Jacky Cheung - 離人

[MsAngrypig]

张学友版本比较男人，帅气

[e81028]

"不後悔"那張專輯~我有買喔~~陪我度過國三準備高中聯考時期­!

[alcovex]

歌神真好聽 厲小姐的詞意境好美

[imGemmy0v0]

這個唱腔聽到會想哭

[ge2nou2]

my favorite song....

[ivan07105a]

學友的離人比林志炫更耐聽!

[9l1492198]

林志炫很工整的把整首歌唱完

學友哥則唱岀了離愁......層次高下立判!!!

[virnowi]

3'25''时 学友的神情好可爱

[shoinchang]

這MV真的很妙 女主角又穿大紅色 好像不屬於人世間一樣

[kattyty]

@willchannel 我也是

[dannyip1229]

@willchannel

我也是...

[QQQ978]

先前有聽過這首歌~並沒注意到這首歌~~而後..越聽~是越有感­覺......張學友唱起這首歌...真是好聽....

[funnybunny9396]

每曰都要黎拜一拜神至舒服

[abinent]

很有意境

[vienna2046]

太美了

[lagyssas]

i kinda like this version

[Raiyne324]

i didn't know he sang this song

[mitil16]

这个歌太爱了！

<3

[Wong]

我还是很喜欢听张学友的版本，他完全唱出了这首歌的含义...我­的心几乎被他的歌声感动了，我真的很希望学友以后开演唱会时，会­选这首歌来唱...

[wintere]

一開始是先知道林的版本

可是連結那邊看到學友的版本..

覺得學友的唱法絕對比林的唱法耐聽 ....

聽久了這首歌的人就知道 ....支持學友

[iamwjy]

這個伴奏和弦有點怪。

[dellimma75]

林的版本 一開始聽不錯 聽久了就膩了 相對下張的版本比較雋永 像美酒越陳越香

[peteraucs]

我同意. 林的唱法注重technique. 張的板本藏有很有味道.

[forever2005]

他像是為唱而唱的...有感而發....我覺得那是神的境界 ...我都唔知點先可以唱成咁..簡直係神

[tea550]

我覺得張學友唱的比較好聽

跟其他版本比較的話

[cvz1999]

這是1998年不後悔專輯中的歌曲

[ascncblue]

從我懂事開始就是學友歌的歌迷

對我來說他是個謙虛,幽默,低調,迷人的歌手

這首離人更是我最愛的歌之一

為何很多人都以為林志炫才是原唱呢

[vincent880234]

大多數人都是沉默的吧！

[ilovejessiegreen]

@ascncblue 可能因為學友的歌大家耳熟能詳的太多了，難免一時錯漏，再加上學­­友當時比較主打深海那首。還有，林志炫當初講了一段他跟親人的­感­人回憶，他說每次聽到這首歌都會哭，所以才拿過來翻唱，這表­示，­就是學友的歌聲觸動他的啊！或許也因為他的故事太感人，所­以大家­跟著入了戲，就以為原唱是他了。

[eddieyewchinwei]

@ascncblue 因为这首歌好像是林志炫写的

[zeekerblade]

@eddieyewchinwei

不是...

詞：厲曼婷

作曲：何家文

編曲：屠穎

林志炫就是翻唱而已

[kozy147]

I prefer Jacky's version

[millertseng2005]

張學友的感情詮釋更高一籌～

[jasonddd50]

偉大科學家 - 牛頓 曾經說過一句說話:「如果我比別人看得更遠, 那是因為我站在巨人的肩膊上。」

（If I have seen farther than others, it is because I was standing on the shoulders of giants）

[jasonddd50]

是否有這樣一句:「第一個做是天才，第二個做是平才，第三個做是­庸才。」???

[stanley6769]

莎士比亞說:「第一個做是天材，第二個做是庸材，第三個做是蠢材­。」

[jasonddd50]

志炫, 學友 都很好..... 各有特色

志炫 聲線比較 高,

學友 聲線比較 低 且 厚, 感覺上 志炫較有感染力, 可以理解.....

始終覺得 志炫, 學友 都很好..... 各有特色.....

學友帶磁性的嗓音..... 很有吸引力

[1hrspwr]

很喜歡學友對這首歌的詮釋，感情放的恰到好處，聽完後讓人籠罩在­一股淡淡慵懶的落寞中。

[FLORENCEHSIA]

yes, I agree with you.

[denny0000002]

很好 太好了 的確是神的境界

但仍然比不上林志炫的版本

就是差了那麼一點

[fayewes]

i agree with stpiggy0316, yep terry lin;s one was PERFECT but maybe thats where the problem lied, perfect voices do not sell, just look at stefanie sun, her voice is not perfect but it is precisely the imperfectness and flaws that appeals to listeners!

my 2 cents' worth (:

[heartlessjerk]

i'm sorry but you make no sense to me.

but yes i agree terry's version is better.

