Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (92)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Ok let's say that this is one of her bad performance. But it's not right to sabotage Mariah through this videos. Mariah carey is a clever singer and she will do anything just for her fans. Mariah undergo many miscarriage and she has a vocal nodules. She only needs to rest her voice.

  • she just hit the whisper register pretty high so if you can do better just show me. Can't you? pffh, loser.

  • bitch , please . go fuck your mom and some

  • no ones perfect.. even mariah! but she is still amazing as always! cmon try to sing HATE YOU, and surely ur voice will squeaklike a duck! hahahha

  • This is only funny because everyone knows she can sing and is regarded as one of the best vocalists ever. 

  • @tygersflowerz Christina doesn't have a voice

  • LOL at top comments..poor Kummy got her ass handed miserably. what a treat!

  • She suffered a miscarriage and then was probably pregnant here on hormones...I think she also must have had sleepless nice which effects the voice.

  • because it is such a hard song to sing live.

  • Nothing pains over here...!

  • She's struggling cause you have to sing in a restrained voice for this song, just like "butterfly", the whispery and restrained (key word re-STRAINED) vocals are done purposely to represent the longing and desperation she has for her lover in the song, while i will admit she IS struggling, thats only cause due to it being restrained, it's hard to keep your breath (just try singing it like her) and the fact that she is wearing that tight ass corset, adds to why she can't catch her breath

  • Damn it must be hard trying to find Mariah fails. After nearly a decade of flawless vocals. This is what makes lambs rag on wells....nearly every xtina performance ever almost and celine lipping since she couldn't handle the oh so difficult power of love.

  • Even though it's strain so pls ask yourself Can you sing better than this! Idiiot!!

  • Mariah Carey is the BEST!! she is number 1, its a fact not an opinion! "so stop! Hatein is bad" not only does she sing the songs beautifuly! they are jam pack with RAW, REAL, EMOTION, on heartbreak and love and life, and to bare all that intimate feelings when she sings and not cry because the songs have such a connection to her life, she could very well be holding back tears bcuz the song is so real to her, its not make believe lyrics from someone who passed sheet music to her, its all MC!!!!!

  • Amazing as usual!

  • Horrible. Even my burps are more melodious than this crap.

    

  • She is SO AMAZING but.... Omfg' this is horrible ._.

  • @xxcuitiehoneyxx-its funny how all of the many un dubbed mariah performaces its always a sack of excuses even when she first came out they would ask her to sing acapella and she always had excuses bottom line the bitch has cheated for years and people are busting her out with youtube

  • @iamdeznuts1 is that why she sang vision of love acapella ? or even all in your mind acapella (which by the way is a very hard song to sing) i think you just need to get a life and stop hating on mariah.

  • @iamdeznuts1 LOL gay nigga

  • @neinsager Anyone who THINKS he has to poke fun at minority groups to win a point - The JOKE is always on that one.

  • wtf

    

  • @aleeshaee- out of breathe from what? she's standing still singing a ballad .....

  • She is out of breath you idiot !

  • I have wondered about this too, sometimes she seems to have very hard time singing. I just wish she could sing as she used to, effortless. Maybe she is singing "the wrong" songs, you know this "whisper" songs and start sing songs she used to sing, using her voice in a right way? Its difficult because I like MC but I do miss MC from the first MTV performance.

  • what happen to her voice??????????? the bitch never had one to begin with. when you record an album in a top notch studio and fucking the owner of the company you overdubb and retouch live performance she is a mess

  • @iamdeznuts1 today, i notice that even her most epic ballads from the early days are either double-tracked or use a lot of leeway (that echo effect). celine and christina need no such effects on their voices. :-)

  • @iamdeznuts1 you are sooo dumb. She did have one..back in the day it was real, shit wasn't lip synced. pay more attention!

  • i noticed that too

  • Severe alcoholism took away her voice.

  • @kaiyno Yet your fat ass fave is the one who got ARRESTED for being drunk in public. Embarrassing. Stop lying.

