Repeated personal attacks aimed at one particular artist is nothing but pathological manipulation of other viewers mind. Mind control/brainwashing. The worst and most
dangerous human behavior-according to my psychiatrist friend. Viewers continuously
increasing despite of the messy posting/spam flags. Encouraging to see that true beauty
@SKNinHawaii Dear ,still take a cold shower! PROMOTION is the manipulation , brainwashing and mind control! You take things out of proportion!It's YT, where LISTENERS are supposed to express their OPINIONS about ANY artist! If you like it or not, there's no artist in the world whom absolutely EVERYONE adores!If you are obsessed with PJ and just want to silence those who express that he is just a POP FALSETTIST,and not a CT shows how narrow-minded YOU are!You want to PRETEND everyone loves PJ!LOL
@adalgisa5510 I don't know the other countertenor's case, I see large spread of age amongst audiences at PhJ's concerts. Bowman, Michale Chance may ignore "ladies of certain age" who makes up the core audience but PhJ does not. He is always sincere, courteous and appreciative. Any singers who are arrogant and has little appreciation for the fans and audience are bound to show in their artistic expressions.
avout these microphones : saw him yesterday at the Berliner Philarmonie, no microphone. He has the vocal power to fill a hall, even behind him we could still understand nearly each word. partly due to, I must admit, the great room in itself.
The concert was marvellous, and he truly is a fantastic, and very sympathetic singer .
Is this man married? No? GOOD. >:D He's mine... heh heh >w< Gawd his voice is beautiful and he's certainly just as beautiful to look at while he sings. *le sigh* I wish every man could sing with a voice so soft, smooth, and clear.
This CD has just been nominated (as one of three) for best recording for "Les Victoires de la Musique Classique 2012" in France. Congratulations, and fingers crossed!
Great to know that the French musicians, artists and critics have such excellent discernment and taste!
@CaraPhilos Great news !! I have not heard such a beautiful Faure "Requiem" since
the Cluytens/De Los Angeles/Fischer-Dieskau. Finally we have one which deservedly can replace my worn-out LP by Cluytens !! Let's all wish it will receive the honor !! This CD is so well cast that not only PhJ is the shining star here but the baritone part is sung by German baritone who is considered as the successor of Fischer-Dieskau,
@carolineleiden I wonder who hurts whose feelings? Why is it relevant for this video that somebody sings in shower as a purpotedly CT and jokes that he can do it better than real great ones?! Let him post his "morning showers" on his channel then. It still doesn't prove that PJ is a countertenor and not a pop falsettist! And skninHawaii shouldn't take things our of proportion either...
@OedipusTyrannus I agree 100% with you. Obsessed, PhJ hater who believes she/he
is the only human who knows how the CT should be singing and posting hate-comment on the PhJ's major sites is simply sick and obsessed. I know which singers I like and dislike but like you, I don't go around posting how badly they sing. Her obsession to hate and attack Jaroussky went out of control here. Jaroussky is the most loved and successful CT in our time which we all know.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
@SKNinHawaii Dear, take a cold shower.Who is a PJ hater? Me?This cute pop falsettist who is 35 and who pretends that he is still an "innocent" virgin teenager playing with his tender fingers and making touching faces to entertain such primitive old grannies who can't tell serious art from pop doesn't deserve such strong emotions from me as hatred!He has about 2 500 videos on YT.Posting that he is not a CT but a FALSETTIST on SEVERAL videos is out of control?LOL He really has his "troll club"LOL
If I'd read your comments here first, I'd wanted to hear the music even more. There's much controversy here, so it must be at least impressive. I love impressive art. It is not important at all if it's beautiful. Beauty is only one colour on your emotional pallet.
PJ is a monument. He can make you love, he can make you cry, he can make you hate him or laugh. If you like that, you will not be disappointed.He can chase you all around your emotional spectrum, if you let him. If not, why bother?
@ewoutvm1 I agree. But there should be freedom of expression on YT. It was made to give people opportunity to express freely their OPINIONS about any artist if they like him or her or dislike. Do you think it's OK to make YT a circus appealing to everybody not to express THEIR opinions but only to vote against somewhat serenaluce's comments and spread lies that arpeggio is also me? If PJ attracts such brainless morons like CaraPhilos and JaRoWie he really deserves to have his "troll club"!
@OedipusTyrannus Ah,you put a lock on personal mails.Very wise.I guess it's your grandfather's advice too.Check Lemos.Do you think that you can sing like that in your shower too?Do you think that this REAL countertenor emotional singing at its best with full and round voice,very MANLY is worse than PJ's cheap pop one dimentional fake teenage bleating,and it's because of Spanos's fault that somewhat serenaluce put his picture on her channel? This is a REAL COUNTERTENOR. PJ is just a falsettist!
Why are people here feeding the troll "serenaluce"/"Arpeggio" again by answering, wasting your precious life time reading complete nonsense? Just give them the thumbs down, and their idiocies will silently disappear.
@CaraPhilos When can YOUR idiocy simply disappear that EVERYBODY can't love your precious baby PJ,and that there should be freedom of expression?!Stop rushing and barking at everybody like a chain dog who criticizes him!There are many normal people with ears and brains who can hear his WEAK POP voice of a falsettist,but they just don't want to deal with his crazy brainwashed ZOMBIES like you.But Cara, if you want to "kill" everybody who dislikes PJ it still doesn't mean that EVERYBODY loves him!
@OedipusTyrannus Also, if you like it or not, but music and all ART has always been a battle field where all kinds of OPINIONS clashed for all the history of mankind,as there's not only pure MUSIC involved but MARKET, a lot of money, power, intrigues, getting into beds to the "right people" pleasing lovers of those people who can give roles and nowadays record with the best orchestras,etc.If nobody ARGUED perhaps we'd still have castrati.You want just to crush OPPOSITION for PJ and PRETEND?
@OedipusTyrannus So, dear "greatest shower countertenor in the world", thank you for your POINT here. You dislike these singers but you don't go to their videos?Good boy! Do you want a PRIZE for it? You want my positive ratings and comments on you singing naked but supposedly with your balls on as you declare yourself just great in ANY kind of repertoir unlike PJ, in exchange for your not criticizing Netrebko? Where's PERSONAL attack?If PJ is so weak to read about his VOICE let him stay at home!
@OedipusTyrannus Dear, please DO upload your morning showers and show at last the whole world how a true countertenor can sing any kind of repertoir!I'm sure that you sing in shower with your balls on and much better than the only pop falsettist in the world PJ whom artificially made a countertenor and coronated as the best one of all time to whom his troll club with their president madam JaRoWie appeal to kneel and kiss his feet!Let them kiss your clean feet after shower instead!LOL Bravissimo!
@18aaronjames Mamma mia, how badly you are explaining your feelings
l am not going to answer to such coarseness.How poor you are and not able to listen to this wonderful countertenor, you cannot understand, with this dirty mind. By the way Faure wrote , soprano...... did you knew him maybe ?Or may be you cannot read....
@18aaronjames What's the freaking argument? You think all those critics who kiss PJ's ass or criticize somebody can do it better?! They are just paid to sell better the "product"! It's their profession. But this is YT, where there are no titles and authorities, and all LISTENERS are supposed to express FREELY their opinion, and not be intimidated by PJ's brainwashed ZOMBIES like you! Can you dance better or worse than ballet dancers? So, you can't comment who does is BETTTER,and who is bad?!
я слушаю филиппа и вижу его лицо ,а за спиной большие,как у ангела крылья,только почему-то серебристые.я никогда не видела ангелов,но думаю,что они бывают такие и этот неземной голос,который лился и лился откуда-то сверху и серебристые крылья медленно шевелились. потом еще раз взмахнули и сложились за спиной ,голос медленно расстаял и я вернулась на землю. это было волшебство!никогда никому бы не поверила,что такое возможно,пока не испытала бы сама.божественно!!!!!!!!!,
@kosoglazaya1 Gospodi, da u vas uzhe galyutsinatsii! Eto navernoe, vash pervyi muzhik, poyushii fal'tsetom, kotorogo vy uslyshali v zhizni. A oni na mnogikh na pervykh porakh okazyvayut sil'noe vpechatlenie, no potom eto obychno prokhodit. On - voobshe nikakoi ne kontrtenor, a popsovyi fal'tsetist, kotorogo tol'ko promotion i sdelala kontrtenorom.Vy kogda-nibud' slyshali, kak angely poyu? Ya nikogda:-).Angel'skoe penie da, no u zhivykh lyudei kryl'ev net!:-) Sovetuyu kholodnyi dush prinyat'!:-)
Hi everyone. It's useless arguing with a certain user here, because “PREJUDICE, not being founded on reason, cannot be removed by argument”. And while you THINK that you are defending Philippe, IN FACT you are only feeding a troll. I thank you for thinking twice before you respond to certain comments.
@VI0L0NS Can you define first what is PREJUDICE? Where's any PREJUDICE concerning PJ on this video? Nobody discusses here his private life, possible sexual orientation like on many Cencic's videos, that CTs and falsettists are inferior voices, etc...So, think twice before writing this nonsense. No demacratic society can function without OPPOSITION. EVERYBODY can't like the same POPULAR stuff as for POP FANS! You can crush opposition but it doesn't mean that "Everybody loves Jaroussky"!
@serenaluce "No, democratic society can function without opposition." As if Jaroussky were on the brink of being elected to political office and Serenaluce was leading the campaign of his political rival. If her idol Nicholas Spanos is following this he's probably getting a good, but rather embarrassed, giggle out of it all.
@larrydonguy Democratic society can't function with opposition. If it's crushed, forbidden, it's already a fascist regime. You should know it before writing this nonsense. YT is created as a democratic intutition where all OPINIONS are welcomed. Poticial compaign? Are you crazy. I asked you:"Do YOU think that PJ is POPULAR"? Why can't you asnwer this simple question about PJ? It's relevant! Is it an insult to him or to you? Don't be demagogical! Answer my direct question first about JAROUSSKY!
@larrydonguy Honey, I'm waiting. I reply to you right away, but it takes you DAYS to think over YOUR next reply to ME which doesn't characterize you as a worthy adversary to me!Your gastromonical problems and taking blood thinner obviously doesn't help your brain activity.What elections you mean?It's a MUSICAL video on YT, a democratitic institution to express OPINIONS.I have no idols!Only favourite singers.Compare PJ with Lesne.ANSWER at last Is PJ POPULAR?Lesne POPULAR?Are you moralizing here?
So...it is agreed upon that the only thing that matters for a singer is the sound of his voice? Than any criticism should also revolve around his voice. That is fair.
Not his looks, not his image, not his hobbies, not his behaviour, not his promotion, not his extracurricular activities. Just his voice. The sound of it, the quality, the technique, the emotion, the expression.
