I don't really know who is person that say " the piece is ugly " in fact it's amazing ... wowwwwwwwww ... ugly !!!!!!!!!!!!! very very very strange opinion though respected but strange.
pamiętam, grałem ten nokturn na egzaminie końcowym w szkole muzycznej (I st.), do tej pory to gram i wg mnie to jeden z najładniejszych utworów Chopina
I just posted my interpretation of Nocturne opus 9 ,No.2. I would appreciate your comments. Please click on my link 'alfonsopablo' next to this comment to listen.
@tsvetkovprelude Yes, I just double checked. I played it from Itunes against this one and they are in sync. exactly the same rubato, nails tapping the keys, same playing time etc etc
@brianbernsteintv Chopin's music often had some degree of liberty when it came to holding vs. restriking notes, as evidenced by variations in notation within or across different manuscripts. Arrau uses this to great effect in the Barcarolle.
I hear what you're saying, but he doesn't do it anywhere else in the piece... when you follow the score exactly and then do ONE thing different, it looks more like an error than a stylistic choice. Believe me, I know I'm nitpicking this waaay too much, it's an excellent performance, I just found it curious :)
I think this piece would be improved with a steadier tempo - the tempo swings are interesting, but no more. They give no intrigue or beauty to the piece.
This piece is played very well. I am actually using it for reference as I learn how to play it. The only problem with it is that between measures 26 and 27 that F is supposed to be tied. Maybe it was nerves. Other wise it was very beautiful.
Ok, my previous link doesn't seem to work! :( If you go to the websites home page and then type in the search bar 'Chopin Nocturne No. 21 in C', which will take you to a list - click on the first one by the user 'Piupianissimo'. It's well worth looking at 'Piupianissmo's' profile as they've so many pieces from the major classical composers! I hope that this has been helpful! :)
@MissEwilan theres a web sight called freescores where you can dl alot of public domain music like this. there are many other web sights that are free as well if you just google free piano sheet music you can usually find the piece youre looking for at no or little cost and print it out on your pc
@newFranzFerencLiszt This piece does possess a lot of nocturne elements... I don't like this performance though. Bad dynamics, tone abd interpertation, and too much rubato IMO.
it reminds me of a cold winter in europe, watching out the car door as millions of snow flakes fall upon my car window and upon the village in which I'm traveling in.
No, you're thinking of C flat, thats the same as B. C minor has 3 flats, it is the same as E flat Major, but the root note in C minor is the 6th scale degree(C) of E flat Major.
I agree, the nocturnes are beautiful, I wish I could play them all on piano>.< I like just about anything that is Chopin or Scriabin:) E flat minor is also one of my favorite keys.
Acabo de escuchar la versión de Claudio Arrau y es idéntica a ésta. Ok, la interpreta Claudio Arrau entonces. Uno de los mejores intérpretes junto con Arthur Rubinstein.
No entiendo por qué este nocturno, siendo tan bello, no está entre los más conocidos de Chopin. El más conocido suele ser el Nº2 op. 9 Nº 2 o tal vez el Nº 8 op. 27 Nº 2. Este nocturno es otra cosa, transmite una melancolía y una calma exquisitas. Claro que eso es también mérito del intérprete. ¿Arthur Rubinstein, tal vez? Gracias por difundirlo.
I wonder what Chopin didn't like about this piece to prevent its publication. I think it is perfectly gorgeous. I can't listen too it enough. Yundi Li has recorded it and does a wonderful job with it.
@PSaunMusic Lets find him and burn him and then spread his ashes on a piano made from the bones of his children and play this song on the keys made from their teeth
Thankyou for posting the sheet music - I really appreciate it as my Urtext copy of this composition has virtually no dynamics, your posted copy has plenty of detail -a great help in my studies - thanks again. Who is the pianist?
You know, you see the notes on the page, and you think, yeah this is easy to play. WRONG. Its not. Because there's so little complexity there, its got to be spot on. Its not easy
"I must tell you I take terrible risks. Because my playing is very clear, when I make a mistake you hear it. If you want me to play only the notes without any specific dynamics, I will never make one mistake. Never be afraid to dare." - Vladimir Horowitz
The more I try to compose, the more I appreciate the simple beauty of the nocturnes. My melodies are usually twice as complex but not even half as musical and heart breaking. They say he usually conceived an entire piece in one flash of inspiration during, say, a walk.
