Added: 5 years ago
From: thumphrey05
Views: 162,365
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (446)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • awesome man!

  • "HELLO"... what are the two notes for when "in there" as in "hello..... is there anybody in there"... im figuring this song out by ear and im stuck on those two

  • Dear sir,

    you have put something into this song that is so intangible and moving ... thank you for doing justice to the song. keep playing!

  • ESPECTACULARRR

  • this is fucking fantastic!!!

  • 41 people need to get there ears checked!!!!!

  • I'd never thought it was possible to play this solo on a piano. The playing ain't perfect, but it drives me to tears just like Roger Water's original composition. I still believe this is one of the strongest of Pink Floyd's songs. I grew up with that shit.

  • 39 people can't hear very well.........

  • I am so happy, I just signed up for piano lessons, hopefully one day I can be as good as you. Thank you for this video.

  • @GunZTube1

    Piano is an amazing instrument . How hes playing dosn't take that long to play like ! In a year or so depending on how much you practise , you will be playing like this no time !

  • youre like god!

    please be a girl and fall in love with me.

  • Dis is awesome!!!!!!!!

  • Shit man. You gave me the chills.

  • :) GRAN TEMA 

  • Will you marry me and play piano for me every day to the end of my life, please??? :)

    Amazing!

  • @Funialstwo now that sounds like torture

    i didnt mean the marry part

  • @Funialstwo No no, he should play for me every day instead!! XD

  • Geez I swear u freakin ROCK!!! I LOVE YOU!!!

  • is there any way you could email me the sheets to this? i would be so appreciative. let me know

  • is it possible to get sheets? <3

    god, please let me know, i want o learn this so much.

  • Absolutely beautiful. Your playing really brings out the raw emotion in this song.

  • wao

  • Still diggin it  thumphreyo5

  • oh my holy Richard Wright that was amazing!!!!!!!!!

  • C'est malade.

  • 34 people have a completely different opinion to me.

  • Pink Floyd will hire you.

  • Richard Wright will be please in heaven by listening to this. :)

  • i love you.

  • I am so subscribing to your YouTube page...you are EXTREMELY talented...only a moron or someone who is tone deaf would question that, lol

  • Sweet

  • really wonderful what you do with the piano, is a pleasure to hear, beautiful.

  • a month later and i like it more. don't ever piss away your God given ability!

  • are the acoustics right or is it just me???

  • awsum buddy thank u i enjoyed it :-)

    

  • 33 people.. should be castrated before they ever get the chance to reproduce. HOW COULD YOU NOT LIKE THIS?! I don't think you even have to be a Pink Floyd fan to appreciate this guy's playing.

  • Great!!!

  • 33 people are hannah montana and jonas brothers fans

  • wow. that was astounding. wonderful

  • holy crap! that was great! unreal! how did 33 not like it is beyond me. thanks!

  • very good son i loved it

  • Keep on playing, man. You're dripping talent all over the floor and I would love to walk behind you and pick some of it up. . Somehow, I don't know how you do it, but you've got the feel of it down like nothing I've heard before.

  • WOW. There's impressive and there's Really impressive! You got talent. I'm crying hearing this..Love it!

  • GRAET JOB!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!

  • you're awesome!!!! i'm from Argentina, and I like very much Floyd music..

    can you give me the partiture of your cover please??

    thank you very much!

  • Epic!

  • bravissimo

  • This was Awe! summ... and@Pinkchyo..Dude go jump in a well and tell the frogs there.... No need to say it here.

    ..

  • This just sounds epic. Perfect. Thanks for sharing this wonderful piece of music. I hope that you are still practicing this hobby (or profession) even four years after you recorded this.

  • amazing

  • amazing!

    could you share the music sheet? pleaseeee

  • Nice work!

  • can u give me the music sheet ?

  • As classy a version of Comfortably Numb as I think I am gonna hear for a long time to come.

    Man, I hope you treated yourself to something special after that effort.

  • O.O

  • tell me, did you die, go to heaven and come back to take the pain of all of us,,!!??

    YOU'RE A GOD!!!

    AMAZING!!!

    i HAVE A PLAYLIST OF YOUR CREATIONS ON MY I-POD!!!