Aha, people are wasting their time with the troll "serenaluce" still. I am sure you would have much better things to do.
What I would really be interested in, by the way is why this has been posted by EMI but is not being watched? It is not possible to post critical remarks at the videos of Angela Gheorgiu posted by EMI. Or at the EMI main site here. What can we conclude from this?
@CaraPhilos And if CaraPhilos isn't a troll please be so kind to help people to conclude why is this video was posted by EMI but not being watched by EMI?Or by whom else? There are enough views here like on any other POP SINGER's video? You want MILLIONS of views? For that it should be not Faure, even not any imitation of baroque as the majority are just afraid of this word alone, but even more primitive pop like with words "Sex, women, drugs" or "baby if you give it to me I'll give it to you"..
I do not like PJ just because of the promotional machinery that surrounds him. I knew nothing about him when I first heard his voice, but I was completely enraptured by it within the first few bars.
I do not care if it is pop or classical, I do not care if he is famous or not, I do not care what he looks like, I do not care if the music is profane or liturgical: he has a marvellous, pure, clear and very natural sound that I find to be most pleasing and very comforting, calming and soothing.
@carolineleiden Dear Caroline, you sound like the only normal PJ's fan here who expresses ONE's own opinion on his singing and why you like him. All the rest are just obsessed ignorant people who can't stand any criticism, any OPINIONS other than just worshipping PJ like an angel,God, and if somebody thinks differently declare them TROLLS with their hysterical yells to fight them! Madam JaRoWie on her channel BLOCKS everybody who just says that his version is bad and there are BETTER versions!..
@carolineleiden I am totally in tune with you. I don't care who says what about
PJ. His musicality, his voice, singing, style, repertoire which I like very much. I don't care if this singing is pop Faure and not academic Faure, or his image or presentation
disturbs some people, I like his voice and singing above all the countertenors.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I see no vulgar comments by either serenaluce or arpeggio1358, but then you Jaroussky fans have removed some their comments so that nobody can judge for themselves. In what has been left, there is no vulgarity, only reasonable disagreement on the merits of Jaroussky's voice. I believe Yt is democratic, and thus comments should not be removed simply because they disagree with a singer's fans. You Jaroussky fans are being most unfair.
@pucciniverdi777 I am responding to you because you sound to be a fair person. I don't think you have read all the comments serenaluce and arpeggio1358 has been posting from the beginning which are mean and tasteless, totally unrelated to musicality of the singer and no artists should be subjected to that kind of comments.
Whose voice, artistry, repertoire you like or don't like is totally a subjective matter.
their non constructive, non musical personal bashing and not non
@SKNinHawaii Expressing SUBJECTIVE opinion on an artist's work without personal insults that he is just a POP singer, not a classical CT with all 3 well-developed registers but singing only in FLAT voice on HIGH notes and some middle which qualifies his as a typical FALSETTIST like Vitas is being MEAN and TASTELESS, and your comments imposing YOUR OPINION on other people are OBJECTIVE, TASTEFUL and KIND? Expressing OPINION about the VOICE is bashing the artist?
@serenaluce This is the first time you ever made sensible and understandable criticism
on PJ without mean, personal insults. I don't believe attacking the artist with insults
when you have legitimate criticism. Any intelligent artists and their fans are able to
accept that. When your criticism goes off the line and become unfair insults it is no longer healthy nor constructive. By the way Kowalski is growing on me. I like to hear your opinion on his YT site. Not here.Thanks
@serenaluce Yes! Let's be fair to Serenaluce. She has expressed no personal insults toward Jaroussky other than calling him a girl. And her "SUBJECTIVE opinion" of Jaroussky's singing has always been expressed in a respectful manner, such as the time she used the words "pretends, fake, cheap tricks, empty, shallow, sugary, artificial, 'castrated', and without any soul" all in the same comment about his singing.
@larrydonguy Friend Larry Donkey,you just make a bigger ASS of your DONKEY all the time.Do you think that writing here about your gastronomical problems and taking blood thinner is RELEVANT to PJ's singing?You even can't STAND him saying that ALL COUNTERTENORS SOUND LIKE WOMEN?Is it me and not YOU calling him a GIRL?I comment on his IMAGE,and my FINGERS with MANICURED LONG NAILS are SIMILAR to his!I give my reasons that he is NOT a CT but FALSETTIST.Falsettists are LEGITIMITE too,can beFEMININE!
@larrydonguy With your taking blood thinners it's BAD for you to be involved in discussions which you even don't understand!Watch Disney catoon films with SKINinHawaii's grandchildren if you don't have your own and relax!Who says here that for a MAN looking feminine is so AWFUL?But a REAL countertenor can't SOUND feminine as it's the closest substitute to CASTRATI who sang like MANLY men and presented HEROIC men on stage.It's for FALSETTISTS to be feminine.Answer me: do you think PJ is POPULAR?
@tuffy942 Dear, I'm offensive? How did I offend YOU? You work in cooperation with madam JaRoWie blocking everybody who criticizes PJ for doing only POP falsettist's stuff and presenting it as what a classical CT typically does. His "Carmen" is pure pop. He only can sing something like that in shows "Just for laughs". Scholl and Cencic can do similar just for fun, but they have full and round real CTs voices to be taken SERIOUSLY, but PJ is only FALSETTIST with his FLAT voice.YOU sound miserable!
@larrydonguy Larry,what's up with you?Why are you hiding from me?You speculate what I could have meant concerning PJ's looking feminine,lie that I insult him and call him a girl though I never call a man a woman or a girl.It's only your sexual fantasies about what the other people think. PJ is just not CT and belongs to POP FALSETTIST category like Vitas,Klaus Nomi,Artem Semenov.Vitas is just not to my liking, but how come I don't swoon from Nomi's and Semenov's long painted nails?They're GIRLS?
@larrydonguy Mind,that I only comment on what I see on the video before my eyes.If it's presented in the HONEST way as "classics in POP INTERPRETATIONS" or milder "classics in modern interpretations" I can compare PJ with Vitas who also e.g. sings Ave Maria in his pop manner or tenor's aria "La donna e' mobile" pretending that castrati sang like that but it still doesn't make him a REAL operatic CT,but it's stupid to compare him with e.g. the same Cencic.Simple question:" YOU think PJ POPULAR?"
@SKNinHawaii I can't see all of serenaluce's and arpeggio1358's comments because you people have seen to it that they have been removed. From what I've seen, their comments are reasonable. They may be strong opinions, but they are not nasty or vulgar. If they don't like Jaroussky's voice, they are entitled to that opinion.
@SKNinHawaii Now you are removing my comments just because I said I saw no vulgar comments from serenaluce and arpeggio. I must say that this is childish in the extreme. Do you think that others who come to this video can't see for themselves that much has been removed and won't wonder what you people are so afraid of?
@pucciniverdi777 I have not removed your comments nor any one's comments. I delete from my e-mail box as I do all the unnecessary mails. I am personally not afraid of anything and there are nothing to be afraid of. I do not feel it is norm when a person dislike certain artist and post negative and personal insults on many of his YT sites repeatedly. That is beyond posting one's opinion or comments. Comments should not be personal insults.
@SKNinHawaii Dear, I say it again: there's an option on YT REPLY to give people opportunity to DISCUSS. Show me where it says that it's against YT policy that users have to reply only to comments addressed personally to them? What PERSONAL INSULTS I've ever expressed to PJ as a PERSON? I don't know him personally and don't want to know! Have I ever written with whom he SLEEPS, what he does IN BED, any GOSSIPS?He is offering to LISTENERS this kind of IMAGE ON STAGE. I only comment on his VOICE!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
@SKNinHawaii Saying that Jaroussky sings in a pop style and not a classical or opera style is not a personal insult. Nor is saying one doesn't like little boy looks on a man. These are comments. I've even read the removed commentsa, and they're not personal attacks. They're just comments that these posters don't like his voice and feel that he should stick to pop music.
@pucciniverdi777 I couldn't agree more with you here. Another person with ears and brains with real musical knowledge and understanding. Otherwise it's just ridiculous what PJ's ignorant crazy obsessed fans write here as they don't understand at all the difference between a true opera singer and a POP SINGER like PJ who just performs classics in his easy to swallow pop manner. I guess for those who thinks that POP is an insult I have to explain that it only means POPULAR! Where are trolls here?
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
@SKNinHawaii But there has been no tasteless bashing, just opinions. You seeit as bashing because you can't stand hearing the slightest negative comment about him..
@SKNinHawaii Oh dear,you just talk nonsense: there's an option on YT as REPLY button,not buttons on PJ's shirt which in your IRRELEVANT comment are about to POP OUT as a proof only in YOUR ignorant OPINION of this BIG voice.Opera singers are supposed to sing with their VOICE,not their BUTTONS on their shirts.Pavarotti had a BIGGER real OPERATIC voice and much bigger frame. Following your logic he is much GREATER,so all the buttons should have BURST and all his clothes distroyed!LOL It's Related?
I'm not recommending this because I think one's criticism should be honest, but were you to post negative criticism of Serenaluce's and Arpeggio's favorite young countertenor, Nicholas Spanos, on his fans' You-tube sites, you would be subject to all sorts of nasty name calling. I know because I was.
@larrydonguy Dear,be HONEST yourself first.You are just a mean creature making up stuff because you have no MUSICAL argument either here or on Spanos's video. You just stalk arpeggio, that's how you found any COUNTERTENOR video at all. Shall I remind you what you wrote about ALL countertenors? That they ALL sound like "weeping widows", who knows them at all and that men shouldn't sound like that and can't be taken SERIOUSLY in opera.You called PJ "broccoli".And you complain about nasty names?LOL
@serenaluce Actually I said specifically that SPANOS sounded like a "weeping widow," though perhaps this tone is endemic to lower range contraltos and countertenors. I said that Jaroussky who sings higher and more lightly had less of this quality.For someone who likes neither broccoli nor spinach but between the two slightly prefers broccoli, Jaroussky is my broccoli. Some people love broccoli. Some love spinach. Some love both.
@larrydonguy So,why don't you comment on VEGETABLES and tell what is YOUR favourite VEGETABLE as all vegetables of the cabbage family give you GAS!OK, Spanos only to YOU sounds not like weeping widow but reminded you somehow your touching early childhood when you heard madam Schumann-Heink on your mother's album who was a very low FEMALE contralto, and no CTs either Spanos singing closer to SOPRANO, or even PJ don't have similar quality in their voices!You said:"ALL CTs can't be taken SERIOUSLY"
@serenaluce Sorry, no time to analyze your latest offering, Serenaluce. I'm off to do a concert. You see, unlike you, I'm actually paid, if rather modestly, to sing.
