themusic is beautiful and the anime is slightly off but still wonderful please enter this amv into my competition i am holding at this very moment i will send u the one through a video post pls post your submition as a video respeonce I can definetly say by far this is the best one i have come across as of late
@NaruNaruninetails Sure why not? I'll enter, sounds like fun. Is the image really off though? huh... looks okay on my side of the 'nets, maybe it's a youtube thing? :-/ Glad you liked the video though :D
@benjaythewhite yeah that's I saw too, plus when Hohenheim was giving ed and al that look I could tell his how serious he was about stopping Father you know, like he wasn't looking at his kids to spite them but not let them die like the people of Xerxes did ya know what I mean?
wow, i never would have thought this song would have made a great amv for FMAB but it is! you're very creative for thinking of putting the two together. it fits perfectly with hohenheim's story and this is the best amv for him i've seen!
@JerkWarlord In the US, yes, it is FMA: Brotherhood to distinguish it from the first FMA series, but in Japan it is known simply as FMA, the same as the first series. I think at the time I had decided to go with the original title. However, to avoid confusion I will change it, thanks :) Glad you liked the video.
@TheWesternSage Sure thing! :D It's easily the best FMA AMV I've ever seen. What I like best is it's simplicity-it's not overruled with effects or anything. It's just clips, for the most part, and it goes that well with the music. The story told is the best to tell from the whole series, too. (':
@JerkWarlord Part of that is probably because I only have windows movie maker to work with >_> But I've never been a big fan of distracting effects. But this video, I had in mind ever since I read the Xerxes chapters of the manga, (and that Doctor Who episode, not sure which came first) had to wait for Brotherhood to come out to finally make it, so I had plenty of time to plan it out. I'm a big Hohenheim fan, so I definitely agree with you about it being the best story to tell in the series. :D
@TheWesternSage Can I ask your opinion. I found similarities between Gallifrey and Xerxes, both were advanced civilizations but there downfall began when they believed they could do something without consequences like the King of Xerxes sacrificing his own people for his own greed thereby sealing the fate of the entire country.
I also found some similarities between the Doctor/Master and Hohenheim/Father. Both were initially friends until they became enemies.
@Kryptonian250 Yeah, I totally agree with you on these points. I think it's part of the reason I wanted to make this video. I definitely see some Doctor and Master in Hohenheim and Father's histories.
As for Xerxes and Gallifrey, they are both sort of Atlantis archetypes in that they're both civilizations that became so arrogant as to think they could defy the laws of nature, and paid the price for it. :)
@TheWesternSage Yes, a very very terrible price. I also see some similarities between the King of Xerxes and Rassilon, both were arrogant to think they could mess with life itself.
Xerxes and Gallifrey lost much and gained NOTHING!
I love this, I made a fma amv haha but mine had words. Um but this one really made me feel better about my video. Oh and not saying mine is better!!!! haha I mean like the simple effects he/she uses to make this video, made me see that lots of flashy effects are not needed to make a good amv! I was worried that since I never use effects other than fading and flashing that nobody would like it. So thaanks!!!
This is really just perfect. I can't think of a character that this song would fit with better, and the music just goes amazing with it. Though maybe I'm just biased seeing as I'm not only a huge Hohenheim fan but a huge Doctor who fan as well. ^_^
And Ed thinks he's gotta had it rough. Try seeing all your friends and family die before your eyes and everyone you knew since you were a child have their souls sucked out while you remain the same year after year at least he had Al and the Rockbell Gals.
@avatarkatara101 I don't really remember.... one was the recap episode in the middle of the series, and the other was the one where they go into hoho's backstory. There might be some other miscellaneous clips too... really I don't remember, I'm sorry.
Song fits Hohenheim very well because like the Doctor who is the last of the time lords, Hohenheim is the last of the Xerxesians who died in a great catastrophe.
@KylieDeeTastic Ed is a proud and prideful. He's mistaken that Hoho had anything to do with Trisha's death, she was sick and he didn't abandon them he was preparing the counter transmutation circle for the Promised Day.
