teringat kata m nasir,,, siti ni SUARA... dia tidak memerlukan keadaan keadaan tertentu dia tidak memerlukan trend sebab dia adalah SUARA... dia boleh berada di mana mana zaman...
sebenarnye ade rahsie yg sangat2 besar disebalik lagu ni, lagu ni dicipte khas oleh P Ramlee utk Saloma , siti ke jac ke bawak terime & alunkan laguni sebagai lagu yg baik &dialunkan dng baik sbb mereke memang penyanyi yg baik tp x kan same mcm Saloma yg mengalunkan lagu ni ikhlas dari lubuk hatinye sebagai inspirasi cinte(rekod utk sarjin Hassan-belum bergelar isteri P Ramlee) dan kenangan cinte (rekod tahun70an-setelah PRamlee tiade)
suara ct ada lenggok sikit....tu yang bunyi merdu nyanyi lagu ni......suara jac pun sedap nyanyi lagu ni....tetapi arrangement muzik ni versi lain sikit dari jac nyanyi....
i judged the song rendition on which one gives me goose bumps.... guess the original by p ramlee gives that (not fair due to contextual element) second jac due to its high hitting notes, but siti has the melodious hold.
erm, ekceli klu nak compare jac ngan siti memang takleh, sebab arrangement dorang cam ade beza sket bawak lagu ni kan? so bila ade beza for the music for sure ade org minat tech, ade org suka melodious, and so on.
anyway, support local artist, buy their album, and lastly...peace
Tak payah la nak compare siti ngan artis lain.. Dah jelas siti bawak natural jer. Tak perlu nak jerit utk hit the high note. Sedap je telinga mendengar.. Ct the best
xsedap la siti nyanyi lagu ni... sakit telinga ...yang paling sedap bawak lagu ni cuma dua orang aja.. iaitu Rafeah Buang & Jacklyn Victor.. serius cakap..(^_^)
ala..feel mcmana pun..TETAP KALAH DALAM ASIAN IDOL AND IKON ASIA tu.. bikin malu..! yuck..taw menjerit2 jak tapi NO SENI AT ALL>> ellowish..im with you.. ^_^
OMG.. Meremang aku dgr ct bawak lagu ni walaupun dah byk kali dgr ct perform this song. But kali ni sgt menjadi. Ternyata dah kahwin ct still maintain. Even jac still x leh lawan vokal ct. Ct is amazing singer...
relek ar ....bknnyer jerit cam ko pon....ko pernah dgr pontianak 'menjerit' ker...asyik nak komen org mende yg buruk jer bajet diri tu bgus sgt....boleh ke jerit sesedap dier????!!!
siti nyani mcm puki dia baru kena tebuk dua jam sebelum dia buat persembahan memang pantat nak bandign gan jac konon jac dah tinggi darjat sedangkan siti hanya kaya dgn populariti murahan .. tak malu i hate her now walaupun satu ketika dulu kau peminat setia dia ... aku benci dia jgn bandignkan dia dgn jac dia tak layak
ish..kenapa?siti sakitkan hati kau ke? semua orang tahu suara siti bagus. jac pun bagus.tapi jac pernah ke menang award dari luar negara?wakilkan jac masa di festival Voice of Asia pun kalah.aku pun suka jac..anda dinasihatkan bercakap lebih sopan.
wei..apehal ko benci dier sgt wei...nak memuki muki plak kat cni....kurang2 ct tuboleh nyanyi kalo nak bnding ngn ko yg nyanyi ntah ape2...lg cam 'puki' agaknye....bler plak ct publisiti murahan....dua2 ader kelebihan.....org malaysia jgak....so takde alasan nak memantat-mantatkan org kat cni.....kalo ko ckp org camtu....ko tu 100 kali lebih pNTAT dr dier,....hahhaha
to my mind, jac is better with english songs while siti is better with malay tunes.. jac has powerful voice but it's not soulful like ct... anyhow, both have strength n weaknesses, but, both can go well internationally.. for the sake of MALAYSIA....
semua org tau, suara siti ada buluh perindu, setiap org yg mendengar suaranya selalu rindu utk mendengarkan lagi dan lagi, so impresive ...siti bisa jd lagenda becoz "there is somthing in her voice". jac is best in festival, but siti lbh membuat hati berkesan tak tau why?