@larrydonguy At last please do something useful and go sing wherever you like instead of writing all this ignorant NONSENSE on YT about the whole voice category of CTs who according to you should be still discriminated as for people with not sensitive ears they superficially sound like WOMEN and can't be taken SERIOUSLY in this "high gender stereotyping"! Your words, not mine! If you sing as e.g. a baritone, doesn't mean that modification of MALE voice higher makes it "a bastard voice"! Be paid!
@larrydonguy serenaluce tells the truth. You made nasty comments about allCT's, saying they sound like women and inferring that they're all gay.You made fun of them, and you dare to criticize us, you bigot.
@arpeggio1358 I see that your comment has been flagged as spam, Arpeggio; unfairly I think so I'll answer it. I said that countertenors sound like women because THEY DO SOUND LIKE WOMEN. Which doesn't mean that YOUR precisely tuned ear can't tell the difference, but to the average listener they sound like women. I would suggest that YOU were the one INFERRING that I thought that all CT's were gay or gave a rat's ... if they were.
@larrydonguy Dear, it's YOU who is a real TROLL here if you persist that ALL countertenors DO SOUND LIKE WOMEN. So, your precious PJ included, of course, no matter if he sounds lighter or heaver. I wonder why his crazy fans don't mark YOUR comments as SPAM and don't call YOU troll. But I'll tell you why - because his fans are stone deaf like you, and don't give a rat's ass if he sounds like a man or a woman because he SOUNDS like a SEXLESS creature!Do you agree that PJ is POPULAR?Can you answer?
@larrydonguy PS: Also, as you should have seen by now, Arpeg, Your partner-in-arms, Serenaluce, has made all sorts comments not so much implying as outright saying that Jaroussky is a boy-girl. You might take a(nother?) look at the insults she has hurled his way.
@larrydonguy Dear, what insults if PJ HIMSELF chose such an image of a "boy forever" who doesn't want to grow up, who only plays with his soft tender, meticulously manicured fingers with long polished nails to disguise his empty voice which sound technicians only AMPLIFY and video technicians draw the listeners' attention to his so called "singing hands"where a true OPERA singer is supposed to sing with his VOICE! I have almost the same FINGERS with long nails as woman, WEIRD?Answer my GUESTION!
@larrydonguy Answer my question , do you call PJ POPULAR, and what do YOU think about it? Also, speak only for YOURSELF and don't imply that the other people say if you don't understand at all what it's all about as you confessed YOURSELF that you know NOTHING about CT voice. You only are STALKING arpeggio and found this video by ACCIDENT.What can you say about such REAL CTS as Cencic, Lesne, Lemos, Asawa, Daniels, Scholl, Kowalski, Esswood,Wong? Analyze their differences instead of envying Arp!
@serenaluce Sorry, but neither my health (I'm on a blood thinner) nor my palate can tolerate too many green vegetables. I've listened to a few of those folks, quite enough for my taste. I now see that Arpeggio also criticizes Jaroussky for being feminine. Isn't criticizing a countertenor for being feminine a bit like criticizing an interior decorator for the same? Surely it's not a disqualifying trait.
one like is very very subjective matter. Writing false information about the artist with vulgar
tasteless manner is nothing but showing where you come from and what your intention is.
Despite of your ugly spamming, viewers has been increasing constantly. It would be wonderful if viewers doesn't have to read all your rubbish and simply enjoy PJ's singing.
@SKNinHawaii You contradict yourself again.You say that everything is subjective. What false information arpeggio and me purportedly wrote about PJ here? What vulgarity?Artists are public figures and supposed to be JUDGED by listeners. They make their living by performances,and if nobody JUDGES what they do ON STAGE, they'd better look for another job! All POP SINGERS have many views of their videos, much more than REAL OPERA SINGERS!Who doesn't allow you to enjoy it? It's FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION!
@Schizophreniac17 ignore 'them' the multi troll..she is not at all a well woman..add to that, that she is quite old enough to know better and find more gainful pursuits :)
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
@Schizophreniac17 Alas, I feel sorry that the PJ fans actually see magic in his voice. Have you ever listened to a real operatic countertenor like Spanos, Taylor, Esswood, Asawa, Scholl? Please listen to them and maybe you will hear the difference.
@arpeggio1358 what is your intention writing un-constructive rubbish time after time? PJ fans is not going to turn away from him because you and serenaluce are crusading to educate us PJ is over promoted POP CT, uses MC and on and on. Did you think this video was from concert? This is a recording session. What are you talking about.
Have you ever been to Pj, Scholl, Asawa, Esswood, Taylor concert? I have been to three of their concerts and I like PJ the best.
@SKNinHawaii Dear, you are just paranoid.Who do you think tries to change the world on PJ's videos?Take a cold shower. Enjoy your POP. Are you that easily suggested and can turn against your sugary pop idol only if somebody says that he is pop? Do you think that a pop singer is a swearword like a bastard? Then it's only YOUR problem! What's so bad in performing classical stuff in POP manner? It just should be presented in the HONEST way. I like many POP singers but please don't call them OPERA!
@SKNinHawaii There was nothing vulgar in my original comment, but now nobody will be able to read it since you had it removed. Advancing your own agenda by removing comments is chidish and slants everything your way.
@Schizophreniac17 There is a saying"The beauty is in the eyes of beholder". I'd like to add to it ears, a brain and a heart. Those who don't have that cannot appreciate the beauty. They are obsessed by their own negativeness and what worse, they are vulgar, malicious, jealous and simply trying to hack this site or other PJ's site. Useless and dirty acts but she thinks she was trying to be humorous and we take her too seriously. So don't feed her malicious sense of humor !!
@SKNinHawaii Also, be consistent yourself. You say that "Beauty is in the eye of the beholder". If you find it beautiful, I just find "sweet snort", sugarly empty shallow singing always like a singing machine performing the same piece slightly modified according to a different tune without paying any attention to the style and image. Now you try to preach whohas brains and who can understand THE BEAUTY! So, what DIRTY ACTS? To express one's OPINION? I don't spread any gossips about PJ! Wake up!
@Schizophreniac17 You want to fight all the persons who just have a different OPINION about all the artists' work, commenting only on what he or she does ON STAGE? If somebody doesn' appreciate what YOU appreciate you are just intolerant? How do you want to fight such people with different OPINIONS? Exterminate them? Kill them all? Don't you know that all the history of MUSIC there've been ARGUMENTS what it should be. Otherwise there would be no progress.SCHIZOPHRENIAC is a true expert! LOL
strange comments here..a singer using their chest ??? it is the diaphragm which is the singers 'bellows'..still...one can be moved by many things..there are some who find lady gaga a wonder..good luck to them..
@nordischbaby Baby,of course, it's none of my business why you watched this video at all. But your channel is not available. It means that you have something to hide. A bit strange as everybody on YT is anomymous in any case if they are not artists promoting themselves and giving their real names. But at least I commented here about RELEVANT stuff that I find PJ's interpretation not Faure in the academic manner but in pure POP MANNER. You wanted only to know if somewhat serenaluce heard PJ live?
@nordischbaby Dear, everything here on YT is only OPINIONS and nothing more! Do you think that anonymous users who write that they toured with PJ and have the PROOF that he never uses any mike live are more credible on YT? You have no more questions to them? You are sure that they are RIGH?! What about your OWN opinion about this video? You said nothing if you like it or not... You are only an INTERROGATOR here believing that obsessed TROLL JaRoWie who stalks PJ all over the world? LOL
@nordischbaby Thank God, no. I am not gonna waste my money to listen to overpromoted commercial singers who only entertain people with their superficial vocal special effects like PJ with his sugary sounds without any attachment to any character or image or Bartoli with her clucking hen technique entertaining her audience with her ugly singing! Sorry, there's YT now.I can listen to artists and decide who's worth it! I have my own head and not BRAINWASHED by PROMOTION!You can decide for YOURSELF!
@nordischbaby From the sound of his voice in his recordings and from videos on YT.Everywhere PJ's voice sounds artifcial,manipulated and amplified.He has a very small voice with just nauseatically sweet trills with which sound technicians work.From his recordings it's obvious that he doesn't have a proper CT technique as he only superficially touches his vocal cords and uses very primitive pop coloratura.From his videos it's seen he doesn't use his CHEST.How can he sound loud enough with Cencic?
@serenaluce I understand that you never heard PJ in real. Making all those comments
based on the video you watch? Pity on you. Actually his voice is very large, and he uses chest so much so that I was afraid his shirts is too tight and the button will pop out !! I still don't understand why you are so malicious about him. His popularity? being so well promoted? being able to sing in many first class concert halls? Audience love him and he has all the qualifications and more.
@SKNinHawaii Dear,can't you read?Who is malicious?I just said that PJ sings not in academic manner, it's not classical Faure, and he is not a CT, but just a falsettist who performs classical stuff in POP MANNER! Also, pity on you as your ears and eyes are bigger than his voice. Other people who heard him live say that his voice is very SMALL. If you saw bottons on his shirt about to pop out, it just means that he needs a bigger shirt! LOL Audience loves him?So what?People love him as POP SINGER!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
@SKNinHawaii Give me a break! If his voice was really big, he wouldn't need a microphone all the time. He always has one, even in his live opera performances, he sounds amplified..hidden mic? PJ is a pop falsettist, not a real operatic countertenor. Also you confuse popularity with greatness. Popular doesn't equal great. Most people can't even hear the difference between a pop crossover singer and a real opera singer.
@pedrofribeiro Trying to criticize an artist on video and CD only is very unjust. Have you ever heard Bartoli on stage? She has magnetic power and personally that audience are pulled to her. Artist who can give bliss of happiness and deep involvement to satisfy audience's varied musical background are the real artist and any negative quality you mention are trivial matter. Great artist has both great musicality and human appeal to the audience and Bartoli sure has all that.
@SKNinHawaii Oh, really give us a break with your whining and complaining. Do you have nothing else to do? No obligations before your grandchildren as a good grandmother? If you are such a nervious easily getting upset old lady who takes a sedative if any of your favourite singers are criticized ask your doctor first if YT is right for you.There's NO artist in the world whom ABSOLUTELY everyone ADORES and nobody criticizes!Get over it.To listen and CRITICIZE is JUST,and you want just to SILENCE!
@SKNinHawaii You make comments about the size of his chest and we're supposed to believe all you're interested in just his voice?You sound pretty obsessed.I never wrote anything vulgar, but since you and your friends have removed my comments, nobody will ever know the truth.
I simply cannot believe how this discussion has gone completely out of control these last two pages. Come on people: how about a little good taste and common decency from now on, to match the beautiful music?
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
@carolineleiden Actually, really. Where do people see the end of the world? They admire PJ. They can just ignore comments and if they want so much to discuss can say:"Even if PJ isn't a typical classically trained CT, I like his VOICE, enjoy his singing and I don't care if it's pop or not!" That's it! I actually first of all replied to my YT friend MrPapageno who shared this video with me and asked MY OPINION as it's the only video where he found this pop singer PJ not too bad! Why this fuss?!
