Added: 4 years ago
From: Fenristh
Views: 156,561
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (316)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Shattered memories is what made me rethink a second chance, it was good, not sh2 good but honestly it seems fans these days think that if no sh can achieve as great a deal as sh2 then its not worth playing, still because of shattered memories I'm putting my last hopes in downpour which, by knowing the ost is no longer being done by the original team, are getting pretty slim indeed.

  • omfg...-.-' give us a ENGLISH reviewer for god sake...-.-'

  • The gameplay looks really nice... much more smooth and fun

    but if it doesn't have the same horror like the previous Silent Hills' I might reconsider buying this...

  • What is the name of this music? It's amazing.

  • the game looks way better in the earlier stadium, also the ideas and story were better. He talked about that they wanted to based the story on sh2 and you could throw monsters from windows.

  • This looks a little different than the actual game. What's up with that? Was this a prototype version?

  • "Mein patentierter Dackelblick", nein wie genial^^

    Ich frage mich jetzt bloß, ist das Spiel nun zu schwer wie manche Fans es sagen oder zu leicht, wie es von manchen Magazinen behauptet wird o.o

    ach ja..

    German please guys ;p

  • This game is awesome...1 and HOMECOMING are the best. I LOVE SILENT HILL...so much I'm about to move there. But wait... from 0:01 till 0:26 the game looks diferent. This is not the real final look of the game. WHY? Guess its early videos of the game, while in final stages for releasing, right?

  • oh yea i totally agree with this guy... wait what did he say? :3 great quality btw

  • oh i confused this with another game

  • game looks great.

    i enjoy anything silent hill related.

    shame this wasn't made by konami though, it was only published by them and developed by an english company..

    apprently....

  • kurwa niemieckie gówno nic nie rozumiem z tego bełkotu.

  • 00:00 to 00:27: Fucking hell, the graphics look ten times better then in the actual game!

    They should have kept Shepards Glen like that instead of having both SG and SH foggy.

  • i agree it does look better than the real game

  • i don't get it its in German can u get it in Latin

  • All of you that say english please are assholes... you know there is other countrys that speak other languages get your heads out of your ass.

    Good review

  • manderin is the most spoken...

  • i didnt understand the review but the images were really good

  • wat!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11

  • The Japanese are simply great story-tellers:

    Silent Hill, Metal Gear Solid, ...

  • Japanese have unique sense of horror and direction. the west has destroyed this game.....

    Silent Hill will never be the same :(...

    Oh well at least there is Fatal frame...

  • yeah... since silent hill 0rigins this game started to suck.... so sad u.u

  • @telecalcu Homecoming and 4 were fine deep titles not as good as the others overall but still good dont cry because its different. Staying completely the same wouldve degraded the series over time also.

  • I really liked it, and think half of you are just wrapped up in "they changed it" bullshit. The game played very well and had a better story than the last 3 games (besides Origins). All i hear is "they should send it back to Japan to make it like it was" - what? clunky and even slooooower? You people are retarded. Get with the times, Silent Hill 5 took the right direction, it's just breaking nostalgia for you by having tight controls. As for scares, like you never jumped at a well hidden schism.

  • a shitty game from a shitty gamer

  • Agreed, this game blows. Major disappointment indeed.

  • The game was shit... Japanese creators in SH 1,2,3 and 4 did extremely well. But American creaters have spoiled the whole image of silent hill franchise. I am a big fan of silent hill but next time will think of buying it after all this crap. Previous silent hill games made you feel the whole thing as if you are yourself emotionally inside the game. Only best part of SH5 is that the music is from akira other than that its not even worth talking about...

  • @vaqar001 They tried too hard to redefine silent hill, the biggest flaw(aside the embarrasing movie influenced or even plainly imposed references that strip homecoming of any credibility) was replacing the silent hill feeling of unease with this jump-scare scheme we can experience in so many other wanabe-horror game titles, homecoming shames the series, origins improved but the developing team still lacked that feeling and so they resorted to unecessary story plotholes...

  • IT A HORRID GAME!!!IV BEATEN THE GAME. IT SUCKS! WHO THE FUCK GET SCARED BY THIS SHIT?!?

    p.s. only fan boys do

  • I don't understand what he's saying but is a better review than the IGN one.O_O

  • this is a preview not review

  • while i do like this game, i think it should have less monsters and more silence

    its called silent hill for a reason

  • Yeah, it's called Silent Hill because it's based in.... Silent Hill

  • i didnt mean that, i meant that cuz its not as silent in alot fo areas in SH2 and 3 u could walk down a hallway and only hear your footsteps and in this game there is always some kind of noise, while i dont mind it and stuff, but having those moments of complete silence rly add tension

  • True.

