This is actually a thumri - and not a ghazal. It was written as a lament - so really it is a sad composition - something that is not reflected in this rendition.
If sangit is matter of "soor & bhave emulated by a singer " then good singing would very from person to person and from audience to audience. But if Sangit is matter of range & control over the range. Then K L Saigal had very small range & could sing only simple melody. In sangit world (west or east), most singing professional gave lot of emphasis on range & control. By that standard small range is barely respectable.
That's a correct point.. Generally, (old) indie songs were sung like that. I cannot degrade KL Saigal saying he had limited range, actually, he was best at what he was doing...
But at the same time, here with Jagjitsingh..you get Range, control, Raga & everything. Not all can do that.
this song is written by Last nawab of awadh , wajad ali shah. I t was sung by K.L SAIGAL in a film called MY SISTER. This song was sung when there was no recording studio facility. so please listen to the K.L SAIGAL song of 1944.
Bhaio, mai Jagjit Sing ki bahoot ijjat karta hu. Gulam Ali aur Mahedi Hassan ki bhi ijjat karta hu. Magar maine Pandit Bhimsen Josi ko suna, live concert at Pune (babul mora). Pata nahi kia hua muje, magar subh ke subh bache jaise dikh ne lage. Except for K. L. Saigal
Oh my goddddddddddddddddddddd!!!!!!!!!!!!!! this song is unbelievable my God !!!!! i love you!
soron84700 4 months ago
The Maestro has yet again Outdone Himself.. What a Wonderful Listening Experience..
kohiful 1 year ago
Comment removed
Pmd9013 1 year ago
Not even close to Great K.L.Sehgal.
Sorry mr.Jagjeet you should not select what you can not sing.
Muneeb58 2 years ago
Dear Friend,
There is large difference in between of a song & a gazal.
Great K L Sehgal sang a song & that was best.
Jagjitsingh did a classical one !
No comparision, between two great singers !!
kedarnevergone 2 years ago 4
This is actually a thumri - and not a ghazal. It was written as a lament - so really it is a sad composition - something that is not reflected in this rendition.
zad1262 2 years ago
thanks for the value add...
i bliv..
music is free...& open ended...
new creativity & touch gives it a different charm.. There are dozen versions of Vandemataram :)
I loved both - Jagjit Sir's version & KL Sehgal Sir's version ...
kedarnevergone 2 years ago 2
thanks for your love for our music (classical or gazals) guys !
kedarnevergone 2 years ago
If sangit is matter of "soor & bhave emulated by a singer " then good singing would very from person to person and from audience to audience. But if Sangit is matter of range & control over the range. Then K L Saigal had very small range & could sing only simple melody. In sangit world (west or east), most singing professional gave lot of emphasis on range & control. By that standard small range is barely respectable.
Pmd9013 1 year ago
That's a correct point.. Generally, (old) indie songs were sung like that. I cannot degrade KL Saigal saying he had limited range, actually, he was best at what he was doing...
But at the same time, here with Jagjitsingh..you get Range, control, Raga & everything. Not all can do that.
Rare in western musicians...
kedarnevergone 1 year ago
Comment removed
Pmd9013 1 year ago
Stupid! There is no such thing one can not do! This is classical Raag everyone can try on.
Bushrraff 2 years ago
this place looks like IIMB OAT is that right ?
sukraat 2 years ago
there is another filmi version after K L Saigol...a duet..if anyone knows about it kindly email me..thanks
qasrenoor 2 years ago
this song is written by Last nawab of awadh , wajad ali shah. I t was sung by K.L SAIGAL in a film called MY SISTER. This song was sung when there was no recording studio facility. so please listen to the K.L SAIGAL song of 1944.
bholare 2 years ago 2
waah !
nice history !!!
thanks..
kedarnevergone 2 years ago 3
super
KALYANISUNIL 2 years ago
vah vah vah!!
108suvarna108 2 years ago
Bhaio, mai Jagjit Sing ki bahoot ijjat karta hu. Gulam Ali aur Mahedi Hassan ki bhi ijjat karta hu. Magar maine Pandit Bhimsen Josi ko suna, live concert at Pune (babul mora). Pata nahi kia hua muje, magar subh ke subh bache jaise dikh ne lage. Except for K. L. Saigal
NokAppli 2 years ago 3
super mind blowing out of this world!!!! but again dimond is dimond no need for compliment
h235377 3 years ago
I already liked him, but what a great great tribute to Kundan Lal Saigal.
Gothica247 3 years ago
Great! Great Great!!
jendrapra 3 years ago