[i3forever]

林志炫唱这首歌声音太单调根本引不起共鸣

基本上所有的词都是在一个调上没有轻重之分

[stpiggy0316]

Jacky's not bad, but terry lin is perfect!

dont judge me, just my own opinion.

[jessieDai]

I really like this song

[cherriegao]

jacky is better!!

[314991504]

that's why Lin is 唱匠 and cheung is 歌神

[jackchenwuji]

学友版编曲感觉差一点，学友的演唱感到一种沉沉的愁愫。林的版本­感情没那么深刻~有点讲别人的故事的感觉

[kokfah]

i like this version of song better... no more copy and changing of this song please... they sound very.. OFF

[jacinthtw]

比林志炫的版本更有..更有..更有...感情

[tondalava]

jacky chueng is my favourite singer,I love it

[jy1218]

好懷念張學友的歌聲

[woozley18]

寫得很好! 果然是有深入研究這首歌的內容跟旋律,我們地球需要你!

[slacking99]

One of Jacky's saddest song together with Bie Wen (not Wen Bie) and a few more.

[zincthenoob]

i love tis song

[justzforever]

I love this version (his voice, Melody, Lyrics). It touches my heart whenever i listen to it.

[slacking99]

I prefer this version coz it is more emo.

[jgsky]

张学友的版本更加有味道，那种浓浓的，温柔的，把握自如的感觉。

林志炫的版本有那种浪漫的感觉。

总之两个版本都非常好。

[roychan91426]

this song Terry's version is better

But for"李香蘭" by Jacky is far better than Terry's "秋意濃"

[obiwan88]

I prefer Tamaki Kōji's (玉置 浩二) version. ^^

[LifeFirst]

What's the name of his version?

[obiwan88]

Tamaki Kōji's (玉置 浩二) is the original singer of this song (Ikanaide - Don't Go). I'm a fan of Anzen Chitai (安全地带）and Tamaki-san, simply legendary.

[alainon]

你搞錯了!

玉置浩二唱的 Ikanaide 是張學友翻唱的另一首叫 "李香蘭", 請再注意聽清楚.

"離人" 唱過的有張學友, 林志烗, 柯以敏, ...

[obiwan88]

Actually I was responding to someone mentioning 《李香兰》 as sung by Jacky, somehow this user unfriendly youtube UI messed up our communication. Do you seriously anyone could have mixed up those 2 songs? Anyway IMHO, Jacky is rated so high because he's born in HK, and not say like in Japan. ^^

[dotkyo]

i like this... more relaxing... if u prefer techniques and stuff then ... yea terry's version is the one u should listen to

[newzoned]

exactly

everyone knows how much lin like to show off his vocal

[Phil28168]

Lovely song. Thanks for the upload, mate.

[dinogee]

great song but my god that painting in this video is hideous

[rukawa11dark]

both version are awesome, but

[jibikao]

Funny I never really know about this song until 超級星光大道 潘裕文 林志炫--離人 得到 22 分. I think I've heard this song before but I don't think the song was that popular? This song sounds like a Classic now!

[ifonlyicouldfly]

i'm so sorry i wanted to press 'good comment' but pressed the other accidentally. yeah i agree with you!

[nail4e2]

i agree.... jerry lin sings this song better... but if you want to repeatedly listen to this song, then jacky's one is better... i find it strange... only jacky's singing can really allow me to listen a sing so many times without getting tired... maybe this is the reason he is named the god of singing

[theone1998]

I listen to both Terry's and Jacky's version many times. The first couple times I feel that Terry's version is better, his voice seems better for this song; but after couple times, I feel that it is flat, and bored. That is not the case for Jacky's version. You still enjoy it after many times listening to it. That is the difference.

[husuwei]

i like jacky's version=)

[username49]

I agree, Terry's version is better. I think is due to the way he sang ba...

[momomonsta]

terry's is better , but not many people can sing it well haha =)

[chartchua]

same here....like Terry's version better

[hangly3722]

Jacky Cheung is the original singer,but Terry Lin version is better to me

[KmiowC]

who was the real original singer?? i am so confuse??

Terry Lin or Jacky Cheung?

[forever2005]

jacky cheung

[ykwhycare]

i prefer the original version- Jackie Version!

[joystick169]

not the same style only ........

[Flavante]

@joystick169 BETTER.

[vickysky]

I agree,terry's is better.

[solcroft]

terry lin's version is much better than jacky's! no offence to jacky, his voice is awesome!

[sansan4ever]

legendary...

[neihomai]

by the way, the whistling in the song was also by jacky :)

[paulkop888]

He has the best voice. His songs can bring back ones memories (happy or sad)by just listening to it. LEGEND.

[mitballa]

no, Jackie was the first who sings this song

[camoranleodes]

Is this original song from Terry Lin?

[safong]

Thanks for the video - luv the song and his voice