Added: 3 years ago
From: 911investigator
Views: 17,883
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (173)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I think the reason they keep taking it down is because it's a copywritten video. Look up Zeitgeist. This exact video is shown.

  • pretty interesting video. the only thing is the bible never emphasizes or even mentions dec 25th. so you believe in God just not jesus?

  • anyone know where the second part of this video can be found?

  • This video makes more sense than the Bible.. God, a man that no one has ever seen, impregnated a virgin who was most likely only 14, who then traveled almost a hundred miles to give birth to the son of god who had disciples that ate of his FLESH and drank his BLOOD..also. He died and came back to life, lived for 40 days and ascended to heaven. So his followers were cannibals. He was a zombie. And now he's in heaven with his father who is him. Yay Bible.

  • For the most part this video is accurate, as any student of comparative mythology will tell you. Some of the minor details are wrong or are theoretical and not proven. But the underlying message, that many pre-Christian myths had all basically the same concepts of birth, virgin mortal mother impregnated by a god, death/sacrifice and resurrection is correct. The Jesus myth is a rewrite, plain and simple. The Christian version of the Sun of God.

  • Well interesting, but Where is the information really coming from?? and I personally dont think it should be banned even though I am a to the core believer in God cause it is not my place or anyone elses place to judge this person, so do whatever you want buddy, keep things like this coming... Thiswill weed out the real christians from the wanna bes.. God Bless you

  • Great video. Any one who doesn't like it should just find something they do like.

  • God said " put no Gods before him " even Jesus , So as long as you put God first we are all right .

  • @jrashley83 What?

  • @jrashley83 Jesus was God..hence 3 persons in one. You can't say you put God first when God is Jesus and vice versa.

  • The video was interesting, up until 4:18.

    That's when I gave a DISLIKE, got up and left, because it is simple:

    This video is lying. In fact, in the beginning, it asks the viewer that before he flags the video, he should do a little research to make sure the facts are right.

    Well, I did, and this first fact, is wrong.

    Horizon = Horus is risen? WTF LMAO yeah, like the enaicnt Egyptian spoke english .

    Horizon comes from the Latin horizontem, meaning limit.

    Hours = Lat. Oros = boundary

  • Real video starts at 1:55 just fast-forward through the intro (it isn't part of the original video)

  • ...huh? That wasn't very convincing

  • My favorite argument against all religions is one simple word... Evolution. :)

  • @koolmexican Uhh, hmm, evolution is compatible with God. No arguments can disprove God's existence..

  • Comment removed

  • actually jesus christ was born may 14th

  • so whats the deal with bullying christians and making them look like they are fools - WHY DONT YOU GO PICK ON A MUSLIM OR A JEW FOR A CHANGE ?? Try that and see how long it takes to get you beat-up pretty bad by the followers. These people who pick on Christianity are the same ones who were bullies in school and they cant do it now because they are grown-up (using the term loosely) and they need a relaease and purpose so they feel they've done something with their lives.

  • Comment removed

  • Although based in pure hate and intolerance for others opinions, I do think this video should be banned since it does NO good for anyone - what is the problem with religion ?? (They dont kill, maim, or hurt anyone), but the Christians are the target of every nutball who thinks they have been enlightened and need to spread the word that there is no god (Because they are right and everybody else is wrong) Seems I remember being taught that mentally unstable people think everybody else is crazy -

  • actually wrong, the truth is that the oldest religion on earth is the Jewish religion, and now honestly, i have only been saved a short while but God has had an amazing impact on my life, now, i agree, you are entitled to your opinion, as is everyone, but you dont actually have more evidence, true evidence is scene by how peoples lives are changed, there is no way that a non-existent being could have such an effect on peoples lives, not to mention that God does talk to his followers

  • @ParamoreFanFromOz

    Judaism maybe the longest standing religion, but there are older Gnostic faiths (Greek Mythology, early Mesopotamian Culture) however many of them have been weeded out. With the introduction of the Abraham's God (which reflects many astrology and cultural ploys from older faiths) the idea of a purgatory or hell came into thought. This was the selling point of the faith, forcing nonbelievers into blame unless they convert. That's what your faith has done, bullied nonbelievers.

