Today 6.03.2012 our International trade minister Mustapha said. our atomic energy department had issue the temporary license to lynas to start operating the refinery very soon. Ignoring all the protests.
Stop the BN and Stop Lynas..... Who want to stay near Gebeng or Kuantan area..its very scarely......
I wonder why taking the risk of creating Lynas in the first place. Existing "Malaysia" has already problem of their own. Again, Creating more problem!
KANTOI !! Apa yg "Baju Hijau" nak sebenarnya ni?? Adakah kerana kita terpengaruh dengan Idea2 Songsang? Ataupun Syarikat di Malaysia ini diterajui oleh Rakyat Bumiputra Malaysia?
@knightryder7777 Eh bodoh!!!! What they processed are concentrated and the half-life is long.... If as safe as u say then u move ur house beside Ly as refinery .... Fuck you!!!! Bodoh u must be some pro government dog!!! Hidup rakyat!!!! Hancur lynas!!!!!!
ORANG2 CINA TAK BOLEH LAGI BERCAKAP UTK KEPENTINGAN MEREKA SEMATA2. BAGI MENJADIKAN MALAYSIA LEBIH BAIK. MULAI SKRG, TIADA LAGI KEPENTINGAN UTK CINA SHJ, MELAYU SHJ, INDIA SHJ. SEBALIKNYA MELAYU, CINA, INDIA, KADAZAN, MURUT, MELANAU, ORG ASLI,SEMUA KENA SEPAKAT, BARU BOLEH MENYEKAT KERAKUSAN UMNO/BE END DLM MEROSAKKAN/MEMBANGKRAPKAN MALAYSIA. AYUH SEMUA RAKYAT PELBAGAI KAUM,TOLAK UMNO BE END, SELAMAT MALAYSIA DR HANCUR... JGN BIAR UMNO BERTUKAR MENJADI RAKSASA YG TAK BOLEH DI SENTUH LAGI...
My sources suggest this statement re. bitumen is not correct at all. Right now (2012), there is a major clean-up at a low-level radioactive site in Bukit Merah near Ipoh - many years after the site was closed. It was operated by Mitsubishi. There are SIGNIFICANTLY elevated rates of leukaemia & other cancer amongst locals - this can be checked with Dr. T. Jayabalan who is all too aware of the REALITY of safety in low-cost toxic-processing plants. If its safe, then let it be done in Australia.
Fuz is such a great HR puppet-meister. She gets much emo mileage from scaring the crap out of everyone (Vinny + many voters!! haha). At 5:15 who do u think programmed him with an email of the 'whoooole' thing. I bet in her cynical aim to politicise the pissant-low level Thorium in Lynas's waste, she omitted the FACT that Bukit Merah workers took home & put HEAPS of TOXIC SUPER-CONCENTRATED Thorium waste right on their veggie gardens and therefore ingested it!!!!. Save Malaysia Stop Fuziah!
It's a lot better to avoid something unpredictable disaster!!?? why should we let ? we DONT GET ANYTHING.. unless u got 'something' ? even if so, tht something..money is null compare to the ppl's soul/safety. SOUL is more valuable-it affects many people.
What the hell were they thinking!! The conflicting statements of director-general of AELB - he said Malaysia’s laws on radiation are of a much HIGHER standard than the US or Australia, and Malaysia will be downgrading the standards if we followed Australian or American standards. But then again, he admitted the RIA of the Lynas plant near Kuantan was incomplete and not good enough - why license was given to Lynas in the first place????
I reckon- 1.The world needs non-chinese RE's REAL bad. 2. After all the hysteria, the gov will make Lynas stand on its toes to reach the highest standards possible (a good thing). 3. Lynas said it is going to bankroll Malaysian uni courses + R&D to constantly improve (a good thing) 4.The Fukishima HORROR will finally move this stupid war-world from uranium reactors (to get bomb Plutonium) to THORIUM BURNING reactors which CAN'T MELT DOWN & kill us. 5. In 12yrs TAX CASH rolls in - BIG TIME!.
There are very little economic benefits for the Malaysians if the LAMP project is built. 350 jobs? Just consider the significant risks involved for the people living in the Kuantan area. A plantation like this can destroy the lives of 700.000 people. The tourist industry will in any case suffer and reduce important incomes.
@blattmacher Yes,it is very little bit benefits for the malaysian, but huge benefits for the person approved this project..they are not care the people life in danger, Vote out BN....stop Lynas the only way to change the gov..
@cshong87 I know well the Bukit Merah wound, it was an important part of my own research into the global rare earth industry. A sad wound it was & still is, both physical & psychological. Look how it screwed you up!. Mitsub worked TIN TAILINGS with 5000% MORE Thorium than Lynas's ore(50 times!!!) and did so with UNBELIEVABLY SLOPPINESS - even for 1985!!. Mod. company management PLANs, IMPLEMENTs, MONITORs, CONTROLs, REVIEWs.
The hard lessons have been learnt. Policing is NOW in place.
@fargonebewdy I don't care. One time experience is already enough.
When the hypocrite government increase the sugar price, then said it is for people's good, making people eat less sugar and have more healthier life. Then on another hand, they showed their hypocrite attitude by doing other things that may be harmful to the people around. LOL. I will forever remember this.
If our government really learnt from past experience, they will reject Lynas like hell.
@cshong87 Kindly ask yourself : Is Arafura Resources going to kill oz folk around their plant in Whyalla South Aust.? Is Alkane going to betray & kill oz folk around their piloted Rare Earth plant in NSW? Is the U.S. GOV going to betray and kill Americans working their new upgraded Mountain Pass plant in California??? Is Canadian Orbite going to kill everybody around its new plant ? HAS the Socialist Republic of Vietnam now betrayed & killing its people in the NEW Showa Denco plant ? EH?
@fargonebewdy It seems like you want Malaysian to get cancers. Bukit Merah incidents had made so many people die, not enough is it? Want more people to die? You better go see Bukit Merah and ask the residents there, or else pack your things and leave Malaysia. Nothing in this world is perfectt, so I am not going to trust those technology used by Lynas, doesn't matter what the IAEA people said. After Bukit Merah incident, I will be very stubborn in this issue. So, don't think you can confront me.
Malaysians who support Lynas should GET OUT OF MALAYSIA. Those who support Lynas are only those who want Malaysians to die. Lynas supporters are those pengkhianat / traitor who betrayed Malaysians for their own benefits. So, Lynas supporters, pack your things and GET OUT OF MALAYSIA. BERAMBUS DARI MALAYSIA.
And, to BN, since you allow this bushit Lynas to operate here, you betrayed Malaysians also. I will forever remember this and will not forgive you forever.
@rosihantu1 Got some shares in Arafura's coming RE plant in Whyalla OZ - the one PKR Malaysians (and their oz shill R.Albrey) conveniently overlook . The fight against lies and misinformation will soon embroil Arafura as well. Reclaiming RE processing from China is essential. Lynas's integrity is being UNFAIRLY demonised by PKR + ignoramuses - this may occur to other processors - in Whyalla, Dubbo (Alkane) - Vietnam - USA - Canada - Africa. Some think it's a freaking reactor!! LOL
It's all right if Kuantan folks going against Lynas Project but please chase out this group of politicians who just pretend to sympathize but in reality they're just 'fishing' for the next general election. PKR is well known for their 'bad habit' of taking innocent people to street protest which is 'uncivilized' in the 21st century standard.
It's all right if Kuantan folks going against Lynas Project but please chase out this group of politicians who just pretend to sympathize but in reality they're just 'fishing' for the next general election.
All Lynas project supporters, including but not limited to EdmondKua, are all brainwashed by this stupid RUBBISH Lynas corporation. People like EdmondKua, betraying Malaysians, sacrificing Malaysian's health just for his son's benefits, should be expelled from this country. EdmondKua, 你这Lynas走狗，为了自己孩子的利益，出卖了马来西亚人，牺牲国人的健康，没资格做马来西亚人，给我滚出马来西亚，最好滚出这个世界。
@kenjilaihankee , btul, btul, btul. M'sia mmg ng yg kaya tp pemimpin x sdar diri da sebat duit yg sepatutnya diagihkan pd rakyat.Pemimpin yg dilantik rkyat kerjanya menjaga amanah tp sekarang pemimpin da pecah amanah
Bye Bye Vinny! - you did a GREAT job panicking the rakyat for Fuzzy Bear and her manipulative PKR bosses. You finally AWOKE to the FACT that the new Lynas plant will NEVER be another Bukit Merah and left - even with Dr Jayabalan in front of the oz embassy saying "if Mitsubishi can't handle it I don't think Lynas can because it has no experience doing this". Yeah sure Dr J. the 1985-92 "take it home and put it on ya veggies" ethos - and get cancer - sure is a HARD act to follow Doc! - you JERK!.
