Added: 2 months ago
From: dustyohunter
Views: 9,266
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (143)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • hahaha give me the naked2 pallette been looking for it everywhere :D jk love this video-3

  • Thanks for this vid it really helped... am soo subbing <3

  • Miss you yo! :-)

  • LOL! So funny, the way you say you don't know what to do with it. I have the Naked, and haven't exactly plan to get Naked2. I totally hope I don't go down the same track as so many of you. I mean, I absolutely, absolutely understand how you just bought it because they are there. I may just buy the next time I walk into Sephora, just because it's there too.

  • ermm you seem confused

  • @missfashioneye Not confused... Just don't really care for the product. I bought it because I was excited about it, but disappointed when I got it.

  • :)

  • Are you planning on depotting the Naked 2 Palette? I'm in the process of excavating my shadows...I was hoping you'd have tips on how to avoid total breakage of the shadows in the process :P

  • @SilverCrownMUA Probably not. I might if/when I run out of the shadows from the Naked 1 palette.

  • u the best!

  • I agree with your saying something about warm and cool. I think this is a predominantly warm palette. It is a hair more neutral than the last one. I would not describe it as neutral, but I think one could at least sort-of get away with that. I do not think UD should describe it as cool. It is not. There are two colors that are cool, off the top of my head. I do not see how UD and others are saying it is cool. Disturbing to me. Thank you for knowing the difference.

  • i love ur honesty!! i was so beating my self up cuz i cant afford this one and being such a makeup slut..i just want it cuz its the new one. lol!! i have the original one and i love it but i thought the same things u did so that is why i havent gotten it yet and im so glad that i saw your video and havent gotten it yet!! :)

  • Have you seen the NYX butt "naked" palette? I really wish Urban Decay's Naked 2 had the same colors as the new NYX one. They are more cool and on the grey side. I'd love to see your thoughts on the new NYX palette.

  • Give it to me!

  • I agree, I think it stupid that UD come out with another Naked palette, if u have the first u def don't need the new one. Like u said, they just want another big selling product. Y not come out with a palette with dark, smoky, dramatic colors. I won't be buying this as I own the first one.

  • Do a giveaway!

  • LOL "I just got it because it was there" :D :D I wish my life works like this too :D

  • The best part was seeing your own neutral palette, your choices and how you've organized it. Other than UD Naked, what are the other standouts in there? BTW- I'm trying lots of Fyrinnae lately. Right up your alley, IMHO. 

  • give it to meeeeeeeee

  • seems like they just wanted to repeat the success of the original... who knows maybe they'll steal your idea and come out with NAKED ''cools" 1&2 haha.

  • Sick to death of naked 2 reviews but HAD to watch yours! Thanks for sharing- Jodi ; )

  • Wish I knew when this comes out. Not online or in my Sephora store yet.. hmm.

  • There seems to be no consensus on if this is cool or warmed toned. It looks a bit more warm then cool to me.

  • I totally agree~ everyone was all "OMG IT'S A COOL TONED VERSION" - no it's not, it's warm-toned as well.. was so disappointed...

  • I love the tin :0) xJoolsxxx

  • Thanks for the review...though I had already decided not to get this ;)  Buuuuut...I can has your awesome stripey wall and pretty pillows?!?!

  • @ReveNoirSD Haha :)

  • Thanks, Dusty, I value your opinion.

  • I am pretty glad that Midnight Cowboy wasn't included for once in a UD palette, I like that there was 3 mattes, and that its "permanent." The new case is better in the sense that it can get thrashed around. The velvet case is more for everyday women with smaller collections. The palettes are nice, but they both contain warm toned neutrals, Naked 1 being only slightly cooler.

  • But I just really want it ... too....

    I'm trying very hard not to give into the temptation :)

    Thanks for your honest video! I still just like to hear you talk no matter what it's about!

  • Thanks:). You always do such a great job, and you seem like the nicest guy:).

