Hope - hurt

[rlara720]

wow i love simon n he's usually always right but..no if its a group then everyone shld have their part not jst ooh n ahhs n jst her singing the whole song Fts..n she did a horrible job lol xtina wldnt be as proud as u may think..jst sayn

[steph060992]

she is flat like crazy. geeez

[kleinnen]

What's the comment coming from the audience?

[setaloka]

They can't sing 'Hurt'

[pbuk]

One singer(Phoebe)and 4 rubbish others.That Phoebe should go solo as she could be a big star if she does.

[The551922]

Check out her new group Girls Cant Catch. They're fab. The judges admitted they made a mistake and should have put Phoebe forward as a soloist.

[okenough123]

hope they are best singer wall done

[irismey]

Wow that song made me cry, but now I understand the lyrics because Phoebe sung it. They shouldn't given her that song, but they all did well on it.

[CookieLuver1000]

is it me or are louie and simon ALWAYS fighting now???????????

[fffeeemmm]

she did alright considering it was a christina song...but i think they could of picked an easier song for her.. no one could sing christina songs except christina herself..

[rikkiwonka75]

@fffeeemmm

Nobody sucks a big black cock like Christina either.

[fffeeemmm]

that woman is with the same person for the past 8 years.. so i dont think christina is actually a slut when theres other bitches out there..

[PushTenBaby1994]

phoebz is amazingg !!!!! wow. she looks so young here tho ! GCC are awsome ! x

[emilyandmileylover38]

i do love phoebe!!!!!!!!!!!!!

<3 <3 <3 <3 <3

[okenough123]

hope they are good singers

[hawk670]

phoebe is AMAZING

[strikerdes04956]

i think she did well considering this is a christina song, but they shouldnt have given her this, not even melody thornton could sing this the best, phoebe just wasnt strong enough

[kallumsmart1]

she so was i think she did brill

[AtYourSide]

Phoebe really should go solo, a good voice plus she was much more well liked and received by fans who liked Phebe but not the group.

[owenxowen]

She is in a new band called Girls can't catch. They will support girls aloud on tour and have a new single called Keeping Me up?? I think thats the name!

[AtYourSide]

Thanks for that, glad she's moving on. Seems like the Saturdays have paved the way for new girl groups.

[stargirl732]

girls can't catch supported girls aloud on tour n they're its called keep your head up :) its not out yet tho its out in august they've put bk the release date cos it was originally supposed to be released on the27th july xx

[james3515]

@owenxowen its called keep your head up. and they have another song called echo

[that1shizz1is1wack]

eww thats kinda disgusting seeing as i kinda know her

[hawk670]

kool how do u know her

[hawk670]

amazing phoebe did amazing. i love her

[glassflute]

WHO ARE THESE PEOPLE? iVE NEVER SEEN THEM BEFORE, AND WHY DO THEY KEEP SINGING ON THIS SHOW 'X FACTOR?' THEY ARENT THAT GREAT

[suekezgre]

My god!! she is my ideal woman.Where can i find her?.

[KinTOUCHme]

wile emotional.. loved it! hope are unb..

type official hope in google, first one that come up, great fansite.. go go goooo!

now..

[arran2222]

god she is sooooo sexy!!!!

[LanaJayne1]

phoebe should've got through as a solo artist she had definately the best voice outta all of them

[rikkiwonka75]

Phoebe will be a very good karaoke singer who pubs will hire and pay her well. But she's no Leona Lewis or Alexandra Birke. Not in a million years.

[krissykins]

Well doesn't louis think it's unfair that he lets that little elf from JLS take the lead every single performance.

[drfere]

After watching this it just confirms Louis is a twat. Such a hypocrite.

[joemcerlane]

rofl

[rikkiwonka75]

I reckon Simon Cowell interfeared with at least two of them. If I was Simon: I would have had them in a chic hotel room snorting cocaine and sucking my pulsating helmet.

[philbrown999]

For a 33 year old, you really are quite a sad pathetic human being.

[rikkiwonka75]

Actually mate, I'm a rather happy chap. I'm quite the opposite from sad but I can certainly be pathetic - you got me there! ha-ha!

