I would be so incredibly excited about this if it was in the original German.. the fact that it's in English makes me the complete opposite; I wish it had not been made.
There is always something lost in translation and it is obvious from just this trailer that all of the charm of Shikaneder's words has been lost. How disappointing.
Grr classical masterpiece being mind for pop culture tripe! We must not have it down-graded to one of the best languages that has produced the most and best literature in the world! Such a shame when something is downgraded for the masses. How dare anyone re-interpret the master! That said I would love to see a German language one as well. It could happen, depends on the zeitgeist.
Depends on whether a German millionaire will cough up the money to fund it, like Peter Moores was willing to do... I dearly hanker after a 'traditional' setting, though - does it really need reinterpretation? I think not. The opera is as fresh as ever.
(and Im not trying to be a bitch I am honestly curious)
A great many fine authors have written in english as well. No one objects when something origionally in english is translated into another language.
I do see how its different with opera because the composer intended for the music to sound a certain way but I just want ot know why people seem to hate english in general.
Hi! If only people would read my comment entirely. I am after all trained in classic Shakepeare and love the language. Here is what I wrote that should have made you realize I love English, "We must not have it down-graded to one of the best languages that has produced the most and best literature in the world!" I think it's ridiculous people upset about opening up a classic to more people.
STEPHEN FRY wrote the English libretto and he's a clever man with a fine appreciation of poetry. I look forward to this. Mozart wrote German operas for German and Austrian people and he wrote for kings and the music hall. So I think he'd approve.
uneducated americans wont watch it anyway. and I doubt that many educated americans will either. Branagh has fucked up here translating that libretto. Lets blame the producers.
Actually, this film wasn't released in America or intended for America. It was released in (and seemingly intended for) the UK and France. And as Kenneth Branagh is British, not American, this film was most likely intended for the British people.
I really look forward to this. It could be seen as the English interpretation of a classic. It looks like he has really caught the whimsy and joy. Maybe others are worrying he hasn't caught the darkness. But that is inherit in fairy tales. As Heisenberg said Germans are big dreamers and dreams have dark and light, they are fantastic.
very niiiiiiiiiiiiiiiice
asr1sdr 2 years ago
I would be so incredibly excited about this if it was in the original German.. the fact that it's in English makes me the complete opposite; I wish it had not been made.
There is always something lost in translation and it is obvious from just this trailer that all of the charm of Shikaneder's words has been lost. How disappointing.
mitch1601 4 years ago
Grr classical masterpiece being mind for pop culture tripe! We must not have it down-graded to one of the best languages that has produced the most and best literature in the world! Such a shame when something is downgraded for the masses. How dare anyone re-interpret the master! That said I would love to see a German language one as well. It could happen, depends on the zeitgeist.
shiversandchills 4 years ago
Depends on whether a German millionaire will cough up the money to fund it, like Peter Moores was willing to do... I dearly hanker after a 'traditional' setting, though - does it really need reinterpretation? I think not. The opera is as fresh as ever.
Mimameior 4 years ago
why does every one hate english so much?
(and Im not trying to be a bitch I am honestly curious)
A great many fine authors have written in english as well. No one objects when something origionally in english is translated into another language.
I do see how its different with opera because the composer intended for the music to sound a certain way but I just want ot know why people seem to hate english in general.
ajkl27 3 years ago
well frankly if something promises to inject even the slightest bit of real culture in to the american main stream I can do nothing but support it.
I dont doubt some things will get lost in translation but the music is still beautiful.
As long as it is well performed I dont think it will be too much worse for having been made in english.
ajkl27 3 years ago
Hi! If only people would read my comment entirely. I am after all trained in classic Shakepeare and love the language. Here is what I wrote that should have made you realize I love English, "We must not have it down-graded to one of the best languages that has produced the most and best literature in the world!" I think it's ridiculous people upset about opening up a classic to more people.
shiversandchills 3 years ago 2
Ingmar bergman's is the best one.
savpatz75 4 years ago
I have seen it. I would not say it is the best just because Ingmar is attached to it. It will be nice to see a fresh interpretation.
shiversandchills 4 years ago
STEPHEN FRY wrote the English libretto and he's a clever man with a fine appreciation of poetry. I look forward to this. Mozart wrote German operas for German and Austrian people and he wrote for kings and the music hall. So I think he'd approve.
steerpike66 4 years ago 2
i am so sorry they did it in english, i think it look cute, but they should not done it.
fernandoayuela 4 years ago
is this already out??
lickm 4 years ago
otherwise uneducated americans wouldn't watch it
lickm 4 years ago
uneducated americans wont watch it anyway. and I doubt that many educated americans will either. Branagh has fucked up here translating that libretto. Lets blame the producers.
wozzeck 4 years ago
Actually, this film wasn't released in America or intended for America. It was released in (and seemingly intended for) the UK and France. And as Kenneth Branagh is British, not American, this film was most likely intended for the British people.
blackpython 4 years ago
Agreed. Besides, I'll watch it. :)
wongumfie 4 years ago
I really look forward to this. It could be seen as the English interpretation of a classic. It looks like he has really caught the whimsy and joy. Maybe others are worrying he hasn't caught the darkness. But that is inherit in fairy tales. As Heisenberg said Germans are big dreamers and dreams have dark and light, they are fantastic.
shiversandchills 4 years ago
Ew. They're doing it in English? Why?
zacharybr 4 years ago