@dasklavierleben I suffer the same problem, however on top of that I also lack the ability to harmonize my best melodies. Sometimes I even manage to get a harmony going but suddenly no melody to go over it. It's not fair how some people can easily write down what they hear in their heads but some, like me, cannot. Thus while I love Chopin for his works I also hate him for doing it all so effortlessly.
@Zodiarkz In regards to writing down what you hear in your head: I know someone who has perfect pitch and he can write down whatever he hears in his head but he has no soul so his pieces are emotionless. The best thing I can do (as well as you) is to endlessly drill interval ear training and the related training for harmonies. I've been practicing for weeks and it's still a slippery language for me to speak haha
@blondebearsipl no, he's a narcissist who was born privileged and lords it over everyone else. As close to 'no soul' as people get in the modern world.
This lovely piece was posthumously published and the exact date of its composition is still unknown. Although it is 'simpler' than most of his other Nocturnes, it is still a small masterpiece that can convey an almost uncanny sense of reposeful melancholy, for want of a better expression. All the same, only this music can transmit its message... and no one else but Chopin could have written a music of such a tender and delicate intimacy.
The melancholy was there because Chopin had come to terms with the fact that he was dying. THink about it, it was the last Nocturne he wrote; it was a farewell message of sorts. I can hear a great air of weary satisfaction in this piece; the music is saying "I have nothing left to do" and. The crescendos are the occasional notes of protest to the inevitability of death. They are overpowered in a way by the smooth, relaxed, almost content character of the majority of this piece.
While everybody has a right of expresing his or her opinion, it must be said that Chopin was one of the greatest musicians of all time and he was able to express, in his music, an enormous range of human emotions, including , happiness, anger, an enormous amount of passion and yes, sometimes a certain sadness and desolation. Other great composers did also, in their own way, express these emotions in their creations.
i didnt happen yet. its on the 29th. the 6th was a rehershal. i didnt go cause i had a debtist appointment! i was glad! :) still working on it! almost perfect!:)
You know what...I've never thought of Chopin this way but it's so true. Obviously this is a nocturne and there are happier pieces he wrote but I don't associate him with anything but minor key...
I do think though, it is a great mistake to regard Chopin's music as being sad or the man as a depressed fellow. His music can be very brilliant and even demand a great deal of athletic vigor from the pianist. His Polonaises, Sonatas, Scherzos, Ballades, F minor Fantasy, Etudes, among many others are an exemple of pianistic virtuosity at its highest level.
Yes, as an Italian word, scherzi would be the correct plural for this term, but either scherzos or scherzi are used regarding this form of composition. We can see the spelling Scherzos on most LP and CD covers and liner notes. Anyway, thanks for noting this.
at 00:42 perhaps a pianissimo would fit better... but hey whatever makes you happy man! most of us don't play to pass exams or prepare for concerts... so whatever makes you happy :D
I'm not sure if you noticed, but Arrau kind of did prepare for concerts. This interpretation is indeed a serious undertaking, and is of professional quality. I really love the ethereal effect of the interpretation, with its colours, loose phrasing, and subtle changes in dynamics.
i washed my mouth with soap
Mettwurst1stGott 1 day ago
Who plays?
Hrechkoskiy 5 days ago
This is very wonderful.
Kibadda123 1 week ago
Ther's no words to describe this music... it's just incredible! <3
valeferreira23 3 weeks ago
Baraza Israel accurate tuning pianos Comments
ApiosApps 3 weeks ago
I don't really know who is person that say " the piece is ugly " in fact it's amazing ... wowwwwwwwww ... ugly !!!!!!!!!!!!! very very very strange opinion though respected but strange.
seartcher 4 weeks ago
ohh my God it reminds me of precious days they may never come back again.
seartcher 4 weeks ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This piece is so ugly that I wonder if Chopin really wrote it.