[BGrade15]

You've got issues, seriously.

What kind of a sick bastard leaves a comment like that? You're a sad, pathetic shell of a person. These girls are at least 12 years younger than you...Phoebe is fucking 16!

You should be ashamed of yourself.

[rikkiwonka75]

That's what makes it so horny. Look mate: you can't choose who you are sexually attracted to, and I like young women. I'm not ashamed at all - I would cum right up Phoebe, I really would.

[rikkiwonka75]

I just cum

[rikkiwonka75]

These girls really make me cum. I can't stop jerking off over them.

[podsable]

shut up pervy07 you havent got a clue wot ur on about

[xxashleytisdalerox]

totally

[xxxjessrules01xxx]

it wos kl!

[kirbs1995]

listen at 1:25 phoebe stinks she was rubbish

[pervy07]

watched this to compare them to the bands this year and have to say hope had v.bad singer! they have not got any1 with a good voice, even pheobe, shes ok but the cheats when she sings the big notes, she breaks up the words too much so that she doesnt have to sing fluently cuz she knows that shed probably start squeeking! and they were sooo unbelievably stuck up they deservd to go!!!

[nfm56]

OOHH-what an expert on vocal technique you are!! How can singing LIVE in front of 10 milion people be classed as 'cheating'!

[pervy07]

you cant use that as an excuse, if they cant handle singing live they that just proves they are in the wrong industry. they were never good singer, the judges just threw them together as an experiment and it didnt work boohoo.

[nfm56]

Chill love!!!! I'm only looking out for my daughter with the amazing voice!!!! Lots of us are allowed to disagree with you!!!!

[philbrown999]

By the way Phoebe had the mother of colds and a bad sore throat the week she sang 'Hurt'. X factor didn't publicise that. She just got on with it like a true professional. I know I am biased but I think she did amazingly well considering.

[AlseGoodridge]

I think she has a wonderful voice..this is a truly moving performance. I hope she will return to x factor as a solo artist, it would be fantastic to see her performing again.

[ranjitbhandal88]

Phoebe was amazin in every performance!!!! She has a brilliant voice!!!!!

[whoknows2007]

SO GOOD - compare this to the standard of the groups this time round - this year they can't even sing in harmony half the time!

[Blissackerman1304]

No he says 'What about ronan keating in Boyzone?' referring to one person carrying the group which louis said Phoebe does.

As Louis managed Boyzone its a insult to Louis.

Much preferred Back to Black as I dont think Phoebes voice can carry the song

x

[nfm56]

It was Phoebe's dad who calledit out! Just loking out for his girl.....

[philbrown999]

I said the comment about boyzone. I am Phoebe's dad. It was not meant to be an insult to Louis but more about his hypocritical stance. How could he say this about Phoebe and Hope when Ronan carried boyzone for many years. Hope this helps.

[101safa]

OMG - Phoebe singing this gave me goosebumps! She's amazing!

xxx

[101safa]

what did the man in the audience shout at 3:30?

[Tishtash16]

what about boyzone??!!!

[101safa]

thanks!

[whoknows2007]

I think it was 'Stick to Boyzone' or something similar...

[xxxjessrules01xxx]

pkobe shud go and b solo da girls let her down

[DIVAKaiWilliams]

I really loved Hope. They had such passion and their lead singer was incredibly strong and emotional when she sung. Think this was my favourite performance they did and also Gimme gimme gimme as it had so much attitude!! Loved them. I really hope we see more of them soon.

[sallygibbo]

this is such a difficult song to sing but i think they pulled it off i cant wait for their single to come out :D i just hope its not exactly the same as all the other songs in the charts

[Cla900]

wow such a weak performance.

[xogreengiantox]

they should of done a song where each of the girls got a chance to sing a part on their own-- brill job though by pheobe

[Darlinngx]

phobe luks wwelll diffo.

[dannynrobbie]

For A 15 Year Old She Kicks Ass!

Xtina Would Be Proud

[jamieizdabest]

same difference shud ov won but this song waz absolutly amazin

[VanessaTheOne]

i don't think the chorus is good!...