When i first heard jac's version, i was spellbound! It was amazing how she modulated the song to her own style. However, kak siti's version here sounds flat, dull and typical of any classic song. Her style is relativly unimpressive.
OMG very beautiful voice of siti!!
WannIsmailNaqiuddin 4 months ago
like..like
gemilang2011 5 months ago in playlist p.ramlee
klasiknyeee...boleh tertido dengar..best
animax8221316 5 months ago
siti nak mintak hadirin tunggu sekejab boleh ke? mmg kelasss
frosberry 8 months ago
siti legend lahhh, love u datuk :)
shapixable 9 months ago
i love datu ct, u r the legend OK !!
shapixable 9 months ago
suka jac lagi..
atzbest 1 year ago
best arrrrr... ct nyanyi
fauzone1000 1 year ago
siti the BEST.....jac suarenye nyaring.....but still best....both have their own style....
TheHanalia96 1 year ago
teringat kata m nasir,,, siti ni SUARA... dia tidak memerlukan keadaan keadaan tertentu dia tidak memerlukan trend sebab dia adalah SUARA... dia boleh berada di mana mana zaman...
badomok 1 year ago 6
lenggok tu yang mahalnya..susah nk tiru..
hafizdnsh 1 year ago
sebenarnye ade rahsie yg sangat2 besar disebalik lagu ni, lagu ni dicipte khas oleh P Ramlee utk Saloma , siti ke jac ke bawak terime & alunkan laguni sebagai lagu yg baik &dialunkan dng baik sbb mereke memang penyanyi yg baik tp x kan same mcm Saloma yg mengalunkan lagu ni ikhlas dari lubuk hatinye sebagai inspirasi cinte(rekod utk sarjin Hassan-belum bergelar isteri P Ramlee) dan kenangan cinte (rekod tahun70an-setelah PRamlee tiade)
classic3s 2 years ago 2
lagu Saloma is always stayed for Saloma
not for anyone else.Lagu CT is always for CT...u get what i mean Guys....
sh1961ify 2 years ago 3
suara ct ada lenggok sikit....tu yang bunyi merdu nyanyi lagu ni......suara jac pun sedap nyanyi lagu ni....tetapi arrangement muzik ni versi lain sikit dari jac nyanyi....
mrxtreme82 2 years ago 2
the best version belongs to Saloma, then Rafeah, then PRamlee, then CT, then Jac, then Sheila...if u ask me..
TheWanma 2 years ago 2
merepek la korang ni...
as someone said.. Jac n Siti suara dia org berbeza..
tak kan korang nk compare siti dgn saloma? saloma dgn jac?
or mariah carey dgn whitney?
hmmm....
both ada class tersendiri..
zee3737 2 years ago 4
i judged the song rendition on which one gives me goose bumps.... guess the original by p ramlee gives that (not fair due to contextual element) second jac due to its high hitting notes, but siti has the melodious hold.
longman67 2 years ago
love ct very muchhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh....
muahhhhh!! :D
ImNotMonster 2 years ago
siti is much much much much better than jac..but both are divas!!!
bisraya 2 years ago
erm, ekceli klu nak compare jac ngan siti memang takleh, sebab arrangement dorang cam ade beza sket bawak lagu ni kan? so bila ade beza for the music for sure ade org minat tech, ade org suka melodious, and so on.
anyway, support local artist, buy their album, and lastly...peace
ishlop 3 years ago 2
aku setuju.
bg aku jac dengan siti dua penyanyi yg sangat berbeza.. masing-masing no 1 dalam 'kelas' tersendiri.
suara jac jenis yang lantang, powerful & kuat.. kira kalo dengar memang buat orang bersemangat.
suara siti jenis yang sangat merdu, lebih ringan tetapi powerful.
Jac & siti, dua-dua aku minat & kagum.
inviscid86 2 years ago
Sedap ke, xsedap ke, yg penting time ni Panggung Sari IB penuh...