@carolineleiden Hi Caroline, I'm Pilar from PJ's forum. I agree with you. PLEASE DON'T FEED THE TROLLS. I saw arpeggio1358 and serenaluce in other PJ's videos, I guess they are crazy in love with him and feel frustated. Otherwise I can't understand why are they spending their time listening to him if they despite Jaroussky talent so much. So, let's enjoy Mr. Jaroussky gifted performances and FORGET ABOUT THOSE TROLLS!
@78fufluns Oh my God, if somebody dislikes the singer who is just overpromoted and people are brainwashed about his greatness, blinded by PROMOTION you call such people TROLLS?! By the way, you think that only now someone dares to criticize artificially made "great artists"? All history of music there've been ARGUMENTS about perfomances. At time of castrati if you claim that PJ is a real CT who is closest to them they BOOED in the theatre.Farinelli told a NOBLE that he is an ASS and has no ears!
@78fufluns So, for YOU Farinelli himself is a TROLL! Handel himself argued if castrato voice has the right to exist or not as it's caused by butchery,and not natural modification of the voice! In the theatre "De la noblesse" they first BOOED at FARINELLI as he began to perform DIFFERENT kind of music to which those nobles were not used and wanted just soulless virtuosity! Great FARINELLI and HANDEL were definitely TROLLS too in your understanging! But to say that I'm in LOVE with "baby PJ"...LOL
@78fufluns I don't waste my time with guys who look like little boys. PJ isn't my type.I prefer men who look like men. In love with PJ, you must be joking.People like you who can't stand having anything negative written about their favorite singer are the real trolls. Also,grownups can have a diffference of opinion without turnig nasty.
@78fufluns Are you going to trot out "jealous", "Bet you can't sing as well as he can", "hater" and all the other excuses pop opera fans use to discredit people who disagree with them?
Actually they are not. arpeggio, for example, USUALLY expresses her opinions without vulgarity or personal insults. I find both singers quite talented but not to my taste. If you prefer a man who sounds like an exceptional budding soprano you'll like Jaroussky. If you prefer a man who sounds like a seasoned contralto (Madame Schumann-Heink?) or mezzo you'll like Spanos. I prefer men who remind me of men. There are plenty who don't like either for you folks to argue violently among yourselves.
@JaRoWi1647 Couldn´t agree with you more. People, please stop reacting to the TROLL "serenaluce"! (By the way, those who always agree with "her" probably are the same person.)
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
@CaraPhilos Actually,I respect much more those who argue with me, even insult me PERSONALLY but who reply to ME expressing their OPINIONS like me about artists and users.It's more HONEST and more appropriate as there are only anonymous USERS on YT who are supposed to speak only for themselves and express only THEIR opinion and not hysterically appeal to the whole world like such cowards as YOU and PJ's uploader madam JaRoWie who can't even reply to ME!Prove that I have more accounts and not YOU!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
@FestiveSpirit Of course, she is right on this point as her precious protege prince Charming PJ is a TROLL in the CT world, and she knows it too well, because she is just afraid of the truth, that's why she is so pissed off at whistle-blowers, and blocks people the next minute after they dare express that e.g. "after listening to Cencic PJ's version is so shallow. Bravo Cencic!" Or "It's not Tamerlano! PJ is just not made for dramatic roles"... Why don't you ask HER how much PJ pays HER?
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
@ErosAdInfinitum Actually,it's not ME who began this stupid conversation hoW much a somewhat artist whose only PICTURE his or her fans only have on their channels can pay.It's a kinder garten's level to see a PICTURE and ask how much this PICTURE pays me? Very interesting position: if I admire some artists I already can't express MY OPINIONS that the others are not classical though their promoters present them just for money but POP like Bocelli,Brightman,PJ?Licking ASS isn't PJ's GREATNESS!LOL
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
@ErosAdInfinitum So,apparently you are trying to say that it's not PJ but madam JaRoWie herself , "dear Janochka" pays her OWN money to lick PJ's ASS! Did I understand you right? It's such a privilege for some of his uploaders to pay to LICK HIS ASS? In any case, licking ass for some benefits and making money on PROMOTION has nothing to do with the ART OF SINGING! It's no proof of somebody's greatness! What you write if you are not an interested person who is paid too is a SIGN of OBSESSION! LOL
@JaRoWi1647 I have so much fun reading your "innocent rubbish".I wonder if YOU are not TROLL,and PJ is a real "greatest countertenor in the world" and "we should kneel before him for revival of true baroque" as promotion claims,and I read on one Russian site and also this special Russian idiotism that PJ is a great artist because Jaroussky means "Ja roussky" I'm Russian, so many Russians are just proud of anything because they are also Russians why do you block just for prefering Cencic to PJ?
Once again, you have totally missed the point. Good job!
I wonder why it's always so painfully obvious to everyone (except you) that the only reason I would point fingers at you especially is your prolific Jaroussky-bashing. Still waiting for a clear reason from you, eight comments later. Perhaps you can finally grace us with a response~
(Violahen8, unlike you, is a normal person that comments once or twice, so I don't question her integrity. The same cannot be said for you.)
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
@FestiveSpirit Bashing? Are you serious? YOU have totally missed the point. Saying that it's not CLASSICAL ART but POP isn't any insult and bashing! But it should be presented in the HONEST way! PJ is a PRETENDER in the CT world as he doesn't belong to it but to POP ART. His artistic occupation is CLASSICS IN POP INTERPRETATIONS! PERIOD! I'm not stalking him or bashing as a PERSON! But I have the right to express my OPINION to what he does ON STAGE!And you just admit that he is POP if you normal
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
@rjvtylhjdcrfz A ty voobshe sama kto takaya? Pochemu ty mne tykaesh'? Eto chto tvoi kanal? Ty eshe ne zametila, chto YT otkryta dlya vsekh! Vot zagruzhai PJ na svoem kanale i blokirui vsekh, kto khotya by sravnivaet versiyu Cencic, nastoyashego kontrtenora s pop versiei PJ kak madam JaRoWe1647 na svoem kanale, ne pozvolyaya nikakoi svobody mnenii, i komandui tam, chto esli komu-to tvoya popsa PJ ne nravitsya, to pust' sginut ottuda nepolnotsennye, a zdes' ne vystupai, primitivnaya dura!
une voix douce et superbe j'adore
danydane42 6 hours ago
Repeated personal attacks aimed at one particular artist is nothing but pathological manipulation of other viewers mind. Mind control/brainwashing. The worst and most
dangerous human behavior-according to my psychiatrist friend. Viewers continuously
increasing despite of the messy posting/spam flags. Encouraging to see that true beauty
conquer the intention of manipulator or two.
SKNinHawaii 2 days ago 3
@SKNinHawaii Dear ,still take a cold shower! PROMOTION is the manipulation , brainwashing and mind control! You take things out of proportion!It's YT, where LISTENERS are supposed to express their OPINIONS about ANY artist! If you like it or not, there's no artist in the world whom absolutely EVERYONE adores!If you are obsessed with PJ and just want to silence those who express that he is just a POP FALSETTIST,and not a CT shows how narrow-minded YOU are!You want to PRETEND everyone loves PJ!LOL
serenaluce 1 day ago
@adalgisa5510 I don't know the other countertenor's case, I see large spread of age amongst audiences at PhJ's concerts. Bowman, Michale Chance may ignore "ladies of certain age" who makes up the core audience but PhJ does not. He is always sincere, courteous and appreciative. Any singers who are arrogant and has little appreciation for the fans and audience are bound to show in their artistic expressions.
SKNinHawaii 5 days ago 4
This man is a true virtuoso. In this genre of music, it doesn't get any better than this. What a gift!
v1x4g2 1 week ago 4
avout these microphones : saw him yesterday at the Berliner Philarmonie, no microphone. He has the vocal power to fill a hall, even behind him we could still understand nearly each word. partly due to, I must admit, the great room in itself.
The concert was marvellous, and he truly is a fantastic, and very sympathetic singer .
BlackCarc 1 week ago 6
what a masterful singing
doddsalfa 1 week ago in playlist Favorite videos 3
What is there to say? I cried. What a voice, angelic sound incarnated in flesh.
sharzahan 1 week ago 3
Is this man married? No? GOOD. >:D He's mine... heh heh >w< Gawd his voice is beautiful and he's certainly just as beautiful to look at while he sings. *le sigh* I wish every man could sing with a voice so soft, smooth, and clear.
Croogix 2 weeks ago
So I'm a primitive old granny who can't tell serious art from pop... :D
sjuli17 2 weeks ago
This CD has just been nominated (as one of three) for best recording for "Les Victoires de la Musique Classique 2012" in France. Congratulations, and fingers crossed!
Great to know that the French musicians, artists and critics have such excellent discernment and taste!
CaraPhilos 2 weeks ago 8
@CaraPhilos Great news !! I have not heard such a beautiful Faure "Requiem" since
the Cluytens/De Los Angeles/Fischer-Dieskau. Finally we have one which deservedly can replace my worn-out LP by Cluytens !! Let's all wish it will receive the honor !! This CD is so well cast that not only PhJ is the shining star here but the baritone part is sung by German baritone who is considered as the successor of Fischer-Dieskau,
Matthias Goerne What a dream cast !!
SKNinHawaii 1 week ago 6
My mother always told me that if I could not think of anything nice to say about somebody it was best not to say anything at all.
Freedom of expression is fine, but not hurting someones feelings is important too.
carolineleiden 2 weeks ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
@carolineleiden I wonder who hurts whose feelings? Why is it relevant for this video that somebody sings in shower as a purpotedly CT and jokes that he can do it better than real great ones?! Let him post his "morning showers" on his channel then. It still doesn't prove that PJ is a countertenor and not a pop falsettist! And skninHawaii shouldn't take things our of proportion either...
serenaluce 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
adalgisa5510 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
adalgisa5510 2 weeks ago
Let Beauty be Beauty--all else is waste and futility. God bless this man and his gift!
smenkare27 3 weeks ago 8
15 people like Justin Bieber.
austindeantk 3 weeks ago
@OedipusTyrannus I agree 100% with you. Obsessed, PhJ hater who believes she/he
is the only human who knows how the CT should be singing and posting hate-comment on the PhJ's major sites is simply sick and obsessed. I know which singers I like and dislike but like you, I don't go around posting how badly they sing. Her obsession to hate and attack Jaroussky went out of control here. Jaroussky is the most loved and successful CT in our time which we all know.
