Added: 4 years ago
From: Salzomancer
Views: 2,214,699
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (2,467)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Is this what white people do all day? Drink alcohol while mourning over some girl that cheated on you?

  • Nice work

  • wow---I was all ready to be nasty but I really liked it!!! when something is as good as this all a guy can do is enjoy. thanks.

  • Thank you for your interpretation! I never thought of this song like you depicted. Artist expression is priceless as is Pink Floyd.

  • RONPAUL2012 . COM

    

  • the whole theme with him sitting in the chair as his memories play out before him reminds me of the video for comfortably numb from the wall...well done. great video and i could probably listen to this song forever

  • a good video, but its just not how i interpret the song . thats not a bad thing .

  • You really did a great job on this video...I think It was a great way express one of the many different interpations of this song!! Love Pink Floyd!!

  • dude this is the best vid and best song of all time, pink floyds music is the best it speaks to me sooooo much and in so many ways plus they jut have awesome songs. This video touched my heart i can relate to itt.

    LOVE U PINK FLOYD best band ever

  • I know how you feel....

  • freakin AWESOME video! makes me think back and remember a lot of things.

  • I dare 197 people to try and make a better video!

  • this is the best song ever... it means so much to me...

  • Somebody should have cleaned that kitchen before filming.

  • @jasonbeaman86 Somebody should shut the hell up and watch the damn video.

  • awesome video my man! best darn song EVER!!!

  • he doesen't play guitar solo in the beginning. that's shit video

  • You are talented and how creative of you to use this song. There's something in there big things await.

  • pink floyd what can i say?? my top 10 fave songs by this band!

  • salzomamcer TRUELY BRILL VID 10.111.111 STARS

  • one of the most incredible songs ever

  • good stuff

  • This song IS a love song. Whether that love is for a woman, a man, a friend, a family member, or hell even for a part of yourself. It's up to you to decide what the song means for YOU. I know Roger Waters had his own meaning for the song, but in the end the meaning behind the song is what you want it to be, what you take out of it. That's why it's called art (and yes, music is art for those of you who would say no). It's open for interpretation, all good art is.

  • I think you've really captured something here.

  • I think you guys need to read what the videographer wrote. It was a school project. The very fact that he chose a Floyd song lends itself to the notion that he quite likely knows the legend behind the song (Roger Waters missed Syd Barrett). The video itself was done quite well, and let's face facts, most of us think of it as a love song. No matter what the great Sir Waters was thinking. And I DO mean that seriously, not sarcastically. Waters is a genius.

  • this song is not about a woman man relationship

  • Good work men!!!!

  • bimo e stupenda sta conzone e tutta x teeee

  • be che dire mi sento un po fuori.....dato che sono lunico a postare in italiano :)

    cmq dada questa e x teeee ti amo.

    by affus

  • Nice video! Love the song and imagery is pretty well done! Keep up the good work!

  • Wow... that was absolutely amazing. I loved every second of that, that was just awe inspiring. Very great job. Hats off.

  • DUDE UR VI IS SO AWESOME

    PINK FLOYD IS THE BEST!

  • Those were some enormous shoes you tried to fill. Congrats the video was great. You just have to know that some people will never understand that this video was YOUR interpretation of the music, not a literal translation of Roger's intent. Again, great job. It broke my heart as it should.

  • Hope you got an "A" Great video!

  • This song was written about and dedicated to syd Barrett. It's about being alone and thinking of the people you want to be with you (a close friend, a family member etc.). But that's my opinion, anyways, this is a really good video. I liked it a lot

  • I like this video a lot. I think he did a good job capturing the loneliness and despair this song has. I love it.

  • decsent music video bra,.. keep on keepin on

  • thats water bro!!! lol like the song but the vid suck!!!! well good try dont ever do it again.

  • cool vid man

  • I am so glad I decided to watch this. Job very very well done!!!!!

  • Awesome job on the video, loved it! One of my fav PF songs :)

  • gay ass song...and the vid is worst

  • @3967love, then why listen? Geez..... hater

  • @3967love You, Sir, are a jackass. Please keep your disgusting, comments to yourself and respect these musicians. You will never even dream of writing anything close to being as beautiful as this song is.

  • that was awesome :D

  • good ass song!!!!1 good job on the video =>

  • Very nice!!!

  • Great song. Good effort with the video, seriously...liked it!

  • Great Lyrics, vocals ALL GOOD

  • Well done. To the rest of you with negative comments, I would seriously like to see what you would come up with. As he said, this was a video project. I think he did a fantastic job.

  • Perfect. Bloody perfect.

  • 192 people slept when the mouse was crossing the dislike button so their head hit the mouse and clicked the dislike utton

  • Comment removed

  • can you tell?

