Added: 1 year ago
From: BBellidos
Views: 1,046,338
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,866)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • wow madonna did a good job compared to this

  • Take away the lighting and this really SUCKS!!

  • @machitopapi take away the vocals and it is really good

  • I have to say soooo much better than Madonna

  • compared to madonna, this is boooooooooooooooooooooooring.

  • They ruined "Sweet Child of Mine" and "I've Had the Time of My Life" among other crimes. 2012 definitely destroyed 2011. Even if Madonna lip synched two of her 4 songs, her performance still demolished this.

  • girl: YEAHHH USHER!!!

    mom: what about the black eyed peas?

    girl: ugh, dont remind me...

    mom: what did they do?

    girl: fergie broke my mic, will.i.am made autotune die, and the rest of them...well...

    mom:poor usher...

    girl: why?

    mom: he had to listen to their performance...i went deaf!

  • If you like Madonna's performance, might as well just listen to her ALBUM. She probably sounded worse than Fergie, so quit judging. BEP did a better performance than Madonna's awkward terrible grandma moves.

  • Comment removed

  • I Will Always Love The Black Eyed Peas! You Rocked! Amazing!

  • hey guys if my sister see you she can kill you hhh

    she looooves BEP and Fergie but really you don't think fergie is cool

    i mean if some one love Madonna or an other singer ther'se no probleme but just don't talk bad about they otherse

  • THIS VIDEO IS NOT A COMPARATIVE YOU ASSHOLE, if you don't like them, get out of here, i like Madonna too, but she made the worst dubbing EVER. And BEP are singing LIVE, just for you know.

  • Did you know Fergie peed herself during the halftime show? That's why everyone calls them the "Black Eyed Pees!"

  • Madonna is SOOOO much better!

  • at 00:45, think that's yelling

  • Naw ,

    Best Part Of This Was Usherr .

  • @ihasch mm I see your point, it is a tricky one isnt it I dont know why she mimed, i mean when she did Live 8 that was live and she did a great job? Ho hum. Fergie still sucks though lol

  • @gayham-True. I guess it's a philosophical question: Is a poor live performance still better than a compelling mimed performance? What about a mediocre one? I'll leave that to posterity. :)

  • mmmm aburridooooooo

  • WHY are they famous?

  • @justintylercarey theyve had some pretty big hits, and most of all, they produce and write most of their songs, which most artists rarely do.

    where is the love, my humps, i gotta feeling, boom boom pow, meet me halfway,

    imma be, just cant get enough

    all hard hitters on the billboard

    and its not like they always provide trashy autotuned songs, i mean "where is the love" is a known classic

  • @kimster1000 Where Is The Love is a good song. I like some of their music, but they are awful live performers. And that auto-tune shit they do is just pathetic. Don't they realize most people who have an ounce of musical responsiveness HATE auto-tune, especially LIVE auto-tune. They're not singers, they're producers and "songwriters". The only singer is Fergie, and she can't handle dancing and singing at the same time. She's so BLAH that she needs to sit in a chair to hit the right notes.

  • you can tell they weren't lip singing

  • ushers part was the only good thing sowi love bep

  • BEP RULES ! Fergie diva s22

  • I closed my eyes and for a second I thought I was sitting at the bar on karaoke night!

  • @ihasch watch Micheal Jacksons 93 super bowl performance, he is lip synching and has good choreography...but nobody dissed on him for doing it, I think partly because he is a man and also people just like to madonna bash.

  • @gayham-Then he is subject to the same criticism. I just think it's a bit much to start praising a singer who isn't singing based on "showmanship." That should include actually bothering to sing, St. Michael included.

  • BEST PART - 3:40

  • @ultimate1471 The ONLY good part. :)

  • Wait next year Slash should get his own half time show!

  • Too much autotune. I miss the days when Black Eyed Peas were Rock-Rap, Elephunk was their last good album....

  • BEP's concert was not one of the best, but Madonna was bad, I did not like her show! it is a great singer but I prefer fergie.

  • This was one of the worst superbowl perfromances ever! my god! fergie sucks ass. how the hell did she ever become a famous singer? Probally becasue shes a slut.

  • I love the b.e.p but Madonna killt it! She is waaaayyy bettah n she old

  • 53 years old Madonna moves more than this guys.

  • they had to have edited in the cheering...