[mrchazrad]

i remember phoebe sayin she had a cold this week haha she still pulled it off thou..nicely dun brown xxxx

[shandy41]

ha ha a welsh person can't spell wales. that's a supsrise.

[kyaisme]

A supsrise, eh?

[glamourousmakeup]

lmao

[liivvv]

who me? i spelt wales right thanks!

[shandy41]

of course you did. (waless) that's exactly right

[mrchazrad]

as far as I know hope wont be appearing on the x factor one year on show...they want to distance themselves from the x factor..and come out with their new song I Apologize (produced by Pharrell) and come out (in phoebes words) 'with a bang!'

[liivvv]

i wanted rhydian to wiin!!

wooooooo!

go waless :D

[hawk670]

wow phoebe great i love her so much

[alanbelfastwado]

God I love you pheobe

[Freerate]

Where are Hope by the way because they have not being heard of since the x'factor live tour. I guess they juct faded alway

[xA1Mzx]

Actually they have been offered a record deal, been on loads of tours and are realsin sum new songs!

So they haven't faded away

[holder1981]

remember we didnt hear about leona lewis for a hour year after the tour

[Freerate]

That was differnet because Leona lewis won

the £1 millien pound recond deal with simon cowell at Sony BMG in 2006. Hope were sign

to an music management that mean's simon

cannot manage than like Eton Road last year they won't be apparing on TV as far as i know like other acts such as 4tune & Philip macgee. So their you go.

[mrchazrad]

they havn't faded away, theyre currently touring with westlife and boyzone, recored 5 tracks, recored a song with none other than Pharrell Williams also (he produced it) theyve also been having meeting with 3 top record labels who are in there words 'blown away' by hope, theyre vocals etc - i should know being phoebes best mate - hope this answers your question

[Freerate]

They are going to appaer on x'factor one year

on & xtra factor one year on 9/8/08 on

itv1 & itv2. I do belive they are going to be talking about why they were in the botten 2

Three times.& what happen after thay appaer on

x'factor.

[XgreenjacketX]

You mean they're currently getting fucked by boyzone and westlife. The music industry is too too fast to remember a bunch of girls like this who prior to x-factor were tossing off 14 year old boys in they're local park

[BGrade15]

XgreenjacketX that's a very pesimistic attitude. Look at Girls Aloud, they've sold millions of records...what makes them so different to Hope? Hope are easily as good as any girl group in the charts.

[phoebebrownhopefan]

I agree! Infact i think they are better than any girl group in the charts, they just need a chance to prove it, which they will get soon!! Don't give up HOPE :D

[nfm56]

X greenjacketX-You've changed your tune. in the early days you were a hope fan. It's not nice to hear our daughters talked about in this way.

[xxlulusno1fan4evaxx]

i loved niki and this group xx

[flossybob]

im from sunderland and its sad to say that the ugly bad skinned freak charlie is as well christ shes a ugly fuckin slaggy cunt, her fanny is like a fuckin doorknob - every fuckers had a turn

[xA1Mzx]

Ur a fuckin prick

Dont be so horrible

shes stunnin!

[xLooxLoox]

What the fuck.. you fuckin prick!

[PrincessDirham]

To be honest last years contestants were crap, apart from Niki and her. She should of gone solo, yes i think that too. Leon only won because he had the whole of bloody northen ireland and scotland behind him. But wheres that Steven who won in 2005, Shane 2006, the only person who has got somewhere is Leona, Leon where's he? -- To be honest it should of been Pheobe who got through on her own, and they all made that msitake there, they cocked up and cocked up big time. And they know it!! xx

[teuzza]

you know what made leona a star? youtube! many of the people of this world were watching x factor on youtube, just like me. Shane and other before him had no youtube ;). This is the only reason leona is outside of uk. The show it is not televised in other countries, so...youtube make the contestants popular.

