王菀之 "唸你" @TVB Music Cafe

[liupingnam]

叫汪明荃向人家請教下啦，成日唱到好似回魂咁

[musictung]

王菀之呢個LOOK好好睇=]

[lingpakkei]

聽得我好舒服,,

[apple111212]

人真是有病態...點解次次都要同人比較...每個人唱歌風格都­唔同...如果要踩人先可以抬高自己偶像...呢個人對音樂都係­不外如是...

[ericac0104]

我就要e首歌有這種風味及韻味,王菀之做得好好!+oil我喜歡­這個版本！

[leekamching]

佢把聲好柔~~~

[NightTung]

咁先係喱隻歌應有既風格

[yukisodagreen0729]

真係唱得好聽好多!!!

[village283]

唱的真好～好有30年代上海百樂門的浮華感喔～～～～陶醉～～～

這首歌也有台灣70年代歌廳秀的調調～



[winghowwh]

點解好聽咁多嫁-,-

[chiang315]

震音很強;

[Arielmiffy20]

勁牙..一開始唱之前睇留言就覺得佢邊會甘勁,點知....

[SuperBFoo]

這是原唱?

[31679880]

劉子千靠呢隻歌變紅;王菀之用番呢隻歌擊敗左劉子千

[Lostwaterful]

王菀之你知道嗎有個叫劉子千的人抄襲你的歌曲而且很難聽！

[kayin313]

ivana你唱得好好好好好正呀

[nhx2005]

王菀之簡直係音樂既藝術家

可以將一首兩岸三地都拎黎恥笑既歌

唱到咁有韻味，正！

[joycesuntszwai]

嘩... jazz版好聽咁多 @@

第一次ivana用呢個唱腔... 勁!!

[183794]

好有韻味啊*o*



[loklokyue]

根本唸你就係70年代既風格,王菀之咁唱先襯家嘛~LIKE!

[snakesss1112]

原來首歌係好聽架....ivana你好正呀><!

[ausze]

二灣娜唱呢類歌係有一手，佢之前首《她扔了根火柴》都係呢種fe­el

[kitson1989]

好似返左上海灘果個年代既夜總會

[yylovesfung4ever]

@kitson1989 同意

[1211kurt]

好正!100分我比95分!

[coCOcoLA307]

這d先係唱歌架嘛！

[katyfong0219]

好靚女 人靚聲甜

[winwin424]

第88,888個觀看者 咁好意頭既^^



[Lampard2347]

88,888=]

[jasonpolaris]

因為劉子千寫果陣根本就係用呢個方法去寫........

而家用呢種演繹方法.. 成件事咪啱晒囉!

讀錯係唔係"流走"

[MrFranky217]

原來不是歌曲的問題,,是演唱者的問題...千千皮已收,恭喜

[80838405]

有音讀錯-.-

[kayin313]

皇后唱呢首歌好有復古既味道

[queennieshow]

頭髮好柔順!!:D

[ling4495]

唱出另一種風格了...再不是搞笑的感覺

好聽!!!!



[3Hatred]

唱比軒仔聽 ~  xd

[luikahohno]

好有女人味!!!

[a981990]

@chun2005 she's not ugly

[cwssing]

@chun2005

Sorry, I don't think that Ivana gets an ugly appearance,

Y do U hv the power to criticise others' appearance?

I suggested that U should del. wt U posted b4.

Pls don't insult our idol.--> at least, my idol.

[chun2005]

@cwssing Why are you calling her ugly? omg... so mean to my idol... my last comment never said she was ugly... Why do you have the power to force me into doing something i never commit... just WOW you think you are some kind of boss here killing freedom of speech? please dont insult my idol and freedom of speech. I suggest you delete your comment then ill consider deleting mine. Again, the answer is (BECAUSE I CAN) ;)

[1228al]

正wow

[maphow]

Ivana is so good! Rare artist in canto-pop! LOVE!

[kesel5588]

I actually think that Ivana sings in a more comfortable voice when she sings mandarin songs. If she watch out for those distracting breathing noises then she'll be perfect.

[benjaminhk]

劉家昌終於得到平反了…淚。

[26643504]

証明編曲及演譯的重要

[jackyjacky520]

王菀之把聲好溫柔啊~~~

[stitch854679254]

Love  <3 <3

[mab0o0]

she look great with this hair style!!!!

[mauricewg2002]

Ivana <3

[kone7983]

這首歌真的要這樣配才搭啊！

[jackhardylai]

首歌我一聽就覺得有70年代上海歌舞廳既感覺...真係有人做出­黎...

[icsazabi]

@jackhardylai

是三四十年代吧,七十年代的大陸不可能有歌舞廳...而且二灣那­自己也提到是白光(40年代上海歌壇七大歌星之一)年代的音樂.­...

[wingwing0404]

好想要MP3 VERSION

" 艾粒二彎拿!!!!! " <3 <3 <3

[houfaful]

原唱難聽到想喊,

佢唱感動到想喊

[siuwaiiii]

王菀之係咪想同千千講:細路,首歌係咁唱架!