  • Thank youuu Dusty, so helpful :) I hope UD releases a naked&cool palette :P

  • thanks for your honesty

  • Thanks for this review. I actually emailed UD about the frustration of the duplicates and lack of cool toned shadows. Didn't expect to hear back, at all, but a rep emailed me back quickly and agreed with me about them both being completely warm toned, and said she would pass along my email about needing a cool toned Naked palette. I just can't wear warm tones. They make me look sick. And I love UD shadows, so this was just another palette I had to skip :(

  • I dont have the original naked so im really looking forward to this coning to the uk in feb ide be happy to paypal you the $ if you dont know what to do with it lol

  • Not your review, about the palette.

  • -_- <--- all I have to say about that.

  • It would be best if they would make a matte neutrals palette. Then I would buy it. As it stands now, I can't use Naked 1 or 2 in my kit without major dupeage.

  • Oh you need some ideas on what you can do with the palette do you? I got an idea ;) Whenever you feel like unloading it.. you just let me know!

  • Am holding myself from buying this :/ Thanks for your honest review..i love your channel am shopping around for a pencil case gonna use your method for lip pencils/eye pencils :) x

  • I was so hoping this would be cool toned - so many other gurus were saying 'it's more cool toned than the first naked!' but seriously, it's no where near cool-toned enough that I would buy it. Thanks for being honest!

  • haha b-side :) I want it because I want it. its a great deal and my new job only allows for neautral eye looks soooo more naked gets me quite excited. btw love the wall colors!

  • I was hoping naked 2 would come out with more neutrals to play with! I think your idea for cooler tone palette would of been a better idea :-/

  • I so agree with you about this palette! :)

  • erm what is the title of the song that played from 0.00-0.40? sorry cos i really enjoyed the song and would like to hear more

  • @Curiouslyobsessed Details are always in the description of the video :)

  • @dustyohunter ok thank you! i missed that by accident O.o

  • I so was hoping you'd do a review on this. Thanks!!

  • might i just say, you have such a silky, lovely voice. i like your singing voice too but your speaking voice is just so soothing. ever thought about recording audiobooks? :)

  • haha for some reason today i thought - you are the american gossmakeupartist. I like how honest you both are!

  • the loreal one sweep blusher thing review? i hope it will be up soon.

  • God damn they could have at least been a little bit different with the palette...even doing like an entirely matte "Naked" palette would have been worth while!

  • I love your sign off. And you, why do I feel like you'd be an amazing housemate? haha

  • Thanks for your review, I'm the same I want this palette simply because I want it, but I also think the naked 2 will suit me a little bit better because there are more cooltonedshadows. or am I wrong?

    Unfortunatly I have to wait a little bit until they are sold on beautybay or hqhair, because in switzerland we don't have UD

  • Thank you for your review and for being honest. I was going to buy it but it goes out of stock in one day... Now Im just giong to pass on it for now :)

  • Thanks for an honest review, D!! The new packaging really appealed to me too, but I just can't justify buying it when most of the colours are very similar to the first Naked Palette!! I kinda wish they would sway from the "Nude/Natural" tones and try a new kind of palette, like variations on like a teal or greens palette, or a plumb, or blues.....do you catch my drift? They have soo many amazing colours and they can create soo many cool palettes, I just think they should have tried that instead!

  • Thank you for this review. I def. don't need it and won't get it . xo jessie

  • I would love to see a video on depotting eyeshadows - could be the naked palettes, or any brand at all. I think it would be cool to have different depotting methods conveniently in one video!

  • Hey Dustin, I love ALL of your videos! I still really want Naked 1, but the only issue is that I live in New Zealand and we don't get Urban Decay products here :-( I'm so JEALOUS of everyone that has it, I can't get my hands on one and I'm getting really obsessed with it lol. Can anyone recommend a good website to buy it off? The Urban Decay website doesn't ship to NZ...