@fargonebewdy Why are you so eager for the plant to be built here? If you are a shareholder or Lynas than I understand why you are so eager for Lynas investment. But if you neither of those, why are u bothered with people protesting the plant? The country is not losing money - afterall we are not collecting any tax from profit made by Lynas. Creation of 400 job? Big freaking deal, you give a tax free incentive in Kuantan i can assure we can create more than 400 jobs.
bodoh !!! kata nak 1malaysia rakyat di dahulu kan.........penipu..kalau benar la.kau nak dahulu kan rakyat..kau tak akan terima LYNAS...MALAYSIA ni tempat kami..kalau MALAYSIA ni musnah..kami nak lari mana ??kau boleh laa..byk duit..makan duit rakyat...
x-men akan muncul di pahang tak lama lagi hasil produk dari Lynas, tahniah penduduk pahang.. x-men , cirinya kepala besar kaki bengkok matanya satu mcm dajjal ..
Even plastics and domestic rubbishes are too difficult for us to solve, let alone this "small amount" of thorium/radioactives waste! radioactive is a radioactive, so does a poison... not matter how small it is, sooner or later there will be a consequence.... CO2? cigarette? All start with small amounts... but how about after 20 years? 30 years? One more thing, NOW WHO THE FUCK WANT AN OUTSIDER DUMP A RUBBISH IN YOUR OWN BACKYARD?
@Fahimfermiside thats puzzled me... those fucking lynas fed the people a radioactives composite, they still dont like this video??? let me rephrase Tukartiub's "kalau betul2 selamat, kenapa tak buat kat Australia yang berjuta kali lagi besar padang pasir dari Malaysia?" dan "kalau betul2 selamat, kenapa tak buat je sebelah rumah Najib?"
@memangakupoyo our government is hypocrite full with bs and bs-ed. Malaysia yet still the 3rd world country kat mata United Nation. hm.... why? dont ask me i have no power to answer any question.
yg ni last chan adnan yaakob nak gagau duit tu, sebelum pru 13, kalau tak rampas kehilangan peluang. 12 tahun tadak cukai tapi negeri rugi, menteri besar untung la
These two Homer Simpson trained experts and supporters handed a letter to the Aust High Commissioner in KL stating that Lynas's ore was sourced from MONAZITE. Great!. After all the talk on all the blogs and comments all over the internet for MONTHS trying to 'get across' that Lynas's Mt Weld ore - UNLIKE MONAZITE - has SUPER LOW Thorium of 626ppm (0.0626%). They STILL think it's Monazite which contains 10% - 30% Thorium!!! Lynas's waste AIN'T A PROBLEM. Now Fukishima -- THAT'S A PROBLEM!.
@fargonebewdy yeah, yeah, yeah...& u got that fact from whom? the Lynas itself? can u urself guarantee the reality afterward will be like what u've mentioned? everything is beautiful on paper. remember Bukit Merah incident? the same old story, the company (Mitsubishi Chemicals) even Dr Mahathir claim that it is safe..later then what happen..?? yeah, its not the same substance, & im not talking bout the substance..im talking bout how this kind of issues a being handled by both the company & gomen
@keown83 i am a scientist and an engineer. i know the substance is different. Monazite emits a low thorium. before building a plant, there must be a safety test, and waste management plans.
FYI, even the bitumen used in making roads emits a higher radiation to this Monazite. where bitumen emit 2.6mSv while Monazite 0.1mSv. do you what Sv means? it is SI unit of dose equivalent radioactive. what is SI? it is system of unit. please read before you talk something you think is clever enough to you.
@MizZue where did u get the fact that they are using Monazite ? sorry , I am trying to investigate it all , I am not in any sides , at least for now . and yeah , the question is , why Malaysia ? why cant they build it at their own land ? and furtheremore , gov have given 12 years tax-free to them . Thats surely puzzled me a lot . PLEASE PLEASE do reply me , or at least pm me . I really want to know the truth . thanks
it's for logistic & human resource reasons. cheaper labour, almost tax free, good strategic location in terms of shipping. for economist, this indeed a good opportunity for malaysian of getting high paying job.
monazite though can still be radioactive, and the process could lead to produce wastes such acid waste. they can claim they have good waste management but i doubt that. they could dump to a place where the authorities keep one eyed shut.
@MizZue well then, u shud educate Aussies for that..u must be clever than those Caucasians who stay in that vast island with a damn plenty of spaces to build that damn plant..what safety test..?? what waste management plans are u talking about..?? tell that to those Mitsus who until now failed to take those toxic substances out from Papan, Perak..im not talking bout ur cheesy scientific explanation that looks good on paper..im talking bout the reality in Malaysia..Bukit Merah incident is reality
Datuk Aziz, I think you're just afraid protests such as this empties your pocket and hurts your lifestyle! I can imagine the look on your face when you said what you said! Typical people. People your kind. Shame on you!!
@knightryder7777 tell that to Aussies...let them know that it is not dangerous..put the plant in that big vast land..why Malaysia, a small limited land..?? & with 12 years of tax-free as a gift from gomen to this company, how will Pahang people benefit from this plant..???
@knightryder7777 is that not going to add up the total amount of emission? Of course this is just on the emission..not taking into account on the other adverse effects...
My sources suggest this statement re. bitumen is not correct at all. Right now (2012), there is a major clean-up at a low-level radioactive site in Bukit Merah near Ipoh - many years after the site was closed. It was operated by Mitsubishi. There are SIGNIFICANTLY elevated rates of leukaemia & other cancer amongst locals - this can be checked with Dr. T. Jayabalan who is all too aware of the REALITY of safety in low-cost toxic-processing plants. If its safe, then let it be done in Australia.
Revolutionary, when a peaceful protest is not heard, grevience will generate over time and a riot will start sooner or later. I don't hope our country will get into violent solutions for everything.
After this i will suggest the Atomic Energy Licence Board of Malaysia to investigate all the plant in Gebeng whether their radioactivity is high or not..i'm sure all gebeng plant will close or their operating license suspended ...and at that time Vincent and Fuziah will be the heros,, to close all the gebeng plant..and that time u can hear all the Balok resident who is majority works at gebeng voice out..hehehee..just wait lor..
(1) Management of waste - How long the waste needs to be managed and who manage it if Lynas move out of Malaysia?
(2) Contingency plans - In case of accidents, leakages or other failures what are the contingency plans?
(3) Safety standards - Which is the authority or enforcement agency that ensures Lynas meets the safety standards? Do they have the capability? Is there a third party international monitoring agency?
“Mining rare earth is dirty business, so dirty in fact countries with the mineral decided against digging for it, thinking that the cost outweigh the benefit.”
"we don't want another Bukit Merah" - nor does the Govt or Lynas whose CEO said 'it should never have happened', so you/ he/everyone agrees on this point! @ 5:18 Vin says "I only got to know about 5 weeks ago when someone emailed me the WHOLE THING!" LOL - 4sure this sincere man was spammed by a Fuziah IED, i.e. an incendiary email chock full of hysterical bits on the BM fiasco, gently folded in with utter BS that Lynas's huge investment = another 1985 ARE /Chinese result. Dis•in•gen•u•ous!
Of course Government Malaysia said no problem. When disaster happen who goes to come and responsible. Makan Duit number one and know Number 2 screw the people of Malaysia.
Of course is a emotion. You can see he is upset for the whole thing. Image you have a documentation proof is no benefit to Malaysia and try to submit the report the Government ask u go up, down,left,right,here,there and give a big turn again u get upset or not. And he Government learn the lesson on rare earth project happen in Bukit Merah and cost Rm 300 million clean up and yet is dangerous to stay there. So image these plant is no far from Kuantan.
This video is all emotion. NOT A SINGLE LOGICAL REASON for Lynas to pack up their plant and go. This plant is safe and clean and will help bring prosperity to Malaysia.
@davegate2000 Of course is a emotion. You can see he is upset for the whole thing. Image you have a documentation proof is no benefit to Malaysia and try to submit the report the Government ask u go up, down,left,right,here,there and give a big turn again u get upset or not. And he Government learn the lesson on rare earth project happen in Bukit Merah and cost Rm 300 million clean up and yet is dangerous to stay there. So image these plant is no far from Kuantan.
You say he has documented proof? Why did he not mention ANY of it during the press conference? It would be the best time to do it in front of all the cameras . Instead he just ranted about nothing.
I understand Malaysian concerns due to possible health issues arising from previous dirty processing plant 20 years ago. What if the independent review from world experts shows that this plant is clean and there is absolutely no danger to health for Malaysians? Will you still oppose?
