@raymondcrooke very nice......my father in law is in his final hours, though neither he nor i are cowboys (far from it) ive been thinking of this song these past few days........i humbly thank you
I'm learning harmonica and it's one of the songs in the book....I wanted to refresh my memory..your youtube version popped up... so i took a listen... nicely done! Peace, ~Sharon.
John and Alan Lomax should have taken large credit for this song for it is just one of the many hundreds of descendants of an 18th century English broadside,"The Unfortunate Rake". Alan combed the whole U.S. for the best songs he could find. If need be,he'd combine half good songs to make one very good song.
Here,your showcase brilliantly demostrates your utmost respect for the folk song process and I thank you very much for this fine example,kind sir.
The melody is irish allright
Gamberist 3 months ago
@Gamberist Most good songs start as Irish tunes.
raymondcrooke 3 months ago
@raymondcrooke Of course
Gamberist 3 months ago
I love this song. I see with my heart the young and handsome cowboy who dies and regrets his faults.
bonniewayfarer 1 year ago
@bonniewayfarer One of the best cowboy songs I think.
raymondcrooke 1 year ago
very well done. I love this song it always makes me cry
natureboy99 1 year ago
@natureboy99 Glad you enjoyed it.
raymondcrooke 1 year ago
An old friend of mine passed away a couple of weeks ago. He and I
used to play this song 50 years ago. Sad to think that now he's sleeping "in that green valley".
dhgate2 1 year ago
...and don't forget that the great John Cale also performed it in the 80's. that's my favourite. But I like your version too, Mr. Crooke. Thank you.
MrMsBaart 2 years ago
Thanks for watching.
raymondcrooke 2 years ago
best version i have heard!!
romipony 2 years ago
Thanks for subscribing.
raymondcrooke 2 years ago
@raymondcrooke very nice......my father in law is in his final hours, though neither he nor i are cowboys (far from it) ive been thinking of this song these past few days........i humbly thank you
cgambler864 1 year ago
@cgambler864 You're welcome. Sorry to hear about your father-in-law.
raymondcrooke 1 year ago
they're not the real chords
borntokill30 2 years ago
No, they're the unreal ones.
raymondcrooke 2 years ago
Thanks for singing to us, Mr. Crooke. It's such a lovely, gentle ballad and you sing it just right.
fiandrhi 2 years ago
Thanks. I'm glad you liked it.
raymondcrooke 2 years ago
very nice job ray. very similar tone to the great Jimmy Rogers.
mkerrisk 2 years ago
Thank you.
raymondcrooke 2 years ago
Excellent! Every time I'm looking for folk music, I find you've done a version of the very song I'm looking for!
Keep these old songs alive! Youtube is perhaps the best medium today for doing so!
angrydwarfofdoom 2 years ago
Thanks. Glad I could be of use.
raymondcrooke 2 years ago
Nicely done...
I'm learning harmonica and it's one of the songs in the book....I wanted to refresh my memory..your youtube version popped up... so i took a listen... nicely done! Peace, ~Sharon.
sharbohemia 2 years ago
Thanks, Sharon. Hope it helped.
raymondcrooke 2 years ago
Excellent; I've only recently heard a few versions with these lyrics. Thanks for sharing.
usaruss 3 years ago
And thank you for watching.
raymondcrooke 3 years ago
Yes!
I know this song from other versions, a great one...can be interpreted many ways.
OsvaldoPaese 3 years ago
Thanks, Osvaldo.
raymondcrooke 3 years ago
I love this song so much.You do a great job. Thanks for this one.
SirCoughsalot 3 years ago
Thanks for your comment.
raymondcrooke 3 years ago
Awesome, my friend. I can tell you have played this song a few times before....
losthills 3 years ago
Maybe once or twice. :-)
Thanks for dropping by.
raymondcrooke 3 years ago
Fantastic cover, Raymond! :c) 5+Star's!
God bless you and yours, my friend!
GinMillBill
ginmillsinger 3 years ago
Thanks, Bill.
raymondcrooke 3 years ago
Great performance Thanks for sharing.
ghostgal30e 3 years ago
Thank you for listening.
raymondcrooke 3 years ago
Good one Raymond. What a classic and well known this song it.
BCBband 3 years ago
I like to do the occasional well-known song amidst all the obscure ballads I tend to sing.
raymondcrooke 3 years ago
Super version of one of my favourite songs.
blueukulele 3 years ago
Thank you. It's certainly a popular song with a very catchy tune.
raymondcrooke 3 years ago
Hi Raymond,
i like your performances. The slow ones like this and the faster ones like "dragging me down the stairs"!
BTW: Can you play "streets of london / ralph mc tell) for us, please?"
milkyway3011 3 years ago
A great song, but I don't think I've ever tried singing it. Maybe I'll have a go at it some time soon. Thanks for your comment.
raymondcrooke 3 years ago
Great performance Ray..(5*) Sherry
sherrywine1941 3 years ago
Thanks, Sherry. Glad you enjoyed it.
raymondcrooke 3 years ago
Hi Raymond I am sure I can see those Cowboys in your bedroom, so real was this performance. Thanks.
Take Care
David
davidholness 3 years ago
Thanks for warning me, David. I can't see what's going on behind my back.
raymondcrooke 3 years ago
Very good job on an old favorite.
lewdite 3 years ago
Thanks, Lew. I'll put up "Only the Hangman" as well soon.
raymondcrooke 3 years ago
great job Raymond ! I have this song somewhere, a Johnny Cash album I think.
dannyknapp 3 years ago
Thanks, Danny. Yes, Johnny Cash did it very well of course.
raymondcrooke 3 years ago
Hello
Raymond...
John and Alan Lomax should have taken large credit for this song for it is just one of the many hundreds of descendants of an 18th century English broadside,"The Unfortunate Rake". Alan combed the whole U.S. for the best songs he could find. If need be,he'd combine half good songs to make one very good song.
Here,your showcase brilliantly demostrates your utmost respect for the folk song process and I thank you very much for this fine example,kind sir.
Peace
Stewball
oldstewball 3 years ago
Thanks for your informative and supportive comment, Max.
raymondcrooke 3 years ago