    The tension like in Silent hill 2.

    The emotional stress the game creates with it's characters was just perfect in silent hill 2.

    The monsters can be scary yes, but too much monsters will ruin it.

    I heard Silent hill has other producers now ?

  • what!?

  • DUDE I DONT UNDERSTAND WHAT HES SAYING I NEED TO LEARN.............german is it?

  • dude, he speaks Arabic!!

  • is german

  • Fucker.

  • man i wish SH 5 would add an double leg takedown move. that would be so sick. can you guys imagine it taking down your monster with an double leg take down. then into an arm bar.

  • the reviews were between 6.5 and 8.5 the people who reviewed this had different opinions about the whole experience u should read the 1up review they had a good review.

  • There seems to be a lot of focus on the action. But at the same time, the developers promised it would be more like silent hill 2 than the others. Which means less action! I hope that they focus on that type of fear and try to not throw in a lot of monsters. But at the same time, the few batles that do occur should be intensive and scary. What I hated with all SH games was that the combat system SUCKED. The game was good otherwise, but everytime a monster showed up the suspense died.

  • in my opinion sh3 was a good combat system

  • it didn't fell yet, let's just see what that will give. i was scared of merc2, and i was wrong, so i wait and see SH will give befor hating them

  • why is pyramid head in this

  • because the main character feel guilty for something.

  • WTF!?...

  • The lock is broken. I can't open the door.

    Yep, this is Silent Hill allright.

  • german is a beautiful language, how dare you insult their language....

  • i'am afraid of the game, not in the scared sens, but in the gameplay, i fear they will do the same as the RE producers done, with the RE 4 and RE 5, it will be turned completely for action instead than enigm stuff, they will destroy SH if they do that, just like they done with RE, and the movie compared to the game is booring, but still good for a new to the series..RE movie s** hard

  • dude they made RE better with how they did

    they wont do it with silent hill but dont hate on RE cuz they changed there style for the best, it works WAY better

  • i don't hate it, but it is true that they turn completely in action... where is the frustration of forgetting a fckin key on the other edge of the map for opening a door, and you understand that it will be hard, cuz you don't have that much of ammo... that is what i'am scared of, i know the gameplay is better, but, i don't remember that camera function when i played the first RE...whatever, i hope what you say is true, SH won't be like that

  • The helpnesses you felt during the first games is ruined by to much focus on combat. Your ability to deffend yourself was that limited since the caracters where regular people like most of us and had never fired a weapon, or been in any close combat situation before. The camera angles in the old games was perfected to create the most creepy scenes possible. They have possibillites now they didn't have but it was actually limitations in the graphis that created essential features such as the fog.

  • WOW...did i see chekpoint at 0:36? WTF is that?

  • Yes you did! I didn't notice it before ...

    Weel, I guess it's goodbye notepads ;)

  • OMG I agree. I hope they don't make it like a war game. with checkpiints, you know? die than start back at checkpoint.

  • Fuck you and your mother

  • learn german, like I did, and you should understand

  • english please!

  • go fuck yourself "please!"

  • i would but your mom is doing the honors thank you very much!

  • wasted bout 5 seconds of my life. can you give dem back to me...I THINK NOT!! well my fault for believing..lol

  • Is it a Silent Hill 1 remake?

    Cool...

  • i was mega pissed of that they changed the main charecter to a woman, the story was about harry mason not some blonde floozy i boycoted the movie cause of this and im sure a lot of others done the same thing

    ps this game looks awsome cant wait for it, hope they tie it into sh 1 just like 2 3 4 and orgins did

  • yeh, well that's political correctness for you lol, I WANTED HARRY MASON AND CHERYLL NOT 'SHARON' In the game Harry And Cibyl adopt cheryl together at the end, SH1 was my fave of all the series, so origional

  • Quite the opposite, furyplum44. They changed his gender because, apparently, him protecting his child was deemed more of a "woman" thing to do. That doesn't seem very politically correct to me.

  • SILENT HILL ROCK´S´!!!!!!

  • SH5 doesn't even look like a SH game. I don't know why, but this doesn't give me the real Silent Hill feeling. The camera doesn't move like in the other games, the fog is not a real fog, the game now looks more like RE, which is not a bad thing, but it doesn't have that special flavour that the early games had. I'm not looking forward too much for this title.

  • More recent videos of the game look a lot better than this, especially the "attract mode" which should be on youtube already. Even has a new song with vocals.