@ricc00 Fully manageable! - check my 'truth rant' about a week ago. Besides, Bukit Merah's ore had 80,000ppm Thorium - Lynas's has 1,600ppm. Thats 2% of BM's!!! and most importantly it is to be processed with VASTLY superior technology and safeguards to the 30yr old BM mess. Lynas's CEO is on record saying “There is NO RISK associated with the waste at all -even our water will be fully treated before being released back into the environment " Things evolve, but fear mongering politicians don't
@fargonebewdy Funny, I tot our politician only thinking about their pocket change only. BTW it is not the technology that most people fear about. It is about the track record and the people behind it that scared people off. And you believe Lynas' CEO saying there is NO RISK associated with waste? Pffft... Everything has risk in this world, son. Unless you are god, everything is a risk no matter small they are.
Complain Complain all i hear, the company is a safe company- this will bring alot of money into your country which is poor. So except it you will benifit.
You people seriously think the huge investment Lynas is putting into this ultra modern plant won't include waste control? The naturally occuring slightly radioactive Thorium will be MIXED WITH LIME to a maximum of 0.05% which meets INTERNATIONAL STANDARDS for disposal with NO or few restrictions. Lynas however is going to use this harmless mix in making large concrete shapes known as tetrapods to build artificial reefs for fish and sea walls to prevent beach erosion. That is Excellence.
The Malaysia Insider posts ONLY fear mongering bullshit . Facts are 1. The modern state-of-art Lynas plant AIN'T a fucking repeat of Bukit Merah all those 29 years back, 2. Fuziah Salleh suffers from Histrionic Personality Disorder. American Psychiatric Association defines it as a personality disorder with a pattern of excessive emotionality and attention-seeking, 3.....OOH OOH OOH !!!!!! I think the radioactive bit in my smoke alarm is going into a Fukishima
I just browsed to this video upon reading up Bukit Merah incident and also looking through the information regarding radioactive by-products on rare earth processing... and followed by some arguments by 2 ladies here ( or so both of them claimed ). Politically motivated or not, the facts are there for us (who spends time researching information available), to study and deemed it an unnecessary 'risk' - at least it did for me. @EdmondKua, stop wasting your time, you sounded foolish even to me.
I'm sick of the chinese always playing the race card being racist against the malays but when we malays speak out and fight back over this the chinese call us "racist".
@miraclelh This is a POLITICAL ISSUE, Fuziah just used this case to help her position in politic and try to win votes. She does a good job of scaring the people. She did it to help herself and its sooo clear for everyone to see. She could have complain 2 years ago when the Lynas plant started building BUT DID SHE NOOOO! She ONLY ONLY choose to highlight after the Tsunami in Japan HOW CONVENIENT. They way she did this may me support Najeeb even more. I am voting najeeb in the election for sure!
@EdmondKua you know what, 1 easy question, what if u live beside the plant? u dont give a damn because it dont affect u. non of us here, including fuziah herself has accused what najib has done, so why bring politics into this matter? so when majority of the people are standing against the development, everyone is fools except you? pathetic. i hope you;re still young, if you're not, you're thinking like a kid.
I don't need to live next to the plant My son works at the Lynas plant. It has helped him with employment and given him a bright future. Before he had no job after completing his Engineering degree because of teh recession. Now thanks to Lynas he has a bright future to raise his family. I will make sure my whole family and my neighbors support lynas and vote for Najeeb.
@EdmondKua if what u said is true, good for you that your son bought you food compensating his health. and the fact that you have a son, is pathetic because u dont think like a matured man. no one wants to know who are u voting for, its not about politics, its about the people's health
@miraclelh Miracle has added 2 votes to highlight how important rare earths are. The more she type the she highlight how much she needs it. She is sooo addicted to the computer. Keep typing Miracle!
@EdmondKua and how you comment really reflects your immature, do you only know how to accuse "hypocrite","stupid" when u cant win a debate? its like "oh if u fight with me u're so dumb! hahaha!" LOL "if u reply u're hypocrite" LOLOLOL
@miraclelh And how you comment tells the whole world you are a Hypocrite because you cant stop using your PC, In fact you are telling the whole world how important rare earth products are. Keep it up. Keep replying tell the whole world how much we rely on technology to debate about rare earth. Keep reply please i beg you. Let me start counting the number times you need to use the PC
@BangkitlahMelayu Who the fuck brought up the race issue in this video? are chinese people the only race against this project? u fucking racist dumbass.
and also oh...about u know...erm...apa nama...'unemployment case' ....very high is it...i though m'sia on shortage of labor since i see a lot indonesian, bangladeshi, nepals and myanmar ppl working in m'sia...and again edmund since u like pro in this erm...u know...radiation thingy...how about going to BM and check if that is just a rumors...i am emotional as well now...confused...
wow wow wow...edmund so good with his stats...and if my son ever become an engineer i will call him work elsewhere...so sad coz i dun think edmund's son nor daughter gonna become an engineer or something...maybe loser like daddy...i am still looking at which malaysia company will kena halau...since edmund so good in seeking for info maybe he can help...
BN dah terbukti korup, boros, penipu billions of people's money, who are u good citizens?..get lost. BN only want your billion2 rm maa...(it's just the time we good people must vote BN out to be the good pembangkang next..!)..BN is history in the making..!!!
Harap PM dengar dan bertindak dengan bijak. Ahli politik kena sedar bahawa mereka juga ada boss. Boss mereka ia lah rakyat. Jika ahli politik menjadi angkuh dan bongkak hingga tidak menghiraukan kepentingan BOSS mereka, ia itu rakyat, maka sudah tiba lah masa nya kita gugurkan ahli ahli politik ini secara demokratik melalui undi dan mandat yang akan di beri oleh rakyak pada pilihanraya yang akan datang.
@wongcampong And i will make sure i vote for Najeeb. He has down so much for teh country what have you done,how much money did you bring into the country to help Malaysians?
@EdmondKua don't ask stupid question ok. don't ask what we can do for our country (good for old people) but ask what the country can do for us. ( the young generation). this is forward thinking.
@wongcampong The Malaysian government has to think about the WHOLE country and it people ok NOT JUST YOU. The Lynas plant will help 99.99% of the Malaysian population and just 0.001% of the population of the people in Kuantan not happy with it. IF you don't like what the country is doing for you why don;t you migrate to another country?
@EdmondKua Don't worry about my migration. Its in my plan. For the good of others, activities of the company need to be understood. If its just processing radioactive product to extract uranium for another party, why Malaysia need to be a barua of other countries. If Malaysia is hard up to earn the processing income badly for the 99.99% of the population, govt can work on an alternative safe site like an island instead of doing it on the mainland. Use intelligence not emotions.
@DinoAge YOu respect him But he doesn't know anything and is scared and brain washed by Fuziah for her own political purposes. All she tell him is Bukit Merah, Bukit merah woithout telling him all the FULL facts. USed his own emotions against him. So stupid
@DinoAge Brave and uneducated. The way he talks tell people that he is uneducated about the industry and like a puppet to Fuzian. I can she her smiling because she know she is controlling him.
@EdmondKua So why do you think she had the chance to bring up this issue at the first place? ITS BECAUSE THE GOVERNMENT DID A WRONG DECISION at the first place, and they wont admit it. And this is not even about politics, its about the people's health, we are fighting for our health, not who controls the government, get your facts right.
@miraclelh She could brought up 2 years ago DID SHE NO! She could brought this problem last year DID SHE NO~!!! All she care about is wait for right moment to scare all of us Malaysians. I am very proud Malaysian i VOTE FOR NAJEEB!! Yes its about people health the Plant is so safe over 200 people will be working there and they won't have cancer. It is a world class safe plant and over 200 Malays will be working there. If got cancer risk no Malay will work there.
@EdmondKua if the plant is so safe why other countries never approved such a project? why there is bukit merah incident? why terengganu rejected it? once again im begging for u to think wisely, before trolling
someone familiar with Lynas...if so maybe they can build the plant back in Aussie since they scared of unemployment so much...and for your info parents can make the best decision for their own children sake...without those international company???this is a funny statement...
it doesn't matter if u kindergarden teacher or wat so ever...those that don't know the happening and the harzardous of the stuff please shut up...protocols sucks and those that live up with protocols are losers...chicken...cos ur not doing anything illegal...
I can't believe you guys are making such nasty remarks on Vincent's brave move to speak out for people in Kuantan. Thank you Vincent for speaking on behalf of us in Kuantan.
Just wait for the day when government decide to build the nuclear power plant or rare earth refinery in your backyard, and you will beg for Vincent to speak on your behalf.
@TheCschow ..."a nuclear power plant OR rare earth refinery" LOL ...just love the way you equate a nuclear power plant (artificial man made nuclear fission) with the insignificant and entirely manageable (naturally occuring) pissant Thorium content in one unwanted part of Lynas's ore. Truth is POLITICAL FEAR MONGERING - using the old toxic LOW tech/ NO tech Bukit Merah & Chinese waste FIASCO'S - is your REAL smiling enemy - not Lynas's ultra-modern website-stated "ZERO HARM" process!