TempodiPiano 1 month ago
musical instruments chopin nocturne in c sharp minor
ApiosApps 1 month ago
musical instruments baraza israel chopin nocturne in c sharp minor
ApiosApps 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Baraza Israel videos musical instruments web anywhere in the world for Free
ApiosApps 1 month ago
Baraza Israel videos musical instruments web anywhere in the world for Free
ApiosApps 1 month ago
Comments Baraza Israel Expert tuning pianos
ApiosApps 1 month ago
pamiętam, grałem ten nokturn na egzaminie końcowym w szkole muzycznej (I st.), do tej pory to gram i wg mnie to jeden z najładniejszych utworów Chopina
Zacharrr 1 month ago
You think you know al of chopin´s nocturnes.. and then you stumble at this.. wow
SoMaRiOn7 1 month ago
google Baraza Israel tuning pianos books
ApiosApps 1 month ago
pianos Baraza Israel 88 Chopin - Nocturne No.21 in C-Minor
ApiosApps 1 month ago
youtube Baraza Israel in C Major 7
ApiosApps 1 month ago
Hebrew Baraza Israel videos
ApiosApps 1 month ago
musical instruments Baraza Israel Nocturne in C-sharp Minor (Piano) Chopin
ApiosApps 1 month ago
Chopin's Nocturnes video pianos baraza israel
ApiosApps 1 month ago
musical instruments Baraza Israel Hebrew
ApiosApps 1 month ago
Your video went viral on Haiti
franciscomrls0 1 month ago
Your video went viral on Tallinn
gusmcleod922 1 month ago
well played
pacostarr11 2 months ago
nice
pacostarr11 2 months ago
Shivers all over my body...
Serachfan 2 months ago
Great song.
connorg2121 2 months ago
Kocham Chopina całą duszą.
MsKrowaKolorowa 3 months ago 4
i love this song, ive got a book full of great chopin sheets but this song in c-minor is by far the best
apetek12 3 months ago
@apetek12 true story
ya0urt 2 months ago
2:16
Lindatong2 3 months ago
i am playing this song right now
Lindatong2 3 months ago
@Lindatong2 really? i never knew you could PLAY a SONG
audreyhsux5727 1 month ago
i played this for my final ;3
subculturalgirl89 3 months ago
@abidoful Sad story... He was truly in love with her...
cvonhessen 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬ஜ۩۞۩ஜ▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
I just posted my interpretation of Nocturne opus 9 ,No.2. I would appreciate your comments. Please click on my link 'alfonsopablo' next to this comment to listen.
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬ஜ۩۞۩ஜ▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
alfonsopablo 4 months ago
μόλις πέθανα.
fwtios 4 months ago 18
Comment removed
jen1989z 1 month ago
@fwtios στην κηδεία μου αυτό θα παίζει κι εμένα!
B337h0v3n 2 weeks ago
For anyone interested, the pianist playing this one is Claudio Arrau :)
ReubenD99 4 months ago
@ReubenD99 Is it really Arrau?
tsvetkovprelude 4 months ago
@tsvetkovprelude Yes, I just double checked. I played it from Itunes against this one and they are in sync. exactly the same rubato, nails tapping the keys, same playing time etc etc
ReubenD99 4 months ago
@ReubenD99 Grande Arrau.
tsvetkovprelude 4 months ago
why the hell does high F get played twice at 1:42? its tied...
brianbernsteintv 4 months ago
@brianbernsteintv cant you say that nicely?
mwartdt 4 months ago
@mwartdt
sorry about that
brianbernsteintv 4 months ago
@brianbernsteintv yes you're right.... hm maybe its his own interpretation?! strange
doriii8hungaria 4 months ago
@brianbernsteintv Chopin's music often had some degree of liberty when it came to holding vs. restriking notes, as evidenced by variations in notation within or across different manuscripts. Arrau uses this to great effect in the Barcarolle.
JoEbYX 1 month ago
@JoEbYX
I hear what you're saying, but he doesn't do it anywhere else in the piece... when you follow the score exactly and then do ONE thing different, it looks more like an error than a stylistic choice. Believe me, I know I'm nitpicking this waaay too much, it's an excellent performance, I just found it curious :)
brianbernsteintv 1 month ago
@brianbernsteintv the great Arrau does not make an error like that in a piece such as this.. in my opinion it must be a stylistic choice :)
UnitedMilan07 1 month ago
this piece gives me chills...in a very good way. happy halloween everyone!!!!
cymagen 4 months ago
I think this piece would be improved with a steadier tempo - the tempo swings are interesting, but no more. They give no intrigue or beauty to the piece.
phantasm232 4 months ago
This piece is played very well. I am actually using it for reference as I learn how to play it. The only problem with it is that between measures 26 and 27 that F is supposed to be tied. Maybe it was nerves. Other wise it was very beautiful.
