Andrea's not even playing the whistle. What was the point of that? The tin whistle used in the Titanic song is in the key of A-flat. Most tin whistles are in D. Andrea's holding a Wilson whistle, most likely in the key of D but you can't tell. Doesn't matter, though--she's miming.
@gummibearfilms you should see the youtube video of Celine dion singing with Josh Groban...Celine has her microphone close and Josh groban has his about half a foot away and he's still louder then her...i have read somewhere Josh Groban can shatter a mirror with his voice.
@PedrixVk I don't know? I think so, because shes the only one that plays it exactly like in the movie. All the other idiots can't play the simple notes!
@gummibearfilms Hey don't mess with taylor swift, I don't like her, but she's really talented, maybe u meant to write, britney spears, selena gomez, kesha, katy perry, ashley tisdale!
@PrealienA The entire recording, both the flute and Celine sound 100% like the recorded version, which is impossible. There is always some variation in a live performance, for sure. So you are right!
@gummibearfilms I must agree that THAT is true talent on the part of ALL the performers. What's amazing is that Celine sounds just as good live as she would in a studio recording. That's saying a lot because sounding as good in a live performance as you do in a studio is almost unheard of. Damn...
Every night in my dreams I see you. I feel you. That is how I know you go on. Far across the distance And spaces between us You have come to show you go on. Near, far, wherever you are I believe that the heart does go on Once more you open the door And you're here in my heart And my heart will go on and on Love can touch us one time And last for a lifetime And never go till we're one Love was when I loved you One true time I hold to In my life we'll always go on
@siya08 It's called a TIN WHISTLE.The tin whistle also called the penny whistle , English Flageolet, Scottish penny whistle, Tin Flageolet, Irish whistle and Clarke London Flageolet is a simple six-holed woodwind instrument. It is an end blown fipple flute flageolet, putting it in the same category as the recorder, American Indian flute, and other woodwind instruments.
Hey thanks!! but i was asking about the brand of this whistle, and which key.. I think its Generation Bb.... but i wana make that sure.. as I am planning to buy one..
@markniteguy where was this?montreal?grazia" she says at the end so spain or italy? b/c they have the guts to sing along with an artist-like the do from the beginning of this song-pple quebec emotional/ "aggressive"-not much jobs 4 french-only except performers&dairy farming(harsh) lots farmers suicides so insurance will pay banks so farm not lost & family not end in drug sexslave ghettos-quebec declared #1 north american childporn/prost trafic (poverty =landless- b/c rich/corrupt church/police
actually it is low wistle which is specific variation of a tin whistle. You can tell that by it's lower pitch and larger size comparing to traditional tin whistle. I have never seen Andrea playing low whistle except in this one song.
Can't for the life of me understand why they didn't do a duet ... t'would have been heavenly to heart them sing this together. Perhaps another time then ... and we'll all be happy!
how is it possible for a song to be this perfect studio recorded AND live? my brain can't quite comprehend it, so it sends chills down my spine :) not that I mind
As much as I like Andrea Corr, she's not playing the tin whistle here. You can see at 0:36, she takes a breath, and the tin whistle magically continues playing when there should've been a very brief pause in the sound.
@Dev1ner For what reason would she not be playing the tin whistle? That is her instrument; she learned how to play it when she was a child. Why wouldn't she play it live?
@zamusician I dunno, you tell me? The same reason people don't always sing live? I'm fully aware of her musical abilities and I know she can play the tin whistle perfectly... but in this performance, she wasn't playing. You only need to look at 0:35 when she takes a breath, the sound of the tin whistle is still being played. If she's inhaling, she's hardly blowing through the tin whistle so it can't magically continue to play unless it was a pre-recording. I still like her though.. :)
@Dev1ner Oh trust me, I don't doubt that you like her. That moment at 0:35 that you're referring to is actually her playing. If you watch the entire video very, very closely, you can see that the video is just slightly out of sync with the audio. That's why it looks like that.
@Dev1ner You are totally right. I hadn't noticed that! I don't know who she is and I don't know what she does becuase in Argentina nobody talks about her, but she seems to be a good artits(and she's so beautiful). Celine Dion is not very beautiful but I love her voice.