I so agree with you leon in my oppinion had nothing to win the xfactor, rhydian has better voice than leon does

[hotstuff4eva123]

i think rhydian should have won, leon was OK, but definately not better than him. rhydian had a rli rli powerful voice

[MzCarver]

Rhydian would have one but his performance with katherine jenkins lost it for him because she is so much better than he she over powered his voice so it made him look bad were as leon & kylies vocies suted soo...

[shaziscoollike]

she could've won if they let her go in solo.

but they put her with those untalented slags.

[flossybob]

pmsl u hit the nail on the fuckin head there!!

[SuperStarAbi]

i love hope, i just fink the others shud sing more, its a bit like the others are just phoebe's back up singers. but they r sooo great!

[Nephtis4]

i don't like AT ALL how the lead singer sings this song.

[Travelfun4ever]

heard better not that good sound flat yuk

[pergamanic]

phoebe should have left the group and went solo she would have made millions!! ( exxagerating) pheobe was a little out of tune ... ok so i meant a lot out of tune still love the act!!

[tew2007]

peerless

[katielainespicer2]

pheobe's hair looks much better like this without the blonde bit

[jamiehux1]

i like phoebe,brilliant,better off going solo

[ElitePortugal]

They work as a Group as the Pussycat Dolls Worked!

[minime111112]

poor phoboe she sung her heart out

[bbylove91192]

Christina is a better singer by far than phoebe.. but phoebe is a guud singer too but christina is excellent she sings with emotion in her voice she is too young too have as much emotion

[sangie1302]

it doesn't matter how young you are you could still have as much emotion as christina aguilera if you were 14

[nadineANDellys]

why has simon let his group do a SOLAR artist's song

So stupid

[fkfj16]

Lol its pronounced SOLO!

[kh9234]

she really cant sing this i hope christina doesnt see this she will say "what has that stupid girl done to my song"

[Lipshine96]

This song isn't stupid and presice you have a bad taste in music.This sounds way better then Christina's Song.

[Blueflower2007]

She didn't say the song was rubbish, she said she SANG the song rubbish. BTW its not a better version than X-Tina's .

LOL

[Lipshine96]

This sounds way better and She sings great as well.Christina can't sing!!!She has a pronouncing problem.

[mizzz08]

what you mean she has a pronouncing problem?

Phoebe doesn't have a strong voice so she can't sing the song very well.

[fkfj16]

She has a great voice and I think she did well... she made it hers.

[Lipshine96]

I ment Christina has a prounouncing Problem, Phoebe rocks!!!

[stroberimanisrasanya]

phoebe is sooooo cute!!!

[burhani52]

I love this song. It reminds me of when I use to listen to Mariah Carey at her peak.

[coolboy955]

Why was emily put through then? she was 14!!

Pheobe is old enough and she looks 19!!

and i love her voice! so much passion!

[coolboy955]

phoebe looks soooo like my sister in this!!

[ronturn49]

Phoebe wanted last on American

Idol no way she would even be able to compete with Kelly, Carrie or Jordin. Leona Lewis is ten times better

[xnoelfieldingsgirlx]

that is true carrie n kelly are both older nd more talented than phoebe

[Becca0102]

i met these guys the day before this :)

[coolboy955]

phoebe is so hot and she should of been on live shows as a single

[dudefromskye]

I agree but shes only 16, its probably better to do it with people to back you up than go it totally alone

[S3ANii]

Phoebe's hair looks so much better without the blond bit at the front.

[Blueflower2007]

I agree

[realreplikah]

Phoebe should have been picked as a single. She would have won teh xfactor.

SHE'S DEFINITELY BETTER THAN THAT TRASH LEON.

what was this rubbish about LEONA last year and LEON this year. Is this Simontaking a mick at the world???

[jessieac89]

and there was S-teve and S-hanyne!!

not as freaky but still!!

[chewimcdougle]

Phoebe Brown needs a good stalking!

[XgreenjacketX]

lol lol lol lol lol

[ah258]

her lips are amazing when hse sings at one pint they like double two fold!

[phoebebrownhopefan]

phoebe is an angel, and she has a beautiful voice! the box thing they was stood on was a bad idea though, they should have just been on the stage like in the showdown!

GO HOPE!