8557882 6 months ago
Comment removed
Nicksvoiceinthewild 6 months ago
ifany of you want the musicsheet for this song please send me a mesage and ill send u the link for it for free cheers!!
123papafrita 6 months ago
@123papafrita
hello, if you could send me the link , it would be very nice, because i can't find the music sheet anywhere.
Thanks
MAYEULPUJEBET 4 months ago
@123papafrita
hello, can you give me the link, because i can't find it anywhere and i really like this song
thanks
MAYEULPUJEBET 4 months ago
The run at 1:56 is beautiful , great piece.
HermanBerntzen 6 months ago
Ok, my previous link doesn't seem to work! :( If you go to the websites home page and then type in the search bar 'Chopin Nocturne No. 21 in C', which will take you to a list - click on the first one by the user 'Piupianissimo'. It's well worth looking at 'Piupianissmo's' profile as they've so many pieces from the major classical composers! I hope that this has been helpful! :)
bentley1938 6 months ago
Here's the link for the sheet music if anyone's interested! :)
imslp.org/wiki/Nocturne_in_C_minor,_B.108__Chopin,_Frederic)
bentley1938 6 months ago
This was the first Chopin nocturne I learned, and one of my favorites. It's just a gorgeous piece. Then again, what Chopin piece isn't? Lol
EmilyAE19 6 months ago
Somebody knows whose interpretation is this? I'd really like to know.
Jumpmanmauro 7 months ago
@Jumpmanmauro obviously Claudio Arrau, search "Chopin - Nocturno en do menor Op Postumo" or with "Arrau" included.
honron21 7 months ago
大家好 good 好聽 很好的曲子 謝解
twgirl1 7 months ago
How could this be one of the least known?
tonymusicrocks 7 months ago
@tonymusicrocks because this is one of the best ones chopin has.. but that also includes all his work.. that is the best ;)
panchitoborja 6 months ago
one of my favourite nocturnes
kasonleung 8 months ago
who played?
harriethtw 8 months ago
@harriethtw obviously Claudio Arrau, search "Chopin - Nocturno en do menor Op Postumo" or with "Arrau" included.
honron21 7 months ago
Does somebody know where I can find the sheet music...?
MissEwilan 8 months ago
@MissEwilan theres a web sight called freescores where you can dl alot of public domain music like this. there are many other web sights that are free as well if you just google free piano sheet music you can usually find the piece youre looking for at no or little cost and print it out on your pc
dragontooth81 8 months ago
@dragontooth81 Thank you, I searched everywhere, I didn't find... I found other pieces to play ^^
MissEwilan 8 months ago
@dragontooth81 google IMSLP and you shall be amazed :)
amxmachine 7 months ago
OMG I didn't knew this one. I thought there were only 20 nocturnes. Who is the pianist ? It makes me cry ! It's amazing. I want to play it ^_^
MissEwilan 8 months ago
cuts off about a 3 seconds too early; let that last note ring next time!
huzzzzzzahh 9 months ago
thanks this one is very helpful, Sir !! Great warm in music.
tanadihensen73 9 months ago
Chopin never called this "nocturne"
newFranzFerencLiszt 9 months ago
@newFranzFerencLiszt This piece does possess a lot of nocturne elements... I don't like this performance though. Bad dynamics, tone abd interpertation, and too much rubato IMO.
FrameSticker 9 months ago
a fly stepped on the dislike button
Saintbalor 10 months ago
@Saintbalor nobody gives a shit about your dislike button comments dipshit
insertbadname 9 months ago
@insertbadname aww, and you cared enough to reply ;D
Saintbalor 9 months ago
beautiful..
Mtdeadhead312 10 months ago
Does anyone know where I can find the sheet music
vindicadre 10 months ago
It's wonderful to feel the night through Chopin's music.
bontzel 10 months ago
Real music.
annefrankisaho 10 months ago
yay thanks :P i have to play this piece in i have troble doing the harder parts :P
Kyote724 10 months ago
dis is sik bringz back mmrz
5amhassangeeman 10 months ago
it reminds me of a cold winter in europe, watching out the car door as millions of snow flakes fall upon my car window and upon the village in which I'm traveling in.