  • @00AmalteA00

    you're an idiot

    but

    good song

  • @00AmalteA00

    wtf?

    hes just playing the piano

  • @k0stil

    

    My point exactly!!!! =D

  • absolutely amazing man.5/5

  • great bow master

  • 0.o

  • Awesome. My favorite Pink Floyd song. I have heard it many different ways before, but nothing like this!

  • great job!

  • voiceless... Simply amazing !

  • THANK YOU!!!

  • right when I posted, you slowed down the pace.....THAT IS IT! I love it. Thank you!

  • WOW....AWESOME. If I would have heard this 2.5 years ago, I would have asked if i could hire you for my wedding. This was my song. You are awesome. I would have asked you to play just like this at a slower rate while i walked down the aisle. Keep up the fantastic playing....you rock :)

  • @milesofsmiles5 Awwww that's such a lovely song to have for a wedding :)

  • BOOTlicker!

  • excellent - one of the best songs ever

  • thats just over the top u cant even tell where bouts u are

  • stunning

  • i can hear roger and davids voice in that piano

  • Awesome ! very nice cover :)

    I did a cover of this song too on guitar its one of my favourite songs :D

    check it out.

  • freaking awesome

  • OMG! I love it ! Do u know where i could get the sheet for this song ?

  • The best cover I've heard. :)

    Did you do this by ear, tabs or sheet music?

    :)Nicole Tangerine.

  • For those who'd like to solo I can recommend a simple pentatonic scale.

    For example if you're playing it in, let's say C minor. A C pentatonic will work perfectly. :)

  • very good job!

    Bit quick and i think thats where the feeling got missed a little but a pretty good job!!!

  • Nice, very nice... man. Thanks from Brasil.

  • Nice to know you can spell the name of your country correctly.

  • Thats epic man

    keep up to good work

  • well done

  • ok... i'm travelling right now... this is pure inspiration for everyone listening...

  • is that a pit pass on your wrist?

  • That is friggin epic. Very impressive.

  • love it so much

  • great work. loved it...

  • could you please make a tutorial

  • this song sounds the best on piano

  • This is fantastic. Very good job. Poetry to the ears.

  • Very Good!!!!!!! deserve more than five stars!

  • Thats really a superb rendition. You certainly have mastered the art of piano playing. Best wishes!

  • i would faint to this awesome cover!!!!!!!!

  • This is great thumbs up

  • Nice!! awesome in fact! Never heard it on Piano. To hear what I hope is a decent version on Guitar, check out my Channel, really want sum feedback on it!! Plz, :)

  • That was truly amazing!! Thank you very much for sharing this with us.

  • Beyond gorgeous. You incorporated your own style into an amazing song and the end result was fantastic.

    <3

  • This is seariously good. Thumbs up!

  • Wow this is amazing, sends chills down my spine.. BRAVO 5/5

  • One, you are absolutely amazing and I could marry you right now, Idc who you are, where you are, etc. Haha. Jk.

    But yeahh, if you have the sheet music, could I please get it?

    Also, if you can make a tutorial for all us fans, you'd be more amazing than ever. ;D

  • If you ever travel back in time for some reason, back to the 18th century, be sure to play this and you'll go down in history like Beethoven.

  • @ActionHeroMan But then what would happen to Pink Floyd?

  • dude u gotta make a tutorial for this 1!! i remember asking u like a year ago for 1 and im still amazed with how good this is

  • yeahhhhhhhhh rifado ehhhhhhhh!!!

    saka la d great gig in the sky

  • Ahhh, thanks for the comment. Some orignal wokr would be appreciated and anyone and every one can come up with their own version of any song, but only if they can be as awesome as the original or perhaps even better. That remains to be seen. for the time -being, if they can do the covers nicely only.

  • If I may suggest without any intention of offense and undue criticism??? you have demonstrated your remarkable prowess and technical expertise with the piano. However it is not how "well" one plays piano. Its about how "exactly" one reproduces the original song. this was too fast than the original tempo and too loud. If I may also suggest humbly please taek time to Listen to the cover of Hey You by Debbie johnson on youtube. you will get my point. Hoping for your next more blasting post on tube

  • Oh please, can't somebody put their own style onto a song?