  • @Nisha840172 I'm from Australia and really found it hard to find an shop on the net that would ship world wide.....I finally found one and I'm now obsessed!! ;p Check out the guys at "Beauty Bay" they ship worldwide and they give really good service too!! :) They have an advent calendar thingy going at the moment and for today they have 10% off so if you get the chance, go and get it cheaper!! ;) I hope this helps you....I just had to reply cos I know exactly how you're feeling!! Good luck!! :)

  • I was kind of on the fence about whether to get this palette or not but you just swayed me into not getting it. Thank you so much because what I don't need right now is to spend $50 on a palette that I won't end up using. There is one color in this palette that I am in love with but it would be stupid to get the palette for that one color (the matte gray one). xoxo Deb

  • confused now as everyone else said it was more cool toned, thought ok, yup I'll buy it then, but........only so many warm toned neutral shades one needs in life! will have to study swatches closely. and then will probably buy the damn thing anyway :)

  • Great review!!You are so smart!!

  • Karlasugar's swatches are definitely more accurate and true to life than temptalia's. But of course everyone's camera and screen resolution is different. I just prefer Karla better because I never seem to agree with temptalia's reviews. I don't feel she's always being completely honest. And I say this from real life comparisons and being thoroughly disappointed by several products that temptalia has endorsed.

  • @hepcat288 so where is her (karlasugar's) swatches for the n2? temptalia has one, so we were referred to look. why are you slamming Christine?

  • What's weird about half baked is that it's a different color for me in both palettes. My Half Baked in the 1st palette is exact to Snakebite in the 2nd. Mind you, my palette is one the originals with that had the duo liner in it. I don't know how I got that haha.

  • Why do you keep looking to your side?

  • @hepcat288 I'm looking in your window... ;) I actually hadn't scripted this so I was thinking a lot about what I was going to say - I had stuff around me and I was staring at it while I was thinking :P

  • I know temptalia and dusty said its blah. But like dusty said, would have gotten it anyway :( i just did this morning...whaahhh

  • I love when you don't use a script lol. Love your honesty.:D

  • I hate to say it but I think a lot of us (well, me) are like you... no matter what the colors really were in there we would have bought it because it's there and it's Naked 2.

    ... and Urban Decay knows it and banks off that sh*t! Whomp! Someone take my credit card away from me.

  • @alesandrah So what are you so afraid of?

  • @dustyohunter Being consumed by the awesomeness of course.

  • THIS IS THE BEST REVIEW ON YOUTUBE! WE APPRECIATE THE VERY HONEST TRUTH AND YOU MADE IT VERY CLEAR TO ALL YOUR VIEWERS! THANKS!

  • I don't have the naked pallets, so I'd love to take it off your hands

  • Great review!

  • "but...I like b-sides."

    You're my favorite.

  • Yes, exactly! I've been hoping for a cooler toned version for NAKED 2 cuz warm neutrals don't look well on me but damnit...still warm :(

  • I love how you were HONEST in this review. All of the other gurus I follow on youtube RAVED about the N2. Then again, Urban Decay sent them the pallet for free. :shrug:

  • @lameasscatlady LOL! I bought this shiz myself! Hehe

  • @lameasscatlady I'm actually JUST starting to watch some of the more popular reviews on this thing and I'm a little disappointed. It's misleading to say this is an over-all cool toned palette. It's just not. Either you don't know what a cool toned neutral is or you're just reading the press release.

  • @dustyohunter Perhaps the rave is that this palette is "relatively" cool-toned, in comparison to the original Naked palette...

  • @HappyLittleNinja I meant to introduce my statement with "I agree with you."

  • i will drive safe, thank you.

  • Great and honest review. That's why I love watching you. Others are "loving" it and saying it has "cool" tones to it and that if you have the first kit that you might want to get this one too. I have the first one and I also have the NYX one that is similar too that palette so I guess I'm set in neutral colors . Your awsome as always! Happy Holidays!!!