  • This is not pseudo research, it just happens to be an inconvenient correlation that proves Jesus' existence was a plagiarist movement. He wasn't real. Eat shit God!

  • This very video lead me to my disbelief :) Thank God!! (so to speak)

  • To be honest, that was quite entertaining! Especially the Horus vs Set scene lol. They should have used Brian as an example (Monty Python - Life Of Brian)

    No offence meant :D

  • 1:55 really? I always thought that was the moon...

  • Well, after a quick 30 second search on wikipedia, neither Krishna nor Horus have anything of crucifiction, virgin birth on 25th december or resurrection.

  • @alekojlime wikipedia has no credit as a research site since it can be edited by anyone.

  • @prettehface Well, I'm not writing for a science journal. It's a fucking youtube comment.

  • @alekojlime Nice one! :D

  • @alekojlime, well. You are a dick as anyone can edit the information on Wikipedia and change anything on there if they want. Use a reliable source, not Wikipedia.

  • Comment removed

  • SO everything in this video is true? All the statistics i mean?

  • 8:40 not anymore we shifted m orion is in the south way before sunrise

  • Actually this video is a lie. There are 13 constellations and it was shaved down to twelve to make it all fit in a neat little bundle. That being said your argument for anything is void from a logical standpoint because your main tenant from which you base your initial argument on is false.

    Try this:

    Ophiuchus is a large constellation located around the celestial equator. Its name is Greek (Ὀφιοῦχος) for 'serpent-bearer'

    I can go through point by point and destroy your psuedo research.

  • @heatmiser66 Just to you know there are 88 constellations... 48 discovered by Ptolemy alone

    so don't know where you were going with this

  • Crucifixion was utilized from 6th century BC, to 4th century AD. Horus got CRUCIFIED in 3000 BC? Try again.

  • @guitarist347 Nice wikipedia research.. learn to read Crucifixion was in use PARTICULARLY among the Seleucids, Carthaginians, and Romans from about the 6th century .... its not saying tht it was NEVER used before...

  • @willbaboon I went to school, and that's what they taught me.

  • Ok, there are a ton of good points in this video, but most of the information about the god's is incorrect. The story of Horus I know is completely false. Also, even light cursory research would show that Jesus was not born on December 25th as the video states. There are no historical records indicating when Jesus was born, Christmas is a Pagan holiday, as is Easter.

    While I as an atheist do not want this video taken down because I disagree with it, I wish it removed for false information.

  • @tommyss4l I too am atheist but I read into that a little differently. I know that there are theories of Jesus' birth being closer to Spring but I think he is discussing the December 25th birth to point to the fact that people have really just been repeating the same stories for centuries and beyond. Regardless of when he was born, the pagan holidays stood and the names of the gods simply changed.

  • you tell it like it is!!

  • i just wikipedia'D the crux constellation. i dont think the sun is in this constellation

  • this video would be great if it were true; but after looking in to it; it appears to be a load of codswallop.

  • @FoxyFAsh

    lol codswallop

  • it is true that Horus was born to Isis. But where did the trailing name of “Mary” that used in the movie come from? No mention in any Egyptian literature links the name Isis to the name Mary. Isis was also not a virgin. No account of Horus’ birth makes this statement. Isis was not a virgin, but the widow of Osiris, who conceived Horus with Isis. Finally, Horus was supposedly born during the month of Khoiak (Oct/Nov), and not on December 25.

  • @FoxyFAsh One theory is that she was impregnated by divine fire. Virgin or not it was a sexless conception according to this version and though I believe neither, the similarity to the immacculate conception story exists.