  • 0:16 "boy IIII can't wait to *wheeze* HATECHUUUUUU"

    poor moomoo :(

  • I forget something lol in the christmas special 2010*

  • Thats becouse her voice change!!!!!! she sings whistles since she was 3 years old!!!!!!!! i wish you could sing the sime for liike 40 years??? HAHAHAHHAHAHA ...and she's the imperial songbird!!!! in MOAIA tour, she sings EMOTIONS 100 % live and she does the SAME WHISTLES, as 20 years before..and in the christmas she does the SAME NOTE of someday.. a B6 , so SHE'S A QUEEN!!! AND YOU ARE A LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSERRRRRRR !!! you are jelaous becouse you can't sing SHIT!!

  • Cuntonna's envious fans are quite interesting :D Mariah Carey has a great voice, you guys can not stand her, Cher has the same, you can not stand her, too,,, You call "Whitney" "Shitney" why? Because she has amazing voice, either :D Poor cuntonna fans

  • ok this vid is stupid she sounds tire thats all and i guess yall must be fuking death to say she has never been a good singer!! shes the best selling female artist so im pretty sure shes tLented not like yall hater so fuk yall hater ..

  • If anyone wants to know what PATHETIC looks and sounds like, THIS IS IT!!!

  • @Kumtekmeon what a truly awful performance, she was struggling for dear life, the nodules, excessive over-singing and unhealthy breathy notes and whisltes have clearly taken a huge toll on her voice, a mess.

  • @XTINASDISCIPLE I have been pointing out for years that Breathy overtone while singing or speaking is unhealthy, but her fanatics continuously rant that it is a 'Gift'. MC's whistles are abuse of the False Cord, yet they claim she is the Best there is - I wonder when will the reality hit home that MC is just one UNHEALTHY singer?

  • @Kumtekmeon She tried to produce a note at 0:16, nothin but hot air came out, and all her "you's" in this performance sound extremely, I dunno, I can't quite think of the correct word but they sound like she's putting in all her effort and might to hit those basic notes, and you're correct, breathy notes are extremeley unhealthy for the chords, I've said this time and time again but her fans still fail to aknowledge it, the sad thing is she's only 42, she shouldnt be soundin this type of way.

  • @XTINASDISCIPLE All her 'Yous' are BOOS! She is lucky that Tommy had gotten her notoriety with his overspending and False PR, because if they hadn't bought her a Name, she would've been booed off a long time ago. 42 is still young in the world of singing - She's young to have babies, so she should still be young to sing. When you say this to her fans, they claim it's the Tours - They find excuse to deny every Truth! MC was simply never a good singer, and she will never be!

  • @Kumtekmeon preach sis !

  • @Kumtekmeon Look at your straining flop - aka miss Shanice Wilson - and you will recognize how shit sounds like. NEXT!

  • @Stefano94x I don't recall seeing any comments from Devotedlamb19 here for you to pick up the tab. PLEASE!!! Never in Miss Shanice Wilson's career has she EVER sounded this horrible! You ought to be ashamed of yourself!

  • @Kumtekmeon Exactly, nothing in Sharpnice's career has ever sounded so bad. Indeed, she sounded worse than this in every performance. #Dumped. Especially in that tired pitchy mess she claims to be an Alejandro cover. #FAIL.

    You're dismissed.

  • @Stefano94x You are sure HOOKED on Alejandro - Well that's the result of a GREAT performance! Shanice did not have music or background voices to help her in that offering, YET it blows most of MC's poor display of onstage desperation to Kansas!

  • @Kumtekmeon Bitch, you fail everytime you comment.

    Alejandro isn't a great performance. It isn't, it wasn't, it ain't never gonna be. Her labored flat ass screaming is not great singing in the slightest. She destroyed the melody and she was basically singing another song, and that random attempt at whistling proves how much she sucks from a musical standpoint.

  • @Stefano94x From a musical standpoint? SERIOUSLY?!!! From a musical standpoint? Let us examine this performance (or lack thereof). Flat notes, Breathy overtones, squeezed execution of notes, POOR breathing which leads to breaks in delivery - This performance was a squeezed THROATY mess! She sings as if a 500 pound woman is sitting on her chest - She is ZENITH FAIL! Yet you dare to talk crap about Shanice AMAZING rendition of Alejandro? little boy, please consult a REAL voice professional!

