"HELLO! is their ANYBODY in there??" "Wake-Up" YOUR Country is being taken-over by Zionist/Jewish Bankers who are deceivingly orchestrating the Whole WORLD-WIDE DEMISE!! The WORLD-WIDE monetary collapse is NOT just a "Coincident!" It's been designed this way to take TOTAL CONTROL over the Worlds Population! It is called... "The New World (Parasitic) Order!" Read: wake-upbeforeitstoolate(dot)com and see how we have ALL been massively LIED to! Roger Walters Knows this It's called.. "The WALL!"
The arguments are all moot. This song is good enough to transcend either artist, but both are necessary for it to truly shine. Gilmour's voice and guitar are absolutely required for the chorus/solo, but none of his solo performances have felt right without Waters' delivery on the verse. I wish the band could have set aside all the animosity and done one last tour of The Wall before Wright passed...
look one with out the other an the other they make pink floyd that the chimsitry that how they make it happen just keep on listing they get better like wine
Waters is good on the storytelling part, it's more into lyrics. On the other hand, Gilmour has a better voice and guitar technique. Nevertheless, both are true artists and both have outstanding works.
Would you please stop the war on who is best? Does it really matters? Best on what level? Both are really good artists, with different styles, with common roots.
@paingul Liked your comment.So FWIW I just read that, as part of a bargain to persuade Waters to play "To Know Him Is To Love Him" with him at a charity gig (strange but true..) Gilmore has offered to play the comfortably numb solo at one of the gigs on Waters Wall tour..and Waters has accepted !!! No, I couldn't believe it either, but google it you will see it is true
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Great. Waters is pink floyd. Gilmour is a bad blue copy of pink floyd. This guitar solo is better tha Gilmour. Gilmour cant write songs. He can tell money. Gilmour have destroyed the name pink floyd. I have listen to them for 35 years. I saw pink floyd in 1994 and this gig was bad. I like sound and voice not las vegas.
You do realize everything in this is song besides the lyrics, are from gilmour. Every member of pink floyd played a part in their whole era, Roger didn't realize this till he left the band and last i heard he regrets it. He treated his member like studio musicians which they weren't. Pink Floyd would be nothing without rogers, but rogers is nothing without pink floyd.
Gilmour is what makes this song great, nobody can sing the chorus like him, and when he plays this solo the world stops. He's David Gilmour for fuck sakes.
Maybe... But, if Roger Waters hadn't written all of the great PF music, David Gilmour would be... Yes, he played a mean guitar, but Roger Waters was the creative genius behind PF... Tha is pretty much undisputed...
Yeah but who cares Roger is just playing the same old tunes over and over If he is such a genius why wasn't he able to do more then just playing the old stuff every night
Gilmour came up with 3 great albums after pink floyd and with pink floyd without Roger. Roger only came up with 2 shitty albums which proves without gilmour Roger is shit all, and david gilmour came up with alot of fucking sweet songs when they were together
WeHaveLostTheWay: maybe that old stuff is incomparable better then new stuff? maybe "new stuff" makers just wanna grabs that cash with both hands and make a stash?
this was the greatest concert ever...i've been there and i felt every second some shivers down my spine...and i could nor believe myself when some tears fell from my eyes...just...PERFECT!!!
"HELLO! is their ANYBODY in there??" "Wake-Up" YOUR Country is being taken-over by Zionist/Jewish Bankers who are deceivingly orchestrating the Whole WORLD-WIDE DEMISE!! The WORLD-WIDE monetary collapse is NOT just a "Coincident!" It's been designed this way to take TOTAL CONTROL over the Worlds Population! It is called... "The New World (Parasitic) Order!" Read: wake-upbeforeitstoolate(dot)com and see how we have ALL been massively LIED to! Roger Walters Knows this It's called.. "The WALL!"
einrib4truth 3 months ago
Junky handheld videos.
liamtz 5 months ago
The arguments are all moot. This song is good enough to transcend either artist, but both are necessary for it to truly shine. Gilmour's voice and guitar are absolutely required for the chorus/solo, but none of his solo performances have felt right without Waters' delivery on the verse. I wish the band could have set aside all the animosity and done one last tour of The Wall before Wright passed...