SKNinHawaii 3 weeks ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@SKNinHawaii Dear, take a cold shower.Who is a PJ hater? Me?This cute pop falsettist who is 35 and who pretends that he is still an "innocent" virgin teenager playing with his tender fingers and making touching faces to entertain such primitive old grannies who can't tell serious art from pop doesn't deserve such strong emotions from me as hatred!He has about 2 500 videos on YT.Posting that he is not a CT but a FALSETTIST on SEVERAL videos is out of control?LOL He really has his "troll club"LOL
serenaluce 3 weeks ago
Stunning. Simply stunning!!!
userbeverage 3 weeks ago 11
If I'd read your comments here first, I'd wanted to hear the music even more. There's much controversy here, so it must be at least impressive. I love impressive art. It is not important at all if it's beautiful. Beauty is only one colour on your emotional pallet.
PJ is a monument. He can make you love, he can make you cry, he can make you hate him or laugh. If you like that, you will not be disappointed.He can chase you all around your emotional spectrum, if you let him. If not, why bother?
ewoutvm1 3 weeks ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
@ewoutvm1 I agree. But there should be freedom of expression on YT. It was made to give people opportunity to express freely their OPINIONS about any artist if they like him or her or dislike. Do you think it's OK to make YT a circus appealing to everybody not to express THEIR opinions but only to vote against somewhat serenaluce's comments and spread lies that arpeggio is also me? If PJ attracts such brainless morons like CaraPhilos and JaRoWie he really deserves to have his "troll club"!
serenaluce 3 weeks ago
@ewoutvm1 Well said!
sjuli17 2 weeks ago
pure beauty.
michaimeskinsek 3 weeks ago 13
This has been flagged as spam show
@OedipusTyrannus Ah,you put a lock on personal mails.Very wise.I guess it's your grandfather's advice too.Check Lemos.Do you think that you can sing like that in your shower too?Do you think that this REAL countertenor emotional singing at its best with full and round voice,very MANLY is worse than PJ's cheap pop one dimentional fake teenage bleating,and it's because of Spanos's fault that somewhat serenaluce put his picture on her channel? This is a REAL COUNTERTENOR. PJ is just a falsettist!
serenaluce 4 weeks ago
Why are people here feeding the troll "serenaluce"/"Arpeggio" again by answering, wasting your precious life time reading complete nonsense? Just give them the thumbs down, and their idiocies will silently disappear.
CaraPhilos 4 weeks ago 50
This has been flagged as spam show
@CaraPhilos When can YOUR idiocy simply disappear that EVERYBODY can't love your precious baby PJ,and that there should be freedom of expression?!Stop rushing and barking at everybody like a chain dog who criticizes him!There are many normal people with ears and brains who can hear his WEAK POP voice of a falsettist,but they just don't want to deal with his crazy brainwashed ZOMBIES like you.But Cara, if you want to "kill" everybody who dislikes PJ it still doesn't mean that EVERYBODY loves him!
serenaluce 4 weeks ago
Comment removed
serenaluce 4 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@OedipusTyrannus Also, if you like it or not, but music and all ART has always been a battle field where all kinds of OPINIONS clashed for all the history of mankind,as there's not only pure MUSIC involved but MARKET, a lot of money, power, intrigues, getting into beds to the "right people" pleasing lovers of those people who can give roles and nowadays record with the best orchestras,etc.If nobody ARGUED perhaps we'd still have castrati.You want just to crush OPPOSITION for PJ and PRETEND?
serenaluce 4 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@OedipusTyrannus So, dear "greatest shower countertenor in the world", thank you for your POINT here. You dislike these singers but you don't go to their videos?Good boy! Do you want a PRIZE for it? You want my positive ratings and comments on you singing naked but supposedly with your balls on as you declare yourself just great in ANY kind of repertoir unlike PJ, in exchange for your not criticizing Netrebko? Where's PERSONAL attack?If PJ is so weak to read about his VOICE let him stay at home!
serenaluce 4 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@OedipusTyrannus Dear, please DO upload your morning showers and show at last the whole world how a true countertenor can sing any kind of repertoir!I'm sure that you sing in shower with your balls on and much better than the only pop falsettist in the world PJ whom artificially made a countertenor and coronated as the best one of all time to whom his troll club with their president madam JaRoWie appeal to kneel and kiss his feet!Let them kiss your clean feet after shower instead!LOL Bravissimo!
serenaluce 4 weeks ago
I found this to be exceptionally beautiful!
mradaChris 1 month ago 5
listen to the voice with the sound do u feel the presence of god try it
18aaronjames 1 month ago
Why a countertenor? female voice is prettier and the way Fauré wanted it.
l should admit a boy voice may be...
joanabanyeres 1 month ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@joanabanyeres did faure told you soo i mean ppl like you piss me off u cant even sing so shut the fuck up
18aaronjames 1 month ago
@18aaronjames Mamma mia, how badly you are explaining your feelings
l am not going to answer to such coarseness.How poor you are and not able to listen to this wonderful countertenor, you cannot understand, with this dirty mind. By the way Faure wrote , soprano...... did you knew him maybe ?Or may be you cannot read....
joanabanyeres 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@joanabanyeres fuck off unless u can do better
18aaronjames 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@18aaronjames What's the freaking argument? You think all those critics who kiss PJ's ass or criticize somebody can do it better?! They are just paid to sell better the "product"! It's their profession. But this is YT, where there are no titles and authorities, and all LISTENERS are supposed to express FREELY their opinion, and not be intimidated by PJ's brainwashed ZOMBIES like you! Can you dance better or worse than ballet dancers? So, you can't comment who does is BETTTER,and who is bad?!
serenaluce 1 month ago
This is simply sublime ( sublime : "of such excellence, grandeur, and beauty as to inspire great admiration or awe"). Thank you very much !
thestratford51 1 month ago 4
most pure voice Ive ever heard....
HolyMonkey780 1 month ago 4
Lo he escuchado 15 veces seguidas y no puedo dejar de hacer clic en "replay".
cheloales 1 month ago
You;re a Countertenor!!!!!
highnote32 1 month ago 2
Awesome voice!
AntoniettaChines1222 1 month ago
Wow...
More than beautiful!
Goosebumbs all over...
DoroSusi 1 month ago 2
чистота и ясность его голоса просто завораживает!
kosoglazaya1 1 month ago
я слушаю филиппа и вижу его лицо ,а за спиной большие,как у ангела крылья,только почему-то серебристые.я никогда не видела ангелов,но думаю,что они бывают такие и этот неземной голос,который лился и лился откуда-то сверху и серебристые крылья медленно шевелились. потом еще раз взмахнули и сложились за спиной ,голос медленно расстаял и я вернулась на землю. это было волшебство!никогда никому бы не поверила,что такое возможно,пока не испытала бы сама.божественно!!!!!!!!!,
kosoglazaya1 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@kosoglazaya1 Gospodi, da u vas uzhe galyutsinatsii! Eto navernoe, vash pervyi muzhik, poyushii fal'tsetom, kotorogo vy uslyshali v zhizni. A oni na mnogikh na pervykh porakh okazyvayut sil'noe vpechatlenie, no potom eto obychno prokhodit. On - voobshe nikakoi ne kontrtenor, a popsovyi fal'tsetist, kotorogo tol'ko promotion i sdelala kontrtenorom.Vy kogda-nibud' slyshali, kak angely poyu? Ya nikogda:-).Angel'skoe penie da, no u zhivykh lyudei kryl'ev net!:-) Sovetuyu kholodnyi dush prinyat'!:-)
serenaluce 1 month ago
Absolutely BEAUTIFUL !!!!!!
enriquevictrum 2 months ago 2
Hi everyone. It's useless arguing with a certain user here, because “PREJUDICE, not being founded on reason, cannot be removed by argument”. And while you THINK that you are defending Philippe, IN FACT you are only feeding a troll. I thank you for thinking twice before you respond to certain comments.
VI0L0NS 2 months ago 62
This has been flagged as spam show
@VI0L0NS Can you define first what is PREJUDICE? Where's any PREJUDICE concerning PJ on this video? Nobody discusses here his private life, possible sexual orientation like on many Cencic's videos, that CTs and falsettists are inferior voices, etc...So, think twice before writing this nonsense. No demacratic society can function without OPPOSITION. EVERYBODY can't like the same POPULAR stuff as for POP FANS! You can crush opposition but it doesn't mean that "Everybody loves Jaroussky"!
serenaluce 2 months ago
@serenaluce "No, democratic society can function without opposition." As if Jaroussky were on the brink of being elected to political office and Serenaluce was leading the campaign of his political rival. If her idol Nicholas Spanos is following this he's probably getting a good, but rather embarrassed, giggle out of it all.
larrydonguy 2 months ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
@larrydonguy Democratic society can't function with opposition. If it's crushed, forbidden, it's already a fascist regime. You should know it before writing this nonsense. YT is created as a democratic intutition where all OPINIONS are welcomed. Poticial compaign? Are you crazy. I asked you:"Do YOU think that PJ is POPULAR"? Why can't you asnwer this simple question about PJ? It's relevant! Is it an insult to him or to you? Don't be demagogical! Answer my direct question first about JAROUSSKY!
serenaluce 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@larrydonguy Honey, I'm waiting. I reply to you right away, but it takes you DAYS to think over YOUR next reply to ME which doesn't characterize you as a worthy adversary to me!Your gastromonical problems and taking blood thinner obviously doesn't help your brain activity.What elections you mean?It's a MUSICAL video on YT, a democratitic institution to express OPINIONS.I have no idols!Only favourite singers.Compare PJ with Lesne.ANSWER at last Is PJ POPULAR?Lesne POPULAR?Are you moralizing here?
serenaluce 2 months ago
So...it is agreed upon that the only thing that matters for a singer is the sound of his voice? Than any criticism should also revolve around his voice. That is fair.
Not his looks, not his image, not his hobbies, not his behaviour, not his promotion, not his extracurricular activities. Just his voice. The sound of it, the quality, the technique, the emotion, the expression.
carolineleiden 2 months ago 15
Aha, people are wasting their time with the troll "serenaluce" still. I am sure you would have much better things to do.
What I would really be interested in, by the way is why this has been posted by EMI but is not being watched? It is not possible to post critical remarks at the videos of Angela Gheorgiu posted by EMI. Or at the EMI main site here. What can we conclude from this?
CaraPhilos 2 months ago 12
This has been flagged as spam show
@CaraPhilos And if CaraPhilos isn't a troll please be so kind to help people to conclude why is this video was posted by EMI but not being watched by EMI?Or by whom else? There are enough views here like on any other POP SINGER's video? You want MILLIONS of views? For that it should be not Faure, even not any imitation of baroque as the majority are just afraid of this word alone, but even more primitive pop like with words "Sex, women, drugs" or "baby if you give it to me I'll give it to you"..
serenaluce 2 months ago
I do not like PJ just because of the promotional machinery that surrounds him. I knew nothing about him when I first heard his voice, but I was completely enraptured by it within the first few bars.