  • All of them were terrible. The best part was Usher

  • What the heck is it with the live Autotune?!

    And the Mic's without even Reverb sounds like they can't sing..

    Few Years ago the had Tom Petty, Rolling Stones...how about that??

  • Why ant they have Larry gaga jaj z

  • Madonna was better!!!

  • GAGA FOR 2013!!

  • Oh good lord, Madonna was a million times better, much more entertaining

  • Oh Fergie...why!?!?

  • the only cool thing was the dancers lit up.

  • I was thinking, "Well this isn't as bad as everybody said it was," and then Fergie started singing "Sweet Child of Mine." >_<

  • @artizek did they even rehearse this show?

  • El espectaculo de madonna estuvo bien, pero creo yo que este espectaculo supera al de madonna ya que los invitados de black eye peas tocaron sus canciones y ellos como tributo las cantaron, bueno eso pienso y los invitados de madonna como que estuvieron mas limitados

  • So I guess this is why Madonna had to lip sing, because of this.

  • But at least they sung live. A playback show, no matter how expensive and extravagant, is still just a playback show.

  • be prepare for the future!!!i can't wait for gaga to perform to the superbowl!!!

  • Worst Superbowl I've ever seen. The best must be MJ and Madonna for sure. They were fun to watch, to hear and made you get excitement. This performance just wants you to hit the mute button and hit acid in your eyes. Fergie needs to learn the difference between screaming and singing high notes, she still thinks she does the latter but in reality it's the first. lol

  • What r u guys talkin bout?! This was WAY better than Madonna! They had the secret weapon...........USHER!!!!

  • Autotune, only for the most talented singers... derp

  • OMG.... The theme was to promote Tron: Legacy, characters from Tron should've lip-sync the song. Black eye peas=FAILED!!

  • Madonna can them cleans shoes hahahahaha miss playback show !

  • por lo menos ellos no hicieron playback como madonna :)

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • I rather had this performance again than Madonna ... Juust saying .

  • Jeder der von dehnen mal eine CD Gekauft hat müsste sein Geld zurückbekommen !

    Die sollen erstmal Singen Lernen bevor sie Geld damit verdienen das ist Betrug !!

  • Best part 9:10

  • c'mon now, where is the LOIE?

  • Sin ofender a otros artistas. ESTE FUE EL MEJOR MEDIO TIEMPO DE UN SUPER BOWL!! Viva Black Eyes Peas!!

  • there were two good parts to this show; Usher and the part where they went to a commercial at 12:50

  • @deepdnfawb lmfao. AMEN.

  • Way better then this years

  • Madonna no lo supero :/

  • That awkward moment when fergie watches this and realizes she can't sing!

  • @theKTOWNballer23 Maybe you should stick to watching recorded concerts where 20 recording engineers work countless hours to fix every little mistake and make it appear the artist is a perfect singer. Or you could watch Madonna lip sync.

  • those guy back up dancers make usher look gay

  • see this instead of saying Madonna was better U gon' say dat Madonna was better? Then say it in her videos dumbasses This was amazing cuz they actually tried singing!Madonna was amazing as well because she actually moved around Evry artist has something special U dont have 2 hate I get dat ders some people dat dont like it but u dont have to rub it in I luv both performances watch da video! if ur gon' b saying how amazing Madonna was(true) den say amazing comments at her videos I made my point!!

  • AT LEAST ITS REAL

  • I don't see what you guys are complaining about...you try singing/performing for 12 minutes straight, it's not easy.& to make up them not singing they had all those dancers/cool light effects. At least they actually sang instead of lip syncing cause people would give them a lot more crap for NOT singing. No matter what these performers do you guys always find something to complain about. Let's see you put something better together and put on a show that entertains people for 12 minutes.

  • this was really nice! i have to say that the only person who ever got me to see the super bowl was madonna.... and as much as i like this i have to say madonna kicked ass!!! even if she chose not to sing the whole thing ..music and give me all your luvin...she did sing everything but with a strong vocal backings if u cant tell the difference people should just shut up...... she is amazing and this show by the bep showes why u need to lip sync in these shows! nomatter what she rocked it hard!

  • Okay this was pretty good so was Madonna's so stop hating :)

  • Madonna was SO much better, a true show woman, I wish the Peas HAD lip synched, it would of made it sound far better, perhaps they would of moved around more? They sound really bad but its not just the singing, the whole show is badly directed, even the costumes. And to add Fergie should never be allowed near a microphone again.