  • WoW..... All I got to say about this is even though maybe this song isnt about him and his girlfriend, Its still a really good video. And so Phockin what if pink floyd wouldnt make a video like this. This isnt pink floyd making the video. I think Salzomancer has really captured what alot of us that does like Pink Floyd and we have had those kind of fights and break ups feel when we hear this song. SO I GIVE YOU HELLA PROPS for this video. Im a PinkFloydian all the way so FUCK OFF HATERS!!!!!!!!!

  • @wickedcarnnie PINKFLOYDIAN's SHALL RULE OUR WORLD

  • @wickedcarnnie Agree :)

  • Pink Floyd wouldn´t do a video like this , however nice try...!

  • Pink Floyd wouldn´t do a video like thsi, however nice try...!

  • This song is about Syd Barrett's sad descent into a mental wasteland and Roger Waters' lamenting about how much he misses his friend. Not about you and your girlfriend breaking up.

  • GREAT SONG! IT JUST MAKE YOU THINK HOW SAD AND PAINFUL LOVE CAN BE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • this isnt a real video

  • man, i shoudn't seen this video being drunk, it makes me feel like i have to call my ex girlfriend.

  • @ricoguillen.... I feel ya!!!! It does it to me too. =/

  • 192 people dont know what music is

  • man....i love this song so much......i wish he was here!!!!!! :'( i miss him but i guess it's time to move on.

  • Great Job.

  • See how he takes his hat off before he comes inside? Something about that action melts my heart.

  • i'm purely metal but i love this song very much.... nice vid...

  • Great video. Government and health care providers HAVE a cure to cancer, but can make more of a profit on prevention rather than the cure... Think about it. Why fix it when you can make more money selling parts....... And make a bigger profit on the parts. Something to think about and please pass this message on, copy it, etc. theres more going on than we realize...... Pass it on..... Before they catch on.. America used to be a great country, lately I have become worried.......

  • beautifull

  • what did you get on this project? you did a damn good job!

  • el dia que me entierrren quiero que suene esta cancion

    esta es la cancion de mi vida

    maravillosa

  • @botijo es lo mismo q pido

  • hey m8 i did a "how i wish you were" music video for a school work and

    your video was a great inspiration. thank you, for creating this masterpiece.

    I would like you to at least see my video when I upload it. Probably Saturday or Sunday.

  • such a beautiful song with a beautiful story congrats its amazing

  • i love the way he plays guitar big time!!!!!!

  • 187 people do not know what real music is!!!!!! people need to start listening to real music again and not that Justin bieber kid!!........ love this song its awesome and sad :'( pure and simple!!!!!

  • Heey, you can tell that he´s not from Sweden Finland or Norway. He drinks from a glass and not gobblin the whole bottle at once :)

    Anyway THX for uploading this classic, haven´t seen it in many years. Soo fu*king beautiful.

  • Nice portrayal of misery. I love the Pink Floyd score.

  • Nice portrayal of misery. I love the Pink Floyd score.

  • This is my fav song!

  • exelente video jajaja y me encanto el papel que jugo el gato :D

  • @Byrcobain huh? :/

  • i'd be hitting the bottle too if i lost a piece of ass like that !!! man oh man is she hot !!!

    i'm jerking the gerkin tonight !!!

  • But this song is about Sid and it`s just fabulous.

  • I always thought he wrote this song to his buddy Syd Barrett, i didnt know it was about a broad..................

  • @DanielJoe001 "Crazy Diamond" was about Syd. Same album.

  • l idee est bonne mais avec un peut plus de budget sa serait mieu.bref sa la du potentiel

  • the porch cat should be nominated for best actor in a music video.

  • RIP Syd Barrett

  • Esta canción como me trae recuerdos y siempre nostalgia.

    Simplemente de lo mejor de Pink Floyd

  • And the Grammy awards go to... PORCH CAT!!!

  • trop bon!!!!!!!!!

  • This song is so powerful, so touching and beautiful. And I really love the video you guys put together. phonomenal job!

  • Sick of "(# of Dislikes) people suck!" comments. Get used to differing opinions. You're ironically Disliking a Dislike, and I am disliking your disliking of a number of dislikes.

  • This song, as is the whole album, a tribute to Syd Barratt who by the time of recording this album in 1975 had become a recluse.

  • Nice. Thanks Salzomanzer.

  • muy bueno amigo

  • U ROCK GUYS!!!!!!!

  • OK 1 I know for a FACT this song was not based on a Girl.

  • the song is perfect, but...i'm very sorry...the video is very...normal...

  • hey leo its about what you want to hear not what the song is about, an artist doesnt paint a picture for you to see what hes done, but for you to interperet whats been done.

  • damn thats badass jusy damn

  • Sarah if you see this I just want to say I'm sorry please come back I miss you so much

  • This could be a white Stripes video. Nice job man.