I do not care if it is pop or classical, I do not care if he is famous or not, I do not care what he looks like, I do not care if the music is profane or liturgical: he has a marvellous, pure, clear and very natural sound that I find to be most pleasing and very comforting, calming and soothing.
carolineleiden 2 months ago 31
This has been flagged as spam show
@carolineleiden Dear Caroline, you sound like the only normal PJ's fan here who expresses ONE's own opinion on his singing and why you like him. All the rest are just obsessed ignorant people who can't stand any criticism, any OPINIONS other than just worshipping PJ like an angel,God, and if somebody thinks differently declare them TROLLS with their hysterical yells to fight them! Madam JaRoWie on her channel BLOCKS everybody who just says that his version is bad and there are BETTER versions!..
serenaluce 2 months ago
@carolineleiden I am totally in tune with you. I don't care who says what about
PJ. His musicality, his voice, singing, style, repertoire which I like very much. I don't care if this singing is pop Faure and not academic Faure, or his image or presentation
disturbs some people, I like his voice and singing above all the countertenors.
SKNinHawaii 2 months ago 12
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I see no vulgar comments by either serenaluce or arpeggio1358, but then you Jaroussky fans have removed some their comments so that nobody can judge for themselves. In what has been left, there is no vulgarity, only reasonable disagreement on the merits of Jaroussky's voice. I believe Yt is democratic, and thus comments should not be removed simply because they disagree with a singer's fans. You Jaroussky fans are being most unfair.
pucciniverdi777 2 months ago
@pucciniverdi777 I am responding to you because you sound to be a fair person. I don't think you have read all the comments serenaluce and arpeggio1358 has been posting from the beginning which are mean and tasteless, totally unrelated to musicality of the singer and no artists should be subjected to that kind of comments.
Whose voice, artistry, repertoire you like or don't like is totally a subjective matter.
their non constructive, non musical personal bashing and not non
SKNinHawaii 2 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
@SKNinHawaii Expressing SUBJECTIVE opinion on an artist's work without personal insults that he is just a POP singer, not a classical CT with all 3 well-developed registers but singing only in FLAT voice on HIGH notes and some middle which qualifies his as a typical FALSETTIST like Vitas is being MEAN and TASTELESS, and your comments imposing YOUR OPINION on other people are OBJECTIVE, TASTEFUL and KIND? Expressing OPINION about the VOICE is bashing the artist?
serenaluce 2 months ago
@serenaluce This is the first time you ever made sensible and understandable criticism
on PJ without mean, personal insults. I don't believe attacking the artist with insults
when you have legitimate criticism. Any intelligent artists and their fans are able to
accept that. When your criticism goes off the line and become unfair insults it is no longer healthy nor constructive. By the way Kowalski is growing on me. I like to hear your opinion on his YT site. Not here.Thanks
SKNinHawaii 2 months ago 11
This has been flagged as spam show
@serenaluce Yes! Let's be fair to Serenaluce. She has expressed no personal insults toward Jaroussky other than calling him a girl. And her "SUBJECTIVE opinion" of Jaroussky's singing has always been expressed in a respectful manner, such as the time she used the words "pretends, fake, cheap tricks, empty, shallow, sugary, artificial, 'castrated', and without any soul" all in the same comment about his singing.
larrydonguy 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@larrydonguy Friend Larry Donkey,you just make a bigger ASS of your DONKEY all the time.Do you think that writing here about your gastronomical problems and taking blood thinner is RELEVANT to PJ's singing?You even can't STAND him saying that ALL COUNTERTENORS SOUND LIKE WOMEN?Is it me and not YOU calling him a GIRL?I comment on his IMAGE,and my FINGERS with MANICURED LONG NAILS are SIMILAR to his!I give my reasons that he is NOT a CT but FALSETTIST.Falsettists are LEGITIMITE too,can beFEMININE!
serenaluce 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@larrydonguy With your taking blood thinners it's BAD for you to be involved in discussions which you even don't understand!Watch Disney catoon films with SKINinHawaii's grandchildren if you don't have your own and relax!Who says here that for a MAN looking feminine is so AWFUL?But a REAL countertenor can't SOUND feminine as it's the closest substitute to CASTRATI who sang like MANLY men and presented HEROIC men on stage.It's for FALSETTISTS to be feminine.Answer me: do you think PJ is POPULAR?
serenaluce 2 months ago
@serenaluce Why are you so offensive??? You sound unhappy.
tuffy942 2 months ago 14
This has been flagged as spam show
@tuffy942 Dear, I'm offensive? How did I offend YOU? You work in cooperation with madam JaRoWie blocking everybody who criticizes PJ for doing only POP falsettist's stuff and presenting it as what a classical CT typically does. His "Carmen" is pure pop. He only can sing something like that in shows "Just for laughs". Scholl and Cencic can do similar just for fun, but they have full and round real CTs voices to be taken SERIOUSLY, but PJ is only FALSETTIST with his FLAT voice.YOU sound miserable!
serenaluce 2 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@serenaluce unless you can do better shut the fuck up
18aaronjames 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@18aaronjames Whatès your problem buddy! Take a sedative or a cold shower!
serenaluce 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@larrydonguy Larry,what's up with you?Why are you hiding from me?You speculate what I could have meant concerning PJ's looking feminine,lie that I insult him and call him a girl though I never call a man a woman or a girl.It's only your sexual fantasies about what the other people think. PJ is just not CT and belongs to POP FALSETTIST category like Vitas,Klaus Nomi,Artem Semenov.Vitas is just not to my liking, but how come I don't swoon from Nomi's and Semenov's long painted nails?They're GIRLS?
serenaluce 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@larrydonguy Mind,that I only comment on what I see on the video before my eyes.If it's presented in the HONEST way as "classics in POP INTERPRETATIONS" or milder "classics in modern interpretations" I can compare PJ with Vitas who also e.g. sings Ave Maria in his pop manner or tenor's aria "La donna e' mobile" pretending that castrati sang like that but it still doesn't make him a REAL operatic CT,but it's stupid to compare him with e.g. the same Cencic.Simple question:" YOU think PJ POPULAR?"
serenaluce 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@SKNinHawaii I can't see all of serenaluce's and arpeggio1358's comments because you people have seen to it that they have been removed. From what I've seen, their comments are reasonable. They may be strong opinions, but they are not nasty or vulgar. If they don't like Jaroussky's voice, they are entitled to that opinion.
pucciniverdi777 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@SKNinHawaii Now you are removing my comments just because I said I saw no vulgar comments from serenaluce and arpeggio. I must say that this is childish in the extreme. Do you think that others who come to this video can't see for themselves that much has been removed and won't wonder what you people are so afraid of?
pucciniverdi777 2 months ago
@pucciniverdi777 I have not removed your comments nor any one's comments. I delete from my e-mail box as I do all the unnecessary mails. I am personally not afraid of anything and there are nothing to be afraid of. I do not feel it is norm when a person dislike certain artist and post negative and personal insults on many of his YT sites repeatedly. That is beyond posting one's opinion or comments. Comments should not be personal insults.
SKNinHawaii 2 months ago 8
This has been flagged as spam show
@SKNinHawaii Dear, I say it again: there's an option on YT REPLY to give people opportunity to DISCUSS. Show me where it says that it's against YT policy that users have to reply only to comments addressed personally to them? What PERSONAL INSULTS I've ever expressed to PJ as a PERSON? I don't know him personally and don't want to know! Have I ever written with whom he SLEEPS, what he does IN BED, any GOSSIPS?He is offering to LISTENERS this kind of IMAGE ON STAGE. I only comment on his VOICE!
serenaluce 2 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@SKNinHawaii Saying that Jaroussky sings in a pop style and not a classical or opera style is not a personal insult. Nor is saying one doesn't like little boy looks on a man. These are comments. I've even read the removed commentsa, and they're not personal attacks. They're just comments that these posters don't like his voice and feel that he should stick to pop music.
pucciniverdi777 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@pucciniverdi777 I couldn't agree more with you here. Another person with ears and brains with real musical knowledge and understanding. Otherwise it's just ridiculous what PJ's ignorant crazy obsessed fans write here as they don't understand at all the difference between a true opera singer and a POP SINGER like PJ who just performs classics in his easy to swallow pop manner. I guess for those who thinks that POP is an insult I have to explain that it only means POPULAR! Where are trolls here?
serenaluce 2 months ago
@pucciniverdi777 P.S. goes on and on and they will attack comment in favor of
Jaroussky even if the comments are not addressed to them. Selenaluse has been
posting her/his personal bashing, on other Jaroussky's video, totally unrelated to his
musicality. I personally dislike tasteless comments, personal bashing on any artist.
I believe constructive critic knows the fine line between critique and bashing.
SKNinHawaii 2 months ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@SKNinHawaii But there has been no tasteless bashing, just opinions. You seeit as bashing because you can't stand hearing the slightest negative comment about him..
pucciniverdi777 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@SKNinHawaii Oh dear,you just talk nonsense: there's an option on YT as REPLY button,not buttons on PJ's shirt which in your IRRELEVANT comment are about to POP OUT as a proof only in YOUR ignorant OPINION of this BIG voice.Opera singers are supposed to sing with their VOICE,not their BUTTONS on their shirts.Pavarotti had a BIGGER real OPERATIC voice and much bigger frame. Following your logic he is much GREATER,so all the buttons should have BURST and all his clothes distroyed!LOL It's Related?
serenaluce 2 months ago
Toglie il fiatto! Bravissimo!
78fufluns 2 months ago 2
I think I should repeat DO NOT FEED TROLLS, they are always looking for more XDDDD
Enjoy Jaroussky's talented voice or change video, it's up to you!