  • @Kumtekmeon Yes, Shanice is a sucky singer and musician. She lacks taste, her intonation is just not good, she is not technically proficient.

    Alejandro is WAY more out of tune than this performance, and it's WAY more strained than this performance. And unlike Shanice, Mariah never does senseless things when singing like Shanice's "whistle" in Alejandro. Your fav is utter crap. Get over it.

  • @Stefano94x Shanice lacks taste? All this is coming from someone who cares to defend the above CRAP! I love you!!! You obviously DON'T know what constitutes Great Singing! Shanice rendition employed balance of tone, with freedom. Her varying tones were steady and well focused and supported by proper breathing. Shanice overall approach to singing is HEALTHY. MC constipated singing is CLEARLY unhealthy! And Shanice whistle was well placed - You not liking it is your personal opinion. I pity you!

  • @Kumtekmeon Actually, Mariah has a near perfect technique. One bad performance is not representative of her whole career or voice. Unfortunetly, however, she has vocal nodules which were largely disruptive in 2008/09 and is known to like a bit of champagne (alcohol dries the vocal cords).

  • @BigBlyeEyes1234 This is NOT one bad performance! MC has many other poor performances here on You Tube. I am not here gloating, I am simply speaking the TRUTH. In addition her nodules resulted from vocal abuse from an early age.

  • @Kumtekmeon Getting vocal nodules at a young age is near impossible as the voice has to undergo an extensive amount of abuse over a period of many years. On top of this, her mother was a trained opera singer and hugely discouraged unhealthy singing.

    And Mariah has bad performances spanning from 2006-2009 - all due to alcohol, nodules and overuse. Before then, her voice was near enough perfection.

  • @BigBlyeEyes1234 Your claim is not scientifically supported- Children like adults may suffer vocal nodules IF they put strain on their voice, by screaming, shouting, excessive loud talking etc. MC in an interview years ago, confessed that in order to build her whistle register to mimic Minnie Riperton, she would go about talking in a HIGH Whispery voice - I dare you to try that, and tell me how much strain you feel. What MC did was to train herself on the False Cord, hence her nodules.

  • @Kumtekmeon Yes, but Mariah also said that when she did that as it child, it never hurt. Her mother would tell her not to talk like that (because of the potential damage) but Mariah could do it effortlessly.

    And I don't think you understand the severity you'd have to put your voice under to get nodes in such a short amount of time. Vocal nodules typically take seven, eight years to establish which seems highly unlikely for MC under the supervision of a trained opera singer mother.

  • @BigBlyeEyes1234 My point was not whether she felt pain, but that HOW she trained herself was highly abusive - Mind you her mother did warn her about it, but MC interpreted that warning to mean she would feel pain immediately, BUT the hurt was long term, and so when she finally entered the music biz and was required to sing for long periods, her voice FAILED to last for one solid decade because her foundation was built on the False Cord, because she was NOT properly trained.

  • @Kumtekmeon Her voice has lasted for two decades. It hasn't always been in great condition but this is due to alcohol, overuse and the temporality of vocal nodules - not because of bad technique. Last year, her voice massively improved because she stopped drinking. Her singing was clearer and effortless.

  • @BigBlyeEyes1234 Before the start of year 2000, MC's voice was showing strong sign of depletion, so much so a reviewer stated, "Her voice is damaged, and there's not a moment where it sounds strong or inviting." MC is heavily dependent on dubbing and has to use playbacks in order to chip in on various parts that she can no longer manage - Take those effects away and you'll hear a raspy voice with lots of breaks and flat notes. Not to say she NEVER had a pleasant voice, BUT bad techniques.