  • @gayham-I'm not a BEPs fan (this is not a strong performance) but doesn't artistic honesty count for anything? Maybe I'm old-fashion, but it's not OK to lip-synch just because the choreography is good. So it doesn't matter if you don't sing if you put on a "show"? Funny, but I thought a singer actually singing was a integral part of the show. I guess not. Now we accept dishonest performances and treat a "live" performance as a glorified music video where we just critique the costumes.

  • @gayham yeah they suck asz no doubt but at least they didnt lip sync the whole damn thing and stubble on their heels xD

  • Even if they would have sounded great, which they didn't, i still found it kinda boring. They mostly stood in the same spot the whole time. Definitely preferred Madonna

  • The best part of this was when Fergie wasn't singing.

  • I LOVEE MADONNA!!! AMAIZING

  • Don't like BEP or Madonna, but this was SO much better than Madonna. At least these guys TRIED to sing. Madonna didnt even give it a shot.

  • I saw yesterday's performance, madonna sung 3 songs live only one song playback, and sounded great especially in Like A prayer, yeah she did use autotune on music but at least it suited her unlike these BEP who sounded like goats, this is the undisputed worst halftime show ever, madonna saved the halftime yesterday, she didn't stand in one place, the show was all about her, here anytime the camera zooms on the black eyed peas i'm like "no no , go back to the shiney dancers'. M>>BEP. a fact!

  • @mediasansnom Yeah, I really do not think that she sang three songs live. There may have been a few live portions, but I'm pretty sure that the majority of her "singing" was prerecorded. I'm not a BEP fan, nor do I think this was a great performance, but I honestly enjoyed it more than Madonna. Mediocre singing is better than lip-syncing.

  • @WalrusDance maybe you just don't know how madonna sounds live, so you can't really judge, she didn't do major dancing just so that she could sould decent, plus at times her mic would turn off (due to the little time they had to do the soundcheck in). watch madonna like a prayer live hope for hait, she sung like a peayer the exact same way. And by the way, there were way more things to madonna's performance than just her singing, so she beats BEP's asses

  • at least the try to sing , not just like madonna , slash did pretty good making the show better.

  • BEP was terrible. worst half time show ever. Madonna was 100x better than this BS! Fergie needs to just stop. Wtf was she doing to Slash lmao Soo bad

  • I love them both Madonna & BEP are great performers

  • What the fuck... Madonna was thousand ways better !!

    Ok, the black eyed Peas were great but not so great like madonna

  • It sounds not very good, but they even tried to sing live......not playback like Madonna

  • Not only was this performance garbage, but the original songs are garbage to begin with.

  • I love the Black Eyed Peas but I was a little disappointed in this performance. I have to give them credit though for performing these songs live. It's REALLY hard to do, especially when you have to sing in a venue like that. It's really hard to sound like you're singing on pitch so I have to give them props.

  • Just Enjoy The Fucking Show! Stop Criticizing Everything!

  • DAMN these songs do NOT work live.

  • they really are awful

  • beats by dre

  • The only thing worse than the Madonna halftime show was this halftime show. The music/entertainment industry is getting more and more pathetic by the minute.

  • No Talent

  • This is the worst halftime show in the history of football.

  • Much better than Madonna's. Here's why: they didn't fuckin' lip sync it, their visuals were much better, they performed more songs and they were asked to perform because of their huge success in 2009 not in order to gain success from the performance.

  • @TomyHun It was still shit.

  • @TomyHun Are you kidding? They sound awful. Completely out of tune, the levels are terrible. In a huge venues like that, it's hard to sing in tune. Bjork, one of the most amazing artists i can think of, lip synced at the Olympics. she hasn't lost credibility for it because sometimes it's necessary for the performance, sometimes it ENHANCES it, rather than completely ruins the entire thing... which BEP clearly did.

  • Comment removed

  • they did it live not like madonna !!!she ruinned everything!!

  • The autotune is horrible...

  • They hav no moves and sound horrible live but it looked cool

  • what a shit

  • That´s a real half time show!

  • fergie sounds like shit

  • @noonewilleverseeme absolutely !

