Added: 4 years ago
From: gregoryleclair
Views: 142,901
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (174)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Hilary, marry me, k? 

  • hilary is such an incredibly down to earth, completely humble person. and seriously there is nobody in the world more technically brilliant than her. there's nothing she can't do on the violin. I seriously believe that. she never plays a note out of tone either.

  • This is amazing! Does anyone know where this video came from???

  • Personally, I love this video. I think it is a wonderful work of art.

  • I LOVE HER!!!!! She's sooo cute.

  • wow, in 1:16 there is an amazing photo!

    hilary hahn is an amazing violinist, but i admit, this is a weird video. XD

  • ???? que trata de decir el video???

    esta genial la melodia y el estilo pero no entiendo el video....

  • wtf was she doing to her violin????

  • Bellissimo!!!!

    Roberto.

  • Meraviglioso....poesia...roman­ticismo....idea....lascia spazio ad un proprio pensiero come ogni opera d'arte....

    Tra i miei preferiti!

    Roberto.

  • Really lovely playing.

  • Yes DG, I do think of Hilary's cleavage when I listen to her... As such, may thanks for 4.02 ...

  • 2:20 look out there is a wast nest up above in the eve of the barn!

  • she is unbeliveable !!

  • i. Je n’ai rien contre les musiciennes qui se font prendre en photo en maillot de bain dans la mer, en train de jouer du violon. Mais ce n’est pas ma tasse de thé, cela ne correspond pas à ma personnalité. Cela m’éloignerait trop de moi-même et ça, je ne le veux pas. On ne peut pas être un bon musicien si on se laisse distraire par ce genre de choses. Dit-elle en entrevue, Mais je n'ai rien contre, toute nue ce serait mieux!

  • @michelclavecin

    Pardon, mais je ne vois aucune musicienne en maillot de bain dans cette vidéo.

    Rares sont les moments où l'on voit vraiment son visage. Ce n'est pas du tout une vidéo narcissique. C'est juste "spécial" et expérimental. Pas de voyeurisme.

  • @baireniz

    C'est vrai, mais elle est tellement belle qu'elle n'a pas besoin de se déshabiller beaucoup pour me distraire! Et je trouve que ce genre de clip ne correspond pas aux artistes classiques,, vois tu Pollini, Leonhardt ou Argerich faire ça? C'est juste mon opinion!

  • i'm not crazy about the mtv zation of classical music, but i love hilary and this video...

  • this is really experimental...

  • beautiful...but...I don't understand. :( 

  • bravo

  • @kusokosla It's a DAMN good thing that this will never be on MTV since that disgrace of a channel is nothing but proof of ignorance in today's culture! D:<

    No one is saying that she's going to be "modeling Victoria's Secret anytime soon," believe it or not, that's not every girl's goal in life!!!

    Nobody here is even trying to say that it's "hip" it's ART! Unlike that crap that you find on the so-called "Musical Television" (that hardly even plays music any more).

  • Yes... overpracticing can definitely lead to daydreams like that one. I don't particularly like this piece (no matter who plays it) but Hilary is one of the best violinists around. Want proof? Listen to her performance of the Korngold... best I've ever heard.

  • simply brilliant..more words are unnecessary!

  • That's because the pope is an old timer...lol

  • Video aside (and, yes, I would prefer a blank screen), I love this performance.

  • For the way you put that, Louise, you have my unconditional anonymous love forever.

  • Poor Hilary, she did not deserve this video, I'm just a film student but I'm sure I could've come up with something better

  • I know you could!

  • And me thinking I was missing something here..

  • ugh. I love to be a contrarian, so it pains my ego to say Hilary Hahn makes me enjoy composers I never had before.

  • Molto abbastanza, adored il video.

    :)

  • Sorry, I meant "chin rest".

  • There are two violins on this video. Sometimes the one she is carrying has a centrally mounted shoulder rest and sometimes it has one off to the side.

    Weird.

  • Brilliant!!!

  • To each his own. I think she is fab.

  • @jayadsilva67

    unbelievable..did Kogan play for the Pope? I do not know.

  • No, idiot, Hilary played at the inaugural for the present pope and he was falling asleep

  • That is the pope`s problem, not Hilary`s.

    I saw the concert live!

  • That is just amazingly Hilarius!

  • Hilary is cute.

  • Cut the woman some slack folks! I'll tell you a little secret: being this gifted is no party and sometimes it can be hell. I grew up in a working mans house where we listened to my brother play Chopin and Bach before he was ten years old..Elation and the dark side of it.. Every day I thank God he made me a "plug" and I truly enjoy it!

  • Deep.

  • um... was she smashing her violin with an ax? i don't get the plotline here... great playing though! :)

  • It's very good!