  • @Kumtekmeon Mariah's singing technique is flawless. Admittedly, her voice on the Charmbracelet (2002) album was bad, and I assume that's where that review is from. However, with The Emancipation of Mimi, her voice was back on form (if not a little dry). In 2008, she said that her vocal nodules were playing up a lot, which explained why she sounded so bad and started using backing tracks, but by 2010, her voice sounded incredible. Almost as good as in the 90's.

  • @BigBlyeEyes1234 MC's technique is like a child trying to prove how bright she is by adding UNNECESSARY details to answer a simple question. MC's singing is 'CRAMMING'. As such she FAILS to deliver the meaning of her song and you truly don't get it. Which is why her fans are mainly concerned about her ''Whistling ability", which serves as a fitting distraction to keep them focus. What you need to bear in mind is that in MC's case NODULES come about as a result of STRAINS; not touring, straining.

  • @Kumtekmeon Mariah never strains her voice. Only recently has she had trouble with certain belted notes and that's to do with her breath support which was limited because of her vocal nodules. Mariah is one of the few people have a full, rounded and healthy high belt.

    Mariah's vocal runs and melisma's are a way of emphasising the meaning of the song. Her whisper register is another technique she uses to express vulnerability among other emotions.

  • @BigBlyeEyes1234 MC's vocal nodules DID NOT come about magically, they came as a result of the ABUSE she placed on her cords over a period of time! And as I have explained her description of how she practiced herself to whistle, testifies to the abuse she endured to get that 'ability'. I don't know whose assessment of MC's voice you are reading, BUT MC is not a singer to be emulated.

    Vocal runs/Melisma are used to add character to a song and not to strengthen its meaning.

  • @Kumtekmeon You're stating a lot of what you're saying as fact when in actual fact it's just assumptions you have made. The truth is that Mariah did NOT get vocal nodules from attempting to 'whistle'. She's stated several times that her nodules are what help her reach that register, which is how she discovered she could sing that high. Fact.

    Vocal runs/melisma's can be used for whatever the singer intends them to be used for. There are no specific rules.

  • @BigBlyeEyes1234 To love and adore a singer doesn't mean you are to put aside logic. I may love Minnie, Shanice, Debelah, Jean Carne etc, BUT if they were to say that their whistling ability is as a result of nodules I would LAUGH at them and label them Insane! No serious vocal coach will validate such nonsense. Nodules impedes the voice, it doesn't help it. What the scientific community has found is that nodules came as a result of strain, AND it's by straining MC trained her whistling.

  • @Kumtekmeon Actually, there are multiple ways in which you can develop vocal nodules: straining, strenuous use of the voice or bad singing technique. It's most likely that Mariah got hers from strenuous use.

    And I think a vocal doctor and Mariah know more about her voice than you do. You're assumptions are very narrow minded and biased. You clearly dislike Mariah, most likely because of all the success she's had while Shanice remains relatively unknown.

  • @BigBlyeEyes1234 MC's nodules caused by prolonged abuse in a strenuous performing schedule, BUT there is no such thing as 'strenuous singing'. Once you are trained properly, you can sing for a long periods WITHOUT damaging your voice. Sometimes I wonder if you people are aware that MC is just one of HUNDREDS of singers around. Why haven't Nancy, Barbra, Patti, etc developed nodules despite their MANY years of live singing? I am dispassionate about MC and simply refuse to make excuses for her.

  • @Kumtekmeon It IS possible to develop nodes from strenuous use. Even if you sing with an impreccible technique, overdoing it can still cause damage. By the time Mariah got her record deal, she already had vocal nodules but had such a perfect technique that it didn't interfere with her singing. Unfortunely, due to her busy schedule and 'partying', her voice began to deteriote. Age also made it more delicate.

    Mariah's voice is one of a kind. It's excellence is unparralled.

  • @Kumtekmeon Mariah has had her nodules since she was a little girl. Believe it or not, there are some people who develop vocal nodules without doing much singing.

    Besides, Nancy, Barbra and Patti don't have careers like Mariah. Not to mention, Mariah's songs are a lot harder to sing than Nancy's, Barbra's or Patti's.

    Don't believe me: sing H.A.T.E.U. for yourself.