  • @Mrs3angels You're welcome! Glad to help! I actually haven't seen any other reviews on this yet. I try to avoid watching other people's reviews on a product that I KNOW I'm going to be reviewing - I want to make sure that I'm not swayed one way or another. I did read the one on temptalia though and she said about the same thing I did, "Where's the cool tones?!!" LOL

  • Could you possibly do a video on the way you depotted your Naked Palette shadows? I would love to put them in my Z palette instead of having to put up with that annoying as hell velvet case. Great viedo as always :)

  • @topographyofmars I just pried them out with an x-acto knife to be honest. Completely destroyed the palette but I got those frackers out of there! :)

  • I absolutely love this review. You are so honest. A lot of people are like, "I love it!" but say nothing bad and say, "Well, it may be similar, but it is still different..." Now I know not to get it since it is so similar. Hello saving 50 bucks.

  • I love Pistol eyeshadow in Naked 2, but I have the first and makes no sense to buy it just for one shade!! Do you know of a dupe for 'Pistol'?? xoxo

  • @makeupbydewi The original review on Temptalia said it was similar to a color in a palette by the Balm. I don't know of any single dupes but I LOVE colors like that. I'm all over dirty greys and silvers and taupe-ish colors. Check out Gem by ZuZu luxe sometime. It's not the same as Pistol but it's that "type" of color... you might like it! I love it :)

  • @dustyohunter Thank you, I will check!! I love the same colors as you!! Other people swoon over blues and pinks and greens, I go gaga for 'dirty' shimmers haha.

    Maybe a blog post of your all time favourites would be cool (for me at least).

  • @makeupbydewi Me too! Anything gunmetal and I'm all over it! I know I've talked about it before in videos but have you ever checked out Disco Ball by Terra Firma cosmetics? You'd love it!!!

  • You could say Naked 2 is the poor man's Naked 1, except it's more expensive so maybe not, LOL.

  • I meant " I brought "

  • Good review....I don't need but will probably buy it....but won't be buying duplicates in palettes in the future....nice walls. Give Naked 2 away to one on your subbies. Btw, u brought a few of EL Cyber Shawdows....the lillac one looks amazing on me....Lol....starting to buy some Double Wear Creme Shadows ....think I like them better than Paintpots.

  • @urbanfabchic (They are!!! SHHH! LOL!) Estee Lauder definately has it over MAC with many of their cream formulas - They are just lacking the artistic punch of color that MAC has... Always keep your eye on their limited edition collections though (like Cyber eyes), that's usually when Lauder seems to roll out the more exciting products here and there.

  • i just recently got the first UD Naked Palette...and they come out with a second one.. -.- definitely not gonna buy the second one..they look too similar to me..

  • Forget the palette-you look amazing in that royal blue shirt. Aw hell you look amazing all the time :) I thought the colors were quite warm toned, not a fan, already have naked 1 so not buying naked 2. Great review! xoxo

  • @Catalina031 Aw thank you!!!! :)

  • that half baked eyeshadow in this palette makes me so mad! why did they have to repeat it! ):

  • @yumemisakai I don't know. I think they should just make this limited edition and re-release a new version of Naked every year if that's how similar they are going to make these.

  • Your walls are lovely. Thanks for the review, Dusty.

  • i LOVE those colors!!!

  • love the b-side comparison! brilliant!

  • @fromalbiontoarcadia Haha! I thought so myself ;) LOL

  • i heard from someone who review the naked 2 palette and she said the eyeshadows were cool toned......

  • @JessicaLuvsMakeup Nope. She might be mixing up how MAC refers to cool and warm tones maybe? Cool toned neutrals are really lovely but aren't as available. Warm tones are golds, coppers, things with a lot more "warmth" to them. Cool tones would be more grey-based and what you might refer to as "muddy."

  • I agree I like the first one better. But is that because I've only had the other a week and used it twice? Time will tell. I didn't really care for the first one when I got it.

  • Great honest review as always, and actually on this occasion I prefer your swatches to temptalias. Also I think I'm developing a crush on you, I blame you entirely.