This song and its film still make me cry even they became famous in 1996! They are wonderful!
@diegohotful She's a very famous Irish musician from the band 'The Corrs' which have some very good songs! She is the lead singer for The Corrs, and occasionally plays the tin whistle. She plays the tin whistle perfectly normally, so I dont know why it was pre-recorded here... and yea she's gorgeous and a great ambassador for Ireland!
The Irish, which I am in part, call this a "Tin Whistle". Whatever the name, in the hands of Andrea Corr, all the more beautiful. Oui? Celine Dion just nails it! What a voice. Outstanding. Magnifique!
No, i don't speak about the whistle, but the player, she move in front of the micro, but the sound don't move, and the micro should be just in front of the opening for the air in the whistle. The whistle has been recorded before in studio
Sotry. I have played a Generation Bb into Shure SM-58 in front of large audiences (just like she is doing), and she is doing just what she should be doing in that situation -- letting the mic pick up the sound holes and not the fipple blade. It keeps the dynamic range small for the engineer, and avoids breath sounds on top of Ms. Dion.
She ha performed for years, and what she is playing is extremely simple (except for the finesse), so I see no need to dub it in.
What a great video to watch. Celine Dion and Andrea Corr. Two very beautiful woman. In heaven watching this. I can't think of 2 people I would like to see more together.
Andrea's not even playing the whistle. What was the point of that? The tin whistle used in the Titanic song is in the key of A-flat. Most tin whistles are in D. Andrea's holding a Wilson whistle, most likely in the key of D but you can't tell. Doesn't matter, though--she's miming.
RLviddy 3 weeks ago
awesome//amazing collaboration
this song truly inspiring me
thanks for create a beautiful song n I thought it's gonna be everlasting love song
Mitsuakiize 1 month ago
Girl playing flute thingy is HOT!
godisgoodatht 2 months ago in playlist Liked videos
Thx For Music and Celine Dion
ThailandMayBee 2 months ago
@gummibearfilms you should see the youtube video of Celine dion singing with Josh Groban...Celine has her microphone close and Josh groban has his about half a foot away and he's still louder then her...i have read somewhere Josh Groban can shatter a mirror with his voice.
ChosenDruid 3 months ago
andreas hot!
ihamma2000 4 months ago
@ihamma2000 she is hot as hell!!
Algerino307 4 months ago
goosebumps dude
HipHopWillV 4 months ago
Is the original from the movie played also by Corr?
PedrixVk 4 months ago
@PedrixVk no. i think.
msjanblr 3 months ago
@PedrixVk I don't know? I think so, because shes the only one that plays it exactly like in the movie. All the other idiots can't play the simple notes!
calliopeman10 2 months ago
She can play my flute any day.
megadeth1056 4 months ago 2
Is this performance on DVD? It wasn't on the Pavarotti benefit release.
brokeagain2 5 months ago
i love andrea!!!!!!!!!!!!
ihamma2000 5 months ago
dang after seeing the titanic at least 50 times i can't believe it still sinks
imarookey 5 months ago
it may be that the audience sings along?
yougetitbaby 6 months ago in playlist Zu Favoriten hinzugefügte Videos von yougetitbaby
Goosebumps!
UnRe4L88 6 months ago
so beautiful! perfect performance of Celine Dione and Andrea Corr!
TheLGleek 6 months ago
@gummibearfilms Hey don't mess with taylor swift, I don't like her, but she's really talented, maybe u meant to write, britney spears, selena gomez, kesha, katy perry, ashley tisdale!
abrieva 8 months ago
Andrea Corr looks especially stunning here. 0:29
dreamingWisdom 8 months ago
11 dislikers got their heads bleed when push the button
isr4el666 8 months ago
superb...!!! no words..!
SSmusicpvtltd 9 months ago
This song is still great.. Excellent performance for Celine Dion, Andrea Corrs
k3ntang 9 months ago
I Love Andrea Corr !
fraglesws1 9 months ago
quem sabe faz ao vivo
anab9509 10 months ago
Was it playback?
Andrea was moving around the microphone and it still played with the same intensity.
PrealienA 10 months ago
@PrealienA The entire recording, both the flute and Celine sound 100% like the recorded version, which is impossible. There is always some variation in a live performance, for sure. So you are right!
