My greatgrandfather was iin the battle of the bulge, and he told me that the germans, many of them hated hilter. But, they thought they had to fight for their families and countries or death would become.
and you would have been standing there brave, hand risen up into the air and yelling "KILL ME!" ?
you stupid fool would have done the same.. lying for saving your fucking god damn ass!
so dont talk shit about this scene. you dont even know a bit about war. you cant imaging how men felt in the battlefields.. codvideoproductions, wow.. then i guess that you only play CoD, a game from america with pseudo-patriotic bullshit in it.. ignorant child!
@citizenph1L -_- would you calm down? i mean what's eating you man? I play CoD cause its fun. And name ONE part in my comment where i was saying anything bad about the scene in the comment? i don't see any. And i do happen to know a lot about war. Your right maby i can't know what its exactly like in the war, but i have a pretty good idea. Happen to like this movie... a lot... and im very interested in WW2 so i wouldn't say anything really offensive to it so the real ignorant child would be you
Remember kids, if someones making you dig your own grave, the trick is to keep talking and shovelling near the soldier pointing the gun. Then at the right moment, act as if you've struck a rock and can't dig any further, lift the shovel up as if you're going to hack the ground, and dive forward driving it at his knees.
I find this bit the saddest because 99.9% of the Wehrmacht were exactly the same as our guys, not wanting to fight or die. Barely any of them shared the ideals that Hitler and his officers believed in.
@DeformedMelonFilms Yes, but sadly thats how a large scale war is. They take men out of their homes and give them a gun. I was really sad during this scene.
haha yeah most of them may have been forced to fight but watch the end of the movie that german there ran into his men instead of the americans and shot a bunch of armericans at the end
fuck that guy. After they dropped him off, then he killed many Americanere. He is in the movie at the end but dies. Although he was forced to be with and attacking America after having been released. He did not need to kill some one..
I do not know what I am suppose to think when I watch things like this happening in saving private ryan and band of brothers. American soliders killing unarmed german prisioners Am I suppose to think that thoes fascist, genocidic pigs deserve it? or am i suppose to be appauled by it? because to tell you the truth I am appauled by it. I am under the impression that they are humanizing the krauts in this movie and this was directed by same jewish director who made schindlers list. I don't get it.
Most Wehrmacht, Kriegsmarine and Luftwaffe soldiers weren't nazis. SS troops were more than likely nazis, but Himmler basically took the strongest recruits for the SS and didn't really care about ideology.
@abaddon5 This is where most Americans get their history mixed up. When they think the regular German Wehrmacht thinks they are Nazis. Its like saying our U.S. Army are capitalists, which doesn't make sense at all.
I agree. Another point is that the various German services had to agree to wear the swastika. Another point is that various German officers were plotting to kill Hitler since he was basically fucking up everywhere since his fingers were in just about every operation.
@PadraikKasier i dont think anyone should be killed and we should avoid war period. But some guys like this German had to fight for his family and country so.
@DREWVIX1992; Never mind, it's not the same character. But I still stand by that he deserved to be killed, or at least that I would not have blamed Miller and the company if they decided to.
I bet you asshole patriots are gonna be commenting "ohhh he needs to die, screw that german" not callin u guys assholes but if u think this normal german deserves to die like the others then just shame on you. Your the real nazi scum.
@DREWVIX1992; Considering he came back and mercilessly cut the throats of the very men that spared his life, yeah I'd say that's reason enough for him to deserve death. Forgive me if that makes me the "real nazi scum".
@flectz; I didn't argue that all Germans were Nazis, man. I'm saying that this particular character deserved it. It's a soldier's duty to be ready to kill the enemy.
Also, thank you for telling me that. I was not aware that they were not the same character.
I'm a German-American and my grandfather was a Sargent in the German army during WW2. He was living in Russia at the time and was forced to join the army because he was German. He and my uncle hated Hitler but was forced to fight the Russians. He said many soldier felt the same way.