He did a good job at making us aware of what's going on in Kuantan and how does Kuantanites feel about this, no matter what YOU can say about him. Unless you can do better than him facing so many reporters.
Lemme tell you one thing. Making money from thousands of peoples' health has no point. If you want money in exchange of health, you're not thinking.
@Jendix99 He did a good job of SCARING MALAYSIANS and used your fear against you. One day your son wants to be engineer and blame you he cant get a job because you scared all the foreign investments away from the country.
@EdmondKua I'm sorry..? By the time these foreign investments are prosperous enough for my sons to work in, the country would've turned into a polluted wasteland.
Think far, think healthy. Don't work for money, make money work for you.
@EdmondKua I believe that my children would thank me for protecting their health. There is no parents in this world willing to see their children suffer from disease. So, based on your comments, I can 100% sure that you are not a good parents. In this world, not only rare earth industry need engineering students. A lot of other types of industry need them as well, so your comments also proved me that you are an ignorant bushit.
its our country, why are u guys humiliating such a brave man that stood up against the government to defend our health, as a kuantan citizen i really salute this guy, he might not be the rep for the msian people, but for u msian who supports the project, shame on u
@miraclelh People criticised him not becasue he is BRaved and stand for his country people criticise him for been uneducated about rare earth and easy to be Manipulated by Fuziah. You think Fuziah will have a job is shehas nothing to complain about?Thats how she makes a living.
@EdmondKua so what if u are employed and in return ur health is compensated? any point? what if the plant is constructed in your back yard? will u be happily celebrating it? think thoroughly, think. wealth is no where near as important especially when its your people's health that you are compensating. I don't give a damn about rare earth, i know people in Bukit Merah, Perak has suffered from projects like this, and why are we allowing another tragedy to happen?
@miraclelh If i am unemployment . UNEMPLOYMENT lead to drug addiction and crime in this Nation. IF there is no job in Malaysia the crime rate will go up and people will get robbed and even worst rapes.
WHat tradegy are you talking about you are comparing apples and unripe apples. Just becasue one apple is sour doesn't mean ALL apples is sour! This is about politics! This is about Fuziah getting her chance to rise up in politics and she used your OWN FEARS AGAINST you.
@EdmondKua still u dont get the point, its not politics we are talking about, we are just citizens, we care about our health. the government just recently took in 45,000 labour from india, you think they are so concerned about employment rate that they just allow lynas to build a rare earth processing plant just to improve employment rate? so back to the question, what if the plant is situation right beside your home, will you still celebrate it? :)
The Kindergarden teacher is a true patriot. UMNO can eat toxic waste from LYNAS as sambal sauce. Kick LYNAS out of Malaysia!
otonomi1 10 hours ago
Today 6.03.2012 our International trade minister Mustapha said. our atomic energy department had issue the temporary license to lynas to start operating the refinery very soon. Ignoring all the protests.
Stop the BN and Stop Lynas..... Who want to stay near Gebeng or Kuantan area..its very scarely......
afmanne1011 3 days ago
BN not capable to manage our country, be it the toxical wate!! STOP BN!!
venice0990 4 days ago
I wonder why taking the risk of creating Lynas in the first place. Existing "Malaysia" has already problem of their own. Again, Creating more problem!
prettyvase 6 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
KANTOI !! Apa yg "Baju Hijau" nak sebenarnya ni?? Adakah kerana kita terpengaruh dengan Idea2 Songsang? Ataupun Syarikat di Malaysia ini diterajui oleh Rakyat Bumiputra Malaysia?
Lihat lah :
shinetsu.co.jp/e/profile/asia.shtml
alibaba.com/trade/search?SearchText=rare+earth&Country=MY&IndexArea=product_en&fsb=y
CASE CLOSE !!
niefengmalaysia 1 week ago
STOP LYNAS!!! STOP LYNAS!!!!!!
HENTI LYNAS, HENTI LYNAS!
EikaShahAlam 1 week ago
good guy support u 100%
aboy8065 1 week ago
fuck pm,penting kan diri sendiri je
aboy8065 1 week ago
The gov is very irresponsible they allow the project to build the lynas factory at here and didn't care about the health of the citizen
I know the gov do that and they will get many of the money and that can develop Malaysia as well
but I think actually most of money are in their pocket because of the seriously corruption
in malaysia
somebody said that the radiation of Lynaz actually is not dangerous
I want tell u that the radiation never been consider that it is safe by the scientist
samurayen1 1 week ago
@samurayen1 I agree with u, this is big corruption scandal, those involve this project are the BN politician...very big money in the pocket,
afmanne1011 3 days ago
@knightryder7777 Eh bodoh!!!! What they processed are concentrated and the half-life is long.... If as safe as u say then u move ur house beside Ly as refinery .... Fuck you!!!! Bodoh u must be some pro government dog!!! Hidup rakyat!!!! Hancur lynas!!!!!!
cibailumiamak 1 week ago 5
ORANG2 CINA TAK BOLEH LAGI BERCAKAP UTK KEPENTINGAN MEREKA SEMATA2. BAGI MENJADIKAN MALAYSIA LEBIH BAIK. MULAI SKRG, TIADA LAGI KEPENTINGAN UTK CINA SHJ, MELAYU SHJ, INDIA SHJ. SEBALIKNYA MELAYU, CINA, INDIA, KADAZAN, MURUT, MELANAU, ORG ASLI,SEMUA KENA SEPAKAT, BARU BOLEH MENYEKAT KERAKUSAN UMNO/BE END DLM MEROSAKKAN/MEMBANGKRAPKAN MALAYSIA. AYUH SEMUA RAKYAT PELBAGAI KAUM,TOLAK UMNO BE END, SELAMAT MALAYSIA DR HANCUR... JGN BIAR UMNO BERTUKAR MENJADI RAKSASA YG TAK BOLEH DI SENTUH LAGI...
aufy007 1 month ago 4
My sources suggest this statement re. bitumen is not correct at all. Right now (2012), there is a major clean-up at a low-level radioactive site in Bukit Merah near Ipoh - many years after the site was closed. It was operated by Mitsubishi. There are SIGNIFICANTLY elevated rates of leukaemia & other cancer amongst locals - this can be checked with Dr. T. Jayabalan who is all too aware of the REALITY of safety in low-cost toxic-processing plants. If its safe, then let it be done in Australia.
domINkl 1 month ago
translation please!!!
huntingv8 2 months ago
JOHORIAN support every residents from PAHANG~ !!
11cylee 3 months ago
Fuz is such a great HR puppet-meister. She gets much emo mileage from scaring the crap out of everyone (Vinny + many voters!! haha). At 5:15 who do u think programmed him with an email of the 'whoooole' thing. I bet in her cynical aim to politicise the pissant-low level Thorium in Lynas's waste, she omitted the FACT that Bukit Merah workers took home & put HEAPS of TOXIC SUPER-CONCENTRATED Thorium waste right on their veggie gardens and therefore ingested it!!!!. Save Malaysia Stop Fuziah!
fargonebewdy 3 months ago
Go home Lynas! We don't need rare earths!
- message from my neodymium containing iPhone
muttonbuster 4 months ago 3
we fcked...... after that lynas is build up....
puterafadhli 6 months ago
knp yg nak sangat kat linasy ni?
PokjaSokmo 7 months ago
can anybody make this a global appeal? maybe requesting avaaz.org for online petition signing?
poymfw 8 months ago
support stop LYNAS!
mrtoh71 8 months ago
It's a lot better to avoid something unpredictable disaster!!?? why should we let ? we DONT GET ANYTHING.. unless u got 'something' ? even if so, tht something..money is null compare to the ppl's soul/safety. SOUL is more valuable-it affects many people.
sweetbonetto123 8 months ago
What the hell were they thinking!! The conflicting statements of director-general of AELB - he said Malaysia’s laws on radiation are of a much HIGHER standard than the US or Australia, and Malaysia will be downgrading the standards if we followed Australian or American standards. But then again, he admitted the RIA of the Lynas plant near Kuantan was incomplete and not good enough - why license was given to Lynas in the first place????
mssunnyday1010 8 months ago
This plant is reflecting how good our government has been and how much better it will get.
They use to just go bring in low tech labour intensive rubbish to Malaysia as FDI. Now that is also leaving to places that are much cheaper.
So now they go and bring even more utter Rubbish like Lynas and say hey look we are doing great.
We are taking so much risks for nothing in return and that is a fact.
Dont remember the last time wise people did something for nothing in return.