NovaScotiaChick 7 months ago
@NovaScotiaChick could be, but the key is different from the original!
jamen1993 6 months ago
Andrea Corr is particularly cute here. I wonder if she did the tin whistle on the original recording.
MattWhatsGoinOn 10 months ago
wow wow wow did u see that girl playing flute that was really mindblowing, outstanding, fantasticccccccccccccccccccccccc
huepcr 10 months ago
it's like a hands-free bulimia kit.
MrTonyInchpractice 10 months ago
Amazing voice.
HARRYRABBITvmkname 10 months ago
I LOVE ANDREA CORR !
fraglesws1 11 months ago
Amazing ! Take my breath away everytime !!
GuyaneseSweethart55 11 months ago
she´s perfect...
raphaeljesussr2 11 months ago
i cried every time i heard this song....just b e a u t i f u l
TheresaStarshine 11 months ago
Flawless.
NicholausC 11 months ago
Thank God for, and God bless Celine Dion - and that cute, young, and sweet little lady by the name of Andrea Corr!
MattWhatsGoinOn 11 months ago
@gummibearfilms I must agree that THAT is true talent on the part of ALL the performers. What's amazing is that Celine sounds just as good live as she would in a studio recording. That's saying a lot because sounding as good in a live performance as you do in a studio is almost unheard of. Damn...
typhon3808 11 months ago
Best video of ALL time :)
Barderella 11 months ago
Love love love this song ^^
pakbung1983 1 year ago
11 people are suckers
vidostrugaru 1 year ago
@vidostrugaru I agree :)))
peticsek28 1 year ago
if i could sing this song that well, i'd probably cry every time. i don't know how she does it...
dizzypunchpanda29 1 year ago
Crikey just imagine celine's voice and andrea's looks. The ideal woman?
155MikeC 1 year ago
Mỗi lần tôi nghe lại bài hát này,làm tôi vô vùng cảm xúc:(....Thank you Celine Dion! Thanks for upload to YouTube !!!!
Bichvanluong 1 year ago
ahh! this is so amazing :D
jen7 1 year ago
aww makes me cry every time :( :) x
laaurennXx 1 year ago
Stage designer needs to get to the 21st century! - shit stage set up.
MJDickson69 1 year ago
@gummibearfilms especially for talyor swift LOL
florachan92 1 year ago
esta cancion es hermosa!!! unica, wow no hay palabras, y solo celine dion para esta cancion!!!!
andyhermosa1 1 year ago
love this song back then and the rest of my life she has a voice of a real star a and shines like one too
calibear831ful 1 year ago
@leftcoastlean
88THEBUNNYMAN88 1 year ago
@leftcoastlean
The girl is Andrea Corr of the Irish Celtic music band The Corrs. Check out this angel!
Sovokit 1 year ago
yes my heart is going on and on, wish if Celine Dion and Andrea Corr offer a few more of their bests, thanks Celine and Andrea
Omer Sabore
The184300 1 year ago
Who could dislike this?
Amazing song, amazing voice, amazing movie...
DreamDecider95 1 year ago
razelikz 1 year ago
what a performance by Celine! andrea is cute as always.
lk7ar 1 year ago
so butiful song
I so love this song (:
...the movie also fantastic
TheGuy19994 1 year ago
There's no voice as Celine's... :)
crickella 1 year ago
Andrea!...the corrs are so beautiful. And Celine is amazing as always, that goes without saying.
NevanImranTheCambion 1 year ago
1:20-1:38...MAGICAL¡¡¡¡
MrMagikdj 1 year ago
neone have ne idea, which whistle was used exactly by andrea here??
siya08 1 year ago
@siya08 It's called a TIN WHISTLE.The tin whistle also called the penny whistle , English Flageolet, Scottish penny whistle, Tin Flageolet, Irish whistle and Clarke London Flageolet is a simple six-holed woodwind instrument. It is an end blown fipple flute flageolet, putting it in the same category as the recorder, American Indian flute, and other woodwind instruments.
markniteguy 1 year ago 12
@markniteguy
Hey thanks!! but i was asking about the brand of this whistle, and which key.. I think its Generation Bb.... but i wana make that sure.. as I am planning to buy one..