...So there are points to be made for both arguments; those who claim to know truth are just blowhards spouting nonsense. I'd bet some saying this are still in high school, with the typical cocksure assertions of youth. I've read many books on the Third Reich - some opposed, some didn't, but they fought.
...During Stalingrad many believed their Fuhrer would save them, yes even during Stalingrad, one of the most brutal, ferocious, hopeless conflicts of the war (they were wrong of course). You must consider the ethos of the German as well - the importance of following orders and their tendency to follow patterns of authoritarian behavior (Jarausch). The allies tried to eradicate this behavior with denazification after the war.
If you folks are going to make claims that Germans didn't want to fight or didn't like Hitler, you MUST quote sources or you have no credibility. Even historians aren't entirely sure one way or the other how ordinary soldiers felt, but Hitler was undeniably the most popular leader in the world by the late 30s and was at the zenith of his power before Barbarossa (Kershaw). But with Nazification and threat of the Gestapo for speaking ill of Hitler, who knew how most felt...
@mikeduplantier can we at least agree, that though some soldiers probably willingly joined the German army, some didn't? I think both side of the argument both are true in a way
@mikeduplantier I definetely think most germans sympathized with hitler but it doesn't even take half a brain to clue out that this man was sasying positives things about america just so he could survive :)
My great grandfather fought for the German army, and he's still alive. But you know what? He was a conscript. So were all of his friends. His friends who were killed by allied soldiers, whose wives were raped by Russian soldiers. My Great Grandfather does not like what he did, and he hated it while he was doing it. Both sides were terrible, just remember that the victors write the history books, asshole.
I felt bad for that German soldier. He was just fowlling his orders. Most German soldiers were just defending their country and weren't evil like Hitler.
u can see that not al germans soldiers were 'bad' they had to or their children of girlfriend would be shot or something else he had to and he wants to live
no wonder....smoking a german cig was like smoking a turd. It tastes awful. In fact, they liked Marlboro's and Lucky cigarettes so much that German soldiers took them from American POW's. By international laws of war, taking smokes away from soldiers was forbidden because they were considered as personals. But the Germans didn't care.
@WhiteSlift yeah if u noticed, alot of german soldiers in the movie were made to look like cavemen with shaved heads, grizzled features, ugly or old, etc. in reality alot of german soldiers were just regular looking people and they did have hair.
Yeah most Wehrmacht soldiers they would have faced would have been fresh faced 18/19 year old kids. No real difference from your average American in appearance-many Americans are of German descent themselves. Most Germans had loose haircuts, and none shaved their heads. This film also features only Anglosaxons as American soldiers, ignoring German, Irish, Scottish, Italian etc Americans who fought in large numbers,&overstates the role of other minorities,particularly JewishAmericans.
@gunninlinguist Someone is clearly particularly ignorant of a memorable scene in which one soldier points out to a procession of German soldiers that he is a 'Juden' as well as the Italian-American Sergeant of the squad... Plus Upham (spelling?) hardly looks like an Anglo-Saxon to me.
@nddavi58 idk if you are poking fun at Germans by saying they look like cavemen, but I didn't see any of that in the movie. I don't remember seeing ugly and old German soldiers. The Wehrmacht of course had soldiers with shaved hair, bald hair, full hair, and I saw all those types in the movie, even though it was often hard to tell the hairstyles of soldiers when they wore their helmet. They all looked like regular looking people.
@nddavi58 cept for the fact that the german army made them shave their heads. Same with american military personnel. Just saying, both sides looked like cavemen
@staidenofanarchy no actually alot of german soldiers used pomade in their hair and slicked it back. my point is that in this film spielberg used certain tactics to persuade the audience..
@ilovetennis66 he was doing his job his mates killed the americans mates and vise-versa and then they let him go. You can't say hes a bad guy if both groups where doing there jobs.
id let every1 live....xcept the fanatical nazis of the Waffen SS. they were pure evil. the german regulars were forced to fight and most of them hated hitler.