DW has some great music, this is one of my faves and I think it fits Hoho really well, heck even the song's context in DW fits it pretty well. (Hoho/Father is sort of similar to Doctor/Master IMHO)
awesome
Sonic2332 2 months ago
I hey look, it's in the description. I should read those
papercamm 3 months ago
@papercamm hehe ^_^
TheWesternSage 3 months ago
I guess I'm not the only one who noticed
papercamm 3 months ago
Isn't this the music the played when The Doctor explained the origin of The Master?
papercamm 3 months ago
themusic is beautiful and the anime is slightly off but still wonderful please enter this amv into my competition i am holding at this very moment i will send u the one through a video post pls post your submition as a video respeonce I can definetly say by far this is the best one i have come across as of late
NaruNaruninetails 3 months ago
@NaruNaruninetails Sure why not? I'll enter, sounds like fun. Is the image really off though? huh... looks okay on my side of the 'nets, maybe it's a youtube thing? :-/ Glad you liked the video though :D
TheWesternSage 3 months ago
I'm so glad there's some people who know music that fits a video. great job! i love your vid
SuperScribblenauts12 5 months ago
Hohenheim´s attire really resembles the Doctor´s with the Coat and the tie.
Kryptonian250 5 months ago
This is a perfect representation.
Hohenheim is the Doctor.
Father is the Master.
They are all that's left of an ancient Society, and forever must clash. Bravo, I salute you for this masterpiece.
benjaythewhite 5 months ago 19
@benjaythewhite yeah that's I saw too, plus when Hohenheim was giving ed and al that look I could tell his how serious he was about stopping Father you know, like he wasn't looking at his kids to spite them but not let them die like the people of Xerxes did ya know what I mean?
723PanTera 2 months ago
Personal opinion but I think if you left there voices in the audio.
This is my favorite part of FMA with a great instrumental.
Great Video!
Bcdunlap 6 months ago
12,000th view Booyah!
g4m3mast3r 7 months ago
wow, i never would have thought this song would have made a great amv for FMAB but it is! you're very creative for thinking of putting the two together. it fits perfectly with hohenheim's story and this is the best amv for him i've seen!
valeriealicexo 7 months ago
Aww baby Al is so cute xD
Great amv Hoho was one of my fav characters
LuisAntony09 7 months ago
I normally don't like AMV's without words, but this is Just. So. Perfect. Hohenheim's back story in 3 minutes. So incredible!
rosebudmelissa 7 months ago
poor poor hohenheim
edwardsminesuckers 7 months ago
I love your name!!! TheWesternSage!
missharumomo 8 months ago
Oh my god....I saw this song coming the minute I saw Our Childhood, Our Home.....so totally epic, and appropriate for this video....
Father/Homonculu=The Master
Van Hohemhiem/Slave 23=The Doctor
EPIC!!!
Lanayru19 8 months ago
REminds me of transformers. XD
weaselowo 8 months ago
@weaselowo ROFL Transformers? I'm afraid to ask but, how so? XD
TheWesternSage 8 months ago
@TheWesternSage i think they meant the music because i thought that too XD
missharumomo 8 months ago
@TheWesternSage in response to Weaselowo's comment this resembles Transformers "No sacrifice, No Victory"
SSjSylar 7 months ago
this video has no dislikes, at all.
mein gott
theangrysmurf12 8 months ago
The music matches perfectly with the video, excellent job. Im tired of seeing shitty heavy metal music random amvs.
LordDamarMar 8 months ago
I loved this. 10/10.
Only thing-In the description, it says the anime is FMA. It's not. It's FMA Brotherhood. Might want to clear that up ;P
JerkWarlord 9 months ago
@JerkWarlord In the US, yes, it is FMA: Brotherhood to distinguish it from the first FMA series, but in Japan it is known simply as FMA, the same as the first series. I think at the time I had decided to go with the original title. However, to avoid confusion I will change it, thanks :) Glad you liked the video.
TheWesternSage 8 months ago
@TheWesternSage Sure thing :p
And yeah, really-I loved this. I featured it on my channel, if that's OK with you. ^.^
JerkWarlord 8 months ago
@JerkWarlord Wow, thanks :D I don't think I've ever had a feature before ^_^ I'm really glad you liked it that much :D
TheWesternSage 8 months ago
@TheWesternSage Sure thing! :D It's easily the best FMA AMV I've ever seen. What I like best is it's simplicity-it's not overruled with effects or anything. It's just clips, for the most part, and it goes that well with the music. The story told is the best to tell from the whole series, too. (':
JerkWarlord 8 months ago
@JerkWarlord Part of that is probably because I only have windows movie maker to work with >_> But I've never been a big fan of distracting effects. But this video, I had in mind ever since I read the Xerxes chapters of the manga, (and that Doctor Who episode, not sure which came first) had to wait for Brotherhood to come out to finally make it, so I had plenty of time to plan it out. I'm a big Hohenheim fan, so I definitely agree with you about it being the best story to tell in the series. :D
TheWesternSage 8 months ago
@TheWesternSage YOU DID THIS ON WMM? HOLY FUCKER.