siya08 1 year ago
@markniteguy Thank you, i had the same qustion.
yourcollectables1 1 year ago
@markniteguy where was this?montreal?grazia" she says at the end so spain or italy? b/c they have the guts to sing along with an artist-like the do from the beginning of this song-pple quebec emotional/ "aggressive"-not much jobs 4 french-only except performers&dairy farming(harsh) lots farmers suicides so insurance will pay banks so farm not lost & family not end in drug sexslave ghettos-quebec declared #1 north american childporn/prost trafic (poverty =landless- b/c rich/corrupt church/police
lmollot 11 months ago
@markniteguy
actually it is low wistle which is specific variation of a tin whistle. You can tell that by it's lower pitch and larger size comparing to traditional tin whistle. I have never seen Andrea playing low whistle except in this one song.
Corrsarz 1 month ago
@siya08 I think its a generation Bb whistle.
DazIOM1140 5 months ago in playlist Liked
@siya08 I'm not sure... I think its a D tin whistle maybe?
lovingtheglam 1 month ago
everytime i hear that beautiful song i get goose flesh. it´s so magical.
kakapfurz 1 year ago
Can't for the life of me understand why they didn't do a duet ... t'would have been heavenly to heart them sing this together. Perhaps another time then ... and we'll all be happy!
coomhola 1 year ago 2
o gosh! i dont know wat to say! im just stunned with that pretty thimble flutist! anyone else find miss andrea corr pretty and cute? =P
yoshimitsuification 1 year ago
(tear)
birneyqueen 1 year ago
te iubesc enorm Clau...
ButterflyPau 1 year ago
Shouldn't it be Celine Dion and Andrea Corr? Not Andrea Corr and Celine Dion?
xXxiPodSingerxXx 1 year ago
how is it possible for a song to be this perfect studio recorded AND live? my brain can't quite comprehend it, so it sends chills down my spine :) not that I mind
Wishworks 1 year ago 2
when ever i hear this sonh my body just chivers i dont know what this is but very little singers can do that to me :)
Untkapis 1 year ago
5 stars for Andrea Corr !!!
ficolossale 1 year ago 5
The tin whistle sound on background is fantastic, Andrea Corr is a great player!
ISMEP 1 year ago 3
after so many years, everytime i listen to this song and i have goosebump!!!! love u, Celine.
upaa83 1 year ago
So effortlessly she belts out this amazingly smooth sound. The ultimate of female singers ever
Duke4Reuti 1 year ago
meravigliosa.....
francesco7645 1 year ago
I love Andrea Corr, Genetics very good to Andrea Corr !
fraglesws1 1 year ago 4
Gives me goosebumps every time!
AucklandNZ1 1 year ago
makes me cry everytime this song, but I love it
R00RAL 1 year ago
I can't STAND her songs. But hot DAMN can that woman SING! Man!
setialphasix 1 year ago
she is like the ONLY artist that her when she sings live is almost as good as the CD! (: <#
jennydun12 1 year ago 3
@jennydun12 lol this is BETTER than the cd :))))
AyaEroksal 1 year ago
4:05-4:08 - there r ppl leaving? wtf??
matthewosterloh 1 year ago
Andrea Corr... the multy talented artist...
Bataramintaraga 1 year ago 3
Comment removed
lakelandchief 1 year ago
its ok.
8sammysammy 1 year ago
Gulp! I'm filling up too!
1nker 1 year ago
As much as I like Andrea Corr, she's not playing the tin whistle here. You can see at 0:36, she takes a breath, and the tin whistle magically continues playing when there should've been a very brief pause in the sound.
Dev1ner 1 year ago
@Dev1ner For what reason would she not be playing the tin whistle? That is her instrument; she learned how to play it when she was a child. Why wouldn't she play it live?
zamusician 1 year ago
@zamusician I dunno, you tell me? The same reason people don't always sing live? I'm fully aware of her musical abilities and I know she can play the tin whistle perfectly... but in this performance, she wasn't playing. You only need to look at 0:35 when she takes a breath, the sound of the tin whistle is still being played. If she's inhaling, she's hardly blowing through the tin whistle so it can't magically continue to play unless it was a pre-recording. I still like her though.. :)
Dev1ner 1 year ago
@Dev1ner Oh trust me, I don't doubt that you like her. That moment at 0:35 that you're referring to is actually her playing. If you watch the entire video very, very closely, you can see that the video is just slightly out of sync with the audio. That's why it looks like that.
zamusician 1 year ago
@Dev1ner You are totally right. I hadn't noticed that! I don't know who she is and I don't know what she does becuase in Argentina nobody talks about her, but she seems to be a good artits(and she's so beautiful). Celine Dion is not very beautiful but I love her voice.