TheProudAmerican777 11 months ago 8
i LOVE PLAYING THIS NOCTURNE!!!!!!!!!!
92024able 11 months ago
Chopin just hits all the right notes! So lovely with dark tones...
DarkIsis80 1 year ago 2
almost done learning this piece :)
92024able 1 year ago
C minor is one of my favorite keys, great song.
snakeblob 1 year ago 52
@snakeblob isn't a c minor just a b?
Toiletclottingpoop 9 months ago
@Toiletclottingpoop
No, you're thinking of C flat, thats the same as B. C minor has 3 flats, it is the same as E flat Major, but the root note in C minor is the 6th scale degree(C) of E flat Major.
snakeblob 9 months ago
@snakeblob me too, check the name ;) so many pieces i love are in c minor. there's something special about it :)
and love this nocturne. as a group they're probably my favourite pieces for piano
xx
keyofcminor69 6 months ago
@keyofcminor69
I agree, the nocturnes are beautiful, I wish I could play them all on piano>.< I like just about anything that is Chopin or Scriabin:) E flat minor is also one of my favorite keys.
snakeblob 6 months ago
@snakeblob i like too
:)
thescience100 6 months ago
Acabo de escuchar la versión de Claudio Arrau y es idéntica a ésta. Ok, la interpreta Claudio Arrau entonces. Uno de los mejores intérpretes junto con Arthur Rubinstein.
danielbriamonte 1 year ago
No entiendo por qué este nocturno, siendo tan bello, no está entre los más conocidos de Chopin. El más conocido suele ser el Nº2 op. 9 Nº 2 o tal vez el Nº 8 op. 27 Nº 2. Este nocturno es otra cosa, transmite una melancolía y una calma exquisitas. Claro que eso es también mérito del intérprete. ¿Arthur Rubinstein, tal vez? Gracias por difundirlo.
danielbriamonte 1 year ago
I wonder what Chopin didn't like about this piece to prevent its publication. I think it is perfectly gorgeous. I can't listen too it enough. Yundi Li has recorded it and does a wonderful job with it.
TJFNYC212 1 year ago
hello, does anyone know who plays this rendition in this particular video? Thanks! :)
lovemariaaa 1 year ago
Imagine Chopin apparently found these works not worth publishing, I understand he explicitly forbid it. Sometimes disobedience is a good thing.
smitschagen 1 year ago
Isn't this song from slayer...
ThaKillaToAll 1 year ago
@ThaKillaToAll Reminds me of Slayer too...
iamstoned4life 1 year ago
WHO THE #@$% DISLIKED THIS???
Shameful...
PSaunMusic 1 year ago 9
@PSaunMusic Lets find him and burn him and then spread his ashes on a piano made from the bones of his children and play this song on the keys made from their teeth
PoirePerry 1 year ago
@PoirePerry
Sounds like a good idea to me! Haha.
PSaunMusic 1 year ago
@PSaunMusic :O......I'll get started with Google :P
PoirePerry 1 year ago
I can´t download this video =(
miriettee 1 year ago
Thanks for the sheet music *-*
Did you buy the songbook?
miriettee 1 year ago
this is the last piece I played in Music school... hundreds years ago :))))
Anyway, I can still play it... and I do, sometimes... I love it deeply...
Thanks for uploading...
jesienna83 1 year ago
This is brilliant!!! Why have I not heard this sooner?? It's just another testament to Chopin's genius. This man was truly a great composer.
mangaka08 1 year ago
modulation at 1:06 oooooooooooooooo kills me every time...