Rubanrakg19 8 months ago
Comment removed
zkyfengix 9 months ago
the story is like the japanese drama "change". who said a kindergarten teacher annot do better?
zkyfengix 9 months ago
I reckon- 1.The world needs non-chinese RE's REAL bad. 2. After all the hysteria, the gov will make Lynas stand on its toes to reach the highest standards possible (a good thing). 3. Lynas said it is going to bankroll Malaysian uni courses + R&D to constantly improve (a good thing) 4.The Fukishima HORROR will finally move this stupid war-world from uranium reactors (to get bomb Plutonium) to THORIUM BURNING reactors which CAN'T MELT DOWN & kill us. 5. In 12yrs TAX CASH rolls in - BIG TIME!.
fargonebewdy 9 months ago
LYNAS GET OUT OF MALAYSIA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
kelvinling87 9 months ago 3
There are very little economic benefits for the Malaysians if the LAMP project is built. 350 jobs? Just consider the significant risks involved for the people living in the Kuantan area. A plantation like this can destroy the lives of 700.000 people. The tourist industry will in any case suffer and reduce important incomes.
blattmacher 9 months ago
@blattmacher Yes,it is very little bit benefits for the malaysian, but huge benefits for the person approved this project..they are not care the people life in danger, Vote out BN....stop Lynas the only way to change the gov..
afmanne1011 3 days ago
@cshong87 I know well the Bukit Merah wound, it was an important part of my own research into the global rare earth industry. A sad wound it was & still is, both physical & psychological. Look how it screwed you up!. Mitsub worked TIN TAILINGS with 5000% MORE Thorium than Lynas's ore(50 times!!!) and did so with UNBELIEVABLY SLOPPINESS - even for 1985!!. Mod. company management PLANs, IMPLEMENTs, MONITORs, CONTROLs, REVIEWs.
The hard lessons have been learnt. Policing is NOW in place.
fargonebewdy 9 months ago
@fargonebewdy I don't care. One time experience is already enough.
When the hypocrite government increase the sugar price, then said it is for people's good, making people eat less sugar and have more healthier life. Then on another hand, they showed their hypocrite attitude by doing other things that may be harmful to the people around. LOL. I will forever remember this.
If our government really learnt from past experience, they will reject Lynas like hell.
cshong87 9 months ago
@cshong87 Kindly ask yourself : Is Arafura Resources going to kill oz folk around their plant in Whyalla South Aust.? Is Alkane going to betray & kill oz folk around their piloted Rare Earth plant in NSW? Is the U.S. GOV going to betray and kill Americans working their new upgraded Mountain Pass plant in California??? Is Canadian Orbite going to kill everybody around its new plant ? HAS the Socialist Republic of Vietnam now betrayed & killing its people in the NEW Showa Denco plant ? EH?
fargonebewdy 9 months ago
@fargonebewdy It seems like you want Malaysian to get cancers. Bukit Merah incidents had made so many people die, not enough is it? Want more people to die? You better go see Bukit Merah and ask the residents there, or else pack your things and leave Malaysia. Nothing in this world is perfectt, so I am not going to trust those technology used by Lynas, doesn't matter what the IAEA people said. After Bukit Merah incident, I will be very stubborn in this issue. So, don't think you can confront me.
cshong87 9 months ago
Malaysians who support Lynas should GET OUT OF MALAYSIA. Those who support Lynas are only those who want Malaysians to die. Lynas supporters are those pengkhianat / traitor who betrayed Malaysians for their own benefits. So, Lynas supporters, pack your things and GET OUT OF MALAYSIA. BERAMBUS DARI MALAYSIA.
And, to BN, since you allow this bushit Lynas to operate here, you betrayed Malaysians also. I will forever remember this and will not forgive you forever.
cshong87 9 months ago
@cshong87 I'm with you my friend!
memangakupoyo 8 months ago
@memangakupoyo Thank you!
cshong87 8 months ago
@rosihantu1 Got some shares in Arafura's coming RE plant in Whyalla OZ - the one PKR Malaysians (and their oz shill R.Albrey) conveniently overlook . The fight against lies and misinformation will soon embroil Arafura as well. Reclaiming RE processing from China is essential. Lynas's integrity is being UNFAIRLY demonised by PKR + ignoramuses - this may occur to other processors - in Whyalla, Dubbo (Alkane) - Vietnam - USA - Canada - Africa. Some think it's a freaking reactor!! LOL
fargonebewdy 9 months ago
It's all right if Kuantan folks going against Lynas Project but please chase out this group of politicians who just pretend to sympathize but in reality they're just 'fishing' for the next general election. PKR is well known for their 'bad habit' of taking innocent people to street protest which is 'uncivilized' in the 21st century standard.
AcheeKerasKengChibai 9 months ago
It's all right if Kuantan folks going against Lynas Project but please chase out this group of politicians who just pretend to sympathize but in reality they're just 'fishing' for the next general election.
AcheeKerasKengChibai 9 months ago 2
Lynas走狗给我滚。
cshong87 9 months ago
All Lynas project supporters, including but not limited to EdmondKua, are all brainwashed by this stupid RUBBISH Lynas corporation. People like EdmondKua, betraying Malaysians, sacrificing Malaysian's health just for his son's benefits, should be expelled from this country. EdmondKua, 你这Lynas走狗，为了自己孩子的利益，出卖了马来西亚人，牺牲国人的健康，没资格做马来西亚人，给我滚出马来西亚，最好滚出这个世界。
cshong87 9 months ago
stop LYNAS!!!!!
mekaku 9 months ago
1malaysia ka 2malaysia ka,bagi i langsung x caya.
dia org kuat rasuah.mkn duit rakyat.
tiap2 kali sini kawtim sana kawtim.
pentingkan diri saja. pangkat besar hingga pangkat kecil semua pun kuat2 makan duit.kerja x jalan.bulan2 tunggu gaji masuk.
i bagi u tau la kwn,sampai bila2 pun,rasuah ni mmg xj jadi pupus
klu rasuah di hapuskan,malaysia mmg kaya
kenjilaihankee 9 months ago
@kenjilaihankee , btul, btul, btul. M'sia mmg ng yg kaya tp pemimpin x sdar diri da sebat duit yg sepatutnya diagihkan pd rakyat.Pemimpin yg dilantik rkyat kerjanya menjaga amanah tp sekarang pemimpin da pecah amanah
akoris99 2 months ago
Bye Bye Vinny! - you did a GREAT job panicking the rakyat for Fuzzy Bear and her manipulative PKR bosses. You finally AWOKE to the FACT that the new Lynas plant will NEVER be another Bukit Merah and left - even with Dr Jayabalan in front of the oz embassy saying "if Mitsubishi can't handle it I don't think Lynas can because it has no experience doing this". Yeah sure Dr J. the 1985-92 "take it home and put it on ya veggies" ethos - and get cancer - sure is a HARD act to follow Doc! - you JERK!.
fargonebewdy 9 months ago
@fargonebewdy Why are you so eager for the plant to be built here? If you are a shareholder or Lynas than I understand why you are so eager for Lynas investment. But if you neither of those, why are u bothered with people protesting the plant? The country is not losing money - afterall we are not collecting any tax from profit made by Lynas. Creation of 400 job? Big freaking deal, you give a tax free incentive in Kuantan i can assure we can create more than 400 jobs.
rosihantu1 9 months ago
bodoh !!! kata nak 1malaysia rakyat di dahulu kan.........penipu..kalau benar la.kau nak dahulu kan rakyat..kau tak akan terima LYNAS...MALAYSIA ni tempat kami..kalau MALAYSIA ni musnah..kami nak lari mana ??kau boleh laa..byk duit..makan duit rakyat...
MyDeena100 9 months ago 22
rasuahhhhhhhhhhhh punya pukimak punyer citer la ni!!!!!
mdnurul 9 months ago
x-men akan muncul di pahang tak lama lagi hasil produk dari Lynas, tahniah penduduk pahang.. x-men , cirinya kepala besar kaki bengkok matanya satu mcm dajjal ..
kickd24 9 months ago 2
Even plastics and domestic rubbishes are too difficult for us to solve, let alone this "small amount" of thorium/radioactives waste! radioactive is a radioactive, so does a poison... not matter how small it is, sooner or later there will be a consequence.... CO2? cigarette? All start with small amounts... but how about after 20 years? 30 years? One more thing, NOW WHO THE FUCK WANT AN OUTSIDER DUMP A RUBBISH IN YOUR OWN BACKYARD?
memangakupoyo 9 months ago
it there any reply or feed back from prime minister yet?
miminzombie 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I'm joining you Vincent, Good one brave guy. I am Kuantan Citizen.
faizul1334 9 months ago
I'm joining you Vincent, Good one brave guy. I am Kuantan Citizen.
faizul1334 9 months ago
Thank you Vincent
azfarthebelievers 9 months ago
3 people who dislike this has no brain at all
Fahimfermiside 9 months ago
@Fahimfermiside thats puzzled me... those fucking lynas fed the people a radioactives composite, they still dont like this video??? let me rephrase Tukartiub's "kalau betul2 selamat, kenapa tak buat kat Australia yang berjuta kali lagi besar padang pasir dari Malaysia?" dan "kalau betul2 selamat, kenapa tak buat je sebelah rumah Najib?"
memangakupoyo 9 months ago
@memangakupoyo our government is hypocrite full with bs and bs-ed. Malaysia yet still the 3rd world country kat mata United Nation. hm.... why? dont ask me i have no power to answer any question.