I already removed the comment, but it said something like "I would've shot him." In reality, I probably wouldn't have, but I probably wrote it because I know that letting him live comes back to bite those guys in the butt later on in the movie. Sorry to have caused such a controversy.
Did they left him live cause im german so is most of my familiy he had no other choice hitler was makeing everyone fight bust into homes saying your going to war
if they show any mercy let him have it i wont feel right if he dies
@ktockly Really would you now? So if you had 6 guys with guns forcing you to dig your own grave you would be Mr.calm cool and collected? War isn't COD, there is no save points and no respawn. Im sure you would have already shit your self and would be begging at their feet.
@thelastspaceman I know war isnt anything like COD at all, im not that fucking stupid. Yes, i admit i would be fucking terrified if 6 guys where pointing guns at me, ofcourse i would be terrified but i wouldnt start weeping and crying on my knees.
@DesolateGrunt - Wrong, Quarter of the Nazi Military didnt want to fight. This here Nazi's desperate to live, he would do anything to live. He kills this one guy at the end of the movie, btw.
@DesolateGrunt - No, not all of them were. That's a myth. May I recommend "Ordinary Men" by Christopher Browning. Extremely informing and fascinating.
sorry, i didn't. if it makes you feel better, i'll delete that comment. i forgot about it, seeing as how I made it 3 mo ago. i kind of feel sorry for him. how can you be sure that the testimonial of being forced to fight is true, that they weren't lying to make up for what they did, or just to make up for being in the Nazi army?
@AlWaterford Well not all soldiers were forced to fight. Some were straight Nazis, and then you had types like Schindler who didn't want to be a Nazi for all those reasons, so he had to go behind Hitlers back and basically save a select group of jews by lying. I dunno, it's a little foggy seeing as I learned about all of this last year in 10th grade Global history ;P
@NYYankees4240 That's not true. They were soldiers who made an oath to the Fuhrer and as such followed orders. Don't attempt to rewrite history by saying most German soldiers were "forced" to fight. That's bullshit. They're soldiers. That's what soldiers do: Fight.
@Dresden1065 A lot of soldiers were forced into fighting for the Nazi army. I'm not rewriting history at all, that IS history. Hitler might have been great at brainwashing, but he was also very forceful too.
@Pokemon68532 Hitler and his band of Nazis wanted the world to be run by what he considered the Aryan race. Not all German soldiers believe in Hilter's ideals though, but were still forced to fight.
@Pokemon68532 Well if Obama wanted to take over the world and you where dragged out of your dragged out of your home and from your familt,and friends.The russians come to save the day and you are their prisoner I wonder if they say the same thing about you,The person who was forced into this war who seen many others who where and where not willing to die fall into a bloody mess.
@NYYankees4240 You really believe that? They fought for their race and their pride they fought for their country. Hitler made them believe they were superhumans that's why they kept on fighting til the end
@mikeduplantier
Barbarossa. His biggest battle was Stalingrad.
Z0mbieS1ayer 1 month ago
Comment removed
Z0mbieS1ayer 1 month ago
haha, i love this guy!
H4L0K1LL4 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
He probably didn't follow Hitlers ideology but he only said fuck Hitler to save his ass.
HirachieOfSociety 2 months ago
Comment removed
HirachieOfSociety 2 months ago
as always the yank is the winner...
angartex 2 months ago
betty bou what a dish, betty grable, what a gam
TheDarkNobleOne 3 months ago
If I was one of those soldiers I would be like " this nazi is so pathetic and just shoot him .
TheMartinmarine80 3 months ago
@TheMartinmarine80 I'd like to see you pull an arrogant face in his position, stupid kid.
McFaintful 2 months ago
@McFaintful
fuck off
TheMartinmarine80 2 months ago
@TheMartinmarine80 My point proven.
McFaintful 2 months ago
@McFaintful diseapear nazi fag .
TheMartinmarine80 2 months ago
@TheMartinmarine80 Grow the fuck up.
McFaintful 2 months ago
@McFaintful go chock on a dick TROLL
TheMartinmarine80 2 months ago
@TheMartinmarine80 You don't even know what a troll is. Brat.
