Carrie Underwood - Alone (American Idol - Season 4 / 2005)

[patsbeer]

She should rock out more often!

[sweetdreams134]

WOW RYAN SEACREST LOOKS SOOOO DIFFERENT i just had to point that out

[padboi24]

AWESOME! She looks like the Girl On "Romy & Michelles High School Reunion"

[nadrojh97]

SIMON WAS RITE!! SO SHUT UP PAULA!!

[superstitious08]

She looks like Emily Osment so much and she sounds like her when she talks!!

[MrBobbyJ22]

simon was right paula and randy she was and is the best idol ever

[MeekoTown]

no one on idol since have ever even come to how great this performance was

[ZZUBDAA]

So many people have tried to sing this song. Carly Smithson, Alison Iraheta, and Jacob Lusk. Jacobs was very good too, but no one has come close to Carrie's, truly amazing!!

[MeekoTown]

best ever on idol

[makeitrain483]

40 seconds into the song and i already got chills. damn, this girl's got it goin' on.

[livetodancexox]

btw paula and randy

simon was right

she did sell more than anyone else

and she was played on the radio

and was better than everyone else.

[livetodancexox]

carrie underwood and kelly clarkson are the only superstars that have come out of american idol and actually did something, and was successful and lasted.

and all the other people who disagree can bitch about it

but numbers dont lie, and neither does their loyal fan bases.

every year they will find a winner

but not a star.

[japeetila]

CARRIE UNDERWOOD IS THE ONLY WINNER IN HISTORY WHO HAS DONE WELL AMAZINGLY LIKE KELLY CLARKSON..

TAYLOR HICKS, KRIS ALLEN, RUBEN,LEE DEE WIZE ARE JUST A CAPITAL F L O P!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1!

[DMBobcat09]

Obviously Simon was Bull's Eye Accurate. Paula was just jealous because Carrie is young beautiful & talented! If someone's got the talent than acknowledge them for it. That is all Simon was doing.

[pdd3517]

Simon was right. So far she HAS sold more and makes more money than any other Idol winner.

[HHSvbmvp]

she is so awesome!! idk why she didn't win she's bigger than that taylor hicks guy now. I don't even think I heard anything about him sence then

[aznboi1428xxxxx]

@HHSvbmvp she did win...

[bentla17]

@HHSvbmvp Carrie Underwood DID win.

[CrazyyMonkeyy12]

i like how she started with the 2nd verse that's what i would have done

[xxTaylorLambert18xx]

adam lambert's mad world performance is the greatest performance ever!!!

and the 2nd, is the performance of carrie underwood

[nema1218]

I remember this,I so want to go back to 2005,best year ever! I graduated high school and so many good stuff,not to mention American Idol was great,now its awful.Great video,Carrie's moment.I want to go back to 2005.

[erdancer214]

i forgot allll about this, but idk

how i could! she is so amazing.

her voice is so clear and beautiful,

completely effortless. & love the hair!

simon always ends up being right :)

[dsscam]

Simon was right. The others suck. Carrie Underwood is a '10' - she is perfect in every way. With her next album, she'll overtake Kelly Clarkson again as those two battle it out for a career for all time #1 Idol Winner

[row759]

to dsscam, I don't even consider a battle because Carrie is going to easily overtake Kelly with album sales from what I am reading, everybody can't wait until November 3, when her new album titled "Play On" hit stores, the reason I know what the title is, USA Today had it in monday's Life Section, front page.

[dsscam]

Row, Wow! You're a big Carrie fan. I clicked on your profile. Yeah, she's the only girl I've ever fallen in love with via televison. : ) She's an angel with an angelic voice. She's the one 'star' who deserves all the accolades.

[row759]

to dsscam, anythhing wrong with being a fan of hers, she is only singer I know that can go from high to low and back up to high with such ease and she easily will outdo Kelly, I have no doubts about that.

[crashf0rce]

@row759 I think you guys aren't considering that Carrie doesnt sell very well overseas. Kelly has WAY better interanational sales.

[row759]

@crashf0rce , yes, I am considering, Kelly even with overseas, which I think Carrie will over take Kelly in longer even with overseas sales, Carrie is that good or should i say better than Kelly anyday and anytime. If there ever was competition between Carrie and Kelly, Carrie wins hands down with doubt.

[crashf0rce]

Im not saying that Kelly or Carrie is better. But you obviously are not thinking logically about international sales. Carrie has 3 million international album sales, Kelly has 12 million. If Carrie was to continue her International sales pattern, she would need to release 9 more albums.

[row759]

@crashf0rce , I was just waiting to see how Carrie's new album was going to do and I think it will another million or more seller very quickly. Even though Kelly and Carrie are in different music genre, Carrie is still way better than Kelly. Carrie has 11 consective No.1 singles now to her credit. And I still say Carrie will over take album sales with or without international sales help. But countries overseas know about Carrie and they will buy her records.

[cliff90]

allison's sounded kinda forced but carrie's more natural.