  • @BlackLightning20101 Yes, I am well aware that MC had her nodules from childhood - She TESTIFIED as to how she came by them when she related in an interview how she would purposely talk in a HIGH-Whispery voice in order to go as high as Minnie Riperton - I always ask persons to try talking in a high whispery voice so they can feel the STRAIN that is put on the cords - TRY IT!

    Please DO NOT insult real talent, because Patti, BARBRA and Nancy's career FAR outdo MC's Pop Stardom. Learn that!

  • @Kumtekmeon First of all, to say that Mariah Carey is not talented is utter foolishness. Second, Patti, Barbra and Nancy have never had a work ethic like Mariah. I'm not saying that they are lazy but 8 studio albums in 10 years is absolutely incredible. Plus, Mariah writes and produces her own music. Third, she testified that sometimes she would wake up and either not be able to talk or she'd talk in a high whispery voice.

    This doesn't change the fact that Mariah's music IS harder to sing.

  • @BlackLightning20101 In comparison to Barbra, Nancy and Patti - MC is average. What is MC's work ethic? To stay in the studio and record songs, do some promotional appearances and then go on a few months tour along with few social engagements and then back in the studio? Do you think when these ladies release 2,3 albums in ONE year, they simply go home and knit a sweater? There is NOTHING hard about MC music other than that she's a POOR singer! She can't talk is the effect of a damaged voice!

  • @Kumtekmeon Alright. You apparently can't be reasoned with at all. You're just so stuck in your ways that you have become blind to truth and it's hard to have intelligent discussions with you. I'm sorry you've gotten this way but ignorance is not cute. Especially at your age.

    Take care of yourself.

  • @BlackLightning20101 The truth? You are the one who is STUCK in a web of mythologies to the point you dare to assert MC is the ONLY one who sings: No one else performs, and that is why MC is the ONLY one who suffers a vocal decline; are you serious? You come on a video pointing out that MC is STRUGGLING to sing a song she claims to write and all you lots can say is that her songs are difficult! Has the entire Camp Lamb gone CRAZY? The FACT is MC has abused her cords and this is the result.

  • @Kumtekmeon Check your inbox for my reply. It's too big to fit on this comment section.

    But the gist of it was me apologizing.

  • @BlackLightning20101 I do not see any inbox message, but in that case I accept your apology.

  • @Kumtekmeon Shanice's singing WASN'T supported at all. It was all in her throat, the appoggio was nowhere to be found. She sounded anything but free. And that whistle sucked. There was incredible tension.

    Intonation-wise, she was very unfocused, so sloppy. A hot mess.

    The variation in dynamics in her singing is pretty much non-existent. It's always the same amateurish, tasteless, prolonged screaming.

  • @Stefano94x You are obviously on a Hate Campaign. Say what you want to say, IN THE END, MC is a terrible singer with the SIGNS to show for it - This horrendous performance is just a drop in the bucket of her ocean of Vocal Abuse. As for Shanice she will ALWAYS be the one with the Healthy and Beautiful tone - Not that UGLY Raspy tone that MC has. I am so amused by your rants - Say what you will, MC, and all other favorites of yours will still be BELOW average in comparison to the GREAT Shanice!

  • @Kumtekmeon In the end, you're wrong and you'll always be wrong.

    There's nothing such as a 'healthy tone'. It's the TONE PRODUCTION which can be healthy or unhealthy, not your tone itself. Fail. And Mariah didn't abuse her voice. She overused it. Double fail.

    Shanice is 'great'? No, she isn't. She is an average, forgettable karaoke singer like any other. Not only that, she's not even musically brilliant or technically proficient. She flops on every aspect.

    Stay dismissed.

  • @Kumtekmeon In the end, you're wrong and you'll always be wrong.

    There's nothing such as a 'healthy tone'. It's the TONE PRODUCTION which can be healthy or unhealthy, not your tone itself. Fail. And Mariah didn't abuse her voice. She overused it. Double fail.

    Shanice is 'great'? No, she isn't. She is an average, forgettable karaoke singer like any other. Not only that, she's not even musically brilliant or technically proficient. She flops on every aspect.