  • Please, do not distort the music. It's not about a relationship, this song is about protest and you certainly do not know nothing about it.

  • she left you becuase of that fkn hat u gon on man...change that asap

  • Good job on the video and concept. But lol is never a good idea to drink your trouble away. they will still be there in the morning, but you'll have a hangover in addition :)

  • crapy quality, nice concept

  • 181 people deserve to rot in hell

  • This song was for syd who was too high on LSD, not a woman

  • @kjurko1 ....ANOTHER Syd advocate that can't get over it....music is supposed to take you many places you donk, it's not all black and white....Remember what Jerry Garcia said: "Every silver lining's got a touch of grey".....Syd took himself down, so please get over it.

  • 2:40 the house tree setting as they go their own ways

  • i like how u did the whole pink floyd the wall idea from the scene where pink is in his chair and then him and his chair and lamp, tv and table are at a field

  • te felicito esta chido man esta chidoooo

  • This is one of the greatest songs ever. This video is a miserable insult. Personal favorite: throwing the bread as if you wanted to make out w/ the microwave....hilarious

  • Sweet vid guy.

  • omfg this is just so... fucking amazing!!!!

    n im a 23yr old gurl so u aint gota be old, sad or a druggy to love n appreciate this wicked music!!!!!

  • Please take a listen to my new song I am A songwriter and just started a page.Please add me or subscribe I will do the same.Please comment on the song also..I am not trying to spam just trying to get some people to listen.Thank you so much!

  • I sincerely thought this was the official video. Very well done.

  • For all those here that don't like this ? Do you want me to buy you a hearing aid, yes a H E A R I N G A I D you deaf cunts

  • 180 dislikes??? are you people high?? haha how can you not like this song???

  • You better have got an A on this project

  • arte pura!!! (2)

  • Very cool you video ...excelent.. congratulation...could recommend one to do with the song Comfortably Numb?....

    Greetings from Mexico

  • arte pura

  • this is pretty good........

  • As this song is timeless so to is the truth of its lyrics as it relates to reality. Our reality

    is consumed by illusion and the idea that if we wait long enough a hero will save us.

    It has allways been up to us to make the choice and to stop letting the Main stream

    decide for us whom to villianize and who shall lead us. In the end we are all lost souls whom hide in cages as slaves of materialism as the cloth is being dragged over our eyes. Please speak out against tyranny. question all!

  • @endtyrany iluminati

  • @endtyrany well said brother

  • very well done

  • Nicely done!

  • 179 People love a good hard phallus in their mouth

  • i dont know but i thought this song was about syd barret, like a lot of pink floyd songs, not an ex girlfriend. correct me if i'm wrong. amazing song, but im putting a thumbs down to the video

  • @TheShampow44 its a better theme dont you think? or do you wish syd were with you? rather tnan the girl you loved

  • 178 people are mindless screaming justin bieber's fans

  • man that guy looks like my boyfriend :( i really miss him, especially on 3:32.

  • in the final she should have dissapeared it would have look with more drama...

  • Could be better if you lower the exposure of the argue scene. because the direct light makes it looks like daytime. But great idea, good video.

  • its me again. im obsessed with this video. i love you M

  • this is fantastic. wow

    I thought this was real at first. nice. im impressed

  • Damn! Wish those titties were here!!!!

    Dem's nice!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • om te huilen deze muziek

  • so is like the girl really ur girlfriend? that'd b cute if she was and u guys made this project together lol..it'd make u appreciate what u have

  • for my grandparents', my lovel, my now so far family, and pink floyd, wish you were here

  • 176 aren't here.

  • fabiooooooooooo......... i wish you were here

  • porch cat has the acting tallent in this video, whats with the head turning at the end?

  • GGGGGGGGGGGGGreat video and music. I'm only 11 but I can still tell this is awesome music

  • check out my uploads

    i learned this song yesterday evening

  • wish you were here... fabio...

  • Great vid. I loved it.

  • what are some other songs off of this album?

  • @DL345 Shine On You Crazy Diamond parts 1-8, Welcome To The Machine, Have A Cigar. Thats it.

  • Rest In Peace Richard and Syd... Wish both You Were Here... :(( [*] [*] (the lights of memory)

  • great video man

  • Thumbs up if porch cat is awesome!!!!!

  • @horrifyingegg porch cat has more tallent than the (so called) actors !

  • Matko . . . tego nie da się opisać słowami !

  • fabio... i wish you were here

  • I wish I were here.

  • love it...pink floyd dont do it much better than this..but they rock anyway

  • @XPHippiesXP43 sometimes people is weird. how i wish, how i wish U were here

  • i would have left just cos of the hat

  • Porch Cat ftw!

  • i love the song. video's not baaad :)