yo como practicante de este arte marcial quiero felicitar a los participantes en corte de bambu y sigo practicando para tener la misma velocidad los felicito y estoy muy impresionado con la velocidad que tienen felicidades de parte de HDGD MEXICO
Momentum, yes. Sharpness, yes. Accuracy, yes, if you take that to mean that not only do you strike where you aim, but also that the plane of your blade is aligned with the plane of the cut. If it's not, you will not make it through the bamboo. It's not as easy as it looks.
I agree with Sembai. Keep in mind this is a demonstration intended to show rapid cutting techniques against inanimate targets. I would suspect very different tactics would be used against a live opponent.
As for east vs west, techniques and sword styles are so different that we could argue the subject 'till we're blue in the face. Ultimately it would come down to the combat situation and skill of the individual swordsmen.
Very much true, agreed, and in sword cutting, it seems as if the European broadsword, and the Japanese Katana, both do quite (about equally) well, sharp metal cuts through stuff, basic law(s) of physics, speed plus mass equals power.
Just to be nitpicky, power is actually measured in Watts and is usually in the domain of electricity. What you're looking for is momentum= mass*velocity, force = mass*accel., or energy=.5*mass*velocity^2. You also need to take into account centripetal force generated from an arcing cut, point of contact and materials.
Actually I find comparisons between JSA and WSA very similar. The various postures and techniques are similar. Even the method of training is the same. I think its because years of war from either country have filtered out the arts to the best possible techniques.
As for this video... "Tameshigiri mats don't cut back" [/brucelee]
yes, similar need, produces similar stuff, just like reed boats in South America (and pyramids) are like the middle east (I don't believe they floated over or UFOs), and your comment: ROFLMAO!
And you're entitled to that opinion. I only hope you've watched more than just one 2 minute clip before making your summary decision. Check out the other gumdo clips on YouTube, aswell as Google and Yahoo. Haidong Gumdo has a lot to offer, but it's not for everyone.
el kumdo es coreano pero el origen es japones y penetra en corea durante la ocupacion japonesa en aquel pais, Kendo (japon) = Kumdo (Korea) es la pronunciacion coreana, igual q aikido, en korea hapkido y etc...
el aikido y el hapkido son artes diferentes, se desarrollaron independientemente, el hapkido NO viene del aikido, viene del daito ryu aikijujutsu, al igual que el aikido.
hindu viene de hinduista indio significa de la india pero asi como jesus era judio buda por venir de un lugar donde se practicaba el hinduismo tambien era hindu
朝鮮王朝實録：The Annals of the choson Dynasty (The True Record of the Korean Dynasty)…
【June 11, 1480】矧惟國人, 不慣槍劍, 專業弓矢, 爲禦敵之備
The people were not accustomed to use of sword or spear, defended from enemies only by archery...
【October 13, 1592】上敎政院曰“我國絶無劒手”
The king said “There was no swordman in our country at all”...
【July 11, 1594】我國自古劍術不傳
There has not been descendent any swordplay from ancient time in our country...
enushisama 6 months ago
武藝圖譜通志Muye Dobo Tongji (1790) : Comprehensive Illustrated Manual of Martial Arts in Korea .
[It is an official document at a Korean Dynasty, written by The Korean King order in the 18th century]
國練兵之制三軍練于郊，衛士練于禁苑，其禁苑練兵盛自 光廟朝，然止弓矢一技而已如槍劍法技，既未之聞焉，
Archery was the only martial art that had been practiced by Korean soldiers. They have no skills of sword or spear fighting (in the 17th century ! ).
購得戚繼光紀效新書遣訓局郎韓嶠遍質東來將士
Therefore, Koreans began learning sword skills and others from Chinese .
enushisama 6 months ago
Please watch those videos.
watch?v=hG6tqGGZW8Y
watch?v=iFBo-Zs_Dp8
enushisama 8 months ago
yo como practicante de este arte marcial quiero felicitar a los participantes en corte de bambu y sigo practicando para tener la misma velocidad los felicito y estoy muy impresionado con la velocidad que tienen felicidades de parte de HDGD MEXICO
paquicefalosaurio 1 year ago
It is far apart from martial arts.
kamikaze0201 2 years ago
Momentum, yes. Sharpness, yes. Accuracy, yes, if you take that to mean that not only do you strike where you aim, but also that the plane of your blade is aligned with the plane of the cut. If it's not, you will not make it through the bamboo. It's not as easy as it looks.
laxman03699 3 years ago
With enough practice I could do this with my Zweihandler. It's all about momentum, sharpness, and accuracy.