  • I think you need to get a life. The point of someone covering a song like this is too put your own feelings and interpret it the way you see fit. It is not about "how exactly on reproduces the original song". Maybe this very talented man feels that this song should be louder and a little faster. Or maybe that's just how he did it! Who cares, he still has great talent!

  • Indeed, if that is the aim of doing cover songs. but then don't you think it should be in an altogether ORIGINAL style???? IF its mimicking so much then might as well do it perfectly. But anyways, I do get the picture that you are wanting me to appreciate and I do appreciate. thanks for the light. :-) cheers:-)

  • Shut up.

  • Wonderful!

  • Incredible!!! this is freaking awesome! great job.

  • Nice :)

  • That is amazing excellent effort

  • wouahhhhh

    great , splendide..... wonderfull, excellent !

  • incantevole 5 stelle!! good

  • i wish he could elaborate on the outro solo otherwise it was excellent and the first solo was beautiful

  • Im speechless... my tears speak for me...

  • hey man all i gotta say i usually beak people who play piano but you at least get a good collection of songs. keep er up.

  • why so fast???

  • OMG that was awsome!!! thanks!

  • that was like sex in my ear.

  • beautiful sound!

  • great piano playing..But your foot seems to be stuck on the sustain pedal...ease up!..

  • Talent!

  • Wow wa we wa - I like, very niice!!!

  • i want sheet music!

  • great stuff

  • Beautiful!

  • Good show old bean!

  • do u have sheet music? does anyone know where to get it?

  • beautiful.

    this is my favorite song of all time.

    just amazing.

  • Absolutely gorgeous. Thanks for sharing.

  • Absolutely perfect in every way.

  • Absolutely awesome! Best cover ever.

  • you make it so that my grandmother can listen to my music without the look of disgust in her eye.

  • Bravo bravo !!

  • Just like my grandmother used to play...

  • Cool. You are definitely a gifted musician.

  • You sir, win.

  • that was so pretty, thank you

  • that sounds so pretty on the piano. well done!

  • bello!!!!

  • bravisssssimo!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • nice cover!!

    i love this song and this piano cover is the best i have ever seen^^

    i want to play this song

    so if you have time ,please make music sheet for me

  • slow slow!!!

  • nice!

  • Nice cover, well done

  • hey can you send me sheet music to that?

  • i dont have any, sorry

  • oh my, that's amazing<3

  • excellent cover..

    it's great to see something little different..

  • ...sweet. from someone who saw them together at Hollywood Bowl way back when. loved it and thanks for posting!

  • How long have you been playing?

  • for about 10 years now

  • Where do you live? I'd like you to come play at my school :'(

  • austin tx

  • Thats were I am, live,.... well lived anyways.

  • please please tell me the sheet music for this is somewhere on the internet. I have got to get my hands on it.

  • im sure you can find most pink floyd sheet music from amazon or local music stores, i played this version by ear though

  • It's how I played as well when I was 5. The first tune was Star-Spangled Banner.

    I can see it now, you playing on stage in front of the NY Philharmonic Orchestra.

    That makes every hair on your body hurt.

    Nicely done Captain.

  • whay does it means "numb"??

  • morphine

  • really?? so that guy in the Pink Floyd's movie used morpine so he's an addict??

  • i dunno, you'd have to read up on the wall. its a concept album. roger waters spit on a fan or something then wrote the wall reflecting on what he had done. that might not be true though but i think so!

  • yes he was an addict not anymore at least i think

  • thaks for answering, hmmm... isn't thet "the wall" a movie?? or it's also a book, how can I "read up" the wall??

  • it's an album, he means read the lyrics

  • "The Wall" was also made into a movie.

    Songmeanings dot net is pretty good for lyrics, and reading people's thoughts on the music.

  • How long have you been playing the piano, that's very nice!

  • There is no pain tou are receding

    A distance piano near the window

    You are only playing awesome muic

    You´re fingers move but I cant hear what you're playing ...and thats because I have no speakers hahaha LOL

    well done my friend I wish I play like you XD

  • very nice!

  • good

  • Hey, you know those "Rockabye Baby!" CD's? This could be on the Pink Floyd edition. And that is completely a compliment. A very unique tak