Fahimfermiside 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The bitumen used to make roads emit a radiation measurement of 2.6 mSv (millisieverts) while the rare earth processed by Lynas emit 0.156 mSv.
It is not dangerous!
MizZue 9 months ago 4
yg ni last chan adnan yaakob nak gagau duit tu, sebelum pru 13, kalau tak rampas kehilangan peluang. 12 tahun tadak cukai tapi negeri rugi, menteri besar untung la
nistelrooy10100 9 months ago
These two Homer Simpson trained experts and supporters handed a letter to the Aust High Commissioner in KL stating that Lynas's ore was sourced from MONAZITE. Great!. After all the talk on all the blogs and comments all over the internet for MONTHS trying to 'get across' that Lynas's Mt Weld ore - UNLIKE MONAZITE - has SUPER LOW Thorium of 626ppm (0.0626%). They STILL think it's Monazite which contains 10% - 30% Thorium!!! Lynas's waste AIN'T A PROBLEM. Now Fukishima -- THAT'S A PROBLEM!.
fargonebewdy 9 months ago
@fargonebewdy yeah, yeah, yeah...& u got that fact from whom? the Lynas itself? can u urself guarantee the reality afterward will be like what u've mentioned? everything is beautiful on paper. remember Bukit Merah incident? the same old story, the company (Mitsubishi Chemicals) even Dr Mahathir claim that it is safe..later then what happen..?? yeah, its not the same substance, & im not talking bout the substance..im talking bout how this kind of issues a being handled by both the company & gomen
keown83 9 months ago
@keown83 i am a scientist and an engineer. i know the substance is different. Monazite emits a low thorium. before building a plant, there must be a safety test, and waste management plans.
FYI, even the bitumen used in making roads emits a higher radiation to this Monazite. where bitumen emit 2.6mSv while Monazite 0.1mSv. do you what Sv means? it is SI unit of dose equivalent radioactive. what is SI? it is system of unit. please read before you talk something you think is clever enough to you.
MizZue 9 months ago 4
@MizZue where did u get the fact that they are using Monazite ? sorry , I am trying to investigate it all , I am not in any sides , at least for now . and yeah , the question is , why Malaysia ? why cant they build it at their own land ? and furtheremore , gov have given 12 years tax-free to them . Thats surely puzzled me a lot . PLEASE PLEASE do reply me , or at least pm me . I really want to know the truth . thanks
toprookie93 9 months ago
@toprookie93
it's for logistic & human resource reasons. cheaper labour, almost tax free, good strategic location in terms of shipping. for economist, this indeed a good opportunity for malaysian of getting high paying job.
monazite though can still be radioactive, and the process could lead to produce wastes such acid waste. they can claim they have good waste management but i doubt that. they could dump to a place where the authorities keep one eyed shut.
salmanyghebat 9 months ago
@MizZue well then, u shud educate Aussies for that..u must be clever than those Caucasians who stay in that vast island with a damn plenty of spaces to build that damn plant..what safety test..?? what waste management plans are u talking about..?? tell that to those Mitsus who until now failed to take those toxic substances out from Papan, Perak..im not talking bout ur cheesy scientific explanation that looks good on paper..im talking bout the reality in Malaysia..Bukit Merah incident is reality
keown83 9 months ago
@fargonebewdy having fun sucking najib and all BN cocks is it?
ImBadVeryBad 9 months ago
Datuk Aziz, I think you're just afraid protests such as this empties your pocket and hurts your lifestyle! I can imagine the look on your face when you said what you said! Typical people. People your kind. Shame on you!!
dreamchaserJ 9 months ago
dah rembat tanah, jadikan tong sampah, nak bunuh rakyat plak.
syafiqzailan 9 months ago
The bitumen used to make roads emit a radiation measurement of 2.6 mSv (millisieverts) while the rare earth processed by Lynas emit 0.156 mSv.
It is not dangerous
knightryder7777 9 months ago 9
@knightryder7777 tell that to Aussies...let them know that it is not dangerous..put the plant in that big vast land..why Malaysia, a small limited land..?? & with 12 years of tax-free as a gift from gomen to this company, how will Pahang people benefit from this plant..???
keown83 9 months ago
@knightryder7777 are you malaysian?
K2one0 9 months ago
@knightryder7777 NOW WHO THE FUCK WANT AN OUTSIDER DUMP A RUBBISH IN YOUR OWN BACKYARD?
memangakupoyo 9 months ago
@knightryder7777
how if this building built next to your house?
hermanchia 9 months ago 3
@knightryder7777 are radiation emit from bitumen effect our health?please check it first..
azizee861128 8 months ago
@knightryder7777 is that not going to add up the total amount of emission? Of course this is just on the emission..not taking into account on the other adverse effects...
whateverptuih 2 months ago
remember.... paper and action is different... after the operation fully started then you should know they are doing more then that...
gabrieloh 2 months ago
My sources suggest this statement re. bitumen is not correct at all. Right now (2012), there is a major clean-up at a low-level radioactive site in Bukit Merah near Ipoh - many years after the site was closed. It was operated by Mitsubishi. There are SIGNIFICANTLY elevated rates of leukaemia & other cancer amongst locals - this can be checked with Dr. T. Jayabalan who is all too aware of the REALITY of safety in low-cost toxic-processing plants. If its safe, then let it be done in Australia.
domINkl 1 month ago
Revolutionary, when a peaceful protest is not heard, grevience will generate over time and a riot will start sooner or later. I don't hope our country will get into violent solutions for everything.
Joegioamani 1 month ago
@knightryder7777
LOL!! You are so damn right! Are you going to build a house beside the factory? Seriously..0156mSv is nothing.you can handle it. I support you!
rainjay 1 week ago
It's in the best interest of Malaysians to approve the project given the substantial economic benefits that will be brought to the country.
tranceaddictandy 10 months ago 3
After this i will suggest the Atomic Energy Licence Board of Malaysia to investigate all the plant in Gebeng whether their radioactivity is high or not..i'm sure all gebeng plant will close or their operating license suspended ...and at that time Vincent and Fuziah will be the heros,, to close all the gebeng plant..and that time u can hear all the Balok resident who is majority works at gebeng voice out..hehehee..just wait lor..
gopahanggo 10 months ago 3
Stop Lynas, Stop Radioactive Waste, Lynas stop killing, Lynas go do your plant in Australia...
Stooplynas 10 months ago
The following concerns must be addressed:-
(1) Management of waste - How long the waste needs to be managed and who manage it if Lynas move out of Malaysia?
(2) Contingency plans - In case of accidents, leakages or other failures what are the contingency plans?
(3) Safety standards - Which is the authority or enforcement agency that ensures Lynas meets the safety standards? Do they have the capability? Is there a third party international monitoring agency?
philip8464 10 months ago
“Mining rare earth is dirty business, so dirty in fact countries with the mineral decided against digging for it, thinking that the cost outweigh the benefit.”
Watch Youtube:-
China's rare earth monopoly
Rare Earth Mineral Mining in China
Coffman on CNN: Rare Earth Metals
philip8464 10 months ago
One thing i am sure..Fuziah will loose in the next election..hidup BN..hehehe
gopahanggo 10 months ago
"we don't want another Bukit Merah" - nor does the Govt or Lynas whose CEO said 'it should never have happened', so you/ he/everyone agrees on this point! @ 5:18 Vin says "I only got to know about 5 weeks ago when someone emailed me the WHOLE THING!" LOL - 4sure this sincere man was spammed by a Fuziah IED, i.e. an incendiary email chock full of hysterical bits on the BM fiasco, gently folded in with utter BS that Lynas's huge investment = another 1985 ARE /Chinese result. Dis•in•gen•u•ous!
fargonebewdy 10 months ago 3
Of course Government Malaysia said no problem. When disaster happen who goes to come and responsible. Makan Duit number one and know Number 2 screw the people of Malaysia.
prumckt 10 months ago
Of course is a emotion. You can see he is upset for the whole thing. Image you have a documentation proof is no benefit to Malaysia and try to submit the report the Government ask u go up, down,left,right,here,there and give a big turn again u get upset or not. And he Government learn the lesson on rare earth project happen in Bukit Merah and cost Rm 300 million clean up and yet is dangerous to stay there. So image these plant is no far from Kuantan.
prumckt 10 months ago
This video is all emotion. NOT A SINGLE LOGICAL REASON for Lynas to pack up their plant and go. This plant is safe and clean and will help bring prosperity to Malaysia.
davegate2000 10 months ago
@davegate2000 Of course is a emotion. You can see he is upset for the whole thing. Image you have a documentation proof is no benefit to Malaysia and try to submit the report the Government ask u go up, down,left,right,here,there and give a big turn again u get upset or not. And he Government learn the lesson on rare earth project happen in Bukit Merah and cost Rm 300 million clean up and yet is dangerous to stay there. So image these plant is no far from Kuantan.
prumckt 10 months ago
@prumckt
You say he has documented proof? Why did he not mention ANY of it during the press conference? It would be the best time to do it in front of all the cameras . Instead he just ranted about nothing.