  • This is very old, the game doesn't look like this anymore and it's called Silent Hill: Homecoming NOT V or 5

  • Yea its actually 6th game in the series(at least what i know :D) but its 5th game in the story. SH origins is something like 0th game in the story. Thats why most ppl like SH 5 better.

  • Why r people so obsessed with graphics? Just because it doesnt look like RE 5 doesnt mean its bad.

    BTW: Hope its gonna be released for PC soon after consoles.

  • Damn, I think that the reason they changed the game a lot was because they were looking at Silent Hill as a video game and sort of disregarded the fact that the japanese went for plot and tragedy. 'The controls sucks' or 'camera angles are bad' were what I heard in the interviews, but the handicap adds to the horror. It might just be me, I mean it could be an awesome game. Can't wait for it to get out!

  • GOD WHAT THE FUCK HAPPENED WITH FOG?! Remember times of SH1, when the fog... was a real fog? When you could see only about 5 meters? That was the real Silent Hill fog, this one's a shit!

  • this game is gonna be just "ok", nothing special, but i have to admit graphics look like shit, unfortunately, it comes out in 2 months so this is pretty much the final product :(

  • well I it looks ok just know to me I would when it does come out in might get a "worth checking out" rank but who the hell expects this be revolutionary I don't but I still want to buy it

  • it looks like fucking garbage so far. maybe the final version will look better. for the PS3 it should have resident evil 5 graphics but silent hill 5 looks like a ps2 game played at HD

  • dude better graphics doesn't mean a better game

  • I LOVE THIS GAME GREAT JOB FROM MAKERS OF Game Love This Game

  • wtf how did they get the game

  • haha, ihr versteht nix xD

  • its japness fuck tards

  • 'Tis German, retard! You must be American.

  • lol im american, i can tell the difference though, but i agree he must be.

  • Comment of the year.

  • what the hell are you saying?

  • maybe that is why i like resident evil better. they already made the switch to action horror instead of survival horror

  • Yes, this is what i`ve been waiting for. And i know thow day would come.. They have based the game mostly from SH 1 and not the movie that somone is telling :S .. The movie is based on SH 1 .. anyway, this game looks promosing and is gaing to be waaaaaay better than SH 4 (SH 4 is the worst SH game that i have played) and since i`ve got all the games and is just waiting on this one i hope that they take some ideas from SH 1 that im 95% sure of.

  • From best to least

    Silent hill 3

    2

    4

    1

    then maybe this one....when is this comin

  • dude r u kiddin me 1 is the scariest one ever

  • from best to least....not from most scary to least scary....however I found SH3 scarier than other series....with its improved graphics and (environmantel) transformations.....also I played that game first...so may be that's why I like it the most....

  • You`re making me sick :S .. The SH 1 was the best in the series (thats why it was made a movie out from it) and its more like this..

    Silent hill 1 - ( maby Sh 5 will replace SH 1

    2

    3

    4

  • well....helloo..dude....its my opinion...who even asked for urs.....and for ur kind information....they are continuing to make the movies of the other series......i like sh 1...but not more than 3rd...its my opinion...why do u even care....go get ur own life.....stop bothering others///...

  • First of all, i have rights to complain about your meanings since you`re putting the best SH game down and the WORST over the best :S .. Yea I`ve got my own life, you are bothering me by insulting my favorite game and you dont even reson your ranking wich makes me sick.. now, reasong your ranking before insulting me as a person. Keep yourself to the subject..

  • wooooooooooo.....I never insulted ur favorite game....All I did ...that I wrote abt my favorites.....not urs......sooo...stop fighting...bcoz every one has their own likes and dislikes...u can't make others to be like u.....everyone is different...so there...I like Sh1...happy....u r just fighting over a game....so stop it....

  • ahahah stvner u suck btw 3 is better than 1 HA

  • First of all, im not fighting. Second i dont want you to like anything and third you are bothering me with you patetic grammar and plain stupid reason for being insulted.. What im trying to say is that you need to know the right sorces before you are telling your own opinions. and you need to reason them.. here is an example: (P.1) i like that cake. (P.2) But that cake is better.... WHY is it better/bader a.s.o that`s what im trying to tell you..