SingHouse 1 year ago
Thankyou for posting the sheet music - I really appreciate it as my Urtext copy of this composition has virtually no dynamics, your posted copy has plenty of detail -a great help in my studies - thanks again. Who is the pianist?
oorakoora 1 year ago
You know, you see the notes on the page, and you think, yeah this is easy to play. WRONG. Its not. Because there's so little complexity there, its got to be spot on. Its not easy
Eztoez 1 year ago
Is this an early piece of his? Compared to his other stuff this is extremely simple harmonically
Pianoplayer002 1 year ago
"I must tell you I take terrible risks. Because my playing is very clear, when I make a mistake you hear it. If you want me to play only the notes without any specific dynamics, I will never make one mistake. Never be afraid to dare." - Vladimir Horowitz
unyxit 1 year ago 2
at god’s biding wrote he this nocturne
mivalguriashi 1 year ago
i love this peice, pretty much all of the polock's work is amazing. RIP
kiriakdj 1 year ago
chopin <3
creidefy 1 year ago
The ending is cut off too quickly, in my opinion.
Minipawn59 1 year ago
This is my favorite nocturne...played it once, was my best piece ever.
Minipawn59 1 year ago
I love this rendition best! :)
Polydactyl13 1 year ago
Anybody have the sheet of this nocturne? Thank you so much
siguenzatcp 1 year ago
Just lovely.
and yes, at 1:41 the not tied. I looked in different books, they all shown tied.
However, it doesn't matter how he/she played it here; just lovely in my book.
Polydactyl13 1 year ago
fanastyczny numer
fxv26 1 year ago
Beautiful music, beautiful interpretation. Who's the pianist?
irmina1 1 year ago
Could anyone please send me this piano sheet?
Thanks
milol33(arobas)yahoo(point)fr
milol33 1 year ago
The more I try to compose, the more I appreciate the simple beauty of the nocturnes. My melodies are usually twice as complex but not even half as musical and heart breaking. They say he usually conceived an entire piece in one flash of inspiration during, say, a walk.
ridiculous.
marvelous.
dasklavierleben 1 year ago 3
@dasklavierleben I suffer the same problem, however on top of that I also lack the ability to harmonize my best melodies. Sometimes I even manage to get a harmony going but suddenly no melody to go over it. It's not fair how some people can easily write down what they hear in their heads but some, like me, cannot. Thus while I love Chopin for his works I also hate him for doing it all so effortlessly.
Zodiarkz 1 year ago
@Zodiarkz In regards to writing down what you hear in your head: I know someone who has perfect pitch and he can write down whatever he hears in his head but he has no soul so his pieces are emotionless. The best thing I can do (as well as you) is to endlessly drill interval ear training and the related training for harmonies. I've been practicing for weeks and it's still a slippery language for me to speak haha
dasklavierleben 1 year ago
@dasklavierleben so he's a vampire or demon?
blondebearsipl 1 year ago
@blondebearsipl no, he's a narcissist who was born privileged and lords it over everyone else. As close to 'no soul' as people get in the modern world.
dasklavierleben 1 year ago
@dasklavierleben Yeah, nocturnes are really hard just to play, let alone write. I think the simpler, the better, though.
Minipawn59 1 year ago
there is some kind of undescribable touch of sadness to this tune everytime i hear this
sxdutt 2 years ago
the melody just dances throughout the entire tune...gorgeous!!!!
sxdutt 2 years ago 2
Who performes? Wery good
bobon47 2 years ago
@bobon47 YEAH-- who DOES perform this piece? please tell.
SergeiItzamCoiot 1 year ago
@SergeiItzamCoiot
Arthur rubenstein
nleguellec 1 year ago
Wow! That piece is AMAZING with a capital A!
jingchen99 2 years ago
The Part 0:00 - 0:05 sounds like the begin melody of another classic. I think Beethoven. Anybody knows what I mean?
BrainDDR 2 years ago
amazing
moukielatina09 2 years ago
CHOPIN THE POET such mastery and form its all logical, its like science with emotions
StoptheIgnorants22 2 years ago
1:41 - isn't that note tied? a very languid but excellent piece .