  • The only ideas i agree with are the worship of the sun in all cultures and that some ancient religions have erie similarities to those of modern times. Everything else is either slanted or just outright wrong. (Im 19 and i see this). Religion is an excellent form of self governance, so dont get me wrong, but why sway people to rid themselves of something within their control? It just seems wrong, but my thinking could be skewed. Gotta give him this, though: He's got opinions. Good 4 him!!

  • Comment removed

  • To present more information that would back the perspective. SO... this video should not be seen as legitimate information, but it does prove several good points. There are erie similarities between the religions of the past and those of modern times. I just turned nineteen and I can admit this. The astrology is also accurate, but only to an extent. This should not sway people in one direction or another, though I hope that it influences people to do some reseach on the subject.

  • Most of this is true, religion is all a big hoax (who doesn't accept that, even subconsciously?), except for things like "Sunset" coming from Set, as in the Egyptian deity, that's obviously to a learned English speaker, a load of shit.

  • Even most atheists would agree that this video is bull-shit. How stupid do you think mankind is? You really think that we made up the same story that many times? Please check the reliabillity of your records before you post something like this on YouTube. Dionysus was born out of Zeus's thigh, Krishna was born in July and that facts about Mithra come from a fictional book called The Da Vinci Code, not historical documentation. You people need to get off YouTube and read some books.

  • @mrostos hellllyaaaaa YOU TELL EMMMM lol

  • Woooohhoooooo fuck religious people

  • This video is fucking amazing, what a very clever man, if I knew him I'd shake his hand, all religions are full of shit, and just for the record , I hate Muslims , Jews and all other bollocks. Big up to all the athiasts in the world!!!!!!! Wooooohooooo watch it an cry you religious f@cks

  • I've always thought all faiths Islam especially is all full of shit. This video though makes more sense. (although I would have to do more reseearch!)

  • why complain about this video and think its bullshit? its more beleaveable than any religous stories iv heard. this doesnt disprove religion it just proves that religous figures are all copy cats and if people have the right to do it then and why cant people do it now? use your fuckin brain. idiots... and remember if theres no proof in the pudding, then dont eat it.

  • change the minds of christians all over the world because you have the same birthdays of poeple throughout history, including other "gods" that you shouldnt believe in anyway if your athiest. im not saying believe what i believe because everyone has the right to an opinion, but what did you achieve in doing this? if you were so right in your argument, why wouldnt you be famous for "uncovering religion" or something of huge scale? exactly your not.

  • just because things are not explained the way you would like them to be doesnt mean you have the knowledge to CREATE a story yourself proclaiming to know what we who believe in religion to be only of gods knowledge. this is just a stab at Christianity from a person who has nothing in life. what did you think you were going to do by creating this video?

  • what does leo mean? lions roamed the earth during that time of the year? what about cancer? crabs would rise from the ocean? wow these people all have things in common, not unlike 6 billion others in this world, the difference is jesus was able to do ALL the things, not some. also the point of religion is to NOT know why, otherwise we would all be god-like, reasons for these things are to be known by god and god only, building in the term "faith" , "hope" etc. ..........

  • Why do Atheists always have to be liberals? They deny divine intervention (rightfully so), yet believe in government intervention, as if it would solve the problems that would be solved if there was a God? Logically, an Atheist would be politically right winged (Not Republican, Libertarian), and any Libertarian or Right Wing should be an Atheist. On what point in history did Atheists and Libertarians decide to slip up?

  • i believe in god and all that ...but tbh denomination like catholic vs prodesant ...is well...shit...if u choose not to belive all good but dont try to take ppls faith...and if u do belive ...belive what you think is right not what some guy in a pointy hat says

  • this video is deleted because YT know this is the truth and they dont wanna be punished by the true ruler of the world, the Pope

  • you all should just let people believe what the fuck they want cause id rather believe in a god then think oh great when i die its over i will never think eat sleep love laugh or cry ever again you fags

  • How could Krishna be born of a virgin if Devaki had seven sons before him?

