Katharine McPhee Bottom 3 - American Idol Rewind Top 10 Results

[knybee]

looneychooney@ Katherine McPhee is one of the least conceited women singers out there today. She is genuinely humble. Only a coward would say such a lie. You punk, she didn't do the voting. So clam up grow up. And maybe Simon didn't like Kat because she was more beautiful then he was. Meeooowww.

[xxY2JLEDGENDKILLERxx]

kat should never have been in the bottom 3 im happy that she just smiles all the way through it though =)

[looneychooney]

Katherine MCPHEE you conceited bitch!  Lisa should have stayed.

[seventeenboi]

simon hated kat for some reason

[xxSonyBoy1xx]

AI season 5 the only season i watch, the only season that matters.

[MrCrayonInk95]

OMFG I ALWAYS SAY THE SAME EXACT THING ABOUT THIS SEASON!!! I THOUGHT I WAS THE ONLY ONE THAT THAOUGHT THAT LOL. It spoiled us in my mind cuz now we look at this season (season 9) and they all suck compared to season 5. The BEST season ever. Lisa should have been n at least the top 7. Screw taylor, he ruined the season.

[merrimac291]

this season had more talent on it than any other season in idol.

[aema171]

@merrimac291 ya .. season 5 & 9 had the best talents :)

But why in the best seasons the winners are the worst ?!!

This is weird America!!

[MyCommentsMatter1]

@aema171 OMG IKR!LOL