This song and its film still make me cry even they became famous in 1996! They are wonderful!
diegohotful 1 year ago
@diegohotful She's a very famous Irish musician from the band 'The Corrs' which have some very good songs! She is the lead singer for The Corrs, and occasionally plays the tin whistle. She plays the tin whistle perfectly normally, so I dont know why it was pre-recorded here... and yea she's gorgeous and a great ambassador for Ireland!
Dev1ner 1 year ago
Andrea Corr and Celine Dion Rocks!!
TheDrew088 1 year ago
love her hair
niceocean1 1 year ago
Andrea Corr es la que toca la flauta y que linda canción
peruana54 1 year ago
The Irish, which I am in part, call this a "Tin Whistle". Whatever the name, in the hands of Andrea Corr, all the more beautiful. Oui? Celine Dion just nails it! What a voice. Outstanding. Magnifique!
Merci beaucoup, "markniteguy". Good stuff!
Bonsoir.
michaelabasham 1 year ago 3
@michaelabasham
If it ain't made out of tin, it ain't a "tinwhistle", michaela. The Irish call that a "pennywhistle" - specifically a Generation Bb.
Rajamuttu 1 year ago
@michaelabasham
Or simply - a whistle.
Rajamuttu 1 year ago
Comment removed
michaelabasham 1 year ago
the whistle is a playbaaaack!!!
neo035 1 year ago
@neo035
What a load of rubbish. I was even playing along with this on my own Generation Bb whistle.
And that's why AC stopped playing when CD modulated to a different key. Or didn't you notice?
Rajamuttu 1 year ago
@Rajamuttu
No, i don't speak about the whistle, but the player, she move in front of the micro, but the sound don't move, and the micro should be just in front of the opening for the air in the whistle. The whistle has been recorded before in studio
neo035 1 year ago
@neo035
Sotry. I have played a Generation Bb into Shure SM-58 in front of large audiences (just like she is doing), and she is doing just what she should be doing in that situation -- letting the mic pick up the sound holes and not the fipple blade. It keeps the dynamic range small for the engineer, and avoids breath sounds on top of Ms. Dion.
She ha performed for years, and what she is playing is extremely simple (except for the finesse), so I see no need to dub it in.
Rajamuttu 1 year ago
@neo035
Now, I would like to know who was doing the second voice!
Rajamuttu 1 year ago
What a vid :)
sixthprawn 1 year ago
i'm not irish only half welsh but i love irish music and singers..check out my new version of 'the fields of athenry'...cheers
gypwin 1 year ago
this is one of my all time favorite songs!!!!
aamfrsh 1 year ago
Love you Andrea <3
florencelovme 1 year ago 3
flöten spiel live.?
bunny3490 1 year ago
the best song that really makes me feel soo strong for LOVE
norzulita 1 year ago 3
the best song that really makes me feel soo strong for LOVE
norzulita 1 year ago 2
best performance ever!!!
d1zz3l1zz3 1 year ago
i wish i could play the tin-whistle
d1zz3l1zz3 1 year ago
see andrea corr's act with the fleute at 3:29 , was amazing i liked it very much
ammarhureshi 1 year ago
@ammarhureshi its not a "fleute" its a tin whistle similar but not!
OneoftheVoice 1 year ago
the parts with the fleute are the best:)
pepsi1717 1 year ago 2
suchh an amazing voice. true singer cos she can sing well live XD
WiGaNeR100 1 year ago
the girl with the whistle is so amazing too:)
MrGogoshar 1 year ago 3
@MrGogoshar the girl with the whistle omg thats andrea corr she has the voice of an angel herself
huggybear271 1 year ago 3
this is awesome, the film version sucks, it just doesn't sound like her! oh yeah and Andrea Corr!
alexandre1129 1 year ago 2
It's so amazing, that people can sing so well in live!..