I understand Malaysian concerns due to possible health issues arising from previous dirty processing plant 20 years ago. What if the independent review from world experts shows that this plant is clean and there is absolutely no danger to health for Malaysians? Will you still oppose?
davegate2000 10 months ago
@ricc00 Fully manageable! - check my 'truth rant' about a week ago. Besides, Bukit Merah's ore had 80,000ppm Thorium - Lynas's has 1,600ppm. Thats 2% of BM's!!! and most importantly it is to be processed with VASTLY superior technology and safeguards to the 30yr old BM mess. Lynas's CEO is on record saying “There is NO RISK associated with the waste at all -even our water will be fully treated before being released back into the environment " Things evolve, but fear mongering politicians don't
fargonebewdy 10 months ago
@fargonebewdy Funny, I tot our politician only thinking about their pocket change only. BTW it is not the technology that most people fear about. It is about the track record and the people behind it that scared people off. And you believe Lynas' CEO saying there is NO RISK associated with waste? Pffft... Everything has risk in this world, son. Unless you are god, everything is a risk no matter small they are.
zarazagoza1 10 months ago
Stop Lynas ,stupid mind!!!
shimao00 10 months ago
its not all about money u fool
lompatkodok 10 months ago
Complain Complain all i hear, the company is a safe company- this will bring alot of money into your country which is poor. So except it you will benifit.
74Andre 10 months ago
@74Andre where u from ? jz go back to hell !
shimao00 10 months ago
You people seriously think the huge investment Lynas is putting into this ultra modern plant won't include waste control? The naturally occuring slightly radioactive Thorium will be MIXED WITH LIME to a maximum of 0.05% which meets INTERNATIONAL STANDARDS for disposal with NO or few restrictions. Lynas however is going to use this harmless mix in making large concrete shapes known as tetrapods to build artificial reefs for fish and sea walls to prevent beach erosion. That is Excellence.
fargonebewdy 10 months ago
The Malaysia Insider posts ONLY fear mongering bullshit . Facts are 1. The modern state-of-art Lynas plant AIN'T a fucking repeat of Bukit Merah all those 29 years back, 2. Fuziah Salleh suffers from Histrionic Personality Disorder. American Psychiatric Association defines it as a personality disorder with a pattern of excessive emotionality and attention-seeking, 3.....OOH OOH OOH !!!!!! I think the radioactive bit in my smoke alarm is going into a Fukishima
type MELTDOWN!! HELP FUZIAH HELP!
fargonebewdy 10 months ago
Thanks uncle Vincent. We all here are supporting you.
benlkh 10 months ago 9
I just browsed to this video upon reading up Bukit Merah incident and also looking through the information regarding radioactive by-products on rare earth processing... and followed by some arguments by 2 ladies here ( or so both of them claimed ). Politically motivated or not, the facts are there for us (who spends time researching information available), to study and deemed it an unnecessary 'risk' - at least it did for me. @EdmondKua, stop wasting your time, you sounded foolish even to me.
aricat1 11 months ago
@aricat1 EdmondKua just compared his pc radiation with rare earth. Stop wasting your time to explain to such a fool.
42sucker 10 months ago
this man is only Tadika Teacher....is anybody think this man will get the benefits 4 this kind of comment...
84atoz 11 months ago
Thank to god coze now we still a life....
84atoz 11 months ago
good job !
jieyingirl 11 months ago
I'm sick of the chinese always playing the race card being racist against the malays but when we malays speak out and fight back over this the chinese call us "racist".
BangkitlahMelayu 11 months ago
She should have told the chinese to go back to china or wherever 3rd world country they came from if they hate Malaysia so much.
BangkitlahMelayu 11 months ago 2
@BangkitlahMelayu maybe not raise racist issues by posting comments like this
miraclelh 11 months ago
@miraclelh This is a POLITICAL ISSUE, Fuziah just used this case to help her position in politic and try to win votes. She does a good job of scaring the people. She did it to help herself and its sooo clear for everyone to see. She could have complain 2 years ago when the Lynas plant started building BUT DID SHE NOOOO! She ONLY ONLY choose to highlight after the Tsunami in Japan HOW CONVENIENT. They way she did this may me support Najeeb even more. I am voting najeeb in the election for sure!
EdmondKua 11 months ago
@EdmondKua you know what, 1 easy question, what if u live beside the plant? u dont give a damn because it dont affect u. non of us here, including fuziah herself has accused what najib has done, so why bring politics into this matter? so when majority of the people are standing against the development, everyone is fools except you? pathetic. i hope you;re still young, if you're not, you're thinking like a kid.
miraclelh 11 months ago
I don't need to live next to the plant My son works at the Lynas plant. It has helped him with employment and given him a bright future. Before he had no job after completing his Engineering degree because of teh recession. Now thanks to Lynas he has a bright future to raise his family. I will make sure my whole family and my neighbors support lynas and vote for Najeeb.
EdmondKua 11 months ago
@EdmondKua if what u said is true, good for you that your son bought you food compensating his health. and the fact that you have a son, is pathetic because u dont think like a matured man. no one wants to know who are u voting for, its not about politics, its about the people's health
miraclelh 11 months ago
@miraclelh Mircale has added 1 vote to highlight how important rare earths are. The more she type the she highlight how much she needs it.
EdmondKua 11 months ago
"is pathetic because u dont think like a matured man."
Obviously it takes one to know one isn't it? =)
EdmondKua 11 months ago
@EdmondKua agreed. exactly why i know that u are immatured ;D
miraclelh 11 months ago
@miraclelh Miracle has added 2 votes to highlight how important rare earths are. The more she type the she highlight how much she needs it. She is sooo addicted to the computer. Keep typing Miracle!
EdmondKua 11 months ago
@miraclelh At least we agreed on something =D
EdmondKua 11 months ago
@EdmondKua im not a matured man, im a matured woman ^_^
miraclelh 11 months ago
@miraclelh Yeah you are a Matured woman ^_^
EdmondKua 11 months ago
@EdmondKua and how you comment really reflects your immature, do you only know how to accuse "hypocrite","stupid" when u cant win a debate? its like "oh if u fight with me u're so dumb! hahaha!" LOL "if u reply u're hypocrite" LOLOLOL
miraclelh 11 months ago
Comment removed
EdmondKua 11 months ago
@miraclelh And how you comment tells the whole world you are a Hypocrite because you cant stop using your PC, In fact you are telling the whole world how important rare earth products are. Keep it up. Keep replying tell the whole world how much we rely on technology to debate about rare earth. Keep reply please i beg you. Let me start counting the number times you need to use the PC
EdmondKua 11 months ago
@BangkitlahMelayu Who the fuck brought up the race issue in this video? are chinese people the only race against this project? u fucking racist dumbass.
42sucker 10 months ago
and also oh...about u know...erm...apa nama...'unemployment case' ....very high is it...i though m'sia on shortage of labor since i see a lot indonesian, bangladeshi, nepals and myanmar ppl working in m'sia...and again edmund since u like pro in this erm...u know...radiation thingy...how about going to BM and check if that is just a rumors...i am emotional as well now...confused...
purplemonster85 11 months ago
wow wow wow...edmund so good with his stats...and if my son ever become an engineer i will call him work elsewhere...so sad coz i dun think edmund's son nor daughter gonna become an engineer or something...maybe loser like daddy...i am still looking at which malaysia company will kena halau...since edmund so good in seeking for info maybe he can help...
purplemonster85 11 months ago
I salute Vincent for his courage. Yes, you are right if this project is at their back yard, would they be angry and upset ?
betnglh 11 months ago
LOL at the guy @ 1:28 Malaysia Flag upside down la bro! haha
JozefTheophilus 11 months ago
brave guy. keep it up.
broadcastyogi 11 months ago
BN dah terbukti korup, boros, penipu billions of people's money, who are u good citizens?..get lost. BN only want your billion2 rm maa...(it's just the time we good people must vote BN out to be the good pembangkang next..!)..BN is history in the making..!!!
javabeserk 11 months ago
this guy really has guts. I really respect this guy. God bless!
taqirooney 11 months ago
Harap PM dengar dan bertindak dengan bijak. Ahli politik kena sedar bahawa mereka juga ada boss. Boss mereka ia lah rakyat. Jika ahli politik menjadi angkuh dan bongkak hingga tidak menghiraukan kepentingan BOSS mereka, ia itu rakyat, maka sudah tiba lah masa nya kita gugurkan ahli ahli politik ini secara demokratik melalui undi dan mandat yang akan di beri oleh rakyak pada pilihanraya yang akan datang.
wongcampong 11 months ago 4
@wongcampong And i will make sure i vote for Najeeb. He has down so much for teh country what have you done,how much money did you bring into the country to help Malaysians?
