solo.
Jezza40 1 year ago
AhahaahAHAHahah, you play the saxophone solo on a guitar!!!
man, I just hate these games. People should get a life and learn to rock for real. That's why times are changing, everything is virtual, and nobody knows how to create good stuff. They just copy and paste...
reddykiko 1 year ago
I like how you used the whammy bar according to the song.
zteven3000 1 year ago
@zteven3000 Actually in the real song its a tremolo effect, but I see what your saying
PinkMeddle41 1 year ago
I understand playing sax along with it. Easy mistake to put in extra instruments. But he's playing bass when there is guitar playing. This is guitar hero.
ExtraKawaii 1 year ago
I iss the old days where people didn't complain about how realistic a game is. What's wrong with using your... IMAGINATIOOOOONNNN?!
HowPettyful 1 year ago
Amazing how people make this.
furryp 1 year ago
@furryp I really wanted to make my own songs eventually, but then I got lazy :( And then I sold the game and controller :((
MattyBoy714 1 year ago
sweet!!!!!!!!!
bullydog31 1 year ago
Whose chart?
Sorry couldn't resist :P
PlankofWood1 1 year ago
@PlankofWood1
Haha, well at least you were joking! It's the people who seriously ask that I'm worried about.
MattyBoy714 1 year ago
Money, get back. I'm alright Jack keep your hands of my stack. New car, caviar, four-star daydream, think I'll buy me a football team.
GreatDestructo 1 year ago
actually those who complain about the bass intro might be wrong, in my Making of the Dark Side of the Moon dvd says a guitar part is played over the bass
dangaertner7 2 years ago
this is pretty good..i mean i cant do this for shit anyways but it really good ..and great song too...this is like one of my fav pink floyd songs
BradFWB 2 years ago
What the hell? They start clapping for you at the end! Why?! Is the audience tone deaf?!
hotelmario510 2 years ago
It's my imagination or in the first part the person who plays, plays the bass guitar??
1131074804 2 years ago
I don't see why people are freaking out about it being unrealistic. First off, it's a game. Secondly, in Rockband you can play Clint Eastwoord by the Gorrilaz and all you do is play the harmonica if your on guitar.
gettingsmited 2 years ago
Exactly. People these days are getting their panties in a bunch over how realistic a game is instead of just having fun with it.
MattyBoy714 2 years ago
I don't mind playing the bass in some customs, but in Clint Eastwood, you play harmonica, piano, and a couple of DJ scratch effects, because there IS no guitar. If they charted bass on that song for guitar, it'd be boring.
TheLongingSH 2 years ago
The bass part is also guitar part ( the main riff ), those little fills are made by a overdubbed guitar and keyboard.
BlastHardRock 2 years ago
i personally like the tracking, it's not as monotone as if you play only the lead guitar, and it's also suitable for worse players - relaxing song!
SummerPalmsSunshine 2 years ago
its weird how the bass and guitar parts got mixed together...
Tharovil 2 years ago
it's bass
emwjmannen2 2 years ago
most intelligent rock song that i ever heard & one of my favorites, thanks for playin it on GH
stranget92 2 years ago 5
love the song!
iruegas5994 2 years ago 2
Good job playing, got to be one of my favorite songs.
MrBlackhawk2010 2 years ago 5
Wicked !!
hipidude12 2 years ago
AWESOME
1berrycrunch8 2 years ago
guitar hero totaly screwed up the bass and guitar. it be better if they didnt mesh the bass line with the guitar chords!
OTknights666 2 years ago
SHUUUUUUUUUUUT the ffuck up kid, just watch the video.
Meier31 2 years ago
No.
OTknights666 2 years ago
Fuck up nobody likes you.
iruegas5994 2 years ago
Maby I am just too, well bassist.
OTknights666 2 years ago
that was cool its a good song
ilikepinkfloydmmmmmm 2 years ago
Idk if itz just my computer being retarded, but it lookz a ll slow, but other dan dat, gr8 job dude, i luv floyd 4.5 out of 5
WyledKlown 3 years ago
Really Cool!
I Play Sax For Real and It s Awesome You Get To Play It In Guitar Hero!!!
BTW:Im Not Good In Guitar Hero
Rock On !!!