  • One hot mess

  • Loooove BEP but this was terrible, the only thing that was dece was Slash, but even then Fergie started singing :S

  • So what!!!!! Madonna lipsyncing, she already sing those songs before, plus the Madonna halftime show was better and sound better and she dint butcher sweet child!!!

  • boring

  • this is boring, the dancers in the background made the performance.

  • i don't listen to a lot of usher or BEP, so i can say with a couple of biss ears that this performance wasn't too bad

  • Makes Madonna's look lower than shit..

  • I really like BEP but honestly this sucked, i think considering all the auto-tuning and mixing, its too tough to do most of their songs live, Madonna this yr owned it though.

  • can't you guys hear the audience booed toward the end of the show? Obviously the crowds didn't like this one compare to the Madge's!

  • Can't help but notice this is the first act that didn't allow fans right up next to the stage. I guess people yawning and passing out wouldn't have looked to great on the teevee...

  • Way better than madonna lip synching and trying not to break a hip

  • @ae357em

    they all lipsinch, including Michael jackson....

  • This does sound terrible at times, but at least they were singing live.

    Madonna lipsync is a joke.

    Paul Mccartney was the best show. No need for dancing or 50 dressed as romans, just a bass and a piano.

  • @rockshow21 They should have lip synched. There's no way to do a soundcheck and no way to hear yourself. Plus Madonna actually danced.

  • this isnt the best performance but it isnt the worst like some people exaggerate it

  • eww... now i know why the Black Eyed Peas are beong given so much shit for their performance!!

    p.s. i have only watched the first ten seconds!!

  • I hate the black eyed peas, but at least they didn't lip sync.

  • @Robolizardslayer maybe they should have

  • This performance was super weak. Even Slash couldn't save it.

  • Madona was horrible

    

  • 2011 BLACK EYED PEAS WAS THE BEST

  • Better than Madonna.

  • I loved this if you dont like BEP dont comment. Their music is one style, not a style that everyone likes, but i certainly love it.

  • hate how they play miserlou

  • Both Madonna and Black Eyed Peas shows both sucked.

  • i think this was a better show than madonna

  • Thumbs up if you think Madonna should never perform live and if think that the BEP'S should be asked back to the superbowl again!

  • Slash.. THE BEST PART OF Halftime x)

  • BEP didnt lip sync, Madonna did, singing live is way better than lip syncing :) BEP was the best!

  • Ive been watching halftime shows and by far Paul's 2005 show was way better than this and madonnas crap and he didnt need no light shows just a bass guitar and a piano

  • HORRRIBLE THEY FUCKING FAILED MADDONA IS BETTER THEN THIS ANYTHING IS IT FUCKING SUCKS

  • The LED´s on the "V" of love are not running, but 2011 it was the greatest show ever on superbowl i think! Madonna´s Show sucks!

  • someone needs to kill axl rose so he can roll in his grave..

  • See, they need to hire people who actually know how to run Live Sound. End of story.

  • Fuck off with BEP the queen killed the show this year!

  • I watched Madonna's performance and I still think BEP was the best one yet. Thumbs up if you agree!

  • @hiakmura Agree BEP♥

  • @hiakmura AGREE!

  • @hiakmura NO FUCKNIG WAY

  • @hiakmura Hell Yeah! My friends are trying to say madonna was great. She sucked!!!! Madonna lip synched and nicki flipped off the camera!!

  • @hiakmura You're 12, aren't you?

  • @hiakmura you are fucking delusional

  • @hiakmura

    I think I would have to take Helen Kellar's opinion on music and live performance over yours.

    If not her, Osama Bin Ladin's.

    Thumbs Up if you agree!

  • @ROOKTABULA No. I won't thumbs up you just because you say "thumbs up if you agree"

  • @hiakmura The Who was better, man!

  • @hiakmura honestly this performance sucks, but it's better than lipsyncing Madonna. God that's even more embarassing to sit there and lipsync in front of millions.

  • @hiakmura Yep, i think BEP was at least more prepared. They didn't do lip sync but they also sucked singing... its weird.. but last year was more impressive.

  • lol this still beats Madonna's Show. At Least Fergie didn't Lip Sync all the way through.

  • it's not their fault. The PA/Sound is completely off, no reverb or anything. And William should share some of his autotune...

  • @jacklucien the band is shit anyway.

  • i watched the super bowl for the commercials and the half time show.

    theres another few hours ill never get back