JerkWarlord 8 months ago
@JerkWarlord ROFL XD
TheWesternSage 8 months ago
@TheWesternSage *Pun intended*
JerkWarlord 8 months ago
@JerkWarlord XD
TheWesternSage 8 months ago
@TheWesternSage Can I ask your opinion. I found similarities between Gallifrey and Xerxes, both were advanced civilizations but there downfall began when they believed they could do something without consequences like the King of Xerxes sacrificing his own people for his own greed thereby sealing the fate of the entire country.
I also found some similarities between the Doctor/Master and Hohenheim/Father. Both were initially friends until they became enemies.
Kryptonian250 8 months ago
@Kryptonian250 Yeah, I totally agree with you on these points. I think it's part of the reason I wanted to make this video. I definitely see some Doctor and Master in Hohenheim and Father's histories.
As for Xerxes and Gallifrey, they are both sort of Atlantis archetypes in that they're both civilizations that became so arrogant as to think they could defy the laws of nature, and paid the price for it. :)
TheWesternSage 8 months ago
@TheWesternSage Yes, a very very terrible price. I also see some similarities between the King of Xerxes and Rassilon, both were arrogant to think they could mess with life itself.
Xerxes and Gallifrey lost much and gained NOTHING!
:)
Kryptonian250 8 months ago
Amazing job, very proffesionally done.
10/10
LordDamarMar 10 months ago
amazing job!
Spard87 11 months ago
i think its so sad @ 2:38 when hes crying in his family photo
homunculous100 11 months ago
I love this, I made a fma amv haha but mine had words. Um but this one really made me feel better about my video. Oh and not saying mine is better!!!! haha I mean like the simple effects he/she uses to make this video, made me see that lots of flashy effects are not needed to make a good amv! I was worried that since I never use effects other than fading and flashing that nobody would like it. So thaanks!!!
digimonFTW22456 1 year ago
I remember when he left and young Edward said: Al had to go potty lol
Tailsbot885 1 year ago
This is really just perfect. I can't think of a character that this song would fit with better, and the music just goes amazing with it. Though maybe I'm just biased seeing as I'm not only a huge Hohenheim fan but a huge Doctor who fan as well. ^_^
bobo754 1 year ago
And Ed thinks he's gotta had it rough. Try seeing all your friends and family die before your eyes and everyone you knew since you were a child have their souls sucked out while you remain the same year after year at least he had Al and the Rockbell Gals.
Kryptonian250 1 year ago 4
Excellent. Two of my favourite shows. Very well done.
shin1567 1 year ago
0:56 is incredibly well done.
Freak2121GTAF 1 year ago
I love a lot of Doctor Who soundtracks.
worldends08 1 year ago
What episode was when hohenheim was young
deadrose144 1 year ago
@deadrose144 Episode 40.
Freak2121GTAF 1 year ago
@Freak2121GTAF thanks so much :)
deadrose144 1 year ago
Comment removed
France16748 1 year ago
Anime never ceases to amaze me.
blacklight206 1 year ago
Even though I HATE brotherhood, this was very well done
GreedLin 1 year ago
Wonderful FMAB AMV! The music really sets up with the tone delivered in the show/clips. I hope more of these come along in the future! <3
MilleniumFoxMagician 1 year ago
Fuck,
Epic Doctor who Music
Plus FMA Brotherhood(Epic ANime)
=EPIC VIDEO,
Liked, and Favourited :D
SSjSylar 1 year ago 16
@SSjSylar Now there's some math I can get behind :D
Thanks for the fave ^_^
TheWesternSage 1 year ago 2
I love the origonal series way more... but I love this amv.
FullWrangaAlchemist9 1 year ago
The clips respond to the crescendos and diminunodos perfectly.
sasoriwenger 1 year ago
I have a question at the 2:59 mark. That's when Hoho discovers what Father is going to do?