McFaintful 2 months ago
My greatgrandfather was iin the battle of the bulge, and he told me that the germans, many of them hated hilter. But, they thought they had to fight for their families and countries or death would become.
shaydyknight 3 months ago
i say can you see i say can you see........fuck hitler FUCK HITLER greatest national anthem ever!!!!
ARMY2498 5 months ago
he was acting like that cause he didnt want to be killed... end of story
CODvideoPRODUCTIONS 5 months ago
@CODvideoPRODUCTIONS
and you would have been standing there brave, hand risen up into the air and yelling "KILL ME!" ?
you stupid fool would have done the same.. lying for saving your fucking god damn ass!
so dont talk shit about this scene. you dont even know a bit about war. you cant imaging how men felt in the battlefields.. codvideoproductions, wow.. then i guess that you only play CoD, a game from america with pseudo-patriotic bullshit in it.. ignorant child!
citizenph1L 4 months ago
@citizenph1L -_- would you calm down? i mean what's eating you man? I play CoD cause its fun. And name ONE part in my comment where i was saying anything bad about the scene in the comment? i don't see any. And i do happen to know a lot about war. Your right maby i can't know what its exactly like in the war, but i have a pretty good idea. Happen to like this movie... a lot... and im very interested in WW2 so i wouldn't say anything really offensive to it so the real ignorant child would be you
CODvideoPRODUCTIONS 4 months ago
Hey put the whole thing on where also sings the national anthem....i say can you see I say can you see lol
pwrby2zz 6 months ago
Remember kids, if someones making you dig your own grave, the trick is to keep talking and shovelling near the soldier pointing the gun. Then at the right moment, act as if you've struck a rock and can't dig any further, lift the shovel up as if you're going to hack the ground, and dive forward driving it at his knees.
-Chopper
gunninlinguist 7 months ago
They was not forced into fighting...they where brainwashed by false propaganda
But some children where forced into HITLER YOUTH CAMPS.
THESTANDARDKID 7 months ago
I find this bit the saddest because 99.9% of the Wehrmacht were exactly the same as our guys, not wanting to fight or die. Barely any of them shared the ideals that Hitler and his officers believed in.
DeformedMelonFilms 7 months ago 9
@DeformedMelonFilms Yes, but sadly thats how a large scale war is. They take men out of their homes and give them a gun. I was really sad during this scene.
SwordPengy8 7 months ago
@DeformedMelonFilms not 99.9% but deffinetly a very large part of the army, the ones responsable for most of the atrocities were the SS troops.
H4L0K1LL4 1 month ago
@DeformedMelonFilms That and brain washed by Hitler.
MightyMeehow 4 weeks ago
Comment removed
DeformedMelonFilms 7 months ago
Comment removed
DeformedMelonFilms 7 months ago
Comment removed
DeformedMelonFilms 7 months ago
Comment removed
DeformedMelonFilms 7 months ago
haha yeah most of them may have been forced to fight but watch the end of the movie that german there ran into his men instead of the americans and shot a bunch of armericans at the end
Djoneill25 7 months ago
there were 2 armies , wehrmacht( like us army) and SS(ELITE like the marines) SS were the nazis not the wehrmacht who got forced in fight
Sonny0612 7 months ago
fuck that guy. After they dropped him off, then he killed many Americanere. He is in the movie at the end but dies. Although he was forced to be with and attacking America after having been released. He did not need to kill some one..
Divenzz 7 months ago
I do not know what I am suppose to think when I watch things like this happening in saving private ryan and band of brothers. American soliders killing unarmed german prisioners Am I suppose to think that thoes fascist, genocidic pigs deserve it? or am i suppose to be appauled by it? because to tell you the truth I am appauled by it. I am under the impression that they are humanizing the krauts in this movie and this was directed by same jewish director who made schindlers list. I don't get it.
hans1538 7 months ago
wenigstens haben die produzenten nicht so einen wannabe deutschen für den film genommen^^
BasinZima 8 months ago
This motherfucker should be killed because he killed Miller and many more at the end
Xditti 10 months ago
@Xditti naw Umpum killed them, hes a coward and a traitor and he should be shot....