  • i love it

  • they keep taking it down because you blatantly ripped off zeitgeist which is total garbage. look into horus yourself before you go posting misinformation. just as many people do- you can take things out of context and make them support any theory- no matter how unintelligent and misleading. for Christians even remotely believing this- this world belongs to satan. he will mock God and try to mislead and deceive us any way he can. i think the antichrist is a perfect example. peace!

  • @crushthenwo yeah just like the Bible

  • @bdynamyte win lol

  • @crushthenwo what makes you think that the Bible isn't a book written by Satan to mislead you. why can't Christians look at the Bible as a metaphorical book that teaches you how to live instead of it being historical text.

  • My wife is a US History/Latin/English teacher. She talks about this in her history classes fairly regularly(specifically asking who performed miracles, had 12 desciples, raised from dead 3 days after being crucified-when the kids answer 'Jesus', she says 'Yes, and Horus, as well as others, et cetera'). We live in East Tennessee. And because of that, among other things, She's been at 4 different hich schools in the last 4 years. I wish people read more.

  • i am a christian, (well Roman Catholic) and i really liked this video. i think that it is good to have your faith challenged because it is one thing to just believe in something but if you can defend it against an argument then you must feel passionatly about it. the facts could be right though :) thats would be funny if after all these years of worship everything was miss interpretted. lol i dont think it should be banned, it is educational and everyone should know what they are worshiping

  • @chanel2711 I wished there were more christians like you.

  • @chanel2711 i wish every riligious person was like you

  • @ubberJakerz THANKS :)

  • @chanel2711 well atleast you dont freak out. you use logic instead of blind faith. that earns alot of respect with me. you can think for yourself, and more people should try doing just that

  • The only real and true fact is that no one has ever seen or heard God. Thus proof of God's being real or not is truly a matter of faith. Any fact or group of facts really are just a grouping faith. If you believe you can and will find "facts" to prove your believes. No one person will ever know how right or wrong they are until their deaths. At that point it will be to late, except for that one person. If you have faith in something hold on to it. teach others but never push your faith!

  • @chazz7667 yes but by your reasoning,it is perfectly normal and ok for me to believe that there is a pink alligator with wings that can fly.and since you cant really prove theres not,then there must be a real chance that there is one.you just need faith right?

    The only proof i need that there is NO god is common sense.

    may your days be good.peace.

  • I love this video.

  • @mrcloudiesbestfriend tooo right, makes me feel so smug :)

  • Reguardless of a mistake here & there, the concept as a whole still stands up.

    Im not trying to judge the Bible ofcourse or any other holy book. I actually believe for the most part they all have the best intentions @ heart. To me though, the problem comes when each tries to proclaim its the one and only. This causes division & wars. If we could all unite under some basic truths (like the sun and stars...real things), wouldent we all get along A WHOLE LOT BETTER? Just a thought : )

  • this video made me agnostic, and a bit happier and able to enjoy life more.

  • well..i didn't really belived in Jesus..but now im totally confused... i do belive in Jesus someway. but i do belive that he's not the only one who lived the way we all know it... i think this is an innocent video and the facts are true

  • For example I looked up one of those "saviours" on the list- Beddru of Japan? From what I gather, perhaps a poor mashup of Buddha? It's bogus either way

  • some of the claims in this are baseless and wrong, but it's thought provoking nonetheless

  • the virgin birth represents purity

    the sun and the 12 months

    the lord and twelve disiples

    it's all goddanm sun worship

  • Horus isnt a sun god hes god of the sky. Set was the god of the desert and they battled once after Set killed their father. Horus' mother was named Isis, not "Isis Mary" and he wasnt birthed but resurrected from his father's corpse. Krishna was born around july 19 and is Devaki's 8th son shes definitely not a virgin. He wasnt crucified he died from a stray hunting arrow. Dionysus mother was human but not a virgan the list goes on... go do your own research

  • Jesus is considered Lord, he is not God, God is a jealous God, a man is not God. That's like saying You are your father, you're not, you're the Son of your father. Common Sense

  • and what kind of god is jelous? you'd think that some high and mighty person could get over a petty emotion such as jelousy. humans get over jelousy so why would god be jelous? LOL

  • so everybody else in the world is wrong? so the majority of all people are goign to hell? some god you worship

  • this is a good video..why would it be removed?