    Stay dismissed.

  • @Kumtekmeon In the end, you're wrong and you'll always be wrong.

    There's nothing such as a 'healthy tone'. It's the TONE PRODUCTION which can be healthy or unhealthy, not your tone itself. Fail. And Mariah didn't abuse her voice. She overused it. Double fail.

    Shanice is 'great'? No, she isn't. She is an average, forgettable karaoke singer like any other. Not only that, she's not even musically brilliant or technically proficient. She flops on every aspect.

    Stay dismissed.

  • @Stefano94x Do not exalt your stupidity! If the production of the tone is unhealthy then the FINAL output will also be unhealthy: as in the case of MC! How do you know someone's production is unhealthy? Mainly by LISTENING, and when what you hear is CHOKED UP and wheezy and breathy then the final conclusion (in short) is that their tone is UNHEALTHY! So please do not try to get technical with me - Communication is about understanding and I am certain you clearly understood MC is vocally wasted.

  • @Kumtekmeon Bitch, my knowledge over vocal technique is light years above yours. You've never been able to explain what projection, resonance, appoggio, mixing technique and passaggio are. You can't count the right semitones (since you claim Shanice has 5 octaves - she doesn't, just to be clear -) You just refuse to recognize your fav's immense incompetence, and you can't stand that she is easy to surpass vocally.

    Now begone.

  • @Stefano94x Your reasoning is definitely light years above mind; seemingly when the world is taken over by savage aliens. So why not adjust yourself to this Present time and stop acting like a JERK? Here you go again flipping into your theoretic mode - I have NO TIME to school you on Resonance and such information is of NO use here, especially NOT on this video in which MC FAILS to resonate any sign of vocal strength. Come, let us pray for a miracle - Earmuffs, because this is horrendous!

  • @Kumtekmeon Wow you are so pressed and delusional.. You mad SHITnice has lowered herself so much to making YOUTUBE covers to get any recognition? You upset she's a flopped ONE hit wonder bitch from the 90's? Or what about the fact that she raises her larynx and has one of the most ANNOYING voices ever.. Just look at some of her flopped YT covers.. all the dislikes. No one likes the bitch.. NO ONE in the industry has recognized her at all, for her voice or music. Stay mad, you're idol is a JOKE.

  • @MimiDahhling30 Excuse YOU?! I am overjoyed every time Shanice does a You Tube cover - Because it takes SKILLS for a professional singer, in a time when singers CAN'T do without auto tune and Lipsynching, to STAND in bare and DELIVER a song in First Class Style! I'll take Shanice covers ANY DAY over MC's monstrosity! Great singing goes BEYOND hits, how many hits Ella Fitzgerald, Minnie Riperton, Sarah Vaughn etc had? MC is a Pop singer and Popularity supersedes Talent! MC reflects Britney!

  • @Kumtekmeon The only thing FLOPnice's crappy YouTube covers prove is how annoying her voice is, how desperate she is for some attention and how stupid she can make herself look screaming "ALE- ALE - ALE - JANDRO" into the camera. SHITnice raises her larynx and she over-sings. Also.. "Ella Fitzgerald, Minnie Riperton, Sarah Vaughn" Funny you would mention these three because they've ALL received credible praise and recognition for their vocals, music and contribution. Has FAILnice? No, Oops.

  • @MimiDahhling30 Please CONTROL your jealousy! Shanice career is in GREAT standing and she continues to strive! What you need to take note of is that MC CANNOT stand and deliver like Shanice, because she DOESN'T have a voice to do so! May I ask WHAT are the results of a RAISED Larynx? Do you care to answer - Because it is rather CHILDISH and DISHONEST for your brats to accuse Someone of something WHEN there is NO proof to back it up - MC is the one who ABUSED the FALSE CORD and this vid is PROOF!

  • @MimiDahhling30 i don't think they're really liking shanice... they are xtinca fans... and is she even a 1 hit wonder? ive never heard an original song of her, only covers... (and only like 3 xD)

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more