BigPrimo33 10 months ago
@Xditti Its war man
1tacoman17 8 months ago
@Xditti yeah fuck this guy. Just what you wrote bothered me to !
Divenzz 7 months ago
The sad part is this probably happened many times, on many sides. Most soldiers were drafted.
Bmanstudios101 10 months ago
steamboat willie, CHOO CHOO.
airborne1940 10 months ago
Steam Boat Willy.....
CHOOO CHOO!!!!
=]
pvtjamesryan3 11 months ago
not all nazis were bad. Many of them were forced into doing what they did. The rest were either loyal or just plain crazy.
link0zeldarulz89 11 months ago
@link0zeldarulz89
Most Wehrmacht, Kriegsmarine and Luftwaffe soldiers weren't nazis. SS troops were more than likely nazis, but Himmler basically took the strongest recruits for the SS and didn't really care about ideology.
abaddon5 10 months ago
@abaddon5 This is where most Americans get their history mixed up. When they think the regular German Wehrmacht thinks they are Nazis. Its like saying our U.S. Army are capitalists, which doesn't make sense at all.
collegefootballrulez 10 months ago
@collegefootballrulez
I agree. Another point is that the various German services had to agree to wear the swastika. Another point is that various German officers were plotting to kill Hitler since he was basically fucking up everywhere since his fingers were in just about every operation.
abaddon5 10 months ago
were can i find the movie where the german sings the american folksong?
TheKoenBrouwer 11 months ago
i cried here :(, until I saw the end.
SwordPengy8 11 months ago
@PadraikKasier i dont think anyone should be killed and we should avoid war period. But some guys like this German had to fight for his family and country so.
DREWVIX1992 11 months ago
@PadraikKasier when did he come back in the movie and cut throats
DREWVIX1992 11 months ago
@DREWVIX1992; Never mind, it's not the same character. But I still stand by that he deserved to be killed, or at least that I would not have blamed Miller and the company if they decided to.
PadraikKasier 11 months ago
The ironic thing was when he was set free, he came back and fought with the nazi's again..
upakyou 11 months ago
@upakyou then he killed captain miller, then upham killed him...
SwordPengy8 11 months ago
I bet you asshole patriots are gonna be commenting "ohhh he needs to die, screw that german" not callin u guys assholes but if u think this normal german deserves to die like the others then just shame on you. Your the real nazi scum.
DREWVIX1992 11 months ago
@DREWVIX1992; Considering he came back and mercilessly cut the throats of the very men that spared his life, yeah I'd say that's reason enough for him to deserve death. Forgive me if that makes me the "real nazi scum".
PadraikKasier 11 months ago
@PadraikKasier that was a common misconception. it's actually a different guy who cut the throats of mellish
and do you realize how dumb you're sounding right now? you're using a MOVIE PLOT to argue that all germans are nazis..
flectz 11 months ago
@flectz; I didn't argue that all Germans were Nazis, man. I'm saying that this particular character deserved it. It's a soldier's duty to be ready to kill the enemy.
Also, thank you for telling me that. I was not aware that they were not the same character.
PadraikKasier 11 months ago
lol
this is the best part of the whole movie!!!
Steam Boat Willy!!!! CHOOOO CHOOO!!!
pvtjamesryan3 1 year ago
I'm a German-American and my grandfather was a Sargent in the German army during WW2. He was living in Russia at the time and was forced to join the army because he was German. He and my uncle hated Hitler but was forced to fight the Russians. He said many soldier felt the same way.
LVblaze 1 year ago
For some reason, the German Guy reminds me of Gollum from Lord of the Rings. He's cool.
reaverwes 1 year ago
Fancy Chmanzy
RangerSniperX 1 year ago
...These YouTube arguments are getting old. Can we all just agree to disagree and watch the video.
Fancy Schmancy, Go Fly A Kite, Cool Beans.