  • wooooow lookin at dis video makes not even wanna believe in da dude i wud like to see is dis can be disproved

  • this is bullshit....

  • krishna was born jula 21...

  • yeah he was. according to wiki. wtf

  • They're afraid of facts. Anything that would disprove their 'glorious' existence cannot possibly be true.

  • Keep on believing in a 'god' that allows your priests to molest your kids. Weak minded fools.

  • hahaha. it's a funny coincidence that when i tried to open this video my browser crashed

  • It's funny to see how many christians call this bullshit...I'm not going to give a long speech of why The bible is not possible, but for christians of all people to call something religious bullshit....haha...

  • boooooring, even giivideo has a better voice then this -.-

  • Read JESUS THE MAN by Dr Barbera Thiering and then lets hear what you have to say about Christianity!

  • It's good to be open-minded for sure. I beleive that no "belief" is wrong. Everyone is just at different levels. Your presentation is awesome! But I think you could've made your presentation just as great, and gotten your point across without chastising anyone else's beliefs. Yes, I've favourited this before as well and it was removed from youtube again. Again I have favourited it. =) Well done!

  • I did infact flag this video. And the reason for this is not to deprive someone of freedom of speech. I am a strong believer of freedom of speech. However, this video states that many other characters in history have had similar qualities as Jesus Christ. But have any of you dedided to research the outrageous claims made in this video. I did, and i found out that much of what is told in this video is completly untrue and has no evidence or proof to back up the the statements made in this video.

  • Please state your references on the disproved claims or dont post it false. POST your results or STFU and go back to church.

  • well i'm going to go watch heaps of videos attempting to prove gods existance and if they don't have proof to back it up i'm going to flag them on every single one of my accounts how do you like that?

  • you say this video has no proof to back up its claim well neither does christianity

  • Funny i just saw a promo about Dr Jekyll & Mr Hyde on Turner Classic Movies, and the voice on this video voice over sounds just like the voice of the special effects guy talking about the evolution of makeup / cosmetics used to make the transformation of Dr Jekyll into Mr Hyde. I wonder if it is the same?

  • BullShiaaaaaaaaaaaat:)

  • youtube nazis?

  • YOUTUBE pulled this video from my favorites. Why even take the time to favor a video if there just going to delete it from my list. Fucking fed up!

  • If they ban this video then they may aswell Ban FREDOM OF SPEACH along with it. Everyone has a right to be heard. Simply if you don't like the video don't search for the content in the first place.

  • This is a great video. There aren't any reson to be banned.

  • why the hell should this video be banned? If there are videos on youtube about racism and shit why would take this off?

  • cause some religious prick may get offeneded because they are wrong

  • that is true!

  • Comment removed

  • Here is the truth about horus

  • if you think you have more evidence then read lee strobels a case for christ it has as much if not more evidence then you

  • very interesting video. for those of you saying that the information in this video is incorrect how about actually saying why. im inparcaul here so im not gonna take the time to resource how lugit this is but i just have to say. rather then saying this is a lie or wrong how about proving how it is?

  • I could write you a whole book on why.,but i cant because this is just a comment box( I would love to though :)). This is an example: How could all the "gods or enlighten ones" be born on December 25 if each country and culture ( before the renaissance) had their own different month calendars? (December is a roman month) i know this is an obvious answer, but if you want historical fact you can contact me

    p.s.

    I'm a major on Eurasian history.