  • @VivaciaDreams LOL! Thank you :)

  • I want it anyway! There are six colours that I feel are different enough from the original to warrant getting it. If I bought those six individually it would cost more, and in any case some of those six are not available individually.

  • i'd like your opinion. im asian with pale yellow tinted skin, i dont own the first naked palette, but id like to invest in either. which do you think would be better for my skin tone? thank you!

  • @xxLovelyMe Honestly they are both so similar I would say either one... The neutral browns are almost all the same, the only thing that changes is the few dark greys and blacks.

  • I love this palette, the colors are gorgeous, great review and swatches :)

  • BEST SWATCHES AND REVIEW IVE SEEN !!

  • thanks for your all over the place but honest review ;P no honestly i love your way of making videos. i am a big urban decay fan but i am still thinking if to get the naked 2 anytime soon because i have a matte black and i have the 1 and i prefer dark smokey eyes and the naked 2 looks to me like i can only pull them off when i mix them with the black. and i have black in my black palette from urban decay

  • i have a great idea... why don't you raffle the palette off to one of us commentors? i would happily take it off your hands! LOL

  • Thank you for speaking the truth about this. Breath of fresh air. Most people are bullshitting their way through their reviews and that's just annoying the hell out of me. I agree with you entirely.

  • Thank god, someone who speaks the true and admits it is too much the same like the 1st!!!

  • Hey! ill be happy to take that palette off your hands if you dont want it. I kid, I kid.... or am i? lol

  • I always enjoy listening to what you have to say.

  • Thanks for the video! I just can't decide on this one... I definitely don't need it, but my inner makeup addict really wants it lol.

  • I liked this palette! thought Naked 2 did a good job of offering different levels of sheerness. Verve, for example, has a sheerer luminosity that I really like. I did not like the brush, actually, but that's OK. This palette seems to be more about the mid-tones and brights. For me, and I'm really pale, I loved how a lot of these look on me, especially Tease - very pretty. I think if you have a LOT of makeup, though, there are probably a lot of dupes here. :)

  • @LydiaKrow I agree. I'm very fair-skinned as well and actually prefer this one to the earlier one in a lot of ways.

  • @LydiaKrow I actually have Tease swept across my lower lid in this video :) It's a pretty shade.

  • Is the quality of the shadows the same in both pallets?

  • @PerfectlyObsessed I should make a note about that huh? LOL! Yes, it is pretty much there IMO... I was just kind of underwhelmed and because I wasn't excited and hadn't scriped this video, I was sort of running out of things to talk about :)

  • @PerfectlyObsessed I added an annotation about halfway through the video with that info :) Thanks again for pointing it out!

  • The ironic thing is this was marketed as cool tone shadows...

  • @PaigeeB222 Yea I don't really see the grey tones they make this sound like it has...

  • Am I the only one who likes Naked 2 better than the original? Not only are the colors better for me (guess the finishes are better for women older than Jesus), but I haven't experienced any fallout like the first one does (OMG, you should have seen the glitter all over my daughter for prom from that stupid palette). I bought it just for the challenge of getting it, but glad I did :)

  • @PurelyCosmetics LOL I like the packaging better in this one. I don't do much with neutrals anyway though... When I do I'll grab a MAC shadow or to be honest, I really like the dark brown that you make! I blend it with other colors all the time.

  • It's pretty, but I wish there were some matte shadows in there.  I won't be buying this but great review.

  • @Aqualina1 I would have liked to have seen more mattes as well. UD's mattes are usually so nice, why not include some more? If everything is shimmering, nothing really stands out IMO.

  • Love the voice, calming! Great hair...TRACK

  • I've only just picked up the original Naked palette this week, I know, but delighted to see your review of this. You've just saved me €40 x

  • Great video! Loved the swatches comparison and it completely talked me out of buying Naked 2. Thank you for saving me money!

  • If you don't want it and you're feeling generous I'd be happy to take it off your hands :p great review ^^

  • Your Video's are nice and always helpful.. Thanks!!!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more