[kazdaddy830]

i liked allison version better. but i think carrie is the best idol we've seen thus far

[rbrtlee]

this is when i knew she had it in the bag!!

[bloodgirl658]

ditto!

[v6horse]

allison can't even stand in the same room as carrie underwood

[firebender097]

@v6horse speak for yourself!you cant compare them...allison is younger than carrie and they are 2 different ppl.the way they sing is also different but i love em both!

[Lennox2269]

ITS CHICKEN LITTLE!!

[kbarbary5]

No it wasn't I think he was the year after that is Anthony Fedorov

[truebloodfinatict8]

allison was better

[si92uw]

allison iraheta is as good as carrie carrie a little bit better but she's older lol

:) :): )

[teeftaller7]

Carrie Underwood Wins Entertainer Of The Year

[cleverheart123]

the "highest selling singer" is really a very stupid thing, and for me, i don't love comparing singers to each other.. cause kelly has a tone in her voice, and carrie has compleletly different one.. and in season 8 in the idol.. i don't know who i want to win, i want allison, cause she has a tone, and megan, cause when i hear them i knew its allison or megan, so chill out people, kelly and carrie both are awesome!

[ljbless]

i think what simon means is...the previous winners....he does'nt mean "singers"...coz that is for all the singers in the industry....and hey,,,lets face it...she sale a lot of albums and win more trophies or awards than the "previous american idol winners".......PEACE BUDDY"

[deparis29]

Ah that was the night when they messed up with the numbers and they had to replay the previous night's performance with the correct number....Mikalah Gordon left the following day....it was unfortunate cuz i wanted her to go in tour...hehhehehe....i love carrie!!!

[mitchburns82]

lmfao... bet randy and paulla want to agree with simon now...

[dsetzer19]

she's still only the 2nd highest seller... though I do agree w/ Simon's point that Carrie is amazing, Kelly Clarkson is #1

[Traxtitan]

Kelly is number 1 right now, but won't be for long. Carrier is one of the most respected country singers in the world right now. She has the fastest selling country album in history.

Kelly had a great first two albums, but nobody cares about her anymore. She isn't one of the most respected pop singers, and when she releases a new album, she will be lucky if it goes platinum.

Carrier has stayed making great music. If she had released another album by now, she would be the number 1 seller.

[sungmu1]

No. She didnt ruin it, but in no way does it compare to the original. If you want to hear an awesome version of this song, download the LIVE version thats on Playlist: The Very Best Of Heart! Track #4. Gives me goose bumps!

[xeromos]

man shes beautiful

[BaggyJeansBoy]

This is one of the Top 5 American Idol Contestant Vocal moments ever... SO many people remember this performance and this is exactly what Simon wants every week.

[countrymusicluver13]

why is alot of people commenting on her hair!!!?? it doesnt matter she sang her butt off that night and she rocked it

[cleverheart123]

actually i loved her hair, and ur absolutly right, no one should comment on anything but her voice!

[McR328]

LOL! It's funny how SImon is almost always right!

[bryceverlinden22222]

the best idol ever! i think kelly comes in next though!

[ealymc]

wow... Simon was right! I think she HAS sold the most records of any Idol in history at this point!!

[Undiscovereddaisy]

THIS is the best vocal performance in AI history .. I always remember this one .. its gorgeous

[SirLunchbox8907]

Still my favorite performance ever on AI.

Melinda Doolittle's 'My Funny Valentine' is close to it.

[lunestabutterfly]

wat witht the hair though

[alisonnicole84]

This is my favorite AI performance ever. So amazing.

[blooddaisy]

my favourite son! she is really good...

[smr2008]

my favorite song that she sang on american idol. i knew she was going to win when i heard this. amazing.

[wickedphant0m]

Something about her first "'Till now" is just enthralling...I've listened to the same 5 seconds like 20 times.

[Biggsy22]

She's so hot

[ljjcetcmeamjj]

the best idol performance in all 8 seasons i wish she would record this song

[alisonnicole84]

I agree

[onedimpledcheek]

One of the best vocals in Idol history.

She blew it out of the water.

Subsequent contestants have chosen this song, and they can't touch this performance. It's flawless.

The dancing's weird, but only because she was a little out of her element with something other than country. This song's actually upbeat.

[Spkn07]

@onedimpledcheek

What dancing??.. the swaying left to right a few inches? That ain't dancing bud

[Louze09]

thanx for download

[Jaimeg187]

I want to bang her........

[charlliebbz]

amazing voice

she lacks a little emotion

doesnt sing it from the heart

[ch3a]

i love how simon was right about his prediction though hah

[ashluvsjb8]

omg i loved it when she sang this!!!!

[gomounties08]

this is my all time favorite performance from any season

carrie underwood's voice is flawless

[DarkLove95]

her voice is awesome but her hair is...WOW

[CarrieIsDaBomb]

LOLL

[Gochoir]

I Did

[l33r]

Who knew Simon would be right!

[gomounties08]

i did :)

i loved her from beginning to end