For the most part, good performance. I think Phil could have put a little more 'umph' into the song though, and could have made more use of his rough edge (as he did on 'No Son'), which is quite lacking here on a song that really requires it. He still can sing with a rough edge, but purposely doesn't 'cos it's a lot harder on his vocal chords nowadays. Good that he saves his voice for the next gig but does take away a bit from some songs. Overall though, a really good performance.
You can see Phil is holding his voice back to keep the concert going......he doesn't push the vocals out like he used to , but you can excuse him for that.
Would have loved it if Genesis had put a little more umph into the start of Mama like they did in 87 , just seems a little to quiet for my liking , I AGREE , THEY ARE THE BEST BAND IN THE WORLD .
But you've got to remember that Phil is deaf in one ear and that his voice has deepened over the years so they have to work less on the opening and more on the song because they don't want a repeat of the We Can't Dance Tour
so thats why they don't put so much into the opening like they used to
I think we should give Kyle a big 'thanks' for such an incredible job of posting the songs so that we could see the 'full' song and w/ great sound and quality...fantastic job.
They're not exactly young anymore... but what strikes me is they're still amazing! Phil Collins is just incredible, and everything else is just great!
I beg to differ. The best performance was the epic "Mama Tour". This perfomance was the closest they ever got to that concert. Of course, this is just my opinion.
Haha...well, some of us had to hop continents in order to see them! But yeah, it would be great if they did some dates outside the UK/US, hey? Fingers crossed! =)
@kylehudson00 i doubt there will be another concert. thats it from genesis. pink floyd nexet year and that will be for them too i guess. british rock dieing slowly but with a little fight.
heha! the voice is more depper here.
MrBjanka 3 weeks ago
They are not musicians...THEY ARE GODS!
MoonlightKnight94 3 months ago
i was here!!!
FeNDeR4US 11 months ago
Grettings from fan from Poland :-))
danthealighieri 1 year ago
piekne słowa..matka jest jedna ,jedyna ..najdrozsza. Stary dobry Genesis
jarodan33 1 year ago
Para q aprendan a tocar la bateria pageros de mierda
rabp49 3 years ago
Mike Rutherford=Underated Guitar player!
CHAPWELLES 3 years ago 5
I agree, but he sounded really rusty on lead this past tour.
MyNameIsBucket 3 years ago
sang it a little better in the 80's but still kickass!
DoneWithMirrors 3 years ago
Awesome.
Io amo questa musicaaaa.
Molto bella!
pqpfkuate100 3 years ago
Hart Rock von seiner besten Seite gute Arbeit Phil
genesisdvdgeniesser 3 years ago
is saw i live in duesseldorf and it was so great. they still are very great!
JotheBytle 3 years ago 2
Sounds better a key lower and looks better played at night :) Suits the atmosphere.
SPeacock 3 years ago 7
I Watched This Live On BBC1 and it was just amazing.
Genesis is just amazing.
England2345 3 years ago 5
I watched it too! I gotta get the DVD!!
SPeacock 3 years ago 3
I watched it on BBC, but i didnt know it was live :O wow!
Squalada 3 years ago
har har har
JohnW92 3 years ago
For the most part, good performance. I think Phil could have put a little more 'umph' into the song though, and could have made more use of his rough edge (as he did on 'No Son'), which is quite lacking here on a song that really requires it. He still can sing with a rough edge, but purposely doesn't 'cos it's a lot harder on his vocal chords nowadays. Good that he saves his voice for the next gig but does take away a bit from some songs. Overall though, a really good performance.
TornadoOf07 3 years ago
Phih falls into the old PHIL!!!!!!!!
noshodug 3 years ago
Never seen so many people in one place at the same time....
I was there too, never forget I've been a part of that night.
Annikella 3 years ago
excellent :)
xxrugilasxx 3 years ago 4
You can see Phil is holding his voice back to keep the concert going......he doesn't push the vocals out like he used to , but you can excuse him for that.
rafalweb 3 years ago
If you pay attention to that camera thing he did the same thing in 86 at wembley
DudeLove1996 3 years ago
What a great great performance, and look at the crowd, it's endless!!
cybermariano 3 years ago
I love this song!!!!!!!!!!
suzannefromrotterdam 3 years ago 5
Great Post! Scary yet enjoyable at the same time.
soundofstone92 3 years ago 2
Would have loved it if Genesis had put a little more umph into the start of Mama like they did in 87 , just seems a little to quiet for my liking , I AGREE , THEY ARE THE BEST BAND IN THE WORLD .
kissmyhairyone 4 years ago 7
I AGREE..
djeleix 3 years ago 5
I too :)
TheBestPhilCollins 3 years ago 4
But you've got to remember that Phil is deaf in one ear and that his voice has deepened over the years so they have to work less on the opening and more on the song because they don't want a repeat of the We Can't Dance Tour
so thats why they don't put so much into the opening like they used to
DudeLove1996 3 years ago
GENESIS THE BEST BAND UN THE WORLD!!!
crallagham 4 years ago 5
Evil-sounding song. Nice one, Phil Collins! :)
SPeacock 4 years ago 5
I think we should give Kyle a big 'thanks' for such an incredible job of posting the songs so that we could see the 'full' song and w/ great sound and quality...fantastic job.
drcrackaback 4 years ago 4
big thanks to kyle.
i ear this song in 1985 when i was 11 year old and i live in my daddy 's farm in argentina. great song, i love it.
this was in a 17 top hit casette.
sebafloyd1 4 years ago 2
1.12 - i remember that kid!
jcrawley1 4 years ago
The lower key made the song sound creepier, wich is great. Can't wait for the 3-DVD pack...
rodolfostanic 4 years ago 5
THE BEST...!!!!!!
MVS22 4 years ago 4
dvd coming to nz in 6 days, im counting down, cant wait lol
PhilCollinsLFC 4 years ago 2
Sorry but DVD will be released on 17th March 2008. In 6 days it's impossible!!! But anyway, can't way for that masterpiece!
InTheAir77 4 years ago
They're not exactly young anymore... but what strikes me is they're still amazing! Phil Collins is just incredible, and everything else is just great!
thecrazychimpz 4 years ago 2
This Song was NEVER better than on this Tour!
This DVD will be fabulous, for sure!
BloodOnTheRooftops 4 years ago 4
I beg to differ. The best performance was the epic "Mama Tour". This perfomance was the closest they ever got to that concert. Of course, this is just my opinion.
annnan 4 years ago
For those who never saw this tour this year, shame on YOU
thelurker25 4 years ago
Does it count if they never came to your continent?
Mekakakaka 4 years ago
Haha...well, some of us had to hop continents in order to see them! But yeah, it would be great if they did some dates outside the UK/US, hey? Fingers crossed! =)
kylehudson00 4 years ago
I WOULD'VE gone if I could, but I'm just too lazy. :P
Mekakakaka 4 years ago
@kylehudson00 i doubt there will be another concert. thats it from genesis. pink floyd nexet year and that will be for them too i guess. british rock dieing slowly but with a little fight.
xwingclass 1 year ago
@xwingclass I am not a brit,but genesis can never die.they will always be in our minds
greatpcfan 10 months ago
Fantastic! Thanks so much for posting this and the others! Can't wait for this DVD which will be awesome for sure!
InTheAir77 4 years ago