  • Also, I would appreciate if some one with the couriosity of knowing the truth would write me back, not a pissed of person that believes everything to his or her convinience and has fear of finding out the real truth

  • H.L. Mencken wrote Treatise on The Gods....enlightening reading. Interestingly it is very difficult to get a copy to read......ever read it? If not, check it out, Mencken did an exceptional job.

  • thanks! any more suggestions? A book that compares the ties of many religions?

  • Cant think of any with that scope but i believe there's one that covers all the 'flood' stories across religions. Mencken gives broad coverage to anthropology and known scientific discoveries up to his day. I believe there is a site that talks about the twin tools of politics and religion in keeping masses sheeple. Good luck

  • Well then you must be the only man alive that does know the truth?

  • Even though they may have different month titles; it doesn't mean the time that the stars reach these locations isn't the same; no?

  • u are telling a lie man... and christianity is not a religion xD

  • u again? the problem is u say lies and give wrong information at least as far as I m concerned as Egyptian and Muslim what u say about Egyptology and Mohammad is WRONG

  • omg this is so fucking awesome !!! xD this really burns all the religious ppl :D hahaha....

  • Most of the information in this video is actually wrong. I can personally vouch for the etymologies of Horus, Horizon, Sunset etc. as being total nonsense. Same goes for a lot of what's said about the deities he lists as being similar to Jesus. For an instance, neither Dionysos nor Attis were supposed to have been crucified. I couldn't possibly list all the mistakes I spotted, and I daresay people who are experts on fields other than mine could spot many, many more.

  • actually all of this is wrong information, i know because i majored in eurasian history!!

  • When ppl see this they should say "religion is bullshit" but they wont cause there idiots

  • Actually you are wrong you fucking piece of abortion! You have majored on sucking dicks, nothing more!

  • And who are you to tell me what i have majored in?? You are probably just an atheist burger flipper who is struggling to get your GED

  • @ParamoreFanFromOz we cant prove anything, so therefore u should expect anything. we're always finding new things

  • @037342 this stuff is all true, do your research, open your eyes, dont follow blindly, i never follow anything without evidence, i am australian and have caused problems with other aussies with my opinions of anzac day, you gotta learn to think for yourself, if you open your eyes you will see that there is more evidence to suggest that this is correct and that religion is not true

  • @ParamoreFanFromOz its they're, not there. who is the idiot?

  • @fingersmcoy considering i am dyslexic, i have a excuse to accidentally use the wrong grammar, and it dont take away from my point

  • @ParamoreFanFromOz your dyslexia causes you to call people idiots? no, i think that is from your arrogant heart. your an ass, dyslexic or not.

  • @fingersmcoy no you fuck tard my dyslexia can cause me not to use the correct spelling or grammar, fuck you are fucking ignorant, so if you gonna point your fucking finger, point it at something reflective, cause theres only one cunt on this planet who requires your finger pointed at em

  • @ParamoreFanFromOz and my point is proven. thank you

  • @fingersmcoy how fuck tard? come how? if you think having a go at someones perceptual disability proves your point you are fucking wrong fuck tard

  • shit man proves everything was interpitated wrong

  • Re faved and re 5star'd haha, I hate religeous people who cant take others opinions.

  • Very interesting video, why would it be removed? Because Christian fags are ashamed about the truth and don't want it to be revealed.

  • Though.. uhm.. Jesus wasn't sopose to have been born on December 25th. It was some time in the summer/spring. Making me doubt many things said in this anyway.

  • this video gets banned everytime its uploaded for some strange reason, people are so stupid that they flag it because of its religious discussion. This video should not be banned, if you dont like it, dont f***ing watch it!

  • man ppl need to lay off there actual ppl that want to WATCH this.Quit flagging it religious if you cant handle it.

  • Wat the hell did this one get banned again and reuploaded?

  • i think it did, because i had it favourited, and i pressed it and it said it was private, so i typed in the name and this came up

  • the word "banned" should be banned...

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more