Kryptonian250 1 year ago
@Kryptonian250 Yes, that's right :)
TheWesternSage 1 year ago
I like the interval at the end when hohenheim discovers what Father is up to. That he''s going to repeat everything.
Kryptonian250 1 year ago
awesome amv, favorited!!
worrybeunhappy 1 year ago
What episode did you use please help
avatarkatara101 1 year ago
@avatarkatara101 I don't really remember.... one was the recap episode in the middle of the series, and the other was the one where they go into hoho's backstory. There might be some other miscellaneous clips too... really I don't remember, I'm sorry.
TheWesternSage 1 year ago
Wow this is just fantastic!
You did a great job ;)
SulisDark 1 year ago
@SulisDark Thanks ^^
TheWesternSage 1 year ago
He's has got some pretty serious baggage
papercamm 1 year ago
@papercamm Indeed :(
TheWesternSage 1 year ago
the only thing bad about this video is that it only got 2,600 views...
TehRoflBot 1 year ago
@TehRoflBot LOL Thanks ^_^ (Although i'm pleased it's got that many :D)
TheWesternSage 1 year ago
I love this!! It's absolutely wonderful!!
HandbellOlive 1 year ago
@HandbellOlive Thanks :D
TheWesternSage 1 year ago
brilliant!
ghostxxxrebirth 1 year ago
@ghostxxxrebirth Thank you ^_^
TheWesternSage 1 year ago
Song fits Hohenheim very well because like the Doctor who is the last of the time lords, Hohenheim is the last of the Xerxesians who died in a great catastrophe.
Kryptonian250 1 year ago
@Kryptonian250 Exactly :) Poor near-immortal orphans :(
TheWesternSage 1 year ago
It's impossible to hate Hohenheim. He's such an amazing guy.
KylieDeeTastic 1 year ago 4
@KylieDeeTastic Exactly. It's just...just impossible to hate him. Ed's mistaken view of Hohenheim is just so sad.
HikariBun 1 year ago 3
@KylieDeeTastic Ed is a proud and prideful. He's mistaken that Hoho had anything to do with Trisha's death, she was sick and he didn't abandon them he was preparing the counter transmutation circle for the Promised Day.
Kryptonian250 1 year ago
this is amazing
you capture so much emotion in this
and after reading the manga and fma:brotherhood and now watchin this video i am now such a honehiem fan
GoldDragonflame 1 year ago
this is the fourth time ive seen this! love it!! Hoenheim is such a sweaty! it's a good video!!!
edwardsminesuckers 1 year ago
The song fit it so well!! It's hard to make a full-length AMV for Hoho because there's not too many clips to do so, but you did it!! Kudos for that!!
AdonaiAlive 1 year ago
that was great! Hohenheim is hands down my favorite character. Awesome!
GinnyStoleMyMan 1 year ago
I love this video, it's great. Thanks for making it. ^__^
Jennifer337 1 year ago
I like it.....
MultiSapphire21 1 year ago
Pretty good!
Hohenheim is one of my favorites :)
KylieDeeTastic 1 year ago
oh my goodness! This is amazing....
I am also trying to make a vid with pure music, and I am having trouble.
This is inspiring, this is art!
KhmyhVKB 1 year ago
OMG this was so ...... OMG
Lovemanga92 2 years ago
OMG I LOVE YOU MAKE MORE PLEASE :D
tinkxoxo13 2 years ago
Oh my goodness I can't stop watching this - I'm a massive Hoho/Trisha fan and I love the music from DW so this was a Godsend! AWESOME vid!
TheMeyrick 2 years ago 21
@TheMeyrick
Yay Hoho/Trish OTP :D
DW has some great music, this is one of my faves and I think it fits Hoho really well, heck even the song's context in DW fits it pretty well. (Hoho/Father is sort of similar to Doctor/Master IMHO)
Anyway glad you liked it ^^
TheWesternSage 2 years ago
Never watched Doctor Who, but this is a beautiful song. You match it up with the clips very well.
DasBier07 2 years ago 2
Sooooooo amazing !
Overmindead 2 years ago 2
i guess this video really remembers me hohenheim's life
and like the end so much....
cause hoho is one of my favorites fma characthers ^^
CHIBIflameAlchemist 2 years ago 12