  • I guess the director did a great job in making art, since no one seems to understand this at all. Can we turn on the director's commentary track please? lol

    Even though I don't quite understand this, I still think this is quite interesting and thanks for posting this.

  • Too much for me. Weird to see classical take back seat to pop culture. The music gets lost

  • dont get it

  • This video is really weird! I have seen Hilary Hahn perform twice tho and she is an amazing violinist!

  • Thank you soooooo much for posting :D!!!

  • Good girl.

  • odd video..wonder if it is about "deconstructing" the violin so that she and the violin can become one. (the scroll on her head, she IS a violin) The hands around the violin..her hands are filled with the violins very essence..the bars, her physical state and the violins physical state bar their union, thus the deconstruction of the instrument...toss in your ideas..brain storming here!!!

  • What a beautiful piece in all ways.

    A wonderful dream complete with violin shaped clouds and a scroll hair-pin, water-ripple dancing and many earthly elements.

    Divine playing my Hilary which touches deeply.

  • The ironic thing is that this was posted on my birthday

  • Every good classical player needs some humor once in a while. She can't be all boring. Besides she has to show off all her pretty dresses! (notice she's in a different dress every time basically) lol No one else is complaning. She's so pretty! Lucky her :-P...

  • oh yeah cuz she's really gonna take her real violin out in the nasty feild so she can drop it in the mud puddle and fall into it w/ it...with no showers because of no electricity out in the sticks...sure she would

  • There's always a clown in the bunch. Find any photo of a person playing a viola and you'll realize Hilary is holding a violin. Besides, Hilary wouldn't be caught dead with a viola.

  • The chin rest in the centre should be a dead give away. I'm not saying that all violas have the chin rest in the centre (they don't), but many do.

  • actually, there are two instruments featured in this video. scroll back to 40-41, when she turns, you see that the chin rest is on the side, but when she lays, the chin rest is in the center.

    and also, violins do some with chin rests in the center, too. my orchestra teacher has one, and it definitely isn't a viola.

  • yeah, i have one of those chin rests. it suits my style better than the ones that have it on the side

  • A nicely filmed and edited piece featuring a brilliant and beautiful young talent. The violin seen here and that she use as a pillow is most certainly not her concert instrument.

  • That's because it's a viola.

  • She is an astoundingly beautiful woman.

  • Hilary Hahn is about soul feeling emotion humor enormous talent and hard work!

  • Beautiful work on this, Great to see a softer and fragile/delicate side based on the vs of her professional side as a great artist. Truly a pleasure to have a different insight to the mind of brilliance.

    Trey

  • i luv this video!

  • I love this dark video accompanied with dark music performed so emotionally by the greatest female violinist of our days...

  • Hilary Hahn's brilliant - one of my favourite contemporary performers.

    Classical music videos are dreadful though aren't they?! You can almost feel the pain of the producers saying "OK, so classical music videos can't be like pop videos because by enlarge we're targetting a different audience. So what do we do? Hmm... Any ideas... Err... No-one? Nope?! OK let's just do something weird and hope no-one notices!".

  • I just find it so cheesy...she deserves a better video!

  • Haha!  Yeah, it's a weird video. But then again, when some musicians play, they see pictures, not exactly stories. So maybe, just maybe, this is what she sees in her head when she plays this piece. It's fascinating to know what classical musicians are thinking when they are playing. I think this video gives us little snippet of insight. =)

  • hmmm...not so sure that thats her real Villaume. im thinking that it would be stupid....to sleep on it. but um. well idk. this recording sounds a little bit unlike HH to me for some reason. and i listen to her like aaaaalll the time. i heart hilary:) lol

  • Yeah, when I listen to classical violin, it's usually one of her albums. She's great! I can only dream of playing some of the pieces that she plays... =(

    P.S. It isn't her real violin. The violin in this video has a chin rest that is in a different position on the violin than the violin that she plays.

  • My god, its the guy that did those Calvin Klien commercials in the early 90s :o

    Those of us that cherish Hilary and her work, know that this isnt her...To say that she is better than this, is a gross understatment!

    My sincerest thanks to Ms. Hahn, for all the beauty she gives birth too thru her talent..

  • A classical music video! I'm amused.

  • Yehudi Menuhin is the living soul of the violin. I really like Hilary Hahn, but girlfriend, honestly, this was so poorly done. I mean really. I was disappointed as a fan of yours. I saw you in the Kennedy Center...terrific.

  • Man how many idiots in this world !!!

  • Hilary Hahn is all about technique, Yehudi Menuhin is soul behind the technique, aah, I love Yehudi Menuhin.

  • All about technique? Go and listen to the The Village Soundtrack, that's definitely more emotion than technique.

    Beautiful concert, weird video (:

  • beethoven is the greatest composer to have lived...

  • I love Yehudi Menuhin!

  • why does it show hilary smashing the violin if she lves the violin so much?:P

    awkward...