EdmondKua 11 months ago
@EdmondKua don't ask stupid question ok. don't ask what we can do for our country (good for old people) but ask what the country can do for us. ( the young generation). this is forward thinking.
wongcampong 11 months ago
@wongcampong The Malaysian government has to think about the WHOLE country and it people ok NOT JUST YOU. The Lynas plant will help 99.99% of the Malaysian population and just 0.001% of the population of the people in Kuantan not happy with it. IF you don't like what the country is doing for you why don;t you migrate to another country?
All you do is complain complain complain.
EdmondKua 11 months ago
@EdmondKua Don't worry about my migration. Its in my plan. For the good of others, activities of the company need to be understood. If its just processing radioactive product to extract uranium for another party, why Malaysia need to be a barua of other countries. If Malaysia is hard up to earn the processing income badly for the 99.99% of the population, govt can work on an alternative safe site like an island instead of doing it on the mainland. Use intelligence not emotions.
wongcampong 11 months ago
if the plant not stop, let the poll decide
andokov 11 months ago
I respect him... We need more people like him in Malaysia... Wake up Malaysian! U can be brave like him...
DinoAge 11 months ago 2
@DinoAge YOu respect him But he doesn't know anything and is scared and brain washed by Fuziah for her own political purposes. All she tell him is Bukit Merah, Bukit merah woithout telling him all the FULL facts. USed his own emotions against him. So stupid
EdmondKua 11 months ago
@EdmondKua If he is brainwashed by Fuziah, then you are brainwashed by both Lynas and the evil BN.
cshong87 9 months ago
@DinoAge Brave is one thing but also stupid. So you wanna be brave and stupid and uneducated about the facts?
EdmondKua 11 months ago
@EdmondKua You also stupid to be brainwashed by BN propaganda and Lynas.
cshong87 9 months ago
@DinoAge Brave and uneducated. The way he talks tell people that he is uneducated about the industry and like a puppet to Fuzian. I can she her smiling because she know she is controlling him.
EdmondKua 11 months ago
@EdmondKua So why do you think she had the chance to bring up this issue at the first place? ITS BECAUSE THE GOVERNMENT DID A WRONG DECISION at the first place, and they wont admit it. And this is not even about politics, its about the people's health, we are fighting for our health, not who controls the government, get your facts right.
miraclelh 11 months ago
@miraclelh She could brought up 2 years ago DID SHE NO! She could brought this problem last year DID SHE NO~!!! All she care about is wait for right moment to scare all of us Malaysians. I am very proud Malaysian i VOTE FOR NAJEEB!! Yes its about people health the Plant is so safe over 200 people will be working there and they won't have cancer. It is a world class safe plant and over 200 Malays will be working there. If got cancer risk no Malay will work there.
EdmondKua 11 months ago
@EdmondKua if the plant is so safe why other countries never approved such a project? why there is bukit merah incident? why terengganu rejected it? once again im begging for u to think wisely, before trolling
miraclelh 11 months ago
The top man in Malaysia, Rosmah, doesn't give a damn about anyone, better ask his wife Najis to pujok him!!! UMNO/APCO just wants the money!!!
1rasuah 11 months ago 2
someone familiar with Lynas...if so maybe they can build the plant back in Aussie since they scared of unemployment so much...and for your info parents can make the best decision for their own children sake...without those international company???this is a funny statement...
purplemonster85 11 months ago 2
it doesn't matter if u kindergarden teacher or wat so ever...those that don't know the happening and the harzardous of the stuff please shut up...protocols sucks and those that live up with protocols are losers...chicken...cos ur not doing anything illegal...
purplemonster85 11 months ago 2
Someone should advise him some protocols before meet up the reporters
panasveyron 11 months ago 3
@panasveyron it is because of these "protocols" that we dont get to see all these being aired on our national tv
shaun338 11 months ago
I can't believe you guys are making such nasty remarks on Vincent's brave move to speak out for people in Kuantan. Thank you Vincent for speaking on behalf of us in Kuantan.
Just wait for the day when government decide to build the nuclear power plant or rare earth refinery in your backyard, and you will beg for Vincent to speak on your behalf.
TheCschow 11 months ago 18
@TheCschow ..."a nuclear power plant OR rare earth refinery" LOL ...just love the way you equate a nuclear power plant (artificial man made nuclear fission) with the insignificant and entirely manageable (naturally occuring) pissant Thorium content in one unwanted part of Lynas's ore. Truth is POLITICAL FEAR MONGERING - using the old toxic LOW tech/ NO tech Bukit Merah & Chinese waste FIASCO'S - is your REAL smiling enemy - not Lynas's ultra-modern website-stated "ZERO HARM" process!
.
fargonebewdy 10 months ago
@fargonebewdy manageable? to what extend? so please explain what happened in mongolia?
gotten plentiful of cash of lynas just to condemn all these opposing comments in youtube eh?
ricc00 10 months ago
He did a good job at making us aware of what's going on in Kuantan and how does Kuantanites feel about this, no matter what YOU can say about him. Unless you can do better than him facing so many reporters.
Lemme tell you one thing. Making money from thousands of peoples' health has no point. If you want money in exchange of health, you're not thinking.
Jendix99 11 months ago 3
@Jendix99 He did a good job of SCARING MALAYSIANS and used your fear against you. One day your son wants to be engineer and blame you he cant get a job because you scared all the foreign investments away from the country.
EdmondKua 11 months ago
@EdmondKua I'm sorry..? By the time these foreign investments are prosperous enough for my sons to work in, the country would've turned into a polluted wasteland.
Think far, think healthy. Don't work for money, make money work for you.
Jendix99 10 months ago
@EdmondKua I believe that my children would thank me for protecting their health. There is no parents in this world willing to see their children suffer from disease. So, based on your comments, I can 100% sure that you are not a good parents. In this world, not only rare earth industry need engineering students. A lot of other types of industry need them as well, so your comments also proved me that you are an ignorant bushit.
cshong87 9 months ago
its our country, why are u guys humiliating such a brave man that stood up against the government to defend our health, as a kuantan citizen i really salute this guy, he might not be the rep for the msian people, but for u msian who supports the project, shame on u
miraclelh 11 months ago 20
@miraclelh People criticised him not becasue he is BRaved and stand for his country people criticise him for been uneducated about rare earth and easy to be Manipulated by Fuziah. You think Fuziah will have a job is shehas nothing to complain about?Thats how she makes a living.
EdmondKua 11 months ago
@miraclelh Shame on you for not helping the Malaysian economy and improving the prosperity of the malaysian people and increasing unemployment.
EdmondKua 11 months ago
@EdmondKua so what if u are employed and in return ur health is compensated? any point? what if the plant is constructed in your back yard? will u be happily celebrating it? think thoroughly, think. wealth is no where near as important especially when its your people's health that you are compensating. I don't give a damn about rare earth, i know people in Bukit Merah, Perak has suffered from projects like this, and why are we allowing another tragedy to happen?
miraclelh 11 months ago
@miraclelh If i am unemployment . UNEMPLOYMENT lead to drug addiction and crime in this Nation. IF there is no job in Malaysia the crime rate will go up and people will get robbed and even worst rapes.
WHat tradegy are you talking about you are comparing apples and unripe apples. Just becasue one apple is sour doesn't mean ALL apples is sour! This is about politics! This is about Fuziah getting her chance to rise up in politics and she used your OWN FEARS AGAINST you.
EdmondKua 11 months ago
@EdmondKua still u dont get the point, its not politics we are talking about, we are just citizens, we care about our health. the government just recently took in 45,000 labour from india, you think they are so concerned about employment rate that they just allow lynas to build a rare earth processing plant just to improve employment rate? so back to the question, what if the plant is situation right beside your home, will you still celebrate it? :)
miraclelh 11 months ago