ExtremeLonely360 3 years ago
Only if you count the 20 or 25 cents of a blank DVD. Other than that it really just takes a bit of time.
MattyBoy714 3 years ago
Funny the game starts with the bass instead of guitar. Usually the game waits for the guitar part.
Ratkill9000 3 years ago
sax and bass hero
vicariousli 3 years ago
whats wrong with good music? the point of the game is to have fun...stop being so literal
dogzone0918 2 years ago
lol whats wrong with sax and bass?? geez
vicariousli 2 years ago
you know what would be cool? :D
cesaragustincolman 3 years ago
you pass bass to guitar in the song
skullzao 3 years ago
can you not read?
jizzywhizzy 3 years ago
^ this person is a genius.
MattyBoy714 3 years ago
i know i think we should invent something called read it a good idea
mynameisamer 3 years ago
Actually I think in the intro there actually is GUitar played in the background.
bdawg958 3 years ago
There is. In fact the original demo is played by Roger Waters alone on an acoustic guitar. If you ever watch them live, the guitar plays the opening riff with the bass.
SuperDude2111 3 years ago
@mynameisamer, WOW. I mean, WOW. You have just revolutionised the way YouTube works! Give this man a Nobel Prize!
hotelmario510 2 years ago
someones gotta do PIGS man! I WANT MY PIGS!
Drjandm 3 years ago
niceley done
gaypplreadthis 3 years ago
wtf sax..
PatDaGreat 3 years ago
listen to Arnold Layne
Firecloud500 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Worse Charting ive seen so far but other than that good job =]
bigwill017 3 years ago
Bad Chart? Are you retarded?
thenoobassassin 3 years ago
are you retarded? it was mainly the bass parts. if you listen to the dong, you can here slight good guitar.
oneweelr27 3 years ago
uhh... Its not supposed to be so realistic that he only plays the guitar its a fuckin custom idiot. He trying to make a fun chart to a great song who cares if he put bass and a sax part, it makes the song fun. Plus the chart is excellent in musicallity.
thenoobassassin 3 years ago 2
yeah i know. cool your tits and go outside
aginnyboy 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
why does he have to play the trumpet part?
spypengyn 3 years ago
Sax, dumbass
ThatsWhatSheSaid0012 3 years ago 2
pink floyd is awesome
komakcozie 3 years ago 2
trudat :D i luv pink floyd
dangaertner7 3 years ago
the best song ever
toychaser2005 3 years ago
The guitarist and the stage fit so well for this song.
mrneufeld 3 years ago
cool song
sdog9999 3 years ago
great song great job
cjfootballer 3 years ago
Commando, the guitar plays along with the bass in the beginning. Gilmour goes along with Roger in the song. So that's fine. :P
GaryTheMan03 3 years ago
i think you were playing the bass guitar part at the beginning.. not bad!
Commando2936 3 years ago
and he played the trumpet solo
robocop1993 3 years ago
haha, saxaphone
FsEtNrDaEtR92 3 years ago
lol shut up im an idiot
robocop1993 3 years ago
nice chart. might make a good co-op song.... HINT, HINT!!!
RussiaNien 3 years ago
ahha, cool.
Seems like a different version, though..the guitar on the main verses sound less flanged.. hehe nice vid, tho. :]
xdrangedplya 3 years ago
Man i can play this easy, do you play this in Expert or on hard?
Mobstaz101 3 years ago
wtf??? he playing the sax with a guitar?
allistererich 3 years ago
why not, you play the synth in GH1 on Frankenstein?
024yeknom 3 years ago
and on the freezepop tracks :P
ajungulak 3 years ago
and on parts of knights of cydonia in GH3
Guccimon17 3 years ago
saxaphone hero? 2:13-3:15 lol
Glennzorz2 3 years ago
2:42 can be hammered..
nice work thought
diegospbr 3 years ago
I love how it breaks into sax
:)
girlypop11 4 years ago
i like how u do the tremelo illusion on the chords
cyberwaffles 4 years ago
it should be clive wilson playin all of these songs! lol
wowser77 4 years ago
nice job Pink Floyd rules
and thank you for making some mistakes and not useing gameshark 5/5
imfaga 4 years ago 2