DiedrichVK 1 year ago
...So there are points to be made for both arguments; those who claim to know truth are just blowhards spouting nonsense. I'd bet some saying this are still in high school, with the typical cocksure assertions of youth. I've read many books on the Third Reich - some opposed, some didn't, but they fought.
mikeduplantier 1 year ago
...During Stalingrad many believed their Fuhrer would save them, yes even during Stalingrad, one of the most brutal, ferocious, hopeless conflicts of the war (they were wrong of course). You must consider the ethos of the German as well - the importance of following orders and their tendency to follow patterns of authoritarian behavior (Jarausch). The allies tried to eradicate this behavior with denazification after the war.
mikeduplantier 1 year ago
If you folks are going to make claims that Germans didn't want to fight or didn't like Hitler, you MUST quote sources or you have no credibility. Even historians aren't entirely sure one way or the other how ordinary soldiers felt, but Hitler was undeniably the most popular leader in the world by the late 30s and was at the zenith of his power before Barbarossa (Kershaw). But with Nazification and threat of the Gestapo for speaking ill of Hitler, who knew how most felt...
mikeduplantier 1 year ago 7
@mikeduplantier can we at least agree, that though some soldiers probably willingly joined the German army, some didn't? I think both side of the argument both are true in a way
JasmperMdong 1 year ago
@mikeduplantier I definetely think most germans sympathized with hitler but it doesn't even take half a brain to clue out that this man was sasying positives things about america just so he could survive :)
pepinozinanasshole 2 months ago
@mikeduplantier
My great grandfather fought for the German army, and he's still alive. But you know what? He was a conscript. So were all of his friends. His friends who were killed by allied soldiers, whose wives were raped by Russian soldiers. My Great Grandfather does not like what he did, and he hated it while he was doing it. Both sides were terrible, just remember that the victors write the history books, asshole.
Z0mbieS1ayer 1 month ago
Should not have let him lived ; that fucker shot Miller!!!
MrOrion92 1 year ago
I felt bad for that German soldier. He was just fowlling his orders. Most German soldiers were just defending their country and weren't evil like Hitler.
MLC192 1 year ago
this scene almost made me cry. i really like how this movie shows that it was hard for germany an america
boymyfeetsmell 1 year ago
u can see that not al germans soldiers were 'bad' they had to or their children of girlfriend would be shot or something else he had to and he wants to live
pkillerkillz 1 year ago
my favourite scene, would put myself in front of him before they shot anybody.
legewright 1 year ago
too bad he had to stab the guy at the end
Skwiikers 1 year ago
no wonder....smoking a german cig was like smoking a turd. It tastes awful. In fact, they liked Marlboro's and Lucky cigarettes so much that German soldiers took them from American POW's. By international laws of war, taking smokes away from soldiers was forbidden because they were considered as personals. But the Germans didn't care.
gmccord1970 1 year ago
poor guy i know the germans where wrong during WWII but if when i look at him i would have let him go
NLdoggyNL 1 year ago
Poor ol' jimmy
PetoEntertainment 1 year ago
I have so much respect for the german army in ww2 its only the SS that i dont like the regular troops were the best in the war in my opinion.
GillsFan91 1 year ago
r.i.p. steamboat willie
sawu101 1 year ago
Upham=american progessive
tenyardrambo 1 year ago 2
@tenyardrambo
Upham = Coward and homo.
Bllasae 1 year ago
such a sad movie.. i wish i could go back in time though.
pepperonipizza1993 1 year ago
gotta love steamboat willie!
MyHorsesRBest 1 year ago
Poor dude .. Ahhh.. So cruel from the americans maaan
BloXboX37 1 year ago
@BloXboX37 dude..he's been release by miller
NewSarcaticRascist 1 year ago
@BloXboX37 they end up letting him go.
TheBackOfTheBoat 1 year ago
His hair is completely wrong. German soldiers didn't have bald shaved heads during the war.