Merdu atau x terpulang pada telinga masing2. Sometimes we are biased bcoz of our affection towards an artist.
Bagi aku yg meminati Siti Nurhaliza, this is good but I like her Teratak Siti version better. I even like her rendition of Bunga Hutan.
Kpd yg mengutuk Siti tp memihak kpd Jac, suruhlah Jac nyanyi Bunga Hutan. We'll see who's the best and more versatile...hehe
senpai182 3 years ago 3
vtec ni tarikkkkkkkkkkkkkk!!!!!!!!!1
salambagas 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
suma yang komen di bawah ini telinga anjing ni xdapat beza yg merdu dan tak merdu...muakakakak.. FUCK U ALL MOTHER FUCKERS!!
SITI SUARA CAM KATAK KENE PIJAK..!! MIAKAKAKA..
rangmuda 3 years ago
DIAM LAH KO!! SHUT THE FUCK UP!!!!
thatsitlah 3 years ago
ahh. syadap u hanjing!
rangmuda 3 years ago
diamlah ko BABI KURAP MO MAMPUS!!!!!!
thatsitlah 3 years ago
ko lah telingaa hanjing, babi & lahanat..
siti the best!!!
DivaCTku 3 years ago 3
Tak payah la nak compare siti ngan artis lain.. Dah jelas siti bawak natural jer. Tak perlu nak jerit utk hit the high note. Sedap je telinga mendengar.. Ct the best
DivaCTku 3 years ago 11
This comment has received too many negative votes show
yap... sebenarnya P.Ramlee sedap nyayi lagu ni. artis2 lain merosakkan adalah. siti pun aku benci..huahuahua
rangmuda 3 years ago
gi mampus ko la. macam la ko bagus sgt.
ellowish 3 years ago 3
go and fuck ur self lah..mcm pukimak... get out from here.. nama rangmuda tapi mcm sialan makan babi...!!!!
thatsitlah 3 years ago
xsedap la siti nyanyi lagu ni... sakit telinga ...yang paling sedap bawak lagu ni cuma dua orang aja.. iaitu Rafeah Buang & Jacklyn Victor.. serius cakap..(^_^)
IcamStudio 3 years ago
Oii!!, hang gi tengok dier nyanyi lagu ni dalam Teratak Siti Nurhaliza. 10x ganda lebih baik dari sesiapa yg pernah nyanyikan lagu ni.
ellowish 3 years ago
woii..!! aku dah tgok dah.. memang x sedap langsung..xda kemantapan..xde feel! setakat ni Jacklyn paling feel bila bawak lagu ni..
IcamStudio 3 years ago
ahahaha, ni yg ko kata sedap? bodo. jac bawak ni kurang melodious. Siti is more melodious!. NGOK!
ellowish 3 years ago 2
ala..feel mcmana pun..TETAP KALAH DALAM ASIAN IDOL AND IKON ASIA tu.. bikin malu..! yuck..taw menjerit2 jak tapi NO SENI AT ALL>> ellowish..im with you.. ^_^
thatsitlah 3 years ago
Fuiiyooooooooooooo sedap gila babas
goosebump
Tipintaktipu 3 years ago
suara Dato siti merdu giler..fuh..meremang dgr siti nyanyi lagu ni....... superb!
thatsitlah 3 years ago
ct the best....
havy1991 3 years ago
npe u ol nih bodoh sgt...
gado sal artis nih...
sbnrnyer sume pon mcm sial lah...
siti mmg best tp aku x ske dier mek laki org...
hahaha
gado lah korg smpi mampos
afizudin2345 4 years ago
npe u ol nih bodoh sgt...
gado sal artis nih...
sbnrnyer sume pon mcm sial lah...
siti mmg best tp aku x ske dier mek laki org...
hahaha
gado lah korg smpi mampos
afizudin2345 4 years ago
OMG.. Meremang aku dgr ct bawak lagu ni walaupun dah byk kali dgr ct perform this song. But kali ni sgt menjadi. Ternyata dah kahwin ct still maintain. Even jac still x leh lawan vokal ct. Ct is amazing singer...