OmnipotentBagel 9 months ago
Impressive audio quality even to FLOYD standards...
MrDodstink 1 year ago
ma sparisci... nessuno lo farà mai come gilmour!!!!
MrTheRock88 1 year ago
guys stop arguing about is better, damn. Just enjoy the great music.
Thunderfishband 1 year ago
i think the guitar solos are nice..but they dont have that gilmour touch
maxtubeusername 1 year ago
Great performance and koncert from Waters, but that solo doesn't even come close to Gilmour's....
gkjesper 2 years ago 6
Nobody can replace David Gilmour on the other side ...
President Obama "BRING THE BOYS BACK HOME" Please!
edgarflotte 2 years ago 13
They'll come back when their done.
Speedcrave 2 years ago
@Speedcrave they're done doing what?
soricku 1 year ago
look one with out the other an the other they make pink floyd that the chimsitry that how they make it happen just keep on listing they get better like wine
sashafiftyfive 3 years ago
Roger Waters IS PINK FLOYD. I wish him and Gilmour would bury the hatchet already and do a tour.
20carrocks 3 years ago 6
never happen
Pixx4you 3 years ago
mah, eu am stat chiar langa tine :) pozele mele sunt facute din aceasi perspectiva :)
FerKoVaX 3 years ago
pai... sa luam legatura sa vedem c ai tu, si ce am eu.
zdrontzi 3 years ago
ati fost la landgraaf
forward2007 3 years ago
Va invidiez nebunaticilor.......
crystoyu 2 years ago
@FerKoVaX OF la dracu norocosilor :)) presupun ca a fost experienta vietii voastre
clujromanialinkin 1 year ago
@clujromanialinkin categoric a fost :)
FerKoVaX 1 year ago
Todo está muy claro: para sustituir a Gilmour, Waters tiene dos guitarristas, e incluso así no llenan el vacío.
adamcastforth 3 years ago
Waters is good on the storytelling part, it's more into lyrics. On the other hand, Gilmour has a better voice and guitar technique. Nevertheless, both are true artists and both have outstanding works.
Would you please stop the war on who is best? Does it really matters? Best on what level? Both are really good artists, with different styles, with common roots.
paingul 3 years ago 13
well said!
poussyledzep 2 years ago
@paingul Liked your comment.So FWIW I just read that, as part of a bargain to persuade Waters to play "To Know Him Is To Love Him" with him at a charity gig (strange but true..) Gilmore has offered to play the comfortably numb solo at one of the gigs on Waters Wall tour..and Waters has accepted !!! No, I couldn't believe it either, but google it you will see it is true
echo680 1 year ago
@paingul Well said mister, why argue about who's best. Waters or Gilmour. When we have fuckups like Justin Beiber and Brittany Spears..
tuborgsommer 1 year ago
its getting a bit old listing to all you fags fight over whos better water or gilmore just enjoy the fucking music
tony1238 3 years ago 4
Who's the guy on the right?! His guitar work is less than impressive. The guy on the left is okay, though - very "Pink Floyd" sounding...
stonewall00 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Great. Waters is pink floyd. Gilmour is a bad blue copy of pink floyd. This guitar solo is better tha Gilmour. Gilmour cant write songs. He can tell money. Gilmour have destroyed the name pink floyd. I have listen to them for 35 years. I saw pink floyd in 1994 and this gig was bad. I like sound and voice not las vegas.
What have pink be without waters????
Nothing!!!! So stop glamming gilmour.
perspaser123 4 years ago
You do realize everything in this is song besides the lyrics, are from gilmour. Every member of pink floyd played a part in their whole era, Roger didn't realize this till he left the band and last i heard he regrets it. He treated his member like studio musicians which they weren't. Pink Floyd would be nothing without rogers, but rogers is nothing without pink floyd.