WhiteSlift 1 year ago
@WhiteSlift none of them? none at all? nada? nilch? zero?
p0tazzium 1 year ago
@WhiteSlift yeah if u noticed, alot of german soldiers in the movie were made to look like cavemen with shaved heads, grizzled features, ugly or old, etc. in reality alot of german soldiers were just regular looking people and they did have hair.
nddavi58 1 year ago 7
@nddavi58
Yeah most Wehrmacht soldiers they would have faced would have been fresh faced 18/19 year old kids. No real difference from your average American in appearance-many Americans are of German descent themselves. Most Germans had loose haircuts, and none shaved their heads. This film also features only Anglosaxons as American soldiers, ignoring German, Irish, Scottish, Italian etc Americans who fought in large numbers,&overstates the role of other minorities,particularly JewishAmericans.
gunninlinguist 7 months ago
@gunninlinguist Someone is clearly particularly ignorant of a memorable scene in which one soldier points out to a procession of German soldiers that he is a 'Juden' as well as the Italian-American Sergeant of the squad... Plus Upham (spelling?) hardly looks like an Anglo-Saxon to me.
Henners1991 6 months ago
@nddavi58 idk if you are poking fun at Germans by saying they look like cavemen, but I didn't see any of that in the movie. I don't remember seeing ugly and old German soldiers. The Wehrmacht of course had soldiers with shaved hair, bald hair, full hair, and I saw all those types in the movie, even though it was often hard to tell the hairstyles of soldiers when they wore their helmet. They all looked like regular looking people.
elitestar 5 months ago
@nddavi58 their uniforms look so great that they still look better than the americans
01077448731 5 months ago
@nddavi58 cept for the fact that the german army made them shave their heads. Same with american military personnel. Just saying, both sides looked like cavemen
staidenofanarchy 2 months ago
@staidenofanarchy no actually alot of german soldiers used pomade in their hair and slicked it back. my point is that in this film spielberg used certain tactics to persuade the audience..
nddavi58 2 months ago
you are a retard if you feel bad for him: you guys didn't even watch the movie
ilovetennis66 1 year ago
@ilovetennis66 he was doing his job his mates killed the americans mates and vise-versa and then they let him go. You can't say hes a bad guy if both groups where doing there jobs.
ViDeOMaStErPaUl 1 year ago
id let every1 live....xcept the fanatical nazis of the Waffen SS. they were pure evil. the german regulars were forced to fight and most of them hated hitler.
NROONEY456 1 year ago
i feel sorry for that poor german guy :(
NROONEY456 1 year ago
@NROONEY456 Did you feel sorry for him when he killed 2 men of that squad in the final battle? lol
ThatInnerDarkness 1 year ago
@ThatInnerDarkness well it was his duty to fight
NROONEY456 1 year ago
i would have shot him. i said that Before i saw him later in the movie.
nightjj 1 year ago
I already removed the comment, but it said something like "I would've shot him." In reality, I probably wouldn't have, but I probably wrote it because I know that letting him live comes back to bite those guys in the butt later on in the movie. Sorry to have caused such a controversy.
AlWaterford 1 year ago
Did they left him live cause im german so is most of my familiy he had no other choice hitler was makeing everyone fight bust into homes saying your going to war
if they show any mercy let him have it i wont feel right if he dies
mmflattireproduction 1 year ago
This is actually a Lost flashback, Faraday is actually like wolverine and we see him here taking part in one of the many wars in world history.
wavedave45 1 year ago
German soldiers were forced into fighting?????? LOL what history book have you been reading?
Higgins86 1 year ago
@Higgins86 Helloooo it's HITLER where talking about, he FORCED them.
LostSpartanFilms 1 year ago
I love how they are all called Nazi's. oh history...