78fufluns 2 months ago 8
I'm not recommending this because I think one's criticism should be honest, but were you to post negative criticism of Serenaluce's and Arpeggio's favorite young countertenor, Nicholas Spanos, on his fans' You-tube sites, you would be subject to all sorts of nasty name calling. I know because I was.
larrydonguy 2 months ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
@larrydonguy Dear,be HONEST yourself first.You are just a mean creature making up stuff because you have no MUSICAL argument either here or on Spanos's video. You just stalk arpeggio, that's how you found any COUNTERTENOR video at all. Shall I remind you what you wrote about ALL countertenors? That they ALL sound like "weeping widows", who knows them at all and that men shouldn't sound like that and can't be taken SERIOUSLY in opera.You called PJ "broccoli".And you complain about nasty names?LOL
serenaluce 2 months ago
@serenaluce Actually I said specifically that SPANOS sounded like a "weeping widow," though perhaps this tone is endemic to lower range contraltos and countertenors. I said that Jaroussky who sings higher and more lightly had less of this quality.For someone who likes neither broccoli nor spinach but between the two slightly prefers broccoli, Jaroussky is my broccoli. Some people love broccoli. Some love spinach. Some love both.
larrydonguy 2 months ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
@larrydonguy So,why don't you comment on VEGETABLES and tell what is YOUR favourite VEGETABLE as all vegetables of the cabbage family give you GAS!OK, Spanos only to YOU sounds not like weeping widow but reminded you somehow your touching early childhood when you heard madam Schumann-Heink on your mother's album who was a very low FEMALE contralto, and no CTs either Spanos singing closer to SOPRANO, or even PJ don't have similar quality in their voices!You said:"ALL CTs can't be taken SERIOUSLY"
serenaluce 2 months ago
@serenaluce Sorry, no time to analyze your latest offering, Serenaluce. I'm off to do a concert. You see, unlike you, I'm actually paid, if rather modestly, to sing.
larrydonguy 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@larrydonguy At last please do something useful and go sing wherever you like instead of writing all this ignorant NONSENSE on YT about the whole voice category of CTs who according to you should be still discriminated as for people with not sensitive ears they superficially sound like WOMEN and can't be taken SERIOUSLY in this "high gender stereotyping"! Your words, not mine! If you sing as e.g. a baritone, doesn't mean that modification of MALE voice higher makes it "a bastard voice"! Be paid!
serenaluce 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@larrydonguy serenaluce tells the truth. You made nasty comments about allCT's, saying they sound like women and inferring that they're all gay.You made fun of them, and you dare to criticize us, you bigot.
arpeggio1358 2 months ago
@arpeggio1358 I see that your comment has been flagged as spam, Arpeggio; unfairly I think so I'll answer it. I said that countertenors sound like women because THEY DO SOUND LIKE WOMEN. Which doesn't mean that YOUR precisely tuned ear can't tell the difference, but to the average listener they sound like women. I would suggest that YOU were the one INFERRING that I thought that all CT's were gay or gave a rat's ... if they were.
larrydonguy 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@larrydonguy Dear, it's YOU who is a real TROLL here if you persist that ALL countertenors DO SOUND LIKE WOMEN. So, your precious PJ included, of course, no matter if he sounds lighter or heaver. I wonder why his crazy fans don't mark YOUR comments as SPAM and don't call YOU troll. But I'll tell you why - because his fans are stone deaf like you, and don't give a rat's ass if he sounds like a man or a woman because he SOUNDS like a SEXLESS creature!Do you agree that PJ is POPULAR?Can you answer?
serenaluce 2 months ago
@larrydonguy PS: Also, as you should have seen by now, Arpeg, Your partner-in-arms, Serenaluce, has made all sorts comments not so much implying as outright saying that Jaroussky is a boy-girl. You might take a(nother?) look at the insults she has hurled his way.
larrydonguy 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@larrydonguy Dear, what insults if PJ HIMSELF chose such an image of a "boy forever" who doesn't want to grow up, who only plays with his soft tender, meticulously manicured fingers with long polished nails to disguise his empty voice which sound technicians only AMPLIFY and video technicians draw the listeners' attention to his so called "singing hands"where a true OPERA singer is supposed to sing with his VOICE! I have almost the same FINGERS with long nails as woman, WEIRD?Answer my GUESTION!
serenaluce 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@larrydonguy Answer my question , do you call PJ POPULAR, and what do YOU think about it? Also, speak only for YOURSELF and don't imply that the other people say if you don't understand at all what it's all about as you confessed YOURSELF that you know NOTHING about CT voice. You only are STALKING arpeggio and found this video by ACCIDENT.What can you say about such REAL CTS as Cencic, Lesne, Lemos, Asawa, Daniels, Scholl, Kowalski, Esswood,Wong? Analyze their differences instead of envying Arp!
serenaluce 2 months ago
@serenaluce Sorry, but neither my health (I'm on a blood thinner) nor my palate can tolerate too many green vegetables. I've listened to a few of those folks, quite enough for my taste. I now see that Arpeggio also criticizes Jaroussky for being feminine. Isn't criticizing a countertenor for being feminine a bit like criticizing an interior decorator for the same? Surely it's not a disqualifying trait.
larrydonguy 2 months ago
@arpeggio1358 besides whose voice, artistry, singing technique, personality on stage, looks
one like is very very subjective matter. Writing false information about the artist with vulgar
tasteless manner is nothing but showing where you come from and what your intention is.
Despite of your ugly spamming, viewers has been increasing constantly. It would be wonderful if viewers doesn't have to read all your rubbish and simply enjoy PJ's singing.
,
SKNinHawaii 2 months ago 27
This has been flagged as spam show
@SKNinHawaii You contradict yourself again.You say that everything is subjective. What false information arpeggio and me purportedly wrote about PJ here? What vulgarity?Artists are public figures and supposed to be JUDGED by listeners. They make their living by performances,and if nobody JUDGES what they do ON STAGE, they'd better look for another job! All POP SINGERS have many views of their videos, much more than REAL OPERA SINGERS!Who doesn't allow you to enjoy it? It's FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION!
serenaluce 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@SKNinHawaii You can't expect everyone on a particular video to like the singer that you like. All opinions are welcome on YouTube.
arpeggio1358 2 months ago
@Schizophreniac17 ignore 'them' the multi troll..she is not at all a well woman..add to that, that she is quite old enough to know better and find more gainful pursuits :)
MATTDUNCAN1 2 months ago 42
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@Schizophreniac17 Alas, I feel sorry that the PJ fans actually see magic in his voice. Have you ever listened to a real operatic countertenor like Spanos, Taylor, Esswood, Asawa, Scholl? Please listen to them and maybe you will hear the difference.
arpeggio1358 2 months ago
@arpeggio1358 what is your intention writing un-constructive rubbish time after time? PJ fans is not going to turn away from him because you and serenaluce are crusading to educate us PJ is over promoted POP CT, uses MC and on and on. Did you think this video was from concert? This is a recording session. What are you talking about.
Have you ever been to Pj, Scholl, Asawa, Esswood, Taylor concert? I have been to three of their concerts and I like PJ the best.
to
SKNinHawaii 2 months ago 19
This has been flagged as spam show
@SKNinHawaii Dear, you are just paranoid.Who do you think tries to change the world on PJ's videos?Take a cold shower. Enjoy your POP. Are you that easily suggested and can turn against your sugary pop idol only if somebody says that he is pop? Do you think that a pop singer is a swearword like a bastard? Then it's only YOUR problem! What's so bad in performing classical stuff in POP manner? It just should be presented in the HONEST way. I like many POP singers but please don't call them OPERA!
serenaluce 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@SKNinHawaii There was nothing vulgar in my original comment, but now nobody will be able to read it since you had it removed. Advancing your own agenda by removing comments is chidish and slants everything your way.
arpeggio1358 2 months ago
@Schizophreniac17 There is a saying"The beauty is in the eyes of beholder". I'd like to add to it ears, a brain and a heart. Those who don't have that cannot appreciate the beauty. They are obsessed by their own negativeness and what worse, they are vulgar, malicious, jealous and simply trying to hack this site or other PJ's site. Useless and dirty acts but she thinks she was trying to be humorous and we take her too seriously. So don't feed her malicious sense of humor !!
SKNinHawaii 2 months ago 20
This has been flagged as spam show
@SKNinHawaii Also, be consistent yourself. You say that "Beauty is in the eye of the beholder". If you find it beautiful, I just find "sweet snort", sugarly empty shallow singing always like a singing machine performing the same piece slightly modified according to a different tune without paying any attention to the style and image. Now you try to preach whohas brains and who can understand THE BEAUTY! So, what DIRTY ACTS? To express one's OPINION? I don't spread any gossips about PJ! Wake up!
serenaluce 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Schizophreniac17 You want to fight all the persons who just have a different OPINION about all the artists' work, commenting only on what he or she does ON STAGE? If somebody doesn' appreciate what YOU appreciate you are just intolerant? How do you want to fight such people with different OPINIONS? Exterminate them? Kill them all? Don't you know that all the history of MUSIC there've been ARGUMENTS what it should be. Otherwise there would be no progress.SCHIZOPHRENIAC is a true expert! LOL
serenaluce 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
strange comments here..a singer using their chest ??? it is the diaphragm which is the singers 'bellows'..still...one can be moved by many things..there are some who find lady gaga a wonder..good luck to them..
MATTDUNCAN1 2 months ago 13
haha vraiment incroyable, d'une grande pureté et d'une infinie justesse :)
65karamel 2 months ago
@serenaluce
None of your business. I came to know all I was interested in. Bye.
nordischbaby 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@nordischbaby Baby,of course, it's none of my business why you watched this video at all. But your channel is not available. It means that you have something to hide. A bit strange as everybody on YT is anomymous in any case if they are not artists promoting themselves and giving their real names. But at least I commented here about RELEVANT stuff that I find PJ's interpretation not Faure in the academic manner but in pure POP MANNER. You wanted only to know if somewhat serenaluce heard PJ live?
serenaluce 2 months ago
@serenaluce
No more questions.
nordischbaby 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@nordischbaby Dear, everything here on YT is only OPINIONS and nothing more! Do you think that anonymous users who write that they toured with PJ and have the PROOF that he never uses any mike live are more credible on YT? You have no more questions to them? You are sure that they are RIGH?! What about your OWN opinion about this video? You said nothing if you like it or not... You are only an INTERROGATOR here believing that obsessed TROLL JaRoWie who stalks PJ all over the world? LOL
serenaluce 2 months ago
@serenaluce
so you never heard him in reality?
nordischbaby 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@nordischbaby Thank God, no. I am not gonna waste my money to listen to overpromoted commercial singers who only entertain people with their superficial vocal special effects like PJ with his sugary sounds without any attachment to any character or image or Bartoli with her clucking hen technique entertaining her audience with her ugly singing! Sorry, there's YT now.I can listen to artists and decide who's worth it! I have my own head and not BRAINWASHED by PROMOTION!You can decide for YOURSELF!
serenaluce 2 months ago
@serenaluce
You wrote PJ uses a mic everywhere. Where did you get that information from?
nordischbaby 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@nordischbaby From the sound of his voice in his recordings and from videos on YT.Everywhere PJ's voice sounds artifcial,manipulated and amplified.He has a very small voice with just nauseatically sweet trills with which sound technicians work.From his recordings it's obvious that he doesn't have a proper CT technique as he only superficially touches his vocal cords and uses very primitive pop coloratura.From his videos it's seen he doesn't use his CHEST.How can he sound loud enough with Cencic?
serenaluce 2 months ago
@serenaluce I understand that you never heard PJ in real. Making all those comments
based on the video you watch? Pity on you. Actually his voice is very large, and he uses chest so much so that I was afraid his shirts is too tight and the button will pop out !! I still don't understand why you are so malicious about him. His popularity? being so well promoted? being able to sing in many first class concert halls? Audience love him and he has all the qualifications and more.