[bananaberryo7]

pheobe looks so prettty without the stripe in her hair

she looks so grown up

[1111sam1111]

ur sexy but great singer ]

[spudmuffa]

Brilliant! You Btits don't know a goodin!

[spudmuffa]

Utterly brilliant. Equals the Christina version. The Btitish public vote on everything else but good music.

[flickymcbean]

Are you having a laugh? I've never heard anything quite so awful in my life. I hope Christina never hears this version. It's truly appalling.

[xA1Mzx]

Phoebe is amazin!!

hope should have won!

[tubui14]

phoebe is hot!

[childishxx]

Pheobe you wer the best!! didnt no you wer just 15! anywayz if you wer by your self you would have won!! your like the onlii one who could actually sing in hope..you wer really go but i didnt really like hope as a group...

xxxxxxx

[XxBaByCaRlYxX]

onli one problem with this even tho pheobe is the best the others shud have sung alot more x x

[fattyelephant]

pheobe is amazing :D

[Sothertonfan1]

It wasn't note perfect but Hope were my favourite act in the X Factor by a long way.

[AngelicTemptation]

There were moments of pure strength in her voice, but she did falter vocally quite often. With that said, she portrayed the emotion of the song really well and the other girls provided nice harmony.

[lukesheff44]

I know this is a hard song to sing because of the high vocals, however Christina Aguilera does it so much better, with higher notes. she performed day after day in her back to basics tour, it shows there isn't any competition between them. She is in a league of her own, if im honest

[SuperAzooo]

Very good singers!! Should still be in the contest!

[XxprincesstillyxX]

WAT DID THE GUY IN THE BACKROUND SAY?

[tommywood88]

the guy said something along the lines of:

"what about ronan keating and boyzone?"

[SugarKissed]

i think weeks of solo singing has taken its toll on Phoebez voice

[serenaishereok]

there amazing. best perfomance of this years x factor. hope they make it big:D x

[serenaishereok]

how can you say they were crap? they can be compared to christina aguilera because in my opinion i prefer their version. they are all talented especialy phoebe so dont waste your time writing crap like that x

[godseesnocolour]

sorry but they were total and utter crap... she was off key all the time and she sounded like a common person in a pub trying to sing over carryokie. and she + the group can not be compaired to a true talent like christina aguilera and they can not sing like her at all.

[alanbelfastwado]

she is stunning...........and we no who i taking about...........sososososo good

[gmd5]

I agree with Danni, Phoebe should be on her own she's fantastic! You go Phoebe don't give up!

[alanbelfastwado]

brilliant . phebes is amazing xxxxxxxx

[MISSkitchy]

So glad they're out!

I agree with godseesnocolour, they really should not have attempted this song, way beyond their capabilities!

They should have stuck to stuff by Girls Aloud!

[godseesnocolour]

thank you

[godseesnocolour]

terrible!! extremely. her voice is bad who ever is managing this group should know christina aguileras songs are so difficult to sing that it should almost not be attempted my many people expecially if there trying to win a compotition. 1 star there crap. but christina aguilera roxs.

[SuperJack2k7]

I Disagree

[SuperJack2k7]

Its Called X-Factor godseesnocolour No1 Manages Them So Fuck Off And Get The Facts Straight Pheobe Is Amasing

[godseesnocolour]

lol come on they were crap they sang an extremely hard 1 person song in a girl group.. the singer cant sing amazingly well she suits low vocals and the ocasional mid but she cant sing this song to save her career or the groups obviously otherwise they would have still been in X factor.

[godseesnocolour]

p.s sharon no:1 lol haha your having a laught danny minogue who couldnt even manage her own carrier lol simon cowell lol your taking the mick right lol who have they managed that is big except for leona lewis who could do just as well if she had a different manager outside of X factor.

[drumergirl09]

what did the person in the audience shout out

[oatsandsparkles]

"what about ronan keating and boyzone?"

[BGrade15]

Phoebe is a world-class singer, how didn't she make it as a solo girl? Tthis was an amazing performance, Hope were the only act who could really have won...except Rhydian. :( Although I love Niki, Hope were better!