SS0UTHB0UND 1 year ago
wow, if i was that german guy i would have showed some class and wouldnt act so desperate. like he did.
ktockly 1 year ago
@ktockly Really would you now? So if you had 6 guys with guns forcing you to dig your own grave you would be Mr.calm cool and collected? War isn't COD, there is no save points and no respawn. Im sure you would have already shit your self and would be begging at their feet.
thelastspaceman 1 year ago
@thelastspaceman I know war isnt anything like COD at all, im not that fucking stupid. Yes, i admit i would be fucking terrified if 6 guys where pointing guns at me, ofcourse i would be terrified but i wouldnt start weeping and crying on my knees.
ktockly 1 year ago
@ktockly
You'd be a classy Nazi?
>_>
You're criticizing him on his class? xD oh wow.
cawright10 1 year ago
wat happened to the nazi after this?
BLAHBLAH38676 1 year ago
later on in the movie, he was shot by Upham, the guy he was smoking with.
Amysteryname 1 year ago
lmao
and Matrix was a documentary for some morons)
jou managed to lose ardennen battle with like 100% air superiority
crocolix 2 years ago
German soldiers were forced into fighting by the Nazi's, he wanted to live.
DesolateGrunt 2 years ago 33
@DesolateGrunt - Wrong, Quarter of the Nazi Military didnt want to fight. This here Nazi's desperate to live, he would do anything to live. He kills this one guy at the end of the movie, btw.
VNM92 2 years ago 3
I think it was more than one of them he comes back and kills later.
snarst 1 year ago
@DesolateGrunt And at the end he shot one of the guys? Wow, He didn't have to shoot him..
deathwing98 1 year ago
@DesolateGrunt but he delibrately shot miller at the end.
iTZzArJuN 1 year ago
@DesolateGrunt why is that such a popular cliché? German soldiers wanted to fight for their country, and there is nothing wrong with that.
Ismailikov 1 year ago
@DesolateGrunt - No, not all of them were. That's a myth. May I recommend "Ordinary Men" by Christopher Browning. Extremely informing and fascinating.
ThrillerWA09 8 months ago
Comment removed
AlWaterford 2 years ago
You realize most German soldiers were forced into fighting right?
NYYankees4240 2 years ago 40
sorry, i didn't. if it makes you feel better, i'll delete that comment. i forgot about it, seeing as how I made it 3 mo ago. i kind of feel sorry for him. how can you be sure that the testimonial of being forced to fight is true, that they weren't lying to make up for what they did, or just to make up for being in the Nazi army?
AlWaterford 2 years ago
@AlWaterford Well not all soldiers were forced to fight. Some were straight Nazis, and then you had types like Schindler who didn't want to be a Nazi for all those reasons, so he had to go behind Hitlers back and basically save a select group of jews by lying. I dunno, it's a little foggy seeing as I learned about all of this last year in 10th grade Global history ;P
NYYankees4240 1 year ago
@NYYankees4240 That's not true. They were soldiers who made an oath to the Fuhrer and as such followed orders. Don't attempt to rewrite history by saying most German soldiers were "forced" to fight. That's bullshit. They're soldiers. That's what soldiers do: Fight.
Dresden1065 1 year ago
@Dresden1065 A lot of soldiers were forced into fighting for the Nazi army. I'm not rewriting history at all, that IS history. Hitler might have been great at brainwashing, but he was also very forceful too.
NYYankees4240 1 year ago
@NYYankees4240 no they wanted to take over the world
Pokemon68532 1 year ago
@Pokemon68532 Hitler and his band of Nazis wanted the world to be run by what he considered the Aryan race. Not all German soldiers believe in Hilter's ideals though, but were still forced to fight.
NYYankees4240 1 year ago
@Pokemon68532 Well if Obama wanted to take over the world and you where dragged out of your dragged out of your home and from your familt,and friends.The russians come to save the day and you are their prisoner I wonder if they say the same thing about you,The person who was forced into this war who seen many others who where and where not willing to die fall into a bloody mess.
stevedude92 1 year ago
@NYYankees4240 You really believe that? They fought for their race and their pride they fought for their country. Hitler made them believe they were superhumans that's why they kept on fighting til the end
STHLMGnaget 10 months ago
@NYYankees4240 yes but there were no excuses for just following orders
mingfai3 10 months ago