SpecOpCellBorn 4 years ago
so, practice, film it, post it.
not saying you couldn't do it with a european sword, i just think it would be a real cool video :)
guiltybystander77 3 years ago
korean style...lol...not pure
kiko1314 4 years ago
You, arrogant, can, you, do, any, better? LOL!
blugularis 4 years ago
He probably could...
walesdragon 4 years ago
because?
Oyama was (also) Korean, but he developed the strongest Japanese karate!
blugularis 4 years ago
I agree with Sembai. Keep in mind this is a demonstration intended to show rapid cutting techniques against inanimate targets. I would suspect very different tactics would be used against a live opponent.
As for east vs west, techniques and sword styles are so different that we could argue the subject 'till we're blue in the face. Ultimately it would come down to the combat situation and skill of the individual swordsmen.
bonnymab 5 years ago
Very much true, agreed, and in sword cutting, it seems as if the European broadsword, and the Japanese Katana, both do quite (about equally) well, sharp metal cuts through stuff, basic law(s) of physics, speed plus mass equals power.
blugularis 4 years ago
Just to be nitpicky, power is actually measured in Watts and is usually in the domain of electricity. What you're looking for is momentum= mass*velocity, force = mass*accel., or energy=.5*mass*velocity^2. You also need to take into account centripetal force generated from an arcing cut, point of contact and materials.
nii87 4 years ago
Actually I find comparisons between JSA and WSA very similar. The various postures and techniques are similar. Even the method of training is the same. I think its because years of war from either country have filtered out the arts to the best possible techniques.
As for this video... "Tameshigiri mats don't cut back" [/brucelee]
nii87 4 years ago
yes, similar need, produces similar stuff, just like reed boats in South America (and pyramids) are like the middle east (I don't believe they floated over or UFOs), and your comment: ROFLMAO!
blugularis 4 years ago
Cliburnis: You think that he would act like that in a fight? Think before posting please.
Sembai 5 years ago
Eeehh, I don't like a lot of wild spinning, a Western swordfighter would stick them in the liver while their back is exposed and laugh.
Caliburnis 5 years ago
its funny coz its true
yabasha 5 years ago
"wildly swing a sword around", you've never cut any bambu it seems
Benisakura 5 years ago
And you're entitled to that opinion. I only hope you've watched more than just one 2 minute clip before making your summary decision. Check out the other gumdo clips on YouTube, aswell as Google and Yahoo. Haidong Gumdo has a lot to offer, but it's not for everyone.
bonnymab 5 years ago
I must say I don't have much appreciation for Haidong Gumdo. I guess it's good if want to learn how to wildly swing a sword around.
HaMoOhAhA 5 years ago
eso. explicame la historia de esta cosa.
kuiksilver 5 years ago
Para que? eres el clasico que no sabe de algo y lo descalifica.
toro1 5 years ago
it's for you to explain to me smartass. This is a forgery you see? If you really wanna do some sword martial arts, do some iaido, or kenjutsu.
kuiksilver 5 years ago
no es una falsificacion? eso es lo unico que voy a decir, como puedes decir que es falso si no lo conoces
toro1 5 years ago
muchos de ustedes que practican lo japo se creen japos,es como decir que el zen es una falsificacion del buda indu,
toro1 5 years ago
tarado, esto no es "japo" es koreano
leogan 5 years ago
el kumdo es coreano pero el origen es japones y penetra en corea durante la ocupacion japonesa en aquel pais, Kendo (japon) = Kumdo (Korea) es la pronunciacion coreana, igual q aikido, en korea hapkido y etc...
chongkwon 5 years ago
el aikido y el hapkido son artes diferentes, se desarrollaron independientemente, el hapkido NO viene del aikido, viene del daito ryu aikijujutsu, al igual que el aikido.
leogan 5 years ago
esto no es kumdo, es haidong gumdo, no es lo mismo
leogan 5 years ago
a si sabias que buda es indu? p que, es chino, de tailandia,
toro1 5 years ago
buda no es indu, indu es el que practica el induismo, induismo no es lo mismo que el budismo.
leogan 5 years ago
hindu viene de hinduista indio significa de la india pero asi como jesus era judio buda por venir de un lugar donde se practicaba el hinduismo tambien era hindu
tkdhdgd 4 years ago
what the fuck is the fucked up shit?!
Morons
kuiksilver 5 years ago
pues si no sabes que es? mejor no pongas nada es decir tu eres un perfecto PENDEJO
toro1 5 years ago
responde en Ingles Maricon ! Jajaja !
This just sucks
kuiksilver 5 years ago
bien que entendiste! para que en ingles!
toro1 5 years ago