AvidHobbyist 2 years ago 38
@AvidHobbyist Yes it should be tied.
nickovarlamos91 1 year ago
@AvidHobbyist i was wondering the same thing -- though i'm no expert
markmeson 10 months ago
@AvidHobbyist Around 3:04 the same pattern comes up but is played as written. Chalk it up to creative liberty.
facemash 9 months ago
Absolutely gorgeous. Chopin was master of the piano like no other. I love his Nocturnes, who else could put so much feeling and mood into music?
musicallyspeakings88 2 years ago 5
This lovely piece was posthumously published and the exact date of its composition is still unknown. Although it is 'simpler' than most of his other Nocturnes, it is still a small masterpiece that can convey an almost uncanny sense of reposeful melancholy, for want of a better expression. All the same, only this music can transmit its message... and no one else but Chopin could have written a music of such a tender and delicate intimacy.
audiomagman 2 years ago 4
The melancholy was there because Chopin had come to terms with the fact that he was dying. THink about it, it was the last Nocturne he wrote; it was a farewell message of sorts. I can hear a great air of weary satisfaction in this piece; the music is saying "I have nothing left to do" and. The crescendos are the occasional notes of protest to the inevitability of death. They are overpowered in a way by the smooth, relaxed, almost content character of the majority of this piece.
simonf42 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
audiomagman 2 years ago
While everybody has a right of expresing his or her opinion, it must be said that Chopin was one of the greatest musicians of all time and he was able to express, in his music, an enormous range of human emotions, including , happiness, anger, an enormous amount of passion and yes, sometimes a certain sadness and desolation. Other great composers did also, in their own way, express these emotions in their creations.
audiomagman 2 years ago 4
Couldnt explain better myself. Chopins pieces are so amazing...I think that many people dont understand the power in his pieces..
D33JNES 2 years ago 6
i did this song for my summer recital. now i have to do it for a school talent show.... i cant remeber it!!! i got 1 day to memorize it! ugh.
penguinluvgirl 2 years ago
How did the talent show go?
TreeHooker11 2 years ago
i didnt happen yet. its on the 29th. the 6th was a rehershal. i didnt go cause i had a debtist appointment! i was glad! :) still working on it! almost perfect!:)
penguinluvgirl 2 years ago
not everything sad
he was the king of the good sense of humour
Sashomei 2 years ago
This guy must've been so depressed. Everything he wrote sounds sad
SevenfoldFan92 2 years ago
have you heard his waltzes? like minute waltz? beautiful but not sad... or his mazurkas..
0blacone 2 years ago 3
Not everything...
Have you ever heard his poloneses?
And we mustn't judge his musics as sad, they're subjective and can express different sensations.
jlfnetto 2 years ago 3
You know what...I've never thought of Chopin this way but it's so true. Obviously this is a nocturne and there are happier pieces he wrote but I don't associate him with anything but minor key...
aaa1232123 2 years ago
I do think though, it is a great mistake to regard Chopin's music as being sad or the man as a depressed fellow. His music can be very brilliant and even demand a great deal of athletic vigor from the pianist. His Polonaises, Sonatas, Scherzos, Ballades, F minor Fantasy, Etudes, among many others are an exemple of pianistic virtuosity at its highest level.
audiomagman 2 years ago 6
@audiomagman Scherzi, not "scherzos" (Sorry I had to write it ^^)
MissEwilan 8 months ago
@MissEwilan
Yes, as an Italian word, scherzi would be the correct plural for this term, but either scherzos or scherzi are used regarding this form of composition. We can see the spelling Scherzos on most LP and CD covers and liner notes. Anyway, thanks for noting this.
audiomagman 8 months ago
@audiomagman Ok, I didn't know... Thanks for noting this ;)
MissEwilan 8 months ago
This is so beautiful.
Eztoez 2 years ago
Comment removed
sallystjohnuvi 2 years ago
This is Claudio Arrau for sure, I have the Arrau's recording of all Chopin nocturnes, this is him for sure.
raulsaavedra 2 years ago
umm, i think you shouldnt always pause in between measures, and after 1:05 , the timing is uneven. i've heard better D: ,sorry
RosalynTehMuffin 2 years ago
at 00:42 perhaps a pianissimo would fit better... but hey whatever makes you happy man! most of us don't play to pass exams or prepare for concerts... so whatever makes you happy :D
mullahsoutnow 2 years ago
I'm not sure if you noticed, but Arrau kind of did prepare for concerts. This interpretation is indeed a serious undertaking, and is of professional quality. I really love the ethereal effect of the interpretation, with its colours, loose phrasing, and subtle changes in dynamics.
Lukecash12 2 years ago
Indeed, this is one of my most favorite nocturnes by him...
Can you tell me who played this? Or if a recording is available somewhere >.>
Synniyoung 2 years ago