yes im not sure this works well on piano and without lyrics.seems he missed the point although ive got a lot of respect for anyone who can play the piano as its damned hard!
I think some of the people who are saying it sounds nothing like Elliott Smith's song or who are criticizing the pianist I think you should appreciate the fact that he actually played a song by the most amazing artist and just because he didn't sound exactly like Elliott he shouldn't be looked down upon. I don't think Elliott would hate this version just because it's not the same as his, I'm pretty sure he would like it. I certainly wouldn't want to hear a song of mine played the same exact way.
yes im not sure this works well on piano and without lyrics.seems he missed the point although ive got a lot of respect for anyone who can play the piano as its damned hard!
bradshawvincent 1 year ago
I think some of the people who are saying it sounds nothing like Elliott Smith's song or who are criticizing the pianist I think you should appreciate the fact that he actually played a song by the most amazing artist and just because he didn't sound exactly like Elliott he shouldn't be looked down upon. I don't think Elliott would hate this version just because it's not the same as his, I'm pretty sure he would like it. I certainly wouldn't want to hear a song of mine played the same exact way.
jrmagic43 2 years ago
The rhythm is limp. Misses the mark for me. Too bad.
cyrussink 2 years ago
WOW...
normanhate 2 years ago
I just Love the ending, so Dark and rough. .
dondempezar 2 years ago
i actually found the ending to be quite pretentious...but i guess it's just a matter of personal taste.
TrevorKingKwong 2 years ago
:D!!
dondempezar 2 years ago
It starts off good, but ends horribly... went way overboard.
marley404040 3 years ago
Over-harmonized, at times way to dissonant and reeking of arrogance. I can't really see Elliott would have joined this, and i know i don't.
ICantAnswerYou 3 years ago
is it just me or are some notes really off?
ModestMousekateer 4 years ago 4
Yes, i'm not sure if it's intentional or not.
sixxers 4 years ago
Comment removed
shinesinpines 1 year ago
beautiful. i wish you could find sheet music like this.
jenrostyle 4 years ago
Look on his website, I coulda swore I saw it there-but its not cheap.
nicetattoostupid 4 years ago
i love listening to home to oblivion and the radiohead tributes as i drive around portland.. perfect!
ghost
strungoutandthin 4 years ago
thanks for posting this. it's one of my favourites (and my bald spot doesn't look too bad; didn't know i had one!)
cheers!
chris
blackstar69 5 years ago
hey look, its chris himself! great job there, i love this song, definitely one of my favs too.
neurotik 5 years ago
a great song. I like the passion at the end, but maybe a few too many notes for me. Thanks
Barca87 5 years ago
yeah, it is reharmonized a bit, but still pleasing. not quite what elliott intended I'm sure, though a worthy effort.
swansong6666 5 years ago