  • nice chinese violin ;)

  • i'm with her right now and we are talking about all of your comments

  • you're with her right now, violinistchris? Tell her those film makers tricked her to have her play in a shitty, bad for your career movie...

  • i saw her perform this entire concerto in Indiana a couple of days ago. yes, be jealous!

  • saw her in syracuse last nite

  • this woulda been way cooler if she would have chugged a 40 and then burned a pile of violas and ended by driving off in a dumptruck

  • Most YouTube comments make me cringe, but this one made me laugh. Bravo!

  • it reminds me of the movie "the ring"... when she plays that weird video.

    still planning to marry Hilary Hahn one day...

  • Since when does a music video have to "make sense?" It's interpretive, it's not a movie.

    Erotic, no. Expressive, yes.

    I think she's adorable.

  • Is this meant to be erotic?

  • this makes no sence whatsoever......

  • great preformance

  • Whenever I need a laugh I watch this video.

  • search "paganini 18 Anton Polezhayev"

  • i love this piece,

    but i don't get how

    the music video related

    to the 2nd movment?

  • i bet she's a quirky woman. :)

  • What a strange video...

  • she is one of the greatest violinists of this time! and it probably wasn't ever her decision to make a music video! don't insult her!

  • and she is totally gripping the axe wrong

    ( holy smokes, folks!)

    very talented and very human

  • i could never lay down on my violin:))

  • You can have one violin to play, and some violins to act.

  • The violin she lays down is a modern violin with a chin rest. The one she pulls through the bars at 2:30 is the one she plays. It's much older, with no chin rest (watch some of the videos of her in concert, and she wraps a cloth between the wood of the violin and her neck). The neck is a bit less raked and the scroll seems more pronounced.

  • You do realize the chin rest is removable, don't you? Not having a chin rest doesn't make it old.

  • I didn't say the lack of chin rest made it old—I said it was old and it had no chin rest.

    Take a good look at the wood on the front of the violin in the two shots—I doubt her Vuillaume could ever look like the one under her head.

  • she has a vuillaume??

    i thought she was a strad person :|

  • Very sexy!

  • Hilary is a delight to watch live. Granted she isn't emotive like the violnists you metioned, but she does put on a good show. She has all the talent to be one of the best and perhaps she'll grow into being more expressive. She does need ot smile more you're right on that point. I can't think of any of her press photos where she is smiling. This video is clever. I like it.

  • hilary is a talented violinist but she, like sarah change and even joshua bell to some extent, plays it so safe. she doesn't explore and emote. the video tries to be creative and the concept is interesting, but like her music there is no emotion. she should watch people like nadia sonenberg, anne akiko meyers, and yehudi menuhin to see how much more you cna bring out of music through emotion and interpretation. and she should smile more too. the technique is there,,,just give us some feeling.

  • Please... Josh Bell flails around like a monkey when he performs.

  • this is some sony record exec tryin to market someone that is above marketing...Hilary Hahn is one of the greatest violinists in the world....She doesnt need a music video!!!

    And Paganini must be rolling over in his grave!!

  • wtf??????? god, kill me now...

  • Why do they have to make videos for things like this just play! netrebko does the same thing trying to be artful but instead just being stupid. She is a good violinist though :)

  • Why do we have to be critical of one who decides to have a little fun? Sure, she's a professional musician, but she is also a human being. Let her have her fun.

  • Hi Badstringer,I saw your some new comments just now.They're all well written.You know, actually many our opinions are same.But I still I don't understand why you must be so aggressive to me.

    I think the essential difference between classical music and other sorts is not just some higher emotion or technique but,at least for the non-musician, the ideology.

  • Newbee2000, I have read your comments. I have read your emails to me. Your comments about me being "naughty", and your great anger when you discovered I was not Hilary are consistent with an obsessive individual who becomes violent when you don't get your own way.

    In my experience with Hilary Hahn, she is an extremely sincere and thoughtful individual who wants very much to relate well with her audience. I see your behavior as a threat. I fear people like you will make her withdraw.

  • I think you two need to grow up. She is one of the greatest violinists in the world. With a phenomenal technique and sense of poetry, she'll go down as one of the great ones in the pantheon of violinists.

    However,

    Her interpretation of this Paganini is not my favorite, and the video is utterly incomprehensible to me. But I'm not blaming her for it. Let her do what she wants. Except stop playing and recording.

  • Ok, let's just admit it...based on this video, Hilary is rather weird.

  • Okay, sorry for my comment down below. I apologize. I was just overtaken by passion. For me, this is the best close-up video of Hilary ever -- the closest we can come to know her from afar. I really like her. She's a Ginette Neveu incarnate.

  • Ginette Neveu? Well, in my opinion no violonist compares to her.

  • No violinist compares to her? Are you a complete moron?