  • wooo..dude..u r just impossible.....and sorces,,is spelled sources..so i think u r bothering me with ur pathetic grammar...(not patetic, that u wrote)..I like SH3..and since u didnt notice..I gave my reasonings in previous posts.....dude...u r really making others to be like u..so as I said before..go get a life..and stop bothering others..cuz if u r going to reply me back...that will sure prove it that...u just like to step into other people's business

  • reminder:U were the one who started this conversation)..even if I give reasons or not...I still have my own likes and dislikes....and u have urs..I dont feel bad if u say that u like SH1 better..cuz why would I..u have ur own likes..even with the reasons or without them...so Yeah....I like SH3 better.....I dont care ...abt whatever u say....unlike You...

  • I know how sources is spelled but there is no "rendo-change" option on youtube so i was doomed..i`ve dont sayd that you cant have own opinions, but you must be aware that i can also have my opinions about your opinion. That`s the whole reason for posting own opinions, becouse there is more than 90% likely that you would recive a reply. I sayd my opinions about your opinion, Either deal with it or give up. And please, for your own good. STOP THE DAMN SHOT-WORDS LIKE U AND CUZ!! (good advise)

  • ur an idiot dude. they made the movie on sh 1 becuz it was the first one... they werent just gonna start the movies on silent hill 2,3 or 4 first u idiot they r gonna do it in order

  • The order has nothing to say at all. They made the movie after SH 1 becouse the "director" found that much better... Thats all.. nothing else.. and btw, there might not be any more SH movies for a gooood while..

  • yea ok.. maybe the director thought sh 1 was better than the other three or maybe he didnt... but he still would have done the movies in order if he didnt like the first one anyways.

  • They were gonna make the movie with storyline of SH 2, but they wanted a woman to take the role of main character and it would be strange if she got an letter from her wife cause she would have to be a lesbian :D .

    SH 2 movie is gonna be released in 2009... I guess, cause i read it somewhere. And its gonna have the storyline if SH2.

  • I wouldnt mind if she was a lesbian :P but i get your point. and i really dont care what movie who comes when. Becouse i just hope they keep on making them (and the games) for a looong while since i love them :P

  • i dont get it! wheres famous SH camera angles? i hope its just a sample video. SH wont be the same without them...

  • what's wrong with checkpoints? you silent hill fan boys are so silly! Resident Evil is waaaay better.

  • HOW THE HELL CAN YOU COMPARE RESIDENT EVIL AND SILENT HILL?

    Resident evil = action game with zombies;

    Silent Hill = psychological horror game;

  • YOU sonofabitch.....youll pay for this

  • Obviously the graphics are not optimal, but the game is in good way. WHY DID THEY HAVE TO CHANGE THE TEAM!!?? T_T Japan rulz

  • =) me 2

  • I just had an orgasm.

  • Yey for Orgasms!!!

  • Come again?? DOnt under fucking stand you!

  • That's because he's not speaking English, moron.

  • no habla engles?

  • GOD plzzz do not let em release this game... checkpoints, combos... no comment

  • who cares about the checkpoints, its tiny little words that come on screen when u reach a point its not going to turn all the monsters into pink little bunnies or anything. footage is old too so hopefully they take it out but come on have some hope, origins wasnt too bad and that was a different team

  • Origins was good for a different team. I enjoyed it. But it was lacking a lot.

    But come on! Combos in a Silent Hill game? COMBOS!? Silent Hill is one of those rare games that actually mean "survival horror game". Survival! Combos and checkpoints will ruin the feel. "Oh look I died. No worry, had a checkpoint, gonna try again". It used to be "Shit I died! Dammit now I have to go through those damn rooms again! DAMN!"

  • good point but u have to see it from the developers eyes, they cant simply just take the same exact game , they have to add something new to it and their response to many people's complaints of the past games gameplay was addressed with this new fighting system, and hopefully it works, although the checkpoint is unneccesary. the main thing i wud worry about is the story, i have this feeling they are using jacob's ladder influence even more this time around....

  • i just hope they take out that breaking weapon thing, i hated that feature in origins! :P

    and the lying figures that run towards you....creepy. they should have easy, normal, hard, and wussy for people like me who freak out at stuff like that!!! XD

  • lol wheres the fun in that...the fear and creepiness is what makes it beautiful until i start hearing things behind me that is haha

  • haha i liek the creepiness, its just the multiple mosters running at you, thats where i dont liek it, i like it when they are more like silent hill 2 where you hear them and then as you look around they are just creepily moving and twitching then they attack you. the creepy factor is better to me then the surpirse attack factor!!!

  • WTF! CHECKPOINT??? What's the point of adding Check Points O_O

  • Dejen de criticar tanto al juego que ni siquiera lo han jugado u_u

  • They Really Sould Make A Silent Hill Remake... they Remade Resident Evil... And Tomb Raider... They Should Remake Silent Hill!