SKNinHawaii 2 months ago 15
This has been flagged as spam show
@SKNinHawaii Dear,can't you read?Who is malicious?I just said that PJ sings not in academic manner, it's not classical Faure, and he is not a CT, but just a falsettist who performs classical stuff in POP MANNER! Also, pity on you as your ears and eyes are bigger than his voice. Other people who heard him live say that his voice is very SMALL. If you saw bottons on his shirt about to pop out, it just means that he needs a bigger shirt! LOL Audience loves him?So what?People love him as POP SINGER!
serenaluce 2 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@SKNinHawaii Give me a break! If his voice was really big, he wouldn't need a microphone all the time. He always has one, even in his live opera performances, he sounds amplified..hidden mic? PJ is a pop falsettist, not a real operatic countertenor. Also you confuse popularity with greatness. Popular doesn't equal great. Most people can't even hear the difference between a pop crossover singer and a real opera singer.
arpeggio1358 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@arpeggio1358 Popular doesn't equal great, for sure. As example, look to Cecilia Bartoli, a horrible technique, but an army of fans.
pedrofribeiro 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@pedrofribeiro Bravo! Barttoli has horrible, ugly techique, but she sure does have an army of fans. Popular does not equal great.
arpeggio1358 2 months ago
@pedrofribeiro Trying to criticize an artist on video and CD only is very unjust. Have you ever heard Bartoli on stage? She has magnetic power and personally that audience are pulled to her. Artist who can give bliss of happiness and deep involvement to satisfy audience's varied musical background are the real artist and any negative quality you mention are trivial matter. Great artist has both great musicality and human appeal to the audience and Bartoli sure has all that.
SKNinHawaii 2 months ago 9
This has been flagged as spam show
@SKNinHawaii Oh, really give us a break with your whining and complaining. Do you have nothing else to do? No obligations before your grandchildren as a good grandmother? If you are such a nervious easily getting upset old lady who takes a sedative if any of your favourite singers are criticized ask your doctor first if YT is right for you.There's NO artist in the world whom ABSOLUTELY everyone ADORES and nobody criticizes!Get over it.To listen and CRITICIZE is JUST,and you want just to SILENCE!
serenaluce 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@SKNinHawaii You make comments about the size of his chest and we're supposed to believe all you're interested in just his voice?You sound pretty obsessed.I never wrote anything vulgar, but since you and your friends have removed my comments, nobody will ever know the truth.
arpeggio1358 2 months ago
The bliss of heaven in the voice of a man...
VI0L0NS 2 months ago 6
I simply cannot believe how this discussion has gone completely out of control these last two pages. Come on people: how about a little good taste and common decency from now on, to match the beautiful music?
carolineleiden 2 months ago 37
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@carolineleiden Actually, really. Where do people see the end of the world? They admire PJ. They can just ignore comments and if they want so much to discuss can say:"Even if PJ isn't a typical classically trained CT, I like his VOICE, enjoy his singing and I don't care if it's pop or not!" That's it! I actually first of all replied to my YT friend MrPapageno who shared this video with me and asked MY OPINION as it's the only video where he found this pop singer PJ not too bad! Why this fuss?!
serenaluce 2 months ago
@carolineleiden Hi Caroline, I'm Pilar from PJ's forum. I agree with you. PLEASE DON'T FEED THE TROLLS. I saw arpeggio1358 and serenaluce in other PJ's videos, I guess they are crazy in love with him and feel frustated. Otherwise I can't understand why are they spending their time listening to him if they despite Jaroussky talent so much. So, let's enjoy Mr. Jaroussky gifted performances and FORGET ABOUT THOSE TROLLS!
78fufluns 2 months ago 12
This has been flagged as spam show
@78fufluns Oh my God, if somebody dislikes the singer who is just overpromoted and people are brainwashed about his greatness, blinded by PROMOTION you call such people TROLLS?! By the way, you think that only now someone dares to criticize artificially made "great artists"? All history of music there've been ARGUMENTS about perfomances. At time of castrati if you claim that PJ is a real CT who is closest to them they BOOED in the theatre.Farinelli told a NOBLE that he is an ASS and has no ears!
serenaluce 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@78fufluns So, for YOU Farinelli himself is a TROLL! Handel himself argued if castrato voice has the right to exist or not as it's caused by butchery,and not natural modification of the voice! In the theatre "De la noblesse" they first BOOED at FARINELLI as he began to perform DIFFERENT kind of music to which those nobles were not used and wanted just soulless virtuosity! Great FARINELLI and HANDEL were definitely TROLLS too in your understanging! But to say that I'm in LOVE with "baby PJ"...LOL
serenaluce 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@78fufluns I don't waste my time with guys who look like little boys. PJ isn't my type.I prefer men who look like men. In love with PJ, you must be joking.People like you who can't stand having anything negative written about their favorite singer are the real trolls. Also,grownups can have a diffference of opinion without turnig nasty.
arpeggio1358 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@78fufluns Are you going to trot out "jealous", "Bet you can't sing as well as he can", "hater" and all the other excuses pop opera fans use to discredit people who disagree with them?
arpeggio1358 2 months ago
Actually they are not. arpeggio, for example, USUALLY expresses her opinions without vulgarity or personal insults. I find both singers quite talented but not to my taste. If you prefer a man who sounds like an exceptional budding soprano you'll like Jaroussky. If you prefer a man who sounds like a seasoned contralto (Madame Schumann-Heink?) or mezzo you'll like Spanos. I prefer men who remind me of men. There are plenty who don't like either for you folks to argue violently among yourselves.
larrydonguy 2 months ago
@JaRoWi1647 Couldn´t agree with you more. People, please stop reacting to the TROLL "serenaluce"! (By the way, those who always agree with "her" probably are the same person.)
CaraPhilos 2 months ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@CaraPhilos Actually,I respect much more those who argue with me, even insult me PERSONALLY but who reply to ME expressing their OPINIONS like me about artists and users.It's more HONEST and more appropriate as there are only anonymous USERS on YT who are supposed to speak only for themselves and express only THEIR opinion and not hysterically appeal to the whole world like such cowards as YOU and PJ's uploader madam JaRoWie who can't even reply to ME!Prove that I have more accounts and not YOU!
serenaluce 2 months ago
@JaRoWi647
Aw, now where will I get my source of snorts and giggles?
I kid; I'll be good.
You're totally right on this point. :)
FestiveSpirit 2 months ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@FestiveSpirit Of course, she is right on this point as her precious protege prince Charming PJ is a TROLL in the CT world, and she knows it too well, because she is just afraid of the truth, that's why she is so pissed off at whistle-blowers, and blocks people the next minute after they dare express that e.g. "after listening to Cencic PJ's version is so shallow. Bravo Cencic!" Or "It's not Tamerlano! PJ is just not made for dramatic roles"... Why don't you ask HER how much PJ pays HER?
serenaluce 2 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@serenaluce "How much PJ pays her"? Apparently you're not aware of how many people would pay to lick his ass.
ErosAdInfinitum 2 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@ErosAdInfinitum Actually,it's not ME who began this stupid conversation hoW much a somewhat artist whose only PICTURE his or her fans only have on their channels can pay.It's a kinder garten's level to see a PICTURE and ask how much this PICTURE pays me? Very interesting position: if I admire some artists I already can't express MY OPINIONS that the others are not classical though their promoters present them just for money but POP like Bocelli,Brightman,PJ?Licking ASS isn't PJ's GREATNESS!LOL
serenaluce 2 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@ErosAdInfinitum So,apparently you are trying to say that it's not PJ but madam JaRoWie herself , "dear Janochka" pays her OWN money to lick PJ's ASS! Did I understand you right? It's such a privilege for some of his uploaders to pay to LICK HIS ASS? In any case, licking ass for some benefits and making money on PROMOTION has nothing to do with the ART OF SINGING! It's no proof of somebody's greatness! What you write if you are not an interested person who is paid too is a SIGN of OBSESSION! LOL
serenaluce 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Dear people, please, STOP answering to " serenaluce"- it is definitely a TROLL who is here only to prattle any ignorant rubbish.
JaRoWi1647 2 months ago 34
This has been flagged as spam show
@JaRoWi1647 I have so much fun reading your "innocent rubbish".I wonder if YOU are not TROLL,and PJ is a real "greatest countertenor in the world" and "we should kneel before him for revival of true baroque" as promotion claims,and I read on one Russian site and also this special Russian idiotism that PJ is a great artist because Jaroussky means "Ja roussky" I'm Russian, so many Russians are just proud of anything because they are also Russians why do you block just for prefering Cencic to PJ?
serenaluce 2 months ago
@serenaluce
Once again, you have totally missed the point. Good job!
I wonder why it's always so painfully obvious to everyone (except you) that the only reason I would point fingers at you especially is your prolific Jaroussky-bashing. Still waiting for a clear reason from you, eight comments later. Perhaps you can finally grace us with a response~
(Violahen8, unlike you, is a normal person that comments once or twice, so I don't question her integrity. The same cannot be said for you.)
FestiveSpirit 2 months ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@FestiveSpirit Bashing? Are you serious? YOU have totally missed the point. Saying that it's not CLASSICAL ART but POP isn't any insult and bashing! But it should be presented in the HONEST way! PJ is a PRETENDER in the CT world as he doesn't belong to it but to POP ART. His artistic occupation is CLASSICS IN POP INTERPRETATIONS! PERIOD! I'm not stalking him or bashing as a PERSON! But I have the right to express my OPINION to what he does ON STAGE!And you just admit that he is POP if you normal
serenaluce 2 months ago
@serenaluce как же я устала везде встречать твои тупые комментарии! Сгинь уже, неполноценная.
rjvtylhjdcrfz 2 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@rjvtylhjdcrfz A ty voobshe sama kto takaya? Pochemu ty mne tykaesh'? Eto chto tvoi kanal? Ty eshe ne zametila, chto YT otkryta dlya vsekh! Vot zagruzhai PJ na svoem kanale i blokirui vsekh, kto khotya by sravnivaet versiyu Cencic, nastoyashego kontrtenora s pop versiei PJ kak madam JaRoWe1647 na svoem kanale, ne pozvolyaya nikakoi svobody mnenii, i komandui tam, chto esli komu-to tvoya popsa PJ ne nravitsya, to pust' sginut ottuda nepolnotsennye, a zdes' ne vystupai, primitivnaya dura!
serenaluce 2 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Ye Gods, his top notes are screechy and strained. This is not a great countertenor, but a pop artist.
arpeggio1358 2 months ago
He sings like a bird ... Greetings from Poland
MultiKruczek 2 months ago
such purity of voice.... angelic, emotional, such gentle technique... is simply divine!
lilithmoon1979 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@serenaluce
But really, your personal bitterness is going too far. Take your vendetta again Jaroussky somewhere else: this is not the place for it. A per