DivaCTku 4 years ago
Ok2 jerr la..Xde la best sngt mcm jac atau yg paling best..the ori by P.Ramlee!!!
zaid2410 4 years ago
P Ramlee ker plak yg nyanyi lagu nie..
Setaju aku dlm citer Sarjan Hassan tu pompuan yg nyanyi...
Ayu giler suara P Ramlee kalau gitu..
X tau plak kalau P Ramlee ada nyanyi..
MichealangeloJunior 3 years ago 3
Yeke ponpuan yg nyanyi lgu tue? Hm...
zaid2410 3 years ago
Ha'ah... Ko tengok citer Sarjan Hassan..
P Ramlee & awek dier (dlm citer tu) nyanyi time basuh baju... Then, dorang pun membesar..
Kalau aku x silap la..
X pernah lagi dgr P Ramlee nyanyi lagu nie...
X tau plak kalau ada..
MichealangeloJunior 3 years ago 3
but.. i dont think so... huhu..
etiek 4 years ago
setuju...
sape suruh nyanyi jerit2...
ingat merdu sangat ke jerit2 tu..
lagu yg patutnya sedap jd cam jeritan pontianak jer... hehehe...
etiek 4 years ago
relek ar ....bknnyer jerit cam ko pon....ko pernah dgr pontianak 'menjerit' ker...asyik nak komen org mende yg buruk jer bajet diri tu bgus sgt....boleh ke jerit sesedap dier????!!!
2006625037 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
siti nyani mcm puki dia baru kena tebuk dua jam sebelum dia buat persembahan memang pantat nak bandign gan jac konon jac dah tinggi darjat sedangkan siti hanya kaya dgn populariti murahan .. tak malu i hate her now walaupun satu ketika dulu kau peminat setia dia ... aku benci dia jgn bandignkan dia dgn jac dia tak layak
mamalovepapa 4 years ago
ish..kenapa?siti sakitkan hati kau ke? semua orang tahu suara siti bagus. jac pun bagus.tapi jac pernah ke menang award dari luar negara?wakilkan jac masa di festival Voice of Asia pun kalah.aku pun suka jac..anda dinasihatkan bercakap lebih sopan.
epalpink88 4 years ago 2
wei..apehal ko benci dier sgt wei...nak memuki muki plak kat cni....kurang2 ct tuboleh nyanyi kalo nak bnding ngn ko yg nyanyi ntah ape2...lg cam 'puki' agaknye....bler plak ct publisiti murahan....dua2 ader kelebihan.....org malaysia jgak....so takde alasan nak memantat-mantatkan org kat cni.....kalo ko ckp org camtu....ko tu 100 kali lebih pNTAT dr dier,....hahhaha
2006625037 4 years ago
to my mind, jac is better with english songs while siti is better with malay tunes.. jac has powerful voice but it's not soulful like ct... anyhow, both have strength n weaknesses, but, both can go well internationally.. for the sake of MALAYSIA....
ZenoRyu 4 years ago 2
semua org tau, suara siti ada buluh perindu, setiap org yg mendengar suaranya selalu rindu utk mendengarkan lagi dan lagi, so impresive ...siti bisa jd lagenda becoz "there is somthing in her voice". jac is best in festival, but siti lbh membuat hati berkesan tak tau why?
p4atoYT 4 years ago 4
When i first heard jac's version, i was spellbound! It was amazing how she modulated the song to her own style. However, kak siti's version here sounds flat, dull and typical of any classic song. Her style is relativly unimpressive.
acvdj 4 years ago
Okay Siti version not nice
leoshanbob 4 years ago
she has gotten fat!!
cepacol06 4 years ago
hm....i love both of them..jaq n ct..well ct r sweet n jaq r vouge..dey both r like diva
Monsopiad22 4 years ago
wat a sweet-sounding voice...jac is also good in singing this song..i like both of them
zikrane83 4 years ago
jac nyaring, siti lunak n penuh lemak merdu. walau pape pun, dua2 best. have their own stail...
ziriman 4 years ago
jack is better...juz an opinion...PEACE!!! ^^
rsosong 4 years ago