TwelveGirlsBand 1 year ago 2
wohooooooo!!!!!!!!
dontmindthem 1 year ago
What a legend :)
nothinbuthax 1 year ago 3
Andrea Corr?? UP THE IRISH!
bedheadbread 1 year ago 2
bite your tounge, angela is angelic
cityguy2129 1 year ago
beautiful
edituleeeee1994 1 year ago
Zoooon moooiiii nummmmeeerrrr
kusmanonkus 1 year ago
4:10 so much power in her voice
beautiful
naberkev 2 years ago
ANDREA is so AMAZING ! :DD
jowemaya 2 years ago 2
A true diva.. great performer, great singer, great talent.
Definitely not like a Witney Houston, Mariah Carey, where shouting seems to be the thing.
Celine can actually SING!
xvoy2002 2 years ago
...my heart will go on and on..so true Celine Dione ..every time I put the song on I have tears in my eyes .Magic song !
k28ify 2 years ago 36
I love the sound of everyone singing along with her. It warms my heart :)
Britt18ify 2 years ago 49
@Britt18ify I loved it too :) I'm glad someone else noticed also!
XxlissachicksXx 1 year ago
@Britt18ify I agree and I as well feel the same!
mikerussell 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Andrea Corr not only beauty but also very talented.
matutina5 2 years ago
Andrea Corr not only beauty but very talented as well
matutina5 2 years ago 7
girl playin flute is awesum looking
jojoshooter 2 years ago 5
that's andrea corr
forevercupcake 2 years ago
when was this concert? late 1990s?
handsomeian 2 years ago
Andrea Corr - I'd hit it.
theusedish 2 years ago
se me pone la piel de gallina escuchando esta cancion es super HERMOSA.
NicoAdrianTora 2 years ago 2
This song will never be old! It's so wonderful and still gives me chills!
Darkina85 2 years ago 10
This song will never go out of date! It's an EVERGREEN!!! I simply love it!!!
terryleejameson 2 years ago 8
andrea corr.. yur the best!!
ninalualhati 2 years ago 3
best song ever i dont care what anyone thinks.
ironsy9 2 years ago 5
best performance of this I've seen...she has one of the most amazing voices. can't deny it, whether or not you love or hate her. undeniable talent.
FinksEntourage 2 years ago 3
i lluuuv this song the best singers of all time... celiene dion
iamawwefan1997 2 years ago 6
I'm a guy and I love this song! 3:45 - 4:05 is just amazing =)
jmoj9662 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I can't stand Celine Dion's singing. It sounds so pretentious and phony.
jst1998 2 years ago
all this time i thought it was something else i didnt know it was TIn whistle and its Andrea COrr!!
Lai829 2 years ago 4
whistle (L)
panconquesoderretido 2 years ago
I find this song very soothing.
fah85 2 years ago 2
Such a lovely song.
fah85 2 years ago 5
What a great video to watch. Celine Dion and Andrea Corr. Two very beautiful woman. In heaven watching this. I can't think of 2 people I would like to see more together.
qgcboss01 2 years ago 5
One of the best live versions of this song.
Yangedd 2 years ago 2
aww i kan hear the crowd singing wth her
pok3rfac 2 years ago 3
Just Lovely and Amazing. A Great Combination,
fah85 2 years ago 3
wonderfull
Rittersporthero 2 years ago
That is a tin whistle! I love it! And I love this...
fireyulia 2 years ago 3
Its a tin whistle, and whoever wrote that song owes royalties to the Irish culture for stealing the tune.
scati1971 2 years ago 4
are you sure it's tin whistle ??
dontjudgeme8484 2 years ago
awesome awesome performance
celine dion i love ,
andrea corr fabulous penny whistle
dontjudgeme8484 2 years ago 3
Waw!!! I love everything about this.
TheJustKatee 2 years ago 2
It's not a flute it's a Tin Whistle which she plays with The Corrs so having her play was awsome. :)
DaredevilFan1 2 years ago 3
i m in luv wid andrea. I wish she was my girlfriend. uuuuuuuuuuummmmwaaa. i luv u andrea