  • Listen to Kogan, Heifetz, Milstein, Szeryng and Oistrakh for awhile and then you will be revising your opinion. Neveu, for all of her talent (which was substantial) was not in the same league as the aforementioned giants. Not even close.

  • Neveu was the best. She bet Oistrakh at the end of a challenge.

  • @calloffthedogs

    My money's on Salvatore Accordo for Paganine, though I'll not gainsay Ms Hahn.

  • I was a little provocative of course, because Heifetz and Oistrakh, everybody listen to them, however, Ginette Neveu... I happen to listen to her recordings from time to time, kind of "souvenir" from France.

  • i know...this is stupid!!

  • How is this emo??

    It's just a video!

  • how is she an odd person?

  • come on people...this is "hilaryous"!! avant-garde...well to some people, but not if you watch this. she is an incredible violinist with an incredible sense of humour. if some of you think the video ruins the piece, then don't watch it. the one thing i can tell you is that if we try to sell this kind of music to the young americans in a way they might enjoy it, it just might get lost in the shuffle...

  • This is almost as exceptional as her Bach.  Beautiful.

  • OMG what stuff is it????

  • We listen because of the music... not because of the video. And by the way, I'm listening, because its great music.

  • The video is kind of stupid. But she plays very good.

  • what a stupid video, great interpretation of the concerto however

  • This is a bit weird, especially when she chops the violin up. I'm not sure I like it. The video almost ruins the piece.

  • Peter Miller directed. Love it! :)

    They were playing this on a loop at the concert Hilary performed in NY with Chris Thile at a bookstore in Soho, and the first thing that came to my mind when I saw it was the work of Maya Deren, one of the first female avant-garde filmmakers.

  • yes! i thought of maya deren right away!!

  • man......this mtv ruins her music and playing...wonder whoz the director... =_="

    She plays so great.

  • Wow! Very innovative, in the style of Paganini's approach to performances (with many surprises). Paganini used novelty and the fear of the unknown and the finiteness of Life to catch people's attention, start a little controversy. Ms. Hilary is young and playfull - and I think it's great to finally have a medium in which we can "connect" to the artist directly, rather than through a corporation.

  • strange

  • leuk dat de loodzware sfeer rondom klassieke muziek met wat relativerende zelfspot luchthartiger gemaakt wordt

    Ton Olsthoorn, meestervioolbouwer

  • this is funny because she admits to actually having choreographed the third mvt of this Paganini..

  • Comment removed

  • Is it possible Hilary was trying her hand at cinematography? I guess Hilary has a great sense of humor! This video is the "classical" version of a semi-Bjork video.

  • wanna see my collection ?: Shmuel Ashkenazi !!!![DGG] the best ever recorded version of this dull concerto.

  • she is the new Paganini¡¡¡¡

    if u want to understand this video first become into a violin player then, when u get that grade, when u can play beautifully and enjoy it at the same time you will understand hehe

    hilary please come to mexico we have some great theaters and a cool orchestra :)

  • this is just so weird !

  • 2 different chin rests (editing). Stunt violin.

  • I agree!

  • haha. that's not even her violin

  • i met her shes kinda shy but shes sweet

  • this is meant to be funny right?

    well, it damn sure is.

  • man..... no! why is she doing this to us? I mean... I'm not gonna watch the whole thing.. Me myself, I wouldn't even be bothered to play this concerto and she flimed a 'video clip!!' I wish I could give -5 stars to this shit..

  • This vid is one of the funniest things on you tube.. whew.. I hurt from laughing.

  • Gad... when she opened that upper barn door .. I was yelling "JUMP".. She either has a great sense of humor doing this video or she is one crazy puthy

  • All this video lacked is a suicide scene. Seriously, she might as well kill herself if she's willing to consent to doing shit like this.

  • Bee vehwee kwyett -  i'm hunting wabbitys.

  • I can't watch this video and listen to the music. It is rediculous! I start to crack up!

  • ooo shes making another one?!!!! ahhhh!! man!!! why is the adgio posted and not the allegro one? well the introduction to the piece :-) thats my favorite! hilary hahn is off the hook and has humor that only music people can understand! on her dvd, she mentions how she never met bach, but in the context, it was too funny!!ahhhh!!!!! she needs to make some bach videos! tht would be soooooooooooooooooooo wicked awesome!

  • HILARY is just so brilliant! This is a great video accompanied by HILARY'S superb and very fine violin play and tone in the background! It was so sad when it disappeared so suddenly from YouTube some months ago - now it's great to have it back available for everyone to see and hear! THANKS SO MUCH!!

    (Message by a HUGE FAN of HILARY'S, who thinks that this video should be released in better picture and sound quality on HILARY'S NEXT CD/DVD!)

  • where did u get this? it was on youtube but suddenly it wasnt there anymore! thanks, anyway!!!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more