[06starstar]

@siuwaiiii 擺明係啦! 劉子千唱衰晒首歌-.-

[cyuenlam123]

勁好聽

[handsomeday2]

第一下個"我"字對女仔來講可能係最難唱

[shortfat]

勁呀之之

[moc143]

CLASSIC

[uacrazyvava]

唱得好懷舊feel! 好似播梗黑膠唱片咁 哈哈

佢把聲真係好多變!

[HungSuetman]

哇，完全吾覺得把聲係佢個口唱出黎~~_~~

[nicholastang1217]

佢把聲好好聽

[20minutesss]

很懷舊的感覺。旁邊像放著一個舊式收音機~

[amyamylly]

23人不喜歡.

劉家昌和劉子千開分身DISLIKE?

[monolisa161]

好有吸引力 唔知邊度黎

[elmoyupi]

佢把聲好靚牙!轉音個D音聽得好舒服!

[YsL3426]

好有懷舊feel

[loveJingForever96]

王苑之唱得好好聽^^

個乜乜千真係...唉...

[wu0212tung]

點解由王菀之唱出黎係咁好聽~!!

[rbcs0607]

ivana長頭髮好靚

[wantbz]

睇到如何編曲同歌手既演繹係幾咁重要!!

[goukigogo]

真係唱得比原唱者好好多呢！

[sherrychowhaha]

多位歌手翻唱既版本都好聽過原唱n倍-.-

[Joseph06238]

真的好好聽!

[ahjess768]

this is the way the song should've been sang!

[sicilianmansi]

慶幸呢個年代本地仲有歌手 仲可以唱廣東國語歌都冇難度

[Chuchucatbabi]

化腐朽為神奇X2

[Mrlovemusic1992]

劉家昌和子千一起開了13個帳戶來負評

[wasshk]

勁歌金曲 重有歌手上

[samho747]

@wasshk 睇唔睇到係J2播ge Music cafe.....

[lamlambobo]

好好聽呀~~唔同既風格..~~



[okmm26]

更加睇到劉家昌既功力

無論佢既音樂造詣定係佢對娛樂圈生態既熟悉

佢將自己個仔一下就捧紅左,超勁!!!

[kailongque]

好有“她扔了根火柴”feel =.=;;

[achou6699]

好聽:)

[chingsze26]

佢有種好有魔力既唱功~~

[JackieChui0629]

即刻古典哂, 正好多

[siumo12]

改個唱法好幾多

[MrNgobaby]

太棒了!!!

[manyueel]

呢個先系原本要表達出黎既 音樂

[wongchung6]

Ivana looks so beautiful!

[chnalexander]

看到嗎？聽到嗎？就算不懂音樂也感受到完全不同的風格，這是編曲­者的魔力也是演繹者的魅力！



[hkccng]

她說得對，真的好襯果個年代。

如果佢個ｌｏｏｋ都打扮成那個年代。

不用無線咪，改有有線站式舊式咪，

首推，Shure 55 SH。

成個舞台氣氛即時返晒來

望住台上的她，絕對可以帶觀眾穿梭時光，回到那年代　:)

[kimmygoal]

大檸樂~聽完有少少鐘意左呢首歌...

[mirukubaby]

死喇 唔講歌住 佢而家有點似蕭亞軒……

[paulchanml]

完全不同味道good

[ddzero4]

只是劉子千化神奇為腐朽

[212loful]

唸你可以唱到咁好聽! 好犀利!

[daisywong328]

现在香港乐坛少的就是这种功底....

[Chantelle520728]

好聽唷~~~~!!!

你應該很紅的!!!

[217momoko]

不錯~!!!

[yukkeilee]

2人不喜歡

應該是劉家昌與劉子千了

[dancer19820416]

王菀的版本

才是真正的50 60年代fu

[eltbert]

Ivana不如試下打入老歌演唱會市場，應該大受歡迎

[ho617]

@eltbert agree! 佢把聲好有懷舊味道

[nlpthomas]

實在是太厲害了！

[nlpthomas]

實在是太厲害了！

[darkniel105]

即刻升呢可以擺落發燒天碟 ~ 同「被遺忘的時光」可以睇齊

[gn02903173]

劉子千按了dislike



[whatthenith]

1個 dislike ，係咪時候話「劉子千按了dislike」喇

[EdwinXDxd]

好有懷舊feel

正！

[manlokr]

這就是化腐朽為神奇嗎...

[999v999v999]

@manlokr

其實這歌本來就很好聽,

雖然劉家昌說是剪輯問題

但我的想法是劉家昌教了他兒子用一種很爛的方法去唱= =

[suberbbbb]

她唱出了我心目的唸你 好滿足:)

[fishomie]

she's so good!

[ChanYeung17]

應該叫劉子千聽下

[anonymw13]

咁先係歌黎嘛



[yukiabout]

good

[MoMoWorms]

正！咁先o岩feel~!!