I7arkSideofTheMoon 4 years ago 3
Gilmour is what makes this song great, nobody can sing the chorus like him, and when he plays this solo the world stops. He's David Gilmour for fuck sakes.
base147 4 years ago
i am david gilmour
tcas12 3 years ago
no im david gilmour... and so are all of my neighbors
weirdotis 3 years ago 3
David Gilmour is everything and everyone. We all are David Gilmour
dsordlyfolks666 2 years ago
Asshole. Water isn´t Pink Floyd, David is the best.
PzGreni362 4 years ago
it s like...comfortably dumb
renajoule 4 years ago
great!i was there too.but comfortably numb not the same without gilmour:(
renajoule 4 years ago
Who give a sh&t if Waters or Gilmour was better..shut it and enjoy the music!
AmericanKoot 4 years ago 7
Who gives a sh&t if Gilmour or Waters was better...enjoy their music and shut the hell up!
AmericanKoot 4 years ago 2
Pink floyd was great in all the periods... Gilmour is great, Waters too... and syd was amazing....
They can't be compared, they are totally different noone is better than an another in this band... they are different!
56Nikos 4 years ago 3
yo juí al toquin y ha sido de lo meor que he visto en vivo, MASTER !
emeteriozacarias 4 years ago
Roger was amazing live one of the best concerts I have ever been to!!!!
Thedoors1967 4 years ago 3
b/c the people want to fuckin see the old stuff
tanz1771 4 years ago
this song is nothing without its master: DAVID GILMOUR!!!!!!!
RickardJohansson 4 years ago 2
Maybe... But, if Roger Waters hadn't written all of the great PF music, David Gilmour would be... Yes, he played a mean guitar, but Roger Waters was the creative genius behind PF... Tha is pretty much undisputed...
rickc176 4 years ago 2
Waters is very good but especially this song must be with gilmour...
RickardJohansson 4 years ago 2
I agree with you 100% Gilmour is amazing but roger was the brain behind it all!
Thedoors1967 4 years ago
Yeah but who cares Roger is just playing the same old tunes over and over If he is such a genius why wasn't he able to do more then just playing the old stuff every night
WeHaveLostTheWay 4 years ago
Gilmour came up with 3 great albums after pink floyd and with pink floyd without Roger. Roger only came up with 2 shitty albums which proves without gilmour Roger is shit all, and david gilmour came up with alot of fucking sweet songs when they were together
germ923 4 years ago
Pros and cons of Hitch-Hiking was an amazing album. Radio KAOS was weird so I'm not gonna defend it that much. But Amused to
death was really good.
sethmanjette12 4 years ago
amen brother
friendobrians 4 years ago
Gilmour solo great albums?! You mean just for the money. Amused to death and Pros and cons of... are far better than any work gilmour could dream on.
rockaires 4 years ago
WeHaveLostTheWay: maybe that old stuff is incomparable better then new stuff? maybe "new stuff" makers just wanna grabs that cash with both hands and make a stash?
3ras3d 4 years ago
que buena calidad de videoo master
emeteriozacarias 4 years ago
too bad most of his guitar solos are pre-recorded, by either him or he uses dave gilmours
DamoSanchez 4 years ago
"Comfortably Numb" is not the same without Dave Gilmour...
wislaczka 4 years ago
amazing it was.
LUBRIFICAZIONEN 4 years ago
yeah, it was un-b-e-l-i-e-v-a-b-l-e =)
TheGreatEatlon 4 years ago
i've been there too... perfect,amazing...Waters forever!
nihilbill 4 years ago
great, great, great show, the best ever, music that goes under your skin ...wish it would never end.
glogl 4 years ago
A fost minunat! Nu stiu daca voi mai trai vreodata asa ceva.
diakrisis 4 years ago
I've been there too!!! Waters! Waters! Waters!!!
BluesDd 4 years ago
perfect...I've been there too...
atat de mult am asteptat acest concert...
moroshm 4 years ago
this was the greatest concert ever...i've been there and i felt every second some shivers down my spine...and i could nor believe myself when some tears fell from my eyes...just...PERFECT!!!
cosminst2008 4 years ago