  • I do like that fact that the camera is closer outdoors, but I don't like the fact that it stays fixed behind you. It's not stylish like the other games.

    The town ain't foggy enough. It's not dark enough inside.

    I pray for the series. It might be the end.

  • They should of remade the first Silent Hill instead of this, but oh well.

  • im doubtful about this sh, they said they want to focus on combat, so they can make the equivalent of resident evil 4 to silent hill. hopefully they wont fuck up

  • more darkness please

  • xDD

    "patentierter Dackelblick"^^

    THe game looks really good

  • it looks like its going to be really good

  • comon ppl be posotive. ders still heaps of stuff bein put into it so dw. i am, dnt get me wron, but i think it would be nice. ONLY thigim not sure bout r monsters. wtf wit banana-peel head man???

  • i think this game need some work...cause like "Elothriel" said they should be more original.The graphic and the camera system is GREAT!!!! but the enemies and surroundings are just too..plain...and unoriginal!!! : /

  • I think this next gen silent-hill really gonna suck:S

  • I think this silent hill gonna be awesome

  • me too, sure theyre not that original in monster or envyorement design but the real time transition from real world to nightmare world is very original besides im getting sick of crappy transition cutscenes,

  • lol checkpoint? eliminates the need of looking around for the red save thingy's...not sure if its a good thing to do though...it may be too easy now.

  • Yeah, i think the checkpoints will take the tension. you will feel much to safe...

  • man i want to see the video when he gets on the other side of the glass

  • Ja! Das ist Prima! Sehr Gut!

  • this is awsome video, and i can't wait for it to come out. i believe it comes out this year. if so then im gona be one happy camper. anyone know what those things are that are dancing in front of the tv?????????

  • it was them nurses

  • awsome!!!!!!!!! can't wait~!! kookakachoo

  • The camera is free?(

    And Alex's running.. in some strange way.. sidelong o_O

    This SH2/movie nurses again >__> Be more original, dammit! God, how I hate this movie and hackneyed ideas after it..

    I hope The Collective wouldn't ruin symbolicalness of Silent Hill at least.. -_-

  • wow! it looks like a kool game with a lot of exploring to do, and i think silent hill 2 was the best i've played but i still cant wait for this one........

  • and if you hit monsters where you hit them wounds will light up well I would say they are trying to creat a new type of game that is realllllllllllllllllly like humman life to make it more .. um awsome

  • I will tell you what is happaning with the new silent hilll 5 what is soposed to happan is their planing on having a secondary character from what I have seen is she has blond short hair and green eyes their sending it to a new company and they are giding them thogh the game and music and keeping their name on the thingy oh another thing is like resedent evel five you can hit anything around you and it will breake the funny thing is I am 13 yet I know all this hehe

  • its not really funny that your 13 and you know this but it is very informative and contributes to the silent hill fanbase, but i cudnt really understand what you were saying

  • As the same pal,I didnt understand what she said...

  • game is in english but we get some fugly german dude to review it GG

  • wtf is he saying

  • oh my fuking god i can't wait this game can't wait biatchhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

  • can't wait.

    looks good so far.

    don't suck.

  • Man them graphics are a real change, I love all silent hill's Best one silent hill 2 who would of thought we were playing as a killer... But still cant wait even going to buy silent hill collection for ps2 to play on ps3

  • the best silent hill is the first one, to PS1, man, this game is so fucki'n scary

  • ur right,original silent hill is the best in the series

  • Silent Hill 2 is really amazing. In my opinion, the best of the saga so far.

  • the best silent hill is the 1 & 4 (my favourite) but yeah the 2=9.9! LOL

  • Hmm,I would probably say the two best game of Silent Hill is: 2 and 3.But 4=9.2 Because I didnt really like the story lines much,I know theyre great but,everytime you complete an area,it wil come back again. 1=8.9 coz its old.Forgive me what I said,I hope I didnt hurt your feelings =]

  • 2 is better. made me cry at the end. 4 is so awesome cause walter sullivan was the main character not loser henry

  • The only thing I am not excited about is the hammer-head shark enemy and the very industrial look of the "otherworld".

    Silent hill is best in its rusty and dark form, with plenty of desolate fog :)

    Hammerhead people chasing you down a steam-room corridor is not scary to me. Exploring a school.. now thats scary because it has a connection with you.

    Everyone is freaked out by desolate hositals etc.

    But enemies busting through doors after you - looking forward to that!

  • I won't pass judgement